Making D&D Towns Feel Alive
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 06. 2024
- Do your D&D towns feel lived in, or do they fall flat and seem like they were just added randomly to a map? Find more ideas at www.masterthedungeon.com/
Support us on Patreon: / masterthedungeon
See what we're up to on Twitter: / masterdadungeon
00:00 Intro
00:36 Why D&D Towns Exist
02:08 D&D Town Locations & Interactions
03:54 D&D Town Jobs & Keeping Busy
#DungeonsAndDragons #DnD #Animatic - Hry
Quick name generator: Take two normal, two-syllable names, like Walter-Hogan, Edgar-Alvin, Herbert, Lawrence and switch the second syllables around: Walgan-Hoger, Edvin-Algar, Herrence-Lawbert.
That's a really good tip!
A name tip I have, is when you use a 2 or 3 name structure, the last name can be a tradeskill [like carver or smith] or combine two nouns [Flintlock, Rosewood]
or if your really put on the spot, just anything with the word "son" on the end [Cliffson, Swordson]
This is genius!
Pretty cool! My usual trick is to take a regular name or word as a seed and change the vowels or a letter or two. For example from Walter we can get Walden, Velter, or even Zoltar. Also I usually just focus on the consonants and make my own vowels. So for example Walter generates WLTR which if you change the W to a Z can also get you Zoltara. Or just something else that pooped into your head just from toying with ideas.
Bobson-Dugnutt -> Bobnutt Dugson.
What a premium idea!
I remember I once had an old storytelling lady in a town, she’d just sit around telling kids fairy tales & legends surrounding the town’s history, but one of my players kept coming back to hear every story she had
Did you make all the stories or is there somewhere online I can find them?
@@lizardperson445 I had a couple short stories prepared, but one was a modified version of Beowulf and the dragon. I only had to improvise one before the rest of the party told him to stop, though looking back, I should’ve just said something along the lines of “you sit and listen for an hour and are entertained” after the first 2 times so as not to waste too much time
@@bobmcbob9856I like this idea but to sprinkle in foreshadowing about the party's next adventure so that the storyteller might become part of something larger, like the fortune tellers in Red Dead Redemption
@@Frothmeister Wonderful idea. I liked the storyteller, just was a very inexperienced DM at the time & let her eat up too much of our time.
One of the _nice_ things about having players who know more than you about period-appropriate jobs and activities is that you can lean on them for descriptions.
"Hey Dave, what's the inside of this blacksmith going to look like?" and then get your NPC ready while Dave talks about triphammers for the rest of the party so you don't have to.
I always try to tap player creativity. I once had a player playing a dwarf priest, and asked him in the first session - in character - to talk to us about the tenants his religion. About 80% of that religion's story was created right there.
If you can make your job easier while simultaneously making the players feel invested in the setting, do it.
I tried getting into DMing with my group who already have 2 regular DMs. One of them had such a detailed backstory that it became the current main quest and the other has a degree in city building so I asked him to help create a realistic city based on some of the ideas I wanted in it. Really fun dynamic since one player char has inside knowledge of the town while another drives the group forward.
Now my job is to make sure there are enough surprises for all of them and make the rest of the table not feel less useful or feel as player NPCs
@@MWSin1 If you can trust your players to create something appropriate (in the tonal sense and the lack of vulgarity sense), I find this is a great idea.
The campaign can be an ongoing negotiation as you all fumble about and collectively try to figure out the glorious wonder of the early modern period's many bizzare things.
this, if i have a phd player at the table, i'll use them
Funny thing: i play a Lot of the sims games, so i wrote down about a dozen actions that my sims often can be seen doing in the background which caught my interest such as cleaning/ making plans/ conversation etc and i use that list to always make sure that i say that my dnd npcs are doing some ambient action, just like a sim
That's a really good idea. I might need to start keeping track of random things I do or see people doing (since I don't play sims much).
@@thedemonslayer51
The full list of 'ambient' actions, copy pasted from my notes, since it might be of value to you
Organizing furniture / Arranging storage
Writing/ Journaling/ Practicing art
Plotting/ Observing/ Researching/ Studying/ Reading
Bored
Collecting resources/ Working for trade goods
Using large machines/ Concentrating
Conflict (roll an encounter)
Crafting/ Repairing equipment, or cohort items
Designing scale models/ Trial and Error designing
Entertaining/ Consorting/ Practicing politics or philosophy
Pacing/ Indecisiveness/ Wandering
Smoking/ Drinking/ Eating
Commiserating alone/ with others
Insignificant conflicts (man vs. nature/ themselves/ God/ man)
@@daveshif2514 Thanks! I be sure to jot these down and probably add to it over some days!
Clever!
@@thedemonslayer51 And that is a clever adaptation of an idea for your particular environment; kudos! I will be building such lists myself!
My tip: the shop is out of something. Pick one minor thing that shop or business might sell. They are out of it, and won't have any fresh stock until sometime next week. This obviously is not intended to hinder or punish players, but instead to show that shops have customers besides the players.
"Well isn't this just a geological abnormality. Two weeks from everywhere."
Some old modules wrote down what the general store had for inventory. 12 ropes, 5 knives, one old bow, 24 bottles of oil, 20 sacks etc. Often for out of the way stores in nowhere that wouldn't be supplied during the adventure.
In larger towns you simply find other craftspeople, it's assumed that goods are easier to get hold of in larger communities that are more self-sufficient and not limited to a trickle of imports.
A city events table can include sudden market events as well. One week the nutrient-manna machines break down, food doubles in cost overnight and famine threatens. Or imported cloth is declared illegal for some reason.
Sometimes we've rolled for how much a place has in store. The armourer has 2d10 shields, 1d6-3 suits of heavy cuirass and 1d10 light war-harnesses.
Just for fun, when my PCs are in a major city and visiting the "Adventurer Store", I like to off handedly describe another adventuring group exiting/entering. It seems to catch their attention and make them wonder about the other stories that are being lived.
yeah until you get a party that just wants to stalk that party, or views them as some kind of "hidden threat" or competition....
@@djm.o.d.9376 Heh, had that happen "once". Turned out the other party was roughly twice their level. Didn't go so well for the players... luckily the NPC party wasn't a bunch of murder hobos
I admit, I'm curious if the "Adventurer Store" is a literal thing or just a shorthand for this post xD; because the idea of an "Adventurer Store" could say a *lot* about a setting or culture too! Why isn't it just general stores, blacksmiths, fletchers, etc? What about this place makes *that* a profitable enterprise?
It's a fun idea to play with! And, funnily enough, one I used myself. In my own setting, there's a region where the major culture *does* value exploration and knowledge as a "rite of passage" for those becoming adults - and I did use something kinda similar.
@@Sturmensky I had something similar where the players world find maps, equipment, things that would help them travel. Lower quality than more specialized stores, but cheaper and only in bigger urban areas.
@@Sturmensky Obviously no clue if OP's is literal or not, but I have played in/created the content for a game where "adventurer" is a literal job description and there were professionals who made a living out of it. Our dungeon-crawl that I created was flavored as an underground monastery for a deity of plenty, so anything inside it kept reproducing; if it was looted and goods were removed, new identical ones would appear. But since monsters had moved into this safe place, that meant any who were killed got replaced too. So the town above it marketed the HELL out of it as a great place for adventurers to get their start and adjusted their town businesses accordingly. My character didn't know what he wanted to do with his life, so he chose adventurer to bring money home while he figured it out :)
You know what would be cool? Making a town that is really that "NPC's are just idle", but putting emphasis enough to make the players think about what the hell is happening, intentionally making it creepy and awkward, so that they have a mystery to solve, in this case: "why the hell do all of those guys seem like they've been brainwashed?"
That's actually common fantasy trope - all townspeople are idle/overly happy/aggressive generaly leads to some hidden plot behind it :)
Yeah, that’s the town that:
1)Got replaced by some creature.
2) Got killed in a way that left their bodies perfectly preserved and is now run by a Lich that forgot all about the mundane things you do when alive
3)Is actually just an illusion
Ok but the cleaning advice is unironically very solid
After I read how leatherworking often used piss and other excrements to treat their materials, even though I KNOW how it happens, I think I'd rather just describe them cleaning their tools/shed haha
Also with the simple idea of cleaning there arises the question of how the npc FEELS about cleaning something. Are they cheerful? Is this drudgery? Perhaps some busywork or punishment? Are they meticulous, grumbling curses under their breath, have an obvious connection (such as the owner), etc. As an example I offer the simple scenario of someone grooming a horse or cleaning a stable.
And as an added bonus: when two people are tasked with cleaning something they are invariably also chatting among themselves. This can be used to give insight not just into their disposition and motivations but the world around them. Especially if they are gossiping.
Fun bonus about this, you can then have the poor sell such to those who use it. which can then go in interesting directions
I remember populating a tavern of a seaside town with interesting and varied characters, as sailors and travelers from outside the continent would appear there...
And the elf lady of the party glued to an elven sailor, and I had to improv a f*ckton.
It was fun. They got a different route by sea, and I got to use Captain Pen and his ship, the calligrapher, for the first time.
lol if you have a player who has a Phd in medieval history, AND, they are judging you for your world building...
well then I say your table found a new volunteer DM to start running some games too... 🤣
Truth :)
Just remember, D&D is not set in medieval Earth. You can deviate from historical reality all you want.
@@TimLewallen oh for sure! The main campaign im running is based on the begining of the magical industrial revolution, with one faction at arguable close to being a ww2 level power.
@@mokane86 I read a short story back in high school that was like that. The industrial revolution and subsequent information revolution were based in magic. It was really fascinating. I can't remember who wrote it. I *think* it may have been a short story in the Mirrorshades Anthology. There was also a cool book by Bruce Sterling called "The Difference Engine" which was an alternate history where the industrial revolution and the information revolution happened at the same time.
For anyone interested in how candles are made, it's pretty much just pouring molten beeswax, animal fat or paraffin into a mold with a string, and sometimes coating said string in the fuel you used too so it starts burning easyer.
Notes: making them with paraffin makes for a much more uniform process, as it's usually a single compound in contrast to the natural alternatives, which are complex fat mixes.
Making them with animal fat will make for rather dim, smelly and smokey, but cheaper candles.
Additionally, very high grade beeswax will sometimes form little white spots all over it, similar to some chocolates, when exposed to slight temperature changes over time.
GOD yes I fucking LOVE candles
@@TheD736 maybe you could be interested in the extra info I just added
Beeswax candles rock
5:41 EXCUSE ME, I PLAY D&D TO _ESCAPE_ FROM REALITY FOR A WHILE.
I remember an old bit of advice from the 2e players handbook. To paraphrase: an illusionist can only create a convincing illusion for creatures they’ve experienced.
Applying it to DMs, studying up on what you’re describing is hugely important.
Good points made. I try to make at least one unique thing about the town be it the main export or demeanor of the townsfolk. But pointing out basic activities the townsfolk are doing does make it feel more alive. Just make sure you have some generic NPC personalities at the ready as someone is bound to talk to the person sweeping the stoop in front of their home. ;)
one trick ive done that works pretty well , if you havent prepared some random NPCs or have some good table, is to pick a TV show and just start nabbing characters from it as you need to fill in.
since you made me pop in to say this with the "stoop" comment id say this town is pulling from "Hey Arnold" and that first person acts like Stoop Kid, and the random lady NPC they want to talk to is like Helga or Grandma, and etc.
unless you really want to go there, i dont mean total spoof or copy paste so that your players are going to catch on, but for your internal easy inspiration.
I’ve spent the better part of a decade watching videos on writing, world building, real history, how they made things back in the day, etc…
I only started D&D last October.
It’s like I finally found the place where all of that useless yet fascinating knowledge has a use, and it’s great!
I _can_ tell you what’s happening in the cobbler’s shop (and it isn’t _making_ shoes! It’s exclusively _repairing_ shoes!), or what the knights are eating, or how those mountains have effected the weather.
I already kinda understood this, but this video helped me realize I’m not actually using that knowledge in my games, and I should as a DM!
Tonight they’re going into a new town, I’m gonna try to do it!
Cool. How did it go?
I concur. How did it go.
@@spencervance8484 I know the campaign ended well but no clue which town it was 😅
4:13 you should aslo know what time of the year it is because caring for plants depends entirely on weather and time of the year
“You have come to our town on our monthly cleaning day traveller. What do you need”
Thanks for the video! I just realized I've been forgetting to put candlestick makers in my towns. XD
Everyone in your town must have darkvision haha
The bums don't care who makes candles and will most likely not ask.
They want to know stuff like "can I recharge my electric torch here?"
@@masterthedungeon6094 Veins of the Earth completely removed darkvision. And it takes place completely in the deep dark underneath the surface.
@SusCalvin Heh its a detail more for me than them, though my players do occasionally gravitate towards random bits so I never know for sure. 8D
"They can feel flat, un-inviting, and lifeless."
Vallaki, Krezk, and the village of Barovia: "That's...why I'm here."
Great advice! I'm gonna use a lot of this in the future. I'd also throw in that if a campaign involves notable factions, having faction interactions can give players valuable information about those factions too. Stuff like cultist preacher on a soapbox getting arrested by Kingsguard or whatever gives a lot of implied context to the world.
Good video, currently running an Urban campaign in a harbour city. They're always seeing Tellin the fisher hauling that nights catch to market, till they didn't...... New quest, find Tellin.
I love the simple but detailed art style of this video
I love so much this channel. I've seen so many channels just give generic advice and some of them would give examples but this channel really focuses on the little details of being a great DM. After watching one of your videos I feel inspired with a lot of new ideas that I feel that they will improve my DMing. Thank you.
Since all of my players also have Game Master Experiance, I can be lazy. When one player asks for a specific detail abd I have no name or description for it: I just point to another player and relay the question to him. This way I engage more than one player at a time, outsorce the thinking, and give the players the agency to contribute to worldbuilding.
For really committed DMs I highly recommend spending some weekends at historical museums. The most recent I've been to was a glass museum with a glass blowing demonstration. I learned a ton about how glass was made in the early 1700s and those kind of details can really help flesh stuff out.
Great video with a lot of helpful tips. I always find filling my towns and making then feel alive difficult, so all this advice was super useful.
A random encounter table for townies. Can be variable with town districts or day/night if you like. One city-wide event table for what the big talk of the town this week is.
i am quite good in making towns feel alive. so much so that my party immediatly noticed that one of the towns they stopped in was weird. there were still people doing stuff but I made it feel like the whole town solely existed for them (it was a very elaborate illusion using spells such as mass suggestion and illusionary spells. it existed to stall the hero's). but it is good to hear all of this verbalised cause I did it mostly subconciously and did not know how I did it per se
Please help
@@Eldritch_Balloon just make sure there are NPCs that are "useless" to the plot. And NPCs that interact with each other and not just the player characters. And consistently. Just "You hear a small girl mention to their parent, that they don't like the taste of grandma's spaghetti."
i have a large list of names i’ve generated ahead of time (they all have little checkboxes so i can mark the ones i’ve already used). it really helps to *SAY* the name out loud before you use it, just to see if it sounds funny. if you don’t, you might end up making the players laugh every time they interact with the NPC.
When PC enter a shop have a few go to descriptions: One) the shopkeeper is busy replacing merchandise on shelves. Two) the shopkeeper is taking inventory. Three) the shopkeeper is finishing a transaction as the PC walk in.
I've been going through you're videos, and I have to say, there are some of my favorite videos because they are quick and to the point. I mean this in the most positive way possible. I know when I click on one of your videos I'm going to learn something useful, that stays on the topic of what the title is.
I would add a theater as the players main place of operation, or homebase, instead of the usual inn or tavern.
It is a great place to stay and a way to add some "Class" to your characters and your town.
And a great way to reference actual theater plays and opera shows and similar, to show off your great knowledge of such
I really like the animated follow up to everything you say. It's pretty great effort and it's pleasant to see. I only realised that is worthy of praise after a couple videos and realising you're still a growing channel
Really cool advice. I’m running a Pathfinder 2e game where the party keeps hopping between three towns because there’s just nothing to do in them. So I’ve been trying to work on fleshing out the world around them more. Particularly because they have a more reactive play style, so I need to figure out things that can happen around them.
You could try and make them hop on as hired muscle for a caravan out of the three cities, I heard about drovers on a podcast yesterday and now I'm thinking that would be a fun little filler arc for a campaign
@@agustinvenegas5238 That could work, but it’s more about them trying to deal with a noble house that spans across the cities, so random side quests may not help. Especially since they have the unfortunate combination of being laser-focused on the main quest, and also not wanting to make any big moves.
Love the voice, the advice and the drawings! You've earned a subscriber :)
I absolutely love your channel. The videos are so informative, and yet simple and to the point, making them easy to follow and easy to retain the information. Keep on keeping on!
These are some really great tips! I've been struggling to help make the world or the town really feel alive, rather than a bunch of little set pieces or stages for the characters to move from one to the next. Thanks so much for making this, I fully intend to utilize the tips here next weekend! :)
On the topic of doing research, I've found CZcams to be a HUGELY beneficial resource. You can watch videos on history and get a real feel for what it was like and then just take notes on the things that make it *feel* alive. A lot of the time, you can even get details on the smells involved from the people doing the documentary/experiment!
3:49 the answer is always Fireball what was described in the most detail.
5:19 houserule: if for any reason someone with a PHD in medeival history joins the table, they're the DM.
For NPC names for my SciFi game i put together a list of names from "Behind the name" , specifically the list of popular names, and specifically specifically the names when listed in order of names that changed rank the most from the previous year.
This was a pretty helpful video which really gave me a clearer idea of how to make more interactive type of sessions
Love this series (and the art)! Gonna use all these tips for my next DM session.
My players saved a kingdom and then traveled for about 3 to 4 years... So when they came back, they asked to go to their favorite tavern that they used to go at the start of the campaign... I described how when they got in the place where the tavern was supposed to be there was, instead, an alchemist ingredients shop.
Why you ask? Well, the tavern keeper died of natural causes 1 year after they started traveling, and his family (only 2 sons, both 20 years old) now is trying a new life as shop keepers in other parts of the kingdom.
They recognised the players from being the "old man's favorite clients" and offered them discounts, since the gold that the players spended with the tavern helped them to open the shops that they have now.
Everyone felt like they made difference in the lives of the NPCs and were all super sorry for not being at the old man's funeral... It was so wholesome...
(Edit)
Some words they shared:
"He was a good man and the best at beer brewing" - Half Orc Barbarian
"The uncle that i never had" - Symic Hybrid Rogue
"He helped me making money when i had nowhere to go" - Sea Elf Bard
"He always liked when i casted spells for him to see... It was just cantrips most of the time, but he thought i would be the best wizard to come..." - Elf Wizard
The fun thing is that all that they said was roleplayed, nothing was in their backstory, so i felt like a great DM at the time.
This was such a duh moment for me but extremely helpful. It's so easy to over think when deep diving into world building and this was a good wake up call and reeled me way back in. Thank you for this grounding content.
Most towns have an industry or commerce. Whether fishing, smiting, forestry, ag, quarrying or mining, there will be an activity that allows working folk to work.
I those cases when the player knows more than DM, then the DM asks the player what is going on in the candle shop
That's for doing these videos. They help with creativity so much
The art of conversation does play a big role for me.
But also, I learned little interactions and microexpressions from literally talking everyday-this has helped me improv and even design the interactions with the party.
At 6:20 talking about busy people is a busy town seems like a minor detail, its not in a minor town though lol
Just found your channel from a recommendation in a Bob World Builder post! Love your content! You've got one more subscriber, and hopefully many more soon.
one mini encounter i remember from a recent session was the party enterred the town and we were beset by a small pack of young boys being well, young boys. some mudslinging later we find em and get them to go on home
There's ALWAYS something that needs cleaning. Excellent 😊
I've found that Red Dead Redemption 2 makes for some surprisingly effective DnD inspiration. Especially with how each town has their own personality.
This genuinely helps me, I'm running my first dnd session as a DM, and I somehow made my players interested in like the three main NPC's that inhabit the town, which honestly is extremely lucky on my part because without them my town is basically them standing around doing noting, sure the tavern Keeper cleans alot, but the others guys are just static, so tha k you for making this, it's simipw but I never thought about it like this, Thanks!
I will say the vagueness skill is a good skill to have even if you're a well prepared DM because it's impossible to prepare for everything the players will want to do. You can think of everything that sounds reasonable for them to explore and then suddenly they tell you a location in town they want to visit that's out of left field.
"I wanna visit the city graveyard or morgue"
"Uh... really?"
"Yeah my father died in an unknown location so I wanna see if any of the graves have his name"
"Um... okay..."
Really helpful! Thank you so much!
This video was extremely helpful in thinking about what to think about lol
Always make it feel like you’re interrupting something.
My towns are gonna be so freaking clean now
Your videos are excellent refreshers even though I wish I could go into a paragraph of how luxurious a noble's manor is and how badly I want my players to egg his house because he's the guy who insisted on a tax increase to fund his crippling obsessions' with gem encrusted goblets.
Great information, thank you !
"You see ..."
(1) A dozen soldiers sitting on the ground, some sleeping, while the teamsters try to reattach a wagon wheel on their transport.
(2) An old man hit a child, and no one in town seems to notice or care.
(3) An old woman in a fur coat, struggling with carrying two heavy suitcases.
There needs to be an app of audio statements and descriptions so a DM can choose from them
Been seeing youtuber ads for "descryb" which is basically what you are saying. $$$$ tho
I have been a victim of over describing architecture for sure!
Love the cleaning tip!
One tip I’ve heard is keeping a list of names. If you need a name to drop in just pick on from the list, cross it off and make a note for where it fits in, and then later you can refresh the list.
Thanks for this!
sleepy towns where everyone is idol is a town I've used but it was a horror session and the group got to see the town bustling and alive after freeing it from the pall of the shadowfell.
STAHP MAKING SUCH GOOD CONTENT! I can't stop binge watching 💜💙💚💛🧡❤
(sry if my english is too crispy ^^) i love combining staleness with uneasiness. Bring a group into a town where you describe how empty everything is, and how dead the peoples eyes look to them,noone interacting and you will have in no time a group that wants to dismantle the village to find the secret, but also burn it down because there has to be a curse or some other form of evil.
i had a group investigating such a town for way longer than i thought they would be interested in it. It took them some time to realise they were just annoying some peaceful but very ascetic cultist villagers with a vow to never ever talk to an outsider
The Absence of information can be equally appealing as a mass of information as it simply forces you to interact with the remaining things in different way than you did before. My people dismanteled a specific farmhouse before realising the truth and to this day i dont get excactly why they did it, but they swear it made sense to them back then
Great video. Thank you
A few old as dirt tips for settlment enrichment.
Every place has an outcast, the village drunk, the crazy cat lady et cetera. Jot down an incredibly random outcast for each settlment. It provides atmosphere and things for local NPCs to gossip about when you need some filler dialogue.
At the start of creating a new settlement provide it with some absolutely random bit of lore about it's history. "There were five churches when the town only had three citizens/this river provides a prized tiny purple fish people like as pets". Just something seemingly off the wall random. Now you have inspiration for all sorts of things to do with the town. You get to tell a story of how the churches moved in before citizens when the local monarch chartered a new town, and now the place is named or nicnamed Fivetemples. You have a reason for a village to celebrate every year when brilliant purple fish spawn thier young.
Children, except military encampments almost everywhere will have children, and they develop little cultures of their own. Don't forget the kids in any considerations for listing local factions.
3rd places. Children and adults all desire a 3rd place... that 3rd spot other than home or work that they think of as theirs in a way. For Norm and others Cheers was their 3rd place... but even in DnD the tavern can't be the only 3rd place available. Where do the kids hang out, the artists, the rumor mongers, the baseball cap and cup of coffe type old guys?
These randoms bits are extremely beneficial in allowing communties to stand out from each other. PCs will recall "crazy cat lady town/that place which smells like urine because of the giant tannery".
I wish there was a playlist for all the town videos, so I could watch them easily
We can make that happen
@@masterthedungeon6094 that would be great, thanks!
Also: If you have a player who is super knowledgeable about the moving and shaking in a historical setting, you could always ask for their help! In my experience people are more than willing to share their interests if you ask, and the everyday goings on in a candlemaker's shop probably won't be super relevant to the plot of the game... it's the things that aren't ordinary that are usually plot points.
1st - I subscribed. These videos are wonderfully put together.
Towns - 1 to 3 things the town is known for (mining, trading, junction/crossroads, outpost/frontier, leisure/entertainment, criminal safe haven, farming, etc). This will help explain why the NPC's are here.
"A quite town" is a passive perception/investigation by the players. To the players, what they see may seem mundane after days on the road vanquishing "bandits" and weeks exploring a "deadly" dungeon. Doesn't mean it is.
Cities, and larger, should always feel "lively" though with people "accidentally" relieving them of their coin and treasure... I mean, bumping into them and having "places to be."
"Many" sessions later when they enter a city that is "silent" or a town that is "agitated" in your campaign, it should put the "hairs on the back of their neck" up and them on alert. Or allow what ever mishaps befall them because they ignored the clues. *cue evil laugh*
I have a quick description on what is going on at different times of the day. As the adventurers return to the city it might be evening, or maybe they woke up before the sun rose.. I’ll have quick descriptions of what they see at each location based on the time of day to give town that life feel that things are going on without them
being a DM with a menace player is hard on my brain. they keep pickpocket people and throwing rocks to elderly couple
IF the players stay longer in a town have the NPCs do different stuff. Like that candlemaker is making candles on the first two times they meet him, but on the third day he's cleaning up. Or like that old guy they've meet in the tavern on their second day who they then meet again on the fifth days afternoon sitting at the lake fishing. Also have one day of the week be market day - the day when all the farmers come to town to sell the food and other items on the market place. Add one or two travelling merchants who maybe also have some advenruting gear (that would not be sold by the farmers) so visiting that market is interesting for the players.
Basically find ways so the people are not always doing the exact same thing, so they don't feel like those NPCs from videogames nobody wants to talk to because all their reactions are just generic and predetermined.
My favorite way of introducing this is the concept of Street Cred (Shadowrun/ Cyberpunk mechanic) When you first go to a bar, many will ignore you or eye you over with passive interest, and if you're lucky someone might introduce themself or introduce some need they have to your table (consider these options a chance to improve your rep with the locals). Alternatively if they know you or it's your town, you'll find the locals far more cordial, willing to fling open their doors and rush to greet you.
In this way the npc's become a breathing entity that's inhales and exhales pulse to your notoriety or infamy. ;)
I do have a player who knows way too much about obscure things like ye olde candlemaking.
I've found the best thing to do is just look to him, and tell him, "the candlemaker is working. What would that look like?"
People love getting to show off what the know. He always gets excited when his weird knowledge becomes relevant.
I don't think, as adults, the DM needs to know all these things. Use your players weird knowledge. My other player is basically an engineer with his knowledge and sometimes i get things wrong.
Instead of doubling down and say its magic, i let him tell me how it works, and i use that knowledge to fix my description (it also makes it so that seemingly incorrect things stick out to show something is off about the situation).
Great video thank you 😊
I did a rework of Phandalin for a Lost Mine of Phandelver campaign.
I got inspires by Oddworld: Stranger's Wrath. I described the town having a somber tone. The residents were bored and everyone hasn't found their fortune. The Redbrand militia has been protecting the town, but the heavy protection tax has left everyone worse for wear.
It was vague enough that my players enjoyed the "new" town since the residents weren't mean, but sensed that they needed to do something to uplift the mood.
Also, it turns out, out of all the vague details of this town. My players really latched onto the livestock ranch where one cow was nicknamed "Brick" by the players. I tried to do a thing where the rancher couldn't pay a tax so a cow was going to be taken by Redbrands. As it turned out, the Cow rolled a nat 20 on its Athletics check and became an immovable object. The players laughed and vowed to protect Brick the Cow.
"As you poke your head in the door, you are immediately hit with the scent of beeswax. To your left, you see an old elf pouring what you can only assume is the source of that lovely scent into pewter molds, threads that will serve as wicks suspended on a metal rod draped over the top of each. They range in size from barely bigger than the matchstick that would light them, to candles bigger than your own, sizable barbarian thumb, and almost as long as your forearm. 'With ya in a moment, let me finish the pourings, would'ja?' The elf barely gives the slightest nod he's even noticed you. The rest of the shop is mahogany floors and shelves, lined with candles. tallow, paraffin, and beeswax, every shape, size, and colour you could imagine. Hopefully the chandler can read the list Hekore sent you with..."
Just an example of the "lived in" nature of the kind of narration I'd give, re: the town, and since you mentioned "how things work" and candlemaking, it just kind of went from there (since I used to dabble in beeswax candlemaking).
Wow. Simply wow.
"Have you heard of the high elves?"
The sleepy town _can_ be used intentionally, by the way, if you *want* it to feel strange and unnatural.
Imagine a bright, sunny day in a town, and no one's around. Where is everyone? Why do they only speak when spoken to?
The farmers make quick work, and then hurry back inside their homes at the urging of their family. The shops are happy to sell, but... what's keeping them in business, your party's the only one who's been here all day?
Maybe it's the illusion of a masterful mage who, for all her power, doesn't really understand how day-to-day interaction between normal people works. Maybe it's an infestation of pod people, pretending to be human until the time is right... maybe the townsfolk are scared due to a string of recent disappearances, only for the missing persons to return with wide smiles and dull eyes...
Atmosphere is super important! The hustle and bustle of a lived-in atmosphere, too, can be unsettling when unexpected, or perhaps comedic. Imagine sneaking through an enemy camp, when two chatting hobgoblins devolve into an argument-suddenly, they challenge each other to a duel, drawing their blades! Or, perhaps, you watch torchlights light up outside and witness a posse out on a witch hunt.
"What do they eat?"
-MrBtongue
I do something a bit different I do a lot of public DMing at Cons at the D&D experience and Adventure league at game shops. So I tend to use one shot NPCs as a way to get quieter players more invested in the game by letting them describe the NPC and then I run it as that on Improve. The bar maid is old and tired of the lifestyle but it is a job OR this a halfling who balances the drink tray on her hat OR their is no made and the Man behind the counter is using message to take orders, Prestidigitation to transmute the drinks and mage hand to deliver the drinks.
This example isn't from D&D per se, but...
Approach the witches' mansion, you'll probably find the one-legged mechanic who works for them outside, building automatons out of scrap metal and arcane implements. If not, she's probably in either the market district, the industrial district, or the wasteland outside the city, buying or salvaging parts.
If you have time to prepare and you know your players will end up in a town for one reason or another - ask yourself a few questions about the town and take notes.
Personally I think the most important ones are:
* How big is the town? Is it a hamlet with just a few houses, no more than two dozen souls? Or is it a city with hundreds of people?
* What's the reason for the city to be there? Is it a mining town? Do they fish? Is everything centered around this newfangled water powered weaving mill that Gnome founded a few years back? Or is it simply a group of houses that developed around a waystation deep in the woods?
* Weird rituals and customs. For example - when the video talked about let people clean the shop... why not have this superstition, that you HAVE to clean the shop (and the streets and houses) every Saturday, lest the spirits get angry. It should be a bit strange - but not really threatening (well, as long as that isn't your plan).
Not as important, but still good to know:
* How old is the city? Is it built on the ruins of an Dwarven city? Is there a circle of standing stones (like in Avebury in England)? Does anyone know who was appeased / worhsipped here?
* What's the signature drink or food of that town? It's one thing to order 'a beer' in the Tavern. It's something else, if you get Original Hagsbury Pale Hazlenut Ale.
* Who rules the town? Who is important? Who rules the less legal activities?
Other options to cleaning may be sleeping, reading a book or daydreaming. Not everyone is that busy or hard-working :D
I just imagined a castle guard complaining about working a second watch. He is complaining because people don't particularly like the local noble he is guarding so despite the money he isn't invested in his job. They are understaffed because so many people prefer making less money than working for the noble.
Also, looking up random things that your players come up with can also get you to google things that are definitely going to get you on some list somewhere. So far I’ve had to research making gun powder from scratch, how to dispose of a body chemically/non-chemically, explosive potential of at least 4 different items, and (of course) how poisons and toxins effect the nervous systems of biological creatures.
I’m on at least one organization’s list at this point.
Thanks.
I am not a geologist. My players kept asking me about the minerals used in the masonry… it was very awkward…
Nice day for fishing.
I have a plot hook that involves the guards wanting to arrest and question a particular character on sight (due to a case of mistaken identity). I considered having this happen during a shift change. So that instead of just two or three guards, there happens to be twice that at the exact moment. Sure it sounds scripted (because it is), but I'm hoping I can play it off as impeccable timing. Should also deter the murder hobos from going "well, we got this!"
“There’s always something that needs to be cleaned”
Have you been talking to my wife again?
i loooooove these videos, i've always wondered, who does the art for the channel? do they have somehwer i can follow them?
Omg I love your voice!
4:39 NUSREET