Magpul PMAG 30 Gen M2 and M3. Price vs. differences?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 5. 09. 2024
  • Question for AR operators: Is the differences between the 2 mags worth the extra cost?

Komentáře • 178

  • @TractorWrangler01
    @TractorWrangler01 Před 3 lety +106

    Gen 3 has a stop to avoid over insertion. The "Dust cover" also takes the pressure off the feed lips. Gen 3 also has a ridges for a better grip with wet or muddy hands. The Gen 3 has a smaller base plate so the mag fits easier into your mag pouch ect. and closer to your body It's only about 1.5 mm smaller but every little bit helps. Also the base plate is fully inclosed on the Gen 3 and is tapered into the base plate so it helps keep it from getting hooked on things. Gen 3 is also compatable with more rifles than the Gen 2 is. For details on that check the list on the packaging. They made the cut out in the back of the feed lips larger to accomidate different rifles. The Gen 3 ads a ramp for the mag catch for more positive catch for the mag release, and made the pattern in the side slightly deeper. There is also a little bar added to the back of the mag where the clamshell fits together presumably to strengthen it. The front of the Gen 3 tapers slightly more by the bullet end of the feed lips. The Gen 3 also ads some guides internally to direct the round more consistantly by giving slightly better support by the sholder of the round. You already mentioned the dot matrix. The mag well guides are slightly larger on the tapered end because of the slightly increased taper. Also the taper starts slightly lower on the mag, I assume to solve a clearence issue on some non millspec lowers or to clear mag well adapters for added funnel taper exc.. The followers are a different color presunably because they are not interchangable but I'm not sure about that as I have never tried it. As for the cost difference it most likely due to the fact that the Gen 3 comes with the dust cover. I know this is a bit late but hopfully it answers your questions.
    Edit: I forgot to tell you that Gen 2 has a problem trying to load a full mag on a closed bolt. Gen 3 does not have that issue. It was fixed by adding slightly more room.

    • @ooc49
      @ooc49 Před 3 lety +4

      You are right about the problem of m2 full mag loading on closed bolt. It's annoying but they perform pretty good on my ARs.

    • @johnyoungs7453
      @johnyoungs7453 Před 2 lety +6

      Great reply - thanks!! Well spoken..!!

    • @Mgrodem1
      @Mgrodem1 Před 2 lety +2

      Exemplary comment. Thank you.

    • @fredtaylor9792
      @fredtaylor9792 Před rokem +1

      Thank you!

    • @rodney21122
      @rodney21122 Před rokem +1

      Great reply! Ty

  • @heathmason4478
    @heathmason4478 Před 6 lety +119

    Gen 3 has a tab on the spine to prevent over insertion on certain AR15’s.. as you said about the appearance with ribbing and dot matrix.. The Gen 3 is supposedly made out of more durable polymer, but in my experience it’s negligible if any..
    Lastly, the dust cover is for dust, but most important for storing full mag to max capacity to keep pressure of the top round off of the feed lips just enough to prevent them from stretching.. That’s the main reason for dust cover..
    I like Magpul but have went to Lancer LW5 Advance warfighter mags almost exclusively that are polymer with steel heat treated feed lips..
    They are built like tanks.. You pay a few dollars more, but worth it in my humble opinion.. I know you are all about budget, but mags are the life and reliability of the very thing used to protect yourself, so I see it as an investment.. To each his own..
    Thanks for all you do..
    Keep up the great work!

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 6 lety +2

      Heath Mason Lancer....I need to look those up. Got a link?

    • @heathmason4478
      @heathmason4478 Před 6 lety +4

      PrAKtikal Nurse, There are several torture test videos on CZcams about them.. Sootch00 has a good one.. They are very popular and right now they are significantly cheaper than they were when I stocked up not knowing what the result of the presidential election would be.. Just google Lancer L5 AWM 30 rounds and should give you several places to buy from..
      They have solid colors which I have a couple of, but my favorite are the translucent smoke that you can see the rounds through.. and boy is that brass pretty to see them fully loaded..
      Also has round count marked on mags at 20 and 30 round mark.. Maybe 10 too, not sure though.

    • @wolfproducts
      @wolfproducts Před 6 lety

      I agree with you brother! I keep my Magpul as primary use because I bought 15+ of them while I keep my Lancer Mags in storage with my ammo just in case SHTF, they'll be ready whenever Magpul mags break or wore out.

    • @ecoovert
      @ecoovert Před 6 lety +1

      I have also noticed that the dust covers that came with my Gen 3's won't stay on my Gen 2's You can however get dust covers for the Gen 2 mags.

    • @matthewrivera9314
      @matthewrivera9314 Před 5 lety +1

      I prefer Lancers too.

  • @richardlahan7068
    @richardlahan7068 Před 3 lety +11

    I have two Gen 3 Pmags. My other Pmags are Gen 2. Civilian AR15 shooters won't really notice any difference in the performance of either mag. The Gen 3 Pmags were designed specifically to avoid over-insertion in certain select-fire military weapons and to reliably fit more select-fire military weapons. Other features were redesigned to make the Gen 3 Pmags more versatile for military personnel. For civilians, it's just a matter of personal preference.

  • @ozzyo6733
    @ozzyo6733 Před 5 lety +13

    Better feed angle into the chamber with the Gen 3 also. Approved to use with m855a1

    • @johnwicked9301
      @johnwicked9301 Před 2 lety

      I was having problems with a gem 2 mag sometimes the mag locking on mag release. I bought gem 3 and the problem was solved.

  • @johnsonjerrad
    @johnsonjerrad Před 4 lety +8

    I'm a little late to the party but the gen 3's won't work with some aftermarket magwell extensions like the Lancer adaptive magwell, due to the over insertion stop on the back of the magazine.
    I've also been told the gen 3's don't have feeding issues with the m855A1 ammunition that the marine corps ran into with on the standard USGI mags. The gen 3 follower positions the rounds higher so they don't ruin your feed ramps. This is why the Marines adopted the gen 3's. Not that anyone here is likely to be shooting m855a1 ammo on a regular basis (unless you're in the Marines, I guess).
    Personally I use the gen 3's but I've got about 4k into my AR, I spare no expense when it comes to a life saving piece of equipment like a battle rifle. I do have some Lancers and some USGI mags though, just in case.
    If you're going for budget magazine, grab some Okay Industries Surefeed aluminum USGI mags. This is the company that has been making magazines for the US military for 80 years or something crazy like that. They're the most reliable and they're cheap and they're about half the weight of the p-mags. Okay Industries switched to anti-tilt followers too, which I also highly prefer.

    • @Scortd
      @Scortd Před rokem

      Thanks...had an issue with the mag catch not grabbing with the M3 pmags. The magwell extension was the issue or should I say the insertion stop on the M3 was the issue due to my AR having a magwell extension.

  • @brandonrayner5253
    @brandonrayner5253 Před 5 lety +12

    I’m running the Gen 2 non windowed mags in my AR15

  • @johnnypwn
    @johnnypwn Před 5 lety +6

    M3 baseplates slide on from back to front so if you drop the rifle right on the mag the baseplate is less likely to come off and the mag blowout

  • @drakeaamold3401
    @drakeaamold3401 Před 4 lety +24

    God is good!!!!

  • @blueberryog69
    @blueberryog69 Před rokem +1

    I just got my AR for the first, that was my bday and it came with a standard metal 30 round mag so I ordered the magpul gen 3 mag so hopefully it feeds fine with my AR. I got a Delta Ton Echo 316.

  • @refugiogolf1
    @refugiogolf1 Před 6 lety +6

    One noticeable difference between the two is the baseplate one is slimmer than the other I believe! .I like the gen 2 because it has a thicker baseplate andIs easier to grab from magazine pouches (bag)..

  • @Espi68One
    @Espi68One Před rokem +1

    I just picked up 5 (used) of the M3 at a local shop for $8 buck each, no tax with cash, so $40 bucks. I have a bunch of the standard black M2 and those have been very good to me, I even purchased 20 more and have them still on the package. You can never have TOO many magazines.

  • @mache3984
    @mache3984 Před 3 lety +2

    So far the gen 2's work just fine for me. No need for me to waste money.

  • @WhatkindofAmerican
    @WhatkindofAmerican Před 6 lety +1

    They are similar. Gen M3 is a different body that helps with over insertion on the weapons that are mentioned on the list aside from m16/m4/blah blah. As to the dust/impact cover... They make them for the M2 as well and the main thing is it relieves pressure on the feed lips for long term storage AND prevents rounds from popping loose upon heavy impact(which does happen, in my experience) And it does both very well. An excellent little piece of plastic. Oh, and both mags are typical of Magpul magazines... Stupidly boring reliability, which is just how I like my mags.

  • @Jam3s99
    @Jam3s99 Před 6 lety

    @PrAKtikal Nurse-When you load both you will see the gen 3 the round sit higher than in the gen 2. The gen 3 is suppose to feed better and was changed to accommodate for feeding the next gen of military 5.56 rounds. I generally just go with the gen 2. I have gen 3 and both are reliable. The other difference is when I go buy them at Cablea's the gen 2 dose not come with the dust cover. You are right the dots on the bottom are to number your mags by filling in the dots. Hope this helps.

  • @georgefenrich4119
    @georgefenrich4119 Před 4 lety +1

    I am 2 days in on owning anything AR... All I know is the STOP tabs so it does not go in too far. LOVE the window too! :)

  • @joeprepper8172
    @joeprepper8172 Před 6 lety +6

    I run the m3s,now the 2s had some problems. I havent heard of any body having any problems with the 3s

  • @jeffdonner1912
    @jeffdonner1912 Před 6 lety +1

    I loaded up on 10 MP Gen 2 magazines for my Ruger AR 556 when Midway USA had them on sale for $7.90 each if you bought 10, about six months ago.

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 6 lety

      Jeff Donner If there is another sale like that again, let us know😁

    • @jeffdonner1912
      @jeffdonner1912 Před 6 lety

      I will do that. I buy a lot of stuff at Midway USA, and they are always running sales. I have also purchased a lot of spare Glock magazines there and at Brownell's in Iowa.

  • @aceseightsazhvacsparkyandg8138

    If I remember right the gen 3 has more steel reinforcement then the gen 2 . I seen the the windows break so I stay away from that . But do upgrade my aluminum government mags with magpul inner parts !

    • @muddyhotdog4103
      @muddyhotdog4103 Před 5 lety +1

      There is no steel in the Magpul ar15 mags.. They DO steel reinforce the newer ak pmags though.

  • @jmmartin7766
    @jmmartin7766 Před 2 lety +2

    There's already some great comments in here, so I can only add: Seems like I saw a video, recently, that mentioned how the Gen 2's weren't functioning reliably with a lot of our "NATO allies," non-AR, 5.56 rifles-- which the Gen 3 fixes.

  • @uga83joe
    @uga83joe Před 6 lety +1

    I bought one gen 3 mag. Compared to the gen2. Took me awhile. Matrix is okay...I havent paint filled it yet. Probably wont. Plastic feels same. Other than cosmetic differences I too could not tell why it cost more and why the gen 3 logo. Looked at it again and there it was...the base plate is reversed. My only reasoning is that with the mag loaded and inserted, on the gen2, and if dropped on the mag that the base plate would pop off and the rounds would be expelled. I dont think that would happen to the gen3 when loaded and inserted if dropped directly on the mag. Just my thinking.

  • @jeshely
    @jeshely Před 6 lety +4

    There was a Torture test performed by CountryBoyPrepper that had Gen1 and Gen2 failing against a Lancer Mag but the Gen 3 PMag holding up to it.

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 6 lety +2

      Chili SheepDog thanks for the he info. I will score some more of these

    • @jeshely
      @jeshely Před 6 lety +1

      Your welcome. Love your no nonsense practical videos.

  • @bboutdooradventures491

    I love the gem 3m, it has a difference not mentioned. The stop for to prevent it from overly inserting. I have also found that the GEN two will not work and my Ruger bolt action and the GEN three well.

  • @tjsoutdoors4786
    @tjsoutdoors4786 Před 4 lety +1

    I use what comes with the rifle which mine came with m2 p mags and have never had any issues with p mags

  • @zed332l
    @zed332l Před 4 lety +1

    M3 I heard anti dust tab , Different Follower Helps with New spring also Believe Stainless Steel spring keeps from developing a set when kept loaded for long length of times, and as mentioned above different material. heavier feed lips. Just what I heard.

  • @Xng88
    @Xng88 Před 3 lety

    I have no issue with gen 2 mag that came with my ar. Also, I bought gen 3 mags and it just works flawlessly and very capable with no issue when shooting

  • @dustinweaver3032
    @dustinweaver3032 Před 5 lety

    TO PRAKTIKAL NURSE:very informative please keep up the great work I hope you had a great Christmas and Happy New Year I have the gen3 with window to see how much ammo is left in mag it works great my local gun shop charges around 20 dollars a piece for them I know they are cheaper on line but I try to support my local businesses as long as its not a huge price difference once again I love the videos I give all your videos a thumbs up so far

  • @treyyergin
    @treyyergin Před 6 lety +1

    the m3 pmags are the NATO mags but I also think that the m3 mags are also improved a little

  • @ratagris21
    @ratagris21 Před 6 lety +6

    Great video like others said that the M2 was known to have issues mostly with feeding and fitment, but M3 is improved design and includes the dust cover for the $2-3 difference. Magpul generally charges more for the latest and greatest "pul of the art" kit.

    • @poncho12335
      @poncho12335 Před 6 lety

      ratagris21 But how long do you keep up with that dc?

    • @jodyfelland2162
      @jodyfelland2162 Před 5 lety +1

      Don't forget different tolerances in lowers. Some are very loose. That's really where feeding problems start. The more the mag rocks in the well, the more feeding can be an issue. Tolerance stacking is an overlooked problem.

  • @markmilcetich6997
    @markmilcetich6997 Před 2 lety

    Good question I have both also. I don't know.

  • @nathansun7200
    @nathansun7200 Před 5 lety +2

    i have many gen2 30 rnd mags and a few 40 rnd gen3's. i purchased some magpul ranger plates for them and was unaware that they will not fit on gen2's. the bottom plates are different and are not compatible.

  • @drewg3087
    @drewg3087 Před 2 lety

    As a fellow future Murse in his last semester in Nursing school glad to meet another that likes guns and accessories!

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 2 lety +1

      @Andrew G. Best of luck and many prayers to your health and success!! If you are in Central Texas and looking for that "starter nurse" job, get in touch with me. 😃👍🇺🇲

    • @drewg3087
      @drewg3087 Před 2 lety

      @@praktikalnurse504 thank you man, I’m on critical care now. Interesting for sure but just want to be done already, Lol. I’m in the South but if I ever do a contract assignment in Texas I’ll definitely reach out. Thank you so much for the opportunity and kindness!

  • @tannerb5716
    @tannerb5716 Před 5 lety +1

    If I fully load a m2 as well a M3 magazine with dust cover on .. m2 dust cover pops off when not wanted . M3 clips on and stays on in pouch with rough handling . M3 does feel (seem) stiffer.

    • @PangolinStirfry
      @PangolinStirfry Před 5 lety

      It's not a dust cover. It actually pushes the rounds down to take pressure off of the feed lips when you leave it loaded.

  • @EvendimataE
    @EvendimataE Před 6 lety

    bought magpul gen 3 because the have lots of good reviews....when i got them 4 out of 6 dont drop free.....i had to figure out which parts are tight, heated them a bit to fix them....they are easier to insert if they are loaded to 29 only.....i want to try D&H aluminum and the red lancer if i could find a 30 riveted to 10.....sometimes im thinking magpul is just so good in marketing....there is a lot of recomendations on their k2 pistol grip....when i bought one i cant really feel the more vertical angle they are claiming compare to my moe...to me they are just the same.....i event tried to close me eyes and griped each one.....even faced a mirror to see the position of my hand...hmmm i think magpul is just good in marketing :D

  • @Brykk
    @Brykk Před rokem

    If price is the same, or at least close, i choose the gen 3 windowed pmags. The gen 3 pmags are designed for european type ar variants, and for other non ar type rifles that take ar mags. It also makes them more attractive (and valuable) if you need to use them to barter with.
    I just got a christmas deal on the gen3 windowed pmags for $10 each and so i ordered another 20.

    • @nativetexan8247
      @nativetexan8247 Před rokem

      If I may ask; where did you manage to find windowed Gen 3's (new?), for only $10. apiece?

  • @boss350z5
    @boss350z5 Před 5 lety

    the grip texture, dot matrix, floor plates are different between the m2 and m3s. Also, the polymer is supposed to be more tolerant of extreme environments and stresses such as being ran over and having cracked feed lips or being shot and still operating; but Ive never tested it. I just get which ever ones are available, thouhh I actually like the gen m2 a little better because they have the correct floor plate shape for magpods...

  • @johnyoungs7453
    @johnyoungs7453 Před 2 lety

    Not speaking from experience, but gen 3 pmags push the top round a tiny bit higher at the top of the loaded mag, supposedly to eliminate or reduce issues involving the round sliding or scraping part of the gun when the round is being shoved into the chamber. Maybe someone else "in the know" can comment on this...?

  • @PangolinStirfry
    @PangolinStirfry Před 5 lety +1

    That's not a dust cover. It pushes the rounds down to take pressure off the feed lips when you leave the mag loaded.

    • @jacobbrown3097
      @jacobbrown3097 Před 5 lety

      Michael Homer true but he is not wrong. It will help prevent debris getting into the magazine

  • @giovannihooker6319
    @giovannihooker6319 Před 2 lety

    Love the chocolate sweater dude!!!!

  • @joemorganeatmyshortschannel

    i have a bunch of mags 18 for the one rifle i have a three pack of amend 2 30s those are good got 5 mft gen 2 good mags i have 5 gen 3 pmag 40s those are great a gen 3 pmag 20 also great
    an amend 2 20 love it and i have an old 88 dated colt mag works fine as well as an okay 20 rounder also awesome and i have a mystery black mag with white follower metal i think also works fine waht do they all have in common you ask? cheap and good im not made of money when others cleaned out ammo last year i grabbed mags and started stuffing them

  • @pkgreens_9998
    @pkgreens_9998 Před 6 lety +2

    Go gen3...dust cover/feed lip saver plus the better follower is worth a few more bucks in the long run. Keep up the good work and happy new year!

  • @poncho12335
    @poncho12335 Před 6 lety

    I always buy the g2 pmag.irag veteran 8888 has a good video about ar mags check it out.I still use d&h aluminum mags with the Nagpur anti tilt followers.At 7.99 on sale you can't beat them.

  • @rubenramos4943
    @rubenramos4943 Před 4 lety

    The Gem 3 have to force it in to my AR, got it from Primary Arms together. had to take 10 round before I can get it to lock and release

  • @rickhunt3183
    @rickhunt3183 Před 6 lety +1

    the main difference / per magpul is to make the m3 more compatable with weapons that deviate from the colt ar15/m4 specifications like the scar and others that have a few problems with the m2 magazine. I see a couple of people talking reliability issues with the m2..I just cant believe that. I have lots of m2s and every magazine i own is numbered so if a malfunction happens i know what mag and i can set it aside for later. I also use a paint marker and have a line on the side of my mags so i can instantly see what type of ammo is loaded..fmj line at the bottem..DRT line at the top..then hollow point below that. makes it easy to grab a preloaded mag for whatever the application. i might spend the extra for the mags with the roller followers. if someone has had a problem with m2 mags ..i want to know what kind of rifle and under what conditions. oh…about the window in the magazine its probably only useful at the range...put a tracer round in your mags as the second round..when you see the tracer go off you know the mag is empty and you have one round in the chamber.

    • @Dan-di9jd
      @Dan-di9jd Před rokem

      I'm having issues right now where 2 M2 mags did not work on this particular AR but the 1 M3 I had would work consistently. I picked up a couple more M3 mags and plan to do a bit more conclusive testing with them as I have some spare M2 mags that I plan to bring out as well.

    • @rickhunt3183
      @rickhunt3183 Před rokem

      @@Dan-di9jd if you have calipers I'd measure everything. It sounds like the different is going to be very small. I would guess if you were to measure every m3 or every m2 mag there are going to be a range of differences. I'm guessing if you measure the magwell between the rifles they're going to be a difference in measurements. I can't say for sure. I had a bunch of troy battle mags that fit my troy rifle perfectly but had some difficulties going into a generic AR built from parts. You might be able to lightly buff the magazines with some fine steel wool to make them fit better and still keep them within manufactures tolerances. I think we can eliminate the possibility of over insertion. I've never had that happen to me and I've inserted magazines countless times.I've never known anyone to have over insertion problems either. I'm curious if the AR that's having the problem is a brand; S&W, Ruger or a generic branded rifle.

    • @Dan-di9jd
      @Dan-di9jd Před rokem

      @@rickhunt3183 it's too hard to tell exactly what the culprit is. I'm just going to test M3 mags and if they work I'm just going to use those instead and not worry too much since I'm not really particular to any magazine. But yeah it's very unusual that it wouldn't work. On an empty mag it locks back manually for everything and looking at how high the catch goes, I don't see any difference at least visually. I decided to change out the bolt catch with a different one and it behaves exactly the same. one thing I can "feel" is that it feels like the bolt catch goes up because I can feel something "slipping" on the last round if that makes sense. Almost as if it was short stroking but regardless the M3s would always work. Very weird problem.

    • @Dan-di9jd
      @Dan-di9jd Před rokem

      @@rickhunt3183 I actually pulled it out and used a piece of paper to see how high the mag catch goes on the follower. The M3 is significantly higher than the M2. Visually I'm seeing the mag catch location to be nearly exactly in the same spot side by side but no way to know if they are different or not. Putting a M3 magazine into the receiver and putting a M2 magazine, I do see a slight difference in the angle of the bolt catch rising.

    • @Dan-di9jd
      @Dan-di9jd Před rokem

      @@rickhunt3183 okay I came back from the range. 6 m3 pmags and 4 m2 pmags. I load each magazine with 1 round to see if they lock back. All 6 m3 pmags would fire and lock back. All 4 m2 pmags would not lock the bolt back and feels like the bolt “slips” over something. I did this a total of 6 times and they consistently did that. I then loaded each mag with 3 rounds and again all 6 m3 pmags locked the bolt back. All 4 m2 pmags would feel like it “slips” after the last round fired. I can lock it back with the empty mag inserted. Anyway I tossed the m2 mags into the dumpster after asking someone if they wanted them. I bought 4 m3 pmags at the range so now I have all 10 m3 pmags and I’m happy. Not really particular with m2s as I only bought they without realizing anything about them. I started to pay attention to which ones were failing and now conclude the overall issue is with m2 pmags not locking the bolt back after the last round.

  • @jdcusic7427
    @jdcusic7427 Před 6 lety +6

    The Marine Corps is making the m3's standard issue now

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 6 lety +3

      JD Cusic I wonder if there will be a spike in the aluminum surplus mags, since they are going the Magpul.

    • @Brew1dCity
      @Brew1dCity Před 3 lety

      @@praktikalnurse504 yes they are, as you predicted 2 years ago.

  • @justinphoenix5514
    @justinphoenix5514 Před 5 měsíci

    So the gen M3 has a stop so it can’t go too far into the mag well that the gen M2 doesn't

  • @colby7625
    @colby7625 Před 4 lety

    I like the Gen M3 with the slimmer base plate.

  • @Satchmoeddie
    @Satchmoeddie Před 4 lety

    Gen 3s also are made from a tougher nylon that is better at super low temps, and the geometry fits lowers other P mags had some problems with, and that is about it. If the Gen 2s work in your gun....... Use the gen 2s. If you maybe plan on buying another fancier AR with a flared magwell billet lower, buy the gen 3s so you won't have future issues. I run Okay, D&H, Brownells, & Mag Pul P Mags for 556/300/223, and ASCs for my 6.5 Grendel AR. That is it. I am not too fond of ASC, but until Magpul makes a 6.5 Grendel mag.... I also run a CMMG .22 LR conversion kit, and for prepping .22 LR is awesomeness to the Nth power. I run Savage Model 24s chambered in .22 and .410 and one in .223 and 20 gauge, single shot rifle shotgun combo guns, also super awesome for preppers! My big guns are 30-06 hand loaded hot, 300 Win Mag, 300 RUM, .308 and 338 Lapua, but I also run muzzle loaders, and recurve bows. When all that other ammo is gone I can shoot melted car battery lead from a muzzle loader. When the primers are gone, bows n arrows.

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 4 lety

      @Seth B. Sounds good!! I keep my bow and arrows at the ready also. Silent and can be made with about anything

  • @lorihernandez5835
    @lorihernandez5835 Před 6 lety +1

    AR girl,, I personally need the dust cover. Hope your new years eve was great and cheers to you great vid. ❤🙏

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 6 lety

      Lori Hernandez Hi 💖. I had to work on New Year's Eve. I hope you had a good one.

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 6 lety

      Lori Hernandez We have dust here in Texas even during the winter, LOL!! Dust up there where you are?

    • @lorihernandez5835
      @lorihernandez5835 Před 6 lety

      PrAKtikal Nurse yes sir in the summer gets real dry sometimes . I am in Michhigan born and raised here. I love it country girl prepped and ready always. Right now I have about a foot of snow❤🙏❄⛄❄⛄

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 6 lety +1

      Lori Hernandez I wish you could send me a picture..It has snowed here a little, it was snowing today, but it doesn't stay long.

    • @lorihernandez5835
      @lorihernandez5835 Před 6 lety

      PrAKtikal Nurse I wish I knew how to send ya one too. What's even more of a problem than the snow is how very cold it is this year,, it hasn't been above 14 degrees since Christmas. Some days -2 or 0. I'm staying warm but man a bit of normal weather would be like 20 25 degrees right now.

  • @toycoma98
    @toycoma98 Před 4 lety +1

    Pmag gen 2 does not drop freely, i have to pull the mag out when empty. It requires some filing to drop freely. They were given to me from an Army buddy of mine that said the mags was issued to him. Never owned a gen3.

    • @SkintSNIPER262
      @SkintSNIPER262 Před 4 lety

      I find the same issue with Gen 3.

    • @dundeeecroc
      @dundeeecroc Před rokem +1

      Where on the PMAG GEN 2 did you file down?

    • @bigmacfullerton7870
      @bigmacfullerton7870 Před 10 měsíci +1

      @@dundeeecrocOn the back of the mag (skinny Part) where the mag goes into the well you will see a line of over-molding. Take a sharp knife and file that down and the mag will work much better. Any area you see rubbing can be filed down too.

  • @lutherwilson5786
    @lutherwilson5786 Před 6 lety +2

    M2 if only AR. I THINK FITS BETTER. M3 For muti weapon s

  • @lylebonney3081
    @lylebonney3081 Před 5 lety +2

    The gen 3 is made to feed M855A1 without damaging the feed ramp Gen2 is not besides that not a whole lot difference

  • @treyyergin
    @treyyergin Před 6 lety

    I like the m2 mags I do really think there is a big difference in the but I think the m3 has an improved follower in it but I would say for the cost differences the m2 is a better buy

  • @icu_corey_rn_903
    @icu_corey_rn_903 Před 4 lety +1

    Glad to see I’m not the only nurse into prepping/guns 😂

  • @mache3984
    @mache3984 Před 3 lety +1

    Well when you're buying 10 to 20 mags it makes a hell of a difference.

  • @randcoudray138
    @randcoudray138 Před 6 lety +2

    I use Tapco magazines almost exclusively. They are built like a tank and feed smooth as silk. My experience with the Gen 2 Pmags is that they run perfectly well in all my ARs. I believe that the Gen 3 pmags are for NATO rifles other than the M16 that prefer metallic magazines.

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 6 lety

      Rand Coudray Yes. I was reading off the list of rifles the M3 is supposed to cover. One of my AR buddies said they changed the follower a bit also

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 6 lety

      Rand Coudray I would like to try some of those Tapco CAR mags.

    • @openmythirdeye
      @openmythirdeye Před 5 lety

      I have never heard "tapco" and "built like a tank" ever used in the same sentence. You got jokes.

    • @irchristo
      @irchristo Před 5 lety

      @@openmythirdeye Please embellish your negative opinion of the tapco mags. ... I am learning, not contradicting.

  • @michaelhorn4540
    @michaelhorn4540 Před 2 lety

    I prefer the gen 3 mags because they come with dust covers

  • @humblewarrior6585
    @humblewarrior6585 Před 6 lety

    Another great video Brother. At the moment I only have the Gen 2 and a 30 rd aluminum mag for my M&P 15 Sport, so cant give my input at this time, sorry :-) Take care !!!

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 6 lety

      Soldier Of The Cross I had some mags I found in a yard sale..

  • @tonyhenry2012
    @tonyhenry2012 Před 4 lety

    Digging the AE Lifeteam hat

  • @brandonhaddock6563
    @brandonhaddock6563 Před 6 lety

    If you are just using it for the AR the Gen 2 is fine. If you have an FN Scar, the Gen 3 is the way to go, look at the back of both, were the bolt picks up the round, the Gen 3 has the cut out for the FN. The Gen 2 will hit it. If you run the Gen 2 you will have to modify it for the Scar.

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 6 lety +1

      Brandon Haddock Awesome!! Thanks for breaking it down. After I did the video I noticed it, plus there are a few other differences. These mags are joining my other ones that are loaded and ready to rock.

  • @Dan-di9jd
    @Dan-di9jd Před rokem

    The difference? None if they both work. It would come down to just price difference. The most important difference I've seen is that the M2 has sort of a oval shape where the bolt catch would come up on vs the M3 that has a more rectangular point that the bolt catch would rise up on. I also had lowers that just didn't work with M2s and it seems like there is a slight dimensional differences between the two where the M3 would work better in certain rifles. I never heard of the inverse where the M3 didn't work but the M2 did. It always seem like when you have issues with the M2, then the M3 would likely cure it.

  • @Hunter-eh4pz
    @Hunter-eh4pz Před 5 lety +4

    If you leave a pmag fully loaded,it'll break its feed lips off. That's what the dust cover is for. Also a loaded mag inserted in a rifle, if dropped on that mag will make the floor plate break. Gen 3 they improved by thickening. Gen 3mags dust covers won't fit over its floorplate. So I like gen 2, but I keep a few lancer awm mags loaded for emergency. They have steel feed lips that won't break, and they come in transparent colors. If you already have mags, switch to getting lancer...$$17 a mag

    • @BI-dw8uz
      @BI-dw8uz Před 4 lety +4

      I have had gen 2 pmags fully loaded sitting around over 5 years and none have yet to crack or break near feed lips so idk honestly.

  • @HurricaneWindPower
    @HurricaneWindPower Před 4 lety

    I was dumb enough to buy 10 magpul G2 promag and that thing does not
    seat worth shit. In a gunfight the last thing I want to deal with is
    dropping my mag like a douchbag out the magwell. They just do not sat
    like the steel......everyone says these things are great ....am I
    missing something ?

  • @bobbybenson849
    @bobbybenson849 Před 5 lety +1

    if you look at the back of each mag the gen 2 has a round looking cut ... back the gen 3 have a square looking back i had the mod all of my gen 2 to look like the gen 3 they wouldn't feed at all ....trimmed them to the square look and they work fine now ...you can see what im talking about at the 4:33 mark

    • @jake27schannel
      @jake27schannel Před 5 lety +1

      Bobby Benson i had a similar feed problem with my hex mags bc the bolt kept getting stuck. But i just trimmed a little corner off of the raised part of the follower and no problems now

    • @jake27schannel
      @jake27schannel Před 5 lety

      Bobby Benson ohhh wait are u referring to the actual cut in the body of the mag? That creates a problem?

  • @LeQuito
    @LeQuito Před rokem

    Gen 3 is made of a newer developed polymer

  • @fulcrum322
    @fulcrum322 Před 5 lety +5

    I always wondered why Palmetto state gives you 10 gen 2 Pmags with the purchase of literally any damn thing you buy.

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 5 lety +8

      @Matt Covington as long as they work, I am ok with it. 😀 If they don't, then I "regift " them, kind of like Christmas fruit cake.

  • @jasonholguin4121
    @jasonholguin4121 Před 6 lety

    It one is newer and cost is more on new one that is it. M2 is the way I’d go being it’s a few $ cheaper.

  • @texask9110
    @texask9110 Před 5 lety +2

    WHY you MUST KEEP your Gen 2 Mags.......When you travel to places like Colorado, there are States that now have max capacity laws which often EXEMPT mags purchased before a specific date... If you have a Gen 3 in Colorado, it is not legal,,,a Gen 2 however IS LEGAL because they can't prove you did not purchase it before the expemption date...With the Gen 3 however, since they were not put into production until AFTER the exemption date, there is no way you could have owned them when the laws were changed... Just food for thought.

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 5 lety +1

      @K C thanks for info😁 with all the differences of laws from state to state, I plan on just staying here in Texas, where I know the laws on firearms.

    • @P_double_H
      @P_double_H Před 5 lety +1

      RIP Colorado! You are inbound to a left turn crash!

    • @brianunderwood7437
      @brianunderwood7437 Před 5 lety

      Texas K9-If I am correct, the date of manufacture is printed on the side of all Pmags.

  • @adk187cm
    @adk187cm Před 3 lety

    Why won't the m3s fit my db15?

  • @Rayzor66
    @Rayzor66 Před 2 lety

    I shot my AR build today for the first time. Psa upper. 80% lower. Rare breed trigger h3 buffer. The gen2 mag jammed every second shot. The gen3 mag worked better but jammed some, but less than the 2.

  • @rodolfodelacernajr.2101

    Sir can you help me purchase them...? I am from the Philippines...

  • @aaronsliva4251
    @aaronsliva4251 Před 6 lety

    Gem 3s offer a bit more reliable and they can shoot m855a1 too

  • @surb02
    @surb02 Před 5 lety +8

    M3 locks in more precise. Seems to me any way.

  • @whjerts
    @whjerts Před 6 lety

    At Rural King the gen 3 is cheaper than the gen 2

  • @its5.56somewhere9
    @its5.56somewhere9 Před 6 lety

    JJ BALOONS........... I only use pmags in my Mini 14 . I use C-Products in my AR 47, and only Hexmags in my AR's.

  • @rudyswoodwork7236
    @rudyswoodwork7236 Před 6 lety +12

    M3 has a dust cover

    • @bhuff4748
      @bhuff4748 Před 3 lety

      This is really about the only difference. M2s are proven and work well.

  • @SixTwoHemi
    @SixTwoHemi Před 6 lety

    Happy New Year

  • @ThePNWRiderWA
    @ThePNWRiderWA Před 5 lety

    The HK 416 originally would not work with the Pmags prior to the G3. HK has a slightly newer version of the 416 that will work with all the mags.

  • @stevenshewfelt888
    @stevenshewfelt888 Před 4 lety

    are you gonna get the D60

  • @yetisuncle666
    @yetisuncle666 Před 2 lety

    the only difference is that the gen 3 has the dust covers. THATS IT.

  • @animalmother8117
    @animalmother8117 Před 2 lety

    Gen 3 is slightly more durable.

  • @jellyhead7044
    @jellyhead7044 Před 3 lety

    You missed in important improvement in the M3. If you notice the area directly over the mag catch indent, the M3 has a bit of raised plastic where the M2 does not. This is a VERY important improvement as the mag catch on some ARs WILL NOT hold the mag in place regardless of the adjustment. Yes I have one AR where this is a problem where all others I own are fine. The problem is more with the lower than the mag. On the problematic lower, the mag catch recess is not sufficient.

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 3 lety

      @Jellyhead thanks for pointing that out. One would guess with the AR platform, they would all be about the same due to the pattern. Some of my friends point against AK's is because "they aren't made the same". Guess now we all know the same may apply to ARs

  • @yetisuncle666
    @yetisuncle666 Před 9 měsíci

    The ONLY difference is the dust cover. And if you fall for that gimmick then you get to oay the extra couple of dollars for no real reason.
    For you geniuses who do prefer the dust covers, try to think or even research how small a oarticle of dust is...... It will most assuredly get thru the spaces between the cover and the lip. Besides the obvious, dust is not a concern. Unless you live in a dust debil 24/7 -365, then you have bigger concerns.

  • @Traderjoe337
    @Traderjoe337 Před 4 lety

    Hey practical nurse. Get a big daddy unlimited account. Since you love getting the lowest price (I do to) you’ll find gen 2 pmags for 8.99 each. And gen 3 pmags for 10.99 each. You have to pay a subscription BUT if you’re buying firearm gear often, they absolutely can’t be beat on price. If you’re not buying things often then it might not be worth it to you.

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 4 lety

      @Stephen Hayes got a link? 😁 thanks for the info!

    • @Traderjoe337
      @Traderjoe337 Před 4 lety

      www.bigdaddyunlimited.com/bdu-member-portal

    • @Traderjoe337
      @Traderjoe337 Před 4 lety

      So they are out of stock on a lot of things right now, but so is every business that sells firearm products of any kind. It’s $0.99 for your first month and $9.99 after that but you can cancel anytime. It’s worth it if you buy things. I mean their prices are so much lower that other store anywhere. It’s not even close for example the red dot that is my favorite. Sig Sauer Romeo 5 $162.00 at my local gun shop, $139.99 when on sale at PSA, $120.00 at big daddy unlimited. Their prices are legit. Slings that are normally $70 are $40 at BDU. Only problem right now is they are so low on stock and they don’t have any free shipping specials right now which sucks. I love me some free shipping

  • @P46345
    @P46345 Před 6 lety

    I know somebody that has an FN SCAR 16 and he brags to everybody how much more reliable his rifle is than any AR on the planet. I've been out shooting with him before and GEN 1 and 2 PMAGs will not work in it. One round will fire and the next won't feed. Doesn't sound too reliable to me.lol ;-) He claims that the aluminum "half painted" GI magazine that came with his SCAR is the best magazine in the world. I've never had an issue running any generation PMAG through my Colt LE6920. Maybe it's because I shoot left handed???(sarcasm) ;-)

    • @P46345
      @P46345 Před 6 lety

      He's not somebody I'd call a friend, just somebody I know. ;-) He's much worse than a jerk too.

  • @joeprepper8172
    @joeprepper8172 Před 5 lety

    Check out mft they make good mags and they're only 10 bucks

  • @JakelaWeeze
    @JakelaWeeze Před 3 lety

    How much did you smoke before this vid

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 3 lety +3

      @JakelaWeeze 2 briskets, 3 chickens, 1 pork loin, 1 salmon, and some vegetables. Your Mom said it was the BEST.
      How about you? 🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @jimconway6524
    @jimconway6524 Před rokem

    Save your $2. You will never till the difference anyway.

  • @VMJM85
    @VMJM85 Před 3 lety

    R.A.N.!!!

  • @johnwicked9301
    @johnwicked9301 Před 2 lety

    The FDE is better

  • @ryanmayphoto
    @ryanmayphoto Před rokem

    CAUTION, Magpul dose not stand behind their products and will not issue a replacement, refund, or even a partial credit for manufactures defects on items that they sell. If it is defective you are stuck with it. Go with anything other than Magpul!!! Magpul falls apart!

  • @jbell1166
    @jbell1166 Před 5 lety

    Weigh the baseplate s

  • @HurricaneWindPower
    @HurricaneWindPower Před 4 lety

    I was dumb enough to buy 10 magpul G2 promag and that thing does not
    seat worth shit. In a gunfight the last thing I want to deal with is
    dropping my mag like a douchbag out the magwell. They just do not sat
    like the steel......everyone says these things are great ....am I
    missing something ?

    • @praktikalnurse504
      @praktikalnurse504  Před 4 lety

      @Hurricane Wind Power. From what I am told, there may be a couple of things to take into consideration. Some manufacturers mag wells don't fit well with the Magpul mags. Honestly, I should have paid more attention to the ones they mentioned, instead, I filed it under "whew....not one of mine". Some may have to do with the mag catch. I am sure you already tried slapping up on the mags after insertion into the mag well. All of us old M-16A1 military folks made it a habit.
      Hope some of this helps. I am curious to find out which manufacturers don't work with the mags.

    • @HurricaneWindPower
      @HurricaneWindPower Před 4 lety

      @@praktikalnurse504 This is an older Bushmaster like when they made good stuff....do you know where you can find the list of the one your saying they do not fit well with....I mean it fits you just have to push hard and feel the click. Not something I wish
      to do extra if I find needing my rifle for something other than plinking