Treasure Planet - Disneycember
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 01. 2016
- Originally aired in January 2012. Doug takes a look at Treasure Planet.
Get some Nostalgia Critic T-Shirts here - shrsl.com/?~96c0
See more at our Site: channelawesome.com
Follow us on Twitter: / channelawesome
Like Doug on Facebook: / 127127037353766
Like Channel Awesome on Facebook: / channelawesome - Zábava
Steampunk Doug, it's called Steampunk
Ronan Slevin
Um, no it isn't.
He means "steampunk" as in "like" steampunk where they mix two different time periods / technology. That's really the only way to describe it at this point.
its more cyberpunk than steampunk but both are in there so its more like a fusion kind of a cyber steam punk hybrid
Ronan Slevin not really, nah
Ronan Slevin spacesteampunk
You missed the point of this movie. It isn't set in the future, it's a fantasy world. It's taking cues from Steampunk where you mix victorian era culture and technology with modern and even science fiction.
It makes no sense traveling through space in a wooden ship, but that's because this universe is a fantasy, fantasies don't follow reality logically. Space in the movie is a metaphor. Today the frontier we are working on conquering is Space, back a few hundred years, it was the Sea. The movie mixes the natural curiosity of kids of space (there is nothing cooler than Space) and the classic adventure of treasure Island.
Star Wars is another example, it has elements of science fiction, but then again, most of it doesn't make sense, it is more authenthic to real physics than Treasure planet, but it still is totally unrealistic, unlike say, Star Trek, which tries to stay realistic.
He misses the point of literally every animated movie he reviews...
Critic doesn't like animeated movies, just as much as he doesn't read comics. He's an idiot for those.
This comment is great. A thing that a lot of people misses about Star Wars is that it isn science fiction, it is fantasy set in the space. Just as Treasure Planet, which to me is one of the best Disney movies of all time.
Yeah. He made some other valid points but completely missed what made the animation and setting so stunning. The artistic dichotomy between old and new, a culture of its own.
He also talks about wishing they'd made Treasure Island instead, but Disney DID make Treasure Island, they made it as a live action film back in 1950, before Treasure Planet.
Yeah... I never got Doug's hatred for the setting with this one. Especially when he said he liked the Steampunk in Atlantis: The Lost Empire. Having a mix of the future and the past makes the setting unique. It's like, what if this time period's aesthetics had continued into the future? Why have just another spaceship when you can have a space ship? I don't see it as distracting, but inventive and creative. Why does everything have to be set in stone? I mean, the mixing of fantasy and technology is something he praised in the Ghibli films. he's entitled to his opinion, but I really don't understand where it's coming from. It's like:
Doug: I like films with unique ways of telling stories.
Disney: Hey rather than give you just the past or future, we're going to mix the two in a unique way.
Doug: That's dumb. Either be one or the other.
+Randygandalf95 I'm totally with you there! I was actually surprised that the aesthetics were as distracting to him as they were. It's understandable that not everything is going to add up when you mix these two different time periods (what technology exists that allows them to breathe on open-air ships in space?), but honestly, it's not a curiosity that ruins the movie. You don't need to explain every minute facet of your world to keep your audience entertained (if anything, that would make it less interesting), but you need to at least have a world that can get away with leaving certain things to the imagination. Treasure Planet, to me, has that world.
I would be actually interested in seeing what makes the Studio Ghibli films so worth praising over Treasure Planet to Doug, though. I'm not saying that Treasure Planet is better than a Ghibli film, of course, but sometimes I wonder about his thought process as to why some films pull off this sort of time period fusion, and why some don't.
+Randygandalf95
He's seemingly incoherent and contradictory in many of his videos.
Zedek Yeah. One of the key ones is the explanation one.
Doug: I hate films with too much explanation, just get to the point, why is there so much dialogue.
Film: Explains a key piece of information in a short and pretty clear way that just requires a little bit of thought to put into place.
Doug: This film's plot isn't explained very well.
+Randygandalf95 This can be interpreted in many ways however
While you say that the dialogue is important maybe already about 500 lines were spoken before ANYTHING happened at all. Even if its a key piece of information.
Long dialogue sections work when the point in the movie is about something very important at that point in time. Lets say when the movie gets political with what is going on in that Fantasyworld. When they would talk for about 5 minutes everyone would understand it.
But when there are monsters around and you see them talking about how to kill it, even if that is the big boss and it will destroy the world, 5 minutes of talking while being attacked by the thing just dont fit in.
It depends on the situation at hand and overall I could agree with what Doug said about situations like that.
+Randygandalf95 I'm glad I'm not really alone in being bothered by his lack of ability to accept this aesthetic and setting. Guess it's understandable that some may not be into it but it's baffling someone like Doug can't
It's called steampunk, its a thing, and i think it worked well in this movie
I hate this movie, but even I understand (and love) the steampunk design.
Doug wouldn't know that dude, as he has no idea how genres, nor stories for that matter work
Actually, it's Sailpunk, there's very little steam here.
Not all retro futurism is steampunk, some is clockpunk, sailpunk, even cyberpunk and atompunk are part of this.
Since you say that it's called steampunk, then I agree. In a word, "exactly."
@@travtotheworld huh? why would you hate this movie, lol? it's great
The whole steampunk space pirate setting was one of my favorite things about the movie
have to disagree with Doug here the ideas actually pretty brilliant mixing the future with the past
randombro89 Yes.
How often have we seen steampunk in Disney?
yes
How do you not get the setting, Doug? It's one of the most creative and inventive parts about this movie. Retro-futurism and all that. It's based off of old sci-fi where the concept of space as we understand it today, didn't exist. We didn't know how i worked so many writers and artists interpreted space as an ocean and the planets as bodies floating within.
Yup. As a little girl I loved this movie (still do!). Maybe something about liking pirates and knowing how Jim feels without a dad made it so much better for me.
I honestly love especially the setting, but well, I already loved the whole idea of a space train - a classic steam train just driving through space - in Galaxy Express 999. Or the space ship/traditional pirate ship mesh-up of the Captain Harlock Saga.
I guess you either like stuff like this or you don't.
+Lasmiranda Dennsiewillja Harlock is great at making this setting, I agree treasure planet seems like a toy commercial
+DoctorLazers You can tell from his reviews that he has poor imagination.
+DoctorLazers I agree, I mean half the video is how Doug was disappointed because the wasnt what he thought it would be (when no such promises were made) and why he thinks some elements of the movie exist, rather than try to look at it more objectively. But I think biases and expectations are part of the experience when it comes to films
what does nostalgia critic have against good old-fashioned steampunk
Nicktrains thompson I think he just doesn't understand steampunk as a genre, or at least it's not his style. Which is fair; it's not something commonly used in popular media, especially not when he was a kid.
I actually LOVE this movie. I think it is horribly underrated. It never actually confused me because I felt it was well established that the movie universe was SO COMPLETELY different for the real world with just some little things from the real world sprinkled in. I think once that happens I don't need to justify anything to my sense of "real world" and I can just go for whatever physics and whatnot the movie is trying to convey exists in its universe... I don't know if that made any sense. I guess we can just go with "I think the steampunk-like feel was super fun! YAY" since apparently I can't gather my thoughts at 3am.
I love that Tony Jay does the opening narration! I just all around enjoy Treasure Planet, it is another movie I will just stick on when I am working on a project and want to kinda watch something that I don't actually have to completely focus on.
I guess I kinda understand how you feel though, I think it is basically how I feel about that Romeo and Juliet movie with DiCaprio, I never liked that movie being set in modern time but still using the original script, it always felt weird and forced. I just wanted them to stick to the original time period or just use the R&J story with updated terminology or w/o even using the original script, more like 10 Things I Hate About You, only a tragedy... Anyway, I just mean that I can understand what you meant even if I don't necessarily agree.
@@HydraSpectre1138 Agree.
Apparently Disney did not want this film to succeed that's why it's getting a harsh review. They didn't even advertise for it properly.
Fuck you and fuck this movie!
@@alexyoutubechannel8175 Upon reading your most eloquent arguments as to why this movie is lacking, I have taken a moment to reconsider my position, with your assertions in mind. Upon reflection I have decided to allow myself to continue to love this movie, despite such excellent rationalizations as to why I should not.
Have a great day.
@@Mustafa70116 yep. disney sent it out to die, they wanted to be done with the animation style, and they released it against 007, harry potter, and their marketing was just absolute shit as well. such a shame considering it’s an incredible movie
I never had a problem with the setting. I like the future-past-pirates motif thing the movie had going for it.It doesn't make "sense," but it doesn't have to.
it's steam punk style and that's why it makes sense it has a huge fan base probably because it it relates future with past and some even modern past like the game deus ex human revolution
+Levi Ponce It's more retro future than steampunk but you're not wrong
+Ezra Daßer yeah true, but it kinda fits in with the whole modern downtown and similar to real life incuding guns, but then you get into all the bioscience stuff that turns people invisble, blade arms sight through walls so it definitely fits it's just it's time periods are closer related
dishonored is also pretty good but that's technically whale punk
Levi Ponce yup ! I love anime for opening my eyes for such beautiful art like this movie , I used to watch as a kid such wonderful work like the Thunder Jet anime which is a traditional samurai arc in the space
+Ezra Daßer have you heard of space dandy, I think you would love it if you like spacey sci fi stuff its a phenomenal looking anime
I like the ships.
Solar sails :D
+Joey Rivera I like trains
+apos apo WAIT! NO NO NO NO!
I like cereal
+Mister69 Jaegerjaquez I like potatoes
"I want to see Disney do Treasure Island".
Err, 66 years ago. _Walt Disney_ Presents *Treasure Island*. Directed by Byron Haskin, starring Bobby Driscoll, Robert Newton, and Basil Sydney.
So why should they do it again? They wanted to do a futuristic pirate-punk movie. They got all the character stuff down right, the important stuff, so why does a creative setting throw you out? Just assume that it's a futuristic fantasy world, not a science based world.
+ErzengelDesLichtes It IS a futuristic fantasy world, really. And it does offer a little explanation as to how the universe works in the opening. The book talks about the "winds of the Etherium", which you can assume is the medium that fills space in this universe.
+ErzengelDesLichtes It IS a futuristic fantasy world, really. And it does offer a little explanation as to how the universe works in the opening. The book talks about the "winds of the Etherium", which you can assume is the medium that fills space in this universe.
So the winds of Etherium are this universe's version of the Force?
Arc Spark
In a sense yes, in a sense no.
It seems to be more like some sort of air that fills all of space.
The word is clearly a reference to the now antiquated physical concept of the aether, which assumed that since light behaves like a wave, it needs a medium to travel through, just like sound. So the assumption was that there was some (presumably matterless) medium throughout the vacuum of space which transferred the lightwaves.
The theory was disproven in the 1880s, and the relativety theory and quantum physics found explanations why light did not need such a medium.
It seems that in setting up this universe, the writers went with the idea that there was such a medium that filled all of space.
If it were a kind of breathable air, that would explain why the ships have open decks.
Or you could indeed see it as some force field, although it seems that unlike the Force, this one is only usable via machines.
ErzengelDesLichtes I guess he meant a animated version
Still my favorite Disney movie. And I'm Still Here is one of my favorite ever songs; pretty much the theme of my teenage years.
i still listen to John Rzeznik's songs from this in 2019. i love everything about this movie, sorely underrated
Hell no this movie sucks!
I think this is one of Disney's most underrated movies. The company did some really good stuff in their last days of traditional animation.
Nah this movie sucks!
It was this movie that got me into Steampunk! i mean, everything about it is so cool! i remember watching it in the theaters as a kid, and thinking, "whoah, space pirates! this is the most awesome thing ever!" literally one of my favorite movies growing up~
Ikr. I love the Setting in this. Shame that Doug doesnt like Steampunk.
+Daisy Tapia (kitsunechan06) i reckon Ratchet And Clank: Tools Of Destruction and Quest For Booty took inspiration from this movie, seriously the space pirates in those games remind me a lot of the ones from treasure planet, with the obvious difference being that they're all robots in Ratchet & Clank.
Is this steam punk? aside from the factory in the opening, there's not much steam.
+ajmrowland I think it is still steam punk but it just doesn't play the steam punk aspects straight. They probably picked what they thought would work for the story they wanted to tell, and what would work for the universe they envisioned.
It isn't steampunk
The music in this movie is so friggin good. Just listening to that main theme gets me pumped!
I think Doug totally missed the point with this one. The clashing setting is one of my favorite parts of the movie, and all of the visuals are breathtaking. It wasn't to be cool and hip, it was to create a completely unique and imaginative world. The parts that you hated were some of my favorites.
AND YOU NEED TO LEARN OPINIONS
@@alexyoutubechannel8175and YOU need to learn that more than one opinion can exist and op has every right to voice theirs
On the contrary, I found the setting absolutely entertaining and interesting.
Just throw Nicolas Cage into this movie and you'll get National Treasure Planet. I wonder how that would turn out.
God dammit that's clever
haha
+MegaSoulhero Now I want to see a Disney animated Nicolas Cage. Not as a character, but he himself as a cartoon.
hahahahahaha
Lmao, that is awesome
I don't care what he says, I love this movie.
he's pretty dumb
@@loveexposure3351 no, he isn’t. And yes I don’t care what anyone says either, I love this movie.
@@mintbrisk5961 yes he is, and no I don't care what you say either, he is
@@loveexposure3351 you're dumb for not respecting his opinion.
@@alexyoutubechannel8175 Nobody asked
I feel like this is the biggest DisneyCember he should revisit this.
WhiteTuxMafiaAndFilms no I think he pretty right
I’m from the future and I’ve got good news for you
Come on, how another one "classic" treasure island film would be better than this? It would be soo boring, wouldn't it?
I remember and love Treasure Planet exactly because of setting
Well, people still like classic pirates, so the setting wouldn't be much of a problem. throw in a storm instead of the black.hole and such and it would work.
But I'm glad they went with the sci-fi setting.
E-123 yeah treasure island would be boring .. we already have a lot of Disney pirate movies and boat/sea adventures ..
Even the soviet union had its own treasure island animated film (which was fucking amazing) but yeah, it's overdone and this is way more original.
Still this movie sucks
And BTW, does anyone else besides me want a Treasure Planet-based world in Kingdom Hearts 3?
all of the yes
+Jack Stevenson YES!!
Omg yes!!!
This is my biggest wish for KH3!!
Jack Stevenson Is prefer Star Wars or Marvel tbh
I grew up with Disney, but this one totally went under my radar. I know Doug's opinion on it, but he can be awfully critical. Do you guys think I should give it a watch? It IS on Netflix.
Oh hell yea, you NEED to witness this one
+Yyasemin Ssabanci (Yasemin) I remember it as a quite decent movie, it was my first steam punk-ish movie, if you think about that way it I suppose you can find it great.
+Yyasemin Ssabanci (Yasemin) It is definitively worth it.
+Yyasemin Ssabanci (Yasemin) I feel like the movie was WAY ahead of it's time, if you watched it now, it would still look like it came out this year.
+Yyasemin Ssabanci (Yasemin) IMO it was a pretty decent movie, I'd say go for it.
I honestly think this movie is great. Disney tried something new, something that was alternative. the theme "Stempunk" leaves a lot of room for imagenation that Disney, in my opinoin, has briliantly used to their advantage.
Fuck no this movie sucks!
"How do these two things go together?"
Critic, its called Steampunk.......
I've never seen this (along with Atlantis), but I absolutely love the animation style....it's gorgeous.
One thing I loved about this film was how well they incorporated the digital and hand-drawn animation, especially with Silver's Cybernetics that gave the character such a unique silhouette.
Doug Walker if you think about it being a Steampunk Future then what would you think of it? I'm curious what you'd think about it being a Steampunk-esqe Future which is honestly what the movie feels like its being
+Braden Twidwell what is a steam punk
+icecream hero think futuristic materials made by the same materials as a steam train engine
Braden Twidwell so its like the Flintstones and how they make gadgets out of animals
icecream hero in a way yes
+Braden Twidwell it is steampunk. that's what this genre is called. he just doesn't or didn't know about it, so asking him on his opinion of it wouldn't be very effective because he wouldn't know what you're talking about. and if you tell him "The setting of Treasure Planet.", he'll say, "Oh. That's a thing? Idk, ig it just isn't for me."
The setting was never distracting for me I actually really like it. It makes this movie stand out; not to mention that the aesthetic seems steam punk inspired and I love that look.
my favorite underrated disney movie ^_^
I fucking love this movie. The visuals, the story, the music. This movie is one of the most underrated Disney movies of all time. The setting is supposed to be odd and different, that's the point and I love it.
🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
For what it's worth, I love the film myself, including the setting
You're not going to mention that I'm still here montage! Well fine haha
Haven't seen this movie, but based on these clips I actually kinda like this visual style, so I think I'll keep an eye out and give this one a watch sometime
+Joe Mazzola It's on Netflix so if you have that then you can watch it as often as you want.
+Joe Mazzola It's pretty good, Critic's rather harsh on this one
+Joe Mazzola this is a fun movie
Joe Mazzola A spectacular Movie mate! Give it a try, Critics gonna hate, but seriously, This movie Is THAT Good!! This is one of Those movies that Shaped My Childhood Lol Awesome Movie, Give it a shot, You wont regret it 😉😉😉😉
This needs to be a kingdom hearts world.
I really love the style in this movie. It's like an interesting mix of sci-fi and steampunk.
Alexandria Thorne I'm not a fan of steampunk.. but I appreciate the art! I can't wait for GOTHAM OF GASLIGHT
if they did what you wanted and had generic spaceships it would just be another typical shitty space adventure movie... and i guarantee you'd be complaining about it in the opposite direction
Why would he complain in the opposite direction? He's never complained about any other Disney movie that's set in a mundane setting.
"When you just have giant boats in space that's all we're going to see!"
...And how is that not inherently awesome, Doug?
Two words Doug: Science. Fiction.
I watched this one several times as a kid. The black hole scene always shook me. Also, the planet collapsing, for me, was always a memorable and utterly tense sequence, like the clocktower fight in The Great Mouse Detective, even if the movies are in otherwise different leagues.
Man I don't get why this film isn't more loved. Everything is so inventive and brilliant. It's kind of sad that one of the few Disney films that strays from the tired formula has been so forgotten. And it holds up really well, I've seen it a few times as an adult and I actually think I like it more now. It reminds me of Titan AE, another great film that was panned by critics and largely forgotten today.
This movie fucking sucks!
Ok, so, this is my favorite Disney movie.
It shouldn't it's one of the worst Disney movies!
@@alexyoutubechannel8175 Hey man, if that's your opinion, that's fine. It's still one of my favorites, though.
@@hurpaderpash7270 I don't care your opinion SUCKS CRY BABY!
@@alexyoutubechannel8175 I'm not the one commenting about how "bad" a 12 year old movie is on a three year old comment and getting mad over someone else's opinion. Happy holidays, friend.
man, doug is really boring in the imagination departament....
when I was a kid I LOVED the setting, the boats in space, the creatures, all the steampunk stuff, I even wrote a comic with this
I always assumed doug was a really boring guy but this is kind of really close-minded
rodan I think he just doesn't understand the steampunk genre as a whole; it's likely he didn't even know it was a thing until now! This is one of my favorite movies too, but we can't be too hard on him if it's not something he grew up with...
I have a different word than weird, unique. The blending of old with future makes the movie different. It's an interesting twist on a classic tale.
My girlfriend got me into this movie.
And I actually like it a lot.
Like... a lot a lot.
I think your issues w/ this film are based in something you misconceived...the story isn't supposed to be taking place 'in the future'...it's a futuristic OTHER REALITY...thus the floating pirate ships, the talking creatures and so on...
A shame you were unable to see it that way, as it makes the combination of the 'future tech' and the 'old world dress/aspects' make more 'sense', if only in that it's meant to be an 'alternate reality' based in two things being meshed...for the fun of it.
Kind of 'steam punk' before that was actually a widely known thing.
Maybe this helps you to see the whole concept differently, and like the movie as a whole a bit better?...;)
Ironic side note:
I knew the guy who wrote the original 'future version of Treasure Island' screenplay this was based on, and it was NOT intended as a kid's adaption/animated film...he wrote it much darker and grown up, tho several sequences and ideas from his original screenplay DID make it into this odd animated version)
I actually don't mind the dress. It gives the movie a sort of steampunk vibe.
People see that it's set in space and assume it's in the future. A reminder that Star Wars was set "A LONG TIME AGO in a galaxy far, far away".
It might very well be set in the future, but it doesn't have to be Earth's future. I think that this film creates it's own universe where there is a space-faring civilization, yet the designs of the buildings, vehicles, and clothing are based on historic imagery. This has been done several times in film and literature and it makes for a very interesting setting. And it should not be something the film is negatively criticized for.
REGENCY/REVOLUTIONARY SPACE PUNK!!!!
this is one of my favorite disney movies, although one thing that always bugged me is the logic behind how they can breath in space, since they travel in open ships.
I seem to recall they explain the ships have an invisible "field" around them that engages whenever they are not within a planet or station's atmosphere. It allows for not only breathing but also gravity. I believe it comes up both when the ship is about to take off and when they deal with the black hole. I may be wrong on the exact times though, as its been a few years since the last time I saw it. I watch it every few years though. I love the visuals and the character emotions.
It's stated in the movie that space in this movie is filled with a breathable gas named Etherium.
***** I think that if that bug will die, it would probably be from starvation, since now be is just drifting.
Dan Eyal I remember they said they had an *invisible force field* on the ship that controlled gravity and air. That's how they don't go floating into the air. And yes, *the writers were witty enough to utilize it* throughout the film, especially at the end! 💕💕
SevenMinuteWarning Scroop died because he was separated from the ship, and unless he encountered another planet or ship he’d likely have starved to death.
This is one of my favourite films of all time! Once I watched this twice in a day, and then watched it AGAIN for the director's commentary.
This movie is terrible! You are not allowed to love it!
*I STRONGLY disagree* , Doug. Part of *what I loved the MOST* about this movie were its bizarre creative scenery and concept. *Not every sci-fi has to look like Star Wars!* And modern day proves that *old aesthetics don't die,* they get recycled.
I love the visuals and design so much! And *I love that the artists dared to think outside the box* and create their own unique world. A true sci-fi fantasy that isn't a boring clone of everything else in the genre!
It's one of my *favorite* movies *of all time* and *I strongly recommend it!!*
20 years laterr i love this movie
This movie reminds me so much of Bioshock infinite.
I like this anime.
Waifu Speedwagon Not an anime. It's an animated movie....not the same thing as an anime.
Pretty sure that was a joke tho. Like how people say Cory in the House is best anime.
uhhhhhhhh.... IT'S CALLED STEAMPUNK!!!!!!
Goodamn I love this movie. Probabley one of my favourite movies
Man, Doug's outlook on films has really changed in 9 years.
I guess she's... a CATPTAIN
How do you even say that?
My favourite Disney film.
God, Doug can be so frustrating sometimes...he will go on and on about a chessy movie being amazing, and then he will look at something thats ACTUALLY good and hes like "Uhhh this is so dumb"
his thoughts on the setting is petty af.
This is why I don't always rely on critics to enjoy something.
I fucking love this movie and still think it's unappreciated
Damn, this was one of my favorite movies as a kid. I've gotta watch it again.
This is still one of my favorite movies 😊
They did it in the future cause the original has been done to death. Also the two time periods makes it kinda steampunk
Who’s here after today’s review
Confused that Doug dislikes the setting. It just makes the story more interesting and lets the world have surprises, like morph.
This movie is great and deserves more attention and love.
This is actually one of my favorite Disney movies.
I was about to comment why I loved the setting but it seems everyone else did it for me.
i love everything abt this movie
This is still one of my favorite Disney movies. It just resonated with younger me when it came out. I've watched it so many times.
You need to understand, it's not set in any 'period' of time, it's meant to capture the feeling of sailing the high seas, but the feeling of wonder that there really could be anything out there is brought back into the picture by setting it in something resembling space. Trying to limit your view of this world to "What period is this set in?" is a sure way to make yourself not enjoy it.
Additionally, the reason that Jim is all rebellious is pretty clear. It's not just because they want him to look cool, it plays really well into his story arc. We see that Jim is very talented and intelligent, but the experience of losing his father has plunged him into a crushing state of melancholy.
I personally love this movie even though I had actually never seen it until a few months ago but, I'm ridiculously glad I decided to watch it. The animation is utterly gorgeous. Everything flows naturally and the coloring is so majestic that takes your breath away. and while the steampunk style in this movie doesn't make a whole ton of sense, it gives you a unique experience beyond what you've seen. I'm glad they kept the odd futuristic, yet some how 19th century idea, thing. it give the story its type of originality without taking away from the source material. To me, Treasure Planet would not be Treasure Planet with out this interesting design choice. If they had put space ships, legitimate spaceships in place of the space boats, that would be boring as hell. We've seen space ships before, thats nothing new, but now we have sail boats that can travel through space? Thats not something you normally think about. In fact it makes think. Its inspiring to think of the possibilities of that world.
FUCK YOU TO HELL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Treasure Planet is my favorite Disney movie along with Atlantis: The Lost Empire.
No lion king is the best Disney movie!
If you ask me, the animation in this movie is actually amazing. :)
One of my favorite Disney movies.
One of the worst
I love this movie. It is not that bad at all.
Honestly, Doug needs to seriously review this movie. As in an ACTUAL review. He must redeem himself for giving this film such a hard time. Especially without giving it a fair shot at that.
Still my favorite Disney movie.
I love this film, and the visual style. It was my fav Disney film when I was a child.
3:40
Nah, it is *exactly* a pet peeve.
They took some of the stale characters from the original story and improved upon them. The setting is fantastical in a way which doesn't take it too far over the top, and immerses you into it right from the start almost seamlessly. One of my favorite films of all time. Doug seemed far too superficial with this one.
Soryykah Wilson Jim is rather a flat character in the original as far as his personality goes.
Hell no niggas!
It's one of my favorite Disney movie
One of my favorite movies ever!
Kind of a waste of time responding to a 4 year old video, but I'm just going to chime in for the sake of it.
Stylistically, I dig it. Much like the Steam Punk genre or Fallouts retro futurism, it's a mash up of old time periods with advanced technology. It's not "THE FUTURE" or sci-fi, it's fantasy with futuristic motifs. I don't find it distracting in Fallout that I'm shooting Laser weapons inside a suit of power armor wearing a hair style Elvis would be proud of, 200 years into the future, next to sleek 50's style nuclear powered cars, old CRTs and manually tuned radios or computers that run like old IBMs.
The age of exploration of the past meets the age of exploration of the future! I like it... actually, I kind of love it.
My problem though is definitely how dated it feels. The 90's influence is strong in this one.
This movie is so underrated, this is suppose to be a steampunk themed Treasure Island. This movie was fun, it bombed due to competition from Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter. There were too many fantasy themed movies out in late 2002. Treasure Planet was competing with big blockbusters and it lost money for Disney.
NO IT'S VERY OVERRATED!
@@alexyoutubechannel8175 it’s not even popular, it can’t be overrated if the movie was a failure for Disney.
growing up this was my favorite disney movie, i just loved the weird setting i found it so creative and fun
I loved this film. I remember watching this in the theatre when I was 7 years old.
Lets see, future tech and 19th century outfits.
Really Doug? You never came into contact with steampunk before?
Doug: "Just tell Treasure Island!"
Me: "Why? so you can lambast it for being something 'you've seen and are sick and tired of'?
This is one of those reviews where Doug honestly really annoys me.
he's always raging about anything being even passingly familiar, but at times he's alarmingly close-minded to anything visually unique or anything with a unique take on an old story... I mean, fair enough, he explains that he just doesn't get into it, rather than just saying it's an outright bad thing about the movie but his review ends up with a very negative slant when he admits the movie gets all the real important stuff dead on... and it really does, the characters here are fantastic, the story is well told, and the presentation, even putting aside the stylistic stuff is absolutely incredible, with maybe the best 2D-3D animation blending you'll ever see and a fabulous score from James Newton Howard, maybe one of the best scores in a disney movie outside of Lion King and Hunchback.
I dunno, maybe he'd be more positive about it now, after all, he got on board with ATLA and Legend of Korra, which had very interesting meshing of technology and fantasy (the former having giant drills, jetskis submarines and airships in what was otherwise a medieval technology level setting,) and the latter introducing giant mechs into a 1920s setting. so maybe he'd be over the stylistic curve now.
also his complaints about the 'manipulative' side... sorry, just don't see it, the sky-surfing was supposed to be visual demonstration of his longing for a bit more freedom and opportunity and also a demonstration of his recklessness, carelessness and disregard for authority... both of which tie heavily into Jim's character arc... I think Doug let a little bit of baggage, (maybe his opinions from when the movie was being marketted before he'd seen it) get to him there.
This is my favourite Disney movie ever (so far at least)
Doug, it's steampunk and it's actually done just great. And gosh, Silver is one of my favourite animated characters, he's just the most likeable kinda-villain I've ever seen! As a kid I watched it hundreds times! I still love this movie and I still can return to it anytime.
I really like this movie and the setting, it is like the Golden Age of Piracy in space. What is there not to like about it.
Love this movie. I wish it had more attention to it. I see lots of people are complaining that you don't understand the totally awesome steampunky atmosphere. So I won't comment on that (And yet I will because WTF critic?! Sorry I couldn't help jumping on the wagon), but what I will say is yes, the characters are amazing and the relationships between them are better.
I also love to praise it for John Silver. He may be a scalawag but he was also bordering on loving father type. Or even just loving male whatever. Which I don't see as often as a loving mother type. So i give it extra points for that. He was just a super awesome villain. Probably my favorite from Disney.
This is one my personal favourite
i love this movie