Behind the Banksy Stunt

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 31. 10. 2018
  • When Banksy shredded his artwork the moment after it sold at auction, he left many questions unanswered. What are we to make of the stunt? And subscribe to the new PBS Digital Studios series Two Cents: / twocentspbs .
    To support our channel, visit: / artassignment .
    Thanks to our Grandmasters of the Arts Vincent Apa and Indianapolis Homes Realty, and all of our patrons, especially Bronze Bond, Patrick Hanna, M12 Studio, Jane Quale, and Constance Urist.
    Subscribe for new episodes of The Art Assignment every other Thursday!
    --
    Follow us elsewhere for the full Art Assignment experience:
    Tumblr: theartassignment.com
    Response Tumblr: all.theartassignment.com
    Twitter: / artassignment
    Instagram: / theartassignment
    Facebook: / theartassignment
    and don't forget Reddit!: / theartassignment

Komentáře • 1,5K

  • @poiewhfopiewhf
    @poiewhfopiewhf Před 5 lety +5567

    Banksy is how to basic

    • @forg7430
      @forg7430 Před 5 lety +46

      Excuse me but I can hardly understand what you said

    • @poiewhfopiewhf
      @poiewhfopiewhf Před 5 lety +49

      Bella Draws look up how to basic

    • @forg7430
      @forg7430 Před 5 lety +20

      Oh sorry I didn't now it was a channel

    • @SianaGearz
      @SianaGearz Před 5 lety +33

      Hello, underrated comment.

    • @poiewhfopiewhf
      @poiewhfopiewhf Před 5 lety +6

      Siana Gearz hello there

  • @gardenhead92
    @gardenhead92 Před 5 lety +12295

    Plot twist: Banksy was both the seller and the buyer

    • @oof-rr5nf
      @oof-rr5nf Před 5 lety +142

      Hahahahaha okay
      I like where your mind is at

    • @draculatod3559
      @draculatod3559 Před 5 lety +119

      That's what I thought

    • @MCAndyT
      @MCAndyT Před 5 lety +35

      Totes like Damien Hirst and "For The Love of God"

    • @kagitsune
      @kagitsune Před 5 lety +20

      @@MCAndyT Thanks for mentioning this, looked it up. Fascinating story.

    • @annakeye
      @annakeye Před 5 lety +26

      *+Stephen Bly*
      Hardly a plot twist. Fairly obvious more like.

  • @moiradarling97
    @moiradarling97 Před 5 lety +4681

    This was a great video but it just made me think about how much I love the word shenanigans.

    • @theartassignment
      @theartassignment  Před 5 lety +178

      It's a great word. I should try to work it into more videos, no?

    • @oof-rr5nf
      @oof-rr5nf Před 5 lety +22

      @@theartassignment That calls for a resounding: Yes, please!

    • @moiradarling97
      @moiradarling97 Před 5 lety +12

      The Art Assignment yes, all of them...

    • @theartassignment
      @theartassignment  Před 5 lety +49

      Open call for two types of video ideas: 1) In which the word "shenanigans" can be easily incorporated, and 2) in which it would be very difficult to incorporate the word "shenanigans."

    • @AlanKlughammer
      @AlanKlughammer Před 5 lety

      @@theartassignment what is all this talk of incorporating the word 'shenanigans' into your work?

  • @katelyns8144
    @katelyns8144 Před 4 lety +324

    I find it ironic because art critics and scholars delve so deep into interpreting his art that they're missing his point of "stop taking art so seriously"

    • @phantasian1592
      @phantasian1592 Před 2 lety +20

      I think you missed his point. To me it’s not about to stop talking art so seriously, but rather that there’s a certain beauty in a piece of arts impermanence.

    • @anxia-tea5846
      @anxia-tea5846 Před rokem +8

      @@phantasian1592 ironically, you just helped OP’s point

    • @modelsnstuffreveiws6628
      @modelsnstuffreveiws6628 Před rokem +1

      @@phantasian1592 you. Are exactly the person he targets. The point is “don’t sell my shit, I’m not here to make you money, your auction is stupid”

    • @chadwicktouchdown
      @chadwicktouchdown Před rokem +7

      @@modelsnstuffreveiws6628 Read their comment again, their saying that banksy's art is good because it's fleeting thanks to it's medium.
      That the message he's giving is given importance because as it's street art, it is bound to be removed. Though when put on a frame and sell it, it dilutes and corrupts the message.
      It's so disheartening hearing people saying they like banksy because his point is "stop taking art so seriously", while it sure seems like Banksy takes it quite seriously!

  • @bloomee
    @bloomee Před 4 lety +3200

    Auctioneer: "1.3 million? Sold!"
    *turns over*
    Everyone: "wtf"
    Random guy in the crowd: "ILL PAY DOUBLE NOW"

    • @avaa7385
      @avaa7385 Před 4 lety +18

      It’s only half off literally

    • @MissyeruCosplay
      @MissyeruCosplay Před 2 lety +10

      This comment aged well... As it was just resold for 1600% more haha

  • @AC3handle
    @AC3handle Před 4 lety +89

    "I can't believe you morons actually buy this shit"
    goddamnit, I'm in love.

  • @caffeecup5319
    @caffeecup5319 Před 4 lety +465

    Buyer: I want your house for 4 billion dollars
    Me: Sold!
    *Detonates House*

    • @mike7546
      @mike7546 Před 3 lety +12

      Buyer: EVEN BETTTER,!!

    • @tilsgee
      @tilsgee Před 3 lety +6

      @@mike7546 hold up

  • @lorenabpv
    @lorenabpv Před 5 lety +3272

    I don't have much to say about the critique of the art world and capitalism. But i feel a bit melancholic about this because of the theme of the art itself. Girl with balloon always felt a little hopeful, the half-shredded image makes me uneasy, sorta like how destruction seems to come for whichever hopeful people and times (maybe this is just a reflection of my pessimistic view of the world, but still)

    • @oof-rr5nf
      @oof-rr5nf Před 5 lety +91

      Hey, I had not thought of it this way yet. Was too focused on the publicity stunt angle, so thanks for sharing!

    • @equesdeventusoccasus
      @equesdeventusoccasus Před 5 lety +308

      The balloon represented the hope, and he didn't shred that, just the child. It seems to be a statement about the end of innocence, but that hope remains. Another child might one day appear. (Or I might just be holding on to the hope that remains.)

    • @lorenabpv
      @lorenabpv Před 5 lety +36

      @@equesdeventusoccasus I like the way you think :)

    • @theartassignment
      @theartassignment  Před 5 lety +220

      As I was working on this one, I kept assuming I would stop to actually talk about the artwork and the meanings behind it, but then never really did. It's touched on somewhat in the various iterations of the balloon, but for some reason it felt unnecessary. Like the symbolism was self-evident. You make a good point, though, that the interpretation of the work can/should shift dramatically post-shredding.

    • @EbonyPenmarks
      @EbonyPenmarks Před 5 lety +20

      Well, the balloon isn't our only source of hope. Balloons are supposed to fly away, and we grow up.

  • @Oli.V
    @Oli.V Před 5 lety +666

    I feel like the message would have been better understood if the canvas was more truly destroyed, like burning or ruining it in a more destructive way, I feel like the shredding (and the “mistake” that it wasn’t shredded all the way) is Banksy not committing to the idea of destroying the art, he’s obviously opposed to auctions and paying two much, and I feel like making a “new” work of art is shallow and covers up the original point he was trying to make

    • @roseblack6342
      @roseblack6342 Před 5 lety +17

      maybe the original plan was to generate hype around selling this half shredded piece?

    • @DeathBringer769
      @DeathBringer769 Před 5 lety +6

      The purchaser has identified themselves. They have bought the shredded pieces and it is now believed to have increased in value, lol.

    • @JoshSweetvale
      @JoshSweetvale Před 5 lety +4

      I think if he completely destroyed it he'd get sued.

    • @the_original_Bilb_Ono
      @the_original_Bilb_Ono Před 5 lety +8

      It wouldve been cool if he planted a explosive device with shrapnel in the frame. When the gavel struck and the painting had been sold BOOM everyone is dead in the room and the painting destroyed.
      (I'm joking of course I don't want anyone to die or be injured.)
      But at least the news would be running the killer's/artist's name all day. Hey, you gotta crack a few eggs to make an omelette...

    • @jae1k279
      @jae1k279 Před 4 lety

      Intended

  • @fantanofanfiction5451
    @fantanofanfiction5451 Před 5 lety +749

    Thank you Banksy, very cool.

  • @russelldofrane6614
    @russelldofrane6614 Před 5 lety +87

    As a professional picture framer and artist, this is FUCKING GENIUS on every level! If his art went through Sotheby's without a stunt like this Banksy's art would be dead.
    So yeah. Well played Banksey.

  • @CanuckJim
    @CanuckJim Před 5 lety +352

    The how-I-did-it video is him playing with us again. At 4m42s in this video, he's supposed to be soldering a wire but he's holding the hot as hades part of of the soldering iron. In the background are the knives that should shred the canvas but they're oriented so the canvas would past the blade instead of across it. I think he's having a wee laugh - good on ya, Banksy.

    • @oof-rr5nf
      @oof-rr5nf Před 5 lety +15

      Gimme more prankster artists, universe! I am into it.

    • @tobybartlett
      @tobybartlett Před 5 lety +6

      CanuckJim Good eye there!

    • @hanniffydinn6019
      @hanniffydinn6019 Před 5 lety +20

      CanuckJim it's all fake money laundering bullshit in the End, he's on the game. Total crap. Art is long dead.

    • @lucidopticlab2373
      @lucidopticlab2373 Před 5 lety +12

      i caught the razor thing. good eye catching the soldering iron

    • @brianclarkhtc
      @brianclarkhtc Před 5 lety +1

      It's very much like when he "played" mixing boards on top of the pops as part of the KLF..

  • @rysiaandrade9213
    @rysiaandrade9213 Před 5 lety +512

    Canadians (CARFAC) are working really hard to advocate for Artist Resale Rights. Meaning that an artist will be entitled to 5% of the resale of their work. This is an issue that has disproportionately affected Northern Indigenous artists. Maybe an interesting point to put into conversation with what's happening in England and the larger auction houses.

    • @lorenabpv
      @lorenabpv Před 5 lety +18

      that's really interesting and led me to a google rabbit hole on the issue, so thanks!

    • @MCAndyT
      @MCAndyT Před 5 lety

      +

    • @proxyproxy3951
      @proxyproxy3951 Před 5 lety +16

      That would be grand seeing how ridiculous the prices get to when art is resold. Always feels a touch unfair considering most things (not all, like antiques and such) decrease in value when resold.

    • @felicityhart20
      @felicityhart20 Před 5 lety +3

      My partner works for my provinces branch of carfac...would love to see a video on the topic and the artists advocacy they do. Carfac originated our fee system, which while optional is a huge standard in galleries and really helps artists!

    • @ERIK31351
      @ERIK31351 Před 5 lety +11

      If you don't sell your work for what it's worth is it not your fault?

  • @dunderheadgood
    @dunderheadgood Před 3 lety +181

    the high art community is so evil that this work will probably be worth way more now. banksy has become the thing he hated most

    • @anewredtruck
      @anewredtruck Před 3 lety +7

      there are definitely things he could become that he hates more

    • @hikarikouno
      @hikarikouno Před 3 lety +21

      While that is true, I can't help but think they''d be having a laugh over it, somewhat.
      "I made a stunt where I spit on all y'alls faces and now that shit's worth even more? You idiots are really messed up in the head "

    • @dunderheadgood
      @dunderheadgood Před 3 lety +4

      andrew his whole concept and drive is to put art in public spaces so everyone can see it. by catering to private collectors he goes against that

    • @greenlemonboy9762
      @greenlemonboy9762 Před 3 lety +2

      Why'd he sell it to the auction if he didn't woant people to own his art. Banksy should be made to pay back whatever money he sold it to the auction for+ a little more for wasted time effort and keeping.

    • @tannerrich2388
      @tannerrich2388 Před 2 lety +2

      @@greenlemonboy9762 wut?

  • @thatguythatgam3s
    @thatguythatgam3s Před 5 lety +1562

    Great video. I've never understood why Banksy's is so popular, their style was never particularly unique but now people call all stencil graffiti Banksy-esque which is a shame to the many talented stencil artists before and after Banksy. Their art tends to be so on the nose and superficial yet it’s often treated like its "deep" or subversive. I'm not saying Banksy is totally bad but it is absurd how most people would happily paint over almost any graffiti and arrest any graffiti artist except the mythical Banksy who gets their work covered in protective plastic, and on the news. The subversive artist, whose work society loves, hardly seems that subversive at all.

    • @prettypurplebelle
      @prettypurplebelle Před 5 lety +105

      Personally I like their (btw its cool you've not assumed its a he) work, a lot is political and holds valuable criticisms of society, but you're right, so does a lot of other street art. I think its a shame the painting wasn't completely shredded/destroyed. Its so frustrating how a lot of their art is designed to be temporary, accessible by everyone or has meaning in its location, but people selfishly strip it to cash in. The attempt to thwart that is cool, but ultimately can't work, unless it literally could disappear into nothing, any destroyed art will only be worth more. It's as if the very idea of subversive art is oxymoronic. The minute someone has a platform to truely critique the system, the notoriety and increased value undermine any meaning.

    • @bree320
      @bree320 Před 5 lety +82

      unesourisverte yea I am sure that Banksy is very aware of the current position they are in. It must be hard to be loved by the very thing you hate. Their art used to be illegal, and destroyed. Now when someone gets a Bansky on their wall they are happy. I don’t know how you can combat something like that.

    • @therealbobmayo5065
      @therealbobmayo5065 Před 5 lety +1

      Epic_Hound love your pfp.

    • @MsHojat
      @MsHojat Před 5 lety +18

      Banky has some really cool stuff and I can see why it's popular, but I do think it's strange that people pay so much for simple low-skill stuff like stencil work.

    • @gayes
      @gayes Před 5 lety +9

      BANKSY IS A FUCKING POSER

  • @luisfelipebayardomelgoza4104

    4:41 Apparently Banksy doesn't know how to solder. That makes me wonder if the video is fake. (He's holding the soldering iron from the hot part, a great way to burn his fingers)

    • @leoingson
      @leoingson Před 5 lety +29

      Nicely spotted!

    • @fearlesslegend021
      @fearlesslegend021 Před 5 lety +31

      I had heard some conspiracies that Banksy is black...and i thought maybe to even further conceal his identity he got a white person to play his part in this video. But yeah you're right, if it actually IS banksy then he's an idiot and a fraud

    • @spoonnz
      @spoonnz Před 5 lety +45

      Plus 5:11 the razor blades are facing the wrong way, their sideways!

    • @SianaGearz
      @SianaGearz Před 5 lety +11

      It's definitely all a joke. I mean he would know how NOT to solder, i'm sure of that.

    • @the_original_Bilb_Ono
      @the_original_Bilb_Ono Před 5 lety +11

      @@fearlesslegend021 why would he not want people to think he's black? Lol I guarantee 100% of his fan base would not care if he's black or white or female, etc. I think your theory holds zero water.

  • @lucash8234
    @lucash8234 Před 5 lety +423

    And everybody (Sotheby's and Banksy) got paid. Mission accomplished.

    • @justinhanna9152
      @justinhanna9152 Před 5 lety +9

      It's not confirmed that banksy got paid

    • @danielaenriquez8875
      @danielaenriquez8875 Před 5 lety +29

      of course. He wouldn't want the world to know that he is making billions out of stencils, sorry "modern art"

    • @dad641
      @dad641 Před 5 lety +16

      @@danielaenriquez8875 I mean he does have a net worth of 40million dollars, but net worth/the amount of money you make doesn't disvalue you as a great artist, andy warhol, damien hirst, and jeff koons prove this point I made

    • @finalcut612
      @finalcut612 Před 5 lety +7

      @@danielaenriquez8875 You wouldn't know art if it punched you in the face.

    • @danielaenriquez8875
      @danielaenriquez8875 Před 5 lety +9

      @@finalcut612 I'll just change my statement. Personally I don't find anything interesting and revolutionary on his stencils. And somehow ridiculous how it's been marketed, but Maybe your knowledge in art is deeper than mine. So if it would punch me in the face it would do anything because it's so futile to me.

  • @JoaoPessoa86
    @JoaoPessoa86 Před 5 lety +131

    My museum co-workers and I agreed that this was the most Banksy thing to ever happen

  • @poisonpotato1
    @poisonpotato1 Před 5 lety +3718

    . ❤️
    /
    🙋‍♀️

  • @Zyrch.
    @Zyrch. Před 3 lety +69

    Anyone feel like Banksy is like one of those teen who just want to express their art (street art) then randomly put into a spotlight. Then he just did what he always does (be a rebel, dont always obey the rules, "i do what i feel i want to do" type of person, be political) but others interpreted it as something magical and artsy and he just kept on going with it.

    • @Boilingfrogg
      @Boilingfrogg Před 2 lety

      He's funded by the elites

    • @BIG2hats
      @BIG2hats Před rokem

      But that IS magical and artsy, that’s the point of him being popular.
      David Choe is a similar artist who is famous for just being him, most celebrities and popular people are, that’s why people look up to them.

  • @NavajoNinja
    @NavajoNinja Před 4 lety +64

    *True art makes you smile, not reach for your wallet.*

  • @raymond6845
    @raymond6845 Před 5 lety +270

    I used to like Banksy, but this has soured me on him to no end. I FIRMLY believe that the painting was never meant to be shredded all the way. It's part of the tragic tale that he wants to weave; "Oh, look at this piece of art that he wanted to destroy so the GREEDY art collectors couldn't have it, but it didn't work and it just HAPPENED to go up in price tenfold". He's a good storyteller, but he seems less and less genuine the more he engages with the established art community. If he just didn't engage, I think it would sit more with the message he seems to want to send

    • @forg7430
      @forg7430 Před 5 lety +10

      You can never see what the artist means by there art unless you ask them though what if the batteries died or something there are many possibilities don't limit you mind to just one

    • @DantesPurgatory
      @DantesPurgatory Před 5 lety +32

      @@forg7430 4:42 blades wouldn't cut in that orientation and you can't use a soldering iron while holding on to the heating element. this is staged af. and not very well either. people should honestly be mad about the false narrative that hiked up this art piece's price. but of course he gets a pass because it's "performance art" at this point.

    • @raymond6845
      @raymond6845 Před 5 lety +7

      I would go a step farther and say that you can never truly know what the artist means, because they already tried to express it the best way they can, which is through their art. Even if you asked, there would be two problems. The first is the barrier that is language; because words, while necessary, are also somewhat limiting in the way you can express something. The other problem is that even if I could ask him, Banksy would stick to his story of what happened, even if it was staged. It's his right to, because the story is part of that artwork now, but taking everything into account this piece feels very hypocritical and leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

    • @forg7430
      @forg7430 Před 5 lety +1

      I understand your points of view but, in my opinion I think that it wasn't staged your opinions are very well thought out unlike mine but, I gotta say I still don't believe it was staged

    • @kaingates
      @kaingates Před 5 lety

      Raymond Davis fair but then you can’t ever say you enjoy fashion. All of the major designers have the same mindset you despise banksy for having

  • @wolfumz
    @wolfumz Před 5 lety +423

    It's a little ironic he's shredding the art with one hand and taking a cheque with the other

    • @More-than-ladyboys
      @More-than-ladyboys Před 5 lety +16

      wolfumz maybe he was the anonymous buyer?

    • @picklesoupparkinson9106
      @picklesoupparkinson9106 Před 4 lety +57

      Did you guys even finish the video? Or at least reach the part where it states a few key facts, one of them being that "none of that money goes to the artists"?

    • @suilqknadrotu934
      @suilqknadrotu934 Před 4 lety +5

      picklesoup parkinson ... "with rare exeptions, ..."

    • @andrewv1671
      @andrewv1671 Před 4 lety +5

      It is ironic but it's all a political statement.
      And as we all know. Political statements sometimes are edgy, bold, subtle, or straight to the point.

    • @H4nek
      @H4nek Před 4 lety +4

      Have any proof of that?
      Officially, it was in somebody else's hands at the time of auction: "the present work is a rare unique painting that was given to the present owner by Banksy in 2006 following the artist’s warehouse show, Barely Legal, in Los Angeles".
      (www.sothebys.com/en/auctions/ecatalogue/2018/contemporary-art-evening-auction-l18024/lot.67.html)

  • @aubreyterry9453
    @aubreyterry9453 Před 3 lety +211

    Plot twist: Banks is Radio Rebel.

  • @jonnyleeg4058
    @jonnyleeg4058 Před 5 lety +58

    I have never really paid attention to Banksy's work. Even when this incident happened it didn't really move my needle. But, as usual, the way you framed this event I have a new found interest and am going to look at Banksy's work more in depth.

    • @chdreturns
      @chdreturns Před 5 lety

      Jonny leeG Please do, it's fucking amazing, and I typically hate paintings. The street art scene is amazing and I am blessed to live in a city which accepts murals.

    • @jmeckle1
      @jmeckle1 Před 5 lety +2

      Banksy's work is interesting in two specific instances:
      1. 15 years ago
      2. You're in your 20s
      Beyond that...

  • @jmelara324
    @jmelara324 Před 4 lety +9

    Remember that one scene of Into The Spider verse where reality is warped and that guy is just like “Maybe it’s a banksy?” 😂

  • @dkpqzm
    @dkpqzm Před 4 lety +9

    That's genius! Art is art, it's whatever you want it to be. Shredding it makes it so much more unique.

  • @valeriavagapova
    @valeriavagapova Před 5 lety +5

    The fact that his work was the final lot despite being the cheapest one of the event is already a solid proof Sotheby was in on it imo. And great video as always, thank you!

  • @jennaln
    @jennaln Před 5 lety +15

    Thank you for such a concise commentary on this, you have articulated my thoughts about this so much better than I ever could! While I am not a huge fan of the work Banksy creates, I can appreciate what he does with his work and I love that this event created such a huge media outpouring. It has people talking, whether they are for or against it.

  • @dangoflower751
    @dangoflower751 Před 3 lety +4

    Ah, I remember going through discussions like these a lot back in art school. Banksy's works never fail to pique my curiosity.

  • @adelined
    @adelined Před 5 lety +86

    I half expected her to say link in the dooblydoo at then end

    • @LegenDarryMe
      @LegenDarryMe Před 5 lety +2

      Hahaha SAME! I thought I was the only one!

    • @chandlerwilliams503
      @chandlerwilliams503 Před 5 lety

      This is an AVE reference right? Please tell me it is.

    • @prepperpatty199
      @prepperpatty199 Před 4 lety

      Adeline D :Don’t mean to sound dumb but Shasta is a dooblydoo? Thanks🦋.

  • @jamescoffey5903
    @jamescoffey5903 Před 5 lety +3

    I like his art. I saw this and my partner said the art was ruined, and was amazed that something so expensive could be shredded. I explained to him the work was now worth twice what had been paid for it. The act of destruction increased it's impact, and forever insured it's provenance.

  • @FlipFlopsGalore123
    @FlipFlopsGalore123 Před 5 lety +251

    This is such a great commentary on the work thank you for doing this. So many people have come to me asking for my views on this being an art student, and I haven't known where to start there's so much to say about it! And you did it in 10 minutes haha

    • @georgeluke4324
      @georgeluke4324 Před 4 lety +2

      your comment is proof that you can be an artist or an art student but still be a complete idiot about art.

    • @marchpet
      @marchpet Před 3 lety

      Creaky voice undercuts your attempt at serious art criticism. You sound more like Kim Kardashian than Kenneth Clark.

  • @restlesssheep7156
    @restlesssheep7156 Před 5 lety +49

    Couldn't wait for you all to upload something about this.

  • @kcbh24
    @kcbh24 Před 4 lety +2

    This man is beyond brilliant, for many reasons, and he will be named as one of the greatest of his generation. I don't even know the artist and he's making my toes curl.

  • @insightfool
    @insightfool Před 5 lety +715

    The "Banksy" stunt was clearly an inside Southby's job for the sake of outside noteriety. This kind of faux rejection of elitism, while simultaneously promoting the elitism, is such a tiresome routine. I can't help but wonder how much the art market in the US/UK is more about creating narcisists and sociopaths than it is about creating art?

    • @Matthew-lm3zl
      @Matthew-lm3zl Před 5 lety +26

      Blah blah blah

    • @robijon1991
      @robijon1991 Před 5 lety +2

      @@Matthew-lm3zl vZaza

    • @MrsRen
      @MrsRen Před 5 lety +12

      It's more about keeping money in assets than anything

    • @kagitsune
      @kagitsune Před 5 lety

      Yeowch.

    • @wednesdayfuentes35
      @wednesdayfuentes35 Před 5 lety +15

      So what? Banksy creates pieces that really effect people. I dont really care why he does it

  • @ojiverdeconfleco
    @ojiverdeconfleco Před 5 lety +3

    Oh how I love meta work. My relationship with Banksy's art is bittersweet, as it lends itself to be, but at least it is a relationship. Makes me wonder why some other works don't engage me as much (maybe they lack the community that shares it and discusses it? Maybe they aren't as flashy and/or taking advantage of social media to the right degree?).
    Thank you again for making these videos 💕

  • @noimdirtydan08stark80
    @noimdirtydan08stark80 Před 4 lety +26

    I just realized his art is on my school walls

  • @saintofcourtiers
    @saintofcourtiers Před 5 lety +1

    i live in Bristol, and it's really very surreal to walk into town and see Banksy's work everywhere. it's somewhat wonderful.. but always leaves you unsettled.

  • @KannikCat
    @KannikCat Před 5 lety

    Thank you for exploring and all the vertical-video sleuthing! Very much seems to have been a semi-elaborate performance art piece, and judging by all of our watching, actions, and reactions, he's managed to make many of us a part of the piece itself. :)

  • @brodersami
    @brodersami Před 5 lety +561

    Banksy makes kitsch with surface-level observations. It works well on the streets as simple commentary, but it has for some reason been elevated to this level of conceptual high-art that it simply just isn't. The only thing subversive about this new artwork is exposing how many gullible people actually believed that the shredding was somehow subversive, and that even the public isn't immune to reading way too much into, and putting way too much value in this (now literal) garbage.
    I know the art world is dumb. I don't need an artwork to bluntly point that out when I can see it in the thousands of truly talented artists who struggle to sell a single painting while tripe like this sells for millions.

    • @oof-rr5nf
      @oof-rr5nf Před 5 lety +41

      But what did you think of the point she made that this is perhaps a move for artists to reclaim power over their work by bringing in greater and more consistently interested attention to how mad the art market world is?

    • @brodersami
      @brodersami Před 5 lety +40

      ​@@oof-rr5nf It sort of works as a form of activism, but ultimately the stunt will be judged as an artwork in itself and at that point it's only been stolen from him again. He knew that was inevitable, and yet he played right into their hands. I just don't see the point of this overt finger pointing, as I really do not give two shits about the art market and I doubt most people do. Thinking about it just seems like an intellectual dead end.

    • @cubeofcheese5574
      @cubeofcheese5574 Před 5 lety +8

      brodersami Well isn't people's lack of interest a great reason to make art that highlights it for the general public?

    • @burymeinmsg
      @burymeinmsg Před 5 lety +2

      Can't agree more.

    • @VashdaCrash
      @VashdaCrash Před 5 lety +15

      @@brodersami I think Bansky could've made a better point by completely destroying the artpiece and/or making a more straight statement, like directly demanding intellectual property protection for the artists.
      So, I agree with ya.

  • @GianniStella
    @GianniStella Před 5 lety +9

    to me this translates into: this youtube video is a part of Banksy's Art

  • @oliverryan2451
    @oliverryan2451 Před 5 lety +1

    Wow you opened my eyes to the beautiful and complex world of art still ament going to bye a blank canvas that some "artist put work into"

  • @0BS9RVER
    @0BS9RVER Před 5 lety

    4:00 love the way he thinks outside the golden frame!

  • @acidsteve9837
    @acidsteve9837 Před 5 lety +4

    When you destroy something and it makes it even more valuable. Art.

  • @kaylaempson5788
    @kaylaempson5788 Před 5 lety +3

    Yay! More art assignment! 😃

  • @chocolateoak
    @chocolateoak Před 5 lety +1

    Brilliant video, thank you Sarah for broadening my understanding of this artwork and the context leading up to it. Great analysis!

  • @Mehrnooshb
    @Mehrnooshb Před 5 lety +1

    I’d been waiting for you to make a video about this! It has definitely made me think more critically about the whole thing...

  • @Matty002
    @Matty002 Před 5 lety +329

    ive never seen that gold frame stick fugure banksy piece. holy shit he really is an edgy 14 year old

    • @forg7430
      @forg7430 Před 5 lety +11

      If he was I'm pretty sure he wouldn't be smart enough to put a handmade shredder in the canvas

    • @Matty002
      @Matty002 Před 5 lety +27

      @@forg7430 woosh

    • @nocop5382
      @nocop5382 Před 5 lety +30

      @@Matty002 i dont see ant irony in your comment

    • @hektur6770
      @hektur6770 Před 5 lety +4

      @@nocop5382 r/Whooosh

    • @wowverynice6732
      @wowverynice6732 Před 3 lety +9

      @@hektur6770 No

  • @davidschmidt5507
    @davidschmidt5507 Před 5 lety +81

    1. I can’t belive Ai Weiwei’s destruction of the Vase wasn’t mentioned
    2. How do we know Banksy is a Him? Has that been confirmed?

    • @AverySuzuki
      @AverySuzuki Před 5 lety +39

      People who know him personally refer to him as him and videos with his face obscured show a male build and he hasn't done a great job distorting his voice in a lot of cases. Wikipedia mentions a article where the author describes him as a cross between Jimmy Nail and Mike Skinner.

    • @denissetiawan3645
      @denissetiawan3645 Před 5 lety +1

      yeah ai weiwei, i forgot about that too. :)

    • @ElenaGlitch
      @ElenaGlitch Před 5 lety +5

      The difference between Ai Weiwei’s vase piece and the works in the video was that he didn’t destroy his own work but rather another artist’s work (albeit work the original artist was too long-dead to personally care about). The artists mentioned in the video all destroyed their own work, or added to them through acts generally considered destructive. There’s a different cultural attitude surrounding personal work that an artist destroys themselves versus the destruction of work outside the destroyer.

    • @brianclarkhtc
      @brianclarkhtc Před 5 lety

      He used to drive a Ford time lord..

    • @ilean7499
      @ilean7499 Před 5 lety

      @@ElenaGlitch not true the Robert Rauschenberg piece was an erased De Kooning

  • @mikekazz5353
    @mikekazz5353 Před 4 lety +2

    Good job banksy you just made it more valuable, because it went from visual art to performance art that can be hung up on a wall.

  • @urface151
    @urface151 Před 5 lety +5

    Shredding strips might make an interesting art project.... I love how this channel always inspires me

    • @theartassignment
      @theartassignment  Před 5 lety +2

      Do we have an assignment for you. Make it Break it, from a few years back: czcams.com/video/8lxXv4ZxcoQ/video.html

    • @MCAndyT
      @MCAndyT Před 5 lety

      @@theartassignment +

  • @mandragora1769
    @mandragora1769 Před 3 lety +7

    Take a look how he’s holding the soldering iron at 4:41? He would burn his fingers!

  • @justanotherhappyhumanist8832

    I love Banksy, but if he'd really wanted to destroy it, he would have shredded it into confetti, not strips.

  • @mykameakulpa
    @mykameakulpa Před 5 lety

    Every element - the institutional critique, the auction itself, the framing, the media’s response, contributed to a live art piece. Bravura

  • @zentouro
    @zentouro Před 5 lety +1

    ugh this is so freakin good.

  • @richardbond258
    @richardbond258 Před 5 lety +82

    I have never been a fan of Banksy or his artwork. I strongly consider him a part of the mainstream art scene that many artists such as myself is fighting against. And this art piece verifies my suspension that everything is an act and not genuine. Banksy clearly increased the value of the piece when he shredded it. He had to know that was going to happen. Now the owner of the worked can say that they have been Banksied. A story to increase its value even more.

    • @amluninuim
      @amluninuim Před 5 lety +5

      What's bad about the mainstream art scene ?

    • @richardbond258
      @richardbond258 Před 5 lety +14

      @@amluninuim it is the Establishment of the Art world and usually pushes artists that don't fit their criteria to the side. The Visual Art community is different than music, and film. To be mainstream doesn't necessarily mean that the art is popular among regular everyday people. Sure some artist gets known that way. The mainstream art scene is set by museums, collectors, art critics, art organizations, art schools, and art Historians. They often set standards that create restrictions on other hard working artists.

    • @amluninuim
      @amluninuim Před 5 lety +2

      Oh yeah, I never knew of how different "mainstream" was for visual art. But you're right, we should fight against what commodifies art. Thanks for making me learn something.

    • @Faby07aleixo
      @Faby07aleixo Před 5 lety +2

      It's a clever marketing stunt. Banksy is nothing but that, a clever marketer.

    • @poisonpotato1
      @poisonpotato1 Před 5 lety

      Suspicion*

  • @lilpepe5515
    @lilpepe5515 Před 4 lety +5

    I’m not much into art but this is interesting as hell and funny

  • @creathechiboi
    @creathechiboi Před 4 lety +2

    Now that is something I wanna do with my art.

  • @Sisu282
    @Sisu282 Před 5 lety +1

    my first thought when I heard about the Banksy stunt was Duchamp's Large Glass at the Philadelphia Museum of Art and how, after it shattered in transit he supposedly said that it was "finally complete"

  • @ClasHDyno
    @ClasHDyno Před 5 lety +6

    Such an amazing concept, and commentary on the world of art. That price probably quadrupled in value by being partly shredded.

  • @MainsMain
    @MainsMain Před 4 lety +16

    2:19 Why? WHY? WHY DID I NEED TO KNOW THIS? WHY DOES IT MATTER?

  • @alexandremarcil498
    @alexandremarcil498 Před 5 lety +2

    Maybe the whole point of this piece is that love is not in the bin after all. The heart does not get shredded, as it was maybe really intended. There is always hope!

  • @safaa9654
    @safaa9654 Před 3 lety +2

    he's such a genius. Love him

  • @miruzanka
    @miruzanka Před 3 lety +28

    Am i the only one who noticed that the auctioneer presses a button under the rostrum and starts the mechanism? 0:09

  • @JOSEPHCHARLESCOLIN2024
    @JOSEPHCHARLESCOLIN2024 Před 5 lety +3

    I did my Own type of Banksy Shred FacePainting .A week After his famous Painting & mine will NOT be Shredded.

  • @MahlenMorris
    @MahlenMorris Před 5 lety

    A couple months ago I was at a Banksy (and others) exhibition at the Moco in Amsterdam. In person, in a gallery, I found the work much less interesting than when photographed in the street. He's always someone I want to like, but I feel like the work's a bit thin, usually. But it was a popular show. And I did exit through the gift shop :)

  • @ChinmayaNagpal
    @ChinmayaNagpal Před 5 lety +1

    this was so well written

  • @AnaFariaable
    @AnaFariaable Před 5 lety +17

    I was so curious about this! Thank you!

  • @Fenrirmcwolf007
    @Fenrirmcwolf007 Před 4 lety +3

    Ironically that is true art, to have a piece of art destroy it's self is symbolic directed to consumers who take things for granted

  • @--Paws--
    @--Paws-- Před 5 lety +1

    I'm amazed he has an Instagram with how he seems to be portraying himself or his art.

  • @KCsFunHouse
    @KCsFunHouse Před 5 lety +1

    I absolutely love this shenanigan! I would love to come across a Banksy Bill they’re stunning!

  • @AmazingAirshowVideos
    @AmazingAirshowVideos Před 5 lety +6

    Banksy put the piece up for auction and bought it back. Let that marinate.

    • @mdude625
      @mdude625 Před 4 lety

      Since the buyer's identity isn't known, that is possible.

  • @nunyabiznez6381
    @nunyabiznez6381 Před 4 lety +7

    Banksy is a genius. He is not an artistic genius although he is quite good. He is a genius at satire. He has chosen art as a way of expressing his satire much the same way as Warhol did but in a much less commercial way. Warhol ultimately did it for the money. Banksy does it to express his opinion and apparently cares little for money. I believe he was both the buyer and seller of this piece and the stunt was an expression of his satirical message.

  • @cyrilio
    @cyrilio Před 5 lety

    Great to get some more info about the context in which this event unfolded.

  • @daveharris2884
    @daveharris2884 Před 5 lety

    This video was the most thorough I have ever seen regarding art. Thank you.

  • @amanatee27
    @amanatee27 Před 5 lety +10

    Really interesting video! Thank you for how carefully the scripts are written and delivered. Also thank you for the heads up about Two Cents - hadn't heard of it, but it sounds neat!

  • @DisasterMaggot
    @DisasterMaggot Před 2 lety +4

    It would be interesting to see if Banksy's work holds up in 200 years.

  • @erinmarie840
    @erinmarie840 Před 5 lety

    This is excellent, Sarah! Great job.

  • @monkeseeaction21987
    @monkeseeaction21987 Před 3 lety

    I like how after the art was half shredded the two gentlemen with gloves took it down immediately with a great sense of emergency, as it that's going to make any difference whatsoever.

  • @zongivila
    @zongivila Před 5 lety +4

    When you watch a youtube tutorial and that's all you can draw XD

  • @Xenolilly
    @Xenolilly Před 5 lety +9

    I wanted to more about Banksy and now I do!

  • @WhiteBloggerBlackSpecs
    @WhiteBloggerBlackSpecs Před 8 měsíci

    Genius way to give the finger to art institutions while making Banksy a household name

  • @GetToKnowNature
    @GetToKnowNature Před 5 lety

    Thank you so much for explaining the Banksy event. I definitely understand it much better now.

  • @bidaubadeadieu
    @bidaubadeadieu Před 5 lety +8

    Wow, feels like this is a "Case For" video in disguise. I find Banksy's aesthetic pretty insufferable, but you really got me thinking. Way to go!

    • @oof-rr5nf
      @oof-rr5nf Před 5 lety +1

      Why so? Too simple?

    • @theartassignment
      @theartassignment  Před 5 lety +5

      Yeah, we have been considering a Case for Banksy for a while, and I decided to do this instead. Also, I don't think the world needs a Case for Banksy. Do they?

    • @MCAndyT
      @MCAndyT Před 5 lety

      @@theartassignment LOL!

  • @lukemcellin8736
    @lukemcellin8736 Před 4 lety +35

    2:19 i can see why he shreded it

  • @NiamhCreates
    @NiamhCreates Před 5 lety

    I thought this stunt from Banksy was absolutely GENIUS and definitely a work of art in and of itself.

  • @unoaotroa
    @unoaotroa Před 4 lety +1

    Banksy is now a video performance artist as well. See the 'performative soldering' at 4:42: he is grabbing the soldering iron by the heating element which when connected to electricity is more than able to cause third degree burns. So the video is more like a performance than a real demonstration of how the frame was made.

  • @philippj5711
    @philippj5711 Před 5 lety +6

    Misattributing the "urge to destroy" quote to Picasso kinda ruined Banksy's street cred for me. The guy hasn't studied Bakunin? Wimp.

  • @adelined
    @adelined Před 5 lety +12

    As soon as a heard about this, I wanted to know what your response was. Thanks!

  • @kujmous
    @kujmous Před 5 lety +1

    Thank you for such a smart review. Loved it.

  • @jannisopel
    @jannisopel Před 5 lety

    At some of his works I spontaneously burst into laughter. What is this wizardry. How do you control me in that way Banksy?

  • @Jfieldsend94
    @Jfieldsend94 Před 5 lety +4

    I will never understand why people love banksys artwork so much.

    • @Altered-Stigma
      @Altered-Stigma Před 4 lety +1

      Jfieldsend94 exactly my thought. Nothin that hasn’t been seen before.

  • @wildcrackers4915
    @wildcrackers4915 Před 5 lety +13

    I know it is unrelated but I have an assignment at school about Henri Matisse and I cannot find any good content about him.If you could pleaze make any sort of video about him I would be eternally thankful.(though i do understand that you propably dont take requests)I love your content!!! It is amazing!!💚💚💚🎨

    • @oof-rr5nf
      @oof-rr5nf Před 5 lety +1

      Matisse! What a cool fucking dude. I don't understand how I feel about him at all, lol. At some of his work, I go "eh", at others "why was he popular again", and at yet others "I love it but don't get why I love it but let me enthusiastically reblog it on Tumblr". His art style is . . . brave? to me. Idk why.

    • @PSYMotive
      @PSYMotive Před 5 lety +6

      There's a lot of good content about Matisse and access to a library can help you find it. The online medium can also be helpful (sites like theartstory.org), but really the limit is only the theme or subject that you want to pursue in your assignment. Regarding books, here are a few recommendations:
      Art in Theory 1900-2000
      A Dictionary of Twentieth Century Art, Ian Chilvers
      Matisse on Art, Henri Matisse
      Orientalist Aesthetics: Art, Colonialism, and French North Africa, Roger Benjamin
      Taschen also has a few books on Matisse.
      Good luck!

    • @oof-rr5nf
      @oof-rr5nf Před 5 lety

      @@PSYMotive thank you. I am not actually an art student, but I have screenshoted your comment just in case researching Matisse ever strikes my fancy. Thanks again!

    • @wildcrackers4915
      @wildcrackers4915 Před 5 lety

      PSYMotive thank you very much for your recomendations !!!

  • @jamesmanders9441
    @jamesmanders9441 Před 5 lety

    i loved the exhibition at the bristol museum i fondly remember the paint pot angel

  • @adlozi
    @adlozi Před rokem +1

    The fact that the balloon heart wasn't shredded reminds me a phenomenon about the dog and the finger. If you point the starts, the dog won't look at the starts, he will look at your finger. The shredded girl was the finger. Banksy forces you to see the starts instead of looking at the finger. That's my translation.

  • @JP-dh1xv
    @JP-dh1xv Před 5 lety +125

    I find his stunt a bland marketing ploy. He is such a self aware sellout.

    • @TheIridescentFisherMan
      @TheIridescentFisherMan Před 5 lety +5

      Been self aware for like 20+ years. How old are you?

    • @KOSMIKFEADRECORDS
      @KOSMIKFEADRECORDS Před 5 lety +5

      The how-I-did-it video is him playing with us again. At 4m42s in this video, he's supposed to be soldering a wire but he's holding the hot as hades part of of the soldering iron. In the background are the knives that should shred the canvas but they're oriented so the canvas would past the blade instead of across it.

    • @starmars2923
      @starmars2923 Před 5 lety

      Joshua Rin are you 12?? They said he was self aware about being a sellout, not just self aware.

    • @TheIridescentFisherMan
      @TheIridescentFisherMan Před 5 lety +6

      @@starmars2923 No actually the exact point I made is Bansky has been doing this a long time. And people didnt always pay attention to him 20 years ago. Like they do now. So I highlighted thefact that hes been doing this a long time...and hasnt been getting paid. Lol

    • @starmars2923
      @starmars2923 Před 5 lety +1

      Joshua Rin you must be stupid, do you know how much money he made from selling his art piece because it’s ‘so unique’ or whatever just because he shredded it a bit?? Probably more than you’ll ever have in your life time. That’s like extreme sellout.

  • @darksepheroth4627
    @darksepheroth4627 Před 5 lety +27

    There's no way that sothebys wasnt in on it.

  • @thegibsonserver
    @thegibsonserver Před 4 lety +1

    You have a very calm and pleasing tone when describing this. Super informative.

  • @myoung48281
    @myoung48281 Před 5 lety +1

    After seeing the image of the guy cracking the whip, comprised of a stock market upsurge symbol, the arrow tipped rising line, the concept of thesis, anti-thesis and synthesis comes to mind as something underpinning his art.