The Lesser-Known Reasons for Divide Between East & West Pakistan | Ep 1 | A Twisted Tale of Betrayal
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 12. 2021
- From the Agartala Conspiracy Case against Sheikh Mujibur Rahman and his peers to the Santahar town massacre against Biharis for cooperating with Pakistan Army, many events went unnoticed in history that actually led to the separation of East Pakistan. The first episode of ‘A Twisted Tale of Betrayal’ explores all such incidents and the role of three major stakeholders.
TCM presents an exclusive series, ‘A Twisted Tale of Betrayal’ where a Pakistani, an Indian and a Bangladeshi come together to analyse what led to the separation of East Pakistan in 1971. This three-part series examines the events from the perspective of all three countries and how history was re-written differently for Pakistan, India and Bangladesh.
Link to complete playlist: bit.ly/3z2SXMY
TCM’s five-year journey has been about telling stories that people want to hear which mainstream media has been neglecting for decades. We want to disrupt the status quo by delivering engaging content which empowers impassioned voices and impacts social change. We are defined by integrity, grit and ingenuity and this is what makes us do what we do.
Support independent journalism in Pakistan and get exclusive access to the full-length version of our videos: / thecentrummedia
-------------------
Subscribe to TCM Original: bit.ly/2A3pOXz
Subscribe to TCM: bit.ly/2Tu6AkW
-------------------
Follow us on
Facebook: / tcmoriginalsofficial
Facebook: / thecentrummedia
Facebook: / centrumenter. .
Tiktok: / tcmoriginals
Twitter: / thecentrummedia
Instagram: / thecentrummedia
-------------------
Join our Facebook community: bit.ly/35oeLVs
-------------------
Website: thecentrummedia.com
-------------------
About The Centrum Media
The Centrum Media (TCM) has the credit of Pakistan’s first digital news operation specializing in visual storytelling. Being a premier online platform, TCM strives to enhance the online experience of the new generation, ranging from hard news to feature stories. TCM creates original content and curates simultaneously from multiple sources.
We will take you where the real stories happen but often go untold and unseen in the shortest possible time having more information. Unlike the traditional media, TCM aims at sharing diverse stories across multi-platforms aimed at the people who consume news through mobile and social stream. We take up the challenge in the digital arena to present the news in the most imaginative and innovative ways.
Your on-the-go lifestyle forces us to bring the news directly to your pocket devices.
52 years later and history is repeating itself, except this time it is Punjaabi Army pitched against Punjab itself. The slogans, narratives, acccusations, charges are exactly the same, only characters have changed.
So the Military General's and Bhutto was the reason of breaking the Country💔
No. Pakistani punjabi people behaviour toward bangali is reason of breaking the country.
@Ali read the history the way it should be read, not they way they taught you to read.
Search below answer of below question by yourself.
1. Whats the population of that time (West and east pakistan)
2. Whats the total earnings of Pakistan at that time and which portion has earn more.
3. Which (east or west pakistan) expenditure more.
4. What Pakistani Army and politicians think about bangalis.
5. What jinnah siad about bangla language. What happens in 1952 for bangla language movement.
6. Why Urdu language impose by pak although 56% of total pakistani language was bangli language.
7. Who wins 1970 election and why didn't pakistani army and politicians didn't handed over govt to east pakistan.
8. What is 6 points.
9. Why pak army niyazi "Main iss haramzade quam ka nasal badal dunga, yeh mujhe samajta kya hai.
Search All those question by yourself.
@Ali You are doing that. You're supporting Kashmir insurgency and you also supported Khalistan insurgency. You don't know about your history.
@Ali India is successful in controlling insurgency. That's the reason, Pakistan is broken whereas India is still intact.
@Ali 1. Initially, India wasn't interested in Muslim majority J&K, but when Jinnah accepted Hindu majority Junagadh as part of instrument of accession, Nehru and Patel decided that it's time to take over J&K too.
2. We did a plebiscite in Junagadh were Nawab and Pakistan representatives were invited but refused to attend.
3. As far as plebiscite in J&K is concerned, UNSC resolution calls for Pak army and it's immigrants after 1 Jan 1949 to leave so that plebiscite could happen.
Bro, your country is a loser. You should cry everyday with this reality. You can never defeat the Republic of India.
If i would've heard it 2 years ago i might have been cursing You guys but the good part is You show the facts and open opinions of the people
As a pakistani we particularly our army should apologize from bangladeshi people.
A wrong deed can never be right whatever the circumstances are.
Brother why should Pakistan’s army apologise when east Pakistan’s army not west also it was for your information Indian army dressed in Pakistan’s army suit’s made it look like Pak army this was planned time ago a general in India admitted am sure there’s a book on this. Pak army doing the zulm as Pakistan’s army was stuck they had no chance to move never mind zulm.. this all done in name of power! control zubaan urdu whould not be the main language mujibur back stabbed Jinna’s dream
For both Pakistan’s. Urdu wud be the main language of both countries. Mujibur His the real reason for all what happened! Not Pakistan’s army..
@@AbdulSamad-jw6xq Well no one can read about it because it was never published. However it was written in it that despite losing, the claim of the Bengalis and Indians that many Bengalis were killed, was not true.
@@multitrickman3886 homudur commission was formed by Pakistan parliament. How can you tell it is not true. Are out of mind or never read history of your nation. 😂😂😂😂
@@multitrickman3886 our own generals admitted it bro.
@@fajeradnan8607
The problem of living in an echo chamber
Even if Mujib had been allowed to be PM, the Army would not have allowed him to function. Separation was inevitable.
Congratulations! Bangali brothers & Sisters for getting rid of corrupt, coward and Traitor army. But you guys left us to put up with these bastards in West Pakistan.
Pakistan Zindabad from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
We always love Pakistan because we made Pakistan..
Insha'Allah Pakistan will be a Economic and Military super power.🇵🇰
Allahu Akbar.
Be always United. Don't try to break the country 🇵🇰.
Now we, Muslims of Bangladesh has become minority to the inferior india and the hindus.
"They were outnumbered but when they were asked to fight they bloody well did" my grandfather who is a veteran of both the Indo-pak wars,was involved on the Lahore sector as well as a regt company commander in '71.
Didnt they all surrender? what fight?
@@asdasdasdqwe123What have you achieved so far? These things aren’t that simple, many did their very best and there were many variables. Try to be logical.
By December 1971, the US was in no position to send reinforcements, naval or ground to the Bay of Bengal due to its own preoccupation in Vietnam. Remember, the fall of Saigon happened in 1975 within 4 years after 1971.
The Biharis killed the Bangalis very brutally, Pakistan has a lot of love for Biharis, so why don't Pakistan take them to Pakistan from Bangladesh.
We have a lot of bangalis here wht about them Bangladesh want to send biharis but don't except banglis
@@alijawwad8649 Those who are so-called ''Bangalis'' actually are not Bangladeshi, they are Rohingya. Bangladeshi don't want to go to Pakistan.
@@AliHossain-kn6kf let me clear they don't come from Bangladesh they are those who work here when Bangladesh was east Pakistan before 1971 but after separation they don't go there due to some reasons
@@alijawwad8649 Good!
@Genocide King Those were the razakars and al badar al shams members.
The generals still want to stay in power . Look at this shameless Bajwa sitting on extension. Total disregard for chain of command
General bhadwa rocks
An unfortunate country, Pakistan is.
Very tremendous content.
The Awami league did not take ownership of the problems of whole country and wanted to be separated. Before 1958, Iskander Mirza a Bengali was all powerful dictator of united Pakistan. What good he did for East Pakistan? The problem was of disparity among people but unfortunately it was seen through racial lens.
Informative..
After Air hijack of Ganga in January 1971, the donkeys in Rawalpindi launched Searchlight on March 25, 1971 without securing supply lines against the advice of Admiral Ahsan, Sahabzada Yakub etc.
Bhutto wasn't with majority.....
Democracy RIP....... 💐💐💐😥😥
@Modič the reason is that, dictatorship has produced more results than democracy, and dictatorship is always backed by so-called democratic goons.......... 😶😶😶
@@wajahatali3754 the so called democratics you are referring are paksitani cultural wadairas and fuedals. Nothing like this shit happened in other countries
@@beautyzline5194 I agree, and the very reason why this situation isn't changing is that, the mindsets of the people aren't on the right track
@@wajahatali3754 Well no one is going to answer the question that why had dictatorshipp produced so much results? Because the democratic governments have always eaten pakistan.
Fervently, waiting for the next part.
Thanks!
General Yahya "prematurely" declared Mujib to be the future prime minister of Pakistan without Washington's nod. The nod never came from Washington. Yahya had to cancel March 1971 session of the parliament paving the way for civil disobedience resulting in the infamous Operation 'Search light'.
They get the representation in amred forces 33 percent of bengali soldiers in our army.
And all betrayed Pakistan army
percentage figure incorrect. Tikka decided to disarm all Bengali units, long before 25 Mar 1971. The results are b4 all. Over estimation of self and under estimating the enemy is absolutely fatal. PMs still blaming others and not looking into their own stupidity.
Pakistan came into being wirh hard work of bengalis and west pakistan was saved too by their sacrifices. Time will come when west pakistan will come to the aid of Bengalis in general. Don't worry brothers, ur always in our thoughts, though we are separated but the link will never be broken.
In 1969 september pakistan army led by brigadiar zia ul haq ( who later become pakistan president in 1979) led pakistan army killed 20,000 palestinian refugee s in jordan refugee camp. this incident is known as black september. pakistan army killed the palestinian refugees on the order of us president lyndon johnson . pakistan receives us aid in return pakistan does dirty works for usa. more palestinians were killed by pakistan army in 3 days than isreal did in 30 years . this is the true face of munafiq punjabi army
We Bengalis don't need help of beggar Pakistan. Joy Bangla 🇧🇩
@@stdew07 before saying anything about Pakistan keep in mind 4 million bangalies are living in Karachi neither the government agencies nor Pakistan Army disturbing them as they are Muslims and our brothers
Come out from the dirty politics of SHEIKH MUNAFIQ UR REHMAN
Love, respect and prayers for East Pakistani brothers and sisters 🇵🇰❤️🤝🇵🇰❤️🤝🇵🇰❤️🤝🇵🇰❤️🤝🇵🇰❤️🤝
@@turabassociates4140 You are the munafiq because you made you Pakistan looted wealth from East Bangal/ East Pakistan from 1947 -1970 . Watch the videos of Dr. Taimur Rahman a professor of University of Management, Lahore . “ East Pakistan to Bangladesh “ 1-5. Then you will be the Munafiq not the Bangladesh’s father of the nation BANGABANDU SHEAKH MUJIBUR RAHMAN.
@Rehaan come out from the fake indian propaganda and dirty, filthy and horrible politics of SHEIKH MUNAFIQ UR REHMAN, he is low profile and inferiority complex person just to become prime minister only for 3 years he brokes a beautiful country.
Best of luck for Bangali brothers and sisters 🇵🇰❤️🤝🇵🇰❤️🤝🇵🇰❤️🤝🇵🇰❤️🤝🇵🇰❤️🤝
Victory for Bangladesh 🇧🇩🇧🇩
in the past years, many blunders happened that changes the destiny of east and West Pakistan. due to political unfair and injustice and non-cooperation between east and west Pakistan politicians Bangladesh seperated
Awami League Ghaddar thi aur Generals and Bhutto were blind ; Indra was cunning. This is what broke Pakistan
Which software you use for editing?
It's bhutto responsible for divide of Pakistan nation, bhutto was the reason for fall of Dhaka, sheikh mujeeb had the right to be PM of Pakistan
Didn't Mujib just prove all the Indian involvement accusations correct?
Zbr 10
Why no. Option to download?
Due to enormous differences among us division was inevitable . However how this happened is really painful. we could have parted peacefully.
Wrong if West Pakistan people can live together why and how bengalis won't live with us. Bengalis were forced to make Bangladesh so that Punjab can easily rule Pakistan.
History of 47 repeated. Your Pakistani army and the nation lives on useless wars. Agents of Shaitaan
@@theyaduvanshiindian391 well if current india is to go by, then inter - religious and cultural harmony isn't going very good in India, so I am happy that we parted but its really sad how it happened
@@anb4351 🤣
@@anb4351
The Partition of 1947 was good for India. The unfortunate part was the perfidy of the Muslims who voted for Pakistan and yet stayed behind and are a perpetual drag on the country.
Regular viewer from India 🇮🇳... Good work and good luck for ur work
Bangladesh was never meant to be part of Pakistan, it never was. Look at the geography, and bulky India inbetween. To me, initial distribution was injust. A country made to stay needed to be intact in terms of geography first.
Funny part is East Pakistan was quite rich and a leader in export. West Pakistan financed itself from that East pakistani money
It's good that our countries got separated.
Now Bangladesh is progressing by leaps and bounds Alhamdulillah.
Had it remained with us it would still be on a double reverse gear.
However the way it happened and the grievances that developed was so bad.
Maybe if QuaideAzam had gotten more time he would have realized it or maybe he could have prevented it but after him it was inevitable.
with intellectuals like ayesha jalal in pakistan it is certain that islamabad will witness more divisions of West Pakistan.
Watching this with blurry vision 😞
At least accept that col. Oli ahmed is a retired. He is no more serving in BD army
Please make video on Ch Rehmat Ali
Azad Kashmir zindabad we are with our freedom fighters I said to the pakistan army to give us a chance to made azad Kashmir army for fight in jammu Kashmir we will fight till our last drop of blood.
Destiny of nations is determined by its ppl and their leaders. It is for Pakistanis what path they choose. As far as India is concerned,as per perception of Pakistanis, it is going to remain their eternal enemy and India is also reconciled to this position. So good luck 😀 to our brethren across borders.
Now a days india is more hatefull and Pakistan centric
It seems Pakistani establishment have infected indian secularism.
Wake up
U have also become religious extremists country with 4 star generals sitting on every news channel in primetime
@@noumanmuzaffar9045 no we are good. It is need of our. Otherwise reconciliation from Muslim community won't come. They were given too much appeasement.
Uniform civil court is true path. No religious bullshitt. Religious bullshitt must be with in boundary of house, mandir and masjid. Otherwise nation won't devlop.
It was the greed of absolute power of that munhoos cursed Bhutto coupled with the derision that Army and overall feudal landlord ruling mafia in W. Pak had against Bengalis that eventually led the situation to the point of no return at the political level.
I’ll agree with most complaints that the Bengalis had but not when it comes to the national state language. Urdu was and is still not a majority language in any province of Pakistan. It was and is a neutral language and allowed people from one province to communicate with a person from another. Also having Urdu meant that no province could claim that another province’s language was being imposed upon it.
Jinnah had said that while Urdu was going to be the national language, the provinces were free to choose any language they wished for official use, but this would need to be done through their elected representatives once a constitution was in place.
Over the language issue, the Bengalis were unnecessarily being emotional
They're an Ott/emotional people, I have experienced it irl
Now are angry with India, saying that they're looting them with trade defecit etc
I don't know why Pakistanis cry about this too much
@@12thman74 You are right
Urdu is Lingua franca but you can't impose it on others without their will especially those who believe they want to attach deeply to their roots. In West Pakistan, it mattered differently due to their close proximity to North India. But in East Pakistan, they viewed Tagore and Nazr Ul Islam as the representative of Bangla Art and Culture, not Iqbal or Ghalib. In South and East India, they still prefer their regional languages over Hindi, and the same is true for Interior Sindh, KPK, and Baluchistan. Punjab is an exceptional case.
@@shoaibazizmeer you totally missed the point. If we apply the Bengali logic at present, Punjabi should be the state national language (as Punjab is the province with an overwhelming majority). This would be rightly unacceptable to KP, Sindh and Balouchistan. Yet Urdu is accepted as lingua Franca by those provinces because Urdu does not belong to any of those provinces. I’m from KP and Urdu is just as alien to Pashto as Urdu is to Bengali, and us Pakhtuns didn’t protest like the Bengalis. Furthermore, as I said, Jinnah had said that provinces were free to choose whether official language they wished. This was a totally fair stance. So Bengalis were being ridiculous here.
@@wkhan5 Bengalis demanded to make Bengali a national language in retaliation and later on they agreed that there can be two national languages. If I go further, Sheikh Muhjeeb did also concede many demands in his six-point movement. Hence there was never a stage where Bengalis wanted to impose Bangla on other parts of the federation My argument is that there is no issue to giving Urdu the status of a national language but the way State tried to propagate the so-called nationhood to all the provinces by attempting to alter the history, we paid a big cost and we are still paying it.
Much better East Pakistan became Bangledesh.
Sam bahadur⚡🧡💚
Massively genocide of Bengali peoples and burning houses of peoples was not solution of political problem. Political problem created by bhutto and Punjabi fouji hukumat. They were not ready to transfer power to Awami League. Bengali peoples were original citizen of east pakistan. Punjabi aor urdu speaking muhajir leaderon ki gulami sae azad hona zaruri thaa. Azadi Bangladeshi awam ka haq thaa. Azadi ki jang bagawat nehi. Bengali peoples started war of independence in 1857. British called Bangalion ne bagawat kiya govt kay khilaf. Mulk aor qaom ki azadi ke liye jang bagawat nehi.
The charge of exploiting East Pakistan by the West is incomprehensible. Governor Burrows agreed with the necessity of a United Bengal. He painted a pathetic picture of the future of Eastern Bengal or Eastern Pakistan, after partition. He said:
It would stagnate to such an extent and become so poor that it would end up as a rural slum. Economically it could not survive as all the coal mines, the minerals and the factories are in Western Bengal, so are the jute processing mills. Eastern Bengal would be deficient in food to the extent of 225,000 tons......if Eastern Bengal was to be properly fed it would be necessary to import 800,000 tons at least. The only main crop in East Pakistan was jute. They might turn over from jute to food, although that would kill the Calcutta Jute Industry.
This proved once for all that "ummah" is only a theological concept. People don't unite only the basis of religion. Culture is a stronger bond than religion. If that wasn't the case, Europe would have been a single country and so would have been the entire middle east.
Exactly, why else would there be 22 countries in the Arab world 🌍? Even the Arabian peninsula is split up between several different countries. Islam ☪️ is the NOT basis of nationhood. Pakistan 🇵🇰 was the FIRST and ONLY country to be created in the name of Islam ☪️. We can see how that turned out.
Ummah is a concept for those who fear Allah and judge by his commandments.
Not for those who usurp power and are greedy.
We as Pakistanis have to admit that what happened was based on racism and impoverishment of the Bengal people.
As a result the Indians put salt on the wounds and Gen YAHYA decided to force power.
Many of the atrocities done in Bihar and the ones labelled on the Pakistani Army were done by Mukti Baani, sponsored by India.
My wife’s uncle served there, he said we were left without proper amunition and resources, very quickly we arrested and our uniforms taken from us.
It’s unbelievable how he returned back.
However the Bengali people were right to have these sentiments of mistreatment from Pakistan and India deeded on it with hate, and when people see military uniformed personal massacring then only hatred comes about.
What happened in Bihar is documented by western journalists and it was extremely heinous. Millions of people became victims as a punishment for aiding with Pakistan.
Even today those Bengalis who didn’t want this to be split from a Muslim country as labelled as traitors even though they were trying not to be split up, and have been hanged in Bengali prisons.
Even Benglis we’re raped and massacred, however we have to see that’s what happens when we fall into the lap of the enemy.
From a Pakistani general perspective this was treason to side with India a staunch enemy!
@@yasararif8292 You as Pakistanis should realize that the holocaust known as the partition should have NEVER happened and that “Pakistan” should have NEVER been created.
@@1525boy
People were killed on both sides, we could never live under the people we ruled for such long, because they had venom inside them.
We see this today in India, look at how the minorities are treated!
Muslims in India are treated below achoot and considered sub human!
Yes we have cases in Pakistan, but just because the west decided not to highlight the atrocities in India because they are their allies and hate Islam and Muslims!
Mob lynchings happen on a daily basis in India.
India is the root of all evil in the area, all the terrorism in Pakistan is being funded by India, be it TTP(so called Pakistani Taliban) air Balochistan Army.
The atrocities it’s doing on Kashmiris is phenomenal.
They even go as far as staging terrorist false flag operations!
We know all this because Kalpooshal yadav has admitted all this!!
@@yasararif8292 lol. Your entire tirade against Bangladeshis proves my point: it didn't matter that both Bengalis and Pakistanis were followers of Islam. They committed atrocities on each other disregarding teaching of Islam.
A dossier was made by Bhutto and generels on 20th march to prevent sk. Mujib to become pm of pakistan.India didn't play roll until 11th december 1971.
People of Pakistan don't aspect it's their fault.
That nation is still doing this with other provinces, no offence but it’s reality. This must be stop because the situation is gone from bad to worse. The bomb is ticking. 💔
Balochistan is already on full protest mode😑
@@byron-ih2ge okay abhijeet sharma , sipping ☕ from Mumbai IT cell are we?
@@hhaze2020 na man for real
@@byron-ih2ge stop liking your own comments tho🤣🤣
@@hhaze2020 pls dont play the cheapest of tricks 😂.
It vindicates the concern Pakistan had of the collusion between Bangladesh and India during Ayub’s era was 100% correct. It makes sense what Yahya said, ihow could Mujeeb could govern Pakistan from that end while India was in between.
Never short of conspiracy theories
After winning absolute majority what the hell is there to negotiate??
امریکہ اور انڈیا کا ایک سوچا سمجھا منصوبہ تھا جو جنرل یحیٰ نے تکمیل تک پہنچایا۔ بس اللہ خیر
🇧🇩 amar rhe
Proud of India Army ❤
Han Hindu hai sazashi tou haii proud of them bt with lannnat
@@fareehakhalid295 lannat pak army pe hai. Duniya ki pehli muslim army jisne surrender kiya kafiro ke aage. thu thu
South Indians didn't accept Hindi as their National Language, so did Bengalis with Urdu. All Pakistani languages have the same script and have heavy infusion of Arbi/Farsi words unlike Bengali.
Actually there is no provision for national language in Indian constitution
You will allways be victim, because aap mai kuwat kam hai Aur gussa jyada hai, in nutshell paw bhar haddi khaile kabbadi,😤chutiye log, din bhar tarjiya karte hai, kaam kuch nahi,
1000 years under Muslim rule!
Gussa ithna jaldi nahi tanda hoga!!
Bas chai peeyo aur kaho fantastic tea.
Phir World Cup ka match dekho aur mazai lo!!!
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
End of… not going to reply to your rubbish
Baap baap Hoya hai bachuuu!
1000 saal pala hai, sonai ki chirya banaya tha hum nai!!
@@yasararif8292 Swaran Singh was the mastermind behind East Pakistan Debacle. He advised Indira to take revenge of 1000 years Muslim rule.
@@MrWahab1969
They’re still at it, TTP IS being funded by them, they kille 150 plus children in cold blood, they’re also trying to fund rebellion in Balochistan, they are the ones who have created hatred among the afghans for us, 20 years of brainwashing.
All I know is that evil will always perish!!
@@yasararif8292 then why talk and make "Peace " deals with TTP ? Negotiating and making deals with child murderers ? The TTP has to hide somewhere and they are doing it in Afghanistan . Pakistan used to claim Afghanistan government used to harbor TTP , now what is stopping you to finish them off ? You actually think Afghani Taliban and TTP are separate entities and they dont help each other .
@@arjunjmenon
TTP are Indian agents, they have nothing to do with Afghan Taliban, you can’t claim that Pakistan helped Afghan Taliban and then say they have no leverage with TTP.
They are separate entities.
Different govt have dealt with rebels in different ways.
The way they dealt with East Pakistani rebels was not the way forward.
The west Pakistani policies led to the rebels falling into India’s hand.
They actually shot themselves in the foot!
Abb saza doooo
Beghairaat log ajj bhi yehi kerrahe Tor ker dum lain Gaye
Ya Allah iss milk ka mahafizz ban jaaa
Sad thing is the generals are still running Pakistan
im sorry to all those bengalis who were murdered in and before the war. we owe you an apology. i wish we were still together
We made mistakes, grave ones. Our leaders put their personal interests over national interests. We deserved this.
Very similar to why Pakistan was created in the first place.......landed elite kept their interets over larger public interest.....
Millions died so that Pak could be created for.the landed elites......
West Pakistan never respected the vote of the people.....
@@rohitkashyap7476 The Founders weren't aiming for any of that stuff you've mentioned.
It's the leaders who came after that are to be blamed.
@@McMillan435
Kaha sae aaye wo leaders......asmman sae....
British gave right to vote to Rich, landed, educated only.....
The zamindars feared that they would loose everything in a secular , socialist India.....
So then you had Pakistan.....for Zamindars / Nawabs .....
They were ok with leaving behind half the Muslim in India...
Why because all they wanted was a country they could rule....they could not convince all muslims to come to Pakistan nor did they try.....
You can keep believing your version...India had land reforms and Zamindari.was abolished...... Pakistan never did so......
The Zamindars / big business and Army Generals have ruled Pakistan and used the country based on individual fancies......
Very similar to what would be in Mughal era
@@rohitkashyap7476 So by your logic, rather than blaming the culprits who committed these acts we should blame everything on the creation of Pakistan.
Lol
@@McMillan435 well, it depends on why u want to blame people....
1. Just to feel , that u have some1 to blame...
2. To understand where the problem lies....
Bangladesh happened because people refused the system...
The same system exists in Pakistan today.... Zamindars/ elites who give two hoots about Pakistan( nation)..... they exploit and leave and settle outside.......common people can keep suffering.....and enduring......and defending the high ideas on which Pak was created.
The ideas were never real.
Today IK is saying ...mujhe PM banao warrna mulk toot jaayega......
If india had that portion which lies inside pakistan in terms of geographical boundaries.
Then pakistan should have to do same not to make it separate hindu land but to integrate it with pakistan.
Pakistan had no capabilities for that😂Pakistan is trying so hard to break a 95 percent muslim kashmir from india still achieving nothing..
Kashmiris r less than 1 crore. East pak population was more than dat of West Pak.so their insurgency was successful.
That’s the difference we didn’t do that.they want separate country we gave them..
Next to BLOAUCHISTAN and PALHUTANKHA
Wots palhutankha😭😭😭 IT cell complete your brainwashing first
Generals mulk kha gay hen
What happened between east and west Pakistan looks somewhat similar to the counter of the Boston Tea Party, between England and America. But the fact cannot be denied that in Pakistan's case, west Pakistan was indeed prejudiced against its eastern half. While the Boston Tea Party was a local riot, similar to today's MAGA rioters, which, sadly, engulfed the entire States.
Quaid e Azam RA founded Pakistan on basic of Islam & Kalma... Then why Bangali people were annoyed by quaid's saying in which he declared Urdu as national language???
Urdu is common in this region...
Bangali could justify their anger if quaid declared pashto, punjabi, sindhi, balochi or saraiki as national language!!!
Islamists supported Pakistan & they are also supporting Pakistan today.
Bangali Muslims are our brothers. We admire their sacrifices for Islam & Pakistan...
InShaALLah one day we'll live together again including India in Greater Pakistan (pure Islami state like present Afghanistan)
In India especially the urban muslim are fast becoming atheists....
😂😂😂this is the reason u r a failure state.don’t worry maximum 25 years u need to borrow money to run ur country literally every month n u r dreaming about gajwa e hind 😂😂 how u goona win with your Talwar 😂 those days r hone poor guy.u need money first go earn some money beggar
I wish Jinnah was alive in 1971 to see the liberation of Bangaldesh. It would have been a perfect slap on jinna who has a british puppet and slave. The seeds of the new nation was sowed by him and he should have seen it the final shape. jinna had no vision or idea other than to just oppose congress. In end it's good that the partition happened and now India can grow and pakistan is on verge of being a bankrupt state. normal pakistani should thank India for doing justice to atrocities going on there. now Bangladesh is a free and fast developing country who has more forex than pakistan.
Jai Hind !!! Joy Bangla !!!
Nope if he would be alive then he never let the bloodshed happened and peacefully sort out the differences
Just like he peacefully broke dream of Akhand Bharat 😌
@@filmyprofessor_99 do u know how many lives were lost due to his direct action day in 1946-47 ? there is blood on his hand and he cared little about who lived or died. he was just a puppet/slave of british and he would have played as per the direction of his masters.
Akhand Bharat is a joke to tease people like u. we dont want akhand bharat and it's good the people like u r out of India. Modern divided India has reached Mars and Moon, if it was united we would be spending time just on internal fighting and no development. we are happy with what we have now and dont want anything more.
@@filmyprofessor_99 do u know that jinna has not written even an article or book? he literally had no idea about what to do with the area British gifted him for the loyalty and the service he had served his masters. i hope some day u will see his true picture and understand the blunder u has done with u folks.
u took almost a decade to finalize your first constitution and not sure many version have been there. here in India we have only 1 version which was finalized in 1949. also u never have regular census which is so surprising as it generates the data which is required for governance. we have regular census every 10 years and regular election every 5 years.
@Genocide King he didnt want to divide punjab also and wanted the whole of it. he was talking all these things to just reduce the size the size of India. he was advising Travancore to say independent. want to include jaisalmer and jodhpur. all these 3 states are hugely hindu dominated provinces. he also wanted hyderabad and was advising them also to stay independent.
@@filmyprofessor_99 No one wants akhand bharat, in fact the right wing in India is super happy that there is a pakistan. to be honest, if there is ever even a talk of annexing pakistan, indians will be up in arms. no one wants your land. its a blessing for us that you all are seperate else all this debt, incompetence and terrorism would be at our doorstep. Good riddance!! Khush raho aap log aur karo apni laadli army ki waah waahi.
Pack Key! Pack Key! Pack Key! - Keep deleting dinks!!
Greetings from Pakistan occupied kashmir
Get ready to make a same type of documentary about Baluchistan soon. That day is also coming.
You mean kashimir Nagaland Junagadh State & Khalistan
@@diabloscar1012 They are in India going no where. So stop day dreaming. But get ready with Balochistan and POK. Gone soon.
@@sayantanguha1708 there is no Baloch Genocide. I’m a Muhajir-Baloch from Quetta and living happily. Aapne aapko itna bhi bara nahi sochna chahi hai. I admit, Pakistan was wrong in ‘71, but this Genocidal thing is just nonsense.
@@mul-el3657 So why are people protesting in Gwadar and the Chinese loot of Baluchistan. Why was Akbar Bugti killed by an airstrike. Do u have answers for this.
@@mul-el3657 there is very strange connection of 1971 episode and Baluchistan. Gen Tikka Khan was sent before Niazi and Tikka was called "butcher of Baluchistan". so what is going on in Baluchistan needs to be fixed and only India can do that.
the repeat of 1971 will be very soon and this time in Islamabad !!!
Jai Hind !!
PAKISTANESIA PAKISTANESIAN PAK PK
UNITED ISLAMIC STATES ARABIC OF PAKISTANESIA UISAP UNITED PAKISTANESIA
URDUISH ISLAMICABAD
Don’t blame West Pakistan for breakup. Bengali Nationalists were planning it for a long time. Now even many BD writers have admitted (including Bir Uttar Sharif Dalim) that Agartala conspiracy was not false. That happened years before 1971. Urdu was spoken all over India where as Bengali was a regional language just as Punjabi, Pushto, Sindhi, Baluchi are regional languages. If for the sake of national unity provinces in West Pakistan can accept Urdu as national language, why not Bengalis? No body was asking them to stop practicing Bengali. I have met many BDeshi in foreign countries and they can manage a reasonable conversation in Urdu. That would have brought us even closer. As for false claims of exploitation by West Pakistan, the fact is many businesses from West Pakistan invested in East Pakistan. Investing is not an exploitation. These days countries do they level best (including BDesh) to attract foreign investment. West Pakistanis did it as one nation. But I know Awami League BDeshi will never accept that.
Bengalis are very proud of their culture....they have superior ego...West Pakistan treated them as less morons and massacred them.... Bangladeshi national anthem was written by Indian Bengali Hindu nobel laureate Rabindranath Thakur.....Amar sona bangla.....Islam divides the world
The rise of the Bengali Nationalism was for many reasons especially after '65 and Ayuub Khan. And by the claim of yours that there were no exploitation, you yourself is making false claims. Urdu was indeed spoken in Bengal, but Bengali had always been the language of Bengali people. It was never an wise option to make Urdu a state language of East Pakistan, that was the first nail in the coffin by Jinnah. How would you feel if Bengali was made West Pakistan's state language? Kinda fascist, eh? Exactly. Make your facts clear not filled with fallacies. You have been taking that dose for a very long time now..
@@rajithasan9319 most of the Bengalis, including yourself, have been brain washed by Indian and Awami League propaganda and fallacies. The first nail in the coffin of East West unity was Agartala Conspjracy hatched by India and Mujib. This is now very proudly admitted both by India and Awami League.
@@sarwaralam3977 Propaganda? Fallacies? Brain wash? It seems a particular state is more familiar to these. Is it a coincidence that Pakistan always chose to hide Hamudoor Rahman commission report? Is it a coincidence that history has been distorted in the Pakistani generation? Is it a fallacy that Rao Farman Ali and Niazi were commandar of genocide and mass rape and destruction? Is it a good idea to run a state and legisleture by theology? Are you not paying the price of using religious fundamentalists for political gainings? Is it not dogmatism to silence the liberals and intellectuals?
Surely some of you Pakistanis will never change, just hope for the future generations that they could be progressive and have some measure s of enlightenment.
@@rajithasan9319 for the genocide lies, read Sarmila Bose book “ 1971 dead reckoning” . It’s written by a Hindu Indian Bengali. Need anything more?
Balochistan 😃
Nagaland and AP :D
despang lake among others are anyways done ;)
Same is the case with Nagaland, Khalistan and Kashmir. Let's hope division not occurs any more.🙂
@@abulkalamasif1270
Kashmir banega Pakistan, yehi churan khila rahe hai 1947 se atlast Pakistan bankrupt ho gaya. 😂😂😂
@@abhijeetpatole4856 Politicians ki game ha janab! awaam ko pagal bnaya jata ha.
Bastard Bhutto was the Nawaz Sharif of those times and General Yahya was the Asim Munir/Bajwa of those times.
No genocide was done, only terrorists of mukti bahini were targeted, soon inshallah we will be united again and those who collided with endia will be punished, and endians will surrender this time.❤
Gandu porki still traumatized from last surrender😂
Stop daydreaming..... It will just give you torment
and it's India not endia 🙂