What if the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact WASN'T signed?
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 05. 2024
- Germany and the Soviet Union briefly allied in a war against Poland. This war started the Second World War, but while France and Britain swore to defend Poland, they only declared war on Germany, not on the Soviet Union.
But what if Germany never contacted the Soviet Union and just invaded Poland alone? You may be quick to shrug this off and say that nothing drastic would happen, but you will be wrong!...
▬ LINKS ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Discord Server - / discord
Patreon - / membership
CZcams Membership - / @rewriting-history
Book - www.amazon.com/dp/B0CTHSKVWP
▬ Chanel Description▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
This channel is a haven for those who crave intellectual stimulation and love to ponder the profound "what ifs" of history. Join our passionate community of history enthusiasts, where engaging discussions and insightful commentaries fuel our collective imagination.
Subscribe now and embark on this enthralling adventure with us. Prepare to question, wonder, and discover as we navigate the corridors of time, peeling back the layers of history to reveal a tapestry of alternate paths and captivating possibilities.
Welcome aboard, fellow explorers of alternative history. Let's rewrite the past together!
#germany #ussr #sovietunion #ww2 #history #alternatehistory #poland #france
Check out my patreon if you want to contribute to more quality videos and gain early access and updates :)
www.patreon.com/rewritinghistory/membership
This video was demonetized the first 24 hours, so for patreon members they should get access to my videos A LOT earlier. I also post future thumbnails and titles.
@@rewriting-history was it because you didn’t say “a toothbrush mustache having Austrian man” lol
@@rewriting-historyhi.❤
I love how he just brings out coins for a bit. Adds some extra character to his videos.
Fair play to Aaron Hunt went from chill with simple Simon and Luke Bennet to kicking a ball with Wayne Rooney round his gafff genuinely sound geeza aswell
@@crimsoniteyt1 do you smell toast?
And in his recent Bulgaria video he actually used them to demonstrate inflation
however maybe the Soviet army may be more ready to face an German invasion(whenever that happens)
Honestly, a very unique scenario I have never even heard of someone making this kind of thing before. Heck I haven’t even really considered the idea before. It’s kind of just one of those things that you feel like would happen anyway, but of course there is a universe out there somewhere where it didn’t.
I've been watching this guy for like a month and I thought he had atleast a million subscribers. the effort and personality is so visible.
Can you do what if ww2 was a three way war with the Comintern and allies also at war?
Possible History already did that and I don't think I can one up him, so it's not needed
@@rewriting-historywhat If romania joined the allies in 1939 and helped poland?
At this point i wont be surprised if bro has coins from heaven
Hahahha nice one! I have so much more to show and I have to double down and purchase and show more. People LOVE it
@@rewriting-history Wait theres more... lemme guess a coin from 450 bc?
I got muted💀
Yikes
Too much spam about contrevercial topics, sorry
@@rewriting-historyseems pretty based
Top comment bruh
Love your content! Can't wait for it.
Thanks so much!
Earliest premiere i've ever seen from you which is good because Australian timezones 😃
Hope you enjoyed it! I'm experimenting with different times
I started collecting ww2 and ww1 coins since 2 months, and it's really interesting seeing your coins in some parts of the video. Keep it up!
I will, thank you so much! I will also start showing off more
Honestly very unique, and a very interesting take on a very under utilized concept! Great you brung your coins out chap!
Much appreciated! I plan to show even more coins and other stuff nobody would even expect
@@rewriting-history Glad to here that!
Great vid :)))
Glad you enjoyed it
Very cool
Love your channel like my self your a student of history...I like your content.
I appreciate that! Hope you continue to learn new stuff!
Another banger from RH!
Appreciate that very much!
@@rewriting-history I'm glad 👍
There is something that isn't ture:
Most likely, if the Soviet Union wouldn't invade, Romania would join Poland's side in the war, as they were close allies, and if they wouldn't then they would definetly highly help them in every way they could.
There is also a possibilty that the Soviet Union would do a bit of a troll, and demand Eastern Poland for joining on thier side of the War.
I did mention like 5 times that the video is not meant to be realistic. I only wanted to create a cool story. I agree with what you said, but it would have made the whole video more complicated. I loved how simple and easy to follow this one turned out to be
That's a far better scenario than the one of the video
I want this guy to set up an ASMR channel, I could listen to his accent all day 😀
Maybe one day lol! Never thought people would enjoy my accent, but here we are
@@rewriting-history I could also settle for a 10 hour loop of you saying "гъм" (gum) cause it's hilarious
The pact also included the soviets providing oil and other materials to Germany which aided the German war machine.
Well I decided not to mention all of the treaty's conditions, but just the most important ones, as I wanted to make a shorter video packed with information. I hope somebody reads your comment and learns something new
Just for curiosity and to compare, I got a 1935 fünf mark from Berlin with Hindenburg still on it, made almost entirely of silver.
Bulgaria
What if the Australian Colonises never United?
probably wouldn't change much, you'd have to make a bunch of random other things happen for it to be interesting like:
During ww2, the western Australians join the axis and invade the rest of australia, and after ww2 is over the continents get split between communism and capitalism, and then somehow the emu war turns into a proxy war between the soviets and americans
what if germany tried to position itself as the protector of the baltics? Keeping them out of the spviet hands would be great for germany no?
Not worth ruining relations with the Soviet Union for little to no support from the west
Can you do what if the spartacist uprising led by rosa Luxemburg and liebknetch was successful?
What if switzerland joined the axis in 1942
where do you get these coins bro
BalkanAuction, Bulgaria's version of Ebay
The problem with your theory that the Germans would believe it would be a quick war in Russia is because it was based two things that didn't happen in your timeline. First, the easy victory over the Low Countries and France. And second, the abysmal performance of the Soviet Army in Finland. Before these events, Hitler was sure that the struggle against the Soviet Union might take years. After these events, He was riding high on his victories and the Soviet's catastrophes.
do you think if the scenario was like this but germany attacked France first just to get it over they would have won?
When it comes to the Baltics, I think they would've sided with the west. The Soviets were seen as a threat, but so were the germans, as they had been the ruling class in the area since the days of the Livonian Order. Although if this arrengement was the case, the Baltics and the Soviet Union would be the same colour, which I think is a bit extreme. It would've been better if the Soviets were sort of a faction of their own with their own colour. Something worthy of note is that all of this speculation is made under the assumption that they'll pick a side at all, since like Finland, they initially wanted to stay out of the conflict.
Other than that, I think this video was great!
I got an idea, what if Hess took over in 1938.
What if the decembrist revolt succeeded in overthrowing the tsar and founding a Russian republic in 1823, when Tsar Alexander decides to go to Kiev as planned instead of diverting to taganrog. I believe this would create a fascinating new balance of power in Europe, and could potentially lead to the American Civil War becoming a world War, being that in our own timeline Russia backed the union against British and French aggression, and if Britain and France were to intervene on the behalf of the confederacy I believe that this could potentially drag a more closely allied, and more modern/industrialized Russian republic into the conflict.
Said in numbers
Late 1939 Soviet Union was weaker, but Late 1939 Germany was too
Yeah I touched on that point that both were a lot weaker too
I dont think Romania would join the Axis this time around, as the USSR hadnt eaten Bessarabia, and Romania would be more likely to join the allies if they refuse the treaty of Craiova and the second Vienna award
**Which internally didnt make the population hate Carol II or radicalize more Iron Guards
This is actually a stronger Germany after NOT wasting resources fighting in the west and a weaker USSR having less time to re arm. Germany would advance further, probably capturing Moscow and the Caucasus, not that that would mean the USSR is completely out. IF France and England don't invade before. Maybe Germany can use Japan as a threat to keep the allies from invading and promising to split the USSR territories with input from France and England.
You have a lot of coins? are you an immortal vampire?
What if aparteid never existed in South Africa.
Lore of What if the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact WASN'T signed? Momentum 100
So the stronger French and UK direct involvement in the victory against the Germans would eventually secure them stronger positions on dictating post war terms eventually saving Poland,Hungary,Romania,Bulgaria,Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia from falling under communism but also splitting Germany on parts since France wanted to outrightly prevent them from rising as a great power again. Also the Soviets are still getting most of the Baltics and Italy retains it's control over Albania and Istria.
Not relly france was very unstable in real life they would probly have a coumnist revolt plus the soveits would have taken all of pand the allies cant do anything about it plus the germans wouldnt had this sucses in the eastren front as they dont have the resources that they got from the tge non aggressoin pact soo thus is very unrealastic plus the french where very incmptonet becuse of there bad high command
Can you do a video about an anglo union forming to combat communism in the cold war, including america britain canada australia and new Zealand. I would say south africa but that nation would throuw a giant wrench into everything
I loved this scenario right until the end... so the soviet union is vastly weaker, France keeps on the defensive, and no US involvement... but Germany still loses, somehow?
Dream postwar treaty
These Poland’s borders 🤤(yes, I’m polish)
How many coins does this man have
Have some virtual ones
Yooo I really appreciate that!
I have like 600 more coins that I haven't shown. I will start showing a lot more as people really enjoyed that
Can you make what if Italy joined Allies?
Hello my friend, I already have a video about that: czcams.com/video/kVTKalOyyj4/video.htmlsi=Pzl8Rt58E3XQh1lB
@@rewriting-historywhat If romania joined the allies in 1939?
The Soviet onion also proved the Germans with a lot of resources due to the molotov ribontruve pack but this will not happen in this world and thus I believe that the German army will be a lot weaker.
Not really. These resources weren't high enough to help Germany, that's why they invaded (among other reasons). Other countries like Sweden, Switzerland, and more provided more and in higher amounts due to the danger posed.
Can you do a german invasion of russia in 1940?
Well this is pretty much it lol
@@rewriting-historyhistorical until the battle of Britain when germany attacks ussr in mid 1940
Ay it's my suggestion, kind of
I don’t think that France and Britain would join the war , they would just observe Germany invading ussr with Japan (because the allies were more scared of communism than fascism)
No need to keep defending from potential comments mid-video. Just make you scenario and maybe address some stuff that’s unrealistic in the description or comment section. Just a way to make the video itself smoother.
Can you do "what if USSR collapsed violently/civil war in 1991(like Yugoslavia and Austria-Hungary)
Would be same like Ukraine war
👍
Whatever scenario he came up with, it didn't seem like he was going to let deutschland won this war lol
The war was hard to win for them no matter what. I think they only could win if it was a quick war, and with Britain never surrendering it becomes impossible..
Why germany let ussr take Lituania irl?
What if romania joined zhe allies in 1939?(They palnned to hep poland but didnt becouse of the soviets)
What if Finland has all of Northwestern Federal District, Tver Oblast, Yamalo-Nenets and Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug since the Finish language was created?
Finland Area: 1,311,727 sq miles
1120s Sweden rules all of Finland, Northwestern Federal District, Tver Oblast, Yamalo-Nenets and Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug.
Many Swedish, Norwegians and Baltics moved to Northwestern Federal District Tver Oblast Yamalo-Nenets and Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug every town, district and settlement has their own Baltic, Finnish, German, Swedish or Norwegian dialect.
1695: all of the Estonians and the 150,000 Finns that died moved to the Northwestern Federal District many Norwegians also moved to Northwestern Federal District.
Many Germans moved to Sweden.
1721: September 10 Sweden wins the Great Northern War Russia never became a superpower.
1809: all of Finland has been annexed by Russia.
1917: December 6 Russian speakers were expelled from Finland or were massacred or adapted to Finnish culture.
1918: January 27 the Finnish civil war ends faster the whites still wins.
1939: November 30 Finland wiped out more Soviet soldiers.
March 13 Finland was able to keep all of their territory lost to Russia.
1944: September 19 Finland has millions of German pows these German pows are given civilian education.
1945 April 9 Finland captured Konigsberg and the rest of East Prussia.
1947 Finland still stays neutral in the Cold war there's no military draft but children are given weapons training.
What if the Austrian painter lived in Australia?😂
Lol, I don't think a lot would happen, he just allies with Japan and still loses
5:21 another coin???
wrong timestamp?
I think rewrite history plays a lotmof ultrakill he loves coins very much💀
I lpve how trying to make germany win ww2 is so unrealistic and hard😂
Well this is how it is. Germany winning looked close if you look at an European map, but on a world map it wasn't even close. Especially considering the economies of other countries. The Germans would have lost in the long-run so their best shot at winning I think is a quick war, but with Britain never surrendering it's close to impossible. Also they were crazy enough to invade the USSR and US at the same time
Is the dollar sign over the swastika some sort of commentary or is every video remotely related to actual history getting its funding cut on account of accuracy?
Thats just the demonetized symbol.
CZcams would demonetize the video if it had the actual nazi flag
What if brazil brought freedom and democracy upon this world?
Hi.❤
Hello!
Can you make some africa vidioe africa has good altenet history like. What if eygbt unite north africa or of if the somalia won the orgadan war and so much more 😅
What if messi and ronaldo kiss?
I dont understand your obsession with britain instaling monarchs in countries. It features frequently in your videos. Britain never even tried this once in history. Even countries which they had a lot of influence in like greece didn't have british monarchs. Even the british colonies, the only british monarchy (as in a independent monarchy like malaysia with a british house was sarawak)
Bro come on this is very unrealistic at least warn us!!!
Sorry next time I will double the warnings lol
Yoo
Yoooooooooo
Yooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Yoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Why is the soviet union weaker in all scenarios
If the USSR was victorious on the Vistula, that's one example of a better scenario. Also, if Poland allowed Soviet troops to protect Czechoslovakia, or if the social democrats didn't side with the Nazis in Germany (which would've spared the USSR of WW2)
the great purge
Because of the Great Purge and Holodomor, which are 2 major events in Soviet History.
@rewriting-history The great purge made ussr overall weaker, but more stable, holodomor is a great misconception because it doesn't affected the soviet army capabilities, if the great purge didn't happened ussr would have a coup or a civil war in mid ww2, people underestimate the soviets
@@rewriting-historywhy the holodomor have sagnificant effects on the soviet milletary?