The Factory Model of Schooling: A Critique of Our Schools
Vložit
- čas přidán 3. 10. 2021
- An effort to understand the inherent flaws in our schooling system which halts all creativity in children. No comprehensive solution provided. Why? because the greatest problem is to be unaware of the problem. If we truly contemplate the problem, solution isn't farfetched.
#pakistanischools #indianschools
My dad was a teacher, and I never had vacations because we would study all summer. When I was in third grade, one of his friends wanted his son to have tuition with me. My father didn’t want to say no, but the guy sent his kid over the next day anyway. My dad's strategy was to make the kid stop coming over for the studies. So on the first day, for my minor spelling mistake, my father beat me so harshly that the other kid got scared and never came back. Later, the kid told everyone at school what happened. I still remember feeling teary in front of my friends while saying it was no big deal.
When I finished sixth grade, my dad wanted me to join his 10th-grade math private tuition classes. I had no idea what I was learning, so I just complied with whatever he asked me to do. One day, he gave a problem to the whole class to solve, and later asked me to show if I had the solution. I had nothing written down, as it was only my second or third day in the middle of the syllabus he was teaching. Next thing, he slapped me so hard…. I almost fell on the floor. The scar still remains with me to this day. I studied the whole night that day just to prepare in advance, whatever math problem he could give me, ofc just to avoid getting embarrassed again. The next day, as I predicted, he called me to check whether I solved the problem this time. Too bad for him..I already had it solved. He was amused that I was able to get it done, only to shamelessly take the credit for my hard work and to justify that the beating was necessary.
There are many other incidents like these, but in summary, I was always a dummy for him to hit and to set example by putting fear in others. I live a better life now and make good money, but every now and then I wake up in the middle of the night from a dream where he was physically and verbally abusing me. I’m over 30 now, and I haven’t contacted him in the last 10 years. We always talk about men committing crimes against women, but we rarely talk about men committing crimes against men. The amount of control, manipulation, and abuse I have gone through, I doubt many would have survived. There is nothing worse than growing up feeling that you’re the reason why your parents don’t love you, and it's embarrassing to talk about - you feel alone. I turned out to be a stronger version of me who started resistance against him since I hit puberty. I took life decisions on my own and gained financial independence from him - just to move far far away from him where he can’t reach me.
Edit: He died in 2022. A part of me is relieved.
feeling for you. very sorry.
👍
Man...this was touchy....God bless u..
Ohhh man I am so sorry.
This is a lesson for all us young fathers to always uplift our kids even when they fail in something and let them follow their passion.
Please join ALOA course. You will certainly come out of this situation.
Your 10 minutes video teaches me more than what I have learnt in my entire educational career.
Hats off to you man!
100%
🤣🤣🤣🤣Nailed it
❤
"The best brains of the nation may found on the last benches of the classroom. " Dr. APJ Abdul kalam
It may be because back benchers are less motivated by schools discipline.
Now In India there are many schools which are totally based on process of learning.
I have been a backbencher all my school life, most of my backbencher friends aren't doing good compared to others
@@civilmonk1166 fees kitni lete he!
@@prashantp2029 Have you read Give and Take by Adam grant.
@@nileshk1455 What's is this?
Another High IQ video from you sir. I never realized how much we are brainwashed since childhood into thinking the school system is educating us. Respect from India!
@Truly Indian nope not all of us are radicals .We are in minority but we do exist
U promoting... redical by ur account..
Please don't forget We are same and equal in IND
Guys he is talking about brainwashing in name of education in schools. We are brainwashed to think that remembering and rote learning fates and formula makes us educated. No one is questioning Indian-ness of anyone.
I have studied MSc Chemistry but I call myself programmer because programming is my passion.
I proudly call myself programmer and I learnt it all by myself. I developed many web and desktop applications.
I don't know anything about chemistry which I studied in 16 years. Lol 😀
you should be proud of what you have achieved on your own, kudos to you
I am Also a full stack developer at 16 and i learned everything by myself..
@Aisha i Can help!
Very encouraging to read this. The feelimg one gets to do what they like to do is our of this world.
czcams.com/video/qF3ZVrzAcfI/video.html
The best sentence after watching your beautiful lecture on education.
علم بڑی دولت ہے. یقین نہ آئے تو اسکول مالکان سے پوچھ لو..
This is how our education system works
One of the best episodes... Sadly. it happening all over third world countries ...🤥😌😔😪😪
All over the world.
Now india have better situation now.teacher cannot beat student.
Carl Sagan was one of the most treasured gems of humanity. The man spent his life teaching people to be curious and question things.
Bro where i can get introduced to carl '
He was a jew.
My favorite astronomer forever 💓
@@autumnspring3480 so, what's your point?
@@autumnspring3480 he was a Jew. What then? Don't show your ignorance here you antihuman cult follower some call Islam. Plus he was an agnostic as far as I know.
वाह भाई 👌👌👌
क्या बात कही है,
Love❤ you Bhai
I am from Mumbai🇮🇳
Ye btana zarore hain ? I am from ....
@@pakhtosongs हा जरूरी है भाई,
हम इंडिया के लोगो की खासियत है के पाकिस्तान की गंदगी का पर्दा फ़ास करे हम उनका ही वीडियो देखा करते है, ताकि हम को अंदाज़ लगता रहे के पाकिस्तान के हालत कैसे है
@@madhusthanvi2554
Don't criticize anyone... Let it be, they know their situation much better.
I am also from Mumbai 😁
@@pakhtosongs
Yes... Cz we are proud from where we are.
So many pakistani people claim to be an Indian when they are in foreign countries. Why?? Cz they know the importance of the name of place one belongs to
Infact, Socratic method of dialogue is seems to be more pragmatic way of learning than our models of schooling
Socrat was a very intelligent philosopher of Greece. Sir do you know where philosophy 1st originated?
@@fahadpapoo6652 Philosophy has existed ever since man started pondering about his existence and his place in the universe. But to answer your question, western philosophy as it is classified as was first recorded in Miletus, and Thales is considered to be one of the pioneers. However, Ionians also inherited their school of thought from early civilizations of the fertile crescent.
It's even more fun to be honest
Excuse me, that way of dialogue is the possible/probable best way to get knowledge on higher levels.
@@fahadpapoo6652
1st philosophy originated through Hazrat Adam (as)
Finally someone exposing mafia schools in pakistan.
but as always nobody will do anything about it
His lectures are way way better then my entire schooling colleges and universities more power to you man ❤️
This video taught me more than my combined school and college studies. Thank You Muzammil bhai keep it up! Keep educating us.
I have four years degree in Plant Sciences but i am earning from E-commerce. Now, i know nothing about plants but proudly I am running a successful online business.
You are 💯 right and I can say that schooling is just for middle and poor class . I have spent years in boarding institutes and just want to say that boarding institutes are hell on earth.
In Finland, they start with only 20 hours a week school for 1st graders and gradually when kids go high up the number of hours of schooling per week start increasing. but nonetheless school hours in Finland in general are less than any other country in the world.
I don't generally comment on videos but man after watching just 3 mins of your video you really won my 💖. I must tell you every word you said is 💯 % relevant as an Indian
@@rashedchouhan Agreed there's no implementation of that law
@Mayur Kanth Dhruv rathee is generally right but sometimes he puts all the blame on Right wing where we can clearly sees radical Islamists are wrong as well .On the other hand Muzammil condemns all sort of extremism
Pakistani schools need to focus less on nails ,hair styles and uniform and dress codes .Focus more on education
Tea is Fantastic
Bewakoof nails saf rakhna nisf eman hai, aur especially larkiyo ne nais saf honey chahiyah because in nails say larkiyah pepsi aur 7up ke cans ke dhakan aram se kholti hein jo mujh say nahi kholtey.
I still remember when I was disrespected and scolded by a teacher for not cutting nails on one day. Before that I used to cut my nails regularly. And about hair we can't even use different colour hair band we can only black or white. And the girls who don't follow any command from the list of rules, she is scolded by every subject teacher
@@fahadpapoo6652 bro is this sarcasm or are u really serious
@@fatimahusayn they should not disrespect kids for these things at least .I am in favour of school uniforms but i never get the concept of hairstyles and nails I mean i agree school uniforms should be proper but whats up with obsession with hair styles ?
@Aisha I'll instruct my daughter to slap her back if that ever happens to her. Nobody will be allowed to touch my child and get away with it.
U are absolutely right Syed Muzammil sahab u are great love from india ❤️
Finally someone said it. I have no words to express how hurt I felt in my school. Insan nai janwar mile hn school me bas.
Hurt? By National anthem or being obedient?
Universities m hstl life m is se bre drinde hai
Thank you Syed Muzaammil for raising this topic. But unfortunately to find a better course of action, it may take us ages. I have tried to work with many parents to help them change their thought process but have always found them to be so strongly tied up with the invisible shackles of the factory model and that uniformity that you talked about we have been brainwashed to accept unquestionably. Hope things may change if not in our lifetime then in the times of our coming generations! Thanks
Puri duniya yeh sab hai kash tohr eroupe mein ladkiya tissuhy paper tarah istemaal hoti hai
Only Two persons in Pakistan Dr Pervez Hodbye and Sayed sab
Parvez hoodbooy should focus only on physics that would make him really better
@@mathsmanic930 Dr Pervez achieved more in physics more than any Pakistani Physest He is a brave man He don't afraid from Pakistani Extremists and relegion fundamentalists Pakistan need people like Dr Pervez and Sayed like brave personalities
@@aisamzia7045 oye chal be liberal saale spelling theek kr ke aa pehle
@@computerist....... Mamo Barak ghaya😂😂😂😂
@@aisamzia7045 chal pehle school jaa phir likhna lol
Sir big fan from India. You should also know what they do in Kota (Rajasthan). Prisoners in North Korea are treated better than students are treated in Kota.
Where do u live??
Kya bakwas h..kon kahta h unhe kota jaao..
Kota is a Choice not Compulsory
@@ParacetamolEdits you're in a fool's world, if you believe for middle class in India, it is a choice for Indian students to be in the rat race! Everybody spawns in this pubg in this part of the world just so one day he can be a slave for the western monopoly!
Bhai apne baap se bolo lund main nahi karna iit aur paise bacha lo apne
I just remembered my school days. and this guy 110% correct.
I wished youtube had option of 1000 likes or more......
Love the sarcastic humour of this guy ..how much awaken and enlightened he is
Love and respect you sir from India. It's the same situation in India also
Absolutely thought provoking content bro...Plz bring up more such topics with their sociological backgrounds.. it would be great if you also discuss some alternative solutions too.... Salute to your rationality based mindset although very rare in my neighborhood ....regards from india🇮🇳❤️
Thank you for love and appreciation although very rare in my neighborhood, love from Pakistan 🇵🇰❤️
@@AbdulSamad-yv9tq Try to open a school that doesn't teach minority hatred and religious radicalization..then it wouldn't be so rare bro😊
boss you are 10000 percent right I still remember this when I was in 8 th class still the time has passed I was 14 years old now I am 30
years old still I remember that day . It can not be removed from my soul
One of the few true Pakistani i know🇵🇰i wish every Muslim was rational like you and every Pakistani was patriotic and loyal like you💙
@Aisha Thanks for asking and poking at the hypocrisy of Majeed's comment!
@Aisha with due respect, where did i say he is a Muslim? I dont give a fuck to such things... I said i just wish Muslims were like him...🙏
@Aisha 💙🙂
@@majeedalee9609 👍👍
he is not a muslim, i can see Christopher hitchens hanging in the background. its an individual choice, must be respected
Same story here in India. Free thinking and Scepticism are discouraged whereas Factory schools are norms of the society.
Hello Eric 👋🏻
@@confirmjannati hello jannati Saheb 👋
I wish India could revive its ancient method of teaching in which Teachers acted only as guide not as an instructor, the learning was based on interaction, debate and discussion, Students were given time to come up with the solution on their own rather than giving them the existing solution. which produced legends like Aryabhatt, Varahmihir, Bhaskar, Chanakya, Kalidas etc.
Great work. Peoples like u r real gems 💎. Love n respect 🙏.
Dear muzammil, thank you for speaking up. A commendable effort indeed!
Early 2020, a science competition took place in a South Korean primary school (if I remember correctly ). A kids group from grade 6 won it by developing a robot that assisted school kids in sanitizing their hands whenever they required. Imagine; grade 6 kids.
I watch all your videos and you inspire me alot. I've always been a creative child, was always daydreaming in class. I liked to draw a lot I never did my homework for which I always got in trouble for and was also a below average student. I never let school interfere with my love for arts and I surprised everyone with this talent when I was in grade 7 and I even made a portrait of my school principal which he hung up on the wall in his office. But it's difficult to continue while studying.
His videos are like a breath of fresh air 😇🍃
Muzammil Sir, you are the only person in Pakistan I have ever seen who raises such huge issues. Here I'm writing not about this particular issue, but your overall effort. At first I doubted whatever you said in your videos, thinking are things this much bad, or is this person exaggerating conditions just for the sake of popularity. Though I am not very educated and not critical thinker, but after much, much thought, I realized that whatever you were saying is true. And everyone can understand you, there is no need of any rocket science to understand what you are saying.
But, I cannot help it but become sad after watching each of your videos because all address very bad almost hopeless issues. This gives an overall negative tone to your videos. My humble request is that though there are many problems in this country, but we still have a lot to celebrate. From the city of lights, to Gwadar's potential, to Balochi culture, to Punjab, heart of Pakistan Lahore, The Capital city, to poets, to our legends, to the amazing fairylands of Gilgit Baltistan, to the huge Mountains, to our sports everything..So if ever you set eyes on this comment I request you to also make videos about the good things, and the other side of the coin. I am sure you have also a thousands of content about the good things. I don't want to see you become just symbol of sad news. You are the finest critic of our land. You are legend and we really want you as an all round leader.
Janaab, kabhi mera dore Khukamat huwa toh apneh ko vela rakna, INSHALLAH :)
Awesome! Unfortunately except for a very few schools, majority of schools also follow similar procedure. One thing which is nowadays changing in india is that parents are allowing kids to follow their passion like sports, arts, music etc. But long way to go. Regards, Sriram from Chennai, india
My nana couldn't read or write apart from Arabic Qura'an, but I'd never seen a more educated man than him. I'm proud to say that he disliked Zia and PTV back then and believed that it controlled our minds. He was called 'run mureed' because he never stopped his wife and daughters do whatever they wanted. He let his sons choose their own way of living. Same goes with my dada who studied till 3rd standard.
P.s. My father is so called educated and he's my father, but a very autocratic person. Aur rehti sehti kasar A*my nay nikal di 🤣
I dont think so that you can become a good human by reading math formulas and physics laws.
@@sanaullahfarooq5527 A creative person is more sensitive than a usual human 😉
@@samiaarif3008 I did not meant that, I edited my comment.
@@samiaarif3008 Pakistanis before zia's era were much better and were less radicalized .
I m very good at exploring theories , philosophies , logical analysing and critical thinking but beaten by this society I m a medical student now . Never find interest in these books but when learning social subjects I usually spend hours without knowing.
Same here bhai.
I felt proud to have a taste of watching your videos....or to digest the intellect that you share at this platform. I feel there is a % of people in our society who is not ready to learn out of the box things.
I studied so hard throughout my life. I never miss my Metric ,FSc days when i have to study alotttt to get into university...and even during university one gets through alot of competition and stuff....and now Career making process..uff.... everything is so messed up.
Sir you put into words what few awakened pakistanis only think. I wish your voice is heard far and wide. Today our youngsters idealize those so-called influencers who shamelessly use foul language and create bsolutely absurd content. I sincerely pray may you and people who think like you become the most admired, inspired and idealized youtubers in our country. Amen.
Syed Muzammil you're becoming day by day very popular in Pakistan.
You are absolutely right brother because i always humiliate in the class due to one certain subject and they always remind me that i am dumb and now i have pain in my heart and one day i showed them that each person has its own abilities and what a person can do
Wow, great food for thought, time to open our hearts and mind think critically :)
Zindabad Jawan Zindabad.
Very appreciative and enlighten explanation. I am feeling very proud to listen you about extreme revolution and Azad thought. Your each word impress me alot and put light in my mind.
Schools are making modern day slaves and Parents are taking active parts in it. Very few parents will stand for their kids but the rest will always be a Yes man to this authority.
Well bro, no doubt we are producing better slaves for our future generations.
Waahhh bhai dil ko chuun liye ....love you bro ❤️....love from india🇮🇳🇮🇳
Amazing sir .... I am always arguing with my family on this topic.... But they all are brainwashed 😢
Same school but different approach!!
Our school teachers taught us that learn all the subjects including drawing/painting so later you know what interests you n accordingly you can choose your career.
My brother and me would do paintings, artwork after we finished our school homework. Still my brother do paintings n I do rangolis.
The reason is we focused on career as well as our interests ; we are blessed with supportive parents and teachers.
We did got bashed by our Chacha but it didn't left any scar cz we knew it's for our good.
I think no heavy loads of studies and open atmosphere to pursue the interests is the key to success.
My brother is a Marine Engineer now. Our youngest brother left chemical engineering in last year and did Hotel Management.
But I don't believe that everyone should have same thinking as ours.
We do need some different curriculum to understand the child's natural inclination so they focus on that very subject n get success through it😊
I always was a creative thinker and curious learner. whenever I used to use my own sense to write an essay or answer, my teachers often scolded or beat me, because they wanted me to memorize what they had provided in the notes. Your video is reflective of this sad reality.
Love and Respect for such a brilliant mindset.
We as a nation are facing such issues. We need you to lead a compaign. We are generating extremist mentality and people like Zahid Hamid and Shaheer Sialvi are becomming mentors of this lame nation. Step a little forward to lead the directionless masses and set a direction for them we would stand with you. This is a candle we can light.
میری تعلیم کو مسلسل چودہ سال ہو گئے ہیں اور میں نے آج تک اپنے کلاس سے کچھ نہیں سیکھا۔ میں نے جو کچھ سیکھا ہے خود پڑھ کر سیکھا ہے اور آپ جیسے لوگوں کو سن کر سیکھا ہے۔
Same
Bhai ya to btao aapny prhna kdr sy sekhaaa.....?????
Mene zyada tar cheezein films or TV se seekhein. School to bus ek formality hai
czcams.com/video/qF3ZVrzAcfI/video.html
M uni gae shok se k boht skills r knowledge mile ga bu t kuch ni sekha even us se beter cheze to hme private college msikha di gae thi haha hmsmjte the k fazo clg hai
You damn, Fucking always Nailing it!💯🔥❤
Extremely well explained JazakAllah khairen kasira ❤
Can you please keep going
We love you from India 💕🇵🇰🇮🇳💓✌️👌
Its always great to hear your important views
So happy to see people like you still exist. Thank you Muzzamil bhai for changing our views and perspectives. Wish we can have more people like you in our society. Much love and respect.
First time i feel jalan Mr syed muzalmil sha kun kay ju main kehna chahata tha wo in kay munh say sun raha hoon God blessed you bahi
Commendable! Glad to know that the rationality still exists in the shape of individuals like you in the society we all live in.
Can't help giving a big hand for you for such a incredible, discrete, dissected, distilled, well substantiated, well argumentative, incredibly well defined, intellectually remarkable & constructively laudable analysis on such a highly debatable subject like education relating to so called Factory-model !!!
This Is Literally True, Today I Experienced Same Type Of Event It Was That Kids Were Very Uncomfortable After The Assembly Because Of Extreme Heat And Long Lecture Of Our PT Teacher So, I Pointed Sir And Said That We Should Move Because Kids Will Faint If It Continues But In Response I Was Disrespected By 90% Of Teachers For Speaking Against A Teacher, Even I Was Threatened That I Will Have To Leave School If I Do This Again. In The End I Realized There Is No Point Arguing With Them So I Apologized And Bowed In Front Of This System.
I'm Sorry 😔😔..
خدا کی قسم، آج بھی جب ان اساتذہ کو یاد کرتا ہوں تو خون کھول جاتا ہے۔ اے کاش میں تھوڑا سا بڑا ہوتا اور ان میں سے کسی کو اچھی طرح سبق سکھاتا چاہے پھر مجھے جیل ہی کیوں نا ہو جاتی۔ کوئی انتہائی بیغرت اور بے ہمیںت انسان تھے۔ خدا جانتا ہے وہ انسانوں کے لباس میں درندے تھے جنہیں صرف بچوں کو زد و کوب اور ان کی عزتِ نفس کو مجروح کرنا آتا ہے۔ ان اسکولوں نے مجھے برباد کر کے رکھ دیا ہے۔ چودہ سال تک ان اداروں میں انگریزی پڑھتا رہا لیکن انگریزی زبان میں اپنے جذبات پہنچانے سے قاصر ہوں کیونکہ اس لیول کی انگریزی ہمیں سکھائی ہی نہیں گئی۔ بچپن سے لے کر اب تک اپنے بَل پر انگریزی سیکھنے کی بہت کوشش کی ہے لیکن ناکام گیا ہوں۔ بس انگریزی کے لحاظ ہے موجیں ہیں تو صرف ان بچوں کی جنہوں نے کانوَنٹ اسکولوں میں تعلیم حاصل کی ہے۔
Should never discuss in front of kids looks bad
@@johnesa635 bahot se baap apne beto ko paltu kutte k tarah treat karte hai. Bakio ka kya kehna 😑
Public schools created in the interests of industrialization. Schools divide the curriculum into specialist segments: some teachers install math and others install history. They arrange the day into standard units of time, marked out by the ringing of bells, much like a factory announcing the beginning of the workday and the end of breaks. Students are educated in batches, according to age, as if the most important thing they have in common is their date of manufacture. They are given standardized tests at set points and compared with each other before being sent out onto the market. I realize this isn’t an exact analogy and that it ignores many of the subtleties of the system, but it is close enough. KEN ROBINSON
I had already realized in my childhood that there was something wrong with education. I was 8 years old in class 3. There was a pointless topic, a story about animals in which there was a monkey who was a musician. Whenever he played the guitar in front of anyone, they would automatically start dancing. While memorizing about 5 questions about it, I was thinking what benefit I would gain from memorizing questions about such a pointless story. If I asked any elder about something serious, I would get scolded for trying to escape from studying. Today, it has been proven that I was thinking correctly at that early age. Hats off to Muzammil bhai for raising this issue.Then, at the age of 18 after completing my intermediate education, I pursued my passion and took a 2-year multimedia course, which revealed to me that even just 2 years of learning could be very impactful, considering the wasted 18 years in so-called education. Today, I am happy to be running a department as a senior editor and animator.
What happened to me after watching this video is that these things were somewhere resting in my mind, but I never happened to express in words. You have made it simple for me and helped to me explore what was hiding inside me.
Excellent analysis! Mashallah! It breaks my heart as a teacher when I hear experiences like yours. Sadly they are all too comment across the world for exactly the reasons you have presented here. Education should open people up to what is inside them. Learning is about curiosity, questioning and pushing boundaries. Children are not empty mugs waiting for a teacher's jug to fill them up. Childhood is not just a preparation stage for adulthood but rather an important phase of human development. Your perspective is closely related to Sir Ken Robinson and Michael Fielding of England. Education is a public good and should be for itself and not to feed industry. Michel Foucault is right schools are run like prisons and this is unacceptable in the 21st C. England me bhi kuch behtar nahi hai. Aap jo kehe rehe hain woh mera mulk me bhi most logoin ko samajh nahi aata. Hum sub milkey kehe te rehain so shiyad log sooney??? Keep going, your work is important. 👏
What's ideal school then?
@@prashantp2029 Thank you for your question. This is what I think and try to do, in a restricted neoliberal system. Schools should be about fostering all kinds of talents to develop. They should be about motivating students to learn not frightening them into it. Of course, academic learning is important and should feature in any curriculum but not at the expense of computing, the arts, science, history, politics the law, human rights, the environment, business and enterprise and public services. it should encourage students to follow their natural aptitudes, encourage critically and questioning of the world as it is as this is the basis of progress and development. The memorisation of facts as a basis for education is defunct because google, the internet and technologies have made it totally unnecessary. Students don't need teachers to teach them facts anymore in a modern education system. Teachers are needed to teach young people to be confident humans that are all differently qualified to meet the challenges of the 21st C. I hope this is helpful
I was never a good boy in school days, today I am topper in my university batch in film department because it was my inner passion
I am Psychologist, mery dill ki awazzz.. We have Condtioneding Knowledge and bookss with Fear..Alas
"Jab sawal he ni ara toh jawab kahan se mily ga".. Gaves me goosebumps! Sir hats off to you ❤
Muzamil ap ki tarif ke liye ilfaz nhi hai mere pas❤️
You were narrating and exposing system meanwhile I was retrospecting my school days. I think our subcontinent has similar problems. We are all divided by boundaries but our social framework is common.
Even your old videos are fantastic, my friend. Keep on keeping up!
Simply superb. I appreciate your thoughts.
In India if u r good at school everyone advice for civil services. Even TOP IITian prefer it.
And in Pakistan people ask for CSS even he or she is doctor or engineer
I am 46 but my dad still feels the same for me.
This happened in my college a lot
They first inoculate Root learning in minds
Daily basis learn if u didn't face the torture
I have done olevels and in fsc system u can't survive neither with their system nor with the social atmosphere
😭😭😭😭 Depressed suppressed stressed Every day I am
I always tried to fight but some day u lose and on that that u face 😈😈😈😈
Sir rona atha hai aur kurtha hu es situation se guzar k aur dekh k.
Thank you so much sir for highlighting this issue!
واہ واہ جیتے رہیں شاہ صاحب
Same in india
Please make some video on partition
Giving your view
Love it.
You look good today
Very well and comprehensive explanation of conflict prespective regarding schooling system . 👌👍
God bless you, I can feel the pain you have in your words and eyes. It seems you are a soft hearted person who is still not able to forget something which happened to you way back in your school.
What else I can says apart from STAY BLESSED AND HAPPY.
Never seen such an omniscient person before in my life who explains the things in the most easiest way. Respect from India 🙏
میں کبھی سکول نہیں گیا ہوں، مگر میں نے بہت کچھ سیکھا ہے، لوگوں کا خیال ہیکہ میں بہت بڑا پڑھا لکھا بندہ ہوں لیکن حقیقت یہ ہیکہ ایک دن بھی سکول نہیں گیا، ہمارے دور میں اتنا رواج نہیں تھا اور گاؤں میں سکول بھی نہیں تھا، میرا خیال ہیکہ آج بچے سکول اس لیئے پڑھتے ہیں کہ پیسے کمائے، اور پیسے کمانے کیلئے سکول کی کوئی ضرورت نہیں ہے اس سے اچھا ہیکہ کوئی ہنر سیکھ لے، میں نے ہزاروں پڑھے لکھے بدتمیز، بدل کلام ، بدتہزیب دیکھے ہیں، جو اچھا ہے وہ بغیر ڈگری کے بھی اچھا ہے اور جو بُرا ہے وہ دس ڈگریوں کے ساتھ بُرا ہے آپ اپنے ارد گرد نظر دہرائیں۔۔۔۔
Ap ne bilkul thek kaha👍
This video just change my whole concept 🖤🖤🖤
Great job Muzammil Bhai. I myself am a teacher and i never liked this disciplined and controlled environmental so called learning. Foucault and Althusser have always been my ideals, you are a hope of ray for the youngsters. Keep doing this work.
Bravo!!! Straight from the heart!
Nice sharing dear bro keep it up
واقعی ✅🙏 سچ پر مبنی ہے۔
پہلی بار ایسی معاملات کی طرف آپ نے توجہ دیں۔ شکریہ۔ بالکل۔۔۔ یونیورسٹی کی تعلیم میں سکول وکالج کی سختی ختم اسی لئے کی جاتی ہے تاکہ آزادانہ تحقیقات کرے اور اگر ایک تحقیق میں مزا نہ آئے تو دوسرا اختیار کرے۔
میں ایک ٹیچر ہوں۔۔۔ اور ایم فل فزکس کیا۔ حال ہی میں پی ایچ ڈی ایڈمیشن کیلئے آیا تھا غلطی سے سی ایس ایس اکیڈمی میں گیا تو میری کریٹیو تھاٹ کو مار دیا کیونکہ اپنی کتاب جسکا میں ماہر ہوں اسکی وہاں حیثیت ہی نہیں رہی جسکی تحقیقات پڑھتے ہوئے مجھے مزا آتا تھا جس کتاب نے کائنات کو پرکھا جس کتاب کی ایجادات سے ہی مجھے اسی اکیڈمی کے بارے میں معلومات ہوئی تھی لیکن اب اسکی اہمیت وہاں تھی ہی نہیں اور دوسری کتابوں کو ترجیح دیتی ہے سائنسی الفاظ کی جہگہ لٹریچر کے الفاظ یاد کرنا پڑ رہا۔۔۔ بلکہ وہاں اکیڈمی کے کچھ اساتذہ تو یونیورسٹی کی تعلیم کو فرسودہ قرار دیتے ہیں اور اپنے گریجویشن لیول کی معلومات کو اعلٰی۔lol۔ انا للہ وانا الیہ راجعون
یہ بندہ تو مجھ سے بھی زیادہ تپا ہوا ہے ایجوکیشن سسٹم پہ۔۔۔
اللہ اس قوم کو عقل کرے۔
you are doing very good, brother
more power to you.
This school trauma is real. Highly intelligent, sensitive, introverted children who are different than majority, suffer profoundly. In our schools there is no proper system to distinguish kids with learning disabilities, giftedness and other neurogical differences to assist them so they lose more than normal kids. Homeschooling can be a good option to save children from rotten schooling system.
Schools are supposed to liberate and build people up instead they are hurting young minds. It is the same the world over. We should be protesting in the streets about the harm that is being done in the name of schooling!
I agree!
In my area Agosh and audassir are schools providing edu ko such children with different disabled lities
IF "KEHKR LUUGA" HAD A FACE 🤣🤣🤣😘😘😘
Excellent. Thoughts are similar to our leftists in Calcutta. In the subcontinent, schools on holistic ideas were indeed tried in "Gurukul" during Vedic period and in modern times by Kaviguru Rabindranath in Vishwabharati, Shantiniketan who never attended any school. Thanks.
You have addressed the root cause, hence the solution of majority of all problems in humankind - EDUCATION.
And, the right word, you have chosen - first time I am hearing saying it - "traumatic", indeed for a creative child. 🙏
The new look really suits you...you always look fresh, presentable and really really awesome and content is great!
Lol you are here .I am surprised you didn't said "he's handsome and intelligent 😂
@@teaisfantastic3338 i am always there in the first 3 mins of each video 😂 and i always search for "tea " or "fantastic" 😂 - no, i thought he might read my comment and i should maintain decency.....how are you doing?
@@teaisfantastic3338 he never comments on my comments :( - but i found him on gnn....he is doing a really awesome job. why does pakistan have the best anchors???
@@alkaagarwal9998 nope . Pakistan dont have best anchors . Muzammil and Shahzaib khanzada are the only two intellectuals
@@teaisfantastic3338 well i like mansoor ali khan too plus meher bukhari (she speaks too fast). in addition, some of the morning shows are nice - like one on geo where anchor is huma qureshi and abdullah. some nice content.
Well if can afford homeschool your kid , most parents cannot do that. School designed mainly as daycare place so parents can work and do other things that is demanded for a family. Learning is at home , school is just for checking on kid.
Brother love from India I was one of those animals who was not just humiliated on the name of knowledge but also subjected to harsh beating 🥺
Thanks a million Muzammil. Your videos are like a paradigm shift in thinking.
I am one of that animal from India 😀 but somehow except beating and fear part I think making children disciplined is not bad. I studied in government funded boarding and my routine was exactly the factory model except most of our teachers were very much loving and helping.
More strength and power to you Syed saab. We need your sane voice more than ever.
تعلیمی نظام پر بہت اچھا تبصرہ کیا ہے۔ مزمل صاحب نے۔جان کر اچھا لگا کہ کوئی اس طرح سے بھی سوچتا ہے۔
Today I have got to learn a lot by listening to you, I started my early education from a government school which took place in Bhopal. I used to feel very sad because I never came top in 15 year in school. But after school, when I went to university for higher education, I went there and realized that there is no point, your skills are your education. What you have read does not mean if you do not learn to use it.