The difference between them is simple one has a 4 inch barrel the other has a 4 1/2 inch barrel the 19 would be slightly easier to conceal carry, and 17 will have slightly better ballistic abilities/accuracy due to the slightly longer barrel..
That ballistics would barley be noticeable, seen a video, the 17 was 4 fps more than 19 lol I think it comes down to the grip you prefer/which one hides better for you
17 is the OG for a reason! Gaston Glocks genius invention and innovative genius! Full size full power 9mm for full sized men! No sacrifice in power, range or accuracy just a phenomenal tool by the great 👍
Glock 17 Gen 5 thats tan... My favorite bedside piece on earth.... It's not even close. My S&W shield plus - performance center, stays on me at work, because of its size & it has a safety for when I carry it in my pocket... My glock however, is my "bump in the night" peice... I would grab it over any of my AR15's. Simply because it's *so simple* to use & it always works. My AR might get grabbed if I knew there were multiple attackers, but 80% of the time when I wake up during the middle of the night at my dogs barking, the Glock 17 is the preferred tool... I also shoot it more than any of my other firearms. I'm *confident* in its performance & I know it'll always perform.. if it doesn't, there's a S&W .357 revolver right beside it that will... & that gun goes *bang* *NO MATTER WHAT* I shoot a glock 19 or 17 better than any other firearm.... I still love my revolvers & Derringers though. There's nothing like having a 100% reliable means of getting a person off of you.... still. I have an officer friend who recently sold ALL of his collectable firearms. He kept his glock 17 though, he said its the only one he shoots or really needs.... he said his Glock 17 filled every roll of his other firearms. I have to agree with him. The average American person will be just fine with ONE glock 17 for the rest of their life. It just works, & it works well... (I'm not hating on people who own multiple guns that would make me the world's biggest hypocrite. Im just saying, a solid Glock will outlive you..)
Hey Lexus, appreciate this comment. really helped me decide between the 17 and 19. I was hoping if you could tell me, for a concealed carry (as a delivery driver), if i got the G19, is there any reason to get larger ammo (.38 or .45SW) or should i just stay with 9mm? Also if i was to find usefulness with the larger ammo, Would it be better to go with a G22 or 23? Appreciate it in advance!
@@rachelandross4evr if you get the g22, you can buy a conversion barrel and run 9mm. And a conversion barrel and run 357 sig... The g22 and g23 and g27 are the same frame as the 17,19, and 26.. But when you buy the 22,23,or 27, the hole in the slide is bigger.. so it allows you to buy a conversion barrel and shoot the smaller caliber 9mm, or 357sig.. Essentially giving you 3 different calibers in one pistol.. 9mm is a great self defense round, 40 is a little better. But 357 sig is SIGNIFICANTLY more powerful than either .
The 17 is bigger woth no real noticeable performance gain as far as muzzle velocity goes. To me just buy the 19 or the 45/19x for the 2 extra rounds. That half inch extra barrel length doesn’t give any noticeable gains
where does the pad of your trigger finger land on both. I think you just don't have the same reach on the 17 which explains your 25 yard shots. The bigger grip will feel better that is why the 17 feels better and the slide is longer so not as snappy.
We in Germany have to make a "gun handling license", be a member in a gun club for minor twelve month and have to shoot every month or minor 18 times in that twelve month when we miss one month. After that we need a state police clearance certificate and must apply for the purchase of a pistol beforehand. In Germany (land of the ever concerned and afraid) it is a long run to be a gun owner. And after that you are not allowed to carry your gun in public, you are only allowed to shoot with it in the shooting club. So I don't need a "every day carry" gun. And with this perspective a prefer the glock17 gen5. I had a few times 1911's, CZ Shadows and other guns in my hand. But I guess my first gun will be the 17 gen5. I like it how it fits my hand, I love the trigger... Almost everybody in my gun club says: "don't buy a glock, buy a Shadow, buy a whatever, but not a glock!" 🤔😆 Don't know why. I like that pistol and I prever it much more than the heavier Shadow or 1911... 🤷🏻♂️ Nice vid, like all the other glock19/17 vids... 👍😆
That sucks. Where I live, people can legally carry and don’t need a permit. I was carrying my Glock 19 earlier today, I like it more than the 17 because it’s more comfortable to carry.
Weight in the grip (ammunition) can make a gun shoot differently, just as weight on the slide (length). So the weight of a bullet is the same no matter what gun you put it in, but the weight ratio can be quite different, which may affect shooting characteristics, even though they may not be felt. This is why a magazine extension can improve, or at least change, a gun’s characteristics. Try firing the G19 with a fully loaded G17 mag and see what you think of my theory.
The width is the same. Now, the grip angle is not so cut and dry. I supposed the grip angle is the same, but the 17 has a bit more of a hump in the back so it's not just a matter of it being slightly longer.
@@theevenstevenchannel8220 you did and I found them on another video of yours where you reviewed them. I hadn’t considered them but I love the profile, nice and short front to back. Thanks
My understanding is that you are legally allowed to have hollow point ammo. The idea you can't have hollow points in New Jersey comes from the fact that if you're charged with a felony, and you're in possession of hollow point ammo, then that's an additional charge.
i wear a size L gloves too but G19 just feels small... G17 is ideal for me... will never sell it - actually got a few G17s. Still have G19s but more for concealed carry - G17 for open carry. Haven't bough5t the G19x - that will be great.
What is that on the rails? If you are only allowed 10 round magazines to me it makes no sense to own these larger firearms. I would choose the slimline Glocks over these.
I sometimes forget to mention it, that's the rail attachment for the Blackhawk Omnivore. It's a universal holster. I tend to put it on all my guns. Something like a Glock 48 or 43 wouldn't be out of the question, but they're smaller guns. These just happened to be the ones I have now.
@@swimbassin6196 you can get a slimline with a 19 length barrel, its called the 48. but for 17 length and longer youd need one of these double stacks fs
Larger firearms are easier to use. There’s a reason LE and Mil shoot these two models and other larger frame pistols. I have no use for a pistol with a smaller form factor than the 19. I recommend relocating to a state that actually has freedom.
It's so funny, when I was first getting into firearms there wasn't a million videos on CZcams..... In fact, I dont think there were any.... so my very first legal fire arm was a Glock 17 and I concealed carried that for 2 years until I was introduced to the G19! Iran out and bought one immediately and when I went to get it, there was a used G26 in the glass. I put it on lay away and picked up 40 days later. Fast forward to today, I have a 34, 2x17's, a 19, 19x and the 26....... Great video Bro..... I may make video telling the story. Thanks for sharing. just sub'd. czcams.com/users/shortsRdYY9uRYlRk
i like how alone the guns have minimal unnoticeable difference but when you put the 19 next to the 17 you can really see it.
Ooof... seeing those magazines hurts my soul my dude
The difference between them is simple one has a 4 inch barrel the other has a 4 1/2 inch barrel the 19 would be slightly easier to conceal carry, and 17 will have slightly better ballistic abilities/accuracy due to the slightly longer barrel..
That ballistics would barley be noticeable, seen a video, the 17 was 4 fps more than 19 lol I think it comes down to the grip you prefer/which one hides better for you
@@crazypitbull16 you mentioned the fps, not the accuracy.
@victorowens9150 the accuracy is subject to the shooter and if u want to be specific to the video he actually shot better with the 19.
17 is the OG for a reason! Gaston Glocks genius invention and innovative genius! Full size full power 9mm for full sized men! No sacrifice in power, range or accuracy just a phenomenal tool by the great 👍
@@dsrrecordsent not when you compare it to the G34. Now that's for true full size men!!!!
The 19 can become a 17 ...but the 17 can't become a 19... hope that helps
love both guns , and love this video thank you for doing this . !!
Thank you. I wasn't having a great day at work that was a nice and unexpected message.
@@theevenstevenchannel8220 thank you brother , I hope you doing better !!
Glock 17 Gen 5 thats tan...
My favorite bedside piece on earth.... It's not even close. My S&W shield plus - performance center, stays on me at work, because of its size & it has a safety for when I carry it in my pocket... My glock however, is my "bump in the night" peice... I would grab it over any of my AR15's. Simply because it's *so simple* to use & it always works. My AR might get grabbed if I knew there were multiple attackers, but 80% of the time when I wake up during the middle of the night at my dogs barking, the Glock 17 is the preferred tool... I also shoot it more than any of my other firearms. I'm *confident* in its performance & I know it'll always perform.. if it doesn't, there's a S&W .357 revolver right beside it that will... & that gun goes *bang* *NO MATTER WHAT*
I shoot a glock 19 or 17 better than any other firearm.... I still love my revolvers & Derringers though. There's nothing like having a 100% reliable means of getting a person off of you.... still. I have an officer friend who recently sold ALL of his collectable firearms. He kept his glock 17 though, he said its the only one he shoots or really needs.... he said his Glock 17 filled every roll of his other firearms. I have to agree with him. The average American person will be just fine with ONE glock 17 for the rest of their life. It just works, & it works well... (I'm not hating on people who own multiple guns that would make me the world's biggest hypocrite. Im just saying, a solid Glock will outlive you..)
Hey Lexus, appreciate this comment. really helped me decide between the 17 and 19. I was hoping if you could tell me, for a concealed carry (as a delivery driver), if i got the G19, is there any reason to get larger ammo (.38 or .45SW) or should i just stay with 9mm? Also if i was to find usefulness with the larger ammo, Would it be better to go with a G22 or 23? Appreciate it in advance!
@@rachelandross4evr 9mm is a badass universal round
@@rachelandross4evr if you get the g22, you can buy a conversion barrel and run 9mm. And a conversion barrel and run 357 sig...
The g22 and g23 and g27 are the same frame as the 17,19, and 26..
But when you buy the 22,23,or 27, the hole in the slide is bigger.. so it allows you to buy a conversion barrel and shoot the smaller caliber 9mm, or 357sig..
Essentially giving you 3 different calibers in one pistol..
9mm is a great self defense round, 40 is a little better. But 357 sig is SIGNIFICANTLY more powerful than either .
You can always add an extended magazine and grip extension to give more handgrip on the Model 19.
Why when you can just get the 45?
How about removing, or changing the backstrap on the 17, then trying fitment.
They are both perfect. Only difference is the size.
It’s funny how everyone opens a Glock case upside down 😂
It's not much different really maybe a half inch max. But seems to feel different when carried.
Glock 19 also feels nicer in my hands. I feel like I can grip it tighter
Baby hands 😂
@@peterwebb1680The G19 is a little bigger front to back of the grip.
@@peterwebb1680”Peter Webb”
The 17 is bigger woth no real noticeable performance gain as far as muzzle velocity goes. To me just buy the 19 or the 45/19x for the 2 extra rounds. That half inch extra barrel length doesn’t give any noticeable gains
It gives less recoil
where does the pad of your trigger finger land on both. I think you just don't have the same reach on the 17 which explains your 25 yard shots. The bigger grip will feel better that is why the 17 feels better and the slide is longer so not as snappy.
We in Germany have to make a "gun handling license", be a member in a gun club for minor twelve month and have to shoot every month or minor 18 times in that twelve month when we miss one month. After that we need a state police clearance certificate and must apply for the purchase of a pistol beforehand.
In Germany (land of the ever concerned and afraid) it is a long run to be a gun owner.
And after that you are not allowed to carry your gun in public, you are only allowed to shoot with it in the shooting club. So I don't need a "every day carry" gun. And with this perspective a prefer the glock17 gen5. I had a few times 1911's, CZ Shadows and other guns in my hand. But I guess my first gun will be the 17 gen5. I like it how it fits my hand, I love the trigger...
Almost everybody in my gun club says: "don't buy a glock, buy a Shadow, buy a whatever, but not a glock!" 🤔😆 Don't know why.
I like that pistol and I prever it much more than the heavier Shadow or 1911... 🤷🏻♂️
Nice vid, like all the other glock19/17 vids... 👍😆
That sucks. Where I live, people can legally carry and don’t need a permit. I was carrying my Glock 19 earlier today, I like it more than the 17 because it’s more comfortable to carry.
Weight in the grip (ammunition) can make a gun shoot differently, just as weight on the slide (length). So the weight of a bullet is the same no matter what gun you put it in, but the weight ratio can be quite different, which may affect shooting characteristics, even though they may not be felt. This is why a magazine extension can improve, or at least change, a gun’s characteristics. Try firing the G19 with a fully loaded G17 mag and see what you think of my theory.
Stupid question, but do gen4 mags fit into gen5 G19s? and vice versa. Do gen5 mags fit into gen4 G19s?
Yes and No
@@dareklecki ????????
Is there any difference in the grip width and grip angle?
The width is the same. Now, the grip angle is not so cut and dry. I supposed the grip angle is the same, but the 17 has a bit more of a hump in the back so it's not just a matter of it being slightly longer.
Very beautiful
What sights are on your 19?
If I didn't say in the video, they're both Truglo night sights.
@@theevenstevenchannel8220 you did and I found them on another video of yours where you reviewed them. I hadn’t considered them but I love the profile, nice and short front to back. Thanks
I heard something weird is it true you guys in New Jersey can’t have hollow points ?
My understanding is that you are legally allowed to have hollow point ammo. The idea you can't have hollow points in New Jersey comes from the fact that if you're charged with a felony, and you're in possession of hollow point ammo, then that's an additional charge.
@@theevenstevenchannel8220 Thank you for clearing that up for me I appreciate your response
You can have hollow points under certain circumstances. The safest type (legally) to use is Hornady Critical Defense with the polymer plug.
What is that attached to your rail section?
It's an attachment point for the Blackhawk Omnivore holster.
What does the recoil management feel like?
For me the G19 seems to snap back on target whereas the G17 has a noticeable wobble.
The main difference is the grip handle not much difference in barrel length
I have big hands i pretty much fill out the 17 grip
Fouvorite to me
that's the first time I've heard about the magazine release difference. One Tuber said he was more accurate with his 26 than his 19.
I'm more accurate with my 17 and 26 then I am my 19. Still accurate but not as accurate.
I find the mag release on the 17 to be stiff. Don't have a 19. Not yet at least.
I shot just as good with the 19 as the 17. Much better concealer and more compatible with magazines.
19 wins.
Tho I think my next is a 34
My dad bought a 19 and I have big hands so it’s not my preferred Glock. I prefer the 19 with a longer handle
G45/19x
What’s funny within the scope of the world is why would a 17 be larger then a 19…. Sorta confusing for people trying to learn guns!
Yes
Spoiler alerts, Lamarr. Come on.
i wear a size L gloves too but G19 just feels small... G17 is ideal for me... will never sell it - actually got a few G17s. Still have G19s but more for concealed carry - G17 for open carry. Haven't bough5t the G19x - that will be great.
What is that on the rails? If you are only allowed 10 round magazines to me it makes no sense to own these larger firearms. I would choose the slimline Glocks over these.
I sometimes forget to mention it, that's the rail attachment for the Blackhawk Omnivore. It's a universal holster. I tend to put it on all my guns.
Something like a Glock 48 or 43 wouldn't be out of the question, but they're smaller guns. These just happened to be the ones I have now.
You can get the better velocity with the lager barrel
@@swimbassin6196 Good point.
@@swimbassin6196 you can get a slimline with a 19 length barrel, its called the 48. but for 17 length and longer youd need one of these double stacks fs
Larger firearms are easier to use. There’s a reason LE and Mil shoot these two models and other larger frame pistols. I have no use for a pistol with a smaller form factor than the 19. I recommend relocating to a state that actually has freedom.
Such a crime beautiful glocks like these are only allowed single stack mags.
The only difference is the 17 is fullsize the 19 is midsize or compact
السلطان احمد. سلطان مصر والسودان
Allah BOHSIA MELAYU bogel
It's so funny, when I was first getting into firearms there wasn't a million videos on CZcams..... In fact, I dont think there were any.... so my very first legal fire arm was a Glock 17 and I concealed carried that for 2 years until I was introduced to the G19! Iran out and bought one immediately and when I went to get it, there was a used G26 in the glass. I put it on lay away and picked up 40 days later. Fast forward to today, I have a 34, 2x17's, a 19, 19x and the 26....... Great video Bro..... I may make video telling the story. Thanks for sharing. just sub'd. czcams.com/users/shortsRdYY9uRYlRk
Well you may be able to answer.. the 17 vs 19 in your opinion which shoots better..
Seems like the 17 is going the way of the dodo 🦤 with the release of the 19x and 45 and now with the 47 seems like there going to pause the 17 .