Learning from China
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 06. 2024
- Maybe we are much more similar than we thought.
China
www.dw.com/en/china-why-is-pu...
www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-c...
www.theguardian.com/world/202...
Beijing
Cases, + 22
Tian Wei Beijing’s municipal party committee
The risk of continued and hidden transmission is high, and the situation is grim
The whole city of Beijing must act immediately
Shanghai
Most of 25 million, strict lockdown, in fifth week
Cases, + 22,284 + 20,634 + 19,657
= 320,000
Symptomatic cases, + 2,988 + 1,580
Deaths, + 3 + 12 + 39 = 87
elderly, unvaccinated, underlying health problems
140 deaths from non-COVID illnesses
Many moved to several quarantine centres or quarantine hotels
Transfers to quarantine facilities 100 miles away
Only those who tested negative could go
Communist Party Vice Premier Sun Chunlan
no exemptions
all infected people should be treated, all close contacts should be isolated
transferred to government-run centralised quarantine
People's Daily
persistence is victory
Health workers in full PPE
Spreading lime powder
disinfection measures will be escalated in homes, some forced to move out
overwhelmed delivery services
You hit the nail on the head today Dr Campbell ! Censorship, and corruption runs rampant in todays world.
Stop it Denise,dr.Campbell IS NOT a violent man. He DOES NOT hit nails on anybody's head. Shame on you.
P.S. dr.Campbell,Denise "inhales",don't listen to her.
So does accusation without evidence.
Dr Campbell's views are evolving; like the science.
The chair of Harvard University’s chemistry department has been arrested for concealing his affiliation with the Wuhan University of Technology (WUT) in China - worth millions of dollars - from his university and the US government agencies that funded his work. On 28 January, the US Department of Justice charged Charles Lieber, a pioneer in nanoscience and nanoelectronics,
@@Andrew-rc3vh evidence is there, it has mostly been labelled conspiracy theory to divide us....
Thank you for addressing "The Narrative", and yes, it's happening here in the U.S. and across the pond in the U.K. It's absolutely frightening and is the first step in a very, very bad direction and it's not only COVID. It's an ideological takeover across all spheres.
globalist agenda coming to the western world, in australia our meat product industry is going to go through globalist zero carbon policy making meat so expensive that few will be able to afford it
Agree with you 100%!! I am another simple guy who is fed up with all this.
It's forcing you to hit the reset button.
I see this too
It only happens if you let them...not all States run by tyrannical Governors there are at least 26 Free States...the problem the Tyrants have is that pesky 2nd Amendment.....the majority of the population is heavily armed....this keeps tyrannical thought in check....
I was infected in December in 2019 in while visiting Southern California for Xmas before the outbreak in China. I still suffer from Long Covid. I had 5 relatives and 6 friends died in 2020 in various part of the country mostly in New York, New Jersey, Connecticut and California, aged from 54-95. As long as you are not infected with serious illness and affected what is around you , you may not feel concerned and treat that it is an issue. I wish that there were some kinds of policies in dealing with the situation. I still don't know how long my long Covid suffering will be. It is getting depressing.
Hello from Europe,
All of us catch covid19 in Europe too, but we have a protocol very effective so please get Fluimicil anycase for caught.
Every day I took vitamins C / zinc that help me to feel better after long covid.
Take care 🤝🏻🌍🌎🌏🕊🌿
Stand up Humanity 💎
I know Dr Brooke Goldner has had success in treating long Covid. You can look her up online. She does it with nutrition, no drugs.
Thank you so much for phrasing so eloquently something I have been thinking for a long time now. As a researcher in an academic institution in France, I am not able to discuss any of this with most of my colleagues or I am being accused of conspiracy… frightening how we can’t think freely at the moment. A huge thank you for your work.
Frightening how educated people can become so easily compliant and closed minded. Almost as if they only value their qualifications as some sort of badge of belonging rather than an accademic foundation that obliges them to use their minds responsibly
Not only did I last to the end of your “rant,” I can’t begin to tell you how much I appreciate you vocalizing what so many of us are aware of but seem to have no way of getting around it. Forever grateful for all you have done throughout this madness to try and bring truth and keep the data in science (instead of just politics). The censorship happening in the West is becoming on par with China and we are rapidly traveling down a path of no return. Bless you John for your integrity!
Couldnt agree more
Indeed.This forced narrative was used for the climate change narrative spread in literature and media very very very successfully.
I was hoping it would never end.
Dr John is a NW0 stooge who works for the W€F. This is what I think the WEF is up to czcams.com/video/9GwSCFwCScs/video.html
Happening here too. 4 replies but I can only see two at the moment.
HEAR! HEAR!!
This should be translated into every tongue, and every individual on the entire planet should see this.
Utterly 100% spot-on.
You sir, are amazing and have been an absolute pleasure to listen to the last 2 years. So grateful for you, your honesty, your openness, and really just the warm caring energy you share with everyone. Thank you ❤️❤️
Dr. Campbell, your comments today go beyond science to the realm of wisdom. Thank you for your invaluable observations and suggestions.
A friend is in Shanghai and living in a high rise apartment.
Said the building doors are padlocked, the fire escapes blocked, the elevators shut down and the building is guarded.
Food is short and food deliveries are often delivered to the wrong apartment or have gone bad by the time it arrives. People in the building are sharing what they have.
People are getting desperate.
Thank you for saying this. I have felt like I have been going insane the last two years having this opinion. It’s cost me “friends”… but I have stuck to my principles and belief that science is ever evolving and to learn and progress we need and must debate and talk and be open. Thank you for saying all of that. It was brave of you 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Opinion MUST change with variables as they come.. There have been massive changes and thus peoples opinions must change ,, look at the change from Delta to Omicrom ,,, Delta and prior people NEEDED to be vaccinated to protect their family / friends and society in general ,,, with Omicrom that is NOT an issue. Prior to Omicrom lock-downs etc VERY effective at stopping spread ,, Omicrom CANNOT be stopped.
Allow depopulation of old, sick and 0.5% of senior population. That is nature.
@@tilapiadave3234 i don’t entirely agree with much of that to be honest. But you are entitled to your opinion.
@@SofiaTheSacredSiren All based on facts ,, the vast majority of which I got initially from THIS channel.
In the USA, most people seem to have forgotten what free speech was intended for. In my opinion, free speech was meant to speak the truth - no matter how uncomfortable or inconvenient it is - in order to solve problems for the good of all. Now, people seem to want to use “free speech” to defend stupid or damaging ideas.
Thank you, Dr. John. I appreciate you very much!👍
The bottom line is total deaths, just give your view to the love ones that have a death in the family, China have 1.4 billion people so on % China are trying to save millions of lives.
Thank you for addressing the “elephant in the room” in our countries.
There is a whole big lot more elephant in the room left to be addressed. But finally, he’s addressing that there IS an elephant.
“The greatest tyrannies are always perpetrated in the name of the noblest causes”- Thomas Paine
China's tyranny is entirely in the name of a single man keeping his job.
Never forget:
czcams.com/video/9ppIR_zd_uQ/video.html
Your rant at the end is spot on. Much respect and appreciation for your insights over the course of the past two years. Your incisive questioning of the narrative when facts on the ground didn't add up is a fine example of science in action. So many in the scientific and medical community either knowingly abandoned science in favor of some other objective, or were virtually blackmailed into obeying the official narrative for fear of losing their jobs. Still others were sheep petrified by the fear porn coming out of MSM. Thank you for your service to truth and keeping your viewers grounded.
Dr Campbell, you have excelled even your usual great broadcasts with this much-needed 'rant'.
Outstanding "that science is supposed to be predicated upon.." "Are we in a similar situation" "Is science bought and paid for.." Brave. Necessary discussion.
Dear John. With each passing episode, I feel that our thinking is progressively harmonising. Thank you for your brave words
Its not about controlling a virus but controlling a population.
@@sergeant64 That seems very possible
Thank you a lot for the time you spend doing this. It is priceless. You're one of the few I want to hear from because of your sense of justice. I appreciate true science from a real doctor.
Dr. Campbell's explanation of the intellectual dialectic, and what we lose as a free society when we allow the single narrative of the powerful to shame us into self-censorship, is the single clearest description of this crisis I have heard. It's simple and brilliant. It's also hauntingly accurate. We're at a crossroads as free people. Getting back on the path of open dialogue about pressing issues in our society is not going to be easy going. People are going to have to speak up and risk their reputations and their jobs; no question.
Flat Earther types deserve to be mocked
Agreed. I wish this was his most viewed video.
Dr. Campbell,
I am a materials engineer, lecturing in a university in Istanbul and I am 60 years old. I forwarded your video to all my students with the hope of your point be clearly understood. What is science and how knowledge increases is clearly mentioned.
You have done a great job.
Keep it up ali . Thankfully some countries are still teaching their students with common sense. I fear most western universities would be banning Dr John for hate speech because he would trigger the pro authoritarian marxist professors
But how do we judge what's scientific?
If the results contradict what we believe is scientific, then would that still be classified as scientific?
As I mentioned in another comment, I don't know about the current latest version of Omicron. But what China has been doing CLEARLY did work for *ALL* earlier versions of Covid *INCLUDING* the previous versions of Omicron.
They've had 2 full years of relatively safe and free life while most of the rest of the world was going through non-stop lockdowns.
I guess you might say I'm lying and the Chinese govt was hiding the real situation in those 2 years.
I can't put video links in Dr Campbell's channel. But if you suggest a place where I can share a few CZcams links to show you what life was like during those 2 years in China, then you can judge FOR YOURSELF if it looks even remotely believable that the Chinese govt was lying.
It's frustrating when you know what is said is clearly not accurate, but you are not allowed to share information to prove otherwise.
How fortunate for your students! Wish I'd had that sort of teaching when I was in school. Learning to think rather than just spit out formulas. Best to you, Ali Sekerli! 👏
Finally, a rant! I was wondering, how long it would take for you to get to do this video.
You have a good heart Doctor. 👍
@nigwasme why be rude?
@nigwasme exactly
@nigwasme 👍
Greetings from Shanghai and thank you for such a clear assessment of the situation here. One comment “asymptomatic cases” has a uniquely Chinese definition. It does not mean no or very mild symptoms rather it is defined as being the absence of lung damage evidenced on a CT scan. Not many Covid cases get a CT scan so the number of “asymptomatic cases” is very misleading. Many thanks indeed for your excellent content.
I am Shanghainese and I could say that's totally true. Besides, even the overall numbers are made up because of the CT values of the COVID tests were 35, now 40, not the international standard which is 30. Each 5 added to this number means there should be 100x more virus in the sample for it to be tested positive. Disgusting.
"defined as being the absence of lung damage evidenced on a CT scan"
Interesting...Do you have any support info regarding this explanation, or you just heard it from someone? I can read Chinese also.
I'm so glad we have you Dr John xx
Hi pretty lady. How are you doing today???
“Powerful people dictate knowledge” completely agree and it shows today
Thank you for a nuanced and self-reflecting talk. I'm Chinese, and every day I opened WeChat, I saw my friends back home posting very disturbing stories, mostly describing how the most vulnerable groups of people suffered the most due to the lockdown that defies scientific evidence. A lot of elderly Chinese people do not know how to use smartphones - without smartphones, they couldn't even get food because most food supplies now come from "group buys", which requires a person to order from an app (and you have to repeatedly try to tap on the order button to have the remote hope of getting the order through). The vision-challenged couldn't use apps and many of them don't have access to screen readers. Some relied on bland noodles for weeks. Despite the fact that China's medical system is not well prepared to handle massive hospitalization, the collateral damage is outweighing the "benefits" every day. The government is not so concerned about science but more about how it looks if they suddenly changed policy and it didn't go well - it's tied to their need for absolute credibility.
Yesterday a friend of mine posted something about a Chinese official defending why any complaints about the lockdown posted on social media were so swiftly deleted - apparently he was quoted saying local officials have been taking the complaints from social media into consideration as they are posted and making policy changes as they go (they have not). He said the "system" (of deleting posts, among others) works well for China, unlike what's going on in the West. They are absolutely the expert in spinning the narrative in any way possible to make it seem like they are always correct.
When you mentioned "I imagined very few people are licking the pavement" in reference to the irrational spraying of the streets, that was the first real laugh I've had in days. These days I'm getting too heart-broken to see the news back home.
I appreciate that this video is not merely about criticizing China, although they clearly are going down the very wrong path (even though up until the Omicron wave, their way of handling the pandemic seemed to be more effective than the disasters in the West). All of my family members are there and it's torture not being able to do anything to help (they made it next to impossible for most people to travel there - I tried). But the nationalist sentiment remains very strong in China, the majority of people, including my own parents, are still very supportive of the government's approach. Critical thinking and questioning authorities is simply not an option there - if you were brought up not knowing these are possible, why would you change now? I love my parents - although I differ from their point of view greatly, I do not attempt to challenge them too much.
Your last point about how academia freedom of speech (or freedom of speech in general) in the West has been corroded away in the past few decades - I have also seen this happen. Freedom of speech is indeed slipping away in the West and people are very quick to point fingers. Everything in moderation has always been my mantra, but it seems like it's not possible when certain interests are involved. Without your channel, I think a lot of people would have been in the dark. Thank you for doing what you do.
Thank you. My son in law is Native chinese
Yeah right...
I'm feeling so bad for the citizens of China, no one should be left behind in such conditions you have mentioned. The elderly should be priority and the very young. Their should be education and out reach of how to deal with such restrictions. Just seems like a lot of control factors playing in that whole senerio. Praying for China and some resolution for this delicate situation that seems to me could get worse over time. Very sad all of it!
It is sad that I can only give you one like
Majority of Chinese people are supportive of the government’s approach because it has been shown to work before. The Chinese people think and act as a collective, not as individuals as in the west. Sure, some are going to complain and some will face more difficulties than others, but if it means a brighter future for the collective whole, then they will gladly endure it.
4:46 “40% of cases in the UK are asymptomatic”. How do we know this ?--by testing only half of the population while leaving the other untouched.
China 90% UK 40%： Only one conclusion， one of them is thrice more diligent and keen on testing and finding out the exact # of asymptomatic cases than the other.
Thank you, Dr. Campbell. As a person living in Shanghai, I wholeheartedly agree with you. The situation here feels political/Machiavellian. The experts/doctors in Shanghai have been completely sidelined by the political people. I passed along your clip to my friends here.
Thank you Dr Campbell for all your research.
This report today is unbelievable.
No. Those who are informed KNOW that this has been going on for 2 years.
It is now happening in Shanghai and people living there are more informed and a bit more free minded so the info does reach you.
The reality is ever worst. They are starving to death now after 4 weeks of lockdown. They are fed with rotten vegetables and you can`t go shopping at all.
As long as we stop the bio weapon agenda. COVID 19 injection bio weapon with two year fuse for full blown VAIDS.
Thanks, this is one of the most important videos Dr John Campbell has posted. It's so easy to point fingers at China when we really should take a good look at ourselves. Or rather, our politicians and other decision makers should take a good look at themselves.
Well, here’s the thing: China is accomplishing what Dr. Campbell and every mainstream epidemiologist wanted countries to do during 2020-21, which was to flatten the curve of infections to prevent hospitals from being overwhelmed with covid patients. With the earlier variants, the idea being propagated by Dr. Campbell and many others was that this could be accomplished if everyone wore masks and social distanced. Protecting hospital capacity was said to justify all damage to mental health and the economy from these NPIs. Now with Omicron, it’s obvious to almost everyone that those mitigations cannot meaningfully alter the infection curve. There’s only one option, and that is Shanghai-style lockdown. It is flattening the curve. The number of symptomatic cases is not enough to overrun the hospitals. Wasn’t that the goal that trumped all liberal values of democratic countries? We endured two years of being lectured about making sacrifices to protect hospitals. I’m not saying whether the covid mandates of other countries during 2020-21 were justified, or whether what China’s doing now is justified. But anyone who preached masks and distancing earlier in the pandemic but now criticizes Shanghai’s lockdown, is not being coherent with their values.
Look, anyone that thinks this is as transmissible as measles needs to give their heads a shake. No virologist would make such an idiotic claim...these wacky ideas are coming from epidemiologists that are pretending they are experts on viruses. The idea of a more transmissible variant is generally absurd, and almost every study that has been done in this regard is a disgrace to science. But the scientists doing these awful studies are getting paid.
Our Govt didn't react quickly enough at the time but as for pointing the fingers at China, everything should be pointed to that vile country who has spread all viruses in modern day times apart from Ebola.
well said, look at yourself and do not make silly comments to others.
@@jparsit Doctors need to stick to what they know. That means stay the hell away from public health, and stop playing 'virologist'.
Thank you so much for this. Salute!!!
You are absolutely right!!! Thank you 🙏
I am extremely angry that I can no longer see a doctor for his honest opinion. What is the point of having a doctor at all when he's not allowed to talk to you. I am extremely insulted by the government's presumption that I'm too stupid to ask or evaluate or pass along an opinion, that rather, I am to be told what to think, and told what goes in my body.
The gov doesn’t think yr too stupid, the government thinks yr too smart. Hence-censorship. Evil and lies in our midst.
My doctor gives me her honest opinion, although it's peppered with the current thinking of the AMA. Occasionally she'll break out of the shell and just be herself. I'd change doctors if I couldn't get a straight answer out of them. In fact, I've already done that. ;-)
@@darcykamin1111 You're right! I forgot that the government does not actually care about us.
@@esstown To say the least…
You have to change doctors then.
Very well said. As someone who is in science (PhD student), I can wholly say that there is a heavy agenda that prevents healthy criticism and debate that would benefit everyone and further science.
A tr3atable dis3ase: "What made Andrew Hill change his mind about publishing a paper that concluded IVM could reduce deaths by 75% if used throughout the world? Phil Harper a.k.a 'The Digger' sheds some light on the subject." 2021-01-18 "One week prior to Dr. Andrew Hill’s pre-print posting of his revised paper, his University received a $40 million grant from Unitaid (Bill Gates)"
Dr., You are a voice of reason. It is scary that is the situation in China for such a length of time. I appreciate all that you do. You speak with clarity.
Another excellent talk John. You have become the world's voice of reason and that extends beyond talking about Covid, vaccines and data. We live in an increasingly controlled world where certain ideas, certain observations are simply not tolerated. Thank you for stating things so clearly for us all.
Thank you Dr. John, for sharing your thoughts with us. Since the beginning of this pandemic you have been a bright light, giving us strength , hope, and knowledge. Watching you grow and become more critical, and aware has been such a joy! Many of us have open our eyes to "The Narrative" In many countries. It's an obvious here in Canada.
Dr Jsy Bhattacharya on the wests response to covid. czcams.com/video/MpnbMIOvbjc/video.html
And Australia and New Zealand
I believe they are (and have been all along) using the pseudo science to burn it all down. Reference the World Economic Forum globalist plan for us all. Evil to the very core.
Its kind of scary when they bypass the nurmberg acord, they was put in place for exactly this reason
Why does this say there is FOUR replies (Now 5) but only two (Other than mine.) are visible?
Oh yeah, Alphabet (Google) owns CZcams, so censors EVERYTHING they don't like.
Dear Dr. Campbell, thanks again. Especially the part about the open discussion and science. The medical part is clear now, but the discussion is still closed. That worries me a lot. We have to fight for it, mainly because of our children.
Thank you. It means a lot to the people of Shanghai (who are able to watch this) that you are looking into this. My friend mentioned the suicides...one was a Health Minister in Shanghai. The top doctor there who spoke out against this has gone missing. What you are doing is so important.
Suicides..... right! I think we know better.
@@germanylicious it's really a suicide, and his wife has cancer, what a tragedy
Qaww0
@@germanylicious What is a typical westerner’s reaction when it comes to China? You just showed it fully in one word. Idiotic..
Dr. John,
I love when you rant ! Do more of this. You give a voice to those of us that feel we have no voice. I agree, I don't like having a single narrative. Do the powers that be think we can't handle more than one narrative cause then we would need to think and contemplate which narrative we believe? Or, are many of us, just needing the one narrative cause we can't think for ourselves ? This could be the chicken or the egg dynamic. Either way I think you've hit the nail on the head, sadly :(
You're right with both!
Thank you for keeping us updated with hard facts Dr. Campbell! Sad that there are so many mistruths out there trying to control us.
Important thought to take a step back at times and realise there is also much good in the world...eg last week the back wheel on my push-bike came loose as I was cycling to work. A passer-by approached me saying he lived 5 mins walk away and would get his tools. He fixed my bike and saved me a load of hastle getting the bus and collecting the bike later on. I told everyone about that lovely guy and I'll certainly remember him and his good deed for years to come...if not the rest of my life!
An excellent balance of brains and balls, truth is beauty. Thanks, Dr. John Campbell! Sincerely, A.D.M
Brains? He believes covid tests are accurate enough to give solid case count numbers! This is what the whole scam relies on.
Dr. John Campbell, SUPPORT FROM CROATIA 🇭🇷
Thanks for watching, send a direct message to the above number for more enlightenment..✍️
I have followed your work from the beginning of the pandemic. Always come back for updates. Thank you for your intelligence, critical thinking and common sense. Unfortunately lost in almost all main stream media and bias narratives. Thank you Dr John
One of your best, Dr. John! I think your summary rants actually help my mental health.
The studies I've seen show that conspiracy theories are bad for mental health.
OTOH, Dr Campbell's conspiracy story is that most studies are bought and paid for by powerful people (whoever those may be) ... Catch-22.
I will never forget how I benefited a lot from your thoughtful scientific contributions on this pandemic. Stopped looking at the media about covid for quite some time and I come here every time I need information, proper information. You're an amazing Doctor Mr. Campbell, THANK YOU ❤🙏
I totally agree with this. Dr. Campbell kept me sane.
Absolutely!!!
My myocarditis is acting up. How thoughtful is that?
Thank you Dr. Campbell for speaking truth ♥️
It’s really great to see you coming to the conclusions you speak of in the later half of your video. The data is wonderful and helpful but hearing you speak personally about the state of the world over Covid is really hopeful. 🙏🏼
Excellent Dr. John. You make an important and valid point. We must be able to disagree and challenge the hypotheses and views of our fellow scientists.
Thank you Dr John as always. I have loved watching your narrative change over recent times as your eyes have been opened wider and wider!!! You have been fair and unbiased throughout and your opinion speaks volumes. Your credibility is beyond reproach!!! So when you started questioning the acceptable narrative so did I and I thank you for that every day. Between people like you, Russell brand, Joe rogan, Dr Robert Malone I am wide awake for the first time in my life for which I am immensely grateful. Xo
One of the chinese person who is living in Washington DC interviewed by Indian channel said there are 100K deaths that are not related to Covid but these are deaths were people needed surgeries or any other treatments. This country will never learn and hope nature is teaching them a lesson now.
Yep science dies in the dark similar to free speech and both are on life support.
We need to ask Facebook, CZcams and Twitter to publish how many articles they have taken down in last 2 years then we will understand. Companies like pizer and WHO are being controlled by few people who are controlling the narrative. in western world it is not the government but the small group of companies and rich people who are controlling the narrative. example is that Bill Gates is heavily invested in the vaccines so he has interest in making more money
And challenge the Pharmaceutical companies and the politicians!
So gratified to hear your thoughts at the end. It’s so refreshing to have an intellectual scientist who is widely respected say some of the things out loud that need to be understood by the masses. I hope you don’t get cancelled or deplatformed. Thanks for your thinking and your courage.
As long as we stop the bio weapon agenda. COVID 19 injection bio weapon with two year fuse for full blown VAIDS.
When they cancel everyone, the only one who gets cancelled is them in the end.
@@Sam-og6uk but perhaps we have already been cancelled and were not aware of it. Hmmmmm
@@stevesheppardmusic Yes, we are npc's in canceled games probably
@@stevesheppardmusic PooTube often does that in the comments section. Quite often your comments are visible to you, yet hidden from others. It's often a good idea to reload the page in another browser or device which isn't logged on, to check everyone can see it.
I vote Dr John as prime minister. You make so much sense and have worked so incredibly hard throughout this pandemic. Thank you
Thanks for watching, send a direct message to the above number for more enlightenment✍️✍️
Yes, yes, and yes Dr. Campbell! Many of us are in complete agreement with you and so appreciate your lucid analysis and commentary!
Thank you very much from Canada, Dr. Campbell: it's easy to criticize Communist China, but you also took the time to question the similarly illiberal tendencies that we have been adopting lately in science here in the English-speaking world.
I am thankful I discovered you--your pensive, thoughtful, critical analysis, always upholding an honest assessment of your issue at hand, is informative. Thanks again.
Thanks for your sharing and thoughts! As a shanghainee locked down for almost a month. Truly grateful to your effort to spread the science and fact!
Thank you! Thank you! Thank you! You have been a voice of reason from the beginning.
Thank you for being soo courageous! Because indeed, it takes Courage nowadays to talk about the existance of censorship, not even mentioning talking about a contra argument to the main narative! Bravo Dr! Again.❤
Gosh! During an attack of insomnia, at 03.30am, I make a cup of tea and find this! Dr John Campbell and 882 people commenting on this most fascinating post. Will I get back to sleep ..... I doubt it!
Thank you so much, I have struggled with an internal dialogue about many things that don't make sense these past years. And here I find sanity.
🧘♂️😴☮️🙏 Hope you get relief from your insomnia too!
thank you, thank you, thank you. you have been a so appreciated throughout this debacle.
good undertanding good delivery i Love you Dr J Campbell
Love the learning points you have drawn from the China scenario. Always look to ourselves before pointing at others
Thank you Dr. John Campbell for carrying yourself with such integrity and humanity when discussing the topics which you are passionate about.
This will be a long healing process to regain trust in our public and medical institutions and the amount of lives that will be lost as a result is a devastating reality.
Just the fact that people distrust national health institutions is kinda bizarre and unhealthy if you think about it
@@paulwerner3150 not once it's clear they are not putting peoples health at the forefront.
@@paulwerner3150 of course it is but unfortunately the reality is they cannot and should not be trusted, as sad as it is..too much financial influence, profits over wellbeing.
As always, a terrific discussion... and your "rant" is so on point and on target... I hope it gets a wide audience!! Thank you!
Thank you for standing up for freedom, which seems to be slowly taken away from us! I 100% agree with today‘s talk!
Common sense is not very common anymore. Thank you Dr John for having it in bucket loads.
My Lord Dr. John! Such great commentary. I believe we all see whats trying to creep in. Thank you for this profound video and all of your other great videos that have helped me through this pandemic. Honesty and truth is such a piece of mind and I really feel like I get that with you. Thank you sir.
It didn't creep in, it stormed in decades ago for directing the climate change narrative. Control of journal editors is so complete that if they mess up and let something through, they crawl to repent at the feet of Kevin Trenberth.
Many thanks Dr. Campbell for your commentary on the tremendous harm from the "single narrative", and the critical importance of freedom of speech and information flow.
John, it's a rare privilege listening to you. You are not only the quintessential man of reason but a born communicator. Like thousands have said before me, you turned this pandemic, this hopefully once-in-a-lifetime disaster, into something bearable; you gave us courage, not just information, and you breached the loneliness engendered by fear.
So, from this far corner of Australia, thumbs up!
Hello 👋 i hope you're safe over there? I hope this year brings happiness prosperity love and peace 💞❤️🕊️🕊️ all over the world 🙏🌍
I'm originally from New Jersey and I am an Engineer where are you from if i may ask..?
Dr you are a human being, thank you for keeping our soul and spirit with hope,it is not the virus that we fear the most it is the insanity around us.
Hello 👋 i hope you're safe over there? I hope this year brings happiness prosperity love and peace 💞❤️🕊️🕊️ all over the world 🙏🌍
I'm originally from New Jersey and I am an Engineer where are you from if i may ask?
I just love you Dr. Campbell. You are the voice of reason. Thank you for your Love.
Kudos, Dr John. We need more voices like yours. Please keep up the good work.
Thanks for watching, send a direct message to the above number for more enlightenment..✍️
Bravo 👏 Dr. JC-once again you have articulated what many of us know to be true. Now what do we do about it? 🧐
Thanks for watching, send a direct message to the above number for more enlightenment..✍️
My best mate and his family live in Shanghai - very hard to get anything. His main concern is one of his young kids testing positive and being hauled off alone to a quarantine centre. Nobody is too concerned about the virus, everyone is concerned about what the government will do with you and your family if you test positive.
Your comment has just answered a question thank you...that being that people are not overly concerned about the virus. Best wishes
@@AcimSharon. It is the police and army controlling the situation now.
They have to collectively rise up, but there is no way of communication to organize anything.
It is the western media that could help by actually spreading this BS, the usual cancel culture hitting China would help here, instead we fuck with Russia now.
@@AcimSharon. It is certainly NOT an easy thing to do in China unless you want to be locked up in jail, tortured or die. There are masses of Communist Officials & Communist spies everywhere, police, cameras, people cannot post anything on the internet without the Government knowing about it, it is so highly censored. It is now much worse living in China regarding censorship than when the Tiananmen Square massacre happened in 1989. Think how many took to the streets & protested in Hong Kong for months & months yet China still took over Hong Kong & jailed, tortured, locked up many & people just simply disappeared. You have no freedom of speech & no way to protest in China..
@@AcimSharon.Living in a Communist country until the age of 23. Your comment makes lots of sense to me. In Cuba we have an oppressive regime. Even though we are lot more population than 'the dictators' in the government.
It's very difficult to overturn a system without the support of other countries. Because Cuban people inside that system are suffering the Stockholm syndrome.
They've suffered so much abuse for so long, that the only reference they have is the one from their captors.
The reality they see, is distorted. The information they receive is strictly controlled by the regime, in every aspect of their lives. What to eat, what to say and where, what to do, where to go, how much material possessions you own, where and when you have to work, what news you watch and so on. The problem is deeper than that, but I tried to resume here as much as I can.
If people protest on the streets, you rest assured that the consequences are going to be severe, from beatings, long prison sentences, permanent abuse outside your house, vandalism of your property, etc. All of these orchestrated and executed by the Cuban regime. Stating excuses like this is happening for our own sake. Using Cubans against Cubans. The ones with the regime always win. The ones opposing the regime always loose.
I resist to believe the Government's form the Western countries don't have any idea. What is hidden underneath these sinister regimes. And keep sending money to support their false Socialism. That money goes entirely to feed their totalitarian greediness. NOT TO the Cuban population.
63 years in power is the result of that support the Western countries keep giving them, massive donations, and publicity of their false 'good medical system'.
I am lucky, I could escape their claws. 30 years in the UK. I am still having anxiety about shortages of food, or being terrified of the police, even the security person on the door makes me anxious.
Dr Campbell here makes us all reflect in a very intelligent and positive way.
In my opinion we are reaching a point of not return of our freedom of expression and other liberties.
We are allowing the governments everywhere to dictate what we say, and how we say it.
That's the beginning of the dictatorship totalitarian regime. That's what they are trying to copy and impose on us. And they are NOT HIDING IT EITHER!
Best wishes for the world! Best for Dr. Campbell.🙋 LOVE AND PEACE!
@@AcimSharon. a lot arent - the penalties are just so extreme that nobody wants to take the risk
Wow Dr. Campbell! You said all this so well. Thank You.
Thank you, Dr. John!!
You're a gentleman and a scholar. More than usual after this video, I want to give you a hug.
Thanks for all you're doing; the rant was glorious, and sadly right on the mark.
Thank you. Just thank you.
The world needs more Dr. John Campbell’s. A whole lot more.
It is very concerning. Especially when those I thought would feel the same way are so easily dismissive of the right to have different opinions/ ask questions.
Do we know of other people like him on CZcams? I watch Russell Brand who does some similar things but any other suggestions? We need people like him!
@@rainasuke from the US, India and Canada if you can cope with the accents and strident volume and if you want stuff other than Covid, ie what's really going on re Ukraine, then I'd suggest the following : Chris Hedges, Redacted, John Mearsheimer, WION. On Covid: Bret Weinstein, Peter Mcullock. UK, Dan Astin Gregory... easier on the ear,. Drbeen Medical Lectures. That'll do for starters. It's like Russell Brand often says Ben needs to be dialogue in debate even with people you don't particularly like. personally I wouldn't have given much credence to any right-wing American news outfits such as Fox News and I was generally left in my views however now Fox news seem to be the only ones going against the general narrative in America and questioning NATOs stance re Ukraine and here GB news who I don't like the politics much but they've been pretty good on Covid. The Times They Are a-Changin
Also the Grayzone
@@kathrynhayman5758 wow thank you! I often watch Fox as well and find it difficult to find things that are actually intellectually stimulating and have truth to them!
I too have friends whose opinions on this have shocked me. One actually said "People need to be managed." We're still friends but I haven't quite been able to think the same way about him since.
I live in southwest China. Currently trying to get my young families paperwork together so we can leave before Omicron arrives. We're not really scared of the virus, but really worried about what the CCP will do to us if we test positive.
I hope you are able to leave
The control has been gradually going on for years, they learnt how easy it is to control and are now using this method to do exactly that. Thank you dr.
WOW Dr Campbell, you are being sooo brave!! God protect you, you ask these questions because you've seen what is going on. In the beginning, you were a naive presenter and then you've seen what's going on and you can't deny it and you are honest enough to talk about it. Stay safe.
Thanks Dr John. Science is science, examining evidence and finding the best explanation to describe and understand what happens. George Orwell was right, his prediction was out by a number of years, but he nailed it.
Having spent time in China, I have seen there is often there is a method and purpose behind the madness, and that purpose can be unimaginably bizarre and sinister. Say something as sinister as practice study and mass conditioning for full on bio-warfare.
George Orwell was right? His prediction was way off. China has always been China. I have been there before. Our society isn't even remotely close to Orwell's world. 1984? That's many decades ago too!
Other provinces of China have had no such problems of containing omicron variant - see Andy Boreham a New Zealander debunk the western media narrative of the handling.
Andy Boreham, seriously mate? If you don't work for Chairman Xi's $.50 Troll Army, then perhaps you are unaware that Andy does.
A friend who spent over 10 years in China just featured Andy. At the 11mns mark in 'Zero Covid Policy Causes Mass Uprisings in China - laowh86'
His 'China is Building a SIMP Army' segment was informative as well.
I am reminded of once when a lady friend in Beijing who worked in the news for BTV-5, asked if I would do an interview with my impressions about Beijing. I agreed and later that night I saw myself on the Chinese national evening new, billed as a Swiss government banking official. They had over-dubbed my voice in Chinese and included English and Chinese subtitles saying that I was in Beijing on behalf of the Swiss government to do a deal with Bank Of China because China was the safest place in the world to bank and invest.
@@markjackson7467 Look up "Emergency - Military Called in as Chaos in Shanghai Erupts after Children Taken Away" Forward to 10:29. Andy Boreham also speaks for CGTN.
Yes. The USA is becoming pretty censure friendly these days. People have trust in their preferred narratives. Fox and MSNBC. People have lost trust in the medical system hopefully because of bad communication from the higher ups and the government which we all distrust. This is why your channel is so popular over here. You are clearly honest and intelligent. We appreciate your talks.
I don't trust US mainstream media at all, I used to watch Fox.
I lost trust in the medical sector due to the medical sector's behavior. The greed and disregard for the patients and also the corruption of government medical and food agencies... Also the propaganda pushed out from almost all news outlets and the government have led me to not be able to trust any of those sources either.
Other provinces of China have had no such problems of containing omicron variant - see Andy Boreham a New Zealander in China debunk the western media narrative of the handling.
Add cnn to that list
@@mikestravelshow It's world wide coordinated across all western main stream media of all major political sides - has to be corporate and intelligence agency involvement.
A stroke of brilliance in a glum age!. Thank you for your courageous position.
I must concur with Dr. John’s comments. The past few years have been terrible (5) the press. Tells you what the want you know & never carry the real story. You see it daily with the war in Ukraine….. people are told the truth of what’s going on! It’s tragic!
It's so illogical that it makes one wonder if it's really Covid...
Yes???? Scary indeed.
Everything is gearing up for the big party Congress (second half of this year); it is it is very big event on the party's calendar and is setting the tone for the 18 to 12 months before it. As long as the great leader sticks to the policies he has proclaimed, officials will implement them.
Thank you Dr. John for this sane, fact producing video. I feel a sense of freedom just having my thoughts and views being spoken openly by yourself. As so many of us chose to wear blinkers.
Thank you for this. I really appreciate you. God bless you and your's. ♥️😊
Many thanks, as usual, Dr John for your insights and data analysis. As many have expressed, your channel is somewhat of an 'Oasis' in an increasingly, uh, "confused" world. I have enjoyed much of what you place online and do also thank your guests and contributors for their appearances and shared knowledge! I don't at all mind sharing that I work closely with my own General Practitioner regarding health/supplements/lifestyle/lifestyle choices and find a good deal of comfort that (in my own words) my Doctor is a sensible person and prefers to work with me regarding preventative measures in health issues. I also don't mind sharing that I'm a 38yo M, from Adelaide, South Australia, 3xPfizer Vacc, otherwise healthy, apart from finally contracting COVID (25/04/22 - S/Australia timezone). Keep up the good and valuable work. 😷❤👍
Dr. John is one of the few people I have listened to about COVID during the last year and half (probably longer). He looks at the data and asks questions. Could we ask for more?
We could ask for him to be openly anti-vaccine, considering his "heart risk after vaccine" video and the other one he did recently about the liver dna getting overwritten
Sad that you think this, there are many things which he doesn't dare mention on youtube.
maybe he should get his facts straight and talk to a doctor in Shanghai? they all speak English even if John doesn't speak Mandarin
all this misinformation is frankly embarrassing
@@shadowpathfinder7723 he never would, because all the data he’s presented shows, and he’s said it directly many times, that the vaccine offers great good protection for those who are at risk.
@@shadowpathfinder7723 Campbell had to apologize for the heart risk video because it was based on a retracted paper by a doctor that had no evidence for what he claimed. And no liver DNA is overwritten - another misunderstanding on Campbell's part. Always cross-check any claim he makes, he is not a medical doctor.
Thank you for posting, Dr. Campbell.
Could the Chinese know something no one knows?
This pandemic has really cracked any idealistic notion of humanity.
how about "life is more precious than GDP and government's job is to protect citizens"?
every time China locks down a port for a single covid case, it's like "omg they must know something we don't!"
I keep saying that, what is in the covid!!
Zero covid is Xi's vanity project. that's why. Nothing to do with science or public health.
Try “Don’t Look Up - Viral Reservoirs Edition - Downplaying reservoirs” or “Silent Organ Damage from sars-cov-2 ignored by policymakers”
You deserve one thousand star for this upload!!!! And more !!!
Thank you. Watched till the end. Love it. Need more self-reflection like this.
Respectfully, how can you take seriously any data that emanates from China, especially considering the circumstances?
Absolutely, never believe anything the Chinese government says
Ya like they did not hide the numbers till the winter games was over, then boom 25 mill
@AD ITC Huh?
We better take China seriously. The bizarreness we see comes from ignorance. Apparently long covid is more than we know.
Exactly. According to them, not a single person died of Covid 19 between May 2020 and March 2022, nearly 2 years. Out of a population of 1.3 billion.
Your ability to tell the truth about what is going on without making it even debatable. It’s fact and we love you for that 🇨🇦 freedoms are being taken away piece by piece.
I can’t watch our news anymore. It is too dystopian and biased. I come here when I feel I am out of touch again.
Maybe they know something we don't??
Thank you for putting into words what so many of us have experienced.
In the times of crisis like this, argument is not gonna work obviously. Swift action is urgently needed to tackle this killing virus, I'd rather want swift action from government than allowing argument with no action at all. Special circumstances need special solution.
Thank you for another excellent video. Our democratic rites here in Australia have been eroded and censorship and propaganda have run riot. It is extremely difficult to obtain accurate, scientific, unbiased data and knowledge regarding this pandemic. Excellent podcast on China's situation and comparing this to our own is very insightful. I appreciate your openness and honesty - thanks!
Australians are busy today with another "for the greater good" Narrative - a noble slogan often misused by the power brokers to move pawns around the chessboard. The slain ANZACs get a bugle call; the jab casualties get vilified and gaslighted. At last John is getting to the bottom of this current coup: nothing to do with public health, everything to do with establishing authoritarian dictatorships calling themselves democracies toward a global technocracy. Welcome to China writ large
I’m glad in a way that we’re not talking about Australia’s heavy-handed government response for once. Thanks China, I only wish that your people could vote out the culprits as will happen here in time.
What a great talk, Dr. Campbell nailed what so many of us were thinking.
I love your optimism@@stevehall5209, and I hope you are right. However I don't recall seeing the word 'opposition' during our "two week" six month lockdown last year.
@@NoddingMoose fair. My hope is that when one group of bad guys see what the voters did to the other group of bad guys, they may temper the response next time.
Your rants are so well spoken and with very logical conclusion .
Great Talk thank you
I enjoyed the last part’s reflections, Doc. Thanks!
Blessings to you Dr. Cambell.