NASA rules out bringing astronauts home on Boeing's Starliner
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 09. 2024
- After weeks of debate, NASA has ruled out bringing two astronauts back to Earth aboard Boeing's Starliner capsule because of lingering concerns about multiple helium leaks and degraded thrusters, both critical to a successful re-entry, officials said Saturday.
CBS News 24/7 is the premier anchored streaming news service from CBS News and Stations that is available free to everyone with access to the internet and is the destination for breaking news, live events, original reporting and storytelling, and programs from CBS News and Stations' top anchors and correspondents working locally, nationally and around the globe. It is available on more than 30 platforms across mobile, desktop and connected TVs for free, as well as CBSNews.com and Paramount+ and live in 91 countries.
Subscribe to the CBS News CZcams channel: / cbsnews
Watch CBS News 24/7: cbsnews.com/live/
Download the CBS News app: cbsnews.com/mo...
Follow CBS News on Instagram: / cbsnews
Like CBS News on Facebook: / cbsnews
Follow CBS News on X: / cbsnews
Subscribe to our newsletters: cbsnews.com/ne...
Try Paramount+ free: paramountplus....
For video licensing inquiries, contact: licensing@veritone.com
An 8 day trip turns into 6 months in space…
And amazingly they had everything they needed to live for years on end for an 8 day mission.
The general public will belive anything the media tells them
Cue the Lost in Space theme music..😂
Gilligan's Island.......in space !! 🚀 🌌
@@youropionmattersnot Well, just like everyone on Gilligan’s Island, they had enough to last 4 seasons..🤣
A 3 hour tour... A three hour tour: yes a sitcom is in order
EMBARRASSING ..... *FOR BOEING*
safer to send an Uber
🤣🤣🤣‼
Maybe not....
EMBARRASSING FOR NASA, the entire US govt, incl Joe and Kamala, who favored Boeing over SpaceX
@@captwillard3346 I'm not sure I want either Boeing or MAGA/SpaceX airlines.
With Elon Musk driving.
Nobody trusts boeing
Boeing hired a LOT of Indian engineers in the last few years, and all the problems started. Boeing employees themselves don't trust the work internally. Fact!
especially their Whistleblowers, is down right dangerous.
suicided whistleblowers
Or Nasa
either way they are batting a thousand
How can Boeing continue to get these contracts after everything that has gone on with them lately? Clearly profits are their highest priority and they are risking peoples lives for it.
Lobby
Government is owned by 1sræl.
@@chadbrambers8346 exactly.
Boeing has a new CEO, who is an engineer. Hopefully, things will change all across Boeing.
Because they donate to politicians, and SpaceX doesn't. Nasa is owned by the government, aka politicians
you hired me for an 8 day mission, now you need to pay me for 12 months!!
Unfortunately, they probably signed a contract that screws them. The contract should be made void, and they need to make these people rich, imo.
Overtime looking sweet. 💵
@parisbarton4304 likely salaried but the hourly rate would make 'em billions
Double and triple their pay for NASA relying on Boeing.
Worst part is that Butch parked in short term parking! He's gonna rack up a serious parking bill.
6 months to wait to get rescued is crazy
Don’t worry, in 1969 America landed humans on the moon and planted their flag. Surely 55 years later America can’t have an issue returning a couple astronauts from the Space station. I would start begging the Russians for help regarding this situation. I guess we have our answer, more important to abandon 2 US citizens in Space than to beg Vladimir Putin for help.
The crew dragon will head up way before that with supplies, they just have to do the jobs of the astronauts of the seats they are taking before they can ride home.
Boeing being allowed to make space fairing craft is ridiculous.
@@tsufordman They have a dragon?
NASA doesn't have a space suit that is compatible with SpaceX. NASA/Boeing doesn't currently have a way to undock from the ISS with the vehicle uncrewed.
They don't have a current way of flying the vehicle return to earth uncrewed.
NASA has a great deal of problems to solve now that they decided to go ahead and launch the test flight with known issues.
FTC: this is what monopoly and lobbying bring to corporate America
What Monopoly? We have SpaceX and whatever Jeff Bezos company is.
Greed is the problem.
@@EikottXD Boeing was not into space until recently
Boeing has lost its edge. This is the beginning of the end
Nah they can get back the greatness but they need to restructure. NASA has come back from their colossal mistakes as can Boeing. Plus what is our alternative. Did y'all forget Airbus forgot to tell the airlines it changed the critical aspects and 3 planes crashed?
@@towritemichelle210SpaceX should bring them back. If Elon doesn't hop on this, then any other space endeavors of his can just be brushed off as complete fantasy
@@towritemichelle210 I have significantly more trust in a plane manufacturer that has made a couple rare mistakes rather than a company that has repeatedly made the same "mistakes" for the past year.
@@ShadowBannedOpinionthey are. That’s the crew dragon that is getting them
NO SAAR DO NOT REDEEM BOEING STOCK
February 2025?!? What the heck. What a major disappointment for Boeing, worst airliner company on earth.
Or outside the Earth 😂.
Aerospace company..Not just jet builders
entire solar system
Yeah, just imagine ...........
"Ladies and gentlemen, we apologise for the delay due to technical issues but your flight will now depart in six months time"
Well. They have to fly new Spacesuits up to them because Boeing suits aren't compatible with Dragon.
Boeing: Here NASA, try our new Starliner 737 Max
-4 bolts
If your core value was safety you wouldn’t have launched with known issues. This is the culmination of over a decade of incompetence and mismanagement at Boeing and nasa. IMHO
💯
DEI is their priority. This is diversity.
Less woth NASA but agreed. At the same time though this is exactly why NASA wanted multiple crew ready systems in place. To imprve on safety and allow for unknown situations to be handled like this, unlike when they were flying the shuttle where damage to a ship basically meant loss of the crew vs just sending another ship up. They had the capability with the shuttle but it was such an undertaking vs the setup that SpaceX uses when it comes to turn around time of their flight hardware.
Their core value is safety of their stock price which is why this conference took place (again) on a Saturday when the markets are closed.
@@wally7856 if you owned ANY Boeing stock you would know this is not true. You’re just a capitalism hater with no education.
At least Boeing is consistent with every product.
Unrepairable I guess
@@pennyhinson4949 *irreparable
Boeing breaking down? Who would have ever guessed!!! (Don't suicide me Boeing)
Hewlett-Packard done stepped up their game too. The yacht.
they keep screwing around, and we’re gonna have the first baby born in space…
This is an interesting take. We definitely should do that as an experiment.
True 🙋♀️
What nationality would it be? Would it inherit that of the parents and be given papers for that country? Would it go by ethnicity? Or just be declared earthling?
She’s in her late 50s.
That lady looks like she's 60... I don't think so
Scoreboard: 13 successful SpaceX crewed flights over 4 years, for approximately $3 billion. Boeing is 0-3 for $5 billion.
I'm surprised the comments aren't turned off. Yet..
Next Feb? They have my condolences
That's a pretty crowded space station...I HOPE THE TOILETS DON'T SNAFU!
@@billjamison2877
No problem. Just try to dodge all those brown U F O's.
@@billjamison2877 The next crew rotation, Crew-9, that would fly to ISS this September would only fly with 2 crew, instead of 4. Butch and Suni would be part of that crew assignment.
They don't even give their engineers raises at all. But the CEO gave himself a 36 million raise when he took over.
The astronauts were going to testify against Boeing and Boeing cant have that.
Thank god last thing we need is a door popping off during descent
Boeing Again showing the absolute foolishness of "trust me bro..."
The fact that after all these months they still don't know what the problem is with starliner says enough. Unfortunately there were flaws in the design that cannot be fixed right now or anytime soon.
Money honey
Human preservation and dignity and humanistic values outweigh a corporation in the court of public opinion. Prayers to those two astronauts.🙏
To bad this situation wasn't part of the program earlier. Three space programs and no one thought about interchangable safety equipment.
Boeing and NASA thought they were above SpaceX to make their spacesuits interchangeable
That's how NASA has done it for years. At least going back to the 60s. That's why Apollo 13 the CO2 scrubbers on the LEM were different from the ones on the command module.
Does anything sound familiar here? Square co2 scrubbers vs. round co2 scrubbers? It has NOT been just 3 space programs, it has been ALL of them!
This clearly demonstrates how far behind we are in the space program. 55 years ago we put a man on the moon and now we can't even get astronauts back from the space station if something goes wrong.
Except we never put a man on the moon.
A smart person would then conclude that we have never been to the moon.
I’m betting SpaceX or a similar company could go get them but that would look even worse for Boeing so it won’t be allowed
Allegedly 😂 yup
@@MrJacobstAnd they better not ask The Russians if they went to keep there jobs or stay out of jail!
So they will have to stay in space for another 6 months? THAT'S CRRAAZZZYYYYY. I hope they have enough supplies to last for that time. WHAT AN EMBARRASSMENT BY BOEING.
Bet other astronauts are sick of that gals hair floating around everywhere.
Six months in space is VERY detrimental to the crew's health. They will experience serious muscle atrophy. And upon return they will probably be wheelchair bound for awhile, and require extensive physical therapy to recover!
@xxxxxxxxxx6903 Yeah, that was the past. They have exercise they can do every day, so the muscle loss that was a problem in the past is not nearly as severe.
@@ryanjohnson3615 she stayed in ISS since space shuttle times its not her first time
@@BondJFK It was probably obnoxious then too.
NASA officials saying they’re proud of the Boeing team makes me want to vomit
maybe another 4 billions contract to Boeing again. you will see 😂😂
Their return on investment is increasing. They donate a few million to politicians and get billions in return to invent failure after failure
Looks like they need to call on Elon again.
He only sends unmanned satellites into space. We need, Endeavor and the other STSs multiple crew manned spaceships back to retrieve ALL OF THE USA ASTRONAUNTS FROM THE ISS.
@@pennyhinson4949??????
@@pennyhinson4949 Hope you had a good nap. It's no longer 2011. We are now in the year 2024 and the Tesla dude is making rockets that humans ride in. Boeing is now an organized crime entity.
@@pennyhinson4949 stop watch the fake news
Huh, he seems too busy running twitter into the ground so he might not have much time to make worse decisions so far...
Boeing can’t build planes or spacecraft…what CAN they build?! 😂 😭
Wealth for shareholders, and cemeteries.
They can build tension and anxiety!
Macaroni art
@@terranotra suddenly clapping after the pilot lands a Boeing doesn’t seem so weird lol
They create room temperature whistle blowers…
Ultimate flex for SpaceX to bring them home
I'm not sure we need the Cyber Truck going up there either with it's MAGA flag on the bumper
Space X has far more failure than success.
SpaceX has already offered to recuse them awhile back. Boeing said no.
@monica93304 would rather a MAGA flag on a cyber truck show up and save me then what is currently going on.
@@monica93304 Which flag would you prefer? I'll bet the stranded astronauts would be happy to see a spaceX rescue craft.
i swear they do this to people on purpose
WhY
Whistleblowers have been crying about the lack of quality control for a while.
Meanwhile at SpaceX: we’re going to be making the first commercial space walk in a couple days and we’ll fly the first polar crewed mission next year. Oh and we’re bring back the other guy’s astronauts
Yeah right. Many new, unproven innovations on that upcoming flight ... what could go wrong?
@@JackOllie4
Can't be much worse than going ahead
despite known problems not addressed like the Starliner fiasco.
@@JackOllie4 which they’ve been testing for the past two years,
@@JackOllie4Okay we'll see if anything goes wrong...
Boeing needs to be put out of business.
They will be. "If its boeing I ain't going" has been trending.
They're doing great job of that on their own
Reorganization from top down, all new management.
Good we don't need another Challenger disaster.
Nor Columbia in 2003.
Nor a disaster during the election.
Why did they risk using Boeing when SpaceX already has a WORKING and RELIABLE vehicle?
Boeing also owns half of SLS & ULA..... but America hates SpaceX....
Because in 2014 when this was awarded, SpaceX was much newer, working through lots of technical bugs on their Cargo Dragon, and had only a few flights under their belt.
"A three hour tour"
"Just sit right back and you'll hear a tale, a tale of a fateful trip."
That was exactly what went through my mind...that theme song.
Where the hell is Boeing? Why are they not participating in this briefing?
Total disgrace.
I hope the crew gets PAID tons of money for this craziness!
Please do Not leave them out there to die, okay. Wtf
Did you watch the report? Or read a single news article?
You definitely can't read lol
For safety measures. Next time I book a flight, Im gonna make sure its not a boeing plane.
Boeing: " no problem, we're a major defense contractor who's too big to fail. We'll keep getting our federal contracts so this is not a priority".
Boeing NEEDS TO BE MADE ACCOUNTABLE this stuff has to STOP, they've been making mistake after mistake. I'm praying for the Astronauts up there. 🙏🇺🇸💙❤️🙏
Boeing also owns half of SLS & ULA..... but America hates SpaceX....
The corrupt politicians that keep flying cover for them need to be in jail, including some on this video.
Could you imagine being stuck on the space station and having NASA tell you they’re going to send You’re only way home back without you but trust us we’ll bring you back later Buy some fashion that we haven’t figured out yet
So Boeing’s equipment fails and these two people must stay in space until February? That sucks.
Gonna miss all the holidays, Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Years, etc.
Sure hope they're home before July 4.
@@norman7179plus being in weightless conditions for so long is gonna wreak havoc on their bodies
They are astronauts. I'm sure astronauts would much rather be in space then doing some boring training in a classroom on Earth.
Bonus for Butch & Sunny: they miss the U.S. Presidential election cycle👍
they get a mail in ballot ...
They will still vote after they are dead 😂
@@direwolf6234 IF it doesn't get ripped off by a so-called 'Porch Pirate'
@@direwolf6234
The mail in ballots will be delayed too, all the ones they have on hand were pre filled in with Joes name as the choice.
Guess no one at NASA wanted to sign off on the chance of two people dying and being in the news.
It did not go unnoticed by me that this report went out of their way to not state the obvious: that Elon Musk’s company Space X will be bringing the astronauts home. The efforts by the mainstream media to show contempt for the man at all turns never cease to amaze me.
Boeing Needs to be Dismantled and ppl need to be held Responsible
I'd rather take my chances free falling back to Earth.
There are no chances. You'd burn up in a fraction of a second. I get it though.
@@SolarDNA You're talking about Boeing, right?
Spacesuits should be made compatible no matter the spacecraft
Send starliner back empty. Send spacex for a rescue mission.
We can't leave them out in space.
NASA be like, nuh-uh, we're not Uber
First, it was the mother of all flight delays. Now it is the biggest flight cancelation of all time.
The Astronauts get paid overtime for this ? Asking for a a friend
No doubt they are being paid for this. It's not their fault they are on a doomed machine
Is your friend deaf or mute, or just tarded?🤔
Why is nasa praising boeing ? How about filing a lawsuit
An absolute embarrassment and tragedy.
Just another nail in the coffin for NOT flying on a Boeing aircraft. What incompatense.
Who uses nails in coffins?🤔
Those are lives out there. They should've called it immediately and asked space X. No one really talks about Boeing, NASA, or even blue origin anymore. Currently the outer regions belong to Space X
Okay this is kinda absurd but somehow wiredly true. Blue Origin however seems have a lot of merit and NASA is still building lots of important technologies for deep space even though they aren't doing a lot with rockets today.
Boeing also owns half of SLS & ULA..... but America hates SpaceX.... Blue Origin are 8 years behind schedule and just lost 2 sections of the fuel tanks in a warehouse accident.
If it’s Boeing, I ain’t going.
Privatizing space flight is going as well as privatizing health care, utilities, and prisons. It is truly stunning how much corruption and greed we the people are willing to tolerate.
I made that decision three weeks ago.
Boeing should leave Starliner attached to the ISS to serve as a new extra bedroom and a reminder of bad engineering practices.
Probably6 too dangerous to even sleep in there.
Too dangerous
What?!? It’s not safe for people to be kept in zero gravity that long. Muscle degeneration is a thing. I’ll pray for their health and safe trip home hopefully sooner rather than later.
People have stayed on the ISS far longer
You say that like they don't know
I’ll guess they should better start using those fitness equipment up on the ISS and start taking some creatine and calcium
come on, they both are astronauts, they know what to do. It's not their first time in space.
Aw ,give Boeing a chance .
They could get a free cremation during that ride .
Boeing is an embarrassment. After all of Boeings shenanigans I’m surprised they are still in business. Government should take over, clean house and fired all the bean counters!
Maybe it’s time for Boeing to close its doors for good. Nothing good has come from Boeing in years.
This was a rare time that it was appropriate for the news broadcaster to interrupt. The whole time NASA spoke they said nothing.
I don't believe any of this. Wake up people.
Never Fly on a Boeing Aircraft !!
Man if I was stuck up there I'd be adding one extra thing to my bucket list and that's banging in space 👉👌
😂😂😂
Lol yup. Gotta be done.
For science!!
Can you think of another iconic American manufacturing company in the 21st century who has fallen as far as Boeing? Their missteps are an indictment of where the culture of big American business is.
Space but not outer
It hurts as many family members of mine worked and engineered things for Boeing. But that was old Boeing. This Boeing needs a complete rework l. Tons of money dumped into corruption. There is no excuse
I've never seen so many congratulations for an equipment failure.
This is the pathetic end product of diversity, equity, and inclusion.
NASA no longer builds space crafts because the government decided it would be cheaper to let other companies compete to do it. This is what "cheaper" looks like. Glad NASA is still enforcing safety protocols.
The difference here is that NASA puts safety first while Boeing puts profits first at the expense of safety.
Hears my ???what were they thinking i wouldn't fly on anything Boeing across the state 😂😂😂😂let alone to outer space
Jesus CHRIST!!!
THEY'RE STILL UP THERE?????
They can't use the transporter or a shuttle craft?
Boeing built those too. 😅
Embarrassing. I can’t imagine being stuck at the ISS for 234 days.
Poor Butch. At least Gilligan got stranded with Mary Ann and Ginger.
And he's stuck there with Witch Hazel! 😂😂
What did he say ? Test flights are risky, we know that. US should help from other countries to help this crew come back. We all help each other. They are not the only one in ISS.
I feel like this will end up like an alien movie.
E.T. to the rescue 😂 dream on 🛸
Alien: Boeing - stuck in space 2025!!! This is the trailer and pre-doc release. S.O.S. 😅
@@captvaghunter I was actually expecting something like a Xenomorph. Sorry, I have been watching too much of this lately.
@@AbrahamCasillas-t3o yea I don't see any "here let us give you our technology for free" visits as a reality will will ever see
@@captvaghunter :0
BS. Boeing knew they had no business launching. Yes, the space shuttle management culture is still strong there. People did come forward knowing this issue shouldn't be ignored before launch. Embarrassing
Suni and Butch are NOT lost in space as the media has sometimes stated. But the psychological-emotional impact in adapting to this unexpected challenge can be addressed in a uniquely uplifting way. NASA should consider coordinating a Livestream Educational Event with they and young future astronaut teens across the planet. The media spin has been negative when this situation can actually prompt a positive - not just for the many worldwide youth whose space career aspirations are being now fuelled with concerns / questions, but for Butch and Suni's morale and sense of purpose by engaging with more than just their personal family members ... but the young members of their earthly human family hungering for understanding. Technical work alone will not sustain a human being in space. Human beings need integration with their earthly teammates in ongoing, meaningful ways.
Butch and Sunny need to have a little fun and get it on because there are no guarantees they make it out of this alive.
Retiring the Space Shuttle was a huge mistake.
Yep
It wasn't. The Shuttle was just too expensive to maintain and too risky for a crew rated spacecraft.
NASA gave it a 1/98 chance of failure/loss of crew themselves which is definitely too risky for our current safety standards. Both Soyuz and Crew Dragon are likely much safer due to the LES and them being launched on rockets that has much better track records than the Space Shuttle.
Boeing also owns half of SLS & ULA..... but America hates SpaceX....
Consider this too. Boing is a major contractor for the Air Force. A very large number of planes came from them, when quality was still a thing. If their quality has degraded so much, I'd think the government would be considering replacing them with one of the other aerospace companies out there.
The first mistake was entering anything built by Boeing..Swallow your pride and call Elon who can retrieve them immediately..You dont just leave people in space for much longer a period of time..You literally just have to call him he said
ELON is very Preoccupied with the CONVICTED FELON right now....
When has Elon been an astronaut and why wouldn't we use SpaceX to pick them up if they could? Your ignorance is showing.
🐻❄️👎🏽
Elon does not run Iss. There is a process to this. You can’t just send a crew dragon to space anytime you want.
The reliability of SpaceX has very little to do with Elon. He's the money bag but he's not the genius behind it.
He ought to be screaming criticism to Boeing instead it’s damage control. Somebody should yelling WTF!!!
So there is no rescue plan to get people off the iss in the event of an emergency??
There is but they don't want to have to ask Elon for help.
Boeing also owns half of SLS & ULA..... but America hates SpaceX....
Dragon can hold 7 people...
There is always a Soyuz capsule docked into the ISS, considering it is the generalized 'emergency' capsule it makes sense, however this isn't emergency there is no reason to use it.
(But yeah when there are more people on the ISS that capsule might not be available, a scenario like that is unlikely but in such an emergency NASA was willing to use the Starliner capsule if it had been the best remaining option.)
"We're building the plane while we're flying it."
Why February? Seems like there MUST be a way to bring folks back from Space within a very short time. What if a station had a serious failure that threatened life of a crew and they needed rescue, NOW and not 8 months after the fact.
They don't want to call on Elon and Biden has irritated Russia.
The reason why they're there is to test the Starliner to see if it's safe to use. But if there was a real emergency, they could get back on a Russian space capsule or a similar vehicle by SpaceX that are already there and functioning.
They said they're going to vote trump so biden ask them to sray there
Most likely is that SpaceX needs to adjust the interior of Dragon to accommodate the additional personnel. Also, it's likely they'll send up supplies as well to replenish what has to be used by the extra 2.
This Gilligan's Island remake has potential
How is this the head of NASA?? Why do we have 80+ year olds running any major government agency? You can just tell by his speech how slowed his cognitive processes are
You'd rather trust our woke youth?
boomers refuse to give up power….
@@derekmorris89slow down with the generalisation there sir. As proper engineers we put science and facts before ideology
Experience.
I rather trust an old wise man then a young unintelligent guy
Space X started out sending modules to ISS with supplies. Then they sent an uncrewed module. Only after those experiences did they send up a crew. Space X did it right. Boeing has made a lot of mistakes in their space mission as well as their planes.