How the radical Left turned America's cities into “slums” | Michael Shellenberger interview
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 01. 2022
- San Francisco is situated at the heart of America’s tech boom. Yet according to this week’s guest, much of the city looks like a slum. Homelessness is rampant. Drug use is soaring and violent crime continues to rise. To find out what is happening to America’s most progressive cities Steven Edgintin is joined by the environmentalist and best-selling author Michael Shellenberger.
Subscribe to The Telegraph on CZcams ► bit.ly/3idrdLH
Get the latest headlines: www.telegraph.co.uk/
Telegraph.co.uk and / telegraphtv are websites of The Telegraph, the UK's best-selling quality daily newspaper providing news and analysis on UK and world events, business, sport, lifestyle and culture.
I’ve lived in San Francisco for thirty seven years, I raised a daughter here. Thank God she left in 2007 for college. I’m an old man now - seventy five - . This city is a surrealistic nightmare . All my friends have left this dump in past two years. There’s no laws ! I’m stuck. The stress is overwhelming …
That's just being 75 anywhere.
Start your own political party.
I lived there for 10 years, the 80's, then I moved to the East Bay for another 15 years. Raised two daughters. I left California in 2005 and never regretted it.
Move closer to where your daughter is....
Move !
As a dual citizen, I’ve enjoyed living in California for three long periods of my life. There’s a phenomenon that blights the welfare of homeless down on Skid Row. It’s called Poverty Pimping. LA County allocates $2Billion on the homeless but little of this money reaches them. Corruption is rife. Charities don’t wish to solve the problem because without the homeless their coffers dry up.
Dual citizen of what?
There is a video called invisible people one could watch if someone is interested in hearing from the actual people living in the encampments instead of an intellectual pontificating on what the see and read
It’s pretty depressing. Dr Drew volunteered to come in(for NO charge) and help out local committees on how to better fight drug addiction .. they rejected his offer as they don’t want to fix the problem
Saw a video of the issues in L.A. Venice Beach in particular...they raised millions to help the homeless. The people responsible and holding the funds...bought a $750,000 place near the beach to " study" the issues. After permits, lawyers fees, etc,,,had no money left for the homeless issues.
Precisely! And neither the host or the guest put forward the idea of 'Following the Money' to put names and faces to who's profiting from this crisis.
The fact that people are flocking out NYC, San Francisco, Seattle and Portland really demonstrate how little the elected officials have done to make the population feel safe and thriving. The last 4 years have given criminals more rights than the victims of crime. It’s absolutely insane!
Guess what? Still very expensive to live in those places. Nobody flocking to Omaha.
I visited LA in 2018 and I was shocked by the amount of tents and crazy people wondering around everywhere. I've never seen so many marquee cars, Rolls Royce, Lamborghini, Ferraris etc, but never seen so many homeless people either.
It is the epitome of American capitalism.
@@mdaniels6311 no it's the epitome of American wokeism.. California is as left as it gets buddy..
(wAndering around ...wOndering what to do today)
I worked out of LA in the Aughties, and things were already getting bad. I went back around 2018, and it was like something out of Escape From LA.
@syddog44 that is the beauty of the far leftist politics of L.A.; this is what they want, extreme rich (the party and those afiliated with it) and the poor. Also, look who has politically controlled the city for the past 30 years or so, not just the mayor but city council people, courts, etc. It is overwhelming far leftists from the dem party
In Finland, they built a huge shelter and eliminated homelessness. But those who use it must rehabilitate, and take the low level job being offered to them at the end of their stay.
It's really sad that in San Fran and LA, the leaders see this problem and they just don't care. I love California, but it's a literal warzone.
Here they’d say that was cruel and akin to indentured servitude or the more popular buzzword of low wage “slavery.” Similar to how they constantly want to model the free higher Ed system in European countries but don’t realize it won’t work while they simultaneously try and eliminate all forms of meritocracy. They’d just turn colleges into the chaos that is the public school system.
population of homelessness in the USA is larger than most cities or towns in Finland.. completely different reality..+ 176,000 illegal migrants enter the USA PER MONTH !...
@@pgroove163 It's intentional. The political class leftists, who are living in the lap of luxury, are using such people to politically target their opposition for irrelevancy.
@@pgroove163 those immigrants work though....lol...at least they provide some kind of service....during the lockdowns when many people were staying at home with their feet up....those illegals in agriculture, meatpacking, slaughterhouses...they kind of played the role of the shadow economy...no stimulus checks for them.
I lived in California for 56yrs.
I left in Jan of 2018.
In California I was borderline homeless
In Texas I’m rich.
There is a lot of foreign money in California and they can buy nearly whatever they like. They don't care about who lived there in the past. I was shocked at how many Asian people own properties in Pacific Heights and Sea Cliff in San Francisco. The hippy Haight Ashbury in SF descended into chaos pretty fast, and it surprises me that it has taken 50 years for the rest of San Francisco to go the same way.
@@FindAReason-mi7go China has basically colonized most of Africa and California and the Amazon/Brazil and everyone just pretends like it isn't happening. Why the people so obsessed with colonization turn a blind eye to this is evil.
I work at a non-profit organization with recovering drug addicts, and I've heard many times that they couldn't quit until the judge told them they could either go to rehab or jail.
That is called "the jumping off point." I also deal with recovering addicts and alcoholics and know that well!
Most of them relapse even with the threat. No one can get better until they WANT to get better. That's true no matter what your affliction is. Though hopefully the threat of jail helps them finally see that they've reached rock bottom.
i've been saying this for years. people act like homelessness is about joblessness. it's not. people whom we see on the streets are not just down on their luck; they are addicts or mentally ill. they have alienated themselves from every connection or relationship because of serious issues. putting them in a shelter or giving them some money won't fix the problem. they need serious treatment
Agreed but who was it who cut the money for mental health? It wasn't the "radical Left". This guy is practicing lazy thinking. Sure the "woke" left are a bunch of idiots but so are the right wing.
@@ironhammer4095 absolutely.
Exactly!
Nailed it
Many of them are criminals too.
I’ve been to San Francisco many times and have watched its decline over the years. I don’t plan to return as a result of what it has become.
@Rob Wood It used to be a great place, as was all of California, but not anymore.
Frisco was always liberal but it WAS clean and the cops DID their job.
@@Incornsyucopia it was a beautiful place in the past but now too many bums, homeless drug addicts with mental illness.
I used to live in the tenderloin in mid 80s..was bad back then.😱
@@robzilla730 the corrupt DAs are the issue instead of the cops
Someone who performs heinous crimes gets set free but someone who speaks vocally on any of the social media platforms gets chastised or imprisoned
They installed DAs to let people go wild
Yeah, so true.😢
Same everywhere, US, UK, EU, Sweden...
Most of the time, anyone who provides concrete evidence of how Democrats and liberals are destroying American society just gets censored by social media. We ALL know it's the truth, though.
and/or shadow banned
Every presentation I've seen from Shellenberger is thoughtful, articulate, logical and well reasoned. He's a true intellectual.
This was a very well conducted interview. Nice to see a media company doing a proper job, for a change.
Lived in SF for 33 years but retired to another state in 2013...Went back a few years ago and was shocked how the city was now unsafe...told "don't park your car in the city it will get broken into" saw a guy in an alley deficating and shocked! Thanks for this article.
People have been craping on SF since 1997 when I whitnesed it, it was on the sidewalk in daylight.
I was shocked also, after returning for a visit, Most of the Citizens in denial. Lived in all the West Coast Cities for years.
Democrats should not be allowed to leave! They need to live in the utopia they created!
> saw a guy in an alley deficating
Defecating.
This guy has an agenda and is pushing his own misinformation as well. I personally visited LA San Francisco and NYC for months this year. I barely saw any homeless or literally no crime. Of course there is crime just as always. The internet and videos just make us see more of it. The coronavirus part is probably true I didn’t get a vaccine. But we have to question this guy as well he is making money to push these narratives. As for climate change narratives I think is a good thing it’s free to live off of energy from the sun and makes our air healthier. Hence Elon Musk trying to push electric cars and solar panels.
A friend was telling me that due to the criminal element, not many are using mass transit to get into NY city. The vehicle traffic has caused traffic jambs and the criminals are now going up to cars stuck in traffic and robbing them at gun point, but the honest citizen can not legally possess a gun in NY city. Never give up your guns, never give up your rights.
Just had an incident here in Maryland that reaffirmed my thoughts about gun control. Woman had a protective order against a man and moved from FL to MD. Yesterday morning the man found her home, I believe entered against her wishes and a struggle ensued. She gained the upper hand with her fire arm and killed him. She's not facing any charges whatsoever and gets to live to tell her story.
@@Chalk89 so pleased to hear that wokeness did not lead to her being arrested in favour of the perpetrators ‘rights’ 👏🏽
DITTO SAN FRANCISCO
This has been happening in Brazil since President Lula took weapons away from citizens, even though the majority of citizens do not agree with the disarmament made by plebiscite.
Nyc has become 😖.
I fled N. California because it became unbearable. Ironically, this guy Michael Schellenberger is the son of two of the best Psychology professors. I attended their classes and worked for them at the biofeedback lab. He comes from an amazing family. I would love to see him grow in popularity and share his advice on family matters.
Why? This guy is ridiculous and speaks complete gibberish.
We have abandoned religion and science for psychology. But it is seems incapable of giving us the answers we need.
@@johnschuh8616 Well, that is not really true; psycology is useful for mentally ill persons, whether through drugs or schizo or other problems, like poor diet, alchoholism etc.
What is lacking is discipline, both of the individual and of the authorities !
@John psychology is a useful tool with many flaws, just like science (or rather, the way humans apply it) has flaws. All of these elements can be beneficial if we are mindful
If I was in California, I’d be giving him a chance. Public services like psychiatry are important, but family & community are probably the reasons religion was significant help to people. I heard, “the opposite of addiction is connection.” Looking after my own brother who is mentally ill. I think this is true.
London Breed, the mayor of San Francisco, has instituted a law allowing thefts from stores of up to $950 without punishment. I used to visit the Legion of Honor art museum, but now the parking lots have "Smash and Grab" warning signs. A friend had her car broken into three times.
The mayor of San Francisco London breed is a Marxist
It's completely insane. When I tell people that crime is literally legal out there, they simply cannot believe it. Then these same dumbass politicians like Newsom, Pelosi and Maxine claim that crime is actually down! See? We let everybody steal and take whatever they want, break into your cars in broad daylight ON CAMERA and loot stores right in front of the cops and security, then claim there's nothing wrong! Since nobody gets arrested, there's no crime! What a bunch of saps.
The term “Regressive” would better describe the character of the community leaders.
I'd go further. Their ideals border on primative.
@@simonbagel maybe we'll luck out with a primitive zone (not autonomous) it is aggressive progressive u'd have to know dem history to see how its democratic. hope things get better.
The depravity in the governing leaders pushing bad leftist policies is causing these Democratic Party run cities downfall! Democrats are the makers for terrible leaders!
Batshit crazy is a better term
I said the same, "Regressives".
As a native San Franciscan my heart breaks whenever I drive down nearly any street. There are vagrants and drug addicts in even some of the more affluent neighborhoods. The average citizen lives in fear of a vicious and mean-spirited backlash from the “progressive” far left, many of whom wouldn’t go near either a homeless encampment or even a black neighborhood. They are a real toxic presence in the City.
What would that backlash look like?
@@DrBarnes1 Vicious verbal abuse, name calling, acting out, ridicule, mockery. Does that answer your question?
Sticks and stones.
No disrespect and not to be mean but People are going to have to learn to stand up for themselves.
The alternative, when things eventually get much worse and out of control, being verbally berated and called names is going to be the least of everybody's concerns.
Those miscreants only attack in packs and are full of nothing sht and hot air. They are all talk, start banding together and fighting back.@@maryannerazzo1737
Maybe time for citizen patrols or maybe even vi gi lantes. I mean, if the city/ D.A won't let the cops do their job then what??
@@DrBarnes1 it varies, from outright hostility and threats to…social shaming. I witness it often, when I push back.
Same story in New Zealand. 10 years ago shootings in Auckland were almost unheard of. After a few years of a soft 'kind' approach to gangs and crime we now have almost daily shootings and ram raids.
….do not feel so bad, this is my city, I feel like crying every time I see it and worse since BIDEN, way worse, and we even are a BLUE town but vote Republican a decent percent considering…. 8 years of OBAMA pounding on the first American city of Philly, the city of brotherly LOVE and this is the end result... SAD, FIX IT! ...yet we still get this: czcams.com/video/zqLTsXD2cHs/video.html
Update: the police minister was just removed from the role due to the explosion in violent crime. Looks like their diversity hire didn't work out.
I believe people nowadays are suffering from total collapse of morale… the drug use, homelessness, crime, gangs… it all roots from life devoid of any purpose or meaning.
We have anomie and nihilism.
People need spiritually and/or a sense of purpose, goals, beneficial things to aim for. The society is sick psychologically
Open drug scenes vs. homeless camps a much better description as to what's going on. Our mindset is so sloppy now, we're generally OK with this.
False dilemma
Thing the establishment relies on as they select the worst candidates.
Except it isn't an open air market, there is a large difference
@@SA-5247 what is this "trash free culture" your referencing lol, wonder bread and 1950s jello molds??
All by design, this current crop of politicians, for the last 30-50 yrs serve a globalist master, and not their voters
I miss when SF was a city with a caring community. I’ve lived in New York and San Francisco and left both cities. It’s not safe in either city. I’ve moved on and don’t even go visit either cities.
same.
Look at who has controlled both cities politically for the past 30 years or so ...
Did he really call Soros a philanthropist with a straight face!?😂
He actually worked for Soros and now has finally realized the fruits of his labour.
Having his signature on your paycheck has that effect unfortunately lol
He technically is. Problem is what he funds destroys American cities
Im already 3 mins in and i thought these 2 people were AI generated for how they moved. Like wtf. Dudes head on the left is on point ai movement
Essentially this guy is reaping what he sowed. He still, however refuses to accept that the changes he worked for failed and led to today’s situation. His work against policing and incarceration is directly responsible, but he refuses to acknowledge that.
Yeah, MS has a long-term BS problem. Even when he has stuff right, he seems to get it wrong.
Bring back mental institutions many homeless people are mentally ill.
Yes, I'm 75 years old and I remember when we used to have mental health hospitals that dealt with all the different types of mental illnesses from the depressed up to the criminally insane. There may have been some abuse in the treatments back then, like shock therapy, but psychology and psychiatry have come a long way in the past 70 years. 🤗
@@janealan2142Only if those who NEED the structure and literal controlled environment receive that care. It's been thrown away.
Mentally ill.....usually because of their drug addiction.....just facts.
As are many politicians.
2 nd gen LA here . Born and raised in Hollywood . What the Democrats have done and how they did it is unforgivable . Our city officials are in the pockets of the drug cartels . They cry climate change when they can’t even keep their own Cities clean .
@Phil Silverman One Democrat I blame though is Clinton for starting those wars and sending so many to fight those wars who got killed, maimed or returned with PTSD. He was also a neo-liberal and cut welfare.
Left wing, Right wing, same bird.
All politicians are puppets of the international banking cabal.
democrat politicians are tyrants and their followers are complete morons.
These fires 🔥 👌 are not available for free 😢 homeless people need to pay for sidewalk space, tax the tents also.
@@AskRemy Absolute truth.
I like how he consistently refers to San Francisco as "San Fransicko." Haha!
Because he is an ableist
@@cherylrichard3059 why not San Franhysterical
Which is in commiefornia
@@davemartino5997 ,says Captain Right-Wing.
@@iche9373 says ignorant demtard muppet
San Diego is the only place pushing back on this stuff, not allowing tents for to long, not enabling drugs abusers, etc
That’s not true at all. They are everywhere.
I left San Francisco in 2006. I knew all this was coming. I pointed out to my progressive friends that the 'tolerant' left is the least tolerant group I have ever encountered. They ignored me and still do. No one wants to hear this part....it's mostly women who were the most intolerant. They lead the arguments since the 60s and they lead it now. Progressive men in California just fall in line with these women because they want to sleep with them or are married to them.
The "far left" (here in N. Cali) are probably also 80% plus "Cluster B personality" people (including some of my relatives) so it's no wonder that S0r0s and the likes of Joey's choice for "VP" (quite clearly a "narc," herself) along with Willie Brown to Gavi Nuisance, etc. have been SO "successful" in turning cities like SFO into open air cesspools, by intentionally overrunning them with illegal immigration, heavy taxation, drugs and unchecked criminality... after stealing (s)elections and taking kickbacks from funders such as the various mobs, cartels and the CCP... Too bad (for them!) China is about to 'implode' under the weight of their own "corruption," and "reality" will soon catch- up with these criminal politicians, as well as their puppetmasters. Indeed, this state was already a "lost cause..." decades ago! (I've returned, then left, several times...)
Absolutely. Listening to women destroys everything 99 times out of a hundred. Hear them out, and then do what is required. And take the hit.
@John Smith At first I moved to Arizona but now I live in Istanbul. When I visit the bay area now I can't stand it. In the 90s it was like a little paradise. Now it's embarrassing. A lot of my friends left for the Sacramento area though. I feel the poison will spread up there too. It's Happening to Phoenix and of course Portland already.
I Know the type, I've said hello to a few passing buy them..they wont make eye contact & walk on by as U weren't there.
The progressives are anything but progressive, and I speak from experience. I'm a libertarian,and I've explained this to my former leftist friends. But they did not ignore me, this is what they would do, typical leftist fashion. They would condescend to me and gaslight me,and then they denounce me and slander me.
Drug addicts are "trapped" within the cities where they easily feed their addictions. This is huge, because it creates "pipelines" that link cities, like Houston to St. Louis, New York to Minneapolis, etc. Each enclave is a "service center" which supplies an enormous radius of smaller cities and towns. A pattern similar to slime mold.
Simple, dismantle the drug networks, from farm (or lab) to the street -- all of it, production, transportation, financial institutions, wholesalers, corrupt functionaries, street level dealers, all of it. Now, with all this money being spent on a 'drug war', why hasn't this been done? Lol
At times leaders had programs to give homeless or addict a couple hundred dollars and a bus ticket out of their state.
Sanctuary Cities
They still do that. My City in Tennessee gets homeless from other places because we provide housing and services. Build it and they will come.
@@user-ex7qx4pv2u , yeah, but why is the drug trafficking and addiction problems so much worse in some places? It has to be different policy in the different places.
Inevitable result of a cavalier social attitude towards drugs.
They got it half right, "let's not put them in jail, instead offer trearment." Well they did the first half, but most of these people don't want treatment. It needs to be forced.
@POOKIE Yup, the wing nut drug war was incredibly effective.
Your assessment is the inevitable result of horrendously bad critical thinking.
No. It’s a voting blue problems
@@highroller-jq3ix It's true that the "drug war" was a money making operation and didn't have enough nuance to navigate the problem,
BUT, that doesn't diminish the fact that drug use has massive negative societal costs and huge personal costs for millions of people. I
Compassion is one thing. However being too tolerant leads to Enabling bad behavior.
Here in Canada we are experiencing all these problems in Toronto and especially Vancouver. All of the reasons this guy talks about apply to our situation as well. I live in Toronto and I started seeing homeless encampments in the city parks in 2020. (I honestly don't recall seeing encampments before 2020, but that's just my experience) It's getting worse all the time. The homeless are getting more aggressive, more entitled and more belligerent and there's way more of them then before. We're not as bad as San Francisco, but man oh man are we heading there. I'm planning on moving back to the country soon. I know where this is going.
That's a shame we went on holiday for 2 weeks in 2012 in Toronto and loved it...ld be afraid to go to Canada now as well as any country...can't even trust my own now...shameful these countries use to thrive on tourists can't imagine what's coming across the borders now l know what's coming here and that's down right scary
That's definitely the case in Vancouver. What's really alarming in the frequency of random violent attacks taking place all over the city - not just in the bad hoods such as the Downtown East Side. We're seeing a few of these each day now. Along with worse violence resulting in murders. And what to the leftist elites do? Deny anything is happening and give themselves fat raises while patting themselves on the back all the while.
A majority of the homeless encampments in 2020 sprung up from homeless shelters limiting entries into their facilities to accommodate the COVID19 mandates of social distancing. Those have mostly been removed now.
The Telegraph is Right Biased based on story selection that strongly favors the right and Mixed for factual reporting due to poor sourcing of information and some failed fact checks. It is owned by British oligarchic twin brothers, Barclay brothers. They are similar to American Oligarchs the Forbes family.
Do we really want the 1% of the world to do our thinking for us??? They have one goal in mind. To maintain their power and money they need to brainwash the masses to keep the system going they put in effect in supposed democratic systems.
WE CANNOT HAVE A DEMOCRACY AND BE RULED BY THE 1% AT THE SAME TIME. It is as simple as that.
"The Red State Murder Problem": The six states with the highest per-capita murder rates all voted for President Trump in 2020 - as did 8 of the top 10. In Trump states, the rate was 8.20 murders per 100,000 residents. In Biden states, the rate was 5.78 murders per 100,000 residents. While the murder rate has gone up in Chicago and Detroit and Philadelphia, all run by Democrats, the murder rate has likewise gone up in Tulsa and Oklahoma City, Oklahoma; in Fort Worth, Texas; in Fresno, California; and in Miami, Florida. Every one of those cities is run by a Republican mayor and overseen by a Republican governor.
Jacksonville, Florida, is known as the "murder capital" of the Sunshine State - and has had a Republican mayor for the past six years. Fort Worth survived its most violent year in the past quarter century in 2020, with a murder rate that nearly doubled from the previous year. Betsy Price has been the city's Republican mayor for the past 10 years.
I, a lifelong Dem. have lived here for 82 years and this city is no longer recognizable.
My home is on the western slope of the city where I live, fairly securely, surrounded by my law abiding Asian neighbors, but for how long ? I no longer go downtown and being an elderly frail woman do not feel safe. I now believe that one party governance is not healthy. There has been no watchdog party in opposition for many decades. The Democratic Party of SF projects itself as compassionate, but an exaggeration of compassion in any sphere of life (eg parental) is dangerous and profoundly unwise. I see little hope for this city.
Jesus mercy Mary help !!!🙏🏻❤️🙏🏻
I had to stop this interview several times to absorb the awesomness.
Wow...this guy has the facts and common sense. My hero.
One party rule in california has resulted in progressive hell.
Oh please as if republican states like west Virginia Louisiana are any better
@@adamlynch6954 I work in West Virginia, some places are actually nice
@@adamlynch6954 yes actually. Alot better. Especially since the leaders there don't have free reign to do whatever they want.
@@alastor8091 that's laughable... I'll take Malibu, Newport beach over west Virginia any day
Pelosi and puppet Biden imported voters as voters from border immigrants. Biden pelosi harvested voters from border immigrants all at USA taxpayers citizens millions of dollars in expense as they issued stimulus checks from Dominion.
It appears in funding the immigrants and transporting around USA they infect pelosi devastation thru out the country
Also registering to vote??????
I am trying to find out more from congress
Do know pelosi and puppet biden are a disaster.
A fantastic insightful & well thought out interview that ought to be mandatory listening by all "progressives".
LEFT RIGHT LIBERAL CONSERVATIVE.MSM TALKING POINTS THAT DIVIDE.AMERICANS CANT FIGURE THIS OUT.TOO STUPID.
The Telegraph is Right Biased based on story selection that strongly favors the right and Mixed for factual reporting due to poor sourcing of information and some failed fact checks. It is owned by British oligarchic twin brothers, Barclay brothers. They are similar to American Oligarchs the Forbes family.
Do we really want the 1% of the world to do our thinking for us??? They have one goal in mind. To maintain their power and money they need to brainwash the masses to keep the system going they put in effect in supposed democratic systems.
WE CANNOT HAVE A DEMOCRACY AND BE RULED BY THE 1% AT THE SAME TIME. It is as simple as that.
Except that this video is simple garbage published by the Reich Wing, and Trump supporters eat it all up because they are so simple-minded and cannot think for themselves sadly.
I think they should switch their name to regressives really
This guy knew his subject. It's depressing how bad we are at doing things. I wonder where we are going as a species.
We've saved the lives and culture of our grandchildren. I once lived and thrived in a safe, working class big city neighborhood. Those spaces do not exist anymore.
I always struggle with how anyone can look at what is happening in liberal cities and think that continuing with those policies will improve things. And this is not a recent phenomenon. Look at the once great cities of Philadelphia, Baltimore, Detroit. The liberal/progressive policies instituted in the 1960s and 1970s absolutely decimated those cities.
TBH I think that today these people are just out for themselves. What may have started decades ago as a legitimate effort to make this country a more hospitable place for everyone is now completely corrupted by completely self absorbed individuals. They don't seem to be in denial as much as they simply don't care how these outcomes impact the citizens. Leftist follow the Left. People on the Right aren't remarkably different in that at times they will blindly support lousy policy as well. The division is probably our biggest problem moving forward...it's entirely replaced common sense.
Jmho
the drug stupor they are used to! In the days gone by, they would have been banished from society to their demise. Perhaps the liberals should step up and take responsibility for one of these individuals. Obviously, things are not going to change if society keep coddling these people and their problems!!
@@hippiebits2071 basically right the group figting is like all that matters anymore
Republicans stand for nothing except cutting social programs to give Kim Kardashian another tax cut. There is no better alternative than the status quo. (Except a Bernie Sanders/New Deal/class-based leftism, which both parties work together hand-in-glove to erase from American politics.)
They can’t be reasoned with so we can’t vote our way out. They will destroy us if we don’t find a final solution.
What I can’t understand is why the people who claim to be compassionate continue doubling-down on the policies that created so much destruction and suffering.
They can't admit they are wrong. It's like belonging to a cult.
@@mysticaltyger2009 That's actually a great analogy-----I have a friend who is for all these insane policies-------- he can't see the forest for the trees!!
Loyalty to the woke cult over-rides everything. The only acceptable response to failure is to double-down on the failed policy.
Let me guess... they´re left wing.
@@mysticaltyger2009 -- Collective narcissism.
I love going dancing in LA and hollywood, have been doing it for over 15 years. the last 5 years have been getting progressively scarier traveling to certain clubs and leaving late at night. Entire streets get blocked off by homeless. I'm from a central american country and it's never been that bad in some of the bad areas! I make sure to avoid those areas but it's still a telling situation in one of America's main cities. It's insane. I feel bad for them but the help is not there for them. It's terrible.
Fantastic interview. I left CA in 1996… It was so clean and beautiful, and could afford living there… NOT ANY MORE… 😢😢😢
People are leaving New York city and the mayor is buying the vacant properties
who is the mayor? - maybe a bit dopey to buy now, why not wait for the crash. btw these people always talk about mental health, drugs, police; but the subject of real estate is never mentioned, in conjunction with these 'home' less.
Lol , typical 🤣 drop the price of real estate and buy it .....
@@skymagenta8758 yes.....
That's the plan
Drive out the owners ND reap the profits
✡Blackrock✡ is buying the real estate. They're buying up the entire US.
In San Francisco a group of Christian businessmen are locked in legal battle with the city hall there. They wish to build modest homes for the homeless but refuse to pay the bribes.
Please elaborate.
That's not the fault of progressives as Shellenberger falsely claims, but of the neo-liberals (and the real estate industry) who actually run the city and the state. Shellenberger misses the point entirely. He's just trying to cash in on the "own the libs" cash cow narrative like Haidt and McWhorter--or else he's genuinely stupid.
@@publiusovidius7386 , Agreed and exactly what's happening here in New Orleans. Gentrification has created a huge problem with the real industry industry, and the natives.
@@publiusovidius7386 so progressives didnt do it they just support it and promote it. Yeah we know.
@@publiusovidius7386 It is though because progressives vote blue no matter who, they are ruining CA to own the reps lol literally cutting off their own nose to spite their face and the mental gymnastics to revert back to the cringe that is advocating for a reactionary ideology that has died out long ago in communism/socialism is truly awe inspiring.
I'm a SF 49er (born there in 1949), was at SF State during the "strike," but rode the PC boom in the late 70s and early 80s. I had had enough in 1998 and emigrated, first to Nevada for a dozen years, and now to Texas for a dozen more. Despite my great-grandfather settling there during the gold mining days, driving a stagecoach, being held up by Black Bart, and running a thriving dairy operation in what is now miles of sagebrush following the drought of 1929, .... despite all that history, I will never go back.
I was in SF a couple of years ago and it took less than a day to get mugged. And then my car was broken into. The cops were overwhelmed and hamstrung. All I could do is report it to my insurance. I was raised in extremely poor area of America called the Mississippi Delta and I've not seen such horrible conditions there that I saw in modern SF. It's a hellscape. I am so sad how destroyed that city is and hope the rich elite progressive better-than-yous get reincarnated as a poor person in the same city they helped ruin.
I hope they get reincarnation in Wheeling West Virginia. From Wheeling.
LOL I'll take things that didn't happen for $400, alex. My wife and I spent a lovely time in the city recently, yes San Francisco and it was fine. This comment is typical Reich Wing drivel.
This guys voice is super important!!
Glad he is getting lots of press👍
Even in Beverly Hills the sidewalks are filthy.
your so pretty
⬆Pretty vacant
@@jamesbong7852 let’s compare vacant GPAs and IQs.
Nice! They are getting what they asked for.
@@melaniehoyt7607 He calls himself Mr Bong. I'm pretty sure his IQ is entirely Bong ( and hopefully only Marijuana ) related.
I live in Oklahoma and it’s a red state and the drug used here is out of control.
Crime, poverty, and infant mortality are probably up too, and GDP per capita not so great.
Singapore doesn't have an illegal drug. What they have is capital punishment. Consequently their country is safe, civil and stable with a flourishing economy.
Exactly
All thanks to his former boss Soros. I am Amazed that Americans are so indifferent and keep voting for the same party election after election. I guess they deserve what they voted for.
that is the problem in CA, that it is effectively a 1 party state. There is no dialectic. CA has engineered an electoral system that will keep the current power structure preserved in amber for a long time.
@@cliffc2546 demographics
California governors are Republican as often as they are Democrat.
It's a one party state and anyone who tries to present a different point of view or solutions are threatened with bodily harm and property destruction by a vigilante political movement.
He literally referred to soros as a philanthropist.. That's a nice way of saying he dumps billions into groups and policies that destroy and rot these cities.
This man went from woke to awake to reality , very well spoken to the reality of things in our society.
I'm glad someone who speaks thier language can talk to them. Radical left people need to hear what thier ideas are doing to human beings stuck under thier policies.
The vid is nonsense. Normal people are driven out of cities by housing costs. It's happening all over the world in the wealthy countries.
I'd like to know how many years he was funded by Soros to remove the legislation the penalized drug use. He pretty much set in motion the exact thing that is now plaguing every large American metro.
The Telegraph is Right Biased based on story selection that strongly favors the right and Mixed for factual reporting due to poor sourcing of information and some failed fact checks. It is owned by British oligarchic twin brothers, Barclay brothers. They are similar to American Oligarchs the Forbes family.
Do we really want the 1% of the world to do our thinking for us??? They have one goal in mind. To maintain their power and money they need to brainwash the masses to keep the system going they put in effect in supposed democratic systems.
WE CANNOT HAVE A DEMOCRACY AND BE RULED BY THE 1% AT THE SAME TIME. It is as simple as that.
According to 2019 FBI data, seven out of ten states with the highest per-capita rates of violent crime voted Republican in the 2020 election. In contrast, seven out of ten states with the lowest rates voted Democrat. However, the District of Columbia had the highest rate despite voting blue.
The FBI cautions against using any one demographic marker to draw conclusions about the causes of crime, which they describe as manifold, complex and often “not readily measurable.” Cited variables include:
Population density and transience.
Poverty.
Education levels.
Racial and ethnic makeup.
Family cohesiveness.
Strength of law enforcement.
Youth concentration.
Climate.
I lived in Novato in the late 70’s and would go across the Golden Gate to spend the day hiking the city. Up and down the steep streets and all around fisherman’s wharf, down to the Cliff House.
The shops where welcoming, people where friendly. I’ll never forget when the movie “The eyes of Laura Mars’ came out, Its posters all over the city - in every windows and on all the streets.
"Addiction"? That implies that these people are victims and have no agency over themselves. They choose to take drugs, they choose to smash car windows, they choose the commit violent crimes against law abiding people.
Some didn’t “ choose” to get hooked on opioids that doctors said it was safe . Not speaking for all these fools in SF but addiction in general .
@@davemartino5997 It's always a choice. There is no such thing as "addiction".
The Republican Party in Texas and other free states must organize welcoming committees to warn newcomers from California not to vote for the same types of politicians who turned the main cities in their home state into the sewers that they felt they had to flee.
Charitable Republicans 😂😂😂
@@jamesbong7852 .?
Oh yeah because there aren't any homeless, drug and violence problems in Houston and Dallas..
@@foro6102 Much much less than San Francisco. Plus San Francisco had nowhere near as many homeless and druggies until recently.
Texas is garbage.
This is happening in Chicago too. Dirtier streets, filthier public transportation, blatantly smoking cigarettes and passing alcohol on the trains, tents everywhere - not to mention all of the robberies and shootings. It’s gotten noticeably worse since Covid.
Tell it to your neoliberal system since Reagan
@@iche9373 not even since Reagan wtf? Since the democrats have actively destroyed the black community, and just overall leftist policies that create more chaos than actually helping people. Government corruption and leftist ideas are apparent for why this is happening.
@@solaireofastora8609 The whole federal system is neoliberal where there is no social state like Sweden.
@@iche9373Go away tool
Wrong, blame it BLM
John, Roland Fryer would make a compelling long-form interview.
Why do "Progressive Policies" often reflect ignoring reality or consequences?
The US did have a state mental health hospital network until the 1980s when the ACLU closed most of the facilities with no plan in place for what to do with the patients. The system then simply dropped them off in the cities many of which had a practice of giving them a free bus ticket to California.
I wonder who was governor at that time 🤔
Yep, so true
In the 80s it was Ronald Reagan who cut the funding for the mental health services and hospitals, many people were just turned out on the streets.
@@sharonkeller8367 because the ACLU and the media riled up everyone and they put pressure on Raegan to do so. They played on everyone’s heart strings and made it seem like every person in a mental institution was being abused. They also lied and said that the mentally ill would receive treatment outside of the institutions. That didn’t quite happen
Britain did the same during the same era, Thatcher in the 1980s. They call it care in the community.
Moderates and Conservatives have left California because they’ve given up and don’t want any part of craziness there.
Wow, so there are no moderates or conservatives in California anymore, propaganda eater?
That describes me pretty well.
Two of my favorite people on social and political devastation plaguing us in the civilized world. Great ques, great insight. We must regain order in this frightening and disordered world. Bravo! 🎉
Shellenberger is the voice of our blip in time. He is an introspective mirror of rationality. God bless him. I pray people will start to soften on their dystopia and come around to seeing things past their ideologically imposed beliefs they have been blinded by.
One party state. California voters get what they deserve.
@RED PILL PORTAL they voted for the morons in charge.
Oh like voting republican would accomplish anything... They have no agenda for these issues
That is precisely why I left
Michael Shellenberger speaks TRUTH from a caring and compassionate and knowledgeable place! I think many of us would like to help out in our neighborhoods and cities - but don’t know where to begin! I think many of us can feel better knowing we are not alone in this major problem! It’s also nice to hear someone hopeful again!
Two years out on April 2024 and it's worse than ever. So sad.
Really fascinating interview.
I have spoken to dozens of the homeless in Tulsa, out of pure curiosity. They, almost all, are willing to admit that their lifestyle is a choice. The lack of pressure on them was the, nearly, unanimous motivation to choose such a lifestyle.
I saw a homeless guy yesterday, (at least he had a sign saying he was homeless) who asked me for money. And, I'm looking at his brand new tennis shoes, his spotless pants and jacket, and thinking one, this guy is wearing nicer stuff then me, and two, he doesn't look like is missing out much in life from being homeless.
@@ralphholiman7401 not that anyone believes many desirable trappings of our culture are easilly accessable from being homeless and jobless
Theres an underground movement in Tokyo of people who just drop out of all the rat race pressures and exhaustion that comes from just trying to survive.
@@sgtpppr , money for accessories, phones, drugs, alcohol, just no money for housing.
Liar.
It is incorrect to label these left-wing policies as "libertarian." Libertarianism is not libertinism. It demands not just personal liberty, but full personal responsibility for the consequences of one's choices.
Aren't Libertarians also for small government?
@@azmike3572 Libertarians are for small government. Leftists/liberals are for large governments so they can affect their agendas through coercion
Exactly! 👍🏾 I’m a new subscriber to the “a frickin american” channel, and yes, libertarianism - which I began to embrace more than 20 years ago - is very different from libertinism.
If it was libertarianism that means an honest citizen can go clean up the ACT in the street and just go start mowing down and cleaning up the mess there's a janky harassing people blown away so this isn't libertarianism if it is it means we could have wild west Justice and that would clean up the mess
The drug policy that the West Coast states have implemented is very similar to what Libertarians have advocated for. Libertarians just want to go even further by making it legal to manufacture and sell.
Shellenberger has lots of moderate solutions to California problems, but he came in 4th in the 2022 election for Governor of CA. California is just fine with the status quo, as it gives everyone plenty of opportunities to virtue signal how much they care about this issue without actually having to do anything at all.
Compassion without wisdom is madness…
I remember being in India in 2004.
When the concrete jungle of Seattle came up around 2010 it reminded me of being back there.
Now I'm not sure I even left.
I also just haven't warned everyone that, Texas isn't even New York or Chicago Illinois.
While Indian streets are quite chaotic and dirty, things have gotten much better since 2004. Seems like San Francisco is progressing in the reverse direction.
Broken society from top to bottom. No wonder these people have given up and want to forget.
@D Legionnaire a few slaps makes your day, eh.
Just as long as it's not the Liberals fault. I think this whole thing misses the point.
I can't believe Michael Schellenberger still calls himself a liberal after all these years of ineffective policies. Perhaps it's how he lives with his past foolishness. At least he is a truth teller and reports honestly on this tricky problem. His term "so-called homeless" is very honest.
Who are "these people"?
Yep the way we run our society today is not sustainable. Money and greed will destroy humans
Trust me I was an addict but now I'm not. I was a liberal but now I'm not. Poverty is Poverty.
This is going on in republican cities and states as well. It's forsaking the mentally damaged, bad parenting, drugs and alcohol.
Many homeless people in San Francisco have severe schizophrenia while the de facto U.S. public health policy is to leave them to their own devices which amounts to homelessness.
Lack of social programmes and free health when needed. Makes the USA virtually
a 3rd world country.
When a country has trillion dollar penal & arms industries, that's a failed country right there.
Why don't the municipalities having the problems deal with them? What's the hold up? Why is it strictly a federal problem? The voters in the municipalities either do not GAF or maybe they're waiting on Uncle Stupid to come up with a plan that will make the problem worse, as he always does.
@@jamesbong7852 Source? Hey, put down that Bong!
@@marycarver1542 no, they need to be put out to pasture when they kill ppl but it’s “inhumane.”
The people who really love the city, will stay and fight for what's right. God Bless the people who voted out the school board members. A step in the right direction. 😃
A very, very small step.
Exactly those who love their city will stay and I had a chance to move to Las Vegas but I didn't because I have goals in my city of San Jose California
@@Oscarphone as they all start
Nothing to fight for anymore. Libs are destroying everything.
@@mfrass830 the fight is not over☝️☝️never say anything like that
Most of these homeless get $600 a month!! CALIFORNIA encouraging homelessness!! IN FRIGGEN INSANE!!
Michael Shellenberger is doing a great job of explaining his position ... And he does make a lot of sense ...
Sad case. I spent time in San Francisco in 1984 and Seattle 1985-1988. Perfectly decent large cities then. Some panhandling,especially in Seattle, but not awful bad. I think the USA is in serious trouble. This problem is a symptom of serious disease in the body politic. I moved to northern Great Plains and have a wonderful life.
Nature will take it’s course,eventually.
It's been a war of subterfuge.. a new opium war in reverse.. this time China flooding the U.S.
The Chinese are making fentanyl and lacing other drugs with it. It's very addictive and dangerous.
This is a drug war.
Your diagnosis is accurate. The rot and decay is deep-seated and inculturated. The progressivism pushed and promoted in urban areas, have turned them into social incubators for leftist agendas. There's a reason why these cities present a stark contrast to what they once were before the late 60s to what they are today. But yes, the overreaching culture has a lot to do with it.
Only the cities run by Democrats have these issues. Nothing new, just bigger in scale.
The West is in trouble due to the overshoot of resources, mainly of oil. The entire economy is based on the concept of growth. Global growth is over since Saudi Arabia's oil reached its pic between 2006-2008. Fracking gave the US some time but not quite near the real needs. The end of cheap energy means the end of the middle class type of economy. Of course the plutocracy knows that since Meadows report and prepared itself to deal with the unrest. Among what they did was promoting idiocracy, woke culture and race issues. Along with strategies to digitally monitor everyone with their consent.
I'm a little older but I remember when San Francisco was a beautiful city. It's a shame to see it now. 😕
"The Red State Murder Problem": The six states with the highest per-capita murder rates all voted for President Trump in 2020 - as did 8 of the top 10. In Trump states, the rate was 8.20 murders per 100,000 residents. In Biden states, the rate was 5.78 murders per 100,000 residents. While the murder rate has gone up in Chicago and Detroit and Philadelphia, all run by Democrats, the murder rate has likewise gone up in Tulsa and Oklahoma City, Oklahoma; in Fort Worth, Texas; in Fresno, California; and in Miami, Florida. Every one of those cities is run by a Republican mayor and overseen by a Republican governor.
Jacksonville, Florida, is known as the "murder capital" of the Sunshine State - and has had a Republican mayor for the past six years. Fort Worth survived its most violent year in the past quarter century in 2020, with a murder rate that nearly doubled from the previous year. Betsy Price has been the city's Republican mayor for the past 10 years.
It was something else, the most beautiful city in America.
I visited San Francisco in the nineties.
Fantastic place to go. And I liked the people.
It had its drug problems and crime, like many other cities.
But what a shame now. The people in charge don't seem to care.
Eventually our entire country will look like SF, Detroit, Chicago, etc. if we don’t stop this
I believe that fact 100% it's all going to hell if we don't stop it
Yup……moved out of Portland because of this.
Wise choice, its beyond redemption. Now. please don't vote for brown, kotek, read, or other cogs in the machine that created the problem
Same. PDX got *dramatically* worse just from 2017-2020...
Of all the voices examining the progressive troubles in San Francisco and beyond, Shellenberger most accurately gathers, properly analyzes, and makes the most sensible conclusions from all the data available. His voice should be the loudest and most listened to by those with a desire to solve these problems.
+BucknerSanFrancisco Actually, his invocation of this "radical left" boogieman undercuts the whole presentation and just makes it feel like more partisan propaganizing.
@@highroller-jq3ix Yeah, I can see the point of view with this interview. This is probably the 10th interview I've watched with him and can say his focus on who to blame for the problems (which he calls the "radical left" at first but really is "Progressives") in this video probably has more to do with the primary vote a few weeks ago for Governor. Other videos I have seen are more solution-focused which is the most important. I've lived at Turk and Hyde for the last 6-7 years which means I see firsthand the depth and nature of these problems as well as somewhat successful and plenty of failed plans to address them. He really nails cause, effect, and best-chance solutions based on my experiences.
@@highroller-jq3ix Well yes. He's pointing the finger at those who created the problem.
We've seen 60 years of "drugs are cool" advertisement from the radical left especially from SF and LA. It's not a coincidence that those end up becoming giant drug slums half a century later.
That being said, the right is also to blame. Right wingers want social cohesion + economic individualism. The left wants social individualism + economic cohesion. What we got is individualism + individualism which leads to misery.
The problem is, the powers that be don't want to solve these problems. In fact, they helped to create them....and many are profiting from this awful situation.
@@highroller-jq3ix Doesn't the message go down easier when it's a former Lefty proposing these solutions? He's got the right CV. Maybe Progressives are really just regressive.
Canada is experiencing the same problems, and they have government healthcare......
Worked on ''harm reduction"... under GEORGE SOROS (the "great philanthropist")..LOL😂😂😂🤣🤣😂
That worked out well. 🤔🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
Great interview! He's right that we not only need police but community support in ending crime and all the other horrible conditions.
I have seen how small towns go down with crime and neglect. The CA one I am in was very safe and no locking doors at all in 80s and 90s. I lived in 40 yrs . I watched it happen . Now we got a few knifings near my area ..
Of the 10+ friends I know who have left California over the last 5 years (including myself) ALL are either politically conservative or Libertarian, none of these people are progressives or Democrats. So some states are going to have a net gain of educated law abiding small government business owners and tax payers.
Good
Any society will sink to the lowest level of behavior it is willing to accept in any part of it.
Depressingly intriguing.
Opioids is a huge problem. Addicts conglomerate in big cities because it’s allowed and accepted. So get used to tent cities within a city as long as they are subsidized. It’s very sad, but can be stopped.
Yeah, but not by listening to this guy
@@lilmoe4364 Then listen to who? Opiods have long term effects.
Been watching this happen over the last number of years with disbelief. Nice to see it getting some honest mainstream coverage
So glad to live in a blue State without the crazy right-wing policies
@@kbanghart enjoy your paradise on earth
@@xjmmjbnqfstjdijoj2044 Amen
I like Shellenberger, but please don't blame this on a libertarian milleua. This is a woke socialist issue. Libertarians would require consequences for actions (that includes for the politicians creating these environments). The woke district attorneys and political leaders are the ones constructing this tragedy of the commons where public venues are turned into their woke public toilets. I live in Denver where this is accelerating to the same levels as in Seattle, LA and SF. I remember being in Seattle 25 years ago and it was beautiful. I went there recently and the amount of homeless tents, trash and graffiti everywhere damaging this naturally beautiful city is a crime. I was touring downtown LA a few years ago near Little Tokyo. I drove down the wrong street and straight into Skid Row. I was shocked and I'm not shocked by much. Block after block of the worst human misery I've even seen... a modern Bedlam of hoarding, defecation and drug abuse. If politicians don't take action (and soon) there will likely be a public backlash and it won't be pretty.
Politicians drag race into it and it hurts black Americans so much. And they can't allow conservatives to help out.
We desperately need someone like this to come up with a viable plan to clean up Seattle. This area is going into to dumpster as well.
No, not someone like this. This guy is a partisan hack
No thanks. People need to put their foot down and stop this nonsense.
It's impossible to understand how the citizens accept what their eyes tell them and reconcile that with their 'progressive' views. Can't they see the system failing?
Somebody is flirtin' with getting canceled!!
There used to be many asylums for the mentally ill, where they were cared for, and trained to one day live on their own. We need to bring them back.
I live in a part of Canada where two large psychiatric hospitals were closed (By a left NDP government). The patients weren't cured, most were just set loose with a hearty handshake and a "good luck, don't forget to take your meds!" from the government. Mayhem ensued and continues, 20+ years later.
In 1963 Community Mental Health Act pushed responsibility for mental patients from the federal system to the states and decentralized community centers. Of course, never adequately funded. 1965 The U.S. Congress established Medicaid and Medicare. Mentally disabled people living in the community were eligible for benefits but those in psychiatric hospitals were excluded. By encouraging patients to be discharged, state legislators could shift the cost of care for mentally ill patients to the federal government. In California in 1967 Governor Reagan signed the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act that ended the practice of institutionalizing patients against their will, or for indefinite amounts of time.
Reagan, with all of conservative wisdon (piching pennies on the populace to enrich the fascists) got rid of the saylums, and made those folks the responsibility of the POLi-ce. Its why we handle the mentally ill like inmates
So true. My cousin who was a vet and mentally ill was turned down by the Palo Alto vet hospital because he wasn't "psychotic"...he died at Market street & 3rd two months later.
In the US they were closed during the Reagan administration. The growth of homeless started during his run but exploded during covid.