Panel discussion on Mindanao independence, Uniteam, charter change
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 02. 2024
- The rift between the Marcos and Duterte families has spawned another issue: Mindanao independence.
In this special panel discussion, Rappler thought leaders discuss Mindanao independence, the Uniteam political alliance, and the push for charter change under the Marcos Jr. administration.
Moderated by Rappler reporter Dwight de Leon, the panel discussion features Alvarez, political analyst Ronald Llamas, and former presidential peace adviser Ging Deles. Rappler Senate reporter Bonz Magsambol and House reporter Kaycee Valmonte also join in.
www.rappler.com/philippines/v...
I am from Mindanao, if ang independence man lang will be lead by the Duterte dynasty, aie wag na lang
Independency of Mindanao is not means be govern by DUTERTE's dynasty. It's better Philippines government can proceed the imposition of federalism means every state can run and drive of their own development and progress of every states
Napaka simply lng naman intindihin. Pagusapan mag karuon ng debate para maintindihan tapos plebiscite kng talo ang pro it's the end. Itong magagalaling para cla lng matalino at pwede mag decide
It's probably better for the PH to run an public inquiry about this matter to the people of Mindanao.
The longer this runs; the hotter it burns because we're sick and tired of all of you.
pwede po ba na maipaliwanag sa mga tao lalo na sa class c&d na kung ano po ang kahihinatnan kung maituloy ang Peoples Initiative na tinatawag mas marami po kase ang hindi naiintindihan kung para saan po yan
Wala na bang ibang host ang rappler who at least sound unbiased?
Ako,isa sa mga tutol na ihiwalay ang Mindanao sa bansang Pilipinas. Paano mabuo ang uniteam kung ihiwalay ang Mindanao sa bansang Pilipinas. Marami akong kamag-anak na nakatira diyan sa Mindanao. Maliit lang ang bansang Pilipinas magkahiwahiwalay pa, ano kaya ang mangyari sa bansang Pilipinas? Bakit hindi natin sundin ang bansang America at bansang U.K.? Malaki na ang bansang America at U.K. Pero bakit humahanap pa sila ng ibang bansa para mangin kasapi nila. Sana madagdag pa sa Pilipinas ang Sabah para lumaki ng kaunti ang bansang Pilipinas.
Bro they want to conquer more lands??? hindi mo ba alam they want more power to dominates others. balikan mo ang nakaraan ng ang mga amerikano ay nasa pinas diba?
Totol akong maihiwalay Ang Mindanao sa pilipinas pagka sa matagal na panahon Ang Mindanao Ang Isa sa bumubuo ng pilipinas sa tinawag na LUZON VISAYAs MINDANAO ang solosyon ay Palitan Ang mga opisyal ng gobyerno na Hindi patas at kurap na d ginagawa ng Tama Ang kanilang obligasyon nilang inihalal at pinatiwalaan ng taong bayan para mamuno at isaayos Ang ating Bansa di yong pansariling lang nilang kapakanan.
.
I support Mindanao Independence para sa kaunlaran. Napupunta lang ang pera sa bulsa ng greedy and corrupt politicians. government.
hindi ba si Duterte ang presidente for 6 yrs before Marcos? may ginawa ba sya para umayos ang Mindanao? Sara spent P125 million in 11 days and Pulong’s P51-B budget in three years who are both from Southern Mindanao. greedy and corrupt politicians?
Panahon pa ng mga lolo namin yan kasi lahat ng kita ng mindanao di na balik sa mindanao. Doon patungu sa Emperial Manila. Tapos wala ginamawa government o tulong sa Mindanao.
For me there is nothing to worry about cha-cha unless the results are the progress or the economic prosperity even though there is a long term position of the highest official in the land.
How big is the Mindanao military?
kami, ang inaabangan po namin ay mapaunlad ang AGRICULTURE para makamura sa bilihin parte sa pagkain, yong SOLAR para pababain ang bayad sa kuryenete, pabilisin ang INTERNET yan ang mga highlights sa kampanya nyo po noon PBBM kaya kayo po ang ini boto namin
Napaka husay mag gpaliwanag ni ronald llmas,.. dati asar aq pag kasamahan ni pnoy. Pero daoat iniintindi m din ung sinasabi nila.👏👏👏👏😊😊👋👋👋
Mag politiko lang ng Mindanao ang ayaw, kaming mga ordinary people , all out support kami sa independent Mindanao , dahil sa mga sakim at kawatan na mga politiko sa Luzon at visayas.
Dapat maalis n Ang senado.
With the contradicting statements ni Duterte, isa lang ang sumasagi sa isip ko, may Alzheimer na sya.
It’s so simple... if govt will push for PI and HSMR seat as a PM, Mindanao do not want to be part of it. It’s like Duterte saying push ur agenda and I’ll push mine and let’s see. Simple as that... this 2 guest missing all the points here.
leni robredo for president bongbong marcos for vice president 2028 presidential election pulahan kakampink the true uniteam ❤❤❤
tama persunal entires😂
Fred Perry Llamas ❤
the topic is good and should have chosen the better panel
Better panel like?
@kool-aidman2797 a panel that doesn't hesitate and minced words- not very believable. I'm not admin or dutertes side but just someone trying to discern what's going on. So the topic is actually good.
@@aspect2846 A better panel would be the notorious Ex-president, the current President, and someone frank and to the point - like BOY ABUNDA.
@jashcarred24 they are the ones needed to settle all issues, well see who can answer logically. No to boy abunda though haha
Itigil na yan tungkol sa mindanao, it will not prosper anyway. Sayang lang oras at gastos.
No separation na mangyayari,, mindanao, still must be still,, in the philippines, no no no no no no no to separation of mindanao,
I think foreign investors also need stable business law, regulations , policies which requires stable governance. IMO longer term for leaders or chance for re election will also favor the economy. It goes hand in hand.
X pres. Duterte has no word of honor, his words always contradict themselves.
You should have invited Duterte to defend his idea. I don't think Alvarez really believes in this movement and will be able to convince people as he cant explain well and very non committal.
Digong demonstrated significant disrespect towards the administration, a responsibility his daughter shares in governing the country. PBBM is characterized by kindness, respectfulness, and diligence. In contrast, Duterte lacks these qualities, leading to a decline in his popularity and rendering him one of the most disliked figures in the nation.
sorry wrong you are wrong. im so sorry you never been a president or politician. how many filipinos did you help in your life? look at yourself first and tell me what have you done to help poor people in the philippines. are you God, President Mayor, Lawyer, Politician, are you a good Christian, soldier, or owner of philippines? pls let me know I will debate with you in a good manner please tell if you are one of the category, I mentioned then I will agree to you or bow down. Sorry Bro. Thou shall not judge others, it will be judge unto you...God Bless
@@user-yq6hj3pt4k, mawalang galang na po, e kayo po, sino po kayo from the enumerations you had mentioned?? 4 of us from the family are good tax payers and we never corrupt any money from the government.
😢😢😢no sense
Wow. 😂😂😂😂 mga tambaloslos gyud ni ilang opinion.
They are not just opinions, these are informed opinions. Tapusin mo muna ang panel discussion before commenting, napaghahalataan ka eh
Singapore, Hong Kong, at Taiwan separate ngayon asenso walang corruption. Mindanao naman maging mayaman Bansa.
Tambaloslos nga.
@@DomingoJrYap jusko anong katangahan yan? Tingnan mo nga nung naging independent ang Pilipinas at India, umunlad ba? hahahahahaha
@@DomingoJrYap tapos plano niyo humiwalay eh malaking porsyento ng kinikita ng bansa nasa metro manila. Pag humiwalay ang mindanao, lalo lang kayong maghihirap at mas uunlad ang metro manila.
Pray for wisdom the three of you and for the country 🙏🤲❣️, your advice is for bbm
Separate is good. to lessen the corruption.
Mindanao independence means more international trade, more international investments, more employment for Mindanaons. No more having to get approval of anyone in Manila.
Ah so Hindi ka mabubuhay if walang ka mag anak sa mindanao?
It's not even about getting approval from Manila that will be the hardest obstacle for "Mindanaoans" in case of secession; it will be your revenue generation capabilities. Total contribution of Davao to overall revenue to the Philippines overall is 1.12% & Northern Mindanao 0.79% vs NCR 84.24%, as per DBM stats. This only means that NCR revenues trickle down to other regions who are not generating enough revenues to cover expenses.
if you look at history of other countries, its better together than being alone, recently, with brexit, most britons regretted the outcome, look at WW1 and WW2, those were not won by british or americans alone, they worked together with other european countries as allied forces to stop the war, so lets learn from history
I support Independent Mindanao. Ito gawing gaya ng Singapore. At deseplinado ang mga tao sa Mindanao.
Yes. Kasi as of now disiplinado kayo. 😂😂😂😂
go go go republic of mindanao
I am from Mindanao. I support the independence of Mindanao dahil sa greed and corruption.
You support independence because of Duterte's greed and corruption. Ok. That's weird. But sure, that's what you want.
😂😂😂😂😂Nayanig kayu sa pasabog ni tatay Digong.
People power for Mindanao ang kailangan , peacefully kaming taga Mindanao ang mag decide sa sa sarili naming distiny
nagiging autonomy kc pinapalit ng imperial manila ang tunay na gusto na independent mindanao at halos mga politiko ay hindi taga mindanao kaya ang tunay na panawagang independent mindanao ay napunta na lamang sa paging autonomy.
Ngayon,hayaan nyo boses at taga mindanao mgdesisyon hindi kayo taga imperial manila, patuloy ang pagsibol ng independent mindanao,
ang mindanao ay para sa mga anak ng mindanao✊
Sinung traidor sa dalawa YES but NO then NO but YES. Mahirap samahan ang taong walang dignity.
Irrelevant
Para sa amin ang pera ng Mindanao para sa Mindanao at Mindanao ang makinabang hindi sa mga corrupt.
Hindi yan ang issue !!! ang issue bakit palitan ang Konstitusyon para forever na naman mga Marcos sa power!!!
Natumbok mo Pare, Hindi kaya si Madam Liza ang gusto din pumalit? hmmmm meron akong duda, 1, taba luslos, 2 Sandro, 3 madam Lisa... siguro nga
Kailangan palitan para umusad ang Pilipinas at umunlad. Pangulong Duterte pa ang nagsabi na kailangan palitan ang konstitusyon. Sadsad na sa kahirapan ang Pilipinas dahil sa 1987 Konstitusyon. Federalism ang kailangan ng Pilipinas dahil archepelagic country tayo at hayaan ang bawat regions na magpatakbo ng kani-kanilang lugar kung papano nila ito mapapa-unlad, di tulad ngayon na national ang government ang nag-dedecide kaya may na iiwan regions sa kaunlaran.
Hongkong , Singapore at Taiwan naghiwalay. Kaya umasenso. Ito na kita ng mindanao. 911 namin very activie than Manila
Kayo Ryan sa Luzon kayo ang Max nakinabang sa amin , kaya ayaw ninyo Perl gusto naming matupad into , kahit sa bingit ng kamatayan, speak up. Mindanao an , let's do our new journey kaya natin ito,
Bkit pg may sinabi si du30 puro paliwanag kyo bkit ung sa peoples initiative di nyo pliwanag maigi sa tao. Galing ni du30 bwat salita nya big issue sa knila'
Kung ang Singapore ay umaklas sa Malaysia,bakit di pupwede ito sa Pilipinas??? Bakit di sila bigyan ng pagkakataon na umunlad sa sarili nila???Tutal,matagal na rin yatang nakakaligtaan ng taga Luzon ang mga taga Mindanao!
Iba ang namuno sa Singapore. Sino Ang mamumuno sa Mindanao. Si dutae? Si Alvarez? Self serving lang mga yan.potek..
Hindi pwede sa Pilipinas if it will be led by FPRRD and his family. He is not and will never be a Lee Kwan Yu. Duterte is corrupt both equally in person and in spirit
The difference was that Singapore was unwanted by both China and Malaysia; they had no choice.
Duterte sure, afraid of rhe ICC ,tama ka sir, pareho tayo,, ng advance thinking about it,
Duterte wants to scape,, ICC,, coward digong,, he is afraid to face his penalty ,of killing enocent individuals, na walang kalaban laban,piro yung mga drug lord hindi nya hinuli,, at hindi pinapatay basta kasabwat sa kanyang illigal trading of drug,s ,yung mga hindi kakampi ni digong sila lang ang tinuugis at pinapapatay ni digong,, cruel sya,, shame ,woe woe to digong delete all of them,, dds / pdp laban,,
U lol. ICC is coming. Dutae get ready.😂😂
Ha? They came and they left na raw.😅😅😅
Republic of Mindanao coke free, corruption free, crime free , 😂
Yaaan yung sinabi noon ni winnie monsod na ang presidential bid ni bbm ay transactional unlike Leny na transformational😅😅
Llamas wala rin yan wala akong tiwala delikado yan
Panong wala, nandyan nga e! At mas wala naman akong tiwala sa iyo, "who you" ka nga e.😅
Anung Ionagsadsbi mo bakit ninyio si PRRD.