What is Ten Hag actually trying to do?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 9. 05. 2024
  • Try The Athletic for FREE for 30 days: www.theathletic.com/tifoirl
    🎧 Listen to the 10 minute Daily Football Briefing here: podfollow.com/1677588464/view
    Erik ten Hag's Manchester United were battered 3-0 at home to Manchester City on Sunday. It follows a slow start to the season, which is seeing United struggle to score goals and implement much of a playing identity.
    With summer transfers Mason Mount, Sofyan Amrabat and Rasmus Hojlund all appearing in tis miserable defeat - the question is, what is the Dutch manager actually trying to do with his squad?
    JJ Bull and Jon Mackenzie break down the Manchester Derby to try to make sense of the future of Man United.
    00:00 Intro
    01:14 In Possession
    03:17 Out of Possession
    05:01 Personnel Issues
    08:00 Examples in MUN v MCI
    10:30 Individual Brilliance vs Structural Success
    11:46 Man Utd at their best under ten Hag was…
    13:47 Can’t play like Ajax because of the players?
    15:11 Is ten Hag changing his approach?
    15:51 The biggest problem for managers at Man Utd
    Follow Tifo Football:
    Twitter: / tifofootball_
    Facebook: / tifofootball
    Instagram: / tifofootball_
    Listen to the Tifo Football podcast:
    Apple Podcasts: bit.ly/TifoFootPod
    Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/06QIGhq...
    About Tifo Football:
    Tifo loves football. We create In-depth tactical, historical and geopolitical breakdowns of the beautiful game.
    We know there’s an appetite for thoughtful, intelligent content. For stuff that makes the complicated simple.
    We provide analysis on the Premier League, Champions League, La Liga, Serie A, Bundesliga, World Cup and more.
    Our podcasts interview some of the game’s leading figures. And our editorial covers football with depth and insight.
    Founded in 2017 and became a part of The Athletic in 2020. For business inquiries, reach out to tifo@theathletic.com.
    Music sourced from epidemicsound.com
    Additional footage sourced from freestockfootagearchive.com
    #manchesterunited #mufc #premierleague
  • Sport

Komentáře • 1,1K

  • @theflyingdonkeypunch
    @theflyingdonkeypunch Před 6 měsíci +717

    Props to the editor for all the quick cuts to JJ sipping from his mug. Felt like I was watching an action movie

    • @chrisgarty
      @chrisgarty Před 6 měsíci +35

      Those sips seemed like a sub-plot and I was expecting a reference to them towards the end 😆

    • @DerekTJ
      @DerekTJ Před 6 měsíci

      Not just me!

    • @PrabhavKhandelwal
      @PrabhavKhandelwal Před 6 měsíci +3

      Its the little things

    • @orhandido2
      @orhandido2 Před 6 měsíci

      That was not accidental,it was deliberate cut,IDN why?

    • @DarrenPaul
      @DarrenPaul Před 6 měsíci +2

      And the pouring coffee. Cinema

  • @nyavoradjei8919
    @nyavoradjei8919 Před 6 měsíci +779

    I think the first step for our rebuild is for everyone around the club, fans included, to accept that we are no longer an elite team. Until we accept that no manager will be given enough time to truly overhaul and rebuild this club without fans and media breathing down their backs.

    • @terrm_
      @terrm_ Před 6 měsíci +75

      For real 👌🏽🖤
      I've been a Fan almost my entire life. But this is our rough patch.
      To actually transition, we all need to bow our heads and accept the fact that we aren't like that anymore, and exercise patience.
      Then the only way would be up.

    • @russellward4624
      @russellward4624 Před 6 měsíci +48

      As a City fan it seems they've overrated where they are kind-of like Spurs. Where they thought they were 1 or 2 players away because of where they finished in the table not accepting that they didn't finish 3rd and 2nd respectively because they were good. But because the teams around were bad. Last year spurs, Chelsea and lfc were bad. That allowed Utd to finish 3rd not because they were good. And they've misunderstood where they actually are with the talent or more to the point lack of talent in the team.

    • @ernestodotei3893
      @ernestodotei3893 Před 6 měsíci +17

      Yh I get that we are not elite anymore, but the lack of effort and lackadaisical body language from the players makes watching united games very frustrating.

    • @Rumborumbo87
      @Rumborumbo87 Před 6 měsíci +40

      I think you've made a really good point, Liverpool saw a distinct style of play when Klopp arrived but he also recorded an 8th place finish.
      I'm sure ETH would love to just go for his Ajax style 100% but he just doesn't have the players for it and an 8th place finish at Utd will almost certainly get him sacked. So he's forced to try and balance pragmatism with slowly introducing ideas which means the team looks all over the place. Obviously injuries and being at a badly run club haven't helped.
      Utd can try and change manager but it's going to be the same thing over and over until they admit how far they've fallen and just take the poor finishes to allow a manager the time like Liverpool did with Klopp or Arsenal with Arteta.

    • @beatty1229
      @beatty1229 Před 6 měsíci +11

      you are right. our finish last season was a bit of a fluke. we overperformed while other clubs underperformed. we are currently a top 6-7 club, not top 3, and we are not even living up to that.

  • @durthacht
    @durthacht Před 6 měsíci +369

    XG against of 4 is "not ideal". Slight understatement there.

    • @subboid
      @subboid Před 6 měsíci +35

      7-0 drubbings are usually around that

    • @duffmid
      @duffmid Před 6 měsíci +6

      TBH I think we should be happy was only 3. Before the game I fully expected it to be a new record loss based on how we've been playing all season.

    • @tompoynton
      @tompoynton Před 6 měsíci +6

      @@duffmidCity are always too nice to United

    • @God_is_an_Atheist666
      @God_is_an_Atheist666 Před 6 měsíci +7

      "Slight understatement" is an understatement.

  • @Doweyyy
    @Doweyyy Před 6 měsíci +1500

    Through this whole period Luke Shaw's absence has been massively underestimated. He is a fantastic fullback and really helps Rashford play the way he needs to down the left hand side. Width is absolutely crucial to a team's shape and Shaw is a massive part of that. His absence massively compromises the team's overall ability to build and keep structure. Martinez is also a huge miss in our ability to play out.

    • @Allschmoi
      @Allschmoi Před 6 měsíci +175

      An top team should be able to compensate with enough squad death. I also think you are kind of overselling how important Shaw is. He is good no doubt, but can not be used as an explanation why Rashford is this bad.

    • @_DioBrando_
      @_DioBrando_ Před 6 měsíci +115

      Luke Shaw wouldn't make City's bench. It's not an excuse to be honest.

    • @opinionatortv6457
      @opinionatortv6457 Před 6 měsíci +104

      ​@@_DioBrando_excuse me? 😂😂😂 So you think Gvardiol would start ahead of Shaw?

    • @Brickhazard
      @Brickhazard Před 6 měsíci +55

      Agreed. ETH has always played his teams with left footed LCB and right footed RCB. Shaw, Martinez and Malacia's absence at the same time has cost us dearly. All the plastic fans calling for ETH head do not realise how bad it is with the players available to us defender wise. Even AWB is a massive miss. Normally when either Shaw or Martinez is injured Malacia can cover LB and Shaw LCB as proven against Barcelona last season. We are playing a lot deeper as a result and resulting to counter attack football. I am pretty sure once our injuries come back the results will also change. Our injury situation is a crisis and the squad depth just isn't there.

    • @Rafaay
      @Rafaay Před 6 měsíci +16

      Even with all of those players, United have no identity in their football unfortunately.
      I back ETH for United but he has gotten most of his signings very wrong

  • @brendanmostek4723
    @brendanmostek4723 Před 6 měsíci +104

    15:25 "I'm sure he didn't come with the idea that were just going to do the same things that we've been doing for the past few seasons and do it just as badly" had me rolling 😂

  • @laurenzhacker5742
    @laurenzhacker5742 Před 6 měsíci +456

    What frustrates me is, why Ange Postacoglu can just come in and completely change the Spurs playing style, from a squad that was built for a back 5 system into a fun to watch attacking side - whereas it's seemingly impossible to do that same thing at Manchester United. Could you maybe cover that in a video? cheers

    • @charlieharper4982
      @charlieharper4982 Před 6 měsíci +178

      Tottenham don’t have the media pressure, owner question also they have a brand new stadium and training ground they are a well run club. At man United there is always pressure and stupid media story’s. Also United had many injuries at the beginning so there can’t be a constant squad.

    • @charlieharper4982
      @charlieharper4982 Před 6 měsíci +110

      Ange is never a better coach than ETH they are both good… but any random can see that the problem at United is deeper every other coach after Ferguson was struggling

    • @sherwan8143
      @sherwan8143 Před 6 měsíci +19

      it's a manager bounce, give it 2 months

    • @jeremyvaask2235
      @jeremyvaask2235 Před 6 měsíci +97

      ⁠@@charlieharper4982and you have those beliefs after 10 games? Spurs are maddison away from falling off and eventually managers will figure ange out. Not saying he’s a bad manager but we haven’t seen him deal with the pressure. Ten hag had most pressure out of any coach in world football last year and managed to get united a trophy and top 4 finish. He’s also going to be the fastest manager in united history to get to 50 wins after they beat fulham, so i really don’t understand why ten hag is under pressure by the media especially when half of his squad has been out injured.

    • @thedaddrive
      @thedaddrive Před 6 měsíci +18

      Both teams have the depth problem. They are both couple starting defenders away from not being able to play proactive football. United have 3 starting defenders out while Spurs don't. Also Spurs don't have Carabao or UEFA right now, so their depth problem is not exposed, but they are just as screwed if they have to start Sanchez and Dier, or Son/Madison injury. Not saying Spurs isn't great right now, but United's injury and depth problem is extreme. Better teams like City and Liverpool have subs that can play the in the preferred style, but Spurs or United do not.

  • @hama.fernandes
    @hama.fernandes Před 6 měsíci +248

    If you looked at the first have of the game Man U backline tried really hard to play from the back,they just couldn't do it ! Not only because of man city's press,but because they simply lacked the ability to do so.

    • @Mertaranta
      @Mertaranta Před 6 měsíci +51

      Which just highlights how important Martinez and Shaw are to ten Hag's system. With them, United are top 4. Without, top 12.

    • @pingusbabyyy451
      @pingusbabyyy451 Před 6 měsíci +28

      @@Mertaranta they are never a top 4 side. they benefitted from chelsea, tottenham and liverpool all imploding last season

    • @heffman94
      @heffman94 Před 6 měsíci +5

      ​@@Mertarantaunited a top 4 side? 🤣🤣🤣 dont make me laugh bro

    • @hama.fernandes
      @hama.fernandes Před 6 měsíci +5

      @@Mertaranta no even with them we're not a top 4 side,we have players upfront who can't play the modern game which is high press ball possession not making stupid passes and shooting randomly like bruno Fernandez and m.rashfurd,and we can't sell them because they are a brand and we lack the money to do so,yes they are good stars but today's football is about teamwork and being clinical which they are not.

    • @hama.fernandes
      @hama.fernandes Před 6 měsíci +5

      @@Mertaranta dalot is underrated too !
      Onana
      Luke shaw,varane,martinez,dalot
      Our backline without injuries can play modern football very good, but our midfield is in shambles besides casemiro,amrabat,mount nobody plays that way,
      In upfront antony,garnacho,hojlund can do it but they need polishing,
      There's no way out of where we are now,we either adapt to the way the top teams play or we become evertons and westhams playing counter attack like a good midtable side and that's it really,we have an elite coach who played the most beautiful, effective football at ajax,he didn't suddenly forgot how to coach ETH is the man.

  • @Miloxiaocelao
    @Miloxiaocelao Před 6 měsíci +356

    So really at the end of the day, the problem is still ETH not having the players he wants and needs to play the style he wants. One can argue “United spent BIG money on ETH” all day long, just as we have with all of the previous managers since SAF, but the puzzling phenomenon remains where ALL of the managers reverted back to the counter attacking strategy to win games. And we have had managers with very different ideas on strategies. The fact it all came back down to this is rather telling of the status of the football club. And it almost doesn’t matter who comes in at this point. We might as well have Mickey Mouse sit in the dug out, and it wouldn’t get worse. Backing the manager under the current context really means to choose between immediate results and actually fixing the problem. And all the pundit and fans, and rivals could all just shut up about “but, but, but it’s United”. Any org is as good as the owners. Where there is a will, there is a way. Well, the lack of will trickles down from waaaaay up top. All the analysis with XGs, and possessions, and narrow lanes and channels and style of plays just cracks me up where we have had to rely on a CB half retired to defend, a CM and a CB both one foot out the door to score goals for us, a young striker who is brand new to the league leading the attacking line of a club size of Man United, and another CM who has literally died and came back to life. That’s how the manager has been backed. Onana must be thinking WTF every game, despite his own faults. Same with Bruno, Marcus, and etc, all of whom I am running out of patience with. But can we really blame them? It’s like forcing Bolt to run 100m races, but forbidding him to use his legs. With the players we have, all the new signings we signed with their forces in mind, can’t use their strengths.
    Even if ETH is just another one-season-wonder, just stick with him until the club structure substantially changes, because what is the point anyways otherwise.

    • @whatthehead
      @whatthehead Před 6 měsíci +38

      "still ETH not having the players he wants and needs to play the style he wants" Are you drunk?? How many players he signed in these two seasons?

    • @AsianLing
      @AsianLing Před 6 měsíci +63

      @@whatthehead bro Maguire is still here he was 5th choice centre back same with Mctominay. Players which Ten hag wanted sold, are still here

    • @nickj.7876
      @nickj.7876 Před 6 měsíci +6

      Could not agree more mate.

    • @scottlinton6577
      @scottlinton6577 Před 6 měsíci +4

      Fully agree

    • @safwaanali5727
      @safwaanali5727 Před 6 měsíci +15

      How is postecoglu doing so well then playing exciting football having basically only signed Madison in the summer?

  • @Oliver-zm2ho
    @Oliver-zm2ho Před 6 měsíci +66

    This is so frustrating because one of the main reasons Ten Hag was brought in was for him to implement his system so we wouldn't have to rely on individual brilliance.

    • @markpaul7623
      @markpaul7623 Před 6 měsíci +7

      Has dissapointed me big time,i hoped for better,am afraid he is not what i expected

    • @yato.692
      @yato.692 Před 6 měsíci

      @@markpaul7623you wouldn’t have said that last season though would you? Bloody sheep.

    • @wingsofsuspensionlifts6814
      @wingsofsuspensionlifts6814 Před 6 měsíci +2

      such bizarre signings too.... what is the point of mount and eriksen? they desperately need some physicality in that midfield.

    • @alexs.818
      @alexs.818 Před 6 měsíci +3

      ​@@wingsofsuspensionlifts6814I bet you he wanted better players, however United's piss poor scouting department and negotiating team were influential in the acquisition of these underperforming signings.

    • @barnettmufc77
      @barnettmufc77 Před 6 měsíci +2

      @@markpaul7623 Do you guys just forget last season? We were a much better team last year, just chill, allow for new signings to settle and get some key players back from injury and trust the process. It may take a season or 2 but bullshit comments just make it plain and obvious are fan base is full of absolute idiots who expect instant success from every manager. Pep even took a year or 2 to get going at City and they were planning for his arrival a year in advance.

  • @benitojayadas1876
    @benitojayadas1876 Před 6 měsíci +106

    I think the moment you are having Maguire as a defender in the team yiu will have to sit deep cos of the lack of pace..its not maguires fault, he was brought to play in that system. So start of thr season when you see that your players are not fight you went back into that system , which would mean relying on counter attack and chaos to get goals

    • @swordsman1137
      @swordsman1137 Před 6 měsíci +2

      Maybe Ten Hag should learm from Southgate.

    • @benitojayadas1876
      @benitojayadas1876 Před 6 měsíci +18

      @@swordsman1137 Dude , Southgate is already getting criticised for playing negative football, in international scenario where matches happen once in 2-3 months. Imagine fan reaction when that happen with premier league opposition's week in week out.
      Even when ole finished second he was criticised for playing counter attacking football and not being able to break down teams sitting behind. Man utd fans want possession based football from a team which consists of counter attacking suited players

    • @russellward4624
      @russellward4624 Před 6 měsíci +3

      ​@swordsman1137 International football is mediocre. You can play mediocre negative football and get away with it because there's only 3 or 4 good teams.

    • @BigAsianMan1999
      @BigAsianMan1999 Před 6 měsíci

      Ten hag should follow the tactics of West ham low line Lets oppoments take possession and maguire is a sweeper defender perfect for stopping strickers in a tight area also maguirr can deliver long balls out for counter attack

    • @benitojayadas1876
      @benitojayadas1876 Před 6 měsíci

      @@BigAsianMan1999 and you think man UTD fans are going to be happy with playing the same style. Ole was playing the same thing.... He was constantly criticised for doing that, till he tried to change that a bit and the system came collapsing down

  • @ONEMADKILLERx
    @ONEMADKILLERx Před 6 měsíci +201

    He was brought in because OF the style of play he used at Ajax. This current football is purely relying on moments from two out of form players in Rashford and Bruno or by force through McTominay Maguire

    • @morlath4767
      @morlath4767 Před 6 měsíci +47

      This is the exact problem with United. They aren't looking to win as a team, they're hoping players do a moment of genius.

    • @fightfan9739
      @fightfan9739 Před 6 měsíci +33

      ETH can’t play Ajax football even if he wanted to as our players are mid table at best

    • @ElEmElEkv13
      @ElEmElEkv13 Před 6 měsíci +27

      But the problem it, that Manchester United is Manchester United. To coach this Ajax style of play you need a LOT of time to do it, and you don't have that time at United, especially if you are playing games every 3 days like last season. With the club being purely profit driven and amount of debt put on the club, United can't accept 2 slow season with finishing around 7/8th with early dropouts in cups, but that's exactly what would it take to drill this team in Ajax way of play. Managing United with it's current squad is just impossible task.

    • @morlath4767
      @morlath4767 Před 6 měsíci +15

      @@fightfan9739He doesn't need to play Ajax football, he needs to play _cohesive_ football. The first half of this video pretty much sums up how the team is effectively a broken system of 6 + 4.

    • @morlath4767
      @morlath4767 Před 6 měsíci +1

      @@ElEmElEkv13I agree in principle. But the system doesn't have to be taught in one giant whole. It's not ideal, but it should be possible to slowly introduce a new style of paly to a squad even with the PL schedule.

  • @ohmane5453
    @ohmane5453 Před 6 měsíci +47

    As a Liverpool fan I think Ten Hag is doing great and should keep the current style.

    • @hijklmn
      @hijklmn Před 6 měsíci

      any other team fans would agree so they can become like chelsea last season lmao

    • @bcbitchkkv
      @bcbitchkkv Před 6 měsíci

      "Ten Hag is a football genius!"

  • @andregolding2248
    @andregolding2248 Před 6 měsíci +83

    Erik wants United to be the best transition team with basic possession principles. Basically a mix of Ajax and Borussia Dortmund.
    It will either be a football revolution or an early dismissal for him. Really hope he can ride out this negative pressure.
    Up United.

    • @iwantgoals1566
      @iwantgoals1566 Před 6 měsíci +5

      I’ve never seen Dortmund go long from their build up play though. I don’t think they usually do but rather build from the back. Whereas ETH is telling Onana to go long. The only resemblance I see with Dortmund is the pressing and high turnovers but still, we’re too poor on the ball to make anything of it. So we’re basically playing fetch with the other team.

    • @andregolding2248
      @andregolding2248 Před 6 měsíci +8

      @@iwantgoals1566 Fair point.
      Mate, I really don't know. He's facing a firing squad this week. He's being cut to pieces by the usuals. Really hope he can climb out of this hole in time.
      If he doesn't, we're fucked.

    • @odoggy1767
      @odoggy1767 Před 6 měsíci

      @@iwantgoals1566 maybe closer to inzaghis inter? still not the best example and not too sure about it with sommer this season (haven't watched them), but a team that is able to build out from the back while also having defenders like bastoni and (at the time), onana playing those long range passes

    • @solenstyle
      @solenstyle Před 6 měsíci +5

      His Ajax side was already good at transitions. They weren't married to possession like Pep's sides were. It was a mix of Klopp and Pep's football. I just don't understand why he thinks he shouldn't work towards that. Fans will be more willing to back him if they can get some entertaining games, while not having the results all the time. Klopp from day one didn't get Liverpool competing for the PL. But from day 1, you could tell his Liverpool side played like his Dortmund side.
      Ten Hag has been far too pragmatic. A lot of United fans are under the idea that entertaining football will eventually lead to good results. To say he's not trying to be like Ajax, is a betrayal of why fans were excited for his appointment. Results first business isn't leading to any major honors and its making fans miserable when watching their club play.

    • @waggna469
      @waggna469 Před 6 měsíci

      @@solenstyle best take so far, thank you

  • @Omnipotentmonkey
    @Omnipotentmonkey Před 6 měsíci +39

    when I saw the line-up I assume the exact same thing, that Lindelof would be tucking in to form a 3 and Dalot advancing,
    in my head it kind of looked like a mirror to City's formation
    so:
    ______________Onana______________
    __Maguire __Evans____Lindelof____
    ____Amrabat___McTominay_______
    Dalot_Eriksen_Fernandes_Rashford
    ____________Hojlund________________
    But Lindelof playing for width was just... bizarre...
    and then you see that Amrabat took up a deeper position than Maguire on average while McTominay, Eriksen, Bruno, Rashford and Hojlund just clustered together with a chasm of space in midfield forming...
    United are just bizarre atm.

    • @FF-oo8nz
      @FF-oo8nz Před 6 měsíci +2

      injuries hit us hard. Luke Shaw and Martinez are missed

    • @MK12275
      @MK12275 Před 6 měsíci

      Ten Hag is trying different things with the current squad. He'll make changes accordingly later. The thing is Bruno could play a pivotal role with Amrabat while playing McTominay as the 8

  • @Wolf_of_Small_St
    @Wolf_of_Small_St Před 6 měsíci +57

    The comparison with Solskjaer is an interesting one. In the last 48 PL games under Solskjaer (i.e including the ones where it all fell apart) compared to the 48 that Ten Hag has taken charge of, EtH has just 2 more points than Ole (90 vs 88). Ten Hag's side has conceded 1 less goal but scored 20 less goals than Ole's team did. Ole was sacked for 3 results:
    0-5 against Liverpool. Ten Hag lost 7-0 to Liverpool.
    0-2 against City. Ten Hag lost 6-3 and 0-3 against City.the
    4-1 against Watford. Ten Hag lost 4-0 against Brentford. And 1-3 against Brighton.
    Ole regularly used to win games against the big teams especially away from home but EtH has got nowhere near. We were humiliated by Istanbul in the CL under Ole, but then this term have lost at home to Galatasary.
    I'm not suggesting that we get rid of Ten Hag (at this point who else is there) but there has been no improvement since Solskjaer at all. It's just narrative creation from former Ole critics to claim otherwise.

    • @teo2157
      @teo2157 Před 6 měsíci +7

      Its obviously deeper than the managers, its deeply rooted in the club, perhaps something thats been here since SAF, a poision in the club, otherwise, every manager wouldnt have failed, wouldnt have been ruined, idk what it is, but its serious.

    • @Timbone07
      @Timbone07 Před 6 měsíci +2

      Zero planning
      We need to start buying players the club needs instead of manager signing or players that are marketable

    • @jr5034
      @jr5034 Před 6 měsíci

      yes but alot of those defeats have come this season or in the Feb - April patch, where the team suffered injuries and didn't play with the best team specifically

    • @tarkomi8830
      @tarkomi8830 Před 6 měsíci

      No improvement? Have been blind? Didn't we lose both home and away against Man C and Liv? What about how we beat the 2:1 huh?
      Better ball pocession tf is wrong with you?

    • @Wolf_of_Small_St
      @Wolf_of_Small_St Před 6 měsíci +1

      ​@tarkomi8830 Our average ball possession is actually down on the Solskjaer era- 54.8% under Ole to 53.5% under Ten Hag. And for all Ten Hag's possession if the team are scoring 20 goals less, then what is the point.
      Also, yes we did beat City and Liverpool at home 2-1. But Ole also beat those sides- he won 4 times against Pep Guardiola, including 3 times at the Etihad and the double over them in 2019/20. And we knocked Liverpool out of the FA Cup with a 3-2 win at OT under Ole. So what's your point? How does Ten Hag winning 2 games show progression when we used to win those games under Solskjaer?

  • @ActuallyAudacity
    @ActuallyAudacity Před 6 měsíci +36

    So the main issue is that we don't have the defence ETH wants in order to play the type of football he wants to play. He's trying to accommodate the slower CBs he has and adjust his tactics accordingly but it leads to the worst of both worlds... I think the Luke Shaw and Lisandro Martinez injury really fucked us up because I remember how high we we're playing last season and even then the CBs weren't at the halfway line because we had DDG. With Onana you would expect us to play super high up the pitch but the injuries messed it all up. What's worse is ETH didn't get Kim Min Jae and he would have definitely allowed us to play ETH ball.

    • @Mopark25
      @Mopark25 Před 6 měsíci +12

      This has been so obvious to me I'm really scratching my head as to why people are surprised.

    • @nicknewman7848
      @nicknewman7848 Před 6 měsíci +3

      ETH didn't get Pavard either or Kane or De Jong and probably a few others that were first on his list. He needs 5 new players to make it work. Onana, Shaw and Martinez are good enough, Fernandez is good enough, Rashford is good enough and Hoilund is one for the future. The others are either not good enough, not ready yet or becoming over the hill fast.

    • @optiondezzo1513
      @optiondezzo1513 Před 6 měsíci +2

      @@Mopark25 rabid fans only live for the moment and have goldfish memory. they most likely forgot shaw and martinez are even man utd players and won't be back till dec/january.

    • @Timbone07
      @Timbone07 Před 6 měsíci

      I disagree.
      ETH needs 15 players but if each will cost 90 million each then you have a problem

    • @ChrisWalker-fq7kf
      @ChrisWalker-fq7kf Před 6 měsíci

      But we know Shaw is very injury prone and maybe Martinez is too. So how is it going to work?

  • @dickykamarullah1507
    @dickykamarullah1507 Před 6 měsíci +7

    I think the first comment Klopp made something about dont take history in your backpack and carry it around when he appoint at Liverpool was brilliant in changing the mindset of the club and make fans and others accept that there are mediocre club, it take pressure off and it allow him time to build the team.

  • @alextee2005
    @alextee2005 Před 6 měsíci +47

    Definitely a challenging task for ETH to rebuild Man Utd. The trade-off between short-termism and building for the future in modern football is every manager's dilemma. Build for the future but not show results in the short-term can mean you're out of job before results can be seen. Focus on short-termism sets the club up for medium to long term mediocrity.
    As a fan who trusted the Arsenal process, a manager who has a clear long-term view is better if the owners are able to invest with the manager.

    • @mrmoe2u
      @mrmoe2u Před 6 měsíci +2

      The thing also about that is the glazers don’t seem like they care. Stan doesn’t seem like he cared either, probably still doesn’t, but josh came in and actually became involved with the club and with whatever the plan is for the present and future.

    • @thebiglebrowski3695
      @thebiglebrowski3695 Před 6 měsíci +2

      I agree. But which camp is Ten Hag in? I think he is in the short term camp. He hasn't planned for the future. If he had then I could forgive the performances and give it time. Instead we sign Eriksen, Casemiro, Amrabat, Onana, Mount ... none of these guys are going to grow.

    • @Spiinellii
      @Spiinellii Před 6 měsíci +1

      @@thebiglebrowski3695 only transfer you can question is mount because feb haag really wanted him for some reason other than that the others werent his first choice

    • @haroldsimarmsta750
      @haroldsimarmsta750 Před 6 měsíci +1

      Another problem is most of the fans are just like @thebiglebrowski3695 here. Sure its hurting fans when United are bad. But the bad run always makes them blind of what is actually going on. There is no way United can go long term with both owners and fans being the same, expectant of high place finish regardless of the state of the club and players. So, i think United is doomed. Every single element of this football club can not ever had the same vision

    • @waggna469
      @waggna469 Před 6 měsíci

      There can’t be a rebuild until the board has changed, he’s just doing another Ole and he has to know that. Still he’s so delusional that he thinks he can change that which is just bad

  • @babixillo
    @babixillo Před 6 měsíci +18

    got to sympathize with ETH. working with united is like when an artist got commissioned by client with bad taste in art, they keep changing things to their liking even though the artist keeps pitching great ideas, and the end result is a bad art that looks somewhat okay purely because the artist skills to make it look not too bad.

    • @thexperimenter88
      @thexperimenter88 Před 6 měsíci +1

      I have zero sympathy. He wasted funds when he purchased Antony, van de beek, Mount

    • @jackfeng813
      @jackfeng813 Před 6 měsíci +9

      @@thexperimenter88he didn’t even buy Donny bruh

    • @thexperimenter88
      @thexperimenter88 Před 6 měsíci

      @@jackfeng813 you’re right. Still funds are limited and he bought Antony who is one of the worse players I have ever seen. Mount also does not contribute much. Casemiro does not also fit the system.

    • @jackfeng813
      @jackfeng813 Před 6 měsíci +1

      @@thexperimenter88 yeah you right, mount has gotta be the most clueless signing I’ve seen.

    • @sqch
      @sqch Před 6 měsíci +5

      @@thexperimenter88He asked for the players, not his fault the fees were high. This ain’t fifa where the manager negotiates. It was the clubs fault for taking years to begin talks and Utd over the years have become an easy target for clubs to overcharge..

  • @cassiusjoe4907
    @cassiusjoe4907 Před 6 měsíci +23

    I think I’d have believed ten Hag’s reasoning for not playing in that same way through necessity… if Ange wasn’t doing what he’s done at Spurs so quickly. Yes, he’s brought in some players that fit his system more, but ten Hag has had way more time to figure things out and bring players in than Ange has. I think it shows the weakness in pragmatism in football. Just play the way you want your team to play! Results may not come, but at least you tried

    • @Jur1_00
      @Jur1_00 Před 6 měsíci +2

      I don't know if I agree with that. Let's say I have a team and I want them to play like Klopp so I go and hire Klopp. If he turns around and says he wasn't brought in to play like he was at liverpool I don't think I will be happy

    • @highnoon7097
      @highnoon7097 Před 6 měsíci

      @@Jur1_00 haha what a strange reply. I don't think you understand the original comment. He's saying a manager should stick to his principles and at least give it a go, rather than the absolute shite compromised football that 7Hag has stunk the place out with for 18 months. Even Jesse Marsch stuck to his principles and had more of a coherent system than 7Hag has. Better to be hanged for a sheep than a lamb.

  • @ShaunLevett
    @ShaunLevett Před 6 měsíci +30

    For anyone who pines for the 'good old days' of Premier League football, just watch United then realise you are wrong.

    • @opinionatortv6457
      @opinionatortv6457 Před 6 měsíci +3

      Nah, the reason we call for "good old" PREM football is because everyone was essentially playing that style. It was open and exciting. However football has changed and it is not as effective especially against high possession teams. Even though, United are trying to do too many things at once

    • @maud8392
      @maud8392 Před 6 měsíci +19

      ​@@opinionatortv6457this is revisionist. boring football has always existed.

    • @F--B
      @F--B Před 6 měsíci

      @@maud8392 so.. nothing has changed and everything is much the same then?

    • @opinionatortv6457
      @opinionatortv6457 Před 6 měsíci

      @@maud8392 just because the system isn't pass 1 pass 2 doesn't make it boring

    • @PK-ts8iz
      @PK-ts8iz Před 6 měsíci

      ​@@opinionatortv6457The same argument can be made for football in the past 5 years or so. There are always going to be clubs who play boring football and clubs who play attractive football in every league in every season. I remember watching Fulham and Charlton in 2003-04 playing beautiful football as midtable sides. Everton, Leeds and even City played some uninspired stuff that same year.

  • @guardaviewer4197
    @guardaviewer4197 Před 6 měsíci +4

    I really love how they got the real Erik Ten Hag here into Tifo studios to tell us all about Erik Ten Hag's tactics!

  • @GrahamPlays
    @GrahamPlays Před 6 měsíci +4

    Fantastic show as always guys

  • @pneale333
    @pneale333 Před 6 měsíci

    So nice to have someone explain it all thank you

  • @jameswolfe7413
    @jameswolfe7413 Před 6 měsíci +6

    1.) The players Ten Hag brought in this season to improve the work rate and stability have (almost) all been injured to start the season. 2.) Even now, no one on that backline is a 1st choice. 3.) The same players who never have conviction when fighting for a 50/50 ball or a header continue to do the same. You can tell when a player is running with belief they will win the ball, and when they are running JUST to show they "did their job" on defense.

    • @theberserker_of_falconia
      @theberserker_of_falconia Před 6 měsíci

      Buying antony for this much money was the true crime. Dude got mad at Doku for doing what he cant in front of him😂😂😂 Also Sancho

    • @theberserker_of_falconia
      @theberserker_of_falconia Před 6 měsíci

      Buying antony for this much money was the true crime. Dude got mad at Doku for doing what he cant in front of him😂😂😂 Also Sancho

    • @jameswolfe7413
      @jameswolfe7413 Před 6 měsíci

      Yeah, right now Antony is a poor imitation Arjen Robben.

    • @Timbone07
      @Timbone07 Před 6 měsíci

      I disagree. I believe ETH needs 15 players but spending 90 million on one and constantly overpaying is a big problem

    • @jameswolfe7413
      @jameswolfe7413 Před 6 měsíci

      @@Timbone07 sure if we had 3 more Martinezes and 3 more Amrabats, then we could keep Bruno and Rashford on the field to score. I still trace this back to Pogba & Co. undoing the culture of success at Old Trafford.

  • @andrewhezekiahdaniel
    @andrewhezekiahdaniel Před 6 měsíci +7

    11:47 Yes because Bruno and Rashford are counter-attacking players who give the ball away for fun.

  • @dushimedavid6345
    @dushimedavid6345 Před 6 měsíci +2

    last season we struggled at the end of the season. I hope we can get some form.

  • @Dave0610
    @Dave0610 Před 6 měsíci +3

    The stars of the team are Bruno Fernandes and Marcus Rashford. I can't even imagine them two playing possession football. It's impossible and I think Ten Hag has seen this. He tried to play "Ajax football", got massacred and changed it to "United DNA" and got the results he needed.
    Just look at some of the players Ten Hag's signed and some that he wanted to sign, it's clear that he wants something else: Martinez, Antony, Onana, Amrabat, Eriksen, De Jong, Hojlund, Kane the list goes on, all these players can play that Ajax style of football.

  • @thepesportsteacher
    @thepesportsteacher Před 6 měsíci +3

    Love this breakdown. Anybody know the app they are using?

  • @raihansiddique5210
    @raihansiddique5210 Před 6 měsíci +2

    This is actually the best take on the current situation 👏🏾

  • @blakelyle2158
    @blakelyle2158 Před 6 měsíci +7

    What program do you guys use for the tactical board?

  • @hamidisaidi2879
    @hamidisaidi2879 Před 6 měsíci +7

    This is a fantastic review of the problems in Utd on the field problems. It really, to me, boils down to the need for Glazers to go and Utd to have a proper footballing structure from top down with a good Director of Football and top top staff assisting the Manager.

  • @gauravpande7746
    @gauravpande7746 Před 6 měsíci +5

    What am analysis guys and that last line that you have to suffer short term to gain long term I agree !

  • @yashodhandamle353
    @yashodhandamle353 Před 6 měsíci +5

    Ten Hag needs to communicate his ideas and thoughts about the game better through media and press conferences. This should be as though he is talking and explaining to the fans. One of Sir Alex's biggest plus was how he communicated with the media. As a fan, we knew exactly how and what he was thinking, so when he dropped someone, we were always kept in the loop. Sir Alex's substitutions were quite telling, he would demote a bad performance by substituting, and a bad pattern by a first-teamer would result in him getting dropped. Ten Hag needs to do these things more than anything

    • @loudmouthdiaries5188
      @loudmouthdiaries5188 Před 6 měsíci +3

      Where have you seen fergurson talk tactics?
      U re either young or ignorance
      Ten hag has the best substitution record in the epl since his arrival.
      Ten hag is more tactical than fergurson.
      Fergurson is king of man management (no one compare)
      Ole has zero tactic he was just nice

    • @Hardy2608
      @Hardy2608 Před 6 měsíci +1

      Yes Eric Ten Haag should tell everyone what his tactics are😂

    • @loudmouthdiaries5188
      @loudmouthdiaries5188 Před 6 měsíci

      @@Hardy2608 we all know what he is trying to do and he has communicated it but it is not yet coming off.
      That's it.
      It is taking longer than he thought
      But every united player has said they know what he is trying to do.

  • @buzzjens1
    @buzzjens1 Před 6 měsíci +5

    Hey, can you do a video on Marco Rose? He's a really good manager, did amazing at Gladbach, did better at Dortmund than he had players to and is doing really well at Leipzig as well

    • @GrahamPlays
      @GrahamPlays Před 6 měsíci +1

      2nd this would love to hear more Bundesliga news

    • @MattVogt2
      @MattVogt2 Před 6 měsíci

      @@GrahamPlays Even just as an excuse to get Seb Halfords Floor in :)

  • @kalvinleogaviola8546
    @kalvinleogaviola8546 Před 6 měsíci +4

    You dont have to look too deep into this to see the problem. You have Evans and Maguire starting for one of the most important matches of the season

  • @grapeappletwist
    @grapeappletwist Před 6 měsíci +3

    No idea. I don't understand why he wants them to become the best team at counterattacking and transitions. It wasn't like that at Ajax.

  • @poppyharlow4448
    @poppyharlow4448 Před 6 měsíci +2

    The injuries are one thing, the fact that there's no cohesiveness within the team is another. When I watch this unit play, I just see 11 guys, not a team. It's so obvious they should be doing better, they win the ball high up the pitch more than anyone else, but they never find a pass. I think they'll have it figured out by the end of the season but I don't really see them pushing for anything apart from a conference league or Europa league spot, and I don't see them making it out their UCL group either.

  • @pulkitchoudhary7246
    @pulkitchoudhary7246 Před 6 měsíci

    what tool do you use for explaining formations and buildups etc

  • @rayjbucknor
    @rayjbucknor Před 6 měsíci +6

    One of the weird things about being a Man United fan over the last couple years is that I've honestly believed the team we've had (all the way back to the last few years of Pogba's United career) has been good/talented enough to challenge for the league or at least a few more cups, even with Man City's unprecedented dominance over the last 3-4 years. (Although, honestly, from a neutral POV, Man City are so f***ing good)
    I've always thought we're one player away or two players away. But with 10 years of pain I'm thinking blow it up, keep a few keystones but blow it up begin a proper rebuild. Literally hasn't been this bad in my lifetime, I'm 26 going on 57 because of this season

    • @highnoon7097
      @highnoon7097 Před 6 měsíci +1

      people play too much fifa career mode. These "full rebuilds" don't happen. Get it out of your head that starting from scratch will ever be an option.

    • @rayjbucknor
      @rayjbucknor Před 6 měsíci

      Who said anything about starting from scratch, I'm agreeing with going through the pain of having a bad team in the short term for long term success. Our current formula of firing a manager and watching the new one show with a team that isn't theirs is boring now

    • @icecreamman3545
      @icecreamman3545 Před 6 měsíci

      ​@@highnoon7097you can have a full rebuild of a position though, Liverpool recognised that midfield was their worst position so they bought in Mac Alister, szobozslai, gravenberch and endo in one transfer window, if United can rebuild a position or 2 every few transfer windows a good squad can be molded within 2-3 years

    • @LordWay
      @LordWay Před 6 měsíci +1

      Yeah our recruitment is so poor unfortunately we overpay for basically every player and then get so little value when they leave. So even the rebuild wouldn't really work at this point we are kinda stuck when we can't generate funds from sales all that much. Each season we creep further towards FFP hence all the loans last season.

  • @maxmartinez3172
    @maxmartinez3172 Před 6 měsíci +26

    We are desperately missing Lisandro Martinez and Luke Shaw 😢 both bring the defense to life and progress up there pitch also casemiro

    • @Silas-gz9zl
      @Silas-gz9zl Před 6 měsíci

      As if those two would've changed yesterday's result. Good players, but the problems obviously lie much deeper than that.

    • @duffmid
      @duffmid Před 6 měsíci +3

      We've had Casemiro most of the season and he's been awful. Either his legs are gone or he's lost his fire because he knows English refs are dieing to send him off any chance they get. He's just another on the very long list of Glazer signings who we get at most a single season from, and then they're here for another 3 years on huge wages. The mistakes and patterns in the way they've run this club into the ground are so obvious it's hard to believe.

    • @joestockton7016
      @joestockton7016 Před 6 měsíci

      All three of them were playing against Liverpool earlier this year when they lost 7-0

    • @Timbone07
      @Timbone07 Před 6 měsíci

      I disagree. I believe ETH needs 15 players but spending 90 million on one and constantly overpaying is a big problem

  • @lptwenty9971
    @lptwenty9971 Před 6 měsíci

    i wonder if it something to do with the backline not pushing up because he doesn't have the players to do so harry maguire to name one cannot play at the halfway however last season when it was martinez and varane they always pushed right up the pitch to compact the space for opposition

  • @Liversh0t
    @Liversh0t Před 6 měsíci +1

    everything feels a bit half-assed tactically, the team doesn't press together, push high together, but they also don't play the way a team that sits deep is supposed to play either

  • @siddheshraorane9224
    @siddheshraorane9224 Před 6 měsíci +51

    Answer: Trying to go back to Ajax 😂

  • @Zephyrr03
    @Zephyrr03 Před 6 měsíci +42

    Manu created 0.9 xg quite high for their current standard.

    • @celtic69
      @celtic69 Před 6 měsíci

      Imo he was introduced into legacy far too early in his career

    • @diegoclark7697
      @diegoclark7697 Před 6 měsíci

      That was mostly cuz city gave them the ball in dangerous areas. Not UTD themselves creating something

    • @Hans.Dewitt
      @Hans.Dewitt Před 6 měsíci +2

      ​@@diegoclark7697having the opponents make a mistake IS creating opportunities, City won't give the ball away for nothing

    • @mikexhotmail
      @mikexhotmail Před 6 měsíci

      Agree but unforce error also part of the game.@@Hans.Dewitt

    • @abhinavkumar4824
      @abhinavkumar4824 Před 6 měsíci

      mostly cause of game state

  • @sjantz8809
    @sjantz8809 Před 6 měsíci

    “They do not” ~ as an editor, im lovin the post production banter

  • @Javadamutt
    @Javadamutt Před 6 měsíci +1

    I don’t know if you can do that anymore. This season is insane, normally you can point to 3 teams that will challenge for the title and within that you will always get another doing surprising things with a good season. This year while you have your clear title contenders there are 10 teams I can see that should be in the running for the European spots. If United take a step back to rebuild they risk dropping not into mid table but into a relegation scrap. As much as I hate to say it, fighting 1 season to the next is the only way to survive currently

    • @tommyshads
      @tommyshads Před 6 měsíci +1

      Utd are almost halfway to survival after 10 (awful) games. Even with a full rebuild Utd would still be picking up enough points to survive. Luton have 5 points in 17th and we could see some record low points tallies this year
      There is an opportunity for rebuild for a club/board/structure with the right vision and determination. United print money regardless of league position and have an opportunity to reduce the wage bill over coming years by letting contracts expire even if they can't sell (Martial 2024, Heaton 2024, Williams 2024, Maguire 2025, Varane 2025, Eriksen 2025, Van De Beek 2025). That's 1.25m+ per week in wages alone. Throw in Sancho and you are looking at 1.5m per week saved. That's with United reducing their wage bill by 1m per week over the past year or so even including new signings (Ronaldo, Jones, Bailly etc.). New players would need to come in, but Utd have the revenue to spend 100-150m per summer comfortably. The Adidas deal value would decrease, but so do salaries with non-CL football (25% reduction).
      Mainoo, Alvaro Fernandez, Garnacho, Mejibri are immediate talents who could be getting minutes. Martinez, Shaw, Malacia, Antony, Onana, Hoijlund, Casemiro are Ten Hag players. With a change in style Mount should be getting minutes too.
      It's possible but requires bravery and pain from top to bottom to achieve. But with the short-termism option failing it surely becomes more appealing?

  • @mathewsnook3803
    @mathewsnook3803 Před 6 měsíci +8

    At this point, he's trying to get sacked, don't get any cheese for quitting your job

  • @eman472
    @eman472 Před 6 měsíci +3

    JJ seemed so pleased with himself when pouring his cup like he just discovered coffee 😂

  • @KayfabeKarl
    @KayfabeKarl Před 6 měsíci

    He needed to do his style and get players that work for his style of play. Clearly theres a lot of issues above the manager still why theyll continue to regress

  • @grahamnewton4381
    @grahamnewton4381 Před 6 měsíci +1

    I think the key to this is the comment that Utd are short term termist and you cannot build a team in the short term. I have seen a number of Liverpool rebuilds. The current Arsenal team is a rebuild. Blackburn and Chelsea virtually bought new teams and Utd were lucky with the ‘class of 92’ which gave them a new team. Since Ferguson left Utd have become a patchwork quilt paying ludicrous amounts to fill individual squares with little regard to the overall shape and blend of the team. Personally I think the current squad is at least as good as when Ferguson left but Ferguson was exceptionally skilled in getting results from average players. Utd don’t have Ferguson but have not made progress since he left.

  • @wiretom
    @wiretom Před 6 měsíci +3

    Imagine city were missing rodri stones dias etc ... Nobody mentioning uniteds back 4 has been out for weeks

  • @cjBFC
    @cjBFC Před 6 měsíci +3

    4xg conceded is shocking even in the Liverpool 7-0 game they only conceded 2.6xg

    • @rajimus
      @rajimus Před 6 měsíci

      Its only beause Onana made 2 saves. Xg is an awful thing to base any sort of stats on. Spurs have the same average Xg as united and chelsea this season. Theyre pretty much top. Yet theyve had mroe penalties go their way and own goals and defelctions.

  • @cameronjones8641
    @cameronjones8641 Před 6 měsíci +1

    This was before a 3 Nil embarressing at home to Newcastle. Fantastic video. The guys absolutely nailed it.

  • @menthodox
    @menthodox Před 6 měsíci +1

    i agree everything they said but the recruitment. Yes ETH brought in martinez onana and antony, but we also failed to get him key player like de jong for his style of play. We end up getting casemiro who does not seem to be his type of player which he needs to adapt. Eriksen is brought in to play the role of de jong at ajax but he is much older and less mobile. Does not have the same defensive mind. He has a van de beek who has messed up by injuries and failed coaching. Mason Mount also does not look like a player for ETH. Meanwhile we cant sell the players, and continue to force him to play players do not suit his style thus he gave up and change. It is clear to see he didnt want to play maguire, mctominay over the past 2 years but he ends up playing them. Besides injuries, it also seems to me like all the former managers there is degree of influence from elsewhere on selection of the squad. ETH to me is a manager who likes to give youth a chance (looking at the ajax team). Garnacho is the only one broke through. Maybe we really dont have quality youth players but is it also due to instructions to play big contract players?
    Looking back at all the former managers, the pattern is we first let them try the styles, failed to get the players they want (mane for lvg, cb for jose, halaand for ole) and gave them second or third choice players (likes of Schneiderlin, Fred), whilst bringing big name commercial players (ronaldo, pogba). This is just the vicious cycle that wont change unless ownership or management is reconstructed. And surely it wont happen just cause sir jim got 25% of the owneship

  • @danchef8823
    @danchef8823 Před 6 měsíci

    8:02 show me the screen shots John 😂😂

  • @Combatwombat-sn7ng
    @Combatwombat-sn7ng Před 6 měsíci +3

    Ten Hag's issue is more than just tactical. It seems like he's a terrible man manager, who makes too many excuses and throws players under the bus. Not to mention he hasn't actually made any of the players better- compare that to the top managers in the league who do improve their players.

  • @scottlinton6577
    @scottlinton6577 Před 6 měsíci +8

    No Casemiro, Martinez, Varane, Shaw, Wan Bissaka is the key reason we haven’t been up to it this season. Simple as that. Maguire can’t play a high line, hence the chasm in midfield. Martinez and Varane, injury prone. Still a lot of players required to even make top 6 let alone 4 now.

    • @jhpfdijtuiweruot
      @jhpfdijtuiweruot Před 6 měsíci +1

      Martinez and Varane who conceded THIRTEEN to City and LFC in around 90 mins of play, you mean? You think that was Maguire's fault? Lol

    • @scottlinton6577
      @scottlinton6577 Před 6 měsíci +3

      @@jhpfdijtuiweruot would hate to know how many we would have conceded if he was playing mate

    • @jhpfdijtuiweruot
      @jhpfdijtuiweruot Před 6 měsíci

      @@scottlinton6577 Well he conceded three less yesterday than Varane and Martinez did against City last season. Do you not know how numbers work?

  • @CizzuCizzu
    @CizzuCizzu Před 5 měsíci

    What is the name of that application with the tactical board?

  • @ahameed4801
    @ahameed4801 Před 6 měsíci +1

    I think cameraman wants some of that tea ( Coffee) as well 😅
    With focusing everytime on JJ whenever he has a sip

  • @SLM3573
    @SLM3573 Před 6 měsíci +19

    when you look at a back 4 of Dalot, Evans, Maguire and Lindelof even Crystal Palace have a better backline. Someone needs to go having spent over a billion and thats your options.

    • @Mopark25
      @Mopark25 Před 6 měsíci

      All 3 LBs and 2 starting CBs are injured, who could have predicted that?

  • @lorenzomartinez8543
    @lorenzomartinez8543 Před 6 měsíci +6

    The question everyone's been asking!

  • @chaikhor
    @chaikhor Před 6 měsíci

    Where is the new Tifo podcast and how can I access it? Someone please advise.

  • @LuisFernandez-dz7ms
    @LuisFernandez-dz7ms Před 6 měsíci

    If he wants to play this way he should switch to a back 5 it will give us more balance while still squeezing the right areas with overloads to win the ball high

  • @hipstr_t
    @hipstr_t Před 6 měsíci +39

    As a Spurs fan, I can truly say that purely transitional football seldom works over long periods. Listening to the analysis in this video reminds me of the time we played under Mourinho and Conte. They largely supplied the structure out of possession but relied on individual quality in the final third to score goals. This is reliant on your forwards to maintain form throughout a season (which rarely happens) and for your defense to be rock solid (which United doesn't possess). Especially for a club as big as United, it's absolutely ludicrous that they don't employ a coach that tries to dictate the game and play possession based football. If their goal is to win leagues, ETH isn't the man.

    • @vitaminamulti
      @vitaminamulti Před 6 měsíci +4

      Without good eggs, no chef can make a good omelette. The problem is the recruitment + injuries. Who is the Son and Maddison for United now? Bruno and Rashford are under performing, maybe they lack key support (ie: Shaw at LW)

    • @Bochop1
      @Bochop1 Před 6 měsíci +2

      eth has tried to play his game and the team paid consequences, we also are missing our whole bsckline

    • @rickysrighteyebrow8167
      @rickysrighteyebrow8167 Před 6 měsíci +3

      They hired ETH to do that but he doesn’t have the players throughout the team to play in that way. Go back to last season when we got thumped in the first two games. He realized that the ingredients to play in the Ajax way were not on hand and are unlikely to be anytime soon.

    • @iwantgoals1566
      @iwantgoals1566 Před 6 měsíci +6

      Exactly. This is why I hate it when top reds dismiss this kind of analysis and say only the score line matters at the end of the day. Because if we keep playing Harram football the results will run out cause the style of relying on individual brilliance is unsustainable at the end of the day. The worst thing is that it’s a former Ajax manager playing the long ball and we as United fans thought we’d finally seen the back of that.

    • @vitaminamulti
      @vitaminamulti Před 6 měsíci

      Yes, recruit the right players so we are not so reliant on Bruno and Rashford when they are not in form. @@rickysrighteyebrow8167

  • @shitvideoquality4856
    @shitvideoquality4856 Před 6 měsíci +3

    Ten Hag basically needs a new 11. I know he got his own players in. But the fundamental core of this team is still from the old. Ten Hag still literally had to rely on signings even from the Van Gaal era.

    • @optiondezzo1513
      @optiondezzo1513 Před 6 měsíci

      which is why i advocate them to offload rashford. big keystone players like that actually hold the team back from a rebuild.

  • @littlemateyfilmsltd
    @littlemateyfilmsltd Před 6 měsíci

    Nailed it 👌🏻

  • @MAYBE673
    @MAYBE673 Před 6 měsíci

    When did he say that quote mentioned at the beginning of the video??

  • @vaibhavthapliyal5234
    @vaibhavthapliyal5234 Před 6 měsíci +30

    Even if he's not able to play his fittest players, over what 1.5 years you cannot see any significant improvement in the players. You would expect that after 1.5 years the current players would start playing like that ajax side a bit or have some change in the playstyle.

    • @InsideManUtdPod
      @InsideManUtdPod Před 6 měsíci +20

      Last year Rashford, Shaw, AWB had massive improvement in their performance. What are you talking about?

    • @n0body550
      @n0body550 Před 6 měsíci +16

      @@InsideManUtdPodhe’s just one of those, “i only have opinions based on the scores i see” type people

    • @Brickhazard
      @Brickhazard Před 6 měsíci +9

      All the players he has to play that style are all bloody injured that's why.

    • @Doweyyy
      @Doweyyy Před 6 měsíci +3

      This is relatively hard to disagree with!

    • @phightinphil25
      @phightinphil25 Před 6 měsíci +3

      10 matches isn't close to a half year, ignoring the improvement from Rashford, Dalot, and AWB last year.

  • @akamiguelsanchez9985
    @akamiguelsanchez9985 Před 6 měsíci +24

    Let’s be honest; they sit deep and lump it

  • @gaba9ool
    @gaba9ool Před 6 měsíci +1

    i think ten hag needs time, more signings and also that the injury troubles cannot be ignored. once martinez and varane are back i think well look better. but idk if thats just blind optimism.

  • @theoraexplora
    @theoraexplora Před 6 měsíci

    18:30 EtH needs players OUT more than he needs them IN; of course he reverted to how former managers played, he has the same players those managers had. it's not about who is brought in, it's about the relationship between who is brought in and who is removed - and that is up to the board/owners/financial decision makers. Mount is the player who should've been in the McTominay position (high pressing chance creator), but has had to be a back up to the ball progressor and possession holding and wing roles due to lack of options (whether through injury, fitness, or off-field issues).

  • @sujayshetty3158
    @sujayshetty3158 Před 6 měsíci +3

    Against the bigger teams Ten Hag's Ajax always played with a counter attacking setup. The trouble for Ten Hag is that in the Premier League almost all the teams play at a higher level than the Dutch teams and hence why he sets up his United team to play how the Ajax team played the "bigger" teams.

  • @bungaIowbill
    @bungaIowbill Před 6 měsíci +20

    It's just a bad season. Ten Hag's the man for the job. 👍

  • @horriblelittlegoblin
    @horriblelittlegoblin Před 6 měsíci +1

    Great point by Jon at the end - the insistence on top 4 every season is a major factor in Utd's repeated failure culture. Managers need a few seasons to create something stable, especially in the shadow of SAF, and immediately sacking them as soon as they finish 5th provides no chance for that and enforces short-termism in tactics & manager planning. It's a point nobody seems to notice as we all buy into the whole absurd idea that finishing outside the top 4 even once is unacceptable

  • @visanion1361
    @visanion1361 Před 6 měsíci

    With the way our defense is at the moment.....it could have been worse.....we basically have our best cb is a coach....a semi retired ex player is our best cb at the moment.....he should have played Lindelof at cb and a winger at rb.....or 3 at the back....3 cb.....but if one gets injured of them then were really in the mud....its nor Ten Hags fault....its a combination of injuries and bad recruiting...
    .blaming Ten Hag is the worst thing we could do....when the man had a fully fit team he delivered and we even beat a full City team even stronger than the one this year.....

  • @alexg3228
    @alexg3228 Před 6 měsíci +3

    What you expect from Erik ten hak, his knowledge of football is to that level only. Compare with pep guardiola, jogen klopp, and others he is miles behind. You sign cheap manager you received cheap result.

  • @JamailvanWestering
    @JamailvanWestering Před 6 měsíci +16

    Trying to fix a broken team with injuries and a squad that’s out of balance.
    The center back he wanted didn’t come, both Lindelof and Maguire are far too unreliable (he wanted to get rid of Maguire, but wasn’t allowed to by management) with Martinez still being injured, Varane being injury prone as hell.
    Both Shaw and Dalot not quite in form (especially Dalot) Scott often having moments of brilliance followed up by a mistake
    Mount, Casemiro and Eriksen having a form crisis to boot.
    The whole Sancho debacle (who has trouble performing ever since he joined United) he already personal issues at Dortmund like this. (At this point the issue solely falls on the player)
    Having an untested #9 as a striker with a youth player as their sole back up,
    All and all their isn’t much ETH can do.
    You can’t fix a team if 1 half understands what the manager wants and expects but the other half doesn’t understand

    • @hzg4013
      @hzg4013 Před 6 měsíci

      I don't think so mate, see how much money he has already spent on the transfer market

    • @mejustme-12321
      @mejustme-12321 Před 6 měsíci +1

      eth spent a good amount of money in the market but they aren't even the right players.

    • @TheMixCurator
      @TheMixCurator Před 6 měsíci +3

      It was well known that Varane had injury problems before his transfer from Real Madrid, but yet they still pursued the signing.
      How Real Madrid also made a 50 million profit on the sale of Casemiro, who's past 30 was another bad transfer for Man Utd.
      The recruitment has been terrible at Man Utd - when was the last time a purchase has actually done well?
      They've needed to get rid of dead wood, but have been unable to. Why is Martial still there? Why did they buy Antony? Why has Sanchez gone from being the youngest Bundesliga player to register 50 assists now look like he's forgotten how to play football? Ericksen has no motivation and has been another poor purchase. Why did they sign Mason Mount?
      The list seems endless, and it does remind me of Liverpool in the Souness/90s era.
      Speaking of Liverpool, I also seem to recall that Liverpool had an injury crisis in their title defence, but were mocked mercilessly for it by rival supporters.

    • @JamailvanWestering
      @JamailvanWestering Před 6 měsíci +1

      @@hzg4013 when you still have so much dead wood on the team, spending that amount of money doesn’t matter. Since it’s still a fractured team with no vision.

    • @JamailvanWestering
      @JamailvanWestering Před 6 měsíci +1

      @@mejustme-12321 most of the players he signed fit perfectly into his system. It’s just there’s still so much dead wood from managers with vastly different tactics that they don’t really understand what he expects from them. Because it’s not in their wheelhouse

  • @vrajpatel3211
    @vrajpatel3211 Před 6 měsíci

    The gap between defence and attack will always going to be problem against team like manchester city as high press can't get though because there in to transition possible in mid which is quite worst part of this system they need big change if they want to be back as big as there history

  • @LeeHusk19
    @LeeHusk19 Před 6 měsíci +1

    For me the biggest problem with this team is that none of our midfielders want to play in the center of the pitch. The gap between the defenders and attackers is always massive and nobody moves to create angles for passes, there’s only ever one good passing option and it’s so predictable that teams trap us or push us back to Onana.
    Casemiro - likes to be between defenders or in the opposition box
    McTominay - likes to play in the half spaces
    Fernandes/Mount/Hannibal - attacking third half spaces
    Erickson - half spaces in defensive third or attacking third
    Even Amrabat avoids central positions.
    We desperately need a Carrick in the middle of the pitch who is happy to play in the centre circle, link play and break down attacks. Fred was the only player who naturally did this and he hasn’t been replaced. Fingers crossed Mainoo can fill this void…

  • @matthartshorn9483
    @matthartshorn9483 Před 6 měsíci +4

    Last season everyone went on and on about the midfield and attack having too much gap. They blamed it on personnel....looks to me ten hag is coaching it.

    • @Vipox92
      @Vipox92 Před 6 měsíci

      Exactly, I think the players are doing exactly what he wants them to do

    • @Mopark25
      @Mopark25 Před 6 měsíci

      The personnel are injured 🙄

  • @SLSAMG
    @SLSAMG Před 6 měsíci +3

    Self sabotage. He's now fully aware the club is rotten. Pep rejected a role in the past, as did Klopp, because they both knew it was a poison chalice.

  • @theoraexplora
    @theoraexplora Před 6 měsíci

    the initial point The Dog made about the "really good coaches making it look like they have more in attack and in defence" in a section titled Individual Brilliance vs Structural Success is ridiculous given that United's structure is being affected by injuries. his "structure" requires that transition moment we saw to have a fullback and a midfielder sprinting up to create a 3-1-6 when the pressing 4 win the ball high cuz that creates opportunities to win the ball over and over in the final third and craft chance after chance; but you can't do that with Casemiro/Eriksen on the pitch and can't do that if you only have 2 fullbacks available. he needs to be able to do that until a goal is achieved and also have the option of taking a tired fullback and midfielder off for an equal quality replacement (AWB and Shaw being injured causes this problem) and have a member of the pressing 4 taken off to reset into the 3-2-3-2/situational 3-1-6 (fewer problems here with Mount and Amrabat back playing regularly, form is the bigger issue). EtH needs to be able to make 3 equal quality changes per game at FB-CM-pressing unit and currently can't

  • @Yewbzee
    @Yewbzee Před 6 měsíci

    Great analysis fellas but with a back four of Lindelof, Evans, Maguire and Dalot you could put Accrington Stanley on the strategy board and they’d struggle against them in the same way.
    ETH is baffling at the moment.

    • @manniking233
      @manniking233 Před 6 měsíci +1

      You DO realize our defence has been wiped out by injuries, right? Opposing fans make me sick! 😡🤦🏿‍♂️

  • @iiNeedSkins
    @iiNeedSkins Před 6 měsíci +19

    He is missing his entire backline, the effect this has cannot be overstated.

    • @Joe-og6br
      @Joe-og6br Před 6 měsíci +15

      Yes but people have articles to write and videos to make.

    • @kukunase1686
      @kukunase1686 Před 6 měsíci +2

      thats an excuse

    • @levVXO
      @levVXO Před 6 měsíci +2

      @@kukunase1686 the entire core of the previous season was made upon degea shaw awb martinez varane
      how is that an excuse.

    • @meep6188
      @meep6188 Před 6 měsíci +3

      ​@levVXO the entire team trains together. Theoretically the backup players should know what the rest of the team is trying to do. Besides, the team doesn't only struggle in defense, the attack is putrid. We have all his preferred attackers and they can barely manage a goal

    • @iiNeedSkins
      @iiNeedSkins Před 6 měsíci

      @@kukunase1686 Well, sure. But reasons are important, how else can they be addressed?

  • @Michael.Koulibaly
    @Michael.Koulibaly Před 6 měsíci +8

    I've never seen a manger refer EXCLUSIVELY to the club's past success as a his reference for how to shape his team tactically. Ten Hag earned his success, reputation and job at Man Utd based on the football he played at Ajax. Now he's saying he wants to be the best transitional team, wants to play according to the clubs past of fast counter attacks and that he'll never play the way he played at Ajax. He's betrayed his identity, and that rarely works anywhere in life, not just football.

    • @n0body550
      @n0body550 Před 6 měsíci +4

      How he played at ajax isn’t an identity, its a philosophy, and philosophies on football constantly change. Dont speak wen you know absolutely nothing.

    • @Michael.Koulibaly
      @Michael.Koulibaly Před 6 měsíci +7

      @@n0body550 Mate, please argue more respectfully. Philosophy and identity are intertwined because a coach's philosophy influences his teams identity. For example: Klopp’s philosophy of "Heavy metal football" means their tactical identity is one of aggressiveness with and without the ball, and coaches often say "This is who we are, and this is how we play". That's identity. You can identify a manager and his team simply by how they play. But this is all irrelevant in the point I was making anyway.

    • @n0body550
      @n0body550 Před 6 měsíci

      @@Michael.Koulibaly From Ten hags own mouth his philosophy/identity is one of past man u teams, and if that isn’t noticeable, then the players are to blame for being braindead children who just dont want to work, and it’ll be the same regardless of any manager

  • @chibbyranjo
    @chibbyranjo Před 6 měsíci

    In the summer there was talk of advancing to a six-up-top system, which is an increase in the pressing group of 50%. That relies on the remaining defensive unit being stable. He clearly does not trust his defence, as much as he tries to voice that he trusts the players. Would he trust his first-choice defenders? He doesn’t currently have them. So he surrenders those extra two pressing players and puts them in front of his unfavored back four. His tactical ideas are entirely undermined. He can’t commit to anything with essentially a first choice back four being out injured. He’s stemming bleeding. Badly. But trying to all the same.

  • @acceleretron4475
    @acceleretron4475 Před 6 měsíci

    I agree with some analyst. It's not about Luke Shaw or AWB. It's about the structure. Man Utd should maintain the same structure in and out of possession. When out of possession the fullback should go up front pressing the wing area of the opp. Thus maintaining the narrowness like you guys said. And the rest is just coordination.

  • @_DioBrando_
    @_DioBrando_ Před 6 měsíci +8

    He's trying to pretend to be a good coach. 😂

  • @MelonGearSolid
    @MelonGearSolid Před 6 měsíci +8

    Without watching the video: he's trying to get his first eleven sorted with no injuries.

  • @maxipaxi6338
    @maxipaxi6338 Před 6 měsíci

    What kind of software is it?

  • @JKS323
    @JKS323 Před 6 měsíci +1

    I can’t think of a perfect video title!

  • @lamestreammedia3154
    @lamestreammedia3154 Před 6 měsíci +7

    Amrabat out McDonut in. Insane.

    • @drex5160
      @drex5160 Před 6 měsíci +8

      McDonut is ironically their most prolific player right now and had a good shot saved in the first half. Should have kept the same midfield for the 2nd half and they might have knicked a draw.

  • @rickysrighteyebrow8167
    @rickysrighteyebrow8167 Před 6 měsíci +3

    Let’s see how other teams play without their first choice defense and their most important midfielder out.

  • @amronpimpinan
    @amronpimpinan Před 6 měsíci +1

    So, High press with low defensive line? Well, I would never try that in fm

  • @jedsithor
    @jedsithor Před 6 měsíci +2

    Ole played counter attacking because he had to. He tried to make United a more front foot team that would be aggressive in midfield and play with a higher defensive line but to do that he needed to be able to bring in more than the 3 big signings per summer mandated by the Glazers.
    Had Ole gotten his way, his team would have been something like:
    De Gea
    Wan Bissaka Varane Maguire Shaw
    Rice
    Bruno Caicedo
    Sancho Haaland Rashford
    haaland, Caicedo and Rice were three players he wanted. The Ronaldo deal meant there was no chance of Haaland, the United scouts didn't like Caicedo and the plan was to go for Rice the following summer, forcing Ole to make do with Fred, McTominay and Matic for another season. It's also possible that Maguire and De Gea would have eventually been replaced.
    Of course in the end, Ole lost his job. Ten Hag brought in Martinez, Casemiro and Antony, 3 major signings plus Malacia as a back up. This season, again, 3 major signings in Mount, Onana and Hojlund. Of those 3, I suspect only Onana was first choice. It's well known he wanted Kane and spent the summer last year pursuing De Jong.
    Everything at United is done in bits and pieces when what's been needed for years is a wholesale restructuring of the squad. Three major signings every summer is fine if you're just adding to a settled team but when the team need 6 or 7 new players, spreading it out over multiple years is hurting United because whoever the manager is ends up being stuck playing players that don't match their vision and you have too many square pegs in round holes.

    • @optiondezzo1513
      @optiondezzo1513 Před 6 měsíci

      man utd will always be on the backfoot and be years behind the top 5 because they do not have more money to spend as the glazers do not inject more funds into the club. man utd's transfer coffers have always been generated by its own financial turnovers and bank loans (which has resulted in them be 1B in debt). the dividends they pay to the glazers every year since their takeover is equal to one new signing to the club and its been going on for over a decade.
      so here we see a man utd team totally spent and totally lacking depth to compete in the modern game, let alone the EPL which has progress tremendously the past 5 years. man utd as a club are still stuck in the early 2000s.
      man utd's eventual decline will be a sharp drop off. serious football observers will not be surprised if they start battling relegation eventually.

    • @manniking233
      @manniking233 Před 6 měsíci +1

      Preach!

  • @thecountofmontecristo8280
    @thecountofmontecristo8280 Před 6 měsíci +3

    Ten Haag has bought a lot of ex-Ajax players. There really is no excuse for why he can't play the Ajax way. In less time and having bought only 3 starting players for comparatively very little money, Ange Postecoglou has achieved an Ajax style at Tottenham this season. No one should be buying what he is selling.

  • @applesoranges559
    @applesoranges559 Před 6 měsíci +3

    Ole Gunnar Solskjær got MUCH better results than Ten Hag with a MUCH much weaker personel against big teams ... Forget City, Ten Hag just keeps on continually getting literally SCHOOLED by ANY half decent footballing team n Mark blew him up so much at the time of bringing him in constantly with that Ajax domination football, thinking they are about to bring in that constant Jurgen Klopp fantasy right from the Ragnick days, that ETH is ROYALLY getting miserably found out, in over n out of his depths ... n yet back in the day wen United were winning trophies with Sir Alex then nobody gave a peep about the Glazers then ... A 6 year old child can see right thru the utter double standards building here n blame the Glazers, Harry McGuire, The Referees, the British Media, The Club's pantry, Their transport services .... Everything n every1 apart from this truly incompetent Manager right at the forefront of it with all the footballing decisions n power 💯 ..

    • @manniking233
      @manniking233 Před 6 měsíci

      Typical Anglophile who'll be real quiet, once Gary Neville or Carrick is hired as manager. Smh. Keep it up, though. Your nation needs you...

  • @adiathama9425
    @adiathama9425 Před 6 měsíci

    Suspect something non technical issues have been going on in utd this season .. warrior full of spirit will not combat the way they did

  • @Irfan87
    @Irfan87 Před 6 měsíci +2

    It's strange to me that injuries is an excuse that isn't afforded for Man Utd, but Chelsea, Liverpool and Arsenal were given that benefit of the doubt. Not having a consistent back 4 is really disruptive as the previously mentioned teams have experienced.

    • @harukrentz435
      @harukrentz435 Před 6 měsíci +1

      our injury problem is the defense, but our biggest problem is in the attack we barely score goal. injuries shouldnt be excuse.

    • @manniking233
      @manniking233 Před 6 měsíci +1

      Yup. Opponents hate us so much and the media are aggressively trying to bury Erik Ten Hag, so no circumspect judgement is being applied at all. They see the scoreline and leap into action. Smh.