REMOVE TOOL - Lightroom Classic vs Photoshop - What should you use?
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 03. 2024
- The Remove tool is in Lightroom Classic and Photoshop, which one should you use. What is the fastest, and the best results in a match up of Lightroom Classic vs Photoshop when to comes to the remove tool.
Photoshop Classes from the start: • Photoshop for Beginner...
Lightroom Classic for Beginners: • Lightroom (Classic) Tu...
Just found your CZcams site, Terry often used to listen to your Podcasts so i am very pleased to find these videos, although I thought I knew Lightroom and Photoshop pretty well, I have certainly learnt new procedures, thank you so much
Fantastic! I am planning some new podcasts, I'll post a note when I get the season done. Thanks for watching and listening.
As always Terry, much appreciated. Thank you.
You are very welcome.
That was so helpful. One to bookmark. Thanks for posting.
You're so welcome! Thanks for watching.
Wonderful demonstration. Your videos are always very informative. I don’t miss any of them. Thanks so much.
So nice of you, thanks Gary.
Thanks Terry your teaching method as nice calm and detailed way about it easy to follow for a new to PS user thank you 😊
You are very welcome
Nicely done, thank you.
Thank you too!
Your videos are amazing. You are teaching that's well-balanced. Your voice is nice to listen to (sometimes people sound off to me). Thank you for spending the time to teach us beginners and making it less scary.
Wow, thank you Vanessa!
Very helpful
Glad you think so!
Thanks Terry for another great video. Love all that you have shown us and have learned alot.
Terry, in Photo Shop, couldn't you use the Laso or the Object Select Tool? Would that make the selection on the item to be removed some what easier?
You could, but when it comes to removing things just swiping with one tool makes it pretty fast. With the selection tools, you then have to find an area to cover it with. I think PS does a quicker job when using the remove tool. Thanks for watching Julio.
Thanks, makes good sense.@@tv510
nicely done
Thanks!
I've been restoring some 97-100 year old blk wht photos. This helps me a lot. I used remove in Photoshop, tried in lightroom. It just put a mask wear I drew. I guess I didn't know to click the check on the top tool bar.
Thanks for the help.
Thanks for watching Jose. Restoration can be complex, good luck.
Thank you. Your lessons have been helpful. I hope you don't mind questions. Using Contextual AI, once you decide which choice you want, how to you select and merge that choice into the photo so you can perform other operations on it.
The change goes up onto its own layer. You have a couple of choices, and they both have to do with working with layers. You can do what I normally do, and make a combo layer. That is, make a new layer, then hold the Shift>OTP>CMD>E keys and it will make a combo layer of everything below it. That is the best of both worlds, in that you can always go back and edit more on those layers. BTW - the short cut for PC uses is: Shift>ALT>CNTL>E
Thank you!
Great! I think it might not be necessary to tell PS in Generative fill "remove person" - leave it empty and just click "Generate", it should work (?)
I'll give that a try. I made the mistake of typing in "remove woman" and I think PS thought I was asking for something unsavory and it denied my request. Funny.
@@tv510 lol 🙂🙂🙂
Hey! Should I edit my image on LRc before removing in photoshop? Once I use remove in photoshop I don't get a RAW file to edit in Lightroom anymore. Thank you for the content, it's great.
When you bring a file over to PS, and save it, the PSD file is now loaded back in Lightroom Classic. The Raw file is still there as well. While that exact file doesn't come back in as RAW it is converted to a PSD file, but you can always go back to the original RAW file.
Will it to use select and mask to refine then use the remove tool in Photoshop
In Photoshop, yes, you can use a refined mask to do the work, but the remove tool is faster.
The remove tool in LR is pretty poor. Small items are ok but that’s it. Even removing small things close to an edge go often wrong.
I'm in the same camp. However, there are people that really resist going into Photoshop - so that is an alternative.
Photo shop does a better job with the remove tool but I can still see that it looks blurred in the two duck picture. I’m watching on an iPhone.
MMM... I don't see that on my computer screen. I guess use whichever program works best for a selected image.
A bit more steps than expected. Hope there is a simpler way.
There is always some give up. However, these new ways of removal are WAY faster than the older ways. Thanks for watching.