Who sings Vivaldi's "Amorose ai rai del sole" best?

Which performance of Vivaldi's "Amorose ai rai del sole" do you prefer?
0:00 Jennifer Larmore
3:53 Kathleen Kuhlmann***
8:33 Julia Böhme
***Please pardon the clicking sounds in the Kathleen Kuhlmann recording. This is due to the source material, and unfortunately I could not repair the audio.

[@megenberg8]

Beautiful voices! The first girl had really excellent depth, feeling and supreme articulation throughout. Never heard so fine and complete a gift for song in one number, very complicated and full of hairpin turns, as it were. I don't know how she managed it! She is something else!

[@p.w.e.2374]

Larmore is an accomplished baroque and bel canto singer. She's been singing since the mid 1980s to great acclaim!

[@inaleyen2737]

Julia Boehme

[@pawelsobolew]

Julia Böhme!

[@tishmusso3949]

Julia Boehme. For me, this performance - tempo, instrumentation as well as the voice - has the "Vivaldi sound".

[@redpriest26]

Julia Böhme the orchestra + tempo + direction puts it over the top for me

[@JacquelineLanceTenor]

I always love Jennifer Larmore. I had the pleasure of seeing her work in a master class a few years ago and got to speak with her for a few minutes at the end. She's a wonderful singer and person.

[@ohmy5650]

Love Kuhlmann's mezzo timbre & tempo chosen. Nice timbre Böhme's too. Guess I didn't fall in love with this so far unknown to me song, renditions are nice though.

[@eyeshowyou]

All great singers...it is just a preference: Jennifer Larmore for me

[@girolamofrescobaldi7285]

Jennifer Larmore

[@myharmony41]

Thx for this musical dedication of Julia Bohme to the soul. I felt between pause of her musical breath that sense of composer wasn't merry about falling in love among lights of the sun

[@p.w.e.2374]

Larmore on the Naive cd is simply wonderful as Alcina, so yeah, Jennifer wins!

[@freiermensch6569]

This is from ORLANDO (RV 728)

[@evgeny.singer]

Kulhmann my big love❤

[@UU-ww6hc]

The quality of sound is not equal to really be fair in judging each one although I think i know who will be in my shopping basket.

[@gordonmartin11]

None unfortunately! On the one hand, it would be preferable to have this mezzo tune interpreted by a man; on the other hand, the instrumental ensembles are heavy and pasty, unlike the baroque spirit.