It’s so interesting to see Spanish growth, for example if you compare it to Italy. It started with an economy 3 times smaller than the Italian one, and finishes with a slightly smaller economy, which is normal, as Spanish pop is also smaller.
Italy's population is shrinking extremely rapidly, a demographic collapse is imminent. We lose 130k young persons each year that migrate towards other Eu nations with better pay, while the fertility rates are plummeting and now sits at less than 1.2 kids each woman. We already lost 5% of our population in the last 5 years (from 61 to 58 million inhabitants) our economy wont grow at all in the near future and will start to shrink as well
@@felixcanas9446 Marshall's plan was in 1945, bro... 50 years before. This plan was to rebuild italian economy which has been destroyed by the war. Spanish economy was not. Did it ? And, just keep in mind, Italy is a net contributor of European budget. Spain is still not. What is not understandable after 40 years.
@@thierryfromgwada9312Spanish economy was not? Spain had a civil war that it was far worse for the country than ww2 for Italy and after the war no Marshall plan and no commerce because the country was isolated after the war by the winners of the war. Spain became the 8th World economy in 1975 by itself w/o UE. Actually UE has been a very bad business for Spain. I recommend you to read and learn something about history and economy
Slovakia is not on/at the list. Thanks to SD politicians and their electorate. It's a shame. Congratulation to Romania. This country has done great progress.
@@Cosmic_Happiness It all depends on where you define Europe's eastern border. As we know, there is no undisputed definition for this in particular. I therefore adhere to the principle of which cultural character a state belongs to. This is essentially determined by where the centre of population is located. Turkey and Kazakhstan, for example, are Asian countries, while Russia is a European country, as is France, despite its overseas territories.
GDP di Russia non è sicuro neanche è vero. Tutti i dati di loro non sono da verificare ma soltanto si basa al loro declarazione propria. Allora così sì può prendere in considerazione che esempio Luxembourg può dire che il suo GDP è enorme !
Россия, которая пережила революцию, отделения территорий с заводами, людьми и ресурсами, несколько войн, самый суровый климат и большие расстояния, санкции.Экономика России занимает 5-е место среди стран мира и 1-е среди стран Европы по объёму ВВП по ППС, который на 2023 год оценивался в 5,51 трлн долларов (по данным МВФ). По объёму номинального ВВП (2,215 трлн долларов в 2022 году) Россия занимала 8-е место в мире и 4-е в Европе (по данным МВФ). По ВВП на душу населения (ППС) в 2022 году Россия была на 59-м месте в мире (МВФ)
@@user-ei9ys9xp1e Хотя хз. Возможно это действительно немецкая мечта. Я тут пообщалась с некоторыми -говорят, что это хорошо. Германия перестанет загрязнять окружающую среду и перейдет на "экологическое топливо". Пожелаем им в таком случае успеха в сбыте мечт 😂
nice comparison, should be shown er capita and corrected by inflation rates. I think that would show the extent of the European economic disaster of the past 30 years!
Technically, it was: 1960-1985ish: USSR 1985ish-1989: West Germany 1989-Present: Germany USSR data was unavailable but there are well-formed estimates.
It's a per capita not overall. West Germany is richest courty in Europea in per capita, alought USSR is highest GDP in Europea, she has many member countries, largest population, but in capita was lower than W.Germany.
The future does not include the end of globalism as we know it, that will be bad for german exports, and also the energy crisis. Both bad for germany in particular and more in favor of France and southern Europe.
Totally true + expensive energy + insufficient workers + high salaries will end German lead. 2030+ Turkey and Southern Europe will be at top 3-4. No question.
@@yasindemir ahahahahahahaha turky? ahahahahahahahah .look guys Germany is at the heart of Europe berlin is the EUs capital due to geography it will always have the highest gdp , btw the conservatives that see globalism as terrible thing can bleet all they like ,they are to stupid to work out that most of the right wing leadership are globalist portending to be nationalists to glean support from morons . but there trying to swim up river, nothing will stop the ebbing away of borders. ridicules artificial constructs that they are any way .when you think about it .
Perhaps, but currently Russia is outproducing all of NATO (including US) in shells and weapons, and has a pretty diversified manufacturing base and comparitivly self-sufficient economy compared to the rest of Europe. Pretty good for "a gas station masquerading as a country".
Data is wrong - Russia as it stands surpassed Germany, which is in recession, like most of Europe and now is the biggest economy on the old continent. It's 4rth in the world after China, USA, and India.
Looks like Germany topped 5.521 Trillion as if UK topped 5.225 trillion. Germany, UK and France are the top three highest economic nations. Even with Norway, Denmark, Finland, and Sweden combined cannot reach 4 to 5 trillion.
The future estimation, doesn't take into consideration deglobalisation, which will certainly impact negatively to German, French and UK economy, and positively on economies of central European countries like Poland. additionaly a society structure, education structure is impacting really negatively on Germany while on the other hand this aspect is actually judge benefit for Poland. Germany are really overestimated, and need to back to their right place. The biggest unknown is how AI impact our economies.
Con una mierda de gobierno sociata, con una política económica e impositiva como la que impone, mucho me temo que aún caeremos varios puestos en el ranquing.
@@Cosmic_Happiness, у Турции, хотя бы самый крупный город находится в Европе, в Казахстан - не в одну тысячу км. восточнее. Т.е., он даже формально, и даже частично, НЕ удовлетворяет критериям "европейскости". А турок ещё, то ли 3, то ли 5 млн.живет в самом центре Старого континента, в Германии.
@@epickzalpha8273Американцы уже всё сделали: продают дорогой сжиженный газ глупым европейцам, обеспечили заказами свой военно- промышленный комплекс за счёт денег Евросоюза, сделали товары из Европы дорогими и не конкурентоспособными. Ещё нужны аргументы?
Сами рисовали цены товаров и услуг и курс доллара. Кроме того и сами объемы производства части товаров и услуг были завышены. Так все могут нарисовать свой ввп. В С.Корее тоже наверняка рекорды бьют постоянно.
😂😂😂 какая икономика , пока голодали оружие производили и обонкротились и Ссср рухнул ! Сейчас и Федерацию ждет банкрот и развал по той же причине ! Мир станет лучше без рашки !
Экономика Россия номер 1!!!! в Европе по паритету покупательской возможности в 2023 году и 5ч в мире, через год станет 4 я отодвинув Японию на 5е место 😊🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺
Хорошо бы посмотреть рейтинг по долгам
It’s so interesting to see Spanish growth, for example if you compare it to Italy. It started with an economy 3 times smaller than the Italian one, and finishes with a slightly smaller economy, which is normal, as Spanish pop is also smaller.
Italy's population is shrinking extremely rapidly, a demographic collapse is imminent. We lose 130k young persons each year that migrate towards other Eu nations with better pay, while the fertility rates are plummeting and now sits at less than 1.2 kids each woman.
We already lost 5% of our population in the last 5 years (from 61 to 58 million inhabitants) our economy wont grow at all in the near future and will start to shrink as well
1986 : They entered in EU and receive money since...
@@thierryfromgwada9312Italy received a lot more money from Marshall’s plan. Spain didn’t.
@@felixcanas9446 Marshall's plan was in 1945, bro... 50 years before.
This plan was to rebuild italian economy which has been destroyed by the war. Spanish economy was not. Did it ?
And, just keep in mind, Italy is a net contributor of European budget. Spain is still not. What is not understandable after 40 years.
@@thierryfromgwada9312Spanish economy was not? Spain had a civil war that it was far worse for the country than ww2 for Italy and after the war no Marshall plan and no commerce because the country was isolated after the war by the winners of the war. Spain became the 8th World economy in 1975 by itself w/o UE. Actually UE has been a very bad business for Spain. I recommend you to read and learn something about history and economy
Slovakia is not on/at the list. Thanks to SD politicians and their electorate. It's a shame. Congratulation to Romania. This country has done great progress.
I ask myself what Kazakhstan has to do on a list of European countries.
Because 13% of Kazakhstan’s territory is in Europe. The Russian Federation has 22℅ percent in Europe, and Turkey has 4℅ in Europe, 96℅ in Asia.
@@Cosmic_Happiness It all depends on where you define Europe's eastern border. As we know, there is no undisputed definition for this in particular. I therefore adhere to the principle of which cultural character a state belongs to. This is essentially determined by where the centre of population is located. Turkey and Kazakhstan, for example, are Asian countries, while Russia is a European country, as is France, despite its overseas territories.
Poland 💪
Romania between 1948-1989 had another flag
Poland 🇵🇱🫡
Gdyby nie Tusk bylibysmy wyzej a tak to nas ciagnie w dół
@@mariach.69zwłaszcza ty bylbyś wyżej. Karle umyslowy.
You realise it was a year ago?@@mariach.69
GDP di Russia non è sicuro neanche è vero. Tutti i dati di loro non sono da verificare ma soltanto si basa al loro declarazione propria. Allora così sì può prendere in considerazione che esempio Luxembourg può dire che il suo GDP è enorme !
Keep in mind, the Netherlands has a population of 18 million. Compare that with other countries
Yes we even have 17 million! We Dutch are proud! 🇳🇱🧡❤🤍💙
Swedes are 10 million.
Switzerland only have 9m bro
Россия, которая пережила революцию, отделения территорий с заводами, людьми и ресурсами, несколько войн, самый суровый климат и большие расстояния, санкции.Экономика России занимает 5-е место среди стран мира и 1-е среди стран Европы по объёму ВВП по ППС, который на 2023 год оценивался в 5,51 трлн долларов (по данным МВФ). По объёму номинального ВВП (2,215 трлн долларов в 2022 году) Россия занимала 8-е место в мире и 4-е в Европе (по данным МВФ). По ВВП на душу населения (ППС) в 2022 году Россия была на 59-м месте в мире (МВФ)
@@Dimadms19 Just wrote it with chat gpt the text is to perfect so shut up bot
And Bulgaria had another flag too in the cold war (1947-1990)
RUSSIA AND TURKEY RISING TOGETHER .. LOOK AT IT CAREFULLY AFTER 2008
В Германии деиндустриализации идёт полным ходом. Предприятия закрывают. Какое 1 место к 2030 году? 😹🤦
Мечты,мечты😅
@@user-ei9ys9xp1e Суровая реальность. К сожалению.
@@user-ei9ys9xp1e Хотя хз. Возможно это действительно немецкая мечта. Я тут пообщалась с некоторыми -говорят, что это хорошо. Германия перестанет загрязнять окружающую среду и перейдет на "экологическое топливо". Пожелаем им в таком случае успеха в сбыте мечт 😂
nice comparison, should be shown er capita and corrected by inflation rates.
I think that would show the extent of the European economic disaster of the past 30 years!
1961-1966 UK
1966-1967 France
1967-present. Germany
Technically, it was:
1960-1985ish: USSR
1985ish-1989: West Germany
1989-Present: Germany
USSR data was unavailable but there are well-formed estimates.
It's a per capita not overall. West Germany is richest courty in Europea in per capita, alought USSR is highest GDP in Europea, she has many member countries, largest population, but in capita was lower than W.Germany.
Technically DDR "absorbed" west germany! 🤭☝
Credits for the guy who time travelled to give us that information
Good luck to Irish from Saudi Arabia
The future does not include the end of globalism as we know it, that will be bad for german exports, and also the energy crisis. Both bad for germany in particular and more in favor of France and southern Europe.
Totally true + expensive energy + insufficient workers + high salaries will end German lead. 2030+ Turkey and Southern Europe will be at top 3-4. No question.
@@yasindemir ahahahahahahaha turky? ahahahahahahahah .look guys Germany is at the heart of Europe berlin is the EUs capital due to geography it will always have the highest gdp ,
btw the conservatives that see globalism as terrible thing can bleet all they like ,they are to stupid to work out that most of the right wing leadership are globalist portending to be nationalists to glean support from morons . but there trying to swim up river, nothing will stop the ebbing away of borders. ridicules artificial constructs that they are any way .when you think about it .
@@yasindemir lol Southern Europe will remain poor for the next 2 centuries. Southern Europe is so last millennia. This is age of Western Europe
Why France would not grow as UK in coming years ?
@@ashutoshpandeyz4508
The forecast hasn't included the effects of Brexit and the war in Ukraine.
Suspicious of any USSR satellite statistics
The World Bank data is not falsified, and more than 30 years have passed.
Perhaps, but currently Russia is outproducing all of NATO (including US) in shells and weapons, and has a pretty diversified manufacturing base and comparitivly self-sufficient economy compared to the rest of Europe. Pretty good for "a gas station masquerading as a country".
Funny how Germany always ends up on top. Must be the water.
2000 was a bad year for the UK😮
Data is wrong - Russia as it stands surpassed Germany, which is in recession, like most of Europe and now is the biggest economy on the old continent. It's 4rth in the world after China, USA, and India.
La Russie ne fait pas partie de l'Europe....
This is wrong, Germany surpassed Japan in 2023 and is the 3rd largest economy globally, Russia is far behind.
All wrong. Zimbabwe is the greatest economy in the world.
@@J_09_Reyпосле России. Россия везде "первая" и "великая" Ура.
@@nikolayruzhilo8267 LOL
А разве в 2к30 в Европе еще будет экономика?
Kazakhstan is Europe?
How? where?
Because 13% of Kazakhstan’s territory is in Europe. The Russian Federation has 22℅ percent in Europe, and Turkey has 4℅ in Europe, 96℅ in Asia.
Looks like Germany topped 5.521 Trillion as if UK topped 5.225 trillion. Germany, UK and France are the top three highest economic nations. Even with Norway, Denmark, Finland, and Sweden combined cannot reach 4 to 5 trillion.
The future estimation, doesn't take into consideration deglobalisation, which will certainly impact negatively to German, French and UK economy, and positively on economies of central European countries like Poland. additionaly a society structure, education structure is impacting really negatively on Germany while on the other hand this aspect is actually judge benefit for Poland. Germany are really overestimated, and need to back to their right place. The biggest unknown is how AI impact our economies.
Poland don't accept immigration
@@ukaszs5057 Польша сосет все европейские страны. Своего развития там нет.
Me parto con las previsiones
Where is Soviet Union
E' errato; da 72 al 74 il regno unito ha subito una terribile inflazione con code chilometriche agli uffici di collocamento!
brexit britain will not achieve that
Indeed Britain has the weakest growth forecast for coming years among large countries in western Europe.
@@Foersom_no that goes to Germany.
Polska przekroczy bilion w 2025
@@kielekm1 esperons pour la ne Pologne
To bardziej dane, niż nadzieja👍@@tobiasdelmore5215
Con una mierda de gobierno sociata, con una política económica e impositiva como la que impone, mucho me temo que aún caeremos varios puestos en el ranquing.
2024 and Turkiyes gdp is 1,3 trillion
The growth forecast for the United Kingdom seems unrealistic to say the least
Not true Russia at first
Where was the Soviet Union?
he was starving while producing weapons.
До 1985г. СССР был второй экономикой мира, пока не пришёл к власти предатель Горбачёв.
and if you count for one person😊
Uni Soviet?
No era Europa
Европа заканчивается на востоке уральскими горами.
1964 kada sam se ja rodio YU je bila jača od Norveške❤
1992-1993 prime İtaly :)
😅😅😅 ....si l'Italia più della Russia 😂😂😂
Where is Hungary? 😮
In Putin's wallet.
Unfortunately part of Russia is in Europe.The rest is in Asia whereas during the days of the USSR it was one continent.
Чего бля?🤨
Türkiye didn’t exist that time
Kazakhstan in Europe??? 🤔
yes, it has a small piece in Europe
Because 13% of Kazakhstan’s territory is in Europe. The Russian Federation has 22℅ percent in Europe, and Turkey has 4℅ in Europe, 96℅ in Asia.
Will the U.K. supplant Germany? It could happen.
I don"t think so...UK lost after Brexit even if GDP is not slowing down
It depends when when we have recessions Germany does better than UK but when times are economically good UK does Better than Germany
Soon.
TURKEY IS NOT EUROPEAN COUNTRY
Part is.
😅🤣😂
Miért, szerinted milyen? Amerikai?
Hogy ne lenne európai?
Turkey has 4℅ territory in Europe, 96℅ in Asia.
Im not suprised, first 8 r the biggest and colonial countries + suisse as bank country for them 😄😄😄
France 3200 billons $ in 2024 not 2900
Kazachstan in Europe? Congratulation.
I thought the Irish were the richest
Казахстан НИКОГДА в Европе не был.
А Турция?
@@Cosmic_Happiness, у Турции, хотя бы самый крупный город находится в Европе, в Казахстан - не в одну тысячу км. восточнее. Т.е., он даже формально, и даже частично, НЕ удовлетворяет критериям "европейскости". А турок ещё, то ли 3, то ли 5 млн.живет в самом центре Старого континента, в Германии.
@@todornestorov7891 И вот в футболе, в УЕФА правильно было бы, чтобы там участвовали только команды тех городов, которые находятся в Европе.
Западно-Казастанская область полностью находится в Европе
@@finglaz , НА,колко мне известно из географии, Азию отделяет от Европы Урал.
Who did this ranking?The Kremlin?
20:30 end
USSR? Never heard about that 🤦🏻
Учи русский язык,скоро пригодится😅
@@user-ei9ys9xp1e если бы у тебя были лучше развиты нейронные связи, ты бы поняла, что это сарказм...
Menuda broma...
🤔 As they stole more resources around the world they rose in rank
Portugal continua sendo pobre
Respect to Germany.. And we need Turkey economy for our Europe
And we need Europe economy for our Turkiye 😊
@@favorius god bless turkey.. Kiss from France and Algeria 😘🇨🇵🇩🇿🇹🇷
Nah, Europe doesn’t need turkiye. Just another beggar. We don’t work our asses off just to feed Europe.
so its Germany number 1 for eternity
Of course.
Нет, потому что больше не будет дешёвых энергоресурсов и сырья из России. И терерь накроется экономика Евросоюза медным тазом.
@@andreig4522cope harder😂😂😂
@@epickzalpha8273Американцы уже всё сделали: продают дорогой сжиженный газ глупым европейцам, обеспечили заказами свой военно- промышленный комплекс за счёт денег Евросоюза, сделали товары из Европы дорогими и не конкурентоспособными. Ещё нужны аргументы?
@@andreig4522 no one is gonna translate your trash ruzzian language to beautiful English language.
Это желание ?
Go Brittain 🇬🇧❤️🇭🇲❤️🇨🇦❤️🇳🇿
Very inaccurate specially East Germany:)
Где СССР? Стыдно показать , что вся европейская экономика совокупно была ниже СССР?
Сами рисовали цены товаров и услуг и курс доллара. Кроме того и сами объемы производства части товаров и услуг были завышены. Так все могут нарисовать свой ввп.
В С.Корее тоже наверняка рекорды бьют постоянно.
Ja,ja, la URSS era un desastre, po eso estalló, mira ahora algo similar Rusia ees inferior a Italia así que imagínate co toda la Europa occidental
😂😂😂 какая икономика , пока голодали оружие производили и обонкротились и Ссср рухнул !
Сейчас и Федерацию ждет банкрот и развал по той же причине !
Мир станет лучше без рашки !
@@periquete6557 Вся ваша экономика мыльный пузырь. 😅
ussr? You mean that country who lost cold war to usa? 😂😂😂😂😂
Well... sucks to be Portuguese huh
Хрень...по паритету покупательной способности надо считать.
паритет покупательской спосоности придумали нищеброды чтобы не выглядеть так убого 😂
🇹🇷
Where ussr 😡
In your dreams kid
The largest economy in Russia. It is necessary to calculate according to purchasing power parity
😂😂😂😂🤡🤡🤡
😂😂😂
Russia has the biggest Economic, this is paid youtube scam!
Russia is not Europe.
@@dariuswroclawski5521 You probably didn't learn well at school. Look where the border between Europe and Asia lies
I guess Russia is way down now 😊
Why do you think European countries rise in rank?
Мы в России переживаем только за то, как бы не заболеть на ваших похоронах. 😅
Завидуй молча! 😊 Санкции пошли только на пользу😂 С Россией все отлично.
Что до вас, посмотрим в ближайший год 😂 на ваши депрессивные состояния😂
It is all wrong....Greece is second and Albania third
Ussr economy collapse
🤣🙈🤪👎🐷
ruzzians gonna cry over this comment 😂😂😂
@@epickzalpha8273Россия смеётся над этим комментарием))))
SS mans o the top
Who it's not USSR??I thinking it European country 😂
Pues no, no era Europeo, era ruroasiatico
No it s a eurasian country! Kazakhstan, Tatchikistan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, Azerbaijan and Russia from the Urals all belong to Asia.
Где СССР дурни? Или специально не показывали чтоб страшно не было?
Most normal ruzzian comment:
так тут о Европе речь, хотя было бы забавно посмотреть на графике как СССР схлопнулся в 91м
@@jamesturbo5490 а Россия это что внезапно азия или границу между континентами с урала куда перенесли?
1960-1991 USSR - GDP ?,
1960-1980 Poland and Romania - GDP ?,
DDR - GDP really ?,
and Hungary ?,
its stupid jokes !!! 👎
DDR is East Germany in this video. USSR is not Europe (can discuss Russia) Poland and Romania did not reach the top list.
GDP of DDR is BS just like any another from "Soviet camp".
@@TheReactor8 USSR is much more in Europe than Turkey. But Soviet statistics are BS
ussr? You mean the poorest country in the world history? 😂😂😂 bot
А СССР где, грамотеи...?
In your asss.. go search for it there 😂😂😂 bot
Точно, а где теперь твой СССР? 😂😂😂
Poland will have 1,7T 2025/6 so change this bullshit
Turkish not in Europe!!
Yes it is in africa
😂
End at 7:44
No figuran rumania, andorra, polonia
Falsche Informationen
Quite ridiculous ranking.
Why? Do you think the IMF is wrong?
This is BS.
Сладкие мечты всемирного банка))) Россия уже давно обходит все эти жалкие страны по размеру экономики, даже прогнозировать ничего не надо, это факт.
это тебе Путин по ящику сказал? А почему тогда у тебя под окном в контейнере пенсионеры роются? 😂
„Rosjanin jest największym i najbardziej zuchwałym kłamcą na świecie”. Iwan Turgieniew - rosyjski pisarz.
@user-gl1sc7my3b вы можете сколько угодно бабки Сороса отрабатывать, ситуацию это не изменит.
@@jamesturbo5490 можете сколько угодно бабки Сороса отрабатывать, ситуацию это не изменит.
Lol XD
Und dann solo jemand erklâren warum Deutschland verschuldet ist!!!!Bitte
These are false figures.!
What is wrong, and why?
Yes, what is wrong?
Hungary missing
Russia is not in Europe.
1/3 Европы находится на территории России. Мы Европа больше чем кто-либо. 😅
Вы смешной
Since what year?
@@finglaz Россия всегда входила в восточную часть Европы.
Если она вне европейского союза - это не значит, что она не в Европе))
@@RafailOsmanov ну я то знаю, а вот автор утверждения видимо в пароксизме русофобии перерисовал границы Европы.
Russian ❤❤❤
Russia has nothing to do with europe !
And turkey does?
@@peterpetrov3060 there is a part of Turkey that is in europe . I don't like it , but it is
@@erwinmeijer1004 well by that logic, Russia has a large part in Europe where 100 million people live
@@peterpetrov3060 russia doesn't want to have anything to do with europe and we don't want to have anything to do with russia , so russia is banned.
@@erwinmeijer1004 rasista
Экономика Россия номер 1!!!! в Европе по паритету покупательской возможности в 2023 году и 5ч в мире, через год станет 4 я отодвинув Японию на 5е место 😊🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺
Spoko dzięki tfuskowi spokojnie w cztery lata spadniemy na samo dno tej listy