Justice Chandrachud-'Narrow Concept Of Merit Allows Upper Caste PeopleTo Mask Their Caste Privilege'
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 12. 2021
- Justice Chandrachud- 13th B.R. Ambedkar Memorial Lecture on "Conceptualising Marginalisation: Agency, Assertion, and Personhood".
Dr.Justice Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, judge of the Supreme Court, said that a narrow concept of merit only allows upper caste individuals to mask their obvious caste privilege.
LiveLaw brings you the latest legal news and updates from India and beyond.
We are into fact based legal journalism.
Endeavour of LiveLaw is to play an active role for a transparent and democratic legal ecosystem, in the larger public interest.
Stay updated. Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/2pskgB3
Support Us: bit.ly/35qFj6A
Visit Our Website: www.livelaw.in
Facebook: livelawindia
Twitter: livelawindia
Instagram: livelaw.in
Live Law app is India's fastest legal news app that will keep you updated on the latest law/legal news from India and across the world. Download now.
Android: bit.ly/2toaimp
iOS: apple.co/39dQ0vh
A narrow concept of merit helps the political class hide their privilege and get away with it by blaming it on the upper caste. When nepotism is systematically rooted out of the court system especially amongst the Supreme Court advocate and judges (most of them are from political families) will merit be respected and social change can be bought forth into Indian society.
FYI, Justice Chandrachud is a prize winning Harvard law grad & doctorate and his dissertation on judicial science is recognised in the global law community. After working as a senior adv in SC, he was appointed as an addl Solicitor General of India and later on appointed as a judge in Bombay HC. He became Chief Justice of Allahabad HC in 2013 and soon appointed as SC judge. Also, his father was longest service CJI from 1978 till 1985.
@@kch2810 he's a prime example of narrow concept of merit. His father was quite politically connected, ensured that his son got the introductions, the education and internships he required to fulfill criterias to get into Harvard. His father did arranged the money and approvals (Bureaucratic redtape like ECNR - Exit visa) that was actively denied to the middle classes.
You can't celebrate his achievements without ignoring the enormous political connections that was available to him by his father and exploited to achieve his goals aided by opaque system called the collegium.
@@libshastra Now that’s a lot of assumptions. Regardless I’ll give u for contriving baseless assumptions to fit your narrative.
@@kch2810 baseless? I doubt you lived in the pre-1991 era. Education and jobs were rationed out (and they still are rationed out to a lot less extent). ECNR was a thorn (and often denied without political connections) for anyone who wanted to go abroad for who had to go to a global conference, program, university until late 1998. Jobs especially those with the courts still require deep political connections, a sessions court advocate applicant still needs a bench of judges to assess "the character" of the applicant. And you think it's contrived?
Oh yes, his first job in India was Senior advocate Supreme Court and Bombay High court. That's pure nepotism right there.
Which rock are you sitting under? I'd like to sit under that just to ignore the miseries around me.
@@kch2810 if its baseless then why we don't see any judge who is From middle class ? Like anyone whose parents are government servants ( clerks, accountants , doctors ,engineers etc ). There are many who are I India who deserve much better place but are denied opportunities. Also harvard University is something which is not affordable even by normal citizens of other countries too. 🙄 the fact you said his comment is baseless shows your level of ignorance , I think this is one of paid media who just want to rub their mindset into public. Ok I can understand its very common nowadays , but please don't think that our iq is this much low.
Except Dr Ambedkar himself, none of you give any credit to Mr Benegal Narising Rau who did all the ground work, travelled and met the constitutional heads in Europe and America. He did not expect anything in return! How can people forget such founding fathers in drafting the constitution?
We do remember him sire. B.R ambedkar himself praised him,who later went on to chair the ICJ. He is well remembered,but just like the Congress have removed BOSE,Shyamji krishna verma,INA trials at length, Savarkar,he was just another move on this great board of chess.
Yes. Even I don't consider him the sole person responsible behind constitution. He may be a member but Constitution do not belong to him
He was not member of constituent Assembly, however he was hired to assist the Assembly. So technically he is not founding father of the constitution.
@@vidyasagar580 he was the technical person. Hired to throw light on Constitution drafting. While ambedkar just drafted. All the ideas were brought and pasted from other countries. Ambedkar applied no mind. And even later constituent assembly applied their mind on Constitution.
True.well said suman ji👍
Future of India in good hands...!!
It's India where Merit is narrow concept, and Reservation is broad. Nice
An idiot like think so. merit does not belongs to your group but it also belongs to other groups who does not even have acces to education equality, liberty,. The pathetic situation here is the other so called caste hindus like Shathriya, choodras thinks they are pride to hinduism but hinduism suppressed them too they did't realises it.
Watch the entire video my friend
video dekh le gawat pehle poori
both merit and reservation goes hand in hand. read michael sandal book. tyranny of merit. merit is a concept which we often perceive as unbiased and clean but in real its not!
nepotism is something which we all do and face but has been so internalised that we avoid to question it. and reservation is not a benefit but rather as a tool because those people who have been forced and subjected are also deserve to get what they deserve.
@@vocal4equal737 i understand your disagreement but i think it would be more appropriate to explain your point rather than just lambasting him. isnt?
Look who is talking about caste privilege.... what about postion privilege sir
I know after 15 yr your son /daughter going to hold the position of yours
He has so much experience and knowledge of the world, why should he Not strive for his children to be holding good , responsible positions. He must be a householder too.
atleast not on the reservation basis
@@manusharma-ht1bw it's reservation, collegium system is family based reservation
This maha judge has taken advantage of his surname. Any generalisation of merit is unfair.
He’s a prize winning Harvard Law grad & phd and his dissertation on judicial science is recognised by the global law community. Perhaps you should check his acumen before trolling like a witless cow dung filled bhakts.
@@kch2810 you ought to pick a better person as an example of merit. Justice Chandrachod is a prime example of Nepotism. Nobody gets to become a senior advocate of the Supreme Court of India and Bombay High court (without local experience) without strong political connections with sitting benches. Guess who had maintained that, YV Chandrachud.
@@kch2810 Real ID se ah Abhinav Chandrachud
Cases backlog also affects those marginalized. That is the ball in your court, Lord.
Well pointed out!
And i think they have been talking about it. Watch the constitution day 2021 speech of CJI NV Ramana. His speech was mostly around judicial pendency.
@UCRDriOYyFM2Y6E6G-hju61A Giving speeches must not do everything but surely does something. That something adds to the collective effort of making society a better place.
Superb.
Essentially he is saying we dont need "equality of opportunity" rather we need "equality of outcome" what a sick concept that's why our growth as a nation is stunted we are WOKE from ages practicality goes down the drain here.
This is the season of speeches, especially for sc judges. Had these judges heard the cases of CAA,KASHMIR or at least habeus corpus petitions from Kashmir these sermons would have been meaningful. Escape people from sermons of judges.
Tq sir ur justice !! 🙏🙏🙏
Say reservations & hence justified , Since 75yrs still I see many Dalits ( who actually deserve reservatn ) on streets & cleaning sewages JUST BCZ OF OUR PSEUDO SOCIAL JUSTICE JUDGMENTS , which is allowing only BENEFIT family students & grand children to get reservstn seats & hence actually deserving looses hope in education & carryon with d same work!
& These ppl who had enjoyed benefits from 75yrs still say unequal & ask reservations for their great great grandchildren & INVITE TO these ceremonies & U pass out such illogical statement to current generation & pushing current youth back into old-age & create caste divide
RESERVSTIONS r meant to b for bring equality , not crushing other community ! & Hence thy had time limits !
My only hope was on supreme court & U sir ! Now evn that lost TQ
Comments show how narrow is our comprehension capacity. The sheer inability to entertain the other side of an idea/concept, and instead barraging with pitiful personal attacks & baseless accusations. It's quite fascinating & tragic.
A lot of general category people get frustrated when facing life and blame the failures encountered on 'quota' system.
It is not fully correct. India has a lot of other more important systemic problems and reservation is a small problem amongst that. Lack of job opportunities, population, developing country status, lack of manufacturing/entrepreneurship etc are the real problems rather than reservation alone.
I feel like reservation is justified for the sc and St categories but not so for the so called OBCs.
"Narrow concept of merit "
LOL .
Someone ask him how he became judge of Supreme Court??
His father was judge in SC and now his son will become soon.
Such a hypocrite!!?
He is a product of nepotism along with justice rohington Nariman, Khanna and other nepo kids.
They they gut appoint a fair committee or comission for selection of judges.
It is shameful that in our country judges appoint themselves their kinds .
His father and son also in the same profession and I guarantee you he will become a judge one day,..keep it as noted...
@@abhimanyusingh6761 v true
Yes, it will not be a surprise if his son gets appointed as sc judge...
There is no privilege in poverty.
its an opportunity to live life and not live like a vegetable.,Challenges set goals .
Society led poverty and natural poverty are different.
@Tangent of Circle shut up, poverty can be from different reasons, so yes there are different reasons for poverty and these reasons can be social, economic and political too. Shame on your narrow mindset of poverty.
The untouchability isn't only restricted to upper caste dr Ambedkar comes from mahar community. Mahar community considers Mandu community untouchable.
Bang!! You just exposed them.
True, there is a caste hierarchy amongst so called lower caste as well. Which they never brings forward in any debate.
@@Lawyer_Hindutva this is all just a hoax they have a agenda of criminalising Brahmins
Caste discrimination is very deep rooted in hindu religion that's why he converts into Buddhism instead of living in caste hierarchy of Hinduism
And remove it
But after converting he still put efforts to remove caste discrimination
@@abhishek.h98 So these so called intellectuals must say that it's not only restricted to Brahmins or pandits but they won't say that it won't work for their propoganda. Ambedkar himself said he doesn't know why people saying that I've made the constitution he further said he will be the first one to burn it.he proposed only 10 years for reservation.
@@abhishek.h98 What efforts he took to remove this discrimination within his community which equally practised in that community.. Please throw some light to it.
There is no need of reservation.
Dalit is the word everybody use for their personal purposes as well as professional purposes but nobody wants their upliftment because it will shut the business of so many running political parties, organisation, NGO.
And will end the career of so many dalit politician and dalit lawyers.
In today's world everybody wants to discuss problems but nobody wants to be a part of solution.
Excellent speech by Hon.ble CJI. I really admire CJI the way in which the hard facts were presented and analysed.
If he wants to promote equality then he should step down & allow either Dalit or OBC judge to become next CJI. Woke Judge.
See... Your argument is not practicable... The appointment of cji is based on knowledge... If one dalit has knowledge and eligibility they can also be cji... Don't worry
Ashtavakramuni teaches King Janakan (poster father of Sita) to the effect that "one's body does not belong to him". Two terms, (1) ''citizen' and (2) 'person' are important from the point of view of Part-III (Fundamental Rights). Dr. B. R. Ambedkar has not only pilotted the Representation of People's Act but has contested election from Worli, Mumbai to fail in his utmost humility like me who once contested the Corporators' election in KDMC (Kalyan Dombivili Municipal Corporation) under BSP.
Sir please help Me my case
Please don't gas light people who are working hard on merit by putting all of us under a privileged umbrella. We work hard and not all of us live in ivory towers . Please come out of your bias and break that privilege bubble for some time. I ain't against reservation yes many scheduled caste and tribals actually need it but reservation is no more about social mobility or upliftment but it's more about vote bank politics and creating and insuring a teflon image of a leader . Its is being used as a scapegoat or a glorious promising curtain to block real life issues like not enough schools in tribal areas , not enough teachers in underprivileged areas , not enough literacy for the marginalised or health care and nutrition .I rarely see the underbelly of the situation being addressed . Why isn't any dalit or tribal actually asking why even after soo many years of reservation are we actually still behind? Why only few Dalits or tribals prospering but not the majority?why the caste system still exist ? Why do obc even need reservation when they were never systemically marginalised?It only means this system is genuinely flawed or need additional help .Sir working hard and achieving merit requires hardwork . Hardwork is hardwork privilege may help but it never goes a long way . At the end it's a person's talent and not privilege. You cannot take the lake near the horse you have to bring the horse near the lake . No doubt privilege helps except few really unfortunate souls who have my best wishes almost everyone is some way or another is privileged. If someone has house and car but may be a terrible family, if someone is poor may be that person is academically amazing etc . Most people are blessed in one way or another also most people are unfortunate one way or another . Thats what average people are .
Excellent lecture by CJI On the Dr te topic Ambedkar memorial lecture on Marginalization Assertion, and Personhood.
Sir this is not about the caste sir its about economic status
Low middle upper classes
Person like you at your position don't speak the language of someone's else
Speak logical
Sir please explain after how many generations of dalit or lower caste's reservation should end .
And I know people in my college who's father having goog government job
Schooling in convent school and still they are SC ST
What's your thought after how many generations a persons family will remain dalit or lower caste or SC ST .
Dont deny the prejuidice they hold for status quoism of hegemony in society
Wonderful. Amazing conceptual clarity.
Sir, you also highly merited judge.
Social security - majority of govt offices , colleges , & universities occupied by SC,ST OBC
ECOMICALLY - EVERY ST,SC , OBC have fee reimbursement + loans for less interest + colleges without merit , + jobs & Ecomical stability without merit for almost 75 yrs
UR super rich - fled away from this country because they anticipated this SILENT GENUCIDE will happen , which is unfolding on MIDDLE TO LOW ECOMICAL STATUS UR Student , whose parents stop eating 2times /day , just to pay fee of COLLEGES OR for book , bcz thy r sined to fall in UR & after getting ranks on merit - U say merit has no value !🙏👏👏 This speaks everything sir about our justice in this country !
V definately have OUTLINERS in UR community & so in SC,ST & ESPECIALLY OBC(Majority of outliners ) - who treat UR badly ! But just for those UR outliners , ur punishing MIDDLE CLASS MERIT ! EVN WAYS RICH UR fly away of buy seat !
U don't consider MERIT UR as people of this country also & pass judgement & feel ur R heroic & saved sm psudeo social justice ! - COST OF IT is MERIT LEAVES INDIA & BECOME CEO IN OTHER COUNTRY & DEVELOP THOSE NATIONS
GOVT OFFICE'S HAS reduced to a joke on engineering side , tht Y govt have to tender for pvt companies for skill , advice & work on small roads !
NOW next in line is GOVT. HOSPITALS
Correctly said
Me and some of my friends belong to Upper Caste. We have graduated with first class. We are not getting jobs that worth our degrees, so we could take financial responsibility of our families. Where is our Upper Caste Privilege if there is one in existence??
See, If we go back to your comment, the complaint is about not getting a worthy job, let alone “a job”. This in itself is a privilege, considering there are communities which are considered not worthy of even standing in front of the so called upper caste. Having said that, this is not to trigger you or anyone reading this comment, so that you jump in and start defending yourself. This is rather for everyone to think why reservation is a step in the right direction. Now you could question, why when I’m not the direct oppressor supposed to endure discrimination in the form of reservation? The truth is, you have indirectly benefited from the exploitation carried over by your ancestors for thousands of years. The last sentence might have hurt you. If so, I apologize as it is not my intention. Back to my point, people who call themselves upper caste think of reservation as a punishment. The TRUTH, IT IS NOT. If you are still not convinced, let me ask you a question. My father is wealthy and he pays more tax than the bottom 90% of the people in this country COMBINED. Hold that thought. Now why should he pay that much? Aren’t we using the same road, public transport, etc. if you find that argument insensible, then unconsciously you support reservation.
@@sabarimanohar1178 Good 👍explanation
@@sabarimanohar1178 u explained it well👍
@@sabarimanohar1178 thank you. ❤️
Is it the Mandal issue that is being ignored.Reservation i leading to vacancies not being able to locate suitable candidates applying from SC /ST but at the same time denying the post to capable candidates who are not from the reserved category. Is this notleading to corruption .
He should become a politician as he defiles logic.
Sadly as Ambedkar said Society gets the leader it deserves
I guess u r from upper caste.
@@kch2810 ooh probability u r from Pseudo lower caste! Where ur grandfather enjyd reservation & doing govt job ! Ur father enjoyed doing govt job ! Doing corruption in govt & eating Money like pigs buy u cars & vehicles & make u study in good schools clg & universities in par with any other student even u don't hav knowledge to earn it ( in the name of reservations) now u cm talk about social justice & want ur children & grand child have same privalages & deny to help those actually deserving candidates for reservstns who r in villages & city doing cleaning roads etc....!
His logic is straightly hiting the target
@@pnikhil4911 that’s why stupidity has no caste or any social identity. Just another hallowed vessel echoing the sheep bleats.
Last breed of chief Justices who deserved to be remain as CJI till life long. Rarely v get such species who understand our society beyond laws books and give a new shape to the just jurisprudence.
Reservation=representation
23/1/2024 12 : 22 pm
सुप्रीम कोर्टाचे उत्तम व्यवस्थापन करणे डाॅ. सरन्यायाधीश धनंजय चंद्रचूड साहेब करत आहेत. धन्यवाद
Upper caste Hindus demographically make up less than 30% of Indian population. By this logic the comments here should be equally for and against reservation. Yet the comments here are overwhelmingly anti reservation. So if we only consider understanding of english and Internet access, the upper castes are privileged enough. Still you all think of yourselves as the most downtrodden in the country. Why? Because you think it's normal to have such privilege. Some of you say you left country due to reservation? Leaving country means you have had no small privileges.
I am proud that our country's constitution doesn't just assures equality on paper but takes proactive steps in law to ensure this. Not even countries like USA and others have done any such things to root out racism. A country will progress when poverty is rooted out and social justice is provided. By these standards we look on the right track.
Imagine the world we are living in, where merit is disregarded.
Yes disregarded 😅😅😅
Sir 'you are a real Nyayamurti - The
Person himself is a statue Justice.
Dr Ambedkar funding to take action of the population of our country India .
Caste discrimination and previlige must be made illegal...it's not good practice for my lordships to make complaint as they have power to make laws itself suo moto..if such previlige and discrimination do exist the courts must take at up suo moto and make exemplary punishment.
But the humor is those who hold power never want to bring changes.
My lordships have power to change this country but my lordships do not exercise the power for reasons known best to them and watch people suffer.
Lord Krishna once said there is a difference between duryodhana and yudhishthir.
Duryodhana knows dharma/duty but doesn't act on it and wants to follow adharma.
But yudhishthir knows dharma/duty as well as act on it..
That is the difference.. mahabharat war was faught because someone tried to disrobe a women..and nowadays we sit in trial for years and acquit rapist for lack of evidence...
Moto of supreme court " yato dharmasya tato jaya"
One who does his dharma/duty always wins.
Similarly Knowledge of law is one thing but bringing it into practice is something other.
Great analysis of caste system prevalent in India. 👍👍
Judges should not biased and act as social reformers. Such basic sense should be there with them not to talk and act favoring certain sections as social reformers.
Honble judge,, s c. .itself explanation of Constitution. I have Great respect for him.
While we do have a few Indian judges whom we can be proud of !
Yes true. Narrow concepts of family make the kith and kin to pursue the profession, business etc in India. Reformation should start from within and not by offering advice. One has to follow what he/she preaches. The problem in India is that merit is not recognized nor appreciated. Mediocrity wins.
Not even mediocrity....base thinking wins...
Hope the present CJI works in a unbiased manner
A perfect candidate for impeachment.
102 Birth anniversary of Honorable Justice Shri. Y V Chandra Chood.
Excellent speech.
Excellant Experience By Me .Thanks .
Ambedkar sir introduce the law to secular change in our country India .
So basically we upper caste are bad/ atrocious and must be pushed down just because we are born in that caste. That's the wisdom of your lordship. 🙏
@@justahumanbeing3916 the issue is not just with respect to reservation. And if you know the practical aspect of SC ST Act then you were not saying these words.
Earlier he blamed the police for poor investigation for least conviction in SC ST case,
He is a judge, how he reached such a conclusion without any data for that matter.
He may be a brahmin Or may not be one. But this does not give him the right to say anything without any basis.
Well said!
And how many instances of 'pushing down' can you point out?
Merely acting as a victim won't make you one when thousands are still victimized for the caste they are born in. And none of them are upper castes, clearly.
Hope you read about the dalit who was attacked recently in Uttarakhand for eating with the rest of the people and not 'minding the caste lines'. Please wake up and look around.
@@Lawyer_Hindutva am not here to convince you or give you stats which you should be Looking for on your own... talking about police spoiling the investigation, Arushi Talwar case is a prime example of how carelessness and stupidity on the part of police ruins the whole case.. initial stages of a crime is crucial time for collecting evidences and police are the ones delegated with that responsibility and if they fail to do their job honestly and dedicatedly then later delegating the case even to CBI would do no good.
@@ayeshaaziz644 my dear friend you are right in pointing out that police ruined the investigation. But making a general statement that all SC ST case are in discharge because of poor investigation is not just wrong but outrageous.
That's not how rule of law works. There are maximum frivilous cases which are filed under SC st act.
So have practical knowledge first. Don't be an emotional fool.
Privileged and underprivileged sections exist in all settings. A Merit based system, makes sure, the difference among the classes is minimised, moving forward. Some sections may take longer to progress, but eventually they will close the gap. It will make sure of financial, intellectual and emotional elevation of the sections.
And how about privilege that you get from nepotism "Brown-shahib".
Anyone who has a problem with him reading from a paper or with the fact that he comes from a privileged family, know that he is not sitting free.. He is not a politician who has to impress the crowd... It's a lecture where people from legal fraternity are sitting, and he has taken time out to address them.... When you speak without preparation, you might miss out on something/ not organize the content well... It's alright to write/ make someone write when you are so busy.... Anyone who has a problem that his father was a Judge, have you ever been to the SC and seen how he listens, throws brilliant questions, and has the guts to dissent ? People with not even half as much merit as him, commenting like fools !
And then come the upper cast who are representing his words in the wrong sense and garnering support for it ! Now that's privilege !
@@aniruddhakashyap6906 No one is great... He does what he does best, and doesn't just preach (what you call "virtue signalling others")... Adhaar was obviously not a money bill, but he was the only one who could say that... I've seen those proceedings, so I can go on and on about how he brought up really important questions .. He kept himself unaffected by public opinion and gave a legally sound judgement in Arnab's case...
Coming to this speech, misrepresenting his words because what he's saying is uncomfortable, doesn't take away from the fact that there's truth in it... So while I do feel bad when someone gets through with an extremely low score because of reservation and I don't make it with a much higher score (just faced that in Haryana Judicial Services), I feel even worse when I see people who've scored more than me but in terms of skills and legal aptitude they are far behind... I've seen so many coming from really good law colleges (I myself am from one) and schools where they made it through merit, or being in government job where they made it through merit (I've worked in a PSU with others with so called "merit"), but when it comes to working, they are so stupid... Can't even draft, they don't know under what provision a certain Complaint/application is to be made, can't interpret provisions... Can't even write mails... They are not freshers but with enough experience to be able to do these things, but they can't ! It's this lack of skill, maturity and professionalism that keeps them from clearing exams which actually have a level (like DJS), but they'ill comfortably blame it on reservation... Meanwhile others who don't behave like them, have true merit, use their resources and clear these exams..
I think twice before comparing myself to an SC/ST because I've seen how they are still treated despite being educated and working in the same office as us... It's done so slyly, that you cannot do anything about it... It is more concerning to see people with privilege, better social status in every way, connections not having actual merit, and complaining... I mean you couldn't even understand such a simple comment above... There's nothing about his or anybody's "greatness" in my comment...
Not really 😕, I think regardless of what he is and where he is from. Right now he is someone who is given a higher position and this liable to be commented upon. This is democracy, so just like others he is also same until he vacates his position. Understood. You are blinded by his performances in court whereas infact its his duty to do so and how can you assume that people half of merit cannot perform better than him . You are also not someone who is capable to judge others here. So get a life
Thanku live law😊
Comment section is filled with pressed upper caste lot. But ofc it was forthcoming.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
You are like the black peoole of America. You will always be in gutter
Narrow concept of merit??? Are you serious??? 😑😑😑👎👎👎
Thanks for this knowledge of the greatest thinkers
This chipmunk hates merit because he'd never reach SC if it were not for his father.
This bugger gave sabarimala verdict isn't it.
Must be remembered.
As a lawyer and judge he's taking sides, like that rajivdhavan who lawyer who was against ram mandir.
I sed similar language
I got a hate comment from a Muslim when wrote similarly on rajiv dhavan.
You have to listen to that liberandu.
Hes from northeast and a lover of faiz.
Judges mustbe selected by people and must be accountable to people.
Exactly.
True that!! 😄 🤣 😂 😆
What about poor members of so called upper caste ?
Sudama quota hai na beta
Sir 1 QUESTION SIR
U ( SUPREME COURT JUDGMENT ) said reservations r NOT BIRTH RIGHT !
please explain me this sir than ,
A candidate get RESERVSTN & get seat in UNDERGRADUATE medical colleges with their peer UR of rank 1/3 to 1/4th his rank + low fee & every way supported & majority of college seats r filled by OBC & ST & SC candidate ( SOCIALLY SECURITY also better ) AFTER 6YRS of in d name of sm 100yrs ago injustice u give them all these benefits ( Named as RESERVATIONS ) still after coming out of 6yrs - thess same people get even more reservstions than tht of UG seats , again in d same name of discrimination - THEN WHT IS IMPORTANCE / PURPOSE IF GIVING THEM RESERVSTNS IN UG MEDICAL SEATS SIR ( it means u ur self i.e supreme court SAYS RESERVSTN NOT BIRTH RIGHT & same court SUPPORTS RESERVSTNS IN PG & passing such statements in sm dalit organisation programs and make it as BIRTH RIGHT ! !!! V FUNNY Sir 🙏
Only ppl v look for genuine justice is SUPREME COURT &. Judges here also speak d same way & see india as 1980s caste feeling during those childhood age.....🤦
Its the merit which keeps the world moving forward not reservation .
Google it
Every country has affirmative action ! Use brain
So reject ur religion which gave 3000 yrs of godly reservation and deprived rest others from receiving education. End ur religion, and end Reservation. Happy? And give separate electorates to us. Reservation was given by gandhi. We dont need it. We need separate electorates demanded by Dr Ambedkar.😂
Literary corrupt judges!
Good Evening And Happy Monday
From
Arunava Dasgupta and family
Member International Court of justice
And
Member International criminal Court
The Netherland s
Sir talks about privilege and their father was a justice, sir himself is a justice and their son is a practicing lawyer BTW a good one. So, privileges are in every section of the society . Just by saying someone has it doesn't show you the whole picture.
The hypocrisy of it all...that this honorable Justice is a product of the very elite he so deplores. He himself is a Brahmin and son of a former CJI. WHILE that doesn't deprive him of his rights to talk of these things....the very thing he deplores is no longer the reality in modern India...particularly urban India. The incident he begins with were part of the late 19th century. No one talks of the very same structures which helped Ambedkar..to help come up in life...support from the so called forward community. Its people like the present speaker...who instill a constant negative message rather than take a more sympathetic view and help the society grow. The question of identity cannot e so easily brushed away...
अमीर गरीब, धनी निर्धन, विद्वान निरक्षर, बडे छोटे
शांति सद्भाव, धैर्य,स्नेह, विनम्र, भक्ति,भाव, श्रृद्धा,सत्य, अहिंसा का पालन करते हुए रचनात्मक, सकारात्मक, गुणात्मक, तरीके से
राष्ट्रीय मैथमेटिक्स साइंस एंड टेक्नोलॉजी रिसर्च सेंटर
शोध के द्वारा उन्नति, तरक्की, प्रगति के अलौकिक ज्ञान प्राप्त करने के लिए मेहनत, परिश्रम, अभ्यास, अनुभूतियों के द्वारा प्रयास करना चाहिए जो देश हित मे हो*
*धन्यवाद*
Exactly. I don't see the point of taking exam, let people of category take whatever seats they want, no matter how rich they are or for how many generations they are enjoying the privileges of belonging to a particular caste. If any year 1,2 seats are left, we who may not have enough to get good education but are General caste, will sit for the exam.
This is the man who helped Modi to brutally ra.e our constitution by allowing reservation in medical education to cross 50%. My people who may not get to eat properly twice a day won't dare to dream any more, so that Amit Shah's and his sons and grandsons and their grandsons can study in foreign schools.
Good spich sir
I am not able to understand a country where Ramayana is written by Valmiki, Mahabharata written by Vyasa, and even today Both are kept at esteem, and puranas, Vedas, Upanishads all these no body said it is written by Upper caste or Brahmin, but respected more by Brahmin. How this theory of non touching came, and when from ? Hindus have no Brahmin God, but non brahmin is worshiped by Brahmin. Shiva, Krishna, and many more. Brahmin is not a caste it is way of living, which is a tough path.
Clearly he is not choosen by merit, need NJAC as soon as possible
Demonising UCs after raking in all benefits. What a leech!
Reservations for upper castes functions through connections, networks and contacts formed due to decades/centuries of presiding as informal rulers of the society.
Kaun si duniya me je rahe ho bhai. ??
@@Lawyer_Hindutva Uss dunia me jahan log denial me nahi hain.
@@RippleReader124 good for you. Hopefully you elevate yourself to the reality. And see the ground situation.
@@Lawyer_Hindutva Please enlighten us about the ground situation. I hope we can have a good converation about this.
@@RippleReader124 a thief came to Mr. X house, he tried to unlock mr. X scooty by applying the key. Mr x and family say him in the cctv camera, they alarmed and the thief ran away. Later that evening the thief was seen again in front of the house. Mr X and family immediately stopped him and tried to enquire. A little quarrel started. Turn out that the thief was working in the house of Mr. Y who live in the same locality and the terms of Mr. X and Mr. Y were not good.
Next morning a case under SC ST was filed against Mr. x (thief belong to the chamar caste as per the certificate produced by him) ... It was alleged that Mr. X and family abused the thief by castism remark.
In reality they did not even knew who that thief was.
Police filed chargesheet and trial court framed charges.
There are n number of cases like this. This is happening in the society . In the name of SC ST Act, people are filing case if they indulge in any kind of dispute.
And it is where Mr chandrachud's statement becomes deadly.
Absolutely true sir... That's why no one talks about the why 97% "Safai karmachari" are Dalit...And all the Main priest are Brahmins....
This should be changed if we want to end caste, inequality n reservation...
Most priest Brahmins are poor , most temples are in govt control so Brahmins get only for livelihood ,if you really want to uplift lower castes then create more job opportunities for them.
come to padmanabhaswamy temple i will show you the SC and OBC caste priest
@@laalsalaam893 are even in ayodhya ram janmabhoomi the head priest is a dalit if I'm not wrong. Even the puja done by PM Modi was presided over by him. So it's not like dalits cannot become priests. You can learn the vedas and become a priest, who's stopping you, especially in the modern era?
@@Ankitwriter812 bhai tune galat bandey ko tag kiya hein ...LOL
@@laxendrachauhan8202better to be a poor preist than a safai karmachari living in shit......such stupid analogy
If charity begins at home, show spine and don't accept CJI post. I'm an upper caste and the reservation policies in India forced me migrate overseas. Suck it down well, utter non sense logic by person of this stature.
so are u working in govt sector their ?
cuz just 2% area holds reservation only in govt sector .
reality is it was ur childhood dream to settle thier.
@@HARSH-sf6pb i work as government contractor and can easily apply for government job. And the good thing is, they don't differentiate category wise for ppl applying for government job. I know you don't know anything about how things work in other countries, but still trying to say about system you have zero knowledge. You are not an astrologer, coz my childhood dream was to get into govt sector here, but shitty reservation system is killing central category youth of today. A general category person works hard to make dreams possible, like i did.
What was Your childhood dream...get everything for free and crying you got nothing???
@@chikswindy5796 cmon don't try to be over smart .which country u live in ?
America also has reservation,where it is called preference .
And the good part is it is not only limited to the govt sector .
Super markets have special places reserved for blacks .
Not even a single country in the world is there which does not have this reservation policy.
U know nothing.
China ,South Africa,Indonesia ,Japan ,Korea etc every single country where
Commonly it is called affermetive action.
In Singapore they have reservations for so-called "native peoples" in the business sector.
I'm a teacher in one of the best institutes of India , my subject is to teach these world Global policies only .
U know nothing.
South Africa gives reservations in their sports sectors too , but ur raised with this hatred for a particular group of people for blaming ur failure on something which do not have any connection with .
No regrets for what our ancestors did to them .
No worries how still every day in any corner of the country someone is being insulted, physicaly and mentaly tortured just on the basis of caste .
See whites won't decide if racism exists or not . similarly we are no one to decide caste based discrimination exists or not.
15 % of the population have acquired 50% of total India's resources.
85% only have 50%
15% candidates fight for 50% area .
85% fight for 50% .
Now u tell me who is fighting more competition?
The reason for u hatred is not u ,it's ur lack of understanding and knowledge.
I dont know ur even aware of how reservation actually works.
Why every time the reserved cutoff goes down .u know?
This year in jee advanced SC ST students outshined generals. ( TOI) .but still the cutoff goes down u know why ? Let's see what u know...
It's a such a disgrace.
Long live Justice Chandrachud. May you bring the positive change in our justice system. So that poor people can also get justice without rubbing feet for years on the court door. May god bless you 🙏
Fantastic explanation sir ' 👏 thanks a
lot ' We are lucky and proud that such a learned and thoughtful 💕
Personality is coming as the ÇJI of the country..
Going by this logic, no one is meritorious! Should not a say a reserved category person who was economically poorer or had a more difficult childhood be considered more meritoroius than another probably richer reserved category person? But again what if the poorer guy actually got an NGO help, while the richer guy had a tumultous childhood? I mean this is life, everyone`s situations are different. While we have to work on reducing the social divide probably by stricter implementation of discrimination laws and more resources to the backward section, we have to also ensure to choose the best person for a job, irrespective of everything else. This selection process in itself maybe a different argument altogether.
Yup and our Constitution is proving the karmic theory that upper caste is paying the sins of their forefathers / ancestors,
Sir you also highly merited juge very very very good sir good morning sir thank you sir good sir happy sir Hi Hi sir Jai Hind Jai Hind Jai Bharat l lndian sir good sir meerandharu pachhaga undaru thank you sir
Funny to see general category people think only they have merit
Funnier to see that even judges of this country think , disregarding merit brings equality.
Thank u sir ,
u have destroyed life and careers of thousands of meritorious doctors. May God be with us.
Narrow concept of merit and broad concept of reservation . How can u even discriminate among mbbs doctors . No patient asks our caste ,
Very much injustice to meritorious doctors .
The country wil face it when they leave this country and serve others .
Well done for ruining the dreams of Unreserved doctors
Absolutely True👍 well said
Fetching marks is not a mere factor of merit, lower caste community who have no social capital , no access to quility education, must not kept outside of having a professional skill . Although doctor is a job for shudras if varna system taken seriously
@@rk95 but how is a doctor an oppressed person ?
this is another way to destroy the merit students.
@@harshasreenath9507 cry now
"it is what it is"
My most favourite hon'bl justice d.y.chandrachud
real man
Yeah, why to have exams. Just take caste certificate and straight away give jobs.
एक दिन judiciary मे भी उनकी तस्बीर लगेगी साहब
Bloody hypocrite 🙄
He is assuming( being a bird brain not his fault though) are all like him, as he will is the CJI because of his father who himself was CJI not because of his talent but because of push. For ordinary person like me, be a brahmin or dalit one should be there because of merit not because of birth. I being genuinely believe that though merit is rare it does not depend on birth. This guy typical woke believes that dalits are not meritorious or brilliant hence they need sympathy and help. Though a brahmin myself , I hate this kind of patronizing nature. I am ashamed of SUCH people. I think in hindi they call this as shaw mein chappal chupake marana...
Thank you so much sir 🙏🏻🙏🏻
History of marginalisation tothe common man is more on economic marginalisation. The life they were forced to take with time bound the class by customs which acquired the form of customary law. Groups were added with the change in dynastic rule in medieval India. Customary law has roots which implementation of conventional law can uproot but with time. By identification of the castes and tribes listed not rechristened them as SC/ST. Achievements of the citizens are not judged first by their social status rather by their intellectual capabilities. We have had brilliant ministers like Late JagJivan Ram who held important posts .Even if was considered granted due to reservation and not merit but every ministry he handled did well. Do we lack the insight of noticing the capabilities as a person allowing our tutored mind to give reservation the advantage and not his capability. Is this a cover up by the deemed superiors in society.
5.20 in this term inferior, ihope you've included all religions women and not exclusively hindu women.
12.25 sacred land of gods. You're referring to India,. You're seeing with color blinds. You're not seeing the minority act differences.
You dont want to highlight the success rate.
With amount of reservations, other hindus lost even a decent chance to live. And you're a judge.
14.25 humilition by dominant society. Who is being humiliated in college entrance exam redilts and seat allocation even after securing above 90 percent. Who is being humiliated in getting government jobs.
Who is being humiliated at time of promotions.
I've been a government employee and ended wher i started. I got increments but not promotions.
Because i dont have the certificate.
14.40. This humiliation has been institutionalised in the name of caste certificate.
And as a judge you're keeling to one side.
16.09. You are referring time and again to USA, but whay are you doning to stop global anti hindutva, for example, professor audrey traushke of Rutgers University.
17. 44. Does your speech encourage unity or encourage conflict. Sounds more tiwards conflict.
18.49. Telling Americans!!. To white supremacists. My god, indians are their own enemies. Look at global anti india feeling.
You could've told to a Saint and you cant find one.
You're sick.
CONSTITUTION BY GIVING RIGHTS TO KNOW THERE FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS AND DIRECTIVE PRINCIPLES.
This is the same guy that made verdict in Shabarimala issue. I assume he believes every one in India is privileged upper caste. He see everything from his perception of which he was brought up. I never in my life got any government benefit but paid my taxes. I believe I also have to right to get the same benifit they give to others. 😅 Literally my country and its government had done nothing for me other than take my money in the name of taxes. The so called privilege of upper class. By the way I am still homeless
Homeless with a phone
Jai Mere maati mere desh
The tendency of reacting out group due to negetivity rooted in society among in group , it be must taken in to account and as a compensation reservation has to be continued till limitless time.
❤🙃
How beautifully we fake words in order appease an applause.
Amist elephusmaxmum I have to infuse elephant pass.Khopoli khandala .With a pair MMmL laxmi and Manikandan 2 let me see how fr i go .
Thanks sir, for such a explanative lecture.
चीप जस्टिस चंद्रचूड़ जजों साहब जी मुझे कलकते का ओ टिकट जो मेरा हक है ममता और मोदी के मंत्री कब्जा किया है मुझे दिला ये बीती है आप से
मोदी ने और काग्रेस ने तीनों पार्टि मिलके नहीं देरहा है बीचार है इन लोगों का
This judge will bcom cji only bcoz his dad was also a cji. He is a product of nepotism.
N knowledge