RED WING VS THOROGOOD: Which Moc Toe Is Best?
Vložit
- čas přidán 3. 07. 2024
- SHOP RED WING: bit.ly/3wUWdsq
SHOP THOROGOOD: amzn.to/37vEH1B
✪ Check out my 10 Best Boots On the Market! • THE 10 BEST BOOTS FOR ...
FULL REVIEW + PICTURES: stridewise.com/red-wing-vs-th...
If you're searching for an iconic, sturdy, American-made moc toe boot you've almost certainly come across these two industry stalwarts: Red Wing and Thorogood. The boots look so similar that you might think it's a toss up between the two, but the design, leather, and ESPECIALLY the sole actually vary significantly.
00:30 Red Wing and Thorogood Similarities
01:30 Red Wing vs Thorogood Aesthetics
03:15 Red Wing vs Thorogood Leather
04:06 Red Wing vs Thorogood Sole
07:18 Red Wing vs Thorogood Fit & Sizing
09:37 Red Wing vs Thorogood Price
09:53 Red Wing vs Thorogood Pros and Cons
MY ORIGINAL RED WING MOC TOE REVIEW: • Review: Red Wing Moc T...
MY ORIGINAL THOROGOOD REVIEW: • Thorogood Moc Toe Revi...
MY 5 FAVORITE BOOTS ON THE MARKET (plus runners-up) • THE 5 BEST MEN'S BOOTS...
MORE COMPARISONS:
Red Wing vs Wolverine: • FIGHT! Red Wing Vs. Wo...
Timberland vs Doc Martens: • TIMBERLANDS VS DOC MAR...
Viberg vs Alden: • FIGHT! Viberg Vs. Alde...
Common Projects vs Oliver Cabell: • Oliver Cabell vs Commo...
#redwing #thorogood #redwingvsthorogood #moctoeboots - Jak na to + styl
I have used work boots for 20+ years. I am on my feet for 10+ hours a day. I tried Thorogood boots for the first time last year. These are a game changer. Very comfortable from day one. Never have had to add insoles in these boots. And yes, I have owned several pairs of Red Wings. Hope this helps.
Very true that Thorogoods don't need insoles! Outsole wasn't too hard?
Did yours have the wedge soles? I work in a large auto plant, and I have seen a few people here and there that wear these.
yea dude I tried thorogood out for the first time this year. def kicks timberland, Georgia boots, and yes even redwing in the ass in my opinion
and I've had multiples of each
Wonder why the red wings are so expensive compare to the thorogoods i think i know which side im leaning towards
I have thorogood steelstoes for work. I work on the railroad typical boots like 6 months but these I have had for 3 years. Twice resoled and still look brand new and have felt amazingly comfy since day one.
I have the 10875, 875, 8130, and the 8138, all moc toes
Once broken in they last forever
I tried the TG, very comfortable for the first couple months but after that they seemed to loosen up, get floppy, with no support. My RW just feel better every time I wear them.
BTW I’m a mechanical contractor.
The Traction Tred Lite 1221's were so comfortable the minute I put them on I had to have them. All-time favorite boots
dude I've been waiting for this comparison :DD
Rose Anvil, search them on YT.
The Perfect Summary: 09:52
Update: Looks like the Thorogoods are hard to find for under $205 now, but the Red Wings have increased to $300, so... the difference is pretty much the same?
✪ Also, check out my 10 Best Boots On the Market! czcams.com/video/9kuHyyefNGE/video.html
just wait till PPP expires and people realize we are in a depression. prices of lotsa hipster wear will be coming down
Look for a coupon for boot barn. Should be around that price after the discount.
I have a local supplier I buy them for around 160-180 but I buy 2 pairs at a time
@Ric von Zipper i do not forgive you
Yes! Thorogoods are for WORK. Was a red wing guy until I tried thorogoods. Won’t go back until thorogoods pisses me off somehow.
Same here
Try Nick’s
Same here!!! It’s just easy to see how confortable thorogood is and then you won’t pay 300 for a pair of boots that will hurt your feet for about a month, when finally starts to feel some comfort your sole is almost gone😂Another thing that nobody mention is the toe box on the red wings gets so out of shape.
They won't. Lol
@Becoming Godsizei personally find thorogoods far more comfortable than redwings.
Thanks. Great video very helpful
Both boots are great, I have a pair RW 1907 and the same thorogood boot. Over time the thorogood boot stretches out and are more loose on my feet but wearing boot socks took care of that. Like you said it depends what you will use them for I like the red wing for normal wear and the thorogood is good for work. Hopefully my next pair will be the 875 rw I love how the 875 looks after the break in.
Thanks for this video, its the one i've been waiting for. i have a pair of 875 Mocs and they are great and yes breaking them in was Hell on earth. but i will now get a pair of the Thorogoods and wear them one day and the Red Wings the next. Cheers from Australia in the time of Coronavirus i hope you have been well.
Hey I appreciate that man! Glad to be of service. Say hi to Australia for me!
I did try half down with redwing, but they were still huge! Full size down fits brilliant. Break in took about 4 days of continuous wear and I could instantly tell once they were broken in. Incredibly comfortable.
I had the same experience with my 877s
Own Thorogoods...VERY pleased with them.
Great video Nick! I prefer the 1907 Moc toe from Red Wing.
I just picked up a pair of Whites 350 Cruisers, I bet you would love them!
Whites are the BEST
This was a great review, visually and verbally detailed. EVEN THOUGH you throw the obvious nod to the Thorogood; AWESOME job!
Haha thanks! the thing is I prefer the Red Wing because it looks cooler, I just acknowledge that Thorogood is better in just about every other respect lol
@@Stridewise Fair enough! Lol Your review actually caused me to gain interest in wanting to purchase a pair of Thorogoods to add to my collection! 👍
Great review, Mate... RW all day, every day for me....
Thanks, I’m with the Thorogoods for now.
I’ve had both and as a diabetic with neuropathy it’s definitely difficult finding shoes or boots that give all day comfort. For me the Redwings are hands down the most comfortable of the two although Both are quality shoes. The red wings are the first pair of shoes I’ve been able to comfortably wear all day without having my feet hurt.
I got 3 of the thorogood 814-4200 and 1 thorogood 804-3600 Steel toe.
They are the best, Most comfortable, pair of boots I’ve ever worn.
A while ago I had the Thorogood sole put on my Red Wings, as I was tired of resoling yearly (I walk A LOT for my job) They lasted almost 2 years before needing to be resoled!
yep better soles
Yes, that's consistent with what I've heard Miles!
I was able to track down a pair of Thorogood Portage boots recently. Truly an incredible pair of boots. I also have a pair of older Red Wing round toe Supersoles. They’re not very comparable as far as style or purpose, but I love them both.
Just got some Thorogood boots! Waiting for them to arrive. Heard nothing but good things about them.
I used to wear Red Wings. A few years back I decided to try Thorogood for the first time. I haven't gone back to Red Wing since. The Thorogood boots are more durable and comfortable.
Thorogood is indeed comfy, Mike!
As someone that's familiar with both brands, can I get away with an eight and a half wide Moc Toe Thorogood? I wear a size 9D Iron Ranger. Thank you for your reply in advance.
@@matttherrien9608 most likely. Thorogoods run a little big, so you should be fine with a half size smaller
@@coyotegrad-collectables much obliged friend. Though, I'm more drawn to the Red Wings. The devil's in the details! Better quality in house leather that ages beautifully. They have style and substance over Thorogoods. Would you be inclined to agree?
I am now at 4 pairs of Thorogood mocs and just bought my 2nd pair of red wings. for work Thorogood is definitely better and my most broke in pair looks almost the same size of the Redwings now. I do agree that the 875 do look better overall. Either way I love both and will keep wearing both.
Thorogood all the way. I've had the heritage moc toe and round toe. Loved them both. And they look way better.
Does Thorogood boots have a warranty like Redwing. Like if I needed to replace the sole in 4 years would they do it or how does that work if they have a warranty?
Just bought Thorogood Waterproof, steel toe, moc toe, 8 inch boot. It’s so comfy out of the box, does need a little break in but all good
I mow lawns and I’m around wet grass all the time so that wedge sole was a con for me, but Thorogood offered the boot described above with a wedge sole carved into a regular heel style with added tread. Also the sole came in black which is awesome cause the white would turn green.
It’s like these were made for me.
I've got thinner feet. I tried the Red Wings on at my local Red Wing store and they were way too roomy. The Thorogood pair fit like a glove and they have worn amazingly well the past year.
I have the red wing boot...awesome and age well... very pleased.
I’m going to have to get both
I have red wing 10877 I used in the office for winters moths is really good boot hard to break in I almost quit , now is little better but still unconfortable some times , I will buy the thorogood and see if is better on my feet
Both are good boots. I have done a lot of work in the Redwings. There are some guys that swear by the Redwings at places I've worked. These do size bigger but I correct it by adding an insert. My favorite work boot from Redwing is the Chukka. I refer to them as the Vans of the work boot world. Super comfortable!!
Thanks for the info! Legit never heard of people using chukkas as work boots!
@@Stridewise That's what the model #595 was made for. They are ideal for warehouse work and for those that stand for long periods of time especially on hard surfaces. They're perfect if you are going from office to worksite and back.
Thorogood has been my go to for heritage work boots. Their boots are still US made and they're really well made. Hardly a break in and they're a consistent boot. Have a set two users and I beat on them hard. They just need their first resole.
Both are very cool.
Great vid! Thinking about finally snagging my first pair of mocs and leaning toward the RW 1907. Btw what jeans were you wearing? They looked awesome
I have the RW Moc Toes for fashion but once my current Wolverine steel toe work boots get out of commission, I'm gonna get the Thorogoods
Great! Wolverine isn't well known for theirs, you like them?
Nice review Nick, I especially liked the pyrotechnic opening. It would be fun to see the people's expression as they walk by you during your shoe modeling moves. I definitely prefer the Red Wings. Cheers mate.
KABOOM! There are a few videos where people look at me weird in the background haha I get so embarrassed walking around being filmed, you have no idea
Stridewise you are a true professional sir.
I’ll have to have both of them
Just got the Red Wings in Oro legacy. I was about to walk up to the register with the thorogoods, then I realized the Red Wings are just $40 more expensive.
It was a little bit more involved though. Had to drive an hour away to the nearest Red Wing store that had my size in stock, then I had the sizing issue to wear a 12 wide was too big, but a 12 was barely too small, so I just got the 12 stretched and they seem to fit perfectly now. The things I do for the things I love
Phew, when you said you got the 12 hoping they'd stretch i held my breath - often doesn't work out! glad you got a boot you like
hoping you get to review the Whites Perry moc toe, recently came out with lower MSRP than Redwing
I like the red wings because they make them the same way they did back in the days when they were introduced. You're getting a boot from 1952. And that requires a break in. It's like you get a molded boot that you have to work at for a month or so (probably less honestly), or you get a more modern comfy boot that doesn't change at all. What you get is what you got. Just different preferences.
Riiight.
Prefer to pay more and feet hurt for a month vs comfyness asap and less expensive
I own both, the Thorogood is the work boot, the Red Wing is the hipster boot.
My Red Wings look better after some wear but the crepe sole is horrible, it's almost gone after a few months of wear.
8" thorogood is a dang fine pair of boots. I own several different boots but these are my everyday go to boots and beat them up
Thanks for another great vid.
I had some Thorogods and in a word, painful. Where all of the stitching starts near the first eyelet dug into the top of my foot and the toe box was too narrow. I kept them thinking they just needed to break in, never did. I later tried wide width but they were too wide and too much slop in the fit. Chippewa's mix toe is a much better fit for me
That's interesting, Karl! You're the first guy I heard say Thorogood just didn't fit, and I appreciate that you tried on different fits and sizes. Chippewa's a solid brand, glad you liked them!
Good video. One problem with speed hooks is that when walking through dense ground brush the laces often get caught and pulled loose.
Great point!
Long pants.
I’m not much into the Moc Toe style, yet if I were; I think you’ve done a great job comparing the pros and cons of these two fine boots. I’d probably go with the Red Wing for the aesthetics. Great job Nick! Hope all is well...Ed
Thanks Ed! Always good to see you.
Thorogood for the win! I work on tugboats and the steel decks can be pretty tough on your joints. The Thorogood is super comfortable and very slip resistant. An all around great work boot.
Moc toeee madness!!! Lmaoooo cracked me up!
hahahaha I'm so happy someone appreciated that
Basically it comes down to this, if you want them for work or to dress up.
Hey Nick, great video!
Is that a filson backpack near the end of the video?
Haha yes, it is! Good eye. I might do a review of it as well :)
I work for a living so I got to go with thorogood.
Great! Glad to have helped, Lee
Haha I say the same thing as you. “I work for a living” nobody else seems to get it. I mean work as in work, not sit behind a computer in ac all day.
Funny - I too work for a living and for that reason I went with redwing. To each his own!
I’m pretty sure rose anvil measured the thickness of the leather and he stated they are both same thickness just T goods are tumbled or something to make it more conditioned
Sizing for thorogoods in my scenario: try them on!!!! I’m usually a size down. This most recent pair, only a half size.
sizing same as redwing. 1/2 size down
Yeah like I said sometimes people are half a size, sometimes a whole size down, but I'm always half a size.
@stridewise Hey Nick! I see you have the 10875's. I can't make my decision whether I like them or the slightly different 875's more. What made you choose 10875's over the 875's? Thanks, and keep up the great work!
good!!!
Great review! do you mind sharing what jeans are you wearing? I really like the fit and color!
Thanks dude! Those are my full counts , I did a video on them: czcams.com/video/N7VMq3rRIbc/video.html
Unless you mean the uncuffed ones I wore with Thorogood, those are just Levis
My Thorogood are years old, look great and show now signs of giving up the farm. They have been through it all and then some. I actually went with my normal show size when I bought my current pair, and yes my feet tended to swim in them. I did this on purpose because I needed to have room for my insert. One thing I noticed right away with the Thorogood and still notice is that I don't get foot fatigue after wearing the boots for any length of time. I also lucked up to be able to purchase them at a great sale price. I think the only reason I've never purchased a pair of Redwings is the cost up front.
You had an insert on top of the footbed already in Thorogood, eh? Great to hear you don't get foot fatigue over time, it really is universally considered great for guys actually working in or staying on their feet all day in them.
Thorogood has exceeded my expectations. I walk on cement for 8+ hours for a big box store. I’ve owned a lot of work steel toe sneaker shoes. Thorogood blows them out the water. But I am looking at the redwing 1907 in the future for casual wear.
Sounds like the right approach!
the 1907 is soooo hard to break in. You'll gonna feel some pain. I Got rid of them and bought the Thorogood. Holy crap, the Thorogood fit is amazing. No break in needed.
Really glad you made this video I have birthday in a couple of weeks and was thinking of getting a pair of moc toe boots and I was gonna get the red wings but I’ve also thought about getting the thorogoods so I guess I’ll find out if my wallets allegiance sticks to red wing or if I decide to go thorogood
Edit : I think I’ll stick with redwing but man it’s hard to turn the thorogoods away
It's a hard one Blake, I know! It's funny like there are so many reasons Thorogood is better but I just like the look of Red Wing so much more. Hey happy birthday!
Stridewise thank you so much ! Love your content
I’m blessed to have both however I found the thorogoods were much easier to wear the redwings took a while to break in
I have the Thorogoods in brown. 1st pair of good boots. After comparing them to RW I want to have my soles sanded down more like the RWs.
I understand wanting the wedge outsole style for work purposes standing a lot at work...But am I the only one that thinks if you're picking one for looks and to wear casually, the heeled outsole looks better?
Grant Stone has some moc toes with heels that look great! See my video on the Brass Boot
Is there a difference between men's and women's moc toe? I am a size 7 us. If they are basically the same I just have more colour choice available on sale.
I have checked the website. But the sizing starts from 7 ( UK ).
Hi what will you say is the best boots for the price around the samme price red wings or doc martens or wolverine or any similar priced brands?
How do you know the leather quality and I thought there are the same thickness
I have both seems the same to me I also have Nike running shoes and addidas running shoes seem the same as well go with preference I guess
I have both. Thorogood are more comfortable
I just got my 875 delivered yesterday. When would be a good time to apply some Bicks on it?
Can you make a video on the waterproof version of redwing and thorogood moc toes?
You mean Red Wing's work boots? I'm doing a comparison of Irish Setter and Red Wing soon
Red Wings have the brand name and the history behind them, so I prefer Red Wings. I own both and they are both great boots!
What model redwings are these? I feel like thicker leather and leather insoles are better for comfort. It forms more to your specific foot shape
Which ones are better in snow and on slippery surfaces?
Hi! how are you? Love your reviews. Red wing moc toe come in size 5, 5.5, 6 (UK sizes)?
I love my Thorogood moc toes but really hate the speed hooks!
I'd love to see a comparison between the Thorogood and the Thursday boots.
My God i like both I'm wearing thorogood now and they give me knee pain 😩 if red wing is heavier it'll be worst for my knees i guess what should i do any suggestions?
How are these for working when there is no steel toe cap in it?
Never owned either. Big problem for me is blisters. I have a wide foot and skinny heal.
Great comparison! But they’re both far from „through punishment“. They look almost new to be honest :D
How dare you emasculate me like this
My Thorogood's are my beaters, and I wear them for knocking around.
@Stridewise, how did the sizing compare between the Red Wing and Thorogood?
Ok so two years have passed. I now have two pairs of the RedWing heritage and two pairs of thorogood both black and tobacco.go to go with the guy below, the thorogood ‘s are considerably more comfortable during the break I. For sure. I think both look great but going forward I’ll stick with the thorogood.
Thorogood leather is close to the same thickness as redwing. It’s barrel rolled making it way softer. That’s the difference. I owned the redwings a few years ago. Took 2 months to break in, then after about 2 months later the sole melted away, super soft. If you drag your feet, your work with concrete. The redwing sole will melt away before the boot is even broken in.
Great input, dude! Thanks for sharing your side
what are the jeans in the video?
What about Carolina American Made ?
Nice video. Where are your boots socks from?
Terry Helm!
For me thorogood all day all year. I tried redwings. I tried the 1907 and my goodness was that an uncomfortable boot. I had to stop wearing them. Then i tried a pair of irish setters. A bit better but still not a very comfortable boot. An uncle of mine steered me towards thorogood boots and i never looked back.
I bought a pair of Therogood 6inch moc toe about a year ago. I double water proofed them. They are american made lock stock and barrel. I have to wear a insole for working on concrete floors. They are comfortable. The pig skin breaks in easier and is softer. Paid $185 for them. They are definitely a better buy. I'd buy a pair again when they wear out.
Redwings are nice but I would go for thorogoods for comfort for work.
Nick, what's your opinion on Mexican made boots ? There is a brand i have seen called Padilla they make a moc toe, with full grain "grasso" leather. Not sure what "grasso" is, my guess is that it is an oil tanned leather (grasso\grease). jyst wondering if you have ever seen a pair. they only run about $50-$60 so i am gussing they're junk.
Hi, what jeans are you wearing? Not just the brand by the style too please. My jeans seems to be a little too baggy, which I don't mind, but the more slim fits do show off the appeal of those nice boots
Hey J S, these jeans are Full Count czcams.com/video/N7VMq3rRIbc/video.html I wear high rise, relax tapered jeans because I have a big butt and thighs. If you don't, you might prefer regular tapered, but in any event it sounds like tapered is what you're looking for :)
I wish I knew about the half down before I bought my Thorogoods
Half down?
@@Stridewisein size my brain went faster then my typing on that one. It's just such a coincidence that the video that answered all my questions regarding my top two Moto boot choices came a week after I decided on the boots lol
@@wallaceavin7490 Right! Sorry I couldn't get it up earlier Wallace :)
The hipster boot goes to Red Wings. You want a work boot, get Thorogoods.
Don’t write off people who want to wear well made shoes as hipsters, I’ve used both of these boots for my trade as a carpenter.
Charles Bronson, hipsters wear red wings.
@@bravobear1844 I wear red wings.. wore them for factory work, wood splitting, and maintenance/grounds work. I also own thorogoods, and love them both. Thorogoods are amazing work boots, way more comfy to start, but my redwings fit like a glove.
BravoBear hipsters died out like 5 years ago
I love wearing my Red Wings when I walk the farmers market for my weekly organic veggies while I enjoy a latte, trying to avoid getting froth on my mustache.
Seems like a lot of people say the thorogoods are better for work, over the redwings. I’m inclined to believe the redwings are better only because of the leather insoles. I just feel like it would be better? I do warehouse labor, so idk which one to get
I like the look of the thorogood better
I think they actually have the same thickness in leather, it’s just that the thorogood’s leather is tumbled and gives it that thinner “feeling”
I’ve got a pair of the Black Goods and wear them
All the time and when I ride my Harley. Just a comfortable boot and they look killer. Oh and that Flag on the side is a nice touch too
Nice one!
I guess not all Redwing boots break in the same. I guess it's the thicker leather. Mine broke in instantly but they aren't mocs they are the boots with the supersole 2.0.
My Thorogood boots, I’ve had 3 pair, never lasted long enough to be resoled. The cloth lining would always come apart and expose the plastic toe cap. Also, the stitching would always come apart. My redwings on the other hand will last about three resolings before they become trash. I’m a farmer that does a lot of walking and my boots are exsposed to everything from wet grass to harsh chemicals and the Red Wings just outlast most any boot I’ve found.
My first pair of Thorogoods had a very short life because I spilled a large amount of gear oil on them. I replaced them with another pair because I liked how there was no break in period with the first pair and they were cheaper than Red Wings and Danners. The second pair is what turned me off to them. They basically fell apart and became uncomfortable very quickly. The third pair was purchased as a Christmas gift for me, and they were just as disappointing. On a side note, I would also recommend Danner’s USA made and recraftable boots too.
Love my Thorogoods. They are great looking and the most comfortable/supportive footwear I have. I do like the more slim style of the RW better but I’m this day and age why put yourself through the pain of breaking in a boot that won’t put last the most comfortable boot on the market? Seams like silly hipster logic. BTW Nick, the tad longer hair suits you well.
They are undeniably comfy boots, Matt, it's true. I think Red Wing is prettier and I think it's fine to pick clothes and shoes based on their looks so long as you don't act like it's anything more than that, I think I was honest in this video haha. Thanks for the compliment on the hair, I'm stuck with long hair because no barbers are open during quarantine. A lot of people prefer it but I hate it and don't know how to style it haha
Just gotta love red wings, there’s just something about them that once you start you’re hooked
Carlos E. Martinez Ramos I’m a huge red wing guy for casual wear. For work, which I do need steel toe, I prefer Carolina Boot Co. I’ve only had them for 3 weeks, but oh my god they are so comfortable. If they turn out to be durable, I can’t imagine ever buying a different brand or model. I’d simply order them again once the current ones wear out.
Brandon Gray well in my line of work (oilfield) the industry buys red wing work boots for all of us, I’m sure there’s better but hey, they pay for them so 🤷🏻♂️. Then again, I keep buying red wing heritage for casual wear so, I guess I’m just a die hard fan
More like Nick’s boots or White’s boots. $600 for a pair of boots that will last you the rest of your career.