Colin Mochrie talks about the difference between the British and American "Whose Line"

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 16. 02. 2017
  • Colin Mochrie is best known as a regular on both the American and British versions of Whose Line Is It Anyway?, which has inspired an entire generation of improvisers. In this episode, Colin sits down with Jimmy at the Genesee Theatre in Waukegan, IL, and talks about starting out in Theatresports in Canada, how he dealt with the sensors on Whose Line and what he really feels about all the bald jokes.
    Check out our patreon for the full video interview: Patreon.com/improvnerd
    #improvnerd #improv #whoselineisitanyway
  • Komedie

Komentáře • 351

  • @Yotrek
    @Yotrek Před 3 lety +309

    Time flies. We were all watching Ryan and Colin in the Britain version 27 years ago.

    • @brianm2881
      @brianm2881 Před 3 lety +16

      I remember looking forward to watching Whose Line on Channel 4 so much, like that was the total highlight of the evening. This was back when there weren't that many channels on TV and you didn't necessarily know if or when the show would return for another series, so opening the TV listings and seeing it there at around 9 on Channel 4 was an air punch moment.

    • @eskimofireman
      @eskimofireman Před 3 lety

      why, are the flies speeding up?

    • @chenzenzo
      @chenzenzo Před 3 lety +3

      Fuck, has it been that long?

    • @cameronmichaels216
      @cameronmichaels216 Před 3 lety

      I was -6 lmaoooo

    • @thebackup2121
      @thebackup2121 Před 3 lety

      Already 30 years since this got off the ground??? 😲

  • @Acaykath
    @Acaykath Před 3 lety +401

    Biggest difference between British and American version, in the British Version, Collin still had hair.

    • @matthewjamison
      @matthewjamison Před 3 lety +1

      That's an Arthurian Legend.

    • @Drums-ve8on
      @Drums-ve8on Před 3 lety +1

      In American version , it is funny.

    • @MickeRamone
      @MickeRamone Před 3 lety +1

      Yeah that was before he signed the contract wich says he has to keep shaving his head 🤣

    • @damientonkin
      @damientonkin Před 3 lety +5

      Colin was still bald but the host had less hair and no neck so the jokes tended to go in that direction. Also British audiences don't make a lot of noise so you can really draw out the scene and build up to a joke. American audiences laugh much more easily so you tend to get a lot of fairly quick lowest common denominator gags. Also there's the American tendency to talk down to the audience which I'm sure comes from some network executive (with apologies to my sister) so you get a lot more explaining of the format like the fact that the points don't matter.

    • @bitzannbobz
      @bitzannbobz Před 3 lety

      wheyyyyyyy

  • @oldmangimp2468
    @oldmangimp2468 Před 3 lety +172

    "This is Clive Anderson saying good night. Good night."

  • @theo2z1z94
    @theo2z1z94 Před 3 lety +134

    Colin is so witty watching him perform improv is like watching a magician perform an unbelievable trick right before your eyes

  • @Jin-Ro
    @Jin-Ro Před 3 lety +30

    I loved Whose line, both sides of the water. Couldn't get enough of them.

  • @ForceMaximus84
    @ForceMaximus84 Před 4 lety +447

    One thing I noticed is that the British audiences tend to laugh less or quicker, which allows the performers to throw in more jokes. The audiences for the American version laugh longer, which makes for less jokes. I prefer the British version for that reason.

    • @justincronkright5025
      @justincronkright5025 Před 3 lety +40

      It happens in most other parts of television where live audiences are there too. The ones in the U.S. perhaps have the host or audience organisers focus the people into laughing more/harder, or clapping louder & longer or often times it's just filled with screaming & flappy/floppy bouncing. In the U.K. I absolutely agree that audiences in a sense take on the 'strict laughing rules' so that the performers/panel members, etc. are able to manoeuvre a bit more as they can then have guidelines moreso than rules.

    • @SecondValveSteam
      @SecondValveSteam Před 3 lety +52

      It’s not that we laugh less, we’re having a great time but we don’t want to miss anything, which is why we might be seen as more uptight.

    • @flatterswhite
      @flatterswhite Před 3 lety +3

      @@SecondValveSteam oh is that what it is?

    • @torernning8652
      @torernning8652 Před 3 lety +10

      @@flatterswhite Same goes for the scandinavian countries to.

    • @keithmccrary325
      @keithmccrary325 Před 3 lety +20

      also the American version is slightly dumbed-down, you have to be a bit more worldly than most Americans to get the British version

  • @Halbared
    @Halbared Před 3 lety +13

    THe UK version was just gold.

  • @MrPicklerwoof
    @MrPicklerwoof Před 3 lety +51

    It's weird, but I felt the US performers were always at their best when appearing on the British version. They got thrown out of their comfort zone a lot more and it allowed them to really mix things up. Which is when magic happens (about 95% of all my favourite WLIIA moments are from the UK version).
    The US version always had an undercurrent of predictability & formula running through it. Although it did still have its moments occasionally.

  • @ElectroTherapyFTSoul
    @ElectroTherapyFTSoul Před 5 lety +110

    "They'll break the fourth wall a lot. . . They're always out of the scene."
    My mind goes straight to Paul Merton and Tony Slattery doing Film Styles. They spend half the time bouncing insult humor to each other (and to Clive) and criticizing each other's performance as they're doing the scene, and it's absolutely beautiful!

    • @zendynamite9058
      @zendynamite9058 Před 4 lety +4

      One of my favourite episodes!

    • @UnwittingSweater
      @UnwittingSweater Před 3 lety

      This is the one scene that came to mind but I'm the opposite to you in I really didn't like it.

    • @Halbared
      @Halbared Před 3 lety +2

      Slattery had a decent sin-off called S&M with Mike McShane.

    • @Nyx773
      @Nyx773 Před 3 lety

      “You shut your face”

  • @ProjectFlashlight612
    @ProjectFlashlight612 Před 3 lety +59

    Colin is a true improv master.

    • @A_Person5280
      @A_Person5280 Před 3 lety +1

      By far. He’s at least a level or two above any of the other Whose Line cast, British or American version.

    • @2Beasty
      @2Beasty Před 3 lety

      Colin is hilarious but that's completely false.

  • @1darkironman1
    @1darkironman1 Před 3 lety +71

    it's quite impressive when they transition back and forth with UK and USA humor

    • @itsvuffu
      @itsvuffu Před 3 lety +11

      @RockMeAmadeus that'd be his daughter, actually. why do you feel the need to misgender her?

    • @itsvuffu
      @itsvuffu Před 3 lety +12

      @RockMeAmadeus how did you manage to fit so much hatred and misunderstanding into one short sentence? it's honestly impressive

    • @ericfloortje
      @ericfloortje Před 3 lety +1

      Reagan Douglas why do you feel the need to be condescending

    • @itsvuffu
      @itsvuffu Před 3 lety +10

      @@ericfloortje because there's no need to be bigoted, and they were being bigoted

    • @hitsugatatsuro9978
      @hitsugatatsuro9978 Před 3 lety

      @@itsvuffu I didn't see any bigotry. Just an honest recommendation. Well, at least before you initially replied.
      I think ya need to review what bigotry means. Just because someone didn't get the pronouns right doesn't make them bigoted; more often than not, it's ignorance or a slip of the tongue. Pls be more mindful before you throw out your buzzwords or accuse anyone in general. It's nice to defend someone's sexuality, but only when it is necessary, called for, and fits in the context. Tho in this case, I'd say they responded with too much venom than was necessary towards your condescending reply. Like, *calm tf down, human* levels.
      Then again, the toxic SJW culture ruins a lot of things for everyone (both for Americans and we from the rest of the world), so I'd understand the flatout scorn to some degree. Ironically, the definition of bigotry could be applied to most SJW twitter people nowadays. Why must they make something that should be about love and acceptance so intimidating to embrace genuinely?
      I honestly don't even see the point in replying to you as you'll just try to argue with indignance and some faux sense of self-righteousness or an ad hominem attack. Maybe it's cuz it's midnight and I'm feeling neutral but thoughtful.
      In the future, I hope the SJW toxicity finally dies down along with the patriarchal BS and we can all just experience *actual* equity. Not the passive aggressive or straight aggression we have even in a comment section for a beloved comedy show.

  • @SaintSwithinsDay
    @SaintSwithinsDay Před 3 lety +115

    I like Colin Mochrie, I really really do.
    I really, really, really, really, really, really do,
    I.... [faints]

  • @commandert5
    @commandert5 Před 3 lety +66

    I want to see him on Mock the Week

  • @WhatInTheDeepestShadeOfFeck

    Colin Mochrie and Ryan Stiles were the only reason I watched Whose Line, especially the bits they did together

  • @foolsjourney8118
    @foolsjourney8118 Před 3 lety +36

    Most of the comedians on the UK version were university graduates, so there was an expected level of 'clever' and 'sophisticated' and the games pushed that. Go to the dry cleaners in the style of Solzjenitsyn, the guest at the party is obsessed with Dylan Thomas.
    I think the best of both worlds was when we had that combined with US guests like Colin, Ryan, Greg etc.

    • @UnmistakableSoundOf
      @UnmistakableSoundOf Před 3 lety +9

      Agreed. It took a while for it to find it's feet and get the right mix of guests. Also, I hated John Sessions who was a regular at the beginning; he was so up himself and determined to show off is educated background, and he wasn't even funny, his characters all sounded the same. The snappy improv and physical comedy of the Americans definitely helped, as well as some anarchic British elements like Paul Merton.

    • @brianm2881
      @brianm2881 Před 3 lety +4

      Yeah, I remember on the first and second series of the show you'd have Sandi Toksvig and John Sessions on it a lot of the time and they'd be doing improvs in the styles of authors and things, and I think that went over much of the audiences' head, or at least over mine.

    • @jamie299
      @jamie299 Před 3 lety +6

      I agree, especially after rewatching some seasons of the UK version recently. And not to be too pedantic, but Colin is actually Canadian (they make fun of him for it a lot on the UK version), and Ryan is dual (born to Canadian parents as well).

    • @gurrrn1102
      @gurrrn1102 Před 3 lety +6

      "I'm going to ask Roger and John to improvise a scene in which a man visits the dentist, in the style of a Sheridan restoration comedy"
      "Aha methinks forsooth perchance, that ye hath cometh verily for a checkup"

    • @eastvandb
      @eastvandb Před 3 lety +3

      Just for the record, Colin is Canadian, not American. (And even Ryan's semi-Canadian.)

  • @LextheRobot
    @LextheRobot Před 3 lety +27

    Our improv troupe was originally called the Sticky Wickets, later we dropped the word Sticky from the name and went with simply 'the Wickets'. Maybe if we'd seen this interview before then, we'd have been the Schticky Wickets.

  • @the98themperoroftheholybri33

    I still laugh at "There's a bun in my oven" and Colin replied "and not what icing if you know what i mean"

  • @chapterblaq
    @chapterblaq Před 3 lety +11

    Thank God Colin is still with us.
    Also, i enjoy both versions.

  • @Tomniverse
    @Tomniverse Před 3 lety +22

    "they can break the fourth wall a lot, some of the guys, they were just always out of the scene" bet he's referring to Paul Merton

    • @chrisninety1
      @chrisninety1 Před 3 lety +4

      That was the first name that came to mind, but then I'm not sure if they would have done any episodes together as most of Paul Merton's appearances came quite early on in the shows run, whereas Colin didn't come in until later. Some of Caroline Quentin's stuff was, quite appropriately, along the same lines and she was on the show a bit longer.

    • @Tomniverse
      @Tomniverse Před 3 lety

      @@chrisninety1 yeah I seem to remember Paul 'behaving' a bit more on his later appearances too

    • @jasonph2522
      @jasonph2522 Před 3 lety

      John Sessions was the king though- often creating a scene on his own and taking it wherever he wanted.

  • @bustedfender
    @bustedfender Před 3 lety +192

    Self deprecation; key to understanding we Brits. Sorry, I feel so stupid even bringing it up...

    • @HartyBiker
      @HartyBiker Před 3 lety +11

      It's alright man, if it's any comfort you look pretty stupid too

    • @bustedfender
      @bustedfender Před 3 lety +7

      @@HartyBiker Thanks man. Nice name, btw.

    • @nathanberrigan9839
      @nathanberrigan9839 Před 3 lety +18

      In the US, the comedian tells the joke.
      In the UK, the comedian is the joke.

    • @twat3789
      @twat3789 Před 3 lety +8

      @@nathanberrigan9839 I am become joke, destroyer of worlds

    • @raintamer8121
      @raintamer8121 Před 3 lety

      Thank you guys this helps separate and clarify the (to me very similar) two different ways. Good jokes by all btw 🤜🤛

  • @Bridgejonesrox
    @Bridgejonesrox Před 3 lety +5

    I saw Colin live, with Brad, and 2 other. All amazing. But there was an edge to Brad, like he needed to be doing the show. With Colin, you could tell he was living in every moment. We got pictures backstage and he was really kind.

  • @StressJudoCoaching
    @StressJudoCoaching Před 3 lety +225

    I learned there are "improv purists." And I wish I hadn't.

    • @MrJacobThrall
      @MrJacobThrall Před 3 lety +47

      There are probably purists in every aspect of human existence. Bombay mix purists, bicycle valve cap purists, tape measure numbering font purists...but yeah, I'm with you. It would be nice to think it was just about laughing at funny stuff and nothing more.

    • @EclecticSceptic
      @EclecticSceptic Před 3 lety +15

      @@MrJacobThrall Bombay mix purists hahaha

    • @Sam-ey1nn
      @Sam-ey1nn Před 3 lety +8

      Colin alludes to it here- everything I've ever heard is that "real" improvisers don't like Whose Line and consider it banal. Whose Line does short-form improv and focuses on comedy- while long-form is considered more prestigious and challenging in the improv community and scenes can last up to 25 minutes.
      That said, I am of the complete 180 degree opinion. it's undeniable that Whose Line and shows like it are vastly more successful than any long-form improv has ever been. I also feel doing short-form comedy scenes (and actually being funny) is vastly more difficult than anything long-form. You can see this in how few performers on Whose Line are able to succeed in the environment. Colin, Ryan, and Wayne were/are masters at it while the rotating guest chair often struggles to keep up (and the host is so bad at improve comedy that their terribleness is often used as a joke in-and-of-itself).

    • @Sentient_Zee
      @Sentient_Zee Před 3 lety +6

      @@MrJacobThrall you got a problem with bicycle valve cap purists?

    • @sarahkinsey5434
      @sarahkinsey5434 Před 3 lety +8

      @@Sam-ey1nn I agree, they have to think faster and that is what makes it so much harder

  • @keithorbell8946
    @keithorbell8946 Před 3 lety +4

    Improv new to the UK in the ‘80? Whose Line is it Anyway grew out of a BBC Radio series called I’m Sorry I haven’t A Clue, which is still running. I believe that this is one of the forms of performance art where there is a major difference between the UK and North America, as Colin said, we are used to Pantomime, and for use “improv” is very much about breaking the rules, in the same way pantomime does.

  • @scriptsundaystv4302
    @scriptsundaystv4302 Před 2 lety +3

    Colin is one of the improv goats, great short but sweet insight, I haven't had a chance to watch the Whose Line reboot but always huge fan of the original show.

  • @Ogrematic
    @Ogrematic Před 3 lety +5

    We love you, Colin. Always have.

  • @jp3813
    @jp3813 Před 3 měsíci +4

    Clive Anderson would constantly try to make jokes after every buzzer in the UK version. For example, he buzzed out Tony Slattery for sounding too high-pitched in "Questions Only". He also caused probably the shortest game of "Old Job, New Job" ever w/ Stephen Frost playing a former veterinarian. One game that I tend to prefer in the UK version though is "Helping Hands", b/c the jokes were way more than just feeding random foods to Ryan.

  • @cooperbybee4308
    @cooperbybee4308 Před 3 lety +8

    Had the interviewer "set a scene" for Colin to answer the question within, his answer would have been concise, articulate and flawlessly delivered.

  • @hengineer
    @hengineer Před 3 lety +3

    I loved both.

  • @trinity72gp
    @trinity72gp Před 3 lety +7

    🇬🇧🙋🏾‍♀️ I love both. Saw them, Colin and Ryan, first on the Brit version and it grew from there to the states just got better and better. They're legendary 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾 long may it continue 😁

  • @MasterChris666
    @MasterChris666 Před 3 lety +3

    Love both

  • @dmark297
    @dmark297 Před 3 lety +50

    I'd say that the biggest difference between the two is that Clive Anderson knew how to not hog the spotlight, and knew that the improvisers were the stars. He still knew how to be funny but not overshadow the true performers. Drew Carey did this at first but then started getting more and more involved, to the point where it just became "Drew Carey and Friends." This is true of UK presenters in general-- they stay out of the way when the occasion calls for it.

    • @hippyhappyhippo
      @hippyhappyhippo Před 3 lety

      @Liam Berg (STUDENT) *"friends" in quotations.

    • @anonymousLeroy
      @anonymousLeroy Před 3 lety +8

      to be fair, Drew was an amazing part of the show

    • @anonomaly
      @anonomaly Před 3 lety +6

      I mean, Drew afaik wasn't a producer (found out he was, same as Ryan Stiles) and was told to be involved. That said, Drew had some of the best segments and the cast ripping on him was the cherry on top.
      Either way, he is way better than the latest host (who was pointed out to me below is Aisha Taylor).

    • @ggundercover3681
      @ggundercover3681 Před 3 lety +1

      @@anonomaly the latest host as in Aisha Taylor? and Yes while some hate Drew's involvement, that's why I love him. Good thing ppl have the UK version that they can enjoy instead of complaining so much. :)

    • @TampaJohn
      @TampaJohn Před 3 lety +1

      Very well put. I couldn’t agree more.

  • @ameldancalippo6912
    @ameldancalippo6912 Před 3 lety +81

    Ive just watched this, heard his answer and I still dont know the difference.

    • @lindagoad2163
      @lindagoad2163 Před 3 lety +13

      I think its something to do with glue as we are apparantly schticky and they are not. Maybe?

    • @tobyhart8515
      @tobyhart8515 Před 3 lety +9

      @@lindagoad2163 it's different in that they use the carrot 🥕 and we use the shtick.

    • @phily8093
      @phily8093 Před 3 lety +16

      The American version is more rigid and comes across a little plastic and soulless, and everyone there seems to have little individual personality on display. They want to be seen as smooth, and as a result each episode seems the same, and it's very boring as a result.

    • @mjames4709
      @mjames4709 Před 3 lety +5

      @@phily8093 Nailed it.

    • @chriswhittaker5075
      @chriswhittaker5075 Před 3 lety +5

      @@phily8093 Exactly that, the US version seemed to do the same games every week and it got old fast. The UK version mixed it up so it was way more interesting and varied. Clive Anderson was also 1000 times better than Drew Carey - the points not mattering in the UK was a thing, just not really mentioned. In the US Drew overpushed it to a breaking point.

  • @In_The_80s
    @In_The_80s Před 3 lety

    So glad I came across this. I've always wanted to know the difference.

  • @ceejay3054
    @ceejay3054 Před 3 lety

    Love his work

  • @stephenlondon3363
    @stephenlondon3363 Před 3 lety +1

    I have been watching: Colin & Ryan Stiles ever since the British “Whose Lines” & love the reruns on BBC America...Seeing early appearances of a young Wayne Brady, Greg Proops or Brad Sherwood does make me feel older but I have been obsessed with both versions of the shows for decades & thank God for all of us fans that they took a trip to Hollywood for a week which begat the American version which I watch to this day

    • @kalapiziks7561
      @kalapiziks7561 Před 3 lety +1

      I've watched them recently on streaming services. This will sound mean, but it was funny watching Wayne get older and less able to do the physical humor he so obviously loves doing.

    • @sarahjane4813
      @sarahjane4813 Před 3 lety +1

      Greg Props and Mike Macshane were on the uk version since series one.
      I love Greg and Colin the absolute best but Greg or Mike should be on the us version more they are really whats missing for me, I liked the bit of edge they brought.

  • @lrba5524
    @lrba5524 Před 4 lety +45

    LETS. GET. SHTICKY

  • @dorianwilliams9586
    @dorianwilliams9586 Před 4 lety +33

    That was the difference between UK and US improv, not versions of 'Whose Line.' He's pretty much talking about short form vs long form improv.

  • @cmodzins
    @cmodzins Před 3 lety +10

    In the British version, they do a lot more 'Film and Theatre Styles'.

  • @vulcan4705
    @vulcan4705 Před 3 lety +3

    I agree with Colin Mochrie from the television show Whose Line Is It Anyway

  • @Mark73
    @Mark73 Před 3 lety +36

    I'm an American and I like the British version a lot better.

    • @jetterjohn
      @jetterjohn Před 3 lety +4

      I'm British and I prefer the American version.

  • @zendynamite9058
    @zendynamite9058 Před 4 lety +41

    The UK version was more anarchic, wittier, more intellectual, with more obscure theatrical references and was largely uncensored. If you can get your hands on some vintage UK episodes, (Season 3 onwards) they're absolutely glorious. Far less razzle dazzle though.

    • @Scorpio9809
      @Scorpio9809 Před 3 lety +1

      They have a whole bunch on UK Amazon Prime which had reignited my love for it

    • @kalapiziks7561
      @kalapiziks7561 Před 3 lety +1

      Here in the US, Hulu has the last 4 or 5 seasons, including the one that was filmed is Los Angeles.

  • @Efemral
    @Efemral Před 3 lety +22

    As an unbiased aussie, it seems the brittish appreciate clever jokes and will applaud them even if they're not that funny.

    • @Cartoonman154
      @Cartoonman154 Před 3 lety +5

      I Fear that clever jokes are hard to come by these days, and all you need to do is just say cock. Don't get me wrong, I was brought up on Bottom, The Young One repeats etc which was more to with heavy satire. But these days we don't seem to get the clever sitcoms like Blackadder.

    • @krashd
      @krashd Před 3 lety +4

      @@Cartoonman154 I guess you never watched Upstart Crow, Plebs, Quacks, Zapped, Blandings, Man Down, W1A or any of the other sitcoms of the past decade that have easily been as funny as Bottom or Blackadder? Let alone Friday Night Dinner, which is just liquid gold.

    • @jamespasifull3424
      @jamespasifull3424 Před 3 lety +1

      Only one 't' please! 😲

    • @bobajob13
      @bobajob13 Před 3 lety +1

      @@krashd I agree with all of those, other than Blandings, the source material of which is 100 years old, still funny though.

    • @Somnogenesis
      @Somnogenesis Před 3 lety

      @@jamespasifull3424 Would you like milk with that? Sugar?

  • @G2thePee
    @G2thePee Před 3 lety

    First few eps of Colin on whose line UK I didnt get him, easily my favourite cast member since then what a hilarious bastard!

  • @baulzzzzzzz2278
    @baulzzzzzzz2278 Před 3 lety

    Him and Ryan were always my favorite they played off each other insanely well and always made the jokes that matter 😂😂

  • @thebrenn882
    @thebrenn882 Před 3 lety +3

    Colin is a comic genius. Period.

  • @That_Random_Bloke
    @That_Random_Bloke Před 4 lety +29

    My memory of whose line UK was there was ALWAYS a Canadian or American on it. And they were bloody funny.
    It kind of ruined “Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves” for me as a kid when Mike McShane turned up as Friar Tuck. He was so good on Whose Line I couldn’t take him too seriously.

    • @brianm2881
      @brianm2881 Před 3 lety

      Seemed like Tony Slattery was on it all the time as well and every time he played the host on Party Quirks, he would ask the guests if they were Lionel Blair.

    • @Somnogenesis
      @Somnogenesis Před 3 lety

      To be fair, I don't think you were meant to take Friar Tuck _too_ seriously...

  • @kalapiziks7561
    @kalapiziks7561 Před 3 lety +12

    I've recently watched all of the Drew Carey version on HBO Max and the last 4 or 5 seasons of Clive Anderson's on Hulu. The biggest difference I noticed is that the American version let's the jokes/games run on and on and on and on. Letting a joke run far longer than it should is a core foundation of American humor. (Yes, I'm American. Jokes that run on too long are not funny. Just embarrassing for the idiot who wrote it or delivers it.)
    The British version is almost always compact. I love watching Party Quirks in the British version, but I was almost always fast forwarding through that game by season 2 of the American show.

    • @Brakdayton
      @Brakdayton Před 3 lety +3

      A bit like their sitcoms. Great British sitcoms last for two or three series. With some exceptions (Only Fools, Yes (Prime) Minister) the longer running ones just get less good as they go on and on. American sitcoms keep going until they can’t afford the cast.

  • @Bison162
    @Bison162 Před 4 lety +54

    That's really interesting. I would have said the British version was more regimented and rule-following. For example, Drew Carey as a host was way more relaxed and they seemed to goof around so much more in the American version

    • @weirdbeard2244
      @weirdbeard2244 Před 3 lety +14

      Yeah. I remember Clive penalizing someone once for using an unauthorized prop (castanets, IIRC) whereas the US version has always pretty much said “screw the points.”
      Although, to its detriment, this meant that the “winner” would usually be the person that Drew or whoever thought would be least funny in the final skit.

    • @FangsFirst
      @FangsFirst Před 3 lety +8

      I think the U.S. version was more regimented in repeating the same games way more often (and obviously maintaining a pretty consistent cast)

    • @meisterlymanu5214
      @meisterlymanu5214 Před 3 lety +2

      yeah, clive anderson was a pompas, upper class prick and should never have been allowed anywhere near the show. He was everything the performers were not.

    • @refaddickproduction1
      @refaddickproduction1 Před 3 lety +5

      With the exception of josie Lawrence and Tony Slattery, who were known at the time for the comedy store players the majority of the British panellist where legit actors, John sessions, Jonathan pryce. It’s only later on when the likes of Ryan and Colin came along and Paul Merton that it loosened up a bit.

    • @lifegoals9528
      @lifegoals9528 Před 3 lety +15

      @@meisterlymanu5214 Nope, he was far better than Drew Carey, who was cringey and tried to hog the spotlight from people with actual talent. Basically America's James Cordon, a tubby clown desperate for attention.

  • @hengineer
    @hengineer Před 3 lety +1

    The show with Robin Williams,.the improv God was absolutely epic.

  • @Halbared
    @Halbared Před 3 lety +1

    Colin really hated the ho-down. I recall one where he just fainted, best joke of the night. I also still recall his 'squeaky squeaky' line. I remember lots of lines from the UK programme, it was iconic.

  • @pauljohnson5190
    @pauljohnson5190 Před 3 lety +1

    Word play- yes!

  • @PhilBagels
    @PhilBagels Před 3 lety +2

    The difference is the difference between British humor and American humor. Whether or not it's improv. It's like MPFC vs SNL.

  • @hengineer
    @hengineer Před 3 lety +3

    There was a small handful that showed up on both, Greg was my other favorite.

  • @janeandrews1790
    @janeandrews1790 Před 3 lety +5

    I love Colin. He's a pro. And...he's adorable.

  • @benbastianiartmusic1421
    @benbastianiartmusic1421 Před 3 lety +1

    I'm normally one of those who doesn't like British shows being tampered with but the American version is MUCH more fun to watch 100%

  • @auroraborelia9504
    @auroraborelia9504 Před 4 měsíci

    The lineup for the British version was so much better. When Caroline Quentin and Josie Lawrence guest starred it was absolutely brilliant 🫶

  • @michiganjack1337
    @michiganjack1337 Před 3 lety +3

    I watched the British version mostly. Much like the original Iron Chef.

  • @tonymontana1179
    @tonymontana1179 Před 3 lety +9

    He’s Scottish, born in Scotland to Scottish parents, therefore he’s Scottish

    • @welshpete12
      @welshpete12 Před 3 lety

      and lived in the US most of his life !

    • @lemiless
      @lemiless Před 3 lety +7

      @@welshpete12 Colin Mochrie was born in Scotland, but actually lived in Canada most of his life. He's Candian, and lives in Toronto.

    • @eastvandb
      @eastvandb Před 3 lety +4

      Yeah, Canadian citizen, actually, and lived in Canada for most of his life.

    • @jackdubz4247
      @jackdubz4247 Před 3 lety +5

      @@lemiless Being "Born in Scotland" makes you Scottish. Growing up elsewhere makes you miss not being in Scotland. ;)

    • @junbh2
      @junbh2 Před 3 lety +2

      @@welshpete12 Huh? He's Canadian. Very Canadian. Born in Scotland, immigrated to Canada as a small child, grew up in Canada and educated here and had a career here and so on and still as far as I know lives here. He has worked a bit in the US but he's worked a bit in the UK too. Still Canadian.

  • @bestestinventions7032
    @bestestinventions7032 Před 6 lety +43

    Colin has a red dot on top of his glorious bald head

  • @TheREALwymario
    @TheREALwymario Před 3 lety

    Is there a full version of this podcast? Where do I listen? Channel description's not totally clear on that.

    • @Improvnerdpodcast
      @Improvnerdpodcast  Před 3 lety

      yep!
      jimmycarrane.com/223-colin-mochrie/
      also on apple podcasts, spotify, and google podcasts as well.

  • @davidwilliss5555
    @davidwilliss5555 Před 3 lety +1

    I miss some of the games they did in the UK version that they don't do in the US version.

  • @connorwright1420
    @connorwright1420 Před 2 lety +1

    i’m incredibly biased being from the uk, but the british version is just so much more natural and relaxed imo - like it feels so much less try hard, that might just be my opinions on america in general though lmao

  • @raymondpruitt5421
    @raymondpruitt5421 Před 3 lety

    Those guys are very funny 😄

  • @lindamckinney3509
    @lindamckinney3509 Před 3 lety

    colin is the best at what he does.

  • @richardlyon67
    @richardlyon67 Před 3 lety +8

    I don't know what "Shticky" means. Is it a good thing, or a bad thing?
    - Edinburgh

    • @slashandbones13
      @slashandbones13 Před 3 lety +2

      To put it in a different medium, when you see a Wes Anderson film, you expect to see A, B, and C.

    • @richardlyon67
      @richardlyon67 Před 3 lety +3

      @@joemengelejr3712 Your reply, while a shite for shore eyesh, dush not purshuade me (Fact: Sean Connery delivered milk to my school).

    • @RFC-3514
      @RFC-3514 Před 3 lety +1

      @@richardlyon67 - Ish that a euphemishm?

    • @richardlyon67
      @richardlyon67 Před 3 lety

      @@RFC-3514 Thatsh positively shocking!

  • @vinnygi
    @vinnygi Před 3 lety +18

    The main difference to me is that the American version is too tailored to the performers schtick. For example, Ryan will always be someone turning into an animal or some such thing.

  • @SupremeChampion-gc2wy

    What does being sticky mean?

  • @CartoonSlug
    @CartoonSlug Před 3 lety +5

    I wish I could understand what he actually means, but I know absolutely nothing about improv :/

  • @DavidOfWhitehills
    @DavidOfWhitehills Před 3 lety

    Wasn't he in an episode of Father Ted?

  • @ljclark2177
    @ljclark2177 Před 3 lety +8

    I got nothing from his response.

  • @andywood5699
    @andywood5699 Před 3 lety +2

    I would have never guessed that there are improv artists, purists, that have their noses in the air.

  • @ukyo1975
    @ukyo1975 Před 10 měsíci

    I've seen both versions of the show from their beginning. I find the differences between the two shows first lies with the audiences. British audiences tended to be less verbose and more polite, which gave the performers more chances to create laughs; British audiences also had more tame, more PG-rated suggestions. Second, the difference is in the style of comedy itself. British comedy, in any form, tends to be more theatrical, more subtle, and more language- based. American comedy is more physical, much more in-your-face. To be honest, I always thought the American version had much better suggestions and give Ryan and Colin more challenging characters and scenes. The UK version sometimes had better performers, like Josie Lawrence and Tony Thackery, although you can't beat Wayne Brady when it comes to the musical games.

  • @Cartoonicus
    @Cartoonicus Před 3 lety +3

    Wait, are you telling me that improv purists... PLAN their improv???

  • @josephinebennington7247
    @josephinebennington7247 Před 3 lety +4

    Did he make a point? If he did it went past me invisibly.

    • @brianvaira486
      @brianvaira486 Před 3 lety +2

      He kind of rambled, but it seems like he was trying to say the British version was more experimental and varied, while the American version was more structured and formulaic.

  • @posinker
    @posinker Před 3 lety

    What does he mean when says “shticky?”

  • @sarahhardy8649
    @sarahhardy8649 Před 3 lety +2

    Question- how can it be improv if there are rules?

    • @paulchedzey7276
      @paulchedzey7276 Před 3 lety

      Sarah Hardy to improvise doesn't mean to have no rules it just means to make it up on the spot

    • @Improvnerdpodcast
      @Improvnerdpodcast  Před 3 lety +1

      there's generally loose structures to scenes, games, etc. the dialogue and how they interact is all made up! But you can definitely learn how NOT to play games, especially in short form improv.

  • @jc2333
    @jc2333 Před 11 měsíci

    The points mattered In the uk.

  • @georgeetboom7719
    @georgeetboom7719 Před 3 lety +2

    I prefer the britsh version caus it seemed more down to earth, woth the american one beong some glam show.

  • @spyrolad
    @spyrolad Před 3 lety +1

    what does schticky mean?

    • @clash5j
      @clash5j Před 3 lety +1

      Well, I'm not entirely sure what he means. In comedy terms it could be considered a not so complimentary word....like a contrivance or something that a comedian ALWAYS uses to get a laugh, so much so, that it eventually becomes tiresome. But, I think it does not always have to be viewed as a negative. Rodney Dangerfield's "I get no respect" was his shtick. That does not mean he wasn't funny. Laurel and Hardy had a shtick. You knew what you were going to get when you watched a Laurel and Hardy clip, but it was still funny.

    • @spyrolad
      @spyrolad Před 3 lety

      @@clash5j ahh thank you!

  • @strawberrylemonadelioness

    Both the UK and US version are hilarious

  • @pup123434
    @pup123434 Před 3 lety +10

    The interviewer looks like a cross between David Cross and John Malkovich

  • @TheNyarcangel
    @TheNyarcangel Před 3 lety +1

    Been watching Colin since he was on the BBC version

  • @rphrph167
    @rphrph167 Před 3 lety +9

    What is ‘schticky’??..

  • @MasterChris666
    @MasterChris666 Před 3 lety +3

    Captain hair

  • @Danmarinja
    @Danmarinja Před 2 lety

    America cares a lot more about the artist, where Britain cares more about the audience. America wants a good improv session, Britain wants a good time.

  • @Chris-rf8eh
    @Chris-rf8eh Před 3 lety +1

    I challenge any American performer to emulate the Australian accent.

  • @stonebrow8898
    @stonebrow8898 Před 3 lety

    neat

  • @ajakuk1
    @ajakuk1 Před 3 lety

    British or american version??
    Me: Brady's boys.😂😂😂

  • @tosspot1305
    @tosspot1305 Před 3 lety +1

    What is shticky?

  • @MrSamu85
    @MrSamu85 Před 3 lety

    BACKSTREET BOYS!!

  • @DevashishMulye
    @DevashishMulye Před 4 lety +2

    What does he mean by schtiky?

    • @Cobalt-Jester
      @Cobalt-Jester Před 4 lety

      I presume that he means that in the UK we don't follow the rules so close. As the interviewer says that in the USA they are told to follow the rules and not be schticky. So I presume that the UK is opposite to that. But here in UK if you give a person some "stick" it means you five them insults in a joking way. Like roasting a person. So maybe he means that. I don't know.

    • @BbGun-lw5vi
      @BbGun-lw5vi Před 3 lety +4

      @@Cobalt-Jester A comic routine inserted to gain a laugh or draw attention to oneself. A gimmick.

    • @BbGun-lw5vi
      @BbGun-lw5vi Před 3 lety +1

      A comic routine inserted to gain a laugh or draw attention to oneself. A gimmick.

  • @Dyrnwyn
    @Dyrnwyn Před 3 lety

    1:12 Can you be icky though?

  • @Porygonal64
    @Porygonal64 Před 3 lety +2

    i thought you were just an old bill murray

    • @GregorBarclay
      @GregorBarclay Před 3 lety +1

      No, Bill Murray is the old Bill Murray.

    • @GrouchoCaesar
      @GrouchoCaesar Před 3 lety +1

      As opposed to the freshly minted Bill Murray we have now...?

    • @Porygonal64
      @Porygonal64 Před 3 lety +1

      @@GrouchoCaesar please dont remind me about how melty he is

  • @MarrsAttax
    @MarrsAttax Před 3 lety

    Nice pants

  • @doctorsatan3371
    @doctorsatan3371 Před 3 lety

    Yeah because Colin and Ryan *NEVER* break the 4th wall...??

  • @dannis8552
    @dannis8552 Před 3 lety +4

    The British version was uncensored and not held down by so much of the deeply boring musical numbers. Parts of the Drew Carey version were still bogged down by music and heavy handed censorship so much so that the phrase "my right hand" was bleeped FFS!!! At least now with the Aisha Tyler version the censors are out to lunch but it really drags with too much music and occasional audience and guest star interaction

    • @monarched
      @monarched Před 3 lety +2

      It(the US version) was also hampered at times by how the network handled certain content. ABC, when they carried it, were very hands-on in regard to certain subject matter. This is likely due to being owned by Disney, which was more "family-friendly", whereas the CW, which carries it now, is more mature-oriented in it's programming. Agree on the music, and i am not overly fond of the constant use of celebrity guests(although, one of the greatest episodes ever was the Richard Simmons episode during the Drew Carey run)

    • @kalapiziks7561
      @kalapiziks7561 Před 3 lety +2

      To me a lot of it drags because for some bizarre reason, Americans seem to love jokes that run on too long. (Yes, I'm American, too. It's an aspect of American comedy I deeply loathe.)

    • @ggundercover3681
      @ggundercover3681 Před 3 lety

      @@kalapiziks7561 fascinating. I've never had an issue with the long running jokes in the American version but that might be because I just love the cast so much and I get to enjoy the moment real time sorta. I sort of like British humour, but I have to be in a mood. Sometimes I want that fast pace, I go to British, other times I wanna wind down and go to American humor. I'm glad that even though you're American, you can find your type of humour elsewhere. Imagine if everyone had the same type of humour. You would be miserable!

    • @kalapiziks7561
      @kalapiziks7561 Před 3 lety +2

      @@ggundercover3681 oh, I adore the cast. They are incredibly talented. I just dislike seeing people with that much talent getting sucked into horrible, overused cliches like the run on joke.

    • @ggundercover3681
      @ggundercover3681 Před 3 lety

      @@kalapiziks7561 ah I see. Very interesting. Thank you for your opinion. I think I'll keep an eye out now and see if I can understand what you mean. :)

  • @MrKaywyn
    @MrKaywyn Před rokem +1

    I really prefer the British version.

  • @Moreofthatminecraft
    @Moreofthatminecraft Před 3 lety

    Colin you are my absolute all time favorite. You probably won’t ever see this comment.

  • @DocJamesH
    @DocJamesH Před 3 lety

    So, "don't be shticky," literally just means don't just try to be cool?

  • @JimShadyUK
    @JimShadyUK Před 3 lety +6

    Colin talks about improv "purists", but he was one of the people who defined the genre for me. There may be "rules" I'm unaware of, but the defining rule of comedy is that it should be funny - everything else is window dressing.

    • @kivimik
      @kivimik Před 3 lety +1

      They refer to Keith Johnstone. His book, IMPRO (yes, that's how it's spelled), can be thought of as a kind of "rule book."