Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite vs Renault Kiger - Playing the value card | Comparison | Autocar India
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 05. 2024
- The Tata Punch, Nissan Magnite and Renault Kiger are your entry point to the world of SUVs. Gavin D'Souza brings the three together to tell you which one offers the most for your money.
Camerapersons: Anand Malepu, Shreyans Chordia
Editor: Mohit Sharma
0:00 - Introduction
1:00 - Design and dimensions
2:50 - Interiors
6:15 - Features
6:43 - Safety
7:06 - Touchscreens
7:23 - Instruments
7:40 - Rear seat
9:27 - Boot space
9:59 - Nissan Magnite NA driving experience
12:27 - Renault Kiger NA driving experience
14:34 - Tata Punch driving experience
15:53 - Performance
16:35 - Tata Punch driving experience
17:56 - Fuel economy
18:16 - Price and verdict
#GoProHero10Black #SUV #AutocarIndia
SUBSCRIBE to Autocar India for the hottest automotive news and the most comprehensive reviews ► bit.ly/AutocarInd
Autocar India is your one-stop source for test drive reviews & comparison tests of every new car and motorcycle launched in India. We also offer a great mix of other automotive content, including weekly news, motor show reports, travelogues and other special features.
Website: www.autocarindia.com
Facebook: / autocarindiamag
Instagram: / autocar_india
Twitter: / autocarindiamag
New car reviews ►bit.ly/ACI-NewCarReviews
Comparison tests ►bit.ly/ACI-Comparison
New bike reviews ►bit.ly/ACI-BikeReviews
Features ►bit.ly/ACI-Features - Auta a dopravní prostředky
After a wait of almost 9 months I got my Magnite Xv Pre O CVT last year in October. Apart from few technical issues in the features like camera and tyre sensors this car is awesome. So comfortable. I drove from Bangalore to Manali and back and never felt tired while driving. Total distance I covered was about 7-8K (with a hault in my hometown, Ballia UP). Drove in fully snow covered roads to no roads, off roading and many places where people would afraid to take their car there. If I have to buy back, I would choose same.
I'm a proud magnite owner,I bought basic edition which they provided with all safety features like air bags and power window for 4 door which is great and they included back viper for all models. I customized for 30 thousand which I added premium leather seats, centeral locking system , Go mechanics Android system and JBL sound system with reverse parking camera and Arm rest .Now made the car so premium and Love it everyday I take. My total budget is 7 lakhs for this car which is a steal for sub SUV. Go for Magnite ♥️
Magnite looks beautiful, kiger's interior looks good and punch's drivablility seems nice.
Magnite 🔥 Along with VFM, Features and Ride quality 16:28 just shows how well Nissan tuned that 1.0L engine .. more faster than Punch & Kiger !!!
punch inspite being a smaller vehicle weighs 100 kilo more as well
Ha bhai tere paas base variant hai na pr 999cc non turbo usse acha base to punch ka h pr
Top models me magnite hi sabse best hai
@@skilz9525 Bhai Punch se jyada peppy hain engine.. Punch 1200 cc k hisab se bohot laggy n slow feel hoti hain.. 999 cc ka rona mat gao.. Quality dekho uski .. Low end torque wo engine ka bohot mast hain.. 14-15 k speed se car 85-90 chali jati hain 3rd gear me.. I hope you understand this why the low end torque matters n wo engine ko mene personally test k liye 158 tak leke gaya hun usse aage bhi jaari thi..mostly 80-90 se upper me chalata hi nahi car toh wo engine mere needs ko pura krta hain, Low end p meko kaafi peppy sa torque mil jata hain.. so its perfect car n engine for me..
@YoMamaBeenFartin' 16:28 pe dikh jayega garbage konsa engine hain😂
Nissan Magnite secured 85K recorded booking it's VFM and looks 😍😍😍 NCAP 4star rating...!!!
Guys go to each and every company show room you will realize that truly🙏
Nissan has done a good jon with Magnite.. Hope It taste success and Nissan does not leave India like Ford or Chevrolet... Nissan is a good brand..
I think magnite is the best pick here
Did 500 kms round trip just yesterday on the magnite non turbo that too in heavy rain. Was easily doing good speeds. 90 to 100 is easy. At 3000 rpm it sets slightly above 90kph. Car was very comfortable no fatigue at all.
Driven Kiger too and magnite is more refined IMO. Punch is poor in acceleration too did a extensive test drive.
Got 19 kpl in the round trip on magnite yesterday. With 2 adults and a kid.
No clutch issues and steering is weighted nicely at high speed.
Good review ! I am using Magnite base variant since last 8 months. It takes little more to get accustomed to its handling. Clutch & gear not in best sync, especially in 1st & rear. However, its best VFM ! Happy with it !!
Magnite ..was superb in all aspects and turbo at 9lakhs it's well packaged ... i had a thought of 2nd car ...And for my wife ..But its too big 😁😁. So i went with tiago ...
Thank God someone talked on value preposition and Magnite won here
Others just want to make Punch a clear winner
Magnite is the best of the lot in almost all departments and even variant wise features
they just need to work on the cartoon like digital cluster 😂
This is from your perspective 🙂
It looks so shabby.. ( the instrument cluster ) 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
Yes. It's really cartoonish. More like a kids video game
@@arghyabanerjee444 the cluster looks like a cheap kid's toy.
Mind - Magnite / Kiger
Heart - PUNCH 🔥
I tried all the cars and damn, really good cars but, to be honest? Loved the Punch!
I vote magnite, 2nd punch, 3rd kiger
Great blog 👍
Is planet gray color available for 2022 model.?
As i planning to book the car. I will be highly obliged if can reply me.
I bought kiger last November.
It's the overall best looking car of the lot when you consider both inside+outside (cuz I think outside of magnite is better)
At this price point, ppl are up for value for money, so the subdued power which comes with is something which you have to live with .
Inside looks premium, outside looks muscular. You get the great ground clearance and bootspace . 2 glove boxes, rear seat air vents( which I think is close to a gimmick feature).
But what beats it all is the superior ride quality.
So can't complain when all of this comes within 9L (OnRoad).
Just ♥️ the kiger.
Thnx for a great short review☺️👍
Magnite is value for money ❤️❤️❤️
Consider Kiger for its looks ❤️❤️❤️
Punch for safety 😘😘
Dude Kiger is just Kwid Pro Max... 🤷
Dude Magnite too has 4 stars good safety
Magnite and Kiger has 4 stars rating and are not low on safety
global n cap safety🤣🤣
Magnite 🔥
Very mellow background music and upto the point presentation, a very pleasant video compared to the other channels who make sub standard presentation in the name of a comparo. I just hope you start including more details like availability of disc brakes, steering adjustment, inside dimming RVM, A pillar for blind spot etc.
Magnite undoubtedly 🥰
Better leg room in 2nd row..
360 degree camera for safety
Esp abs
Cruise control
Rear ac vent
Hill stop assist
Tyre pressure gauge
Wireless car tech
Wireless charging
Ambient lighting
Turbo💙
Led headlights..
I dont expect more for this price with its competitors
And personally I love magnites hunky grill from the front.. 😋
True 🔥
But when you sit in it... It feels like old gen alto.. I'm owner of magnite and I've regretted after launch of punch 🙃
This is the comparison we needed
Thanks Autocar India ❤️
After a long time I found the reviewer well educated and very articulate indeed,it was a pleasure to watch him along the cars!
I wonder which school he's studied in....
Excellent detailed review.
Thanks 👍☺️
Kiger is value for money with all features and good space.. Also with great ground clearance and 4*
Proud owner of Renault kiger
We drop magnit becoz of service centre less number of showroom
Kiger is good for me 😀 but i dont like magnite but why all in comment section are going with magnite 🤔
Kiger And Magnite are better than Tin can Maruti.
Buy a magnite. Get a good sound insulation done. And change the seat colour . Its the best . And buy a turbo version for best performance too
I just cancelled my Magnite XV NA MT booking and booked punch accomplished instead. Because of poor dealership experience.
Also, one thing need to be consider that resale value will be much better for Punch.
@AutoCar : Sir i have two questions because budget is my constraint (keeping my budget at 8.15) and i have driven both Turbo and Non-Turbo, personally i liked Turbo, could you please help as i am bit confused.
1. Between XV Non-Turbo and XV Executive Turbo variant which is better in terms of (Mileage, Maintenance Cost) because i heard that XV Non-Turbo gives more mileage than Turbo variant. I also heard that if we buy Turbo variant (from any Car brand) then Maintenance cost is more. Could you please help i am confused.
2. If i compromise on the XV Non-Turbo feature which is 'Engine Start-Stop Button', 'Fog Lamp', 'LED DRL's' and even 'Infotainment system' and select the XV Executive Turbo variant will it be a value for money.
Please let me know where to base the value based decision (as i was told by my friends that the features mentioned like LED Drls and fog lamp and Infotainment system can be added after market)
Kiger & Magnite are best & If people want to go for Punch, I suggest to increase your budget slightly & go for Nexon
Very true.. if it's possible.. Nexon automatic petrol ⛽ *12.8lakhs* on road is an amazing option 🔥💫👌🏻
For the price of top model punch you can almost get top end Magnite turbo.
Turbo Magnite is real quick
Your presentation, coverage and eloquence was good.
I will go for Kiger Turbo. is smooth and evenly powered in all the gears
Kiger is hands down the best-looking
Really very informative and well explained-detailed comparison... Keep it up..
happy to see gavin again. kudos for the review
At the top end jumping over to turbo engines for a nominal price changes the equation even further. Tata has overpriced Punch, especially with the top 2 variants which should have been much cheaper for what they offer.
Safety comes with price. 5star rated
They've reduced it by 11k and people were expecting at 5 to 8.5 but it's very competitively priced... as people expected at 8 they're saying overpriced..!!!! And see magnite 's 360° camera is simply useless as I've regreted to have magnite after the launch of punch... I'm magnite owner but I truly support punch..!!
@@elleneventevans4676 lol
@@elleneventevans4676 bhai tu itna regret kar raha hai to magnite to sell out kyu nahi kar deta
Really a wonderful comparison thanks for your efforts brother👏👌
Overall PUNCH is best 🔥💥
Magnite looks stunning compared to other and also features wise more cool. 100% value for money 💰
Well Punch is more powerful and safer than both cars,
If you have money to buy turbo variant,
Buying a Nexon would make more sense
Even Tiago has more power than the other 2 cars
Punch has thick metal sheet, which can protect its passangers, Punch is 100 kilo heavier, means thick metal sheets
I have been following your Nexon videos very closely and you have done some really amazing work.Need 1 opinion, I am buying Nexon, I have a budget for buying XZ variant only.
but confused in XE and XM.
if I buy xe and spent extra money aftermarket to make this model XZ is it worth it? a lot of people say don't do any wiring-related work aftermarket as it causes problems after some time.
same with XM variant.
conclusion- or I directly go to XZ variant and skip all aftermarket work.
please suggest your opinion which is a better way.
Xz ....
What a beauty KIGER is, and overall the best car❤️❤️, 4 airbags, CMF-A+ platform (proven in triber and magnite with 2 airbags only still 4 stars), space, comfort, practically, ❤️❤️ Kiger comes with AMT also, no clutch problem and all, effortless.❤️
Best in compact suv segment ❤️
That Red Colored body with White top looks excellent.
Your presentation is very good. The analysis has been forthright and point blank,without bias.Your language is the highlight of the presentation.
Can you send me a comparison between 2022 Baleno vs Latest S cross.
Thank you.
Kiger is better than others
On the basis of Comfort on roads, which is best?
I myself using renault kwid and it's a awesome car with good average and run smoothly on road also I will plan kiger next
Magnite' Dashboard may not be the loudest, but it provides everything apart from design screaming. Magnite has comfortable seating along with backseat space. Magnite is the best car for lazy drivers and normal usage.
all good….yet one problem…How many years Nissan will survive in india with such low volumes. ??? now that we have Chevy, Ford Fiat to the list……At this point i would stick to. hyundai Kia Honda Mahindra Tata….btw i own a ford…no grudge against the companies which exited…its about survival
@@debasissamantray8233 Nissan has plans for India.. they are going to launch a 7 seater under 7-8L at the end of the year.. Secondly Ford didn't had plans for India as such people were demanding for face lifts of Aspire, Figo n ol but Ford didn't understand the Indian Market well.. Nissan survived indian market when they had failures n now after success of Magnite they won't leave .. Note no Japanese brand has left Indian Market untill now.. Suzuki,Toyota,Honda Nissan.. let me tell you KIA is worst of all brands in india right now.. Nissan is better than Kia atleast Nissan is serious for Indian Market and also Nissan has 7-8 car's at low budget like Magnite for Indian Market which would be manufactured in India under "Make in India Make for World" campaign the Nissan Next !!!
@@debasissamantray8233 how does it matters except if you wan to buy a car to sale after ? We should fous on a car & not a company !
@@debasissamantray8233 btw honda may also exit
Only Maruti Hyundai Tata mahindra are go to companies
@@debasissamantray8233 Nissan car will get service till Renault is there, because Nissan is Renault subsidiary, assembled in same plants i think and may have same platform. Chances of both exiting Indian market is very slim. Ford failed to lunch smaller cars, they have American mindset of bigger cars that was the main reason for they leaving India. Renault and Nissan are globally successful in smaller cars, they are also adopting to Indian market needs so I think customers should not have any concern. Though margins are very thins in Indian market and any automaker will have tough time but these cars exist with these features is proof that they are doing their best.
Magnite is the clear winner hands down
Nissan magnite will be my pick out of these. Nissan magnite lovers hit like 👍!
Magnite is best choice in this segment better than punch bcoz it also scored 4 stars Asean ncap
4star🤣
It will score 0 in G NCAP
Bro if you test drive magnite then you will understand how low quality is magnite
Magnite feels really cheap
Doors are like ready go
@@manofsteel646 tested and 4 stars.
French is always and will be the best when it comes to designs. Kiger looks great and it has very good road presence. When you see in the road it is always eye-catching.
Very good review !! I knew it at beginning of the video the Magnite wud win , bt i really wud prefer the turbo variant if i were to buy this car!!
Magnite is love ❤️
Magnite 🔥🔥
Good to see you back after a while.
0:40 what is the background music..
Batado koi wo bgm kya tha..
One important point missing. Tata punch has foot rest which helps driver in long drive. This is not available in both kiger n magnite
@6.49 _ The reason I choose Punch, and it will be deliver in next week. 👍🤗
Good decision
I will take the magnite. All day every day.
Gareeb
Magnite looks good for me
Tata looks better
My choice - magnite
Magnite's cabin noise due to lack of isolation is a huge damper to the daily driving experience.
Magnite Design, Beauty, Spacious and Engine ❤
Nissan magnite xv cvt model prices are increased upto around 12 lakhs, is this car is worth to buy in this price segment and please suggest me another car for roadno price 10 lakhs
Bhai kiger rxz turbo mt ka on road price kitna hai
Dhanbad Jharkhand me
Good comparison. Keep it up
Blue or red Kiger looks stunning 😍❤✌
Renault kiger has more dominant road presence as compare to his rival's and Gavin sir explain more greatly love you AutoCar India.
My initial preference goes to ride handling and safety
Want this video to smash the record views simply for the way you presented the video...
Happy to see Gavin 💞
Great effort well explained.. Cngrts
Amazing mahaa comparison between these three SUVs 👌🔥
Kiger and magnite aren't even SUV
They are not suv's pls !! They are hatchbacks with raised ground clearance*!
Magnite is almost what we are hunting for spacious and features which meet with budget
Magnite 🔥🔥❤️❤️
Overall except exterior body both Mignite and Kiger same overall all specs and price also.. Punch user share long term feedback about city and highway ride stability? Mileage .?
Can you guys make a comparison between the Skoda kushaq, WolkswagenTaigun, Kia Seltos and Hyundai Creta??
Make a video with all sub 4m SUVs in 2022.
1. Kiger Turbo
2. Kiger NA variant
3. Magnite Turbo
4. Magnite NA variant
5. Sonet Turbo Petrol
6. Sonet NA Petrol
7. Sonet Deisel
8. Venue Turbo Petrol
9. Venue NA Petrol
10. Venue Deisel
11. Nexon Petrol
12. Nexon Diesel
13. Vitara Brezza
14. Urban Cruiser
15. XUV300 Petrol
16. XUV300 Diesel
17. WR-V Petrol
18. WR-V Diesel
19. Thar Petrol
20. Thar Diesel
21. Bolero
There are multiple videos with subset of this list.
Compare the base variants of all of these cars.
No other Indian channels can make this except Autocar.
Treat us guys!!
Honest review & verdict 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
kiger is small but nice tbh
As a Indian...Love to see "TATA " in All Segments❤️
Ncap has also tested the magnite and it scored ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Kiger and Magnite are 4 star Global NCap rated now!
Kiger look❤❤❤interior
Magnite sharpboxy❤❤ 👌equipment
Punch❤build
you buy Alto definitely. I know
Nissan is the trendsetter here
Magnite ❤️👌
We have booked Kiger Rxz turbo cvt , monthly running 900 kms approx , 50 % city, 30% highway, 20% Bumper to bumper traffic, is our decision right???
Hey guys " 0:40 " which music is this😂.....please let me know🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻.....please share the link or name of the music if you know🙂🙂🙂💛💛💛
Magnite
Magnite is too good
Is possible please compare turbo version of magnite
I'm going with magnite.. but turbo version
Because normal magnite seems to be very low in performance
Would love to have Tata punch though it may not be like other twos but the trust and service Tata provides is good and also its our Indian Automotive company.
Magnite ❤️❤️❤️
Con for me i am not heavy driver
So my cons in look is
Punch: rear look 💩💩
Magnite front look is not aggressive as kiger and punch interior also
Kiger: over all good
I'm looking for Spacious,good driving dynamics, comfortable car with best in safety
So it is punch for me...
superb job bro 👍 i like this video
i purchas Beast TATA Punch, kya feel h mast
Tata Punch needs to launch it's diesel version quickly. It will outsell everything else like crazy.
Also, we need it's EV version within a year's time. And at a price which is good and acceptable to the customers.
You can do it, Tata. Come on.
Pricing of the diesel variant will be even higher which will again go against its value proposition
Nah, it's cabin is too cramped for the segment.
Also a turbo petrol version must be released bro
@@hrishikesh12341 That's okay. People will shell out a lakh more for a better value for money proposition if one plans to keep the car for more than 4 years or so, while running it for 15-20k kms a year. It will pay back. You have the double whammy of a difference of ₹12-15 a litre between the price of petrol and diesel, and also at least 30% efficiency between the two engine types. So, yeah, people will buy diesel. Just look at how Hyundai/Kia are nailing the diesel game. Even Ford - with its dated EcoSport - was able to put in solid numbers after April 2020 BS6 engine introduction.
There is space for diesel for sure. At least until the EV game is amped up by the manufacturers to serve the masses. And that's really a decade away, considering all practicalities.
Most awaited comparison
Kindly do Magnite Non turbo speed ,pickup and pulling power video to clarify the doubts of people who like to buy that.
Nissan magnite🔥👍