Classic OR Not? (Music Quiz) Part 1 (MEDIUM)
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 06. 2024
- Can you determine whether a given musical piece is a Classic or Not?
Quiz contains 15 melodies of 15 seconds each.
Write your answer in comments.
This experimental music quiz format is differs from other tests and quizes.
ENJOY and SUBSCRIBE!
On Background used pictures designed by pvproductions - Freepik.com
On Background used pictures designed by PNGWing.com - Hudba
Fun idea. Thanks. I can't believe I thought Stravinsky was a game soundtrack
You can find a lot of similar soundtracks to games and films from Stravinsky, Brückner and Shostakovich))
Oh no! I got fooled by the Angry Birds! Gahrrrr
Something new very interesting quiz
Thank you very much, I'm glad it was interesting!
15/15 - what a great quiz - I think it's clear here that modern composers tend to use a subtly different harmonic palate.
Some very good choices here. I had fun.
Really cool quiz!
Thanks for the comment. It is very important for me to collect feedback from viewers in order to understand whether I need to continue doing this format or not!
Finally! A good fucking quiz!
13/15, got fooled by Might and Magic, and Nokia.
With Nokia tune it was also surprising to me that such a modern piece of music turned out to be written more than 120 years ago))
12/15, very fun
Great concept!
13/15
The Dies Irae quote in the Liszt piece fooled me - that's why I thought it was probably film music.
Stravinsky also sounded like something from a movie scene.
This is what surprised me at some point, that some very old compositions sound incredibly “modern”.
15/15 Very easy!
Interesting idea! Somehow I got 14/15 mostly by feel and guesswork. It raises the question of exactly where the boundaries of "classical" music lie.
Thank you. I myself am interested in trying to do something new. And if the audience evaluates it positively, that’s doubly great!
12/15 Well made, I didn't even recognized Vivaldi, which bugs me a bit, but it was an unusually interesting bit by him, imo...
I didn't recognize any of them, but I'm grateful that this video introduced me to fine music I was unfamiliar with, both classic and not. Thank you!
Was fun! Would have been funny to try and trick us with Mahler 3's first movement as it has "Be Our Guest" from Beauty and the Beast as well as "Angry Birds!"
Thank you. I'll try to come up with something more complicated in other parts. There shouldn’t be too many difficulties at the very beginning))
Or the fourth movement of Dvorak's 9th Symphony as it has "Jaws" in it!
@adiosmusictest korngold kings row has the beginning of the main star wars theme
15 ! This one was easy.
14/15, great quiz! Not so obvious :)
Thank you. You have a very good result for this quiz))
В принципе все становится понятно уже за 4-5 секунд. Но признаться, некоторые треки для меня были неожиданностью) Музыку, написанную ранее 20 века, отличить от современной не составляет труда, но вот первую половину 20 века от второй - порой неожиданно сложно) Я вообще был уверен, что в конце 20 века композиторы расслоились на авангардистов и попсовиков. Ан нет))) 12/15
Абсолютно так .. самые запутывающие классические композиции находятся плюс-минус 30-40 лет от 1900 года .. если брать раньше там совсем не интересно. Но я попробую что-нибудь отыскать для разнообразия, возможно у не самых известных композиторов .. Ну и ещё хорошо брать что-то очевидное из классики, что использовалось в известных фильмах, как Вивальди в 1+1, и что можно спутать с саундтреком))
You nerds, just have fun with the quiz instead of trying to be pedants and arguing things that don't matter. My man is going for a fun quiz, just enjoy it.
Thanks for support. I welcome any meaningful and constructive comments and learn a lot from them. Although sometimes they really are too meticulous - Although I can find advantages in this too.
12/15
I lost count of the right answers, but I got 2 wrong. However, I see that Classic won the match 8-7. GO CLASSIC !!
I’m also cheer more for the Classic, but that’s probably not entirely fair on my part))
13/15 got fooled by the first and by stravinsky!
14 for 15 got tricked on Stravinsky which is embarrassing lol
I am not sure this classical vs non-classical juxtaposition is fair. For ex. Ezio Bosso's symphony No. 1 (Oceans): is it 'classical' or not? Or Philip Glass works (other than soundtracks)? Or Zbigniew Preisner's Requiem dla mojego przyjaciela (all of these composed much after 1950)? And what about Shostakovich's Symphony No. 15 (composed in 1971)? And what about Alfred Schnittke?
In my opinion, one can only juxtapose academic vs non-academic music - if you really need to do it. I'd define this quiz as 'pre-1950' and 'post-1950'.
I understand your comments perfectly and in some ways even support them. BUT, first of all, I need a bright short title, more or less understandable to an ordinary person scrolling through CZcams, so that he can grasp the essence of the quiz in a short moment! Secondly, I really tried to select melodies before(Classic) and after(Not) 1950, except for the 1948 Cinderella. And in fact, this is really a quiz "Before and After 1950". In the next part I will try to focus on this fact at the very beginning. I was glad to see such a detailed review.
Great! I liked the format, but the first few patterns were predictable (classin-not classic-classic-not classic) then (not classic - classic- not classic). Be sure to randomize next time!
Thank you for your comment. In the next parts, I hope there were no problems with randomness))
This was a lot of fun, though I got several wrong, shame on me. The one phrased used in electronics turned out to be from a classical piece. You got me good! Some day I'd love to do a lecture, "There Was Technicolor Music Before There Were Technicolor Movies." Many film composers have borrowed ideas from the concert repertoire, the obvious example being bits of the opening section from Holst's "The Planets" inspiring action music in "Star Wars [IV.]"
Of course, modern composers were inspired by the classics. This is the beauty of such a quiz. Although it is quite easy for an experienced listener to distinguish the music.
I think the orchestration and harmonization of "modern music" is slightly different from "classical music"
Naturally, most modern compositions are easy to identify, but there is a small class on both sides, in which it is very easy to get confused))
15/15, as usual.
(potential spoiler) I was tricked my number 12. Sounded like the Nokia ringtone for a sec.
that is actually the nokia ring. the nokia ring sampled tarrega's gran vals for their ringtone.
It's a great idea for a ringtone to take the entire Gran Vals))
12/15 Something different. I tried imagining scenarios that would fit the music, but I don't believe these affected my answers.
Classics of the past Vs classics of the future
14/15 (got Firebird wrong)
Уж брукнера я точно не ожидал услышать)
На мой взгляд Брукнер хорошо подходит под этот формат - я когда подбирал мелодии, которые бы немного сбивали с толку - с Брукнером неопытным слушателям было особенно тяжело выбирать ..
@@adiosmusictest наверно те, кто не слушал, действительно могут запутаться, однако почерк мастера я всегда узнаю) можно даже из ранней какой-нибудь симфонии, может, первой взять фрагментик, там много смелых, дерзких музыкальных идей. Хотя у него везде куча интересного)
13 right. I only guessed 2 composers, though.
Excellent result. The composers you guessed are Vivaldi and Morricone?)
@@adiosmusictest Vivaldi and Bruckner
14/15. #14 fooled me. "...a classic" is somewhat ambiguous as this term could be used within any form of music. I assumed this meant "classical" at least in the sense of construction etc.
Thanks for the result. I enjoy reading reviews and comments. Often, based on them, I later make videos a little differently. But with the transition from Russian to English, it is still difficult for me and it is not always possible to optimally select the right words.
@@adiosmusictest Spasibo za quiz :)
No. 10 is not "Tottentanz", but "Totentanz." :)
Thank you. I have small or large inaccuracies in almost every video. The costs of individual work, I try to check myself, but sometimes I don’t have enough outside perspective view before publishing.
13/15. Very tricky and I agree with PartiallyGeorge: there's no real difference beetween a film score by Howard Shore (no, I absolutely didn't watched The Hobbit) and a symphony by Mahler.
And even I support something. In the next part I will try to more clearly state that music from the “Classic” category will only be before 1950, and the rest (“Not”) will be after 1950.
No surprise because all composers for soundtracks know the scores of their colleagues from the classic area , i e opera stage and concert hall....from the bery beginning op.26 Mendelssohn , then Wagner, Mahler, Strawinsky , Debussy, Schönberg and many others( f ex Holst)
No difference between Howard Shore and Mahler??? Words fail me.
In Howard Shore we can re-discover Mahler......