Is Black Lives Matter Right? - [Bonus Episode]

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 19. 07. 2020
  • If you like what I do consider supporting me at colemanhughes.org/
    If you like what you hear, please subscribe and share bit.ly/CwCsubscribe
    Solo episodes in their entirety are usually available to subscribers only. Due to the importance of the subject matter, I have decided to make this episode available to everyone.
    In this episode, I discuss my views on race and police. A subject that has been on the lips of many since the death of George Floyd by the hands of police officers. I will read an essay I wrote for City Journal called 'Stories and Data', while also providing some additional thoughts.
    Follow Coleman
    CZcams - bit.ly/38kzium
    Twitter - bit.ly/2rbAJue
    Facebook - bit.ly/2LiAXH3
    Website -colemanhughes.org
    #BlackLivesMatter #Police #Politics

Komentáře • 1,2K

  • @MarkHeng3000
    @MarkHeng3000 Před 3 lety +1065

    Just curious- How many of you have hesitated to share a video like this on social media for fear of a backlash? I know I have. Coleman, your bravery is inspiring.

    • @johnbradley2359
      @johnbradley2359 Před 3 lety +81

      I find myself engaging in self-censorship constantly. Every once in a while, I get sick of it and post something, but the fact that this has become part of the process says it all.

    • @timagee147
      @timagee147 Před 3 lety +48

      The social cost is way too high to share something like this.

    • @MeshFrequency
      @MeshFrequency Před 3 lety +15

      @@timagee147 Bring out your inner honey badger!

    • @chrishaughton_1963
      @chrishaughton_1963 Před 3 lety +52

      Hesitated. Then shared. Come on let’s say and promote what we think ....

    • @bongwaterly
      @bongwaterly Před 3 lety +44

      I got the backlash for sharing a tweet from an African American immigrant woman saying that America wasn’t as bad as the media portrays. The people on “right side” of history don’t want to hear anything contrary to their narrative and if you stray from that narrative you’re a racist. I constantly hear Obi Wan in my head - “Only a sith deals in absolute.”

  • @changingminds1422
    @changingminds1422 Před 3 lety +826

    While doing stand up in Chicago I ad libbed a dumb joke about how “BLM” kinda sounds like a sandwich, the 2 black guys in the room burst out laughing while the white people scowled at me. Ever since then I’ve suspected there’s a massive disconnect between what us “white liberals” think is offensive to black people and what is ACTUALLY offensive to black people lol.

    • @cosmick57
      @cosmick57 Před 3 lety +64

      Absolutely! SJWs are totally humorless! 😉 Good one!

    • @TommyLikeTom
      @TommyLikeTom Před 3 lety +5

      Your stand up must suck

    • @alexlopez4
      @alexlopez4 Před 3 lety +35

      That’s pretty funny to be fair 😂

    • @megroekle
      @megroekle Před 3 lety +16

      Humorless! Plus the hubris. And assumptiveness. Blech.

    • @shawnkay5462
      @shawnkay5462 Před 3 lety +56

      Thats the problem with White Liberals, they want to be offended for other people even if those people are not offended.

  • @pierre-lucleboeuf4979
    @pierre-lucleboeuf4979 Před 3 lety +238

    The fact that I was afraid to like this video is a problem.

    • @kirgizikable
      @kirgizikable Před 3 lety +2

      well said

    • @pebblepod30
      @pebblepod30 Před 3 lety +10

      Haha ikr? I was also taught from a teen onwards attitudes i now recognise as racial guilt/white guilt. And it is actually applying racist principles.

    • @pebblepod30
      @pebblepod30 Před 3 lety

      @Owen Marble
      Congratulations Owen 😁🙏
      The other side of the race industry is teaching and encouraging racial resentment from other groups, esp black. And not based on things ppl actually experienced.

    • @blsdthnkfl8896
      @blsdthnkfl8896 Před 3 lety +3

      Owen Marble Hi Owen👋🏾 That’s so sad, but I’m glad you were able to come out of that 👏🏾
      Here’s a couple of videos that might interest you (if you have time)😊
      ☝🏾 Brandon Tatum (former cop, major voice among young black conservatives)👉🏾m.czcams.com/video/eadYJLZi30Q/video.html
      ☝🏾Bevelyn Beatty. Better known for speaking the truth down in CHAZ/CHOP👉🏾 m.czcams.com/video/3q_oKLts10I/video.html
      However, this is my FAVORITE video... All I can say is get your popcorn 🍿🎬 m.czcams.com/video/ow47PLQN0LA/video.html
      As for me, my highest sense of identity is found in Christ (not the color of my skin).
      With all that’s going on in this world, I believe God (the creator of all things) is coming back soon. The God of the Bible says that you are fearfully and wonderfully made (Psalm 139) in His image (you are no accident). Unlike the post modern world view that we see being pushed in which there is no truth, God sent his son Jesus Christ into this world to declare that He is the way, the truth and the life. And Jesus was the perfect truth and perfect standard. All others fall short of this standard (Romans 3:23) which takes us out of relationship with God the father. While all other religions say do (as in trying to meet a standard of perfection by good works or religious piety which no one can do) Christianity says its done (Christ has met that standard therefore we should accept him as mediator between us and God). And whoever believes in him (Christ John 3:16) has ever lasting life.
      God bless ❤️✝️🇺🇸
      #EternalLivesMatter
      #JesusMatters

    • @debblouin
      @debblouin Před 3 lety

      It is

  • @ClarkPotter
    @ClarkPotter Před 3 lety +841

    Let's get Coleman on JRE.

    • @grindcreative
      @grindcreative Před 3 lety +4

      Si muy.

    • @MrGOTAMA420
      @MrGOTAMA420 Před 3 lety +10

      go to his website theyre probably sick of hearing from me.

    • @MrGOTAMA420
      @MrGOTAMA420 Před 3 lety

      @@jedlee2194 thanks!

    • @MrGOTAMA420
      @MrGOTAMA420 Před 3 lety

      @@jedlee2194 lol

    • @michelem7786
      @michelem7786 Před 3 lety +11

      Or maybe... Let's see if Coleman can out pace JRE. I'd rather have Coleman be the host.

  • @becauseicount3483
    @becauseicount3483 Před 3 lety +69

    The hardest part of the story about Tony Timpa is that he called 911 to ask for help because he was scared

    • @EllieDyk
      @EllieDyk Před 3 lety +12

      Because I Count yes 😢 he was a schizophrenic who knew he was in an episode and was terrified. He called the police to help him because he was so very scared and turned to them trustingly for rescue. That’s why the mocking taunting sadism at his suffering haunts me. 💔 One piece of any police reform needs to include some partner accountability for what is said to detainees.

    • @becauseicount3483
      @becauseicount3483 Před 3 lety +2

      Ellie Dyk yes & he informed the dispatcher of his condition & that he’d not taken his medication. But equally sad was Daniel Shaver because if you listen to what’s said it’s really confusing & if anything difficult to do as ordered

    • @brianjoyce9742
      @brianjoyce9742 Před 3 lety

      I would say the hardest part is, he died at the hands of other people, unnecessarily and that no one cared. GF put people in the streets, TT put people on the couch. Somewhere in the middle is the reaction required. Burning, rioting and senseless violence should not be the end results.

    • @notsogreen
      @notsogreen Před 3 lety +4

      One of the most dreaded events that police and EMTS have to face are those involving people experiencing psychotic episodes. The ones in psychosis often have uncanny increases in their levels of energy, strength, and in some, their pain thresholds. First responders often try to relieve their own distress and soaring heart rates, by joking with each other or seem like they are making light of the situation; when actually they are trying to keep themselves from the emotional trauma of the event. Watching someone experiencing a psychotic breakdown is really painful.

    • @becauseicount3483
      @becauseicount3483 Před 3 lety

      Marie ELSTER thank you for that information

  • @voidandnon-2530
    @voidandnon-2530 Před 3 lety +84

    Coleman is quickly becoming one of my heroes.

  • @dustinkdye
    @dustinkdye Před 3 lety +75

    Is it just me, or does it seem Coleman is taking on the same rhythm and mode of speaking as Sam Harris? Not that it's a problem. I love both.

    • @yazshaz5720
      @yazshaz5720 Před 3 lety +2

      Yep, I noticed that pretty immediately too! Sam should definitely have him on the show

    • @lesleytaylor3825
      @lesleytaylor3825 Před 3 lety +3

      Dustin Dye Yes, it’s very obvious. Even Coleman using the word ‘linger’ made me think of Harris. I love them both, too!

    • @snorgonofborkkad
      @snorgonofborkkad Před 3 lety +4

      You're way late to the party. People have been noticing that for years.

    • @myaccount5204
      @myaccount5204 Před 3 lety +8

      That's the sound of somebody thinking while they speak, instead of just reacting to emotions

    • @Pengalen
      @Pengalen Před 3 lety +5

      Sam Harris has accidentally reincarnated prior to death.

  • @billdont2458
    @billdont2458 Před 3 lety +7

    Outstanding young man. This is how we ACTUALLY begin to have conversations and deal with things. This is how productive adults get things done. Not bullying or name calling. I absolutely enjoyed this. Bravo.

  • @MrBfg586
    @MrBfg586 Před 3 lety +17

    In that Tony Timpa case, the family tried to sue the police department and the judge threw it out. So sad for that family.

  • @TheWilding123
    @TheWilding123 Před 3 lety +11

    Wow! Not only was that rational, it ended on such a hopeful note. Thank you sir! Keep talking, I’m listening!

  • @cosmick57
    @cosmick57 Před 3 lety +8

    Always appreciate your thoughtful, intelligent take on issues. Thank you.

  • @rodblues6832
    @rodblues6832 Před 3 lety +1

    I've never really been big into podcasts, but yours is one I never miss. Your show isn't just great, it's NECESSARY. Keep it up!

  • @richtricky6832
    @richtricky6832 Před 3 lety +23

    This has to be the fairest discussion with critical thought I have ever heard about this subject.

  • @sverreaarnes9164
    @sverreaarnes9164 Před 3 lety +9

    Im very glad that an reflective and very smart person is willing to use his voice to discuss sensetive and important topics like these. Thanks!

  • @nikkiarana
    @nikkiarana Před 3 lety +2

    Such a great listen, so worth the time and thanks so much for your thoughtful perspective.

  • @stampede4107
    @stampede4107 Před 3 lety +11

    One more thing to be remembered when bringing up this or similar topics with friends or family is that you still love them, whether or not you guys agree. If you can remember that it will help you to remember when to let the conversation die down before becoming a conflagration.
    And if talking with a stranger, or someone other than friends or family, ultimately you want to be able to live together in peace, even if you are never really friends.
    Truth + Love & Peace.

  • @joey_bingham
    @joey_bingham Před 3 lety +4

    With me being 23 and Coleman 24, I find myself ever more intrigued and interested in his thoughts on modern issues. This one year difference allows me to relate to his takes more then someone 2.5 times my age (not to obviously discount someone’s validity on issues just cause age). Keep up the thoughtful work Coleman!

  • @416sessions
    @416sessions Před 3 lety +3

    Excellent analysis, well balanced essay. I like the pace your reading, slight pause in all the right places.

  • @BradfordHills
    @BradfordHills Před 3 lety +1

    Truly outstanding presentation. So often human communication hinges on not just substance, but form. Coleman's pacing and measured tonality are of tremendous benefit when dealing with this important but difficult subject.

  • @craigwatkins7011
    @craigwatkins7011 Před 3 lety +2

    Your approach to issues is wise and refreshingly calm, fair and reasonable.

  • @yurekandsnakes
    @yurekandsnakes Před 3 lety +3

    I’ve been listening to so many people on these issues, and Coleman is one of the best.

  • @justinasvd
    @justinasvd Před 3 lety +3

    OMG, I simply love you, man! Please continue doing good work in these times of insanity.

  • @andrewlim9345
    @andrewlim9345 Před 3 lety +2

    Thanks, will share this with my friends and family.

  • @pjdcntv
    @pjdcntv Před 3 lety +3

    Thank you for discussing this very difficult topic. I commend you and great job, your reasoning is sound in my estimation and is a voice I feel sorely lacking in this conversation.

  • @KSRobinette
    @KSRobinette Před 3 lety +3

    Coleman, your clear, evidence based, balanced thinking is like a breath of fresh air. Thank you so much for being you and doing what you do.

  • @ec78548
    @ec78548 Před 3 lety +5

    this is fantastic. Coleman is my new favorite "most thoughtful" commentator

  • @logosproclamation453
    @logosproclamation453 Před 3 lety +1

    Coleman, your work is outstanding. Thank you for your work and providing resources!

  • @annettacatchingsformercand7433

    Loved the content of this podcast. Just enough real food for thought in a time that is so inflamed by differences in our personal experiences and perception. Thanks for urging all to be tolerant and raise the level of discussion and discourse.

  • @TheEtienne14
    @TheEtienne14 Před 3 lety +3

    You are such a great voice in our world Coleman! Love from Canada.

  • @lexparsimoniae2107
    @lexparsimoniae2107 Před 3 lety +3

    What a well reasoned piece! Thank you.

  • @misslydialove
    @misslydialove Před 3 lety

    You are a breath of fresh air! Such a compassionate and calm voice of reason in today's age of inflammatory commentators and influencers.
    Where can I find more people like Coleman!?

  • @lstromness
    @lstromness Před 3 lety +2

    It is nice to hear a calm coherent explanation from a person following the data where it leads and willing to change his mind with new information.

  • @mkm1206
    @mkm1206 Před 3 lety +4

    Just discovered this podcast wow I am So impressed !

  • @tuxmusicman
    @tuxmusicman Před 3 lety +13

    Almost every time I listen to him, he changes my mind on something.

  • @CheekClappersPodcast
    @CheekClappersPodcast Před 3 lety +2

    Such an amazing essay. So amazing to hear someone that actually takes time to be thoughtful about this stuff and doesn't appear to have any agenda except basic decency and truth.

  • @emilysimmons3529
    @emilysimmons3529 Před 3 lety +2

    Love this guy! Thank you so much for being thoughtful, intelligent, and meticulous in an age where most people want to sling soundbites and profanities at each other.

  • @terranbishop5549
    @terranbishop5549 Před 3 lety +3

    Coleman is one of the most brilliant, young minds out there. Keep speaking up!

  • @jdawg119
    @jdawg119 Před 3 lety +15

    This was so good I wasn’t even mad about all the ads

    • @Richusbabe
      @Richusbabe Před 3 lety +1

      There's a ton! Apparently, there's no other way to hear controversial opinions.
      But I'm sticking with it.
      The funny thing is, the ads are there because these videos are hugely popular. People want to listen to thoughtful ppl like Coleman, even if they don't admit it and are unable to discuss the nuances in society :(

    • @TrumpFanNetwork2
      @TrumpFanNetwork2 Před 3 lety +1

      You can get Google Chrome, with a no popup blocker, and never get an ad on CZcams again.

  • @Emblanefilms
    @Emblanefilms Před 3 lety +2

    Damn you are smart man. The sophisticated and impartial way your words flow are both captivating and mesmerizing.

  • @anthonythompson1677
    @anthonythompson1677 Před 3 lety +2

    Coleman, bravo on the work you’re doing. Actually just wanted to give some positive feedback on your intro music here. Excellent choice!

  • @WifeOfTheBeast
    @WifeOfTheBeast Před 3 lety +4

    Sincerely brilliant, Coleman.

  • @DGot14U
    @DGot14U Před 3 lety +35

    Hey Coleman. You need to go on The Breakfast Club. Exactly because this is the audience that needs to hear what you have to say.

    • @mikew2610
      @mikew2610 Před 3 lety

      This is what the audience needs to hear? Sorry to break it to you but you don't understand the game being played. Coleman's job is to say things to white people about blacks that they can't. He isn't the only one.

    • @DGot14U
      @DGot14U Před 3 lety +15

      @@mikew2610 How can I not understand. I am black. I believe many of these things. And I know I want to uplift our people, not knock them down. I believe Coleman and the others want this too. And I've heard real debate from these black individuals on what the best way is to do that. But that whites are the ones listening to them isn't an indication that they aren't speaking any truth or that they are speaking at the behest of some white masters. I understand the association problem. But I'm an engineer. It is not in me to ignore well thought out and presented arguments with evidence that counters my own views.

    • @mikew2610
      @mikew2610 Před 3 lety +2

      @@DGot14U I'm black too and we can agree to disagree. All he says is typical right-wing conservative talking points. Since you are an engineer and like to hear a good argument. When was the last time you heard him or others in his position talk about whites as they do blacks? I'm just asking, where is the objectivity and does he say uplifting. Seriously, I'm curious on what I am missing.

    • @DGot14U
      @DGot14U Před 3 lety +1

      @ZoSo221 Even Rush Limbaugh of all people has been on the breakfast club. Why? Because their urban reach is undeniable. It's not about them, it's about their audience. All Coleman is doing here is preaching to the choir. And he isn't saying anything that people like Thomas Sowell haven't already said. Yet Sowell is now 90 and most black people never heard of him.

    • @jaydoe5654
      @jaydoe5654 Před 3 lety

      TBC would never have him on. They are OWNED by revolt TV.

  • @nocomment5214
    @nocomment5214 Před 3 lety +1

    Amazing! Keep up the good work Coleman.

  • @coolmofo123
    @coolmofo123 Před 3 lety

    Quoting Hitch at the end and then dropping the mic!!! Nice work Coleman!

  • @simongregory3114
    @simongregory3114 Před 3 lety +3

    Thank you for this. I'm going to post this on FB, with a little quote, (if I can pluck up the courage), with this message:
    "Coleman Hughes, a 23 y/o black writer from New York, is one of a smallish group of humans whose views I’ve come to trust as being insightful & mostly free from ideological bias. I’ve just been watching his latest video, and at the end (quoted below) he implored me to speak up so here goes.
    In the interests of us all living together on this planet, take 43 min 52 sec of your life and check him out. "
    then I quote the section near the end where he talks about preference falsification and encourages speaking up. I think including quotes is a good idea, not many people will click and watch, but people will read a bit despite themselves.

    • @prybarknives
      @prybarknives Před 3 lety

      I hope you get... and I get, the courage up.

  • @johnhaynes9910
    @johnhaynes9910 Před 3 lety +34

    Although I have lived and worked in the USA, I am English and live in the UK where despite the wishes of the loony woke people, circumstances are very different. The thing that strikes me is that regardless of the particular cause, BLM, Extinction Rebellion, Remainers (anti UK leaving the EU) and so on, the baying mob are predominantly white and middle class with the primary goal of claiming "greater virtue" than their fellow citizens who do not agree with them. It is as if what they are really missing is belonging to a religion, they have the same religious ferver as ISIS, the Crusades or the Spanish Inquisition, in whatever cause they support they have made their own "God" to worship.
    I always enjoy listening to Coleman Hughes, it matters not whether you agree with him completely, his importance along with some others, is that he is bringing reasoned and civil debate into the public arena and this is desperately needed in an atmosphere where "all heritics must be burnt at the stake", has become the norm, we seem to have made little progress in society of late.

    • @megaloschemos9113
      @megaloschemos9113 Před 3 lety +1

      Well said 💯

    • @johnneville403
      @johnneville403 Před 3 lety +1

      Spot on. I'm from the UK, too.

    • @angelhelen84
      @angelhelen84 Před 3 lety

      Also from the UK

    • @scartissuefilms
      @scartissuefilms Před 3 lety

      Agreed, the people who used to be fundamentalist religious Puritans have now become 'woke' in Secular societies. They've created a broken religion, with all the trappings of sin, but none of the restorative or redemptive qualities.

    • @rupert_harvey
      @rupert_harvey Před 3 lety

      He is, ironically, one of the most progressive voices of our time. The "baying mob" to which you refer are, if anything, regressive.

  • @glicmathan1771
    @glicmathan1771 Před 3 lety

    Coleman, as always, your analysis is brilliantly methodical and logical. You are one of my favorite intellectuals today. Thank you for all your great work!

  • @kathygill5714
    @kathygill5714 Před 3 lety +2

    Thank you for bringing back civility, true academic discussions and hope for the end of our challenging division

  • @justjudijjb3455
    @justjudijjb3455 Před 3 lety +5

    Smart young man.Wish we had 1000 more of him speaking out. Coleman’s voice matters.

  • @peterrogers565
    @peterrogers565 Před 3 lety +3

    Thank you so much Coleman, your clear thinking is helping to keep me sane in the current insanity.

  • @dorisfalkenrath4273
    @dorisfalkenrath4273 Před 3 lety +2

    What a great and intellectual mind! Love your insight concerning this topic.

  • @naturallysimple4938
    @naturallysimple4938 Před 3 lety +1

    I appreciate your calm soothing tone of voice... I need to work on my tone if I want to be heard.

  • @doug196
    @doug196 Před 3 lety +3

    Seriously powerful presentation.

  • @Adam-bq2vw
    @Adam-bq2vw Před 3 lety +16

    The problem is that too many of that ilk are not trying to solve problems; they’re just expressing anger.

    • @ronnywijngaarde7555
      @ronnywijngaarde7555 Před 3 lety +3

      You can get past a persons anger towards solutions... But that could require empathy. Angry people especially, usually want to feel respected and understood. Making light of their anger or condemning their anger generally doesn't help reach that effect.

  • @brianjoyce9040
    @brianjoyce9040 Před 3 lety +1

    This is so well conceived and executed. A coup de grace would be a picture of Coleman wearing the Trayvon, M Young etc t-shirt and his epiphany.

  • @sherrycooper1370
    @sherrycooper1370 Před 3 lety

    How refreshing to listen to you. Kudos, Mr. Hughes.

  • @dianamcintosh6738
    @dianamcintosh6738 Před 3 lety +6

    You speak so eloquently on this Coleman, and although I completely agree with what you're saying, it seems that I don't have "the right" (as a white woman) to voice my opinion on the matter. I get told that I must be very careful what I say. I do my best to convey my thoughts that although I don't support BLM (b/c of their underlying agenda), I wholeheartedly support the fact that all men are created equal and in MLK's words that we must judge a person by the content of their character, not the color of their skin! Why is that concept so hard to grasp and why shouldn't I have the right to have an opinion because of the color of my skin? I believe I do have that right.

    • @scarlet8078
      @scarlet8078 Před 3 lety +1

      We're in a strange time. I'm mixed but can pass for white, & even I dare not speak against BLM on social media. I think if you want to write on the topic & don't mind doing it anonymously, you're better off using a black profile picture. You can find an artist to illustrate this for you or go on websites that generate pix of people that don't exist by using AI technology

    • @oceansdeserts4446
      @oceansdeserts4446 Před 3 lety

      @@scarlet8078 While I appreciate your own experience, I have to agree to disagree with your advice even if you meant well. You're asking her to be an imposter at best or to put on black face at worst. If it is okay for Coleman Hughes to express his beliefs, which are largely data-driven versus experience-based, then why can someone of another race not do the same if they are sourcing their beliefs with the exact same facts? I believe my point is this: what if you and I listened to this entire podcast believing Coleman Hughes was black and then learned he wasn't? Would he then be wrong? I agree with most of his thoughts, not so much on gentrification, but do wonder about this question. I'm also basing that on my own minority experience and if it would be okay for someone of another ethnicity to speak on my behalf. If they can do it with data, then I may actually be grateful for their knowledge. If they try to do it from personal experience, then of course not. Thanks for commenting as your advice is exactly why we need more civil discourse. As a biracial woman, you should have a huge voice right now. Never be afraid to use it!

  • @Genuinelycuri0us
    @Genuinelycuri0us Před 3 lety +3

    Dude, thank you for this! The last part deeply resonates with me because I just got into a screaming match with my cousin (he did the screaming, and yes we’re both black). Glad to hear that other people are going through this too.

    • @02nf2i
      @02nf2i Před 3 lety +1

      I’m just becoming so disillusioned with my fellow liberals. I went to a liberal college, and my friends are super-liberals. I always considered myself very liberal too, but I feel like they all went bat-shit crazy and now embrace extreme, emotional, and irrational positions. Sometimes their views are anti-liberal because they are totally against the liberal concept of an open exchange of ideas. Anyone who questions their dogma is seen (to quote John Mcwhorter) as a moral pervert. As a pretty well-off white guy, the second I open my mouth, I lose all credibility. We’re told not to ask questions of black people or challenge their views. When they speak we must nod and say things like “I see you.” In other words, we shouldn’t do then the honor of grappling with and responding to their ideas. I can’t imagine having so much disrespect for my fellow black Americans to treat them in such a way-as if they didn’t have an intellect and fortitude. I feel lost because I believe everything Coleman is saying, but I know if I share it, I too will be seen as a moral pervert.

    • @Genuinelycuri0us
      @Genuinelycuri0us Před 3 lety

      @@02nf2i exactly! It’s almost like liberals are becoming conservative while conservatives are allowed to speak liberally about their opinions.

  • @anneji2946
    @anneji2946 Před 3 lety +1

    Can't thank you enough for this! The encouragement to speak up, especially amongst friends and family, was much needed. Would be interested in hearing about why people like Ta-Nehisi Coates or Nikole Hannah-Jones can be so influential. How do we use logic and emotions effectively and in a balanced way? How do you respond to people who only rely on emotions? I would love to see you do a breakdown of the video where you testified opposite of Ta-Nehisi Coates during the congressional hearings on reparations. In what areas would you agree with him, if you were just having a one on one conversation, how would you respectfully disagree?

  • @gtrainum
    @gtrainum Před 3 lety +2

    Voices like yours are what this country needs, 🙏

  • @brianjoyce9742
    @brianjoyce9742 Před 3 lety +5

    When a man is right, as Coleman is here, it should be required viewing/listening(×3), for any person that wishes to protest. The purpose of the protest must coincide with the facts. Thx Coleman, as clearly stated as I have found.

  • @stephenhenrich2625
    @stephenhenrich2625 Před 3 lety +138

    The cadence and inflection of Coleman's voice are nearly identical to Sam Harris.

    • @Bradley_Lute
      @Bradley_Lute Před 3 lety +22

      I have the feeling he is quite influenced by Harris

    • @MS-jz9ne
      @MS-jz9ne Před 3 lety +6

      It is actually cool. It would only work if what he says is smart, and that's the case. I'm very happy to discover this channel.

    • @MS-jz9ne
      @MS-jz9ne Před 3 lety +14

      Also don't forgot both meditate... It might helps explaining it. Kind of zen attitude'

    • @dingerness
      @dingerness Před 3 lety +13

      I've had the same thought. I get the sense he is very much a protégé of Sam Harris. Sam had been speaking highly of Coleman for some time on his podcast. I have absolutely no problem with the Harris-like delivery and format. We tend to imulate influential people around us, and Sam is a great model. Keep doing what you're doing Coleman!

    • @scratchscratch12
      @scratchscratch12 Před 3 lety +8

      When he said "Now back to the text..." it hit me.

  • @ifeanyiokonkwolevi7995
    @ifeanyiokonkwolevi7995 Před 3 lety +1

    This is an amazing podcast/analysis. kudos to you.

  • @rageagainstmyhatchet
    @rageagainstmyhatchet Před 3 lety

    Wonderfully well spoken and reasoned.
    This man's career is going places...

  • @dukedematteo1995
    @dukedematteo1995 Před 3 lety +197

    Coleman is chasing Sam Harris for my favorite podcast...

    • @samhand8270
      @samhand8270 Před 3 lety +17

      Check out Bret Weinstein’s Darkhorse podcast, especially of this topic interests you. Their insight from the Evergreen meltdown is pretty relevant today.

    • @DreadfulNW
      @DreadfulNW Před 3 lety +10

      It's cool to see the influence Sam, Glenn Loury, and others have had on Coleman. He's really coming in to his own.

    • @dukedematteo1995
      @dukedematteo1995 Před 3 lety

      @@samhand8270 which one....the last one with Matt Taibbi?

    • @samhand8270
      @samhand8270 Před 3 lety +1

      Duke DeMatteo
      No, the ones with him and heather, or the discussion with Glen Lowry, John McWhorter, Coleman, etc..

    • @VelkePivo
      @VelkePivo Před 3 lety +3

      You can discern a difference? :D Seriously, if my mind wanders I can sometimes think I'm listening to a Harris podcast. Maybe it's just a coincidence....

  • @PresidentialWinner
    @PresidentialWinner Před 3 lety +6

    Love the last quote by Hitchens.

  • @swanyay3304
    @swanyay3304 Před 3 lety

    I honestly was going to skim through this but I found myself listening to this essay in full and sending to several friends of mine..very impressive

  • @morganmeyers6444
    @morganmeyers6444 Před 3 lety

    Wow, what a clear objective point of view, I will be sharing this with as many people as I can.

  • @billhopen
    @billhopen Před 3 lety +3

    I'm so glad to hear your calm truth, so well stated. Gives me faith in your generation, I now see there is wisdom going forward, there is reason-based, evidence and data driven assessment of our situation, not just loud violent tantrums. This old white baby boomer was losing faith. I am an enthusiastic fan of your writing and pod cast, look forward to watching your career.

  • @socksoppressmytoes476
    @socksoppressmytoes476 Před 3 lety +140

    Ppl who busy themselves with activism while their household is broken are never right.

    • @worsethanjoerogan8061
      @worsethanjoerogan8061 Před 3 lety +21

      Jordan Peterson said the same thing. People don't have their own lives in order yet want to change the entire world

    • @haszmarcus9603
      @haszmarcus9603 Před 3 lety +10

      Why is it safe to assume activist's houses are broken?

    • @KPenceable
      @KPenceable Před 3 lety +2

      @@haszmarcus9603 im pretty sure this guy is just parroting a JP meme. I think it's him virtue signaling to other JP people

    • @user-pr5tx9ep4m
      @user-pr5tx9ep4m Před 3 lety +7

      @@haszmarcus9603 Valid point in general. I didn't read this particular comment as saying something Iike, if you are protesting then your house isn't in order. I read it, unconsciously before seeing your post, as an AND thing. Meaning, if you are protesting AND your house happens not to be in order.
      It also has nothing to do with Jordan Peterson. The idea of working on oneself as a means of working on the world is widespread and as old as philosophy itself.

    • @haszmarcus9603
      @haszmarcus9603 Před 3 lety

      @@KPenceable ahhhhhhhh gosh the internet is confusing. so many memes

  • @AM-zd7pu
    @AM-zd7pu Před 3 lety +1

    Thank you Coleman, great work.

  • @annieaviles4760
    @annieaviles4760 Před 3 lety

    You have very strong convictions that steer you to seek and share truth. Powerful.

  • @Alelisass
    @Alelisass Před 3 lety +7

    Hi Coleman, I've recently started following you, watching your videos and listening to what you have to say. I really enjoy your intellectual, cool, and reasoned approach to current events and the cultural/philosophical movements of the day. May I humbly request you make a video or do an interview with someone on the topic of anti-semitism in the Black community today in the US. Full disclosure, I am Jewish. Also important to note, I am in no way saying that all blacks or African-Americans are anti-semitic, or even that the majority are. But it certainly does seem, perhaps uniquely from the perspective of a Jewish person, that anti-semitism does have somewhat of an audience (more than simply fringe) amongst blacks/African-Americans (not sure which communities in particular), and it is something that worries me. There is actually so much in common, and prominent Jews had a role to play in the civil rights movement. Unfortunately, due to the widespread respect given to leaders such as L. Farrakhan because of his work in black communities across the US, hate and stereotypes towards Jewish people is given a big microphone, and it too often unfortunately goes unchecked. I think the recent spate of black entertainers and athletes posting anti-semitic messages is a reflection of this. So, humbly requesting you do a video on this. I would love to hear your thoughts on the matter, and I would love to see educated, intelligent, well-spoken black leaders addressing this important issue! Thank you in advance!

  • @nomad062
    @nomad062 Před 3 lety +31

    I'm not positive but I think I read that essay sometime ago. I really enjoy your pragmatic approach to these questions. A question I have:
    Why is all of the focus on the police officers? Many of the situations that lead to conflict are created by the policies of the local governments and their seeming desire to use the police as income generators or statistics generators proving that they (the politicians) have value.
    I completely agree that de-funding or lowering police budgets doesn't seem like an obvious solution.
    De-militarization? Absolutely!
    No Knock? Absolutely. There are abundant horror stories with this one.
    Justice reform in general but especially as it is related to drug users? Absolutely.
    There are definitely situations in which some sort of mental healthcare professional taking lead might be appropriate but I suspect not as often as people seem to think. Things can go bad very very quickly and I think having non police responding to calls might find they have a high injury/mortality rate. That said, police are expected to wear way too many hats, especially for the level of training they are given. Perhaps some of the training should go to sub-specialties so that there is some blend of skills besides criminal justice.
    I think though that the biggest problem for police is that most departments don't 'police' themselves. For obvious reasons they don't want to tattle but at the same time bad cops have to be known to their colleagues. Just as no one believes the Hollywood community in general had no idea Weinstein was a creep.
    Here is a question from a purely pragmatic point of view. How much perfection do we expect from our police? In 2018 250,000 people died from medical MISTAKES. Now I'm not a researcher or statistics person so I am sure the comparison needs much qualifying to come up with a number that is actually reflective of a valid comparison but is it likely to come to a number that is less than 1200+- people that die at the hands of police per year? And the medical profession as a group is some of the most highly trained people we have.
    People FU, they get tired, they don't pay attention. There are certain professions where we aim for the best possible, but what is actually possible an environment such as policing?
    Keep up the good work!

    • @egolayer13
      @egolayer13 Před 3 lety +6

      Yeah, this was recorded over a month ago, near the beginning of the riots. And I totally agree with you. Coleman's stoic pragmatism to questions is almost unparalleled. Like a modern day Chomsky without the communist baggage.

    • @eb.e.1649
      @eb.e.1649 Před 3 lety

      No knock warrants are needed. To get a no knock warrant is not as easy as people think. You don't go to a criminal's house and knock and say you want to arrest him. That's why no knock warrants are important

    • @misterlyle.
      @misterlyle. Před 3 lety +2

      @@eb.e.1649 I have read that they were introduced so that a drug raid can be carried off without giving the suspect time to flush evidence away. Such warrants have in some cases targeted the wrong address or wrong person based on false accusations. Innocent people have died as a result of such mistakes, including law enforcement. It seems to me such "unintended casualties" are intolerable. In most arrests at home, police do in fact knock and announce who they are. There is lots of room for improvement in law enforcement, and reform is an ongoing process.

    • @66dragonfly66
      @66dragonfly66 Před 3 lety

      This is the best comment so far!

    • @eb.e.1649
      @eb.e.1649 Před 3 lety

      @@misterlyle. it is intolerable but you can't end a good policy if it has a few bad effects. Almost every policy always has an unintended effect. We have to learn and adapt to those effects in the preparation of the future

  • @Kerenr88
    @Kerenr88 Před 3 lety +1

    Thank you coleman!!! I watch you all the time... I so appreciate your wisdom 🙂🙂🙂

  • @stevenlight5006
    @stevenlight5006 Před 3 lety

    Excellent conversation, thankyou ,

  • @dv8148
    @dv8148 Před 3 lety +4

    our hero on the field!

  • @dipdo7675
    @dipdo7675 Před 3 lety +50

    Mainstreet media is failing us...big time!!

    •  Před 3 lety +3

      A lot of things are failing....hence, the vital need for rational voices, insightful ideas, and common sense.

    • @lesleytaylor3825
      @lesleytaylor3825 Před 3 lety +1

      Availability heuristic bias should be guarded against. Exceptions shouldn’t be presented as the rule, the norm, or necessarily the trend.

    • @rainbowthrustars
      @rainbowthrustars Před 3 lety +2

      corporate media has basically always failed us. They are in it for the clicks and money.
      The day the racist card is not getting them the clicks they like and in extension the money flow I bet they will not be bothering much about police who kills unarmed black people either.
      It will be treated as when white people are killed by the Police, they will not bother.

    • @lob1523
      @lob1523 Před 3 lety +1

      I didn’t want to think it before since I’m not easily persuaded but in looking at the way my peers react to issues and share “memes” as news made me realize there is a big problem. Everything is written in a polarizing way in order to stroke a emotion vs. delivering facts. When a person watches CNN they are reconfirming existing beliefs they hold. When they watch Fox News they are also being told to feel a certain way. Even following certain political talking heads has gotten out of control. I watch a Ben Shapiro video and I already know what my conservative friends will be posting. I watch a Now This video and I’ll already know the exact talking points my lefty friends will be saying. It creeps me out in a way because I am literally seeing people being told how to feel and think and following suit.

  • @Flippyfloppy007
    @Flippyfloppy007 Před 3 lety +1

    Love your work as always. I recommend using a noisegate to remove the background noise from your recordings :)

  • @spacap1
    @spacap1 Před 3 lety

    Outstanding work. Honest, insightful, and hopefully thought provoking for our citizenry in general. With voice like yours and others, there still is hope. And that voice must stay strong in order for hope to survive. The gen pop is at each others throats, with the bellows of hate and divisiveness blowing hard on both sides. Others with more nefarious intent are playing and enormous role in this, and must be exposed and rooted out. Keep fighting!🗽🇺🇸

  • @vaporwave4880
    @vaporwave4880 Před 3 lety +7

    Another intellectual bullseye from Coleman.

  • @coreyashleyjones
    @coreyashleyjones Před 3 lety +6

    I think the recording date in the video image is incorrect. It says "02/06/2020". This sounds like it was recorded mid July, 2020.

  • @vickidianekimbrel4541
    @vickidianekimbrel4541 Před 3 lety +1

    I have truly enjoyed your conversations. I love to listen to intelegent people and to have a fresh new young voice is refreeshing. Thank you

  • @mumblesbadly7708
    @mumblesbadly7708 Před 2 lety

    Coleman, I applaud your level-headed and impartial approach to this topic.

  • @quabot
    @quabot Před 3 lety +4

    You amaze me. I recognized your philosophical mind before I learned that was actually your major.

  • @dubovaya
    @dubovaya Před 3 lety +26

    Thanks, I been struggling with my own sanity lately.

    • @rifrafbarker
      @rifrafbarker Před 3 lety +4

      yup. you are not alone. its...lonely though!!!

    • @larissadueck2643
      @larissadueck2643 Před 3 lety +3

      We are all struggling with that! It dawned on me last week that I need some counseling. I have so much anxiety right now. All due to the garbage that the radical left/mainstream left is espousing right now. I'm an American living in Canada, though, so I might have a hard time finding a counselor who will be sympathetic to me.

    • @dariuspalmer2829
      @dariuspalmer2829 Před 3 lety

      @@larissadueck2643 yh it good to gets some help you are not alone my friend, this is why I don't listen to the media anymore because of this.

  • @keith_pictures
    @keith_pictures Před 3 lety

    Brilliant as always, Coleman. And it makes for a more convenient, shorter version of Sam's #207 to share with friends.

  • @mikegrecamusic5917
    @mikegrecamusic5917 Před 3 lety

    Coleman you and the black guys at blogging heads have kept me sane these past months. Thank you!

  • @ZachMaxon
    @ZachMaxon Před 3 lety +4

    Every activist needs to hear this...

  • @StrategicWealthLLC
    @StrategicWealthLLC Před 3 lety +2

    As the beer commercials of my youth said, “I love you, man!” Great commentary as always, Coleman.

  • @dmbeckmann
    @dmbeckmann Před 3 lety

    Coleman, this is the most thoughtful, fact based and balanced conversation. I wish more people would take the time to listen and discuss these facts.

  • @harveychometsky
    @harveychometsky Před 3 lety +2

    Parrhesia: to speak in the face of danger. Thank you Coleman Hughes.

  • @willemvanloon5979
    @willemvanloon5979 Před 3 lety +6

    Its sounds impossible to have an opinion on BLM on CZcams, with a like vs dislike ration of more than 99% ... but Coleman pulls it off :o

  • @nancysherrod2428
    @nancysherrod2428 Před 3 lety

    I love your thoughtful and well balanced critique of our societal tensions. Thank you for modeling an honest and respectful conversation on race. You are a bright light in a time beset by the "fog of war".

  • @scottedwards9704
    @scottedwards9704 Před 3 lety +1

    I wish there were more like Coleman. This was so earnest. It wasn’t partisan. His thoughts here are thorough and productive. Coleman stays away from sensationalizing the issues and thinks rationally. Way to go, Coleman! We need much, much more of this in our society today.

  • @posieglom3215
    @posieglom3215 Před 3 lety +23

    The role of lawyer Benjamin Crump must be uncovered and become national headlines. All of the cases with his involvement need to be examined. He was the lawyer who yanked the T. Martin case from a closed case of self defense to an open case, clearly using untruths and likely a false witness (the substitution of Eugene with Jeantel seems real, and that Zimmerman followed Martin a lie). He then moved on to M Brown and perpetuated the "hands up" myth. There are other cases in which he seems to have spread faslehoods to flip a case of self-defense or accidental death into a murder, like Kendrick Johnson (lied about coroner, used an incorrect photo of body as evidence for the public, etc.). He was/is involved with Floyd, Rice, Taylor, etc. This should be the fulcrum for flipping the narrative. He has pretty much single-handedly created the myth/hoax/lie of racist violence in the cases used to create the BLM movement, and all the evidence is there, easily accessed and in need of sunlight. I know this sounds like conspiracy theory stuff, but it truly is not, even as some of it is (so far) put forward by shaky sources. (They are the only ones with nothing to lose.) The evidence of truth is all in the primary sources, and in need of public airing by objective and responsible media outlets.

  • @90arar
    @90arar Před 3 lety +5

    Everything spoken is what I feel.... Thank you Colman for making me feel like I am not alone. I will probably listen to this a couple of more times to in grain some sanity and common sense.

  • @anjy2l332
    @anjy2l332 Před 3 lety

    Fantastic Essay. Thank you!

  • @jraider2
    @jraider2 Před 3 lety +1

    Thank you Coleman! Is it troubling that a rational, empirical analysis of the most important issues of our time are an exception to the rule.

  • @ArchdukeAnderson
    @ArchdukeAnderson Před 3 lety +4

    Sometimes I can sense the influence of Sam Harris on you. The intro to this video was one of those times. It's a compliment, trust me.

    • @DejanOfRadic
      @DejanOfRadic Před 3 lety

      The influence is totally understandable in someone so young.....what i can't understand is where he found such sincerity and such a calm but robust commitment to looking for the truth.