POLISH VS DUELLING SABER: COMPARISON AND CONTRAST!
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 01. 2023
- Help support us on Patreon!
/ sellswordarts
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @sellswordarts
This Video is Powered by GFUEL
Follow this link: gfuel.ly/3IovTw2
Use code SWORD on checkout for 10% off your order.
Join the Discord!
/ discord - Zábava
One of my favorite sabers were the ones used on Navel ships, and how those evolved.
The British really pushed it to its end point, so many patterns they would fights another empire, see their sabres then reverse engineer them and use them to improve their own innovations.
I wonder if those "navel" ships sailed the umbilical sea
@@bozoforceHaha! I see what did there you clever, clever s.o.b. you! That was a good one!
Him: mentions something polish
Me being a pole: jumping excitetly.
Also reminded me of a duel from the movie The Deluge
MAN MOOD shit activates my fuckin almonds
Deluge po angielsku
@@coldbastard6859 thanks
Him: polish saber
Polish people: *excitation intesifies*
I gotta say, my absolute favourite has to be the Polish variation of sabers. There's something in the curvature of the blade and knuckle guard that just itches a little spot in my brain
Probably because it looks weirdly modern with the more geometrical hand guard and the curved blade
Agreed
Lol Poles had plenty of different kinds of sabers there is no distinct polish saber type
@@egm01egm Well, I could link to a couple of specific examples, if you'd like?
Just get some spare fingers first
When I heard “Polish saber”, I immediately thought of the Winged Hussars, Poland’s cavalry equivalent to the Roman Legionaries 😊
Same
I Dont see the connection between Roman Legionaries and Winged Hussars, the are no similarities beyond their armor that look kinda alike
Weren't hussars the Serbs and Hungarisn legions at first? I mean, before the formation of the winged hussars
@@xolhex9220 what I meant was while the Roman Legionnaires were the best infantry of their time, the Hussars although short lived, were some if not the best cavalry of their time
@@Captain_Sanders yeah one is cavalry and the other infantry
Sabers are actually some of my favorite swords. Will you guys be doing any saber-based combat skits?
What about the light saber?
My favorite
An elegant weapon, for a more civilized age.
Took me a while
Fun fact the name saber is come from its hungarian name Szabja meaning to Cut. The first Hungarian sabers has less curve and had an axe head wich means the tip of the blade was heavier the drag the sword forward and for higher impact and also had a short edge on the top back of the saber.
Sabers in poland comes along with the Hussars wich was the hungarian chivalry units implemented in polish army under the personal union of Poland and Hungary.
The very first Sabers date back in th 8th century with the Avars and at that time it had almost no curve.
I personally prefer the curve in a saber as long as it's not too crazy, but there are some VERY effective straight blade sabers too that will make every bit as devastating a cut as the curved blades will.
As a saber lover and also as half italian half polish i approve of this
I’m quarter Italian so I may be a little biased here😂
The polish Saber is so elegant an powerful in it's design, I love it! And your historic explanation is amazing
Its pretty much just a Hungarian saber though
I always find it interesting how swords were an extension of culture back in the day. They weren't just weapons, they were symbols. Ultimately, they all do the same thing and have similar strengths and weaknesses, but they look so unique from culture to culture
I love sabers, they're some of my favorite types of swords especially the thick and heavy ones like the polish saber in the video!
I have always wanted to know how a duel between someone armed with a norman broadsword and someone with a saber like the one in the video would look. The ways one fought using these swords were fairly different and I'd really like to see a comparison and duel some day
And you and I actually got to fence this matchup at Schnegel! I was completely unfamiliar with dueling sabers before our fight and quickly figured out why they're referred to as such lol. I definitely enjoy the Polish saber style but it was really difficult to cover the distance and speed the dueling sabers had against me, honestly it felt more akin to facing a rapier.
Great fights though and looking forward to more!
Okay! I couldn't tell from the other comment which match this was, but now I totally remember! I was a really fun match, and I love your Sigi saber! I think yours is somewhere in between two dueling saber in a cavalry Sabre.
The dueling saver is quick, but it can get beat around if you let it. So got to go fast 😂
@@SellswordArts it was! It was my first time doing anything saber in a competitive format so I'm glad there were other, more experienced saberists like yourself to learn from. I'll take my lumps as lessons haha. Til next time buddy!
When I think of Polish sabers I think of the Deluge. One of, if not the best sword fighting scene in a movie.
I wonder how David would perform using ancient Egyptian style swords like the Khopesh
I really like the look of the Polish saber
If a Polish person was up against a Dueling Saber, I think the Pole would win
Not necessarily. The dueling saber is faster and has better hand protection. It would not be an easy fight for either
@@SellswordArts it was supposed to be a pun because pole = polish person and your title is Polish vs. Dueling rapier... unfortunately my jokes are exceptionally bad 😶🌫️
@@SellswordArts buthey i got you to reply to me which is pretty cool
@@Say_Tin sorry i didn't get it!
@@SellswordArts haha that's okay, my joke was just bad
My favourite is the Argentinean Saber, it is really beautiful in my opinion
My favorite curved sword would have to be the pulwar, which is similar to that Polish saber, but longer and with a much more exaggerated curve. Deadly weapon on horseback
My Personal favorite type of swords are the scimitar espacially the persian shamshir, which i grew up with learning to use for martial art duels
More great content, this is what I want to learn about ❤
Show us millitary swords used in WW1 or slightly before
This polish saber is known as hussar/mount saber. Longest which was used, and mostly was used on horseback. Notmal dueling sabers was a little bit shorter. The most known dueling saber in poland was karabela.
More polish sabers!
Question: What is the ratio of sharp to dull swords that you have?
I don't actually know how many dull swords I own... But I have 5 sharps (two are on loan to me)
Fun facts the sabers were used to kill the wolves of the forest. And is one of the best weapon to fight wolves in the wild back in the day.
really interesting stuff
I've liked sabers simply cause they seem very fancy for duel. Where you shout such archaic lines as "ON GARDE" and "have at you, ruffian!"
That's why they were often used for cavalry. They're a really good well rounded weapon. I also like cutlasses which are pretty much just a short variant of the saber.
I'm sorry, is this the best video ever.
im a big fan of mid 19th century military saber. i just really like the mix of cut abd thrust work in it, and the (infantry at least) sabers have this great median feeling to them. heafty enough to cut more then decently and take a beating in a bind, but also often with a nice spear tip with a false edge, minimal curve, and a nice weight distribution for nice pointwork.
its my Goldilocks choice. not too x, not too y, but just right.
We really need to see polish saber in fantasy. Curved swords are always restricted to middle eastern culture according to media.
It comes up quite a lot in The Witcher series
Why Polish saber specifically? Use by Hungarians was much more prominent, that's where Poles adopted them from
@@Tovalokodonc Because polish culture is unique and cool in its own way, just as the polish saber. Wanna put some Hungarian in your fantasy? Sure, go ahead, I bet it'd be cool. This isn't a contest.
@@leoprzytuac3660 What i meant, that you didn't get - no offense -, is the fact that Polish sabers are literal copies of Hungarian ones
@@Tovalokodonc I take it as a logical cultural transition resulting from the constant conflict and exchange between the polish lithuanian commonwealth and the east, including Hungary. However, putting it as "just a copy" is ignorant. The characteristics of that specific type of saber deviated in other directions because of the context in which it was used and personal-regional preferences. For example, the preference for a thumb ring, or a straight pommel. That also goes for the fencing style. Rounding up: yes, they are variants of the same saber type, but far from considering those differences unimportant, I take them as crucial and very interesting testaments of history and culture. Trying to decided which country is more sabery is out of topic.
that Ensifer Black is purty
Hey I love the dance of blades but one problem I had in mind for awhile is could a long handle scythe (the weapon of the grime reaper)
Poland mentioned URAH
A personal favorite of saber.
Very cool 👏🏾👏🏾
Ive been told by certain hema practitioners that there is no such thing as 'polish sabre' per se, as there are no surviving sources of it having been a unique or existing style of its own, and that what is currently practiced under the term of polish sabre is really just a modern theoretical interpretation of what mightve been.
Polska mentioned!!!!
I'm pretty sure that The Don Kuban and the Ukrainian cossacks used sabers similar to the Polish one
I would really like to know about the weapon of puss in boots. Especially if you explain it.
Can you do a review on a Mongolian scimitar pls i would really love it
My favourite saber is the blond one
I personally prefer the polish saber because it’s fun to cut with
“This Sabre could be used on horseback and on foot.” Well considering the Polish Hussars were mainly a cavalry unit, that makes sense
Do you have any videos that show the progression of swords through history? Would love to see early versions of the rapier compared to newer
I love how it protects your fingers
More on Polish sabers!!!
can we get a short about arabic swords
Could you do a review thing on other types of bladed weapons or is it just swords?
As someone new to sabers, and hema in general, (im a FMA Practitioner) what are some great historical dueling manuscripts you can suggest? And to me, this kind of seems like a dumb question, but what is the practical application difference between a saber, whether Polish or Italian, and a cutlass?😅
What polish saber is that?
I am no expert but it looks like an early Polish-Hungarian saber, on the model of which hussar saber was later created. I have been training Polish-Hungarian saber style for some time and it is really fun!
The brand is VB. Purple Heart Armory is the US supplier.
@@kari3740Hungarian-Polish**, i'd much prefer if you'd respect the original in the word order
@@Tovalokodonc Sorry, I didn't really think about that while writing this. In Poland we call these sabers in that order, "Polish-Hungarian". But thanks for pointing that out, you are absolutely right :) After all, the Hungarian saber was the first, it was us who 'borrowed' the design. I'll make sure to properly name this weapon in the future :D
@@kari3740 Nah, sorry, i came off a bit hostile, nothing against my Polish brethren after all. It's just incredibly frustrating that all the Hungarian contributions, achievements to history are either downplayed or forgotten. This creator specifically made a short, under which he stated that sabers are of Polish origin.
Polish Saber, my favorite weapon of them all
My favorite weapon is the spear
i love szabla
What you are holding in your right hand is not a duelling sabre, this is a common misconception steming from Hutton and other contemporary Brits being idiots and knowing very little about Italian sabre, usually talking about "continental sabre", whereas sabres in Europe were wildly varied at the time.
That is an Italian (Radaelli style) fencing sabre, Italians were well known for using lighter practise sabres than anyone else in Europe, their dueling sabres (sciabola da terreno) were actually rather heavy at about 800g and their military swords were not particularly heavier or lighter than other counterparts
Also Polish sabres like that were well spread from 16th to 18th century tbh and were both a cavalry and infantry weapon since there is no really standardisation of sabres to speak of at that time
Cheers :)
Just to broaden view on polish sabers: yes, they were used on foot and from horseback and there was no standardisation of sabers at that time but lighter ones were used on foot and heavier ones mostly from horseback.
Polish one looks like winged hussar saber. It's nice to know that you like our design ;)
I am Polish and I'm happy to see something of ours to impress someone like you ;)
Let me cite the meme "polska gurom"
podjebaliśmy tą szable od węgier więc nie jest nasza
Im Polish and my Great Grandfather's Brother was im pretty sure quite good at Saber fighting and im thinking of learning it too
Any good introductions to saber? Books? I remember years ago cold steel had a DVD on saber with Anthony DeLongis, I was going to ask for opinions but i I guess it’s out of print.
Just imagine if your full gallop on a war horse with those sabers. You don’t even gotta wind up or even swing your saber, just stick it out and let it do the work
“Polish Sabre used in 1500’s”
My brain: WHEN THE WINGED HUSSARS ARRIVED!
I think that the right one is actually a Hungarian saber. I might be wrong, but it looks like one.
I personally like the lightsaber
Spicy glow stick
@@nxxynx5039 yes
@@nxxynx5039 pole of burning light
Can you talk about the Kyu Gunto as one of the Sabres?
So if it’s thicc it’s a horse.
Horse Enthusiasts will be glad to hear this one 🫡
Swiss sabers are my favorite
poland mentioned!!!!!!!!! 🇵🇱🇵🇱🇵🇱🇵🇱🇵🇱💪💪💪💪💪💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
My favorite saber The Civil War calvary saber. Beautiful weapon
..."Ol' Wrist breaker"...
YES! SABRES!
My favorite is the lightsaber
I had to fight with both of them and face many oppoents, before I understood an obvious truth: calvary saber is better for horseback charge (or cutting competition) and dueling saber is better for duelling (even would duel be ,,to the death").
... you should have mentioned the weapon of academic fencing and the Mensur...
...the Schläger...
Can you talk about Turkish swords that have an almost 90 degree angle of curve? Made absolutely for cutting.
Can you talk about halberds, axes, or sythse or do you only do swords?
So shanks from one piece has an Italian dueling saber
Edit: I know that thumb rings are not on every single wz or mk of Polish sabers. Just an observation.
What sort of model is that saber based on? It sort of looks more like a Hungarian than a a Polish one to me. Unless that is just the POV/angle and lack of the thumb ring IDK
Husaria!
I have a question if your knew to the whole Sabre and learning how to use it then what would be a beginner way of learning if you can’t buy a trainer Sabre?
Do you know who San Martín was? He was the guy who freed argentina in the 1800's and he had a saber
where did you get the polish saber? it is beautiful.
Have you covered the Dao yet Sellsword?
man curved weapons in history... tang heng dao, Nodachi, Sabers, cutlasses, ect (i listed pretty much most of them but apperently katana odachi and tanto count even tho the only difference was size)
My favourite saber is the hungarian hussar sabre from the 1500's
Can you do a episode going more into sabre
Specifically cavalry sabre
"Not as elegant as a saber, but elegance is overrated."
How polish is your saber?
Was the dueling sabre worn from the day to day or was it kept in safe keeping until on the dueling ground? 1800s Italy dueling was legal or illegal? I ask because it looks uncomfortable to wear vs the smallsword, stirrup hilt sabres.
Check out the Iranian shamshir
Now what about an unpolished saber? 🧐🧐
so id really like to get into HEMA but i dont know where to start, anybody got any advice?
Question then: did people also call Sabers Swords or were they distinguished as Sabers?
I have a American Civil War saber
Song?
Were do you get most of your sabers
Where could I get decent, cost effective swords? To start a collection.
My favorite saber is a lightsaber.
I prefer the look of the dueling saber but I'd probably buy the polish saber.
Polish sabers are really good tho
Please tell us about a cutlass
What's the bleed build up rate on those?