Why did Spain give up Gibraltar?
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 03. 2023
- Why did Spain give up Gibraltar?
The Iberian Peninsula encompasses the territories of Portugal, Spain, and Andorra, as well as part of France and Great Britain…the latter, often being forgotten. But, while the homeland of the former British Empire floats a bit further north than the peninsula, what some don’t always remember is that just below the borders of Spain sits a tiny, yet crucial, piece of land known as Gibraltar. And Gibraltar belongs to the British.
Looking at a map of Europe, however, begs the question: why does Britain own Gibraltar? Why isn’t it part of Spain instead?...
♦Consider supporting the Channel :
/ knowledgia
♦Please consider to SUBSCRIBE: goo.gl/YJNqek
♦Music by Epidemic Sound
♦Script & Research :
Skylar J. Gordon
#History #Documentary
Gibraltar, it's actually more British than Britain. When I went there they actually had a pub in the supermarket.
That is why they all speak Spanish.
@@jiminverness That is why they speak Spanish.
@@jiminverness To be frank it is not a place, I would like to live in. It's overcrowded, there is huge money laundering, drugs and lots of dirty money.
@@jesusbermudez6775 _"That is why they all speak Spanish."_
What is why they all speak Spanish?
@@jiminverness I said that is why they all speak Spanish. I never asked the question why they all speak Spanish. I made a statement, I did not ask a question.
Im Gibraltarian, its surprising and nice to see my very tiny irrelevant homeland getting a little bit of attention :-)
@@hugomartinez2387 No, en el propio video te dice que los españoles se fueron de gibraltar, es un colono ingles.
@@hugomartinez2387 Nope, my family name is Italian so ethnically I'm not Spanish. My Great Great Grandfather was from there who migrated. Though im British since I was born & live here, and raised with a British education. Also have a few family members back in the UK, who Ive visited many times. No hate toward Spaniards though, I like Spain also, just not so much their government.
@@jonjon2767 You are a brittish colonizer of foreign land in the XXI century.
Fuck Spain Jon Jon......Rule Brittiana 🇬🇧🇬🇮
It should go back to Spain
The one time Spain had a chance to retake Gibraltar, Franco refused. Why? Because picking a side that might lose, will cost Spain more than Gibraltar. In the end, remaining neutral, for the most part, was best for Spain. And Gibraltar remains British.
I visited Gibraltar 12 years ago and fell in love with the place and its people! During my visit, I learned many of the historical details outlined in this video that relate to Gibraltar’s ongoing connection with Britain. One thing not mentioned in the video is that citizens of Gibraltar enjoy benefits the same benefits as British citizens, such as higher education and healthcare, which provide a higher standard of living than is common in Spain. On a side note, a Gibraltar restaurant served me the BEST fish and chips I have ever eaten. Absolutely delicious!
The enjoy so many benefits that they pass over to Spain when they need to be hospitalized. It's one of their main complaints since brexit (they complaint to Spain, tho. As if Spain had anything to do with it).
Gibraltar is a shithole. I used to stop there often during time working on boats.
@@jal051they should not be allowed to go to a spanish hospital
@@albertomunoyerro5562no bc they are british, go to united Kingdom if they beed hospital
Spain has the best public health system in Europe, and the highest life expectancy in Europe. Gibraltar's standard of living is with tax havens stealing money needed for social services from other countries.
Gibraltar name origin: The name is derived from the Arabic "Jabal Ṭāriq" which means "Mount of Tariq". Named after the 8th-century Moorish military leader Tariq ibn Ziyad. This continues to be its name in Arabic.
As for its ancient history: Evidence of Neanderthal habitation in Gibraltar from around 50,000 years ago has been discovered at Gorham's Cave. Gibraltar was regarded by the peoples of the Mediterranean as a place of religious and symbolic importance. The Phoenicians were present for several centuries since around 950 BC, apparently using Gorham's Cave as a shrine to the genius loci, as did the Carthaginians and Romans after them. Gibraltar was then known as Mons Calpe, and it was considered by Romans and Greeks as a pillar of Hercules.
You are right brother 💞
Muslim claim everything but invented nothing.
KIM JONG-UN ?
What was its name before the Moors invaded and colonised?
Well nownit in Christian hands .So sod off Muslims 😅
Gibraltar has a pretty neat flag! It's the only British Overseas Territory flag to not have the Union flag on the upper left corner of the flag! The flag was adopted in November 1982 and is based on the coat of arms of Gibraltar, granted by Royal Warrant from Queen Isabella I of Castile in July 1502! The castle represents Gibraltar's status as a strategic fortress, while the key represents Gibraltar being the key to the Mediterranean.
The largest battle of the American Revolution by number of combatants didn't even take place in what's now the US! It was actually that time you mentioned Spain tried to take Gibraltar from 1779 to 1783! Spain, joining the side of France, saw Gibraltar as their primary aim. Spain and France had a combined strength of 65,000 while Britain and Hanover defended Gibraltar with 7,500 and 12 gunboats! The assault was a humiliating failure, and a British relief convoy under Howe sneaking in past a barricade and joining the garrison in October 1782 sealed the deal
Great short history lesson! I like your channel, perfect to play in the morning or at night to start or end the day. Keep them coming.
My grandmother was born and raised in Gibraltar. She was so proud of it. Her family moved to New York, where she met a son of an Italian and got married. Then they moved to Costa Rica. My mom visited Gibraltar on 2011.
What a globe-trotter!
Maybe do a video on Spains colonies in Africa. Ceuta and Mellilia.
dude those where spanish before morocco&collonialism existed
Do you even know what the word colony means or are you just coping?
@@alegp97 morocco existe before ur contry
Spain sometimes rattles on about wanting Britain's enclave of Gibraltar, but are they willing to surrender their own enclaves of Ceuta and Melilla to Morocco?
🇪🇸 *GILBRALTAR IS A PART OF SPAIN* 🇪🇸😊 So get use to it. Never mind *OUR* own enclaves. That's *OUR* own business. *GET YOUR OCCUPYING BRITISH TROOPS OUT OF OUR COUNTRY! NOW!* 😮🚫🇬🇧🚮🗑️↘️🚽 Or we will send in the *SPANISH ARMADA* They'll kick your British arses out!
Yes and Spain owns Portugal? No because of British protection
@@kippsguitar6539 Spain 'n' Portugal are (almost) the same country. Portugal is more like a region (of Spain) such as Galicia or Catalunya etc. than a "proper" country!
@@sanchoodell6789 Have you said that too a Portugiese resident.
@@sanchoodell6789 What a numpty!! 😂 😂 Funnily enough, many people in the regions you mentioned dont want to be a colony of Spain anymore. Will you give them the oppurtunity to vote? No.
I do like videos like this because I feel like when people think about Gibraltar, they thinking oh it's a territory that the british are refusing to let go of but not realising that the people of Gibraltar they voted to remain british a number of times, its not the UK's goverments choice but the people from Gibraltars choice, as it should be.
Also many local Spanish nearby rely on Gibraltar for income; something that Madrid often forgets.
of course they are going to want to remain British, because they were born British, imagine that for more important reasons you had to leave your house and when you come back a family has settled there and they have had children and everything, you can't take them out Force obviously but they don't want to leave even if you ask them to, you call the police and when they arrive they ask the children if they want to leave the house where they live or go find a life somewhere else, obviously they won't want to even if what their parents did is illegal for them that house has always belonged to them so it creates a moral dilemma, it is unfair for Spain not to be able to recover their territory but it is also unfair for the people who were born in Gibraltar. Britain had another similar problem with China in the Hong Kong territory and they solved it, but for some reason they refuse to do it with weaker countries like Spain, Argentina, Honduras, etc. So in this case referendums are practically useless.
@@drazig7579 Apart from the fact this goes back generations, your right they were born british but they were also born in Gibraltar which is their home and they have EVERY right to decide what to do with THEIR home.
Also Hong Kong was leased in the first place, Gibraltar had no such agreement.
@@pipercharms7374 ok, so im going to take a terrytory for your country, im going to make It a tax Heaven, im going to keep it for decades and then were going to do a referendum, are you ok with that?
@@llama878 I’m confused with what your asking here.
Am I in the territory that was taken for generations? Then I would feel at home with what I know and wouldn’t want to change it but I would like the fact I have a right to choose.
If you mean another country has taken an territory that belongs to my country, then again yes I would be fine with that because I don’t live there, it’s not my home and the ones who call it home should decide. They have lived their for generations, not me.
If all countries went back to who they first belonged to then your ripping many people away from their homes and plopping them down in a unfamiliar culture and possibly language without giving them personally a right to choose which I see as wrong.
was out there for 6 week back in 2016 loved it would move there if it was not so expensive, determined to retire there. Great video I did not know the history in depth.
Let's go Your videos are amazing!
First comment from the U.S.
As always amezing 🔥💥❤️
The fact that people are comparing this to Ceuta and Melilla
They're two total different cases since Spain had Ceuta and Melilla before the existance of Morroco
And the UN recognizes Gibraltar has a colony
@@satiresaturn8783 No they were not part of the spanish protectorate of Morroco, and again, they were part of Spain before the concept of Morroco even begun
@@satiresaturn8783 Lower Hispania (HIspanic diocesis of the north of africa) during the roman empires existed as a defined and recognized territoritory belonging to the Roman empire... so ceuta, melilla, half of marocco, tunisia, north argelia should be Spanish again.... if We take your argumentation then
A colony that has been owned by Britain longer than it ever was by Spain, and was formally relinquished by Spain. It is not Spanish. End of.
@@zigongosaurus5274 I would like to argue but ik you're not gonna change your mind
Ya pero ¿sabes lo que pasa?
Que estás en un canal anglo y aquí están todos de acuerdo en lo mismo: Gibraltar británico y España que se joda.
Da igual que informándose veas que Ceuta, Melilla y Gibraltar no se tratan igual ante la comunidad internacional.
Nadie reconoce los reclamos marroquíes sobre esas dos ciudades y Gibraltar está dentro del comité de descolonización.
También Hong Kong fue británico y cedido a perpetuidad y... ¿qué pasó?
Si España fuera China (o India, que invadió y anexó la Goa portuguesa) ya habría recuperado Gibraltar.
Por otro lado, yo soy de los que cree que si España quiere recuperar ese territorio debe invitar a su gente a formar parte.
Ver en qué les puede beneficiar formar parte de España. No se me ocurre otra manera.
Y no es cierto que seamos un país pseudofascista, con una monarquía decrépita y gente vaga, como muchos comentaros he leído.
Saludos.
An old pal of mine is Gibraltarian. Many have Spanish surnames, and English first names. The referendums were telling. Ppl who voted against remaining British were often embarrassed publicly. The people of the Rock love being British. UK has been a parliamentary democracy while Spain has swerved from autocratic monarchy, to far left republican to fascist recency to a modern constitutional monarchy .. choosing between UK and Spain is a no brainer to the people of Gibraltar.
466 / 5.000
Resultados de traducción
Resultado de traducción
Suppose the citizens of Gibraltar are subjected to a predatory tax regime by Great Britain as the Spaniards on the other side of the border suffer, suppose also that Spain then offers Gibraltarians for the next 300 years the tax status it enjoys now Gibraltar and that has turned it into a tax haven and that allows its citizens to enjoy a very high level of income, after 5 years the referendum is held agai
You have no idea of what you are talking about. According to the Economist ( the prestigious British economic mgazine) Spain is one of the only 20 full democracies of this planet. Even though I couln't care less about what either the economist or an idiot like you thinks I just don't want your lies to prevail before the public. Spain is a parliamentary democracy in some aspects more democratic than the UK, at least we are not a theocracy, (your head of state is also head of a 'national church of england'), we don't have unelected chambers like your 'house of the Lords'. We live in a secular state and our king, unlike yours, cannot ban any laws that don't suit his interests.
Gibraltarians want to remain British because they want to preserve their fiscal priviledges and their money laundering which is the true reason of their success.
@@fernandoten6002
From 1967 to 1985 Gibralarians suffered economic hardship, yet never moved from being British. They cannot be bought.
as usual : some questions exist just for not-participants !
Fantastic video keep it you're doing great job
From history point of view, while Spain was neutral during WW2, it was beneficial for the world that the gate to enter the Mediterranean sea was under control of the British
@@AntiFurry927 everyone but the spanish because free passage
@@AntiFurry927well unless you wanted to speak german japanese or italian while supporting the nazis it was pretty dam beneficial to you
@@UnholyWrath3277 how are you so absolutely uneducated?
Not really benficial fo us though. Allies were nothing but enemies for us.
@@AntiFurry927 Well unless you wanted Europe to speak German its likley better that it was British and not Spanish given that Franco was friendly with Hitler and that Spain was far closer with Germany and especially Italy than it was with the Allied Powers.
Besides dont forget how Imperialist the Spanish also were in their day having territories across almost all of the known world and in almost every populated continent in the world as they say what comes around goes around.
I like Gibraltar but it's also a weird place - it's like a pokey British town on the side of a mountain and everything is in miniature - small highstreet, small supermarkets etc. since space is at a premium. There is absolutely no doubt at all that the people living there consider themselves British and have no intention of uniting with Spain. The funny part is Spain also has enclaves in Morocco and there is a little bit of "you too" going on whenever they complain about Gibraltar.
No they are spanish and Gibraltar a colony. They have been peninsular since roman times, when ceuta was part of the iberia region, while Gibraltar is a colony, where they killed the population and force a new one that would bote for themselfs. Learn history and then you speak.
Appart from that ceuta and melilla didn't need to take aut their morrocan side, while the spanish were masacrated in gibraltar.
@@satiresaturn8783 the protectorate,but ceuta was not conquer they choose to stay with spain in the Portuguese war for independence
Cueta was part of Portugal until 1580. Phillip the Second of Spain became king of Portugal in 1580 during the Union of the Crowns. When that ended and Portugal regained her independence in 1640, Spain retained Cueta - as a colonising power.
What were you saying about knowing your history?
Wow!!!This is an interesting topic indeed,good friends!!!:-D
Same thing happened in Texas and Hawaii… Americans overtook the land, filled it up with their population and when a statehood referendum was made obvisouly the people felt American yet native Hawaiians or Mexican in Texas didn’t like it
Gibraltar have a lot of mixed race with latin speaking...not same
That's why the world is messed up and the same thieves point their dirty fingers at Russia now.
Yep
There were almost no mexicans in Texas
3:07 -- Actually, Spain did not lose Florida as a result of the American Revolutionary War of 1776. And, in fact, it did not "lose" Florida. It was sold to the U.S. in 1819 for $5 million.
"sold" the US never paid
I love seeing yalls videos but I gotta ask, why were there so few graphics and stats? I mean, like dates and names printed on the screen.
The Vichy French ( the French that collaborated with the Germans ) attempted to bomb Gibraltar from their bases in North Africa at least twice but were extremely unsuccessful ! Mainly as attempt in revenge for the British destroying the French naval fleet in an Algerian port when they refused to scuttle their ships or hand them over to the British ( so the Germans couldn't get their hands on them!) . Their bombing raids on Gibraltar were unsuccessful mainly because they were so astonished and suprised at the ferocity of the anti -aircraft fire the British put up from Gibraltar that many Pilots bottled out and just dropped their bombs in the sea ,turned around and headed back to Africa !
The Frexxch as cowardly and treacherous like their leader Macron
During WW2 the Germans' main focus was Russia due to the need of resources. If the Germans wanted to conquer England they would have done it without any problem.
@@chris1806 i only see one reply to the first comment ! what does the other one say ?
@@chris1806 They could have done it straight after Dunkirk if that had planned ahead a bit better ! But instead they delayed and dithered and gave the RAF time to re-group and re-organise
@@Sam_Green____4114 The Germans needed resources. England was of little interest to Hitler.
p.s may be it's a glitch with youtube
I have spent a week in Gibraltar last year, very beautiful place. I am currently living and working on the Isle of Man, but I am thinking of relocating to Gibraltar.
Gibraltar is amazing . It’s so British you feel you are in the UK as soon as you cross the border
Except the people speaking spanish
@@kaliyuga1476 they all speak English too
Yes. When you cross the Spanish border and enter Gibraltar on June, suddenly you need to put on your coat because the weather is the same you can expect at Blackness Castle, equally surrounded of water, that of the Firth of Forth. That is, 20 ºC less than beyond the Spanish border. And the Sun somehow slows down its way across the sky to lenghten the day 3 hours and make up for those 20º of latitude from the Table of King Arthur to Gibraltar.
Of course, the most British place in Gibraltar is the great mosque of Ibrahim at Levanter way. You can feel there as if you were beside the sepultures of Churchill, Wellington and so many other great British men and women at Saint Paul's Cathedral.
And the people, with so many Italian surnames, mostly Catholics, make you feel as confortable as surrounded by your neighbours at Eglwyswrw's little Anglican church.
Gibraltar is soooo British. 🥰
Apart from the sun 😂, couldn’t be more compared further more to uk than anywhere ! Does not feel like in uk 100% !! Apart from the fake coppers and letter boxes. Nothing else is the same
@@shsh-he5qg rubbish!
It’s a myth that the inhabitants are all British. It’s about 25% of each Spanish and British. Genoese/Italian are about another 20% and Portuguese and Moroccan account for around 10% each as well. It is a very diverse place.
What about the land!
It's very simply of a civilians point of view why not to join Spain, as literally one of the poorest Spanish cities is next to Gibraltar and Gibraltar itself is very rich...
Yes exactly, Spanish as a people are good, its just their total governmental incompetence that completely removes any thought of rejoining Spain.
The British propaganda strikes back. Gibraltar is a tax heaven and a smuggling spot
Because they are British colonist, not native population
And why do you think that the poorest part of Spain is precisely Next to Gibraltar, do you really think It is a coincidence?
Because Gibraltar is a tax heaven. More questions?
Spain owns two territories in Morocco - Ceuta and Melilla - which undermines their claim to Gibraltar somewhat. Also Franco did owe gratitude to Britain for enabling his rise to power by smuggling him from the Canary Islands to Morocco, therefore sparking the Spanish Civil War. We did that as we were worried Spain was about to become a communist state.
yes people forget that Spain still occupies territories across the straits in Africa, once they divest themselves of these "colonies" they may have somewhat of an argument to claim Gibraltar
Ceuta and Melilla were both taken long before Morocco as a nation existed. Unlike Gibraltar taken from Spain during its succession war.
@@ignacio4159 After Spain was humbled and gave it away, you forgot to mention.
@@ignacio4159 who old marrakech and fez or madrid barcelona morocco existed 789 by idris1
Please, do not fight. After all, with things in europe going the way they are, both sides should start learning Russian, lol...
I was in Gibraltar in the late 80's. Though, not as a civillian, I was in the Army (TA) on exercise. Though it was more of a holiday as we only really did our training at night in the tunnels due to the heat and in the day, we were adventure training (with 2RGJ, who were a great bunch). We did get to see quite a bit and was allowed to cross the border into Spain. There's more pubs per square mile in Gibraltar than we have in anywhere in the UK.
What!!! More pubs per square mile!! Where did that análisis of yours comes from!! As a Gibraltarian, Firstly Gibraltar today, in 2023,,is not a ragged military outcrop as some ex military personnel puts its we are trying to make best of the situation the Uk has put us in after Brexit. Our economy is based on the finance centre, online gaming, tourism, ship bunkering and others. We are trying to do our best to clean the image which, though at the time it was important, the military stiffness that once existed before, as it was at the time, Them & Us poor minions. Today, though a British Overseas Territory (a new terminology call it a colony) we have gone a long way, we manage our own taxes and our own affairs, and taking into account the situation we are in, we are not doing to bad.
@@greengardengreen6666 I'm only repeating what I was told when I went over there, don't kill the messenger 😁
Nice video
Incredible! 👏
Malta is independent.... I think it is more likely to go like this than Spanish unless London freak out and scare Gibratltar somehow.
Malta at one point voted to join the UK but was rejected by the UK government. It wouldn't impossible for Gibraltar to be a microstate like Andorra
@@goughrmp Malta joining the UK would've given the Brits a full "Mediterranean Monopoly" thanks to having control over Gibraltar, Malta and military bases on Cyprus plus better weather too. Perhaps too much influence?
That said, only 60% (roughly) of the eligible voters actually turned up to the UK-Malta referendum so it was clear it wasn't going to pass regardless.
Yes, this is the way it should go. Gibraltar should become a small sovereign country by itself.
@@lynxfresh5214the uk was being pushed to decolonize at the time and the initial economic strain was deemed as too high
The population of Malta was much bigger, plus they weren’t kicked out of their own land. Malta is also much bigger too.
They didn’t give it up, the Royal Marines took it. It is the only Battle Honour on the Regimental Battle Flag of the Royal Marines.
The Spanish did give Gibraltar up. The Royal Marines, along with 400 Dutch Marines captured the Rock on 25 July 1704. They then withstood two long sieges by the Spanish and French armies. It was then, in 1713, that the Treaty of Utrecht was signed and by this treaty, Spain ceded the territory of Gibraltar, together with its territorial waters, "IN PERPETUITY" to the British Crown. Successive Spanish governments up to the present day have forgotten the meaning of the words IN PERPETUITY.
@@adrianchurch5542 It is contested if Spain ceded any territory at all, because that Word is never mentioned in the treaty of utrecht, but territorial waters? You are just making that Up, Spain never ceded any water to britain at all in fact the only thing they ceded were the Port, Castle, town and fortifications, so you claiming Spain ceded "territorial waters" just show how biased you are.
@@javierrojo1153 , salty, just like the territorial waters around Gibraltar
@@MrPenguinos very useful comment, thank you for sharing your wisdom with us.
At this point, Gibraltar has been under British rule far longer than it was under Spain
When was it first under Spain?
@@Valencetheshireman927 from 1469 to 1704
@@quimera7012 Ah, thank you.
so if russia occupies Ukraine long enough, then it makes it okay?
@@user-op8fg3ny3j no?
During the American Revolution Hanoverian soldiers actually played a crucial role in Gibraltars defence
The Brits were a lot more worried by the French at the time than the Yanks which was only a far off side show.
The Gibraltarians are the people who decide. They chose overwhelmingly to remain British in the last referendum this may change in time if they so choose but it may suite them to remain British for the foreseeable
Yep. Same with the Falklands.
@@lyndoncmp5751 British are scammers. They take terrotories illegaly like Belice, Guyana or the Falklands then proceeds to occupied them with british people... from here can happen 2 scenarios: 1. UK grants independence after. 2. Make a referéndum with only british people. This sounds like the russian take of Ukraine, Isn't it???
Because British allow them to be a tax heaven. If tax heavens won't be feasible in the future, things might change.
@@marcind4644
Doubt it. People tend to prefer the status quo, not the unknown.
@@lyndoncmp5751 yeah, but if there will be a crackdown on tax heavens they might have to chose a new solution.
Surprised "History Matters" didn't make a video on this topic first.
You left out Menorca ! It was captured alongside Gibraltar, but the French won it back for Spain =)
It was Menorca, not mayorca, but close enough XD
@@javierrojo1153 I meant that. I'll edit the post soon
You left out all the former Spanish colonies they are now chaotic and ruined after Spanish rule and destruction, Venezuela Colombia etc
@@kippsguitar6539 So did the British, French, Dutch, etc. And before Romans and so on...
@@kippsguitar6539 yeah, it is because of Spain that Venezuela is the shithole that it is, they have been independent for 200 years, if they are still poor with the amount of land and resources they have is only on them, by the way is very funny how you talk about former spanish territories but you dont talk about places like sudan or Nigeria, which are WAY poorer and miserable than any hispanoamerican country.
Why isn't Alaska part of Canada with which it has a contiguous border and is further away from the rest of the USA than Gibraltar is from the UK?
Gibraltar is not part of the UK. It's an overseas territory that has the consent of 96.6% of the population.
They found out after brexit.
@@jal051 Found out what, exactly?
Gibraltar is the size of my neighbourhood, 30 houses do not enter there. But does it has naval importance.
there are a lot more than 30 houses in Gibraltar lol i've been around it 4 times on foot
It had a naval importance. Not nowadays.
You have 32,500+ people living in 30 houses in your neighbourhood? Where is this?
@@gagamba9198 that is over 1,000 people per house. It must be big houses.
@@jesusbermudez6775 thats just not true, it has important navel duties to this day, just because they are not shouted about doesn't make them unimportant.
Last time I was in "Gib" it seemed that many of the population hailed from North Africa, just over the straights, and more than happy to be there.
for practical matters, Gibraltar is like an amusement park for the British in Southern Spain to lure British tourists to visit Southern Spain.
I used to drive a truck to Gibraltar and as a Gibraltarian once said “you have to be sadistic to want to ruled by the Spanish”
Better that a colony. If spain had to abandon Sahara and guinea why the British don't decolonise
Millions of Brits and others nations living in Spain don't mind it. The reason why Spain will never be popular in Gibraltar are the low taxes, and subsidies combined with special treatment from the UK. If they had the same rules as in the UK, who knows what they would chose.
@@marcind4644 no, is because they are culturally british because they expulsen the spanish.
That is racist.
@@albertomunoyerro5562 they can move away... just like the British left Hong Kong.
I tapped to know about Gibraltar but ended up discovering Andorra 😅
My father came from Gibraltar while my mother's great-grandmnother came from Andorra.
Good story... Awesome...🌐🇬🇧❤️
Hi, I can translate your videos?
The use of the name Great Britain in this video is used incorrectly. The sovereign country is known as the United Kingdom where as great Britain is a geographical term for the largest island which contains Scotland England and Wales.
Mainly mentioning this as it includes Northern Ireland under the name of Great Britain when it shouldn't be as that's on the island of Ireland (but also a part of the United Kingdom.
Not the only one
@@TheMcspreader They are still separate countries.
@@JanosFeherWrong, there are 2 Kingdoms in one Country.
I am sure you can try to take Gibraltar by force to test UK resolve, if you think this tiny territory is worth having a war in your hand.
Wait, I've seen this one
does UK capable of waging war by itself? hahaha! all it can do now is wag its tail to its real master, the almighty US
@@leexingha Britain doesn't need to wage war, it owns Gibraltar. If any nation was going to try to take it they would be waging war.
@@leexingha Tell that to Argentina.
Yes, why not. Let´s behave like Putin.
Spain wanting back Gibraltar is kinda like Morocco wanting back Ceuta and Melilla.
@Knowledgia and what about to do a video about the devolution of Olivença??????
Because nobody knows about it. It’s just a small town on the Portuguese border. I bet the people there prefer to be Spanish. Plus there’s no border, you can go live there if you’d like.
Ya les dimos las Salvages, ¿no es suficiente? y no deberíamos haberles dado nada por robar la mitad de Brasil.
In my opinion, Gibraltar is one of the best places to visit in iberia, you can go visit the rock, I can go and see my family and a lot more
Good plan for geologists
Can I see your family
The people there are awful, though. Rich off of usury, they're pretty creepy too.
Best places in Iberia? It's tiny and boring.
"Your opinion is bad, and you should feel bad!" Zoidberg
The first time I've seen France and England described as being part of the Iberian Peninsula. Britain has water on 4 sides, making it an island. It's included in their definition, but they leave out most of the Emerald Isle. WTF?
Didn’t he mean Britain is on the Iberian peninsula due to them owning Gibraltar
@@Nolangainsborough I have no idea. 'Peninsula' is all about geography, not borders.
Hahaha, I was laughing too when he said Britain and France are part of the Iberian peninsula.
I am not surprised as he’s an American. their ignorance is Legendary 😅😅
@@siadwarsame2045 lol He's Romanian. Talk about legendary ignorance. 😆
@@bobhenry6159 lol, so I guess the Romanians are ignorant too just like the Yanks😀😀
Nice
Do a Video about azores and Portugal
It’s also worth noting that the population is not exclusively of British origin, yes some are, but there’s also Italians, Maltans, Arabs, a variety of people & yes they chose to stay part of the UK not Spain!
mainly british workers for some reason the uk companies dont seem to employ many locals not sure why
So the Referendum in Gibraltar counts but in Crimea, Donetsk, Luhansk no ! Total hypocrisy. No wonder the world is so messed up.
Population of 30,000. What are you smoking. The Spaniards can bring 100,000 and conduct a referendum...
Treaty of Utrecht I think where they signed it over to the brits in perpetuity.
Why does Spain have land in Morocco? Ceuta and Melilla anyone..?
Don’t you dare mention this.
Spain retains 2 exclaves on Moroccan soil, what’s good for the goose is good for the gander!
Be careful what you give away in perpetuity is the moral of this story.
Sure, still doesn't excuse the illegal invasion of the istmus of Gibraltar, nor the also illegal construction of the airport, if one side doesn't respect the treaty, why should Spain respect it? I don't think the solution is war, but the exodus of the Spaniards make any referendum really just an excuse, with the British knowing full well what's gonna happen "Oh, but it's up to the Gibraltarians" is basically lying.
Unless you’re China, in that case it’s ok to return territory.
A quick note about the referendum results - you posted "Remain as a British Territory or Rejoin Spain". You should've posted Remain in the EU or Leave, as it's misleading. Fairly good video nevertheless.
Next you should do "Why Portugal didn't take back Olivença"
Up
Because it doesn't belong to them that's why !!
@@Sam_Green____4114that's where you're wrong, my british ally. Not only does it belong, Spain recognised it, had commitment to deliver it in the vienna treaties. But it never did.
You can start first giving back half of brasil to the spanish crown or its heirs...remember oranges war in its full dimension
@@mammagon well, sure, take it then xD but treaty wise it wasn't "half of Brazil", just a small bit in the south and west; and secondly, the return of Olivença under the Treaty of Vienna, as ratified by Spain, wasn't hanging on delivering south american territory.
A shame you didn't go over the great siege of Gibraltar. It would have been worth explaining the last time Spain used force to retake it.
Don't do that, we all know what happened in the Falklands, never, never by force but could be negotiated peacefully as China done with Hong-Kong and UK agreed to return it to China 1987 or 1997.
I read a history of the siege. Apparently the British government had the choice of sending a fleet to North America or go to the relief of Gibraltar. They decided that Gib was more strategically important. The consequence of that choice was that the British army was trapped at Yorktown by the French fleet.
What an Epic piece of Land & Rock. It’s stunning as well. U.K Never give this one up 👈🇬🇧 🇬🇧🇬🇧
It would never be given up as what happened to argentina with the falklands would happen to spain except 10x worse the spanish mainland would be targetted also
why have you got the flag of your enemy (the British union flag of oppression) in your post, you are not British 🏴🏴🏴🏴
Where does the name Gibraltar originate from? Good Work!
Hello. Kim Jong Un gives a thorough explanation in his above comment. It's currently the third comment.
Spanish want territory named after arabic,
Argentinian want territory named after French (as their claim)...no surrpise they are double standard
I've never heard Great Britain being referred to as 'The Ladder'
Spain and UK are about to sign an agreement that will effectively make Gibraltar Spanish territory again.
In their dreams it stays british
@@Mauri7782 I agree, it stays British in their dreams
@@EmisoraRadioPatio bahaha no they arent. Itll be british forever
Gibraltar is british and your father Moorish
@@Mauri7782 Mother* more likely
I have been to Gibralter and too be fair the people there consider themselves to British. Even when I crossed the border and asked the Spanish what they thought almost everyone said, they are British...
They consider themselves Gribaltareños and supported by the British.
Gibraltar is British Gibraltarian. We have our own political leadership and democratically elected government. Under Gibraltar constitution, we are a self governing overseas territory, with exception on matters of Defence and foreign affairs.
Why do you make your bubble captions so small that they are unreadable, even on a large TV screen?
Did the people of Hong Kong get to vote before being handed back to China?
Nope
China was and is stronger than Britain and could just take Hong Kong if they wished it.
So Britian could not say no, and China would not give a crap about a vote
It's a different situation, the UK 'owns' gibraltar but never owned most of Hong Kong as it was on a 99 year lease. Also the CCP said that they would just take it if the UK didn't leave.
In the Hong Kong treaty it specifically said it must be returned, in the Treaty of Utrecht it did not.
@@jonjon2767 the treaty of Utrecht explicitly said that if britain violated any parts of the treaty Gibraltar has to be returned to Spain. Britain has violated the treaty time and time again, you just need to look at where the airport was built.
I say if the Gibraltans want their homeland to remain with Britain then that should be honored.
Finally, the based comment in this comment section
If gibraltar wasnt a tax haven, there would be basically no british living there, very easy to say that they want to remain with britain when they are one of the most privileged places in the world.
Sounds like how the US took Hawaii. Displace the native population with Americans and suddenly they want to be American.
@@simonb2109 Imagine then what would happen with gibraltar if losed all his privileges, pretty much all british people here would leave.
@@poorsvids4738 Pretty much yeah, same thing happened in texas before the mexican-american war. the americans and the english have both used this tactic a bunch of times, to be fair they are not the only ones who did this in all human history, but they are the most recent examples.
It is a pity the people of Hong Kong and Macau were not consulted by plebiscite if they wanted to stay with the UK and Portugal or be part of Red China, or be independent.
Always found it weird how much Spain complains about Gibraltar yet has no issues holding on to its weird little enclaves in Morocco.
In Morocco? Learn some history please. They NEVER belonged to Morocco.
Love and lovely really love to you. Gibraltor was Andulusia. After conquest of Tariq Bin Zayed it was called Jablut Tariq. Lastly as Geralter. Means the Mountains of Tariq.
Visigothic kingdom and Count Julian betrayed to Roderic
It is a bit rich for Spain to want Gibraltar back when Spain retains more than one enclave within Morocco.
Big respect from Morocco ❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹💯💯
Ceuta and Melilla are so nice too!
@@jeanbethencourt1506 But they are not Moroccan, they have been Spanish long before Morocco formed as a nation
What is morroccos opinion on ceuta and mellila I am from turkey so I am not familiar with this subject
@@sergionator1007 I never said they were Moroccan. Hopefully they will never be Moroccan.
@@batuhanyayla7214 I personally think that they are colonies
When a territory has been part of a certain country long enough that in many ways they are indistinguishable then it's de jure that country
South africa got colonized by the Dutch in the 1600. Does that make that zone theirs??😊
@@kaliyuga1476 no, because the dutch colony was yoinked by britain
@@Crimsrn then southamerica should be spanish, and africa english/french
@@kaliyuga1476 that would be good
The Polish would certainly disagree.
Geographic location does not automatically confer ownership.
and it's probaly best if the gate keeper to the mediterranean is the Royal Navy. Europe's largest navy.
Great Britain does not include Northern Ireland. The United Kingdom includes Northern Ireland, as well as the Channel Islands and the Isle of Man.
"Great Britain" can be used as a short for of "Great Britain and Northern Ireland". If you were speaking in a geographical sense then it would mean the island that is England Wales and Scotland, but in a political sense it is clearly a shortened form and means the same as UK.
Similarly "America" is used to indicate the USA but you do not take it as meaning two continents.
@@grolfe3210 I think you’re missing the point my friend. This comment only reflects the geographical position of the term because he’s referring to Great Britain within a geographical map! The political inflection is totally irrelevant in this scenario.
Actually no the Isle of Man and the Channel Islands are not part of the uk as they are crown dependencies therefore being owned directly by the the British crown
Trevor Mould: Great Britain = England, Scotland and Wales.
The UK = all of the above plus Northern Ireland.
8:09 That is the result of the 2016 EU referendum within Gibraltar not the vote on sovereignty which was in 1967 and 2002
Can't say I have ever given Gibraltar much thought, but after watching this video, I have a newfound respect for the Gibraltians; they sound like they are more patriotic with a love of being British and independent than too many wet lettuces here in the UK who would gladly sign our nation over to the EU to be dictated to.
That video went on about 8 minutes longer than necessary.
When I was briefly a teaching assistant in Sweden, Gunnar, the head of the English department, delighted in setting translation tests for the students. One sentence always came up: Det brittiska lejonet bevakar ingången till medelhavet. (The British lion guards the entrance to the Mediterranean.) I miss old Gunnar Hammarlund. A great Anglophile.
I've been to Gibraltar several times and surprisingly everyone speaks a adaptation of Andalucian Spanish called Lladito (heavily influenced with latinized English words). And most of the population lives on the edges of the small peninsula.Not much to see there, though you must see it once in a lifetime. Most of the peninsula is barren rock cliffs. Most of the population want to stay part of the U.K. territories due to British tax breaks and subsidies. Most travel back and forth into Spain daily and watch Spanish T.V., radio and such. The best of two worlds, so ofcourse they want to stay under the current status. Having British pounds, which is more than the Euro, makes it even more advantageous. Also I would say that the local Spanish towns also benefit from this arrangement. This video is so uninformed! Sounds like the video maker had never been to Gibraltar and has no idea of what he's talking about. Supposedly a large portion of the population are from Andalucia who fled there during the Napolianic invasion in the early 1800s. The other large portion was immigrant laborers from Malta, Italy and Portugal. Only about a quarter is actually British, who usually are connected to the military and administrative personnel and their families.
It is not surprising at all, the vast majority of people living there are spanish in denial Who Desire to remain "British" to mantain Gibraltar tax haven status, the only few British living there are rich retirees. And my ass the "local spanish town benefit by this arrangement" they are being keeping perpetually poor because Gibraltar with his "low" taxes and shady business is leeching off all their wealth, you should study the situation of la línea, the spanish bordertown with Gibraltar, and then lets see of you still think they "benefit of this arrangement".
Thanks for the info
We pay local Gibraltar Government tax not Uk tax and get no Uk or British tax breaks as you call it and we also don’t receive subsidies from the UK. From you comments, you obviously have no idea what you are talking about. All Gibraltarians are British not just a quarter as you claim. But I’ll leave it at that because you ain’t worth anymore of my time and I will not engage any further on the post. By the way, I watch UK Tv.
_"Most travel back and forth into Spain daily "_
They do not. The Spanish mainly travel back and forth into Gibraltar daily.
Thanks for saving me the effort of saying how clueless this video is about the current situation in Gibraltar.
Over 3 centuries yo, not 2.
So the French airforce was bombed in the Summer of 1940. Was this before of after the 22nd of June 1940, which is when France surrendered to Germany early in World War 2 ? I had not heard about that but I was aware the French navy was sunk by the British around that time after being given the option to join the British fleet (their commander in chief said no).
or sail to North America which includes French Canada.
If you see how successful British-governed lands generally became, & how unsuccessful Spanish ones did, it’s another good reason.
I agree. pretty much ALL are successful
Africa....
What of Spain's control of Ceuta and Melilla? The argument is no different to that of Morocco's claim, and many have drawn comparison. I would like you to tackle that one next Knowledgia.
And the Canary Islands
Ceuta and Melilla were Spanish before Morocco was known as Morocco.
@@thebarber5379 in your dream
@@thebarber5379 Correct, but it holds the same implications on what defines reasonable claim considering where the territories are, size, and economic/strategic importance.
@@A190xx Morocco never had the canary islands ocupied, thats the difference. Also Spain is just 150km away from those exclaves, an britain over a thousend and a half i think, so the argument from proximity is on a completely different scale.
Interesting
Middle age European wars have always been interesting in my opinion, they spend so many lives to fight wars and then go "Your nobility have been bad, bad boys so we are going to take some small territorial gains and allow you to choose new nobility from the same bloodlines as the ones we have just been at war and conquered, see you next war our continental bros"
The chances of the UK returning Gilbraltar to Spain are around the same as Spain returning Olivença to Portugal. Although the Portuguese claim is a lot stronger, neither will happen... So don't cry about it Spain and forget it.
literally nobody claims olivenza, plus, the status of gibraltar are miles away from the status and repercusions of gibraltar
This is a informative video: not a crying video + the channel is not hispanic
Portugal claims Olivença since since the Spanish invasion and according the Vienna treaty agreed in 1815 Spain should had returned it long time ago. Even today, on any official map the border around Olivença is not defined. Anyway, its just a bit strange all this spanish cry about Gilbraltar when they occupy territories Olivença and the north african cities. If logic applies, they would have to return those territories to be entitled to Gilbraltar, luckly for them, logic doesn't apply...
@@cfmcabrita the status of those territories and the status of Gibraltar are completely different, ask the UN if you dont want yo believe me
@@javierrojo1153 You mentioned the UN. The UN is an organization where countries meet to reach agreements. In the Olivenza case an agreement was already reached between Portugal and Spain in 1815 to restore it to Portugal. Spain just decided to not honor their own signature. The English never said they would leave Gilbraltar. Now you tell me, who have a bigger claim? Spain doesn't have the higher ground neither legally or morally.
Even the Spanish population of Gibraltar want it to remain British.
Exactly, who would in sane mind want to break down their own tax haven and the wealth that comes from that?
Gibraltar devers there wishes from 🇬🇧
Some Spaniard has been quoted as saying, "For heaven sake just give Gibraltar to the British just let them give Spain back to us".
Britain doesn't need spains approval to keep gibraltar
Spain talking about this, as though like they are still not holding any pieces of tiny lands in North Africa.
I feel if Spain handed over in a treaty is Sovereign British territory Spanish respect your word
I would say more than feeling British, they would just not receive the same benefits from the Spanish government
The Spanish built a great fort and wall along the border but can't find any info on it
3:18, Spain didn't lose Florida in the aftermath of American Revolutionary War.
Spain, along with USA, were the winner in American Revolutionary War, with England, French, and Dutch as the losers. Spain gained Minorca from that war, and there was a sense of rejuvenation in Spain navy after a century under England's navy shadow. The territory of Florida was sold some three decades later to USA, it was not lost during that war.