One of the GREATEST Mathematicians that ever lived - Srinivasa Ramanujan
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 07. 2024
- Download Cambly and start practising English in 1-on-1 classes with native speakers
bit.ly/3yAKfav
Use the code 22SID to get 22% off
This is the story of the greatest mathematician ever and how he did everything without a formal degree.
One-time donation:
UPI: scienceisdope@icici
buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope
Community:
CZcams Membership: / @scienceisdope
Patreon: / scienceisdope_
Discord: / discord
#Ramanujan
#Mathematician
#God
Sources:
Ramanujan’s letter
writings.stephenwolfram.com/2...
Chapters:
00:00 - Intro
01:12 - Early life and religious influences
03:45 - Life in Madras
04:47 - Correspondence with Hardy
09:33 - An Unlikely Partnership
10:44 - Ramanujan's Contributions to Math
14:06 - Did God give Ramanujan his mathematical ability?
Patrons that support me at the highest tiers:
rahul raman
Abhilash
Nate Hand
Prabhakar Bhat
Dev Agrawal
Jeevan
Prince Rachit
Sushanth
Kashmira wagh
Kiran CJ
Prachet Verma
sashipraveen kalli
Suds Mekathotti
tariq sharif
Akshay Gupta
Thinking Humanist
Dheeraj
Wrichik Basu
Sumana Gopinath
Music Credits:
A Fool's Theme - Brian Bolger
Never Surrender - Anno Domini Beats
El Secreto - Yung logos
Warm Water - Underbelly
Contrast - Anno Domini Beats
The Itch (Instrumental) - NEFFEX
Smokey eye - Cheel
Follow me on social media:
Instagram: / scienceisdope_
Twitter: / scienceisdope_
CZcams: / scienceisdope
Reddit: / scienceisdope
Download Cambly and start practising English in 1-on-1 classes with native speakers
bit.ly/3yAKfav
Use the code 22SID to get 22% off
Three things are learnt and 2 are established by this video
1. Ramanujan was a genius his work on elliptic integrals, hypergeometric series, the functional equations of the zeta function, and his own theory of divergent series proves he is one of the greatest.
2. You don't know anything about religion can be established by the way you talked about it.
3. You hold a certain grudge against sanatan established by more than 90% of your videos are criticizing those practices or the people who support those practices. The most ironic thing is that your researching capability on those topics decrease and you portray how those practices are the worst possible things to ever exist on this planet.
@Stardust Meant To Shine his speciality is criticizing hindu culture and religion at every opportunity he can get.
Amazing video man one humble request to you if you can also make a video on various religion missionaries who are trying to brainwash people to move from one religion to another thinking that it can solve their problems I have seen many of my friend's families go through the similar process and later on they keep boasting about it and keep spreading false knowledge that any of these religions can make their problems go away.
@@vibharshp2194 regarding your 3rd point
He's most likely targeting topics of pseudoscience or myths claimed that are most famous in India.
If you look closely all the people who were shown are quite famous so he's indeed targetting people or topics are really famous (as you can clearly see the Zakir Naik one if you'd begun to claim about being selective )
Also are you perhaps saying that the people he exposed were saying legit things based on research and if yes why shouldn't I assume you to be one of their community members who's here just for criticising stuff? If you've arguments to present present after you answer to mine
Have a good day/night ❣️
iemann had aldready found the best approximation for prime numbers till now .The problem is that it is a hypothesis or a conjecture without proof famously called the riemanns hypothesis .having said that the mathematician you are talking about did not prove his prime number formula(or for that matterany of his formulas) the riemanns hypothesis is more or less accepted as true and modern super computers have tested it and not found a contradiction yet though it may be found in the future .riemanns formula works correctly for all computable numbers so i belive you need to correct your statements hardy considered him a genuis because some of his results matched that of euler's and jacobi and not for his resultsregarding primes even though initially he found it interesting later he judged him by works initially done by euler and considered him to be equal to euler
According to wikipedia, he had already learned the mathematics of two local colleges when he was 11, for reference, Einstein was learning algebra at that age.
Boy, it must be killing you to know that Ramanujan mentioned that he got all his maths from Devi herself. 😂😂
Hahahahaha 😂 definitely
Hindu Brahmans be really getting butthurt by this video lmao
@@yash1756 Brahmins? Lmao people of lower castes are now more hardcore hindus than bamans 😂😂😂😂
@@llj500 I think brother lives on Mars.
@@yash1756 naah i live in jammu
Ramanujan is the perfect example that religion doesn't need to be against religion. Religion is a tool/philosophy, it depends on who use it
@lakshya varshney huh???????
@lakshya varshney seems like you're really young so I am not gonna pursue this argument would recommend u to watch more educational videos about how we solve daily problems through science as it looks like ur perspective on science is very limited
There is only one way to use religion. That is by not using your brain.
@@alanjohn2675 science itself bound in limitations 😂
@@manmeetsingh1712 sati & caste were society cultures, don't call sati a religious culture, practice of which began not before the invaders, to prevent themselves frm cruelties faced which were more thn death.
I really don't know anything about Abrahamic faiths but I've been researching Indian/dharmic faiths for a while now and I'm astonished to realize how aligned ancient Indians were with research, maths, science, medicine, law, and philosophy.
the world often talks about the Greeks and the Romans being the pioneers of many great things but the Indians are always left behind. we really must open our eyes to the greatest and one of the oldest civilizations on this planet!
True 🔥🔥
Ghanta brahmanism is developed in 8 and 9th century 😁😁😁😁
Ghanta
@@Thephilosopher319 Islam is the oldest
@Knight Awakened listen, sweetheart, their is absolutely no need to demean any country, religion, or culture without knowing it like the back of your hand, if you do not know the ground reality of India, I'd suggest you not talk about it. millions have gained wisdom from Dharmic religions and continue to do so. yoga, the number zero, Ayurveda, and many more things were invented by Hindus. don't bother replying to me as I have no interest in arguing with an ignorant person.
Ramanujan : mujhe Devi maa ne maths sikhaya
Random CZcamsr to Ramanujan: Bhai main youtuber hoon , main zyada jaanta hoon ya tum
Haha 😂😂
Appeal to authority.
Fr bro 😂😂😂
Newton also said that his knowledge came from Jesus/God himself. We all know Newton's wayy greater than Ramanujan. So would you believe in Jesus just because Netwon said it? I'll personally come to see your conversion to Christianity
@@zz2793 convert to Christianity? 😂😂
Why bro ,?
,,did Ramanujan ask anyone to convert to Hinduism?
Atheists ki yahi problem hai har chiz me chutiyapaa karna zaroori hai
Can't we just respect their beliefs ?
Ramanujan expressed gratitude towards namagiri devi just like carl sagan use the word Universe
False! he said my godess bleeds equations in my sleep, not the same, It was his devotion to the form of devi namagiri. His devotion made his emotions and focus one pointed.
@@AS-tm7eq Namagiri devi was a part of his collective unconscious. An archetype of his psyche
@@Indianpsychonaut Who put that archetype there?
@@AS-tm7eq and how do u know that r u any more intelligent than he was?? he experienced god
hence he stated existence of god
He was able to channelise and communicate with higher form of intelligence while he was in his REM sleep.may be
You didn't get difference between ramanujan and other mathematician credit for god. Ramanujan said he get all formula in dreams and written down in morning. It means his mind was such an extraordinary that he started getting answer of every difficult problem.
That’s called motivation which people get from faith doesn’t mean he’s saying it literally
Ramanujan was communicating with Demonic Intities.
He was genius there are only few such people. Like nikola
However brilliant you are u cannot get formulas in dreams without knowing the proof or context. There is a 0 probability for it unless what he said was true about namagiri telling him it
@@AhSjdv Just because there is no proof doesn’t mean it’s not real🤷🤦🤦
India gave birth to brilliant, and wonderful people like him... U will be forever cherished.
There was no India before 1947. He was born in Mysore Kingdom.
@@sgn9754 if there was no india before 1947 where did East 'India' Company come from?
@@technicalist101 East India is a region in Asia. East Indies. East India company was formed to trade with them.
@@sgn9754 India named was coined by Greeks which the Brits brought to India in the 17th century. Prior to that ancient foreign travellers mentioned the Indian Subcontinent land as a United nation only by various names.
Primary Indian texts mentions the concept of refering to this land as "Bharatvarsha " or "Aryavarta " . Their boders are well-defined.
The Manu Smriti (2.22) gives the name to "the tract between the Himalaya and the Vindhya ranges, from the eastern to the western sea.
The Vasistha Dharma Sutra I.8-9 and 12-13 locates Aryavarta to the east of the disappearance of the Sarasvati in the desert, to the west of Kalakavana, to the north of the mountains of Pariyatra and Vindhya and to the south of the Himalaya.
Similarly in the Mahabharat, where whole of Aryavarta was captured by Emperor Bharat of the historical Bharata dynasty that land is also named as Bharatvarsha.
So as per your reply, India didn't exist as "India" for the Indians it's true for we have our own local name.
@@Arjun-pi2iq None of the terms you described describes a nation state. India exists as a nation state and not as a Geography. The OP should then be claiming that he was born in South Asia. Mahabharata is a story book and is not in any way part of history. Greeks called the region between Persia and Himalayas as India. Ramanujam was not born there.
If ramanujan says it was devi,then what’s wrong with you it was his belief and I respect his belief,we shoul just admire him and appreciate his love for maths
True
Well it was his faith, and that faith is used by others to claim the existence of God. That is the only problem. No one is insulting Ramanujan for having that faith, but just because Ramanujan was a prodigy in Mathematics does not mean that he can be correct about everything
@@MonkeyDLuffy4885 can u prove that god exists or doesn't exist. What is consciousness?? .
This is the power of beliefs which this channels breaks in process of being rational
I am a rational and I hate it
@@technoviper4939 The criteria for existence of anything in this universe is "the evidence supporting it". For example, earlier existence of gravitational waves was purely theoretical and mathematical, and it was backed by logic but even then there were no practical evidence of it.
It has only been recently that modern scientific setups have confirmed its existence. Hence, even something (in this gravitational waves) whose existence could be backed up with enough mathematics, cannot be accepted without evidence in Science.
Hence, definitely I cannot prove you that God exists because there are no evidences to support it's existence except some anecdotes which are purely subjective in nature.
Moreover, experiments are performed to testify the existence of something not otherwise. Because if that was the case, then I could simply ask you to prove that "prove me that there is no ghost standing beside you" which is purely absurd.
When i asked my guru why do we dedicate our work and achievements to God?
She said because that helps us in making sure that we don't develop ego (general type ego, not the psychological explanation one)
An it is important to not develop ego, because ego can blind even the best of best minds
My guru teaches me that religion is meant for betterment of humankind, to help them live better, not particularly for some supernatural being.
The best I have ever heard. Your guru is the truest guru. May I know more about guru and your learnings and experiences ji???
Nice self created story but messed up at end lines
@@A_randomguy.care to explain why messed up towards end?
Being an aithiest he can't digest the fact what Ramanujan said about Devi. Tell you how Seudo secular people work🤡🤡
Yes bro he's doing all these bs to earn his bread by using Famous people names who has large followers that's it he is a 🤡
Science can only go such far!
Feeling sorry for you! 😅
True, Ramanujan is a pure RAW GENIUS 🤩🤩👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
The video quality has gone up several notches. Amazing Pranav!
Awesome video!! You are very talented and skilled in explaining complicated topics in simplest and the most understandable ways. I would like a video on the application of Srinivasa Ramanujan FRS' formulas, especially Partitioning, in various other scientific fields (like black holes, genetic engineering etc). Love your videos :)
He only chooses to prove hinduism wrong i dont think he can clearly explain ramanujam formulas and how they are being applied. I bet him !
@@manojrenikunta2301 Yeah, but he's talented and is very capable! He explained clinical trials very well and he is capable of offering a lot more when he focuses more on science communication, Idk why one needs to bother dissing the idea that he was a devotee. I also feel Pranav is more biased towards proving religion wrong. In the Gaurav Taneja video a commenter had stated scientific studies from peer reviewed journals (like medical ones) that proved Gaurav Taneja's point was valid, but that comment got deleted in a few days, I checked out those studies, they are pretty good
Great video. Thanks for it.
Michio Kaku wonders in one of his books had Ramanujan received formal education he would have leapt far ahead in mathematics. He spent a lot of time deriving and proving what has already been done. Even with that the originality in his work is astounding.
I think that would have helped him in creating a sharp intuitive thinking.. a formal education might have hampered its development..
it is our misfortune that he died in such an young age.
It is our fault as an Indians who could not provide favourable environment.
Also, in these current times we Indians are making same mistake again. Not providing favourable research environment for students. Not improving the education system.
@@shrin210it was British rule
I always wanted this to be discussed anywhere . Good Video. Thank you sir.
Editing is dope! 😍
Good to see you are getting ad offers!!! Keep up more videos like this
Believing that someone said something out of belief is also unscientific 😅....may be someone said something out of an experience which was beyond the mind.
Good Work Man.....The last section where you logically explained his statement on God was really good....And that tag team edit of Ramanujan and Hardy too 😂😂
That tag team name is "The Revival".
@@noelchristian8373 now known as “The FTR”.
Jake itli kha
Recently Binge Watching your videos, They are logical and Interesting. Keep it up Man!!!
The History of scientific progress is more interesting than itself.
I agree
You meant than "science* itself" ?
Hard disagree, maybe almost as interesting as science.
@lakshya varshney don't take it in a negative note ... I'm unable to understand what you are trying to say 😅.. can you explain futher with some examples. Please 🙏
@Cratonic I agree
The quality of video and presentation is just getting better and better 🔥🔥
Liberandu got butthurted by ramanujan giving credit to hindu goddess😂☕
Absolutely
Thank you so much man for making this video .. you are dope 🔥
Nice animations.Keep up the good work
Appeal to authority. Your videos are getting addictive ❤️
Ramanujan was never been accepted by his people after his return from Cambridge.. just for the say of "Brahmins should not cross the sea" his death was very tragic but none of his family members showed up for the funeral.
And now they're claming him and trying to swollow him just because he was a thiest.. a great forgotten man..💗 he's always in our hearts and will be forever..
Oh I should have included this little detail
Don't you just love sncient Indian Vedic yogic traditions?
Ramanujan was never been accepted by his people after his return from Cambridge.. just for the say of "Brahmins should not cross the sea" his death was very tragic but none of his family members showed up for the funeral. --- can u provide the source of this info ?
Source?
@@vibhutisrivastava2789 - Source? The same Devi came to his dreams. The same Devi who visited Ramanuja, she visited OP. The Devi is his source as well.
The Devi wants Ramanujan to get justice.
A much needed video
Insightful video . Happy to see you're getting ad offers !! 👏👏👏
No religion existed in india it has always been a land of seekers. When shiva got enlighted 1000 questions were asked by parvati. Shiv sutra is answers to those questions. When krishna stepped foot on earth arjuna had 1000s of questions. Bhagavad gita answered it. Its always been a land of seekers.
All you said are part of Hinduism only don’t seperate ohr things from our culture to make it universal period.
Exactly
The man who knew infinity ♾️ 🔥💪
Again, the story telling was on point. The animations made it magical
This story is old and was all in our childhood books and every educated indian takes pride in his diligent practices, commitment and his down to earth nature and respect for his godessess. We really dont need people like pranav who have achieved nothing in life to judge who is Ramanujam and what his real intentions are. A true indian will know what ramanujam meant and what he has gone through. Its just that new generation converted mindset will never understand the true meaning and pride we take when he mentioned his supernatural experience. Its just fate of india and its culture that some people like pranav always throw filth on! after being brain washed
@@manojrenikunta2301 that's right, pranav tried hard to give all the credit to hardy behind the success of ramanujan, and pranav's small children becoming happy from this fantasy , 😂,
Ramanujan, and like him so many great mathematician born in India , but #uck the britishers system , who made the law that after getting a degree u will be considered as a genius ,
In India from thousands years a person doesn't need degree or certificate to be a genius, !!! Proud on my country!
Ramanujan was great, I crazed about sum of infinite numbers by Ramanujan that was taught to me by my maths teacher.
Infinite Editing and Research. Science is Dope!
Dope vid!!
I would highly recommend the movie THE MAN WHO KNEW INFINITY if you wanna know more about Ramanujan's life and his work
That movie is based on Western view. Read THE MAN AND THE MATHEMATICIAN written by Ramanujan's friend to get an Indian perspective and understand him better.
@@rishabhkhatri what's the difference?
As well as The Imitation Game......
@@relaxationhub2512 The perspective
@@rishabhkhatri Maths is not based on perspectives or nationalism.
This channel is very addictive. Thanks for making this type of content . Love your work ❤️
Thank you! Love to hear that!
@@scienceisdope Awesome video!! You are very talented and skilled in explaining complicated topics in simplest and the most understandable ways. I would like a video on the application of Srinivasa Ramanujan FRS' formulas, especially Partitioning, in various other scientific fields (like black holes, genetic engineering etc). Love your videos :)
@@technicalist101 ya he can explain every formula and he can write proofs as well. I wish he joins NASA team to figure out that the world is ANANTHAM ( never ending) which is stated in hindu Sanskrit scriptures that too
in very very fundamental basic mantras about lord vishnu the creator of universe. He is proud of hindus and their ancient achievements. Great job @Science Is Dope
@@scienceisdope i don't agree with you in a lot of things
@@santanukumaradhikari4852 Acharya Prashant ( IIT ,IIM alumni , ex civil servant ) has already started debunking pseudo scientific claims of mainstream religious preachers like Sadhguru and others . He is the only man in India working tirelessly for last 8 years to revive Non theistic/atheistic school of Advaita Vedanta and Sankhya that was lost with the prominence of theistic mainstream schools...I hope Indians get their own Indic Atheistic/Agnostic Astika philosophies like Advaita Vedanta , Sankhya . Charvaka Podcast is helping Indianized dharmik atheists. People who are trying to import Marxist-Dawkinian abrahamized proselytizing atheistic influence in India will find it difficult soon.This land has always been land of Self Introspection and doubt , No one in the ancient past was penalized for being critical about religious dogmas. So trying to replicate the Dawkin's westernized neo atheism will be difficult.
Great fricking video bro!!
Really love your channel man. Thank you for trying to reduce the misinformation on the internet and the world
The fact that you go beyond debunking pseudoscience investing so much time and money in making such cool content is mad impressive
While isro's scientists reading Hindu scriptures and taking inspiration and reached moon and this guy reading science and Hindu texts to prove it wrong (not really) . This guy thinks that he know everything and declare himself a pseudo science police though not getting much attention he stated membership and patreon to take money from them and feed his suscribers what they want.
Irrationality ke naam par atheism promote kar rha hai
Aapna suscribers ka kaat rha hai
Great! See you in Bangalore tomorrow. 👍😊
The production quality is dope bro!
Man when you showed Alan Turning, I just got sad remembering his tragedy🥲
It is just a testament how much religion holds back science. Imagine if his mother never had that testament or delusion. We would never have known Ramanujan as he is today.
Did you watch the vid it was said that the same religious 'delusion' gave his mother the confidence to send her son abroad.
Religion does hold back science to an extent. But it wasn't needed to be commented on this vid or for ramanujan's story! Cuz it doesn't relate here
Its funny, a "delusion" gave her the confidence and not her own son's abilities and qualifications.
@@1_RITIK_1 It absolutely does, read my original comment. What if his mother never had such premonition and never let him go abroad ? And what about after ramanujan came back to india. He was ostracized by society because he travelled the seas and that was forbidden in his culture. Now that he's known as a famous mathematician, everyone would like to claim that he was from their society and how lucky people were to be with him.
@@MegaNerevar it could be argued that ramanujan going to Cambridge is what shortened his life. Ramanujan wasn't welcomed with open arms in Cambridge. He faced a lot of backlash and racism because of his methods and origins.
He did not have access to his comfort food or environment, often working in unhealthy conditions.
What if he never visited Cambridge? Sure he would not have been able to contribute so much to humans, but atleast he would have led a long fulfilling life. Him visiting Cambridge did us good, not ramanujan
Ramanujan said he would, in his dreams, be visited by a Goddess and SHOWN mathematical truths that he would then remember and write down. Personally, given his genius, I'm inclined to believe him.
Math/science and religion/spirituality can be compatible, and I think Ramanujan is a great example, since he obviously reached the peak of math and yet was a very sincere and strong believer.
satan and who else. it is a well known tactic of satan, it seems he, ramanujan, opened the door of mysticism, without much brain got lost in illusion.
the people aquatinted by mysticism know by mediation and other such arts one can see illusion and even satan can show you these kind of things.
thats exactly why prophet Muhammad was accused of it but quran tells them he never trained nor did he ever gave to mysticism.
m
Amazing video 👍
He is ONE of the greatest mathematician who ever lived, of course, but not the greatest. I mean look at the works of Euler, Riemann, Hilbert, von Neumann, Grothendieck and the likes. Ramanujan was a prodigy, no doubt, and he gave world some of the greatest mathematics we have seen. Calling him greatest is disservice to the contribution of other great mathematicians. There are other mathematicians who literally discovered numerous fields of mathematics (Euler discovered Graph Theory, Topology etc). Nothing against Ramanujan, hell I would be glad if I can be as much talented as tiny fraction of Ramanujan.
By the way, great video. Liked the presentation. I didn't find discussion of his religious background necessary for the video but anyway his pure vegetarianism is also a reason for deterioration of his health when he was in London. You are doing a great job.
It depends on who is calling him greatest. When every mathematician in the world has acknowledged his surreal way of instantly coming up with formulas and start math class with lecture about him certainly proves his uniqueness and greatness. You dont need to call him great or compare with others. The world just speaks the truth :). The fact that you and i know EULER means that he is also famous and his contributions are definitely considered. Only people who are jealous and too religious will compare them with others mathematicians and try to set levels of greatness which is not required :) peace
Isherayek zaffer 😂😂 a Muslim saying these things, i got it 🤣
@@manojrenikunta2301 No one is denying his greatness or uniqueness. But calling him the greatest is wrong. And I am neither jealous nor religious. I know the contribution of Ramanujan and other mathematicians and that's why I am saying it. Honestly, even if you had graduate level knowledge of mathematics you would know the difference between the contributions of Ramanujan and let's say Hilbert. Instead, it is you who is being too much attached to Ramanujan's religion and nationality. Tell me honestly, if I had said same thing about non Indian mathematician would you have replied a such? At least go Google about the mathematicians I mentioned. Or search for the few list. See, Ramanujan is one of the greatest and almost no one denies this in mathematical community. He could come up with equations and identities out of thin air, and almost all of those were correct. Few of his claims wrong. Imagine writing something out of nowhere and most certainly it being correct. Every mathematician would dream of such intuition. But his contributions were confined primarily to number theory. I am yet repeating, he is one of the greatest. Now look at the contribution of Gauss and magnitude of his revolutionary ideas. I will not even talk about the contributions of Euler or Hilbert. When you are at that also read about Galois and his contributions.
So next time before jumping to the conclusion kindly at least read what someone is refering to. It is easy to label someone jealous etc but harder to understand why you yourself are being biased. Because you yourself know you wouldn't be defending Ramanujan if he hadn't Indian. On the contrary, I would defend every mathematician for his contributions be it anyone.
@@maths_nerd you dont have to explicitly state that he is not greatest. Thats why i said it depends on who call him greatest and in which context. He might be greatest in india, he might greatest for someone who doesnt know others etc.. but if i come across some other video and names i will not go on denying saying “your mathematician is not greatest and is just ONE of great mathematicians” . Okay for the sake of this argument how will you measure someone’s contributions and which one will you award greatest ? Depends on what criteria you take ? I am not biased at all me being Indian have heard about him and saw in school books but did not know nothing about him until recently. I dont compare nor ignore contributions of other great mathematicians like you mentioned i will definitely google euler and hilbert or any great achievements in history. From a hindu and spiritual perspective everything is fascinating. For example i read about someone who invented lead based fuel and how it caused numerous deaths it is rare we belittle someone. :) peace. but i respect your view
@@maths_nerd also i am not defending ramanujan and what is there to defend ? I just was asking what is the needed to measure someone greatness and ask other to stop
calling someone greatest:) but u made your position clear and positive
Nice work Pranav. I was waiting for you to cover Ramanujan. Really appreciate your efforts. I would have liked more if you added the applications of Hardy-Ramanujan theorem in various fields. (Even though Mr. Hardy would be aghast knowing that his maths is getting applied today).
This video editing is dope
When u compare dharmic view with Abrahamic cults..
"Science is Dope" is dope!!
Excellent analysis.
Your way of video making is wonderful.
You explained it quite well. Our upbringing also has a impact on what we conclude out of miraculous or intuitive thought process.
Love your content . Please making such videos.
Amazing content!✨✨✨
P.S. The fallacy is Argument from authority fallacy
this channel needs to grow
I see people talking in the comments saying that the devi was part of his imagination. He believed her to be true , so she must be true . He was an intelligent man and a rational thinker . What your problem with his ideology. Why can't you accept it. Just leave it at that . This channel is totally irrational. It does not use real debates to debunk myths .
I am a religious guy and believe in god . If you don't want to believe it's your choice , but criticising our god's is wrong . People post video's on CZcams trying to debunk . Let's see them face Sri Adi Shankara in a debate .
Jai shree Ram
Har Har Mahadev .
Won't partitions of 3 also include the case 1+1+1 ? Then p(3) would be 3?
Congrats on 100k
yes u r so right sir u know everything even u r smarter than the greatest mathematician in the world and u knw how they dont about themselves but u knw this such a great video..........and you find every possible way to degenrate or insult our culture great sir hats of to u
Just an opinion: I recently watched some of your videos on exposing some gurus and religious mythology.I think (or atleast I hope so) your viewers are mostly those people who themselves study science or are interested in it. So, I think they already know it and you don't need to "expose" anything because those who doesn't believe in science will not understand and it's their choice. It's matter of their faith. I expect something more from you ,I want our indian "science" youtubers to actually be like foreign science youtubers like veritasium, alpha phoenix, minute physics etc. because it would really help those people who study science as well as to general audience to develop a scientific temperament .I want you to "expose" the ambiguities in science itself because many ambiguities arise from understanding a single concept from different perspectives like recently veritasium made a video on electricity which I really liked because that was something I really want to get discussed on a large scale. I want you to actually explain what science is and wat it can do because it will directly help general audience (who are interested) to not be completely dependent on "GOD" . Then only people would realise that religion is just a matter of faith and it's good if it motivates you, it's good if you think someone is there watching your struggle when no one is with you, it actually keeps humans away from negative thoughts and if it really doesn't help you , it's also fine. I know you are also not against religion, but still I don't think these videos would really help general audience in realising who really "GOD" or "NATURE" is because most of them think of it as a person.
I think you miss the point of this channel. This is more of a pseudoscience expose channel than a science channel. I think he has another channel where he does stuff like you mentioned
I've seen a lot of people discredit Ramanujan as not one of the absolute greatest minds of history because some of his well known work has been proven wrong. But I disagree with that approach. Being wrong doesn't mean being bad. Just the fact that he was able to think all of this stuff up in his mind without any prior education and the fact that STILL TO THIS DAY we haven't deciphered everything he's discovered so long ago proves the fact that he IS one of the greatest, no matter if even his most well known theory is disproved.
Pranav runs after proving hindus wrong and their respect pride and belief in god wrong. He hates sadhguru, he hates indian astrology, he hates temples, he hates navagrahas, he hates aryabatta and indian ancients, he hates praveen mohan youtube channel for being fascinated about how temples are built , finally his only MOTIVE is to prove anything indian wrong . Pranav is truly a legend who knows everything about this universe with modern science in his pocket. He does not work on creating new inventions he only works on proving someone wrong for no real significant oroblem
@@manojrenikunta2301 I do Critize him for not making Any videos (except Zakir Naik one) on other religion's logical fallacies too,In last video he said he would come up with them,But No videos on it yet ,he made some logical arguments and Me confused About My faith,So I would like To hear him more about Logical fallacies,But not only upon my Religion
@@NoMatterWhat279 he is just ignorant. We dont need to prove others religion wrong. We just need to correct someone like pranav who are confused to the peaks and doing these videos with confused motive or just as an act of revenge. Not sure what he faced or preached by invaders or intruders
Which of his work has been proven wrong if you may mention
@@manojrenikunta2301 pranav is a half knowledge guy he don't have any complete knowledge i guess no one given him a Job and he doing vdeios on you tube to prove himself that he has a complete knowledge but by making vdeios he himself tells he is a half knowledge guy a mad person always argue with the people that he is not mad pranav also Same type of guy 🤣🤣😂😂 and now people started beleiveing a half knowledge guy 🤣🤣😂 and also after uploading Pranav works even on comments to comment on his own vdeio with different accounts and some Paytm batch 😂😂😂🤣🤣
My favourite channel so far ❤️
Awesome video as always….. waiting for a video on Alan Turing and Jhon Nash please…..
Imagine the narrow mindness of the people of that time who stopped him from going to Cambridge
Yes when Ramanujan was telling it was because of Devi namgiri but now suddenly an unqualified YT know more about Ramanujan. you are just blind believer of science..If it was 100 years back you were fighting with others on plants having life
Pranav with regards to the question you asked, is it the fallacy of 'appealing to ignorance'? (although I am kind of not sure) ... i am trying to decide on this fallacy with regards to the previous videos you had made on these types of fallacies.... pls do correct in case I am wrong
when i 1st came to knew about him in detail i was stunned and always wish he and nikola and few other (cant remember now) would have right recourse or cure our gen would have been on another level
Best CZcams channel in India
To promoting scientific temperament, logical, rational,cratical, thinking mostly based on facts, theory ,hypothesis,or modal of scientific personality above all promoting basic common sense... Science is Dope...
12:05 Shouldn't p(3) be equal to 3. You missed counting (1,1,1) as one of the partitions.
Right, was looking for this comment.
Your videos quality is increasing day by day ,! .
Haha nice !
Your best video
"His eyes rose
to his third eye
while solving
a problem.
The genius and capabilities of Ramanujan were such that they could not be due to mental powers, because the intellect moves very slowly, thinking takes time, but Ramanujan didn’t take any time in responding to Hardy’s questions. No sooner was the problem written down on the blackboard or put to him verbally than Ramanujan began to reply, without any time gap for thinking. It was very difficult for great mathematicians to understand how it happened. A problem which would take about six hours for an eminent mathematician to solve - and then too he was not sure about being right - Ramanujan solved instantaneously, unerringly.
It proved that Ramanujan was not replying through the medium of the mind. He was not very learned, he had actually failed in matriculation; there was no other sign of intellectual ability, but in connection with mathematics he was superhuman. Something happened that was beyond the human mind. He died when he was thirty-six because of tuberculosis.
When he was in the hospital, Hardy, along with two or three other mathematician friends, went to see him. As it happened, he parked his car in such a place so that Ramanujan could see its number plate. When Hardy went into Ramanujan’s room, he told Hardy that his number plate was unique: it had four special aspects to it. After that, Ramanujan died. Hardy took six months to understand what Ramanujan meant, but he could only discover three of the four aspects. On his death he left a will that research work on that number should continue, to find out the fourth aspect. Because Ramanujan had said there was a fourth, there had to be. Twenty-two years after Hardy’s death, the fourth was discovered. Ramanujan was right.
Whenever he began to look into any mathematical problem something began to happen in the middle space between his two eyebrows. Both his eyeballs turned upwards, centering on that middle space. In Yoga, that space is described as the third eye spot. It is called the third eye because if that eye becomes activated it is possible to see events and scenes of some different world in their entirety. It is like looking out of your house through a small hole in the door, and suddenly, when the door opens, you see the whole sky. There is a space between the two eyebrows where there is a small aperture that sometimes opens - as in the case of Ramanujan. His eyes rose to his third eye while solving a problem. Neither Hardy could understand this phenomenon nor would other Western mathematicians ever understand it in the future"
-- Osho, Hidden Mysteries, Ch 3 (translated from Hindi), excerpt
Something very interesting!!!!
Ohho...you r OSHO fan 😭🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@VIKASHSINGH-hf3kt YES!
Hahahahahahahaha. you are a novice. Real third eye opening and spirituality is the domain of juggy vasudeva.
I was not sure about this Osho guy but after reading this it seems like he belongs to the category of people like Sadhguru even though he might not be that worse.
You are wrong
Descartes and gauss didn't claim to have a vision of God meanwhile ramanujan did
Wow 👀 just wow
I had a prejudice since I watched The man who knew infinity, but man I have never in my life been convinced otherwise that too in few minutes 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
VERY INFORMATIVE
16:28
- Appeal to authority fallacy :
Something doesn't automatically become true just because a genius believed in it without any evidence.
- Either/Or fallacy :
It is believing that there are only 2 possibilities .
For eg. Either god did all the good things or god doesn't exist .
But what about the other hypothetical possibility that these deities are actually evil ?
What if praying to these imaginary deities actually makes them more evil?
What if NOT praying to that godess would have made Ramanujan more genius ? What if actually praying to that godess made him get infected with TB ?
Ofcourse there is no evidence for the above possibilities , blindly believing in any of them would be obviously irrational.
But blindly believing in one of them thats convenient to their superstition, while ignoring the other contradicting and equally non-evident possibilities is confirmation bias .
You dont need to prove if someones belief something is right or wrong. Only people with colonial mindset and invaders who came to india try to do that. The fact that fools and anti-nationals try this proving right wrong business just to feel happy to be part of majority religion in world :). Believing in god is so much beautiful thing but enforcing ones god and beliefs on others and trying to prove others god as false is not a practice in hindutva. So just let india live in its own beliefs, practices and gods isnt it? Who cares about your theories about confirmation bias and either or fallacies? No one! Ramanujam is just one example which unfortunately came into lime light other wise we have seen and heard many many stories of such supernatural happenings! In fact the whole knowledge of Indian ancient texts was given or written by people who have meditated (saints and rishis).
@@manojrenikunta2301 man you just proved your ignorance and hypocrisy try reading some books
@@manojrenikunta2301 can u understand Hindi ?
No deity is ev** it’s you karmas and karmic patterns are supported by psychology too you can learn about that.
Bro u should also start writing on quora about pseudoscience it will increase your influence a lot.
If it is not sure or proved that Devi has not gave him the formulas ,how can you state that it is not given by Devi too. Its like we just dont know
What a fuckin smooth transition into an ad 🔥Science is dope but you You are dope 💯
Its amazing that you put your biases into your videos while talki g about peoples religious bias 😂
You say that scientists, who believed their religious beliefs had a role to play in their achievements were wrong but atheists were absilutely right :)
Im not trying to argue if these people were gifted by god or not. My point is your opinion is biased and as such not dependable. You mentioned a few scientists who attributed their work to god and said it was just their intuition and bias but then you go on to add the athiest scientists and making the argument that they were right. Where is your proof my dear science is dope?
Rational thinkers forget to accomodate the unknown sometimes.
Bro.. i am one of the earliest subscribers of your channel. Amazing content!
Please make a series on contributions of Indian Scientists to the world.
FTR as Ramanujan and Hardy the parallels are so accurate
Good work
Excellent, this is the best video you have ever made, everything to the point, good animation although there is still some scope for improvement but I know its going to improve in future, keep it up.
Suggestion - make more videos about science history, get out of this atheist niche coz I feel you can do much better in this niche. I also feel that atheist content doesn't has that much viewers in India and all the hate you receive is not worth it at the end of the day people are still gonna believe what they have been believing.
@Arjun Yadav
There is nothing wrong in having an atheist niche.
Do you know what would happen otherwise?
The religious people would go on appropriating more and more of the things invented and discovered by means of the scientific method. The religious would be even more vehement in their unfounded claims all these inventions and discoveries made by the scientific method are due to the "blessings of god".
The logical fallacy is 'Argument from Authority'
It's called “ Authorative Fallacy”
Awesome
Ramanujan just like aryabhata, bhramagupta, kali das and other great Indian scientists, mathematicians, writers etc was a religious Hindu. You can cope all you want.
The formula you have labelled as Ramanujan's formula (of the prime counting function) was already predicted by Gauss and proved by other mathematicians. I guess Ramanujan gave a slightly different formula. Please check it once. In his letter Ramanujan doesn't claim to have found an exact formula as well. However, there was still a mistake in his approximate identity.
Also the names of mathematicians Bernard Riemann and Bertrand Russell are misspelt (See 8:01 and 10:01).
Can you give a source/reference to the photo shown in 1:12 ? I never seemed to have seen it earlier.
Yeah , thats what I thought
@@krishnapanchal0735 Paul dirac you
Bro I reverse searched and got that pic titled "Ramanujan's Mother" on website called mavink.
I will attach link in next comment but usually it gets removed from yt comment section
@@DeepuKumar-th1wq yes i am
@@pauldirc.. one of the greatest physicist 👍
I ❤️ you channel and all the good work that you do, God bless you 🙏, However, i humbly disagree with the title of this streaming, Mr Ramanujan, like Me Abel, Mr.Galois before him, is one of the greatest mathematician that ever lived.
The title is only an opinion :)
@@scienceisdope 👍, Congrats, this video is awesome!!!
@@scienceisdope Sir can you pls explain why would Heinsberg have said that "Quantum theory will not look ridiculous to people who have read Vedanta.”
He never had any hindu upbringing neither he attributed his achievement to any God
I think there are some parallels between vedas and upnishadss
That is why many prominent scientists are drawn towards it.
Always thought that someone needs to make a video on the religious practices of famous scientists. Job well done.
Logical Fallacy: Appeal to Authority
His facts may hurt but they are legit and true most of times..
Its not a fact it is purely his biased opinion which is trying hard to prove hinduism and worship of gods wrong! Look into all his videos you will know the answer. There will be a day he will realize the existence of supernatural power. All he has to do is just understand what really hinduism is so praise its beauty :)
@@manojrenikunta2301 😂😂
@@tinkudada5553 😂 i know.
@@manojrenikunta2301 yes seeing his videos it looks like he only targets only hindu religion and hide it under the umbrella name "science is dope".
@@rexxter5718 so true, it is soo evident.. just for the sake of it he recently made videos on other religions as well. But his hatred is seen. He expresses his hatred and he thinks he is sharing wisdom. This fool’s knowledge and preaching will not change anything!
Thanks bro mene hi bola tha ye video bnane ko apko
Nice work👍
This comment section shows Indians care more about Ramanujan's religion more than his actual contributions to mathematics 😂😂😂
We care about his contributions as well as Hindu Vedic maths which brought the whole world out of stone age. but some anti-hindus like to deny the reality.
@@Yogis_BitterTruth_BrahmNirvana 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@Yogis_BitterTruth_BrahmNirvana bruh I guess the only Vedic maths you know is from WhatsApp forwards
@@epicmusic9029 illogical assumption
@@epicmusic9029true😂