News in Snapshot 24w20a: Massive Redstone Farming Change! New Piston Sounds!
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 05. 2024
- Snapshot 24w20a is here with a massive change for farming redstone, new sounds for pistons... and more! Check out all the details here! #minecraftemployee
slicedlime works as a Tech Lead for Minecraft at Mojang, but the CZcams and Twitch channels are personal projects run entirely in his spare time. This is an unofficial update video that aims to be the most comprehensive guide possible. Official announcement: www.minecraft.net/en-us/artic...
News in Data Pack Version 44: • News in Data Pack Vers...
How to get a Snapshot: • Minecraft Tutorial - H...
Introduction: 0:00
Mobs: 0:15
Sounds: 1:01
Gameplay: 1:34
Enchantments: 2:33
Advancements: 3:01
User Interface: 3:08
Stability: 4:01
Known Issues: 4:10
Technical News: 4:18
Thank You: 4:28
Thanks to Bl4ckscor3, Octojen & Vegguid for the assistance!
Some camera sequences rendered using the ReplayMod: replaymod.com
Music: "Beyond the Lakes" by Malcolm Horne ( / musicman1017 )
--
Leave me a comment, or find me elsewhere:
Second channel: / @limeuncut
Outdoors channel: / @limeoutdoors
Twitch: / slicedlime
Twitter: / slicedlime
Fediverse: mastodon.gamedev.place/@slice...
Facebook: / slicedlimeyt
Patreon: / slicedlime
Discord: / discord
#minecraft #snapshot - Hry
![KING of BedFight [👑BedFight Clip Dump👑]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/lFnrALXR9VE/mqdefault.jpg)
I agree that pistons are too loud, but this new sound isn't it, man. Doesn't sound mechanical anymore, old sound had weight to it, it really sounds like something heavy being pushed
Eating food is a universal human experience that extends far beyond the basic act of nourishment. It encompasses cultural traditions, social interactions, sensory pleasures, and health considerations, shaping our identities and lifestyles. This essay delves into the multifaceted significance of eating food, exploring its roles in nourishment, cultural heritage, social bonding, and personal well-being.
@@MicahJavaOnly and that had nothing to do with it 🤣
@@MicahJavaOnly dead internet theory
The new sound isn't even audible to me at full volume...
Not only this but it was also iconic
I love the idea of the piston sound change, but i think the new sound feels a little... wet? I hope we get to hear a couple different options before the release is done
Waterlogged piston foreshadowing
It sounds like horse galloping
@@jameswise9171Hell yea! Good call honestly i'd love to see this come to java and then it keeping this sound
💀💀💀💀💀💀
The piston now sounds so sloppy. Previously it had a sound of a real machine, but now it just lost all the effect
If you ever have a real machine that sound like the old pistons, turn it off immediiatly and take it to somone to fix!
@@Octojen I'm pretty sure they mean a classical mechanical type of machine, older style machines were pretty noisy, but they have a sort of character to them.
Definitely a swing and a huge miss with the piston sounds
Yeah, something just kind of feels wrong about it... Like the Redstone doors don't have that mechanical clanky feel to them anymore.
I feel like they could keep 2/3 of what it was and 1/3 of the new sound, like less loud and smoother but NOT THAT MUCH
I'd rather the piston 'kerchunk' was just flattened down a bit than to get a new sound. The piston sound as it stands now is one of the most iconic sounds in minecraft, and while it is noisy, it's completely unambiguous as to what that sound means. Redstone component's already have a ton of simple high-short sounds like dispensers, droppers, various door sounds, as well as a litany of other redstone component related sounds that all fall in the same range. Pistons may be noisy, but this new sound is like adding another fire alarm to the list of ones you need to find and change the batteries in, while the old piston sound is mellow like the dull thrum of a pleasant rainstorm.
EXACTLY
not a big fan of that piston change. its way too quiet and sounds too “sticky” like its a honey block
yeah
Maybe it should only apply when slime blocks are pushed? That should help to make flying machines quiter which are the main thing that's loud.
that piston sound... not a big fan of it
yes it was loud but that old mechanical sound I preferred a lot more, made it sound like there was real machinery at work
but I guess it is what it is... at least resource packs could be used to bring that old sound back
Had to turn up my speakers at first as I thought I couldn't hear the new piston sound. Thanks for continuing to summarize the changes.
Thanks Mojang and Slicedlime! Can I make a suggestion? Loudness isn't just a piston problem, it's a problem with mobs and other blocks as well in many circumstances. Perhaps the game could have a more general solution such as recognizing when there are too many sounds (especially) similar sounds playing and lowering the gain on them, or adding a limiter. Thoughts?
Pretty sure they already have a maximum cap for the amount of sounds that plays at the same time, I guess what they can do is allow us to configure that through sound settings
I think it's a good idea to reduce the sound of the piston but for me it's too much, you should keep the old sound and tweak it just enough to make it less noisy
The new piston sound is a miss in my opinion. Old one was too loud I agree, but at least it felt more heavy-duty and like it actually moves blocks.
Even if this newer sound sticks around I would still want it louder, because honestly I had trouble hearing it without blowing my ears with the rest of the audio in this video.
In-game it can also now only be heard from a very short distance which I'm not a fan of either.
I agree with others here about the piston sound, the new one is too wet and weak, and sounds more like a plastic toy or clicker thing than a piston. Even when it’s pushing just one block or nothing, it doesn’t feel like it fits what I’m seeing. It doesn’t sound like a full block-sized, wooden/stone mechanism that pushes stuff around. It feels even weirder when hearing it while seeing contraptions like piston doors or the ones here in action (the flying machine feels too quiet as well, and the observer clock even makes it seem goofy tbh xD). It needs more strength to it, imo.
The old one had mechanical charm, and personally never bothered me, though I can see how it’d bother others. I feel more general volume options may be a better solution, since piston sounds aren’t the only ones to bother people, and many still like them anyway.
Spot on
You know, I didn't even realize just how loud pistons were before until I heard the difference.
I kind of like it, just could use a slight volume adjustment is all
Making the piston a little lighter on the ears is a good idea, but the new sounds like many have said sound wet. Like you shoved a squid into the piston to reduce the noise
The new piston sound effect sounds... wet. It sounds like its squishy rather than the mechanical clank that the sound had before. I overall dislike this new sound because it lacks the mechanical-ness the old sound had.
agree
Cool that witches drop redstone, kinda awesome.
That piston sound. It sounds like pressing a key on a keyboard with a wetness filter. Like, they could've mixed the piston sound with that new one and lowered the volume...
Or at least add some sort metallic clang instead of... two toothpicks slapping each other.
The new changes with redstone is huge!
The piston sound change was totally uncalled for
But it's nice tho
Sounds bit like flopping fish when there are a lot of them.
It was very much called for because everyone working with redstone ended up getting vanilla tweaks resource pack and similars to lower the volume of pistons
@@mkDanielwhy is that so accurate
That being said I do think this sound is soulless and lacks character, expected way more because of the stellar work they're doing with sound. This one probably is a residual from vaults and trial thingies.
I'd add more of the pistoney magic the OG had
Wow those new piston sounds are... interesting. Despite their original annoyance, I think I am going to make a resource pack to change the sound back
Its a Snapshot they may change it again based on feedback
@@OLIVER427 you can’t compare this. The copper bulb behavior was reported as inconsistent to other redstone stuff and was „fixed“ because of this feedback. This is a sound that some/many (I dunno) me included don’t like.
piston got a better volume, but the weight is much worse, it feels like it's moving paper, not heavy blocks
your videos are 1000% more straight forward than a lot of big YTs update vids ive seen
the sound needs some 'heft' to it
The piston sound change is really not great. Really hoping it gets reverted, and the volume level of the sound just gets decreased instead. It also sounds weirdly like the copper bulb activating? So weird.
I’m with you all with the piston sound, I’m not sure about it either. I am however, pleasantly surprised how calm the community has been about this, I’ve seen no excessive toxicity about this change, rather I see proper feedback. Nice.
Piston doors sound quieter but slimy and kinda disgusting. The piston needs _some_ sound, akin to a "whoosh", to better sell how it extends and retracts. It currently sounds like a lever or a slimy button, which is not satisfying.
The new piston sounds are much quieter, which is awesome, but they feel… wet.
I hope this is going to have a few revisions
The old piston sound was fine, and iconic, just too loud. Why was the solution to change it instead of just.. changing how loud it is?
I gotta ask, where is the QA team with seeing if changes are actually applied ive seen so many times where you show a feature then a text saying oops still didn't work
not a fan of the new piston sounds. i think just reducing the old sounds in volume would be better, or make them a separate category in the sound settings. the new sounds don't really sound like anything and i actually had _trouble_ hearing them
Same. They were actually difficult to hear, without making the rest of the video TOO loud. The new sound also can't be heard when you're even a little away.
I feel like the piston sound is inspired by the copper bulb
Makes no sense lol
love changing the piston sound but get a better one that isnt so wet please
Those sheep piston michines seem a teeny bit too... Realistic(?) now..
I will say that I was never expecting an actual sound change instead of an addition... This is literally the first change to a (even somewhat)iconic sound in years.
Couldn't they have just turned the original piston sound down a little instead of replacing it with gentle nearly-inaudible plapping?
Piston sound change is great, but I hope they make it sound less.. squishy. Makes it sound a bit too much like slime.
Or flopping fish when there is a lot of them.
The piston sound needs to be adjusted. It’s too… organic? Maybe try a mix between the old and this new one?
Villagers haven't been able to accept enchanted items as a currency since 1.8.0
Hope this gets fixed eventually
The piston sound, why ? Pistons being loud is literally fixed by toning their sound fx down a little ... And it's also kind of part of the charm and satisfaction just hearing them work behind a new contraption you make ...
Thank you, slicedlime.
I'll definitely be installing a resource pack to bring the old piston sounds back. These new ones do not sound good at all.
Mojang: we don't like mob farms
Also mojang: There, more redstone from Witch farms
I don’t think they’ve said they hate mob farms, have they?
Because you guys are delusional for thinking they hate mob farms, the only farms they wanna phase out are ones that are overpowered and breaks a certain aspect of the game (like Raid Farms destroying Trading and the risk of death)
@@user-tzzglsstle585e38 I mean yeah, they just changed the redstone drops for witches to buff witch farms for getting renewable redstone
That piston block sound sounds weirdly
As a pvp player I really hope the java mace base stats are adjusted before release, the current slow attack speed makes it feel extremely clunky and unfun to fight with. The only reason breach was good is because the base stats of the pre-nerf mace made it a decent side grade to swords, but with the current abysmal attack speed there's no reason to use it over a sword on the ground (it gets outDPSed by unenchanted diamond or sharp 1 iron), and a density mace in the air. I find it odd that this update's flagship weapon is now less useful than a trident despite being far harder to obtain than a trident, and these bad stats sticking around through multiple snapshots is concerning. :(
Thank you!
Piston sound should sound a bit more drier and have more chonk to it imo
So the "solution" to the piston sound "problem" is to... make them basically mute? With a wet-sounding fish flop no less?
Gotta love to hate change for the sake of change!
2:15 thats so good
The new piston sound sounds like Pinocchio having a good time.
there's a typo on the Sounds timestamp
I got recommended this 24 seconds after it was posted
It was right after I finished watching a different snapshot breakdown too
Thank you !!!
Add an accessibility setting to swap between the old (loud) and new (quiet) piston sound.
You can enchant horse armour? Didn’t know that. Sleipnir gets an upgrade today
Only by using commands.
Or by just using an anvil in creative mode.
Ahhaa thank you for the explanation
hmm. not sure i like the new piston sounds. i understand wanting to make redstone quieter, especially pistons, but these new sounds are almost entirely inaudible. pistons don't sound like they're doing anything anymore.
i feel like the sound issue would be better solved by just giving redstone components their own volume slider. i should learn how to use the feedback website maybe.
I miss the old piston sound. Yes, it was loud but it was iconic
piston sound needs some work
The piston sounds like its wet
I think you should get this if you add feathers to the piston recipe!! I love the idea of the new sound but the original sounds more FEARSOME! Like some big mechanic yk.
I think overhauling the swamp and giving more spawning locations for witches (for example through multiple witch huts connected with walk ways in stilts) would have been the better solution and keeping more with lore, as witches really should drop all their ingredients at about the same rate.
But I get that you want to get the raid changes done this update and you can't pack a swamp overhaul into the same update, considering the time constraints and all the stuff that is already in there. So I get why you went for the quick fix.
I just worry that now we'll never get more/bigger witch huts, since you probably won't be able to revert this change.
1:29 I should call her
Never thinked to find an employee who did Minecraft devlogs
the new piston sound is very cool! this will make piston heavy machines so much nicer
Love the new piston sound. I believe you guys should look at it from another perspective - it's just a piston sound.
if you can enchant the horse armor, can u add the glint on to it
New piston sound makes me sad 😢
Did anyone noticed the +7 Luck and +2 Step height on the Chestplate ..
Honestly the piston fix is simple. Revert it and make it quieter. Allow us to apply wax to it to have it make it play a much quieter sound.
In todays snapshot, they reverted the sound back to the old one and made it more quiet
The new sounds needs more punch
I’m not a fan of the new piston sounds, it would make more sense to be if they put a button in sound settings to toggle on and off quite pistons, that way people with sound sensitivity issues can have it off while other people have their classic piston sounds they’re used to
What is the difference between "when equipped" and "when worn"?
3:25 I'd assume equipped also includes the offhand for shields and such, not sure about the main hand though.
That piston sound is just bad. It sounds like you're dropping a marble on a table from like 2 inches above it. Yeah I think pistons can be really loud and annoying, but where is the character in that sound? Its a machine that has a giant arm that extends. The new sound is like a dinosaur making a chicken sound.
chickens are dinosaurs tho, and other (past) dinosaurs likely made bird sounds or something similar (bird sounds is a very varied term i know)
agree
Hi Minecraft developer, can you tell us more about the new cape thing we can get on twitch by any chance?
When were horse armor enchants added?
custom enchantments now exist
We just wanted piston sounds to go down a deciblw or two not... whatever that new spund is. Why does it sound so wet???
Make the new sound less squashy and its perfect.
Still hoping for the copper bulb to be reverted
What the fuck is that piston sound 😭i tought they fully removed the sounds because i basicly cant hear it at all
Piston sounds weird like a wet trap door
ohhhj no please keep the old piston sound
Oh no… the piston sound it’s something I don’t like at all. I understand the point of it being less of a concern for big redstone builds, but it just doesn’t feel like a piston at all
I liked the piston sound at first but now I’m starting to hate it… it sounds like slapping a fish and not a piston
The piston sound could be punchier. Doesn't sound like something strong enough to move a cubic meter of solid gold.
That's on the "extreme" sound. But still, it will commonly be moving stone and other heavy blocks
soiunds
Eating food is a universal human experience that extends far beyond the basic act of nourishment. It encompasses cultural traditions, social interactions, sensory pleasures, and health considerations, shaping our identities and lifestyles. This essay delves into the multifaceted significance of eating food, exploring its roles in nourishment, cultural heritage, social bonding, and personal well-being.
this sounds like the piston isn't cobblestone, it's made of rubber
👍
this sound is not as satisfying as the old one, i prefeer the old one. Maybe it's volume, and maybe other aspects, could be changed to be better
should’ve just lowered the og piston sound
took 13 years to lube pistons
Why not just keep the old sound but quieter?
You sick? Hope you'd get better if you are
It sounds like crap now. Sounds like my dog licking his feet
New piston sounds like me after taco bell
Poor things sound like they're sick.
am i the only one who likes the wetness of the piston sounds
#RevertCopperAndPistonSounds!
wow
This new sound isn't good :(
Another sound and redstone change I would be a high fan of is if the dropper could be quieter or if given a solid redstone signal it would stay dropping until turned off
Macaroni in a pot, that's some we-...New Piston sound
The new piston sound is not fitting the Piston at all even if it was made to make pistons not make you go crazy just by hearing them its not what I would expect from Mechanical part to sound like its in water.