Neil deGrasse Tyson on How Monster's Inc Got the 4th Dimension Right
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 02. 2017
- Neil deGrasse Tyson talks about the science inaccuracies in movies, and how Monster's Inc. got the idea of a 4th dimension right.
Taken from Joe Rogan Experience #919. - Komedie
_"love me some dimensions."_
- Kneel The Grass Tie Son
Sun* 😂
grease machine that’s his Jedi name 😜
Cosmic Donkey what’s the difference
@@yamemeguy4744
Sun: as in the flaming ball of gas
Son: as in my father's son
No difference, I just wanted to be included 😢😂😂
Smoke de grass tyson
Like if "Tatoonie" hurt you.
Hoyos13 thank you
It hurt me very much..
Hoyos13 Hahahaha I thought I was the only one who noticed that
I felt ripped open.
Hello there
Arrival was actually one of the best movies I ever watched. It was so beautiful and well thought out. The science also was super complicated and interesting but didn't take away from the plot
have you watched interstellar
@@morningstar52 terrible movie.
@@zzodysseuszz terrible take
@@zzodysseuszz obvious troll is obvious
@@zzodysseuszz terrible opinion but it's yours
Tyson absolutely refuses to be interrupted when he is on one of his well-rehearsed talking points.
lol mr intellectual
Shut up, you wouldn't be half as good even if we let you rehearse 😆
Train of thought can be lost in a second
@@LXW-Arts I don't think it's about the train of thought though, if you've seen his interviews in the past you know what I'm talking about. He goes on these almost verbatim sound bites every time and I think he realizes that that's entirely what his career is based on therefore he refuses to be interrupted.
i’m convinced he was on speed or some shit during this podcast
"Neil on Toy Story: 'Toys can't do that'"
Neil “toys can’t do that” Degrasse Tyson
Underated comment 😂
Every Pixar movie can be boiled down to "What if ______ had emotions?"
Buzz's beam is fake to!!
Neil to buzz: You can’t fly, you’re a TOY..
me: “okay i need to get an early night tonight”
also me at 3:40am: “how monsters inc got the 4th dimension right”
isaac persell as i read this it’s 2:59 am
8:43am
Help
I have finals tomorrow and I am watching this instead
Same situation
isaac persell 2:49 am for me
Neil is that guy you invite to the house party because he's cool and everyone likes him, but you also know you can't stay in conversation with him for too long, else he'll start being insufferable. You kinda just chitchat and sip your drinks a few times, hear him tell a cool story and some clever jokes, then before he starts to focus on one thing for too long you excuse yourself to go to the bathroom and simply never return.
Good people.
You lack integrity. You don't enjoy a person's presence and then not say goodbye. What the hell is wrong with you?
@@ChristAliveForevermore have you ever been to a party?
They just need a good mushroom trip one time or just smoke some zaza everytime they go to a party
Stop overanalyezing people u don't know
@@bengeelen3639 what the fuck are you taking about?
I’ve always loved the tents in Harry Potter that appear to be regular sized but actually have an entire floor plan inside. If that could become a reality in this lifetime, I can die in peace
i wonder has he ever seen Dr Who ????
@@DaraGaming42 I haven’t
@@NickRidgers i meant Neal Degress Tyson, not you or the other guy. i Love to see Neal Degress Tyson breakdown Doctor Whos "physics" and TARDIS concept
@@DaraGaming42 Oooh gotcha
What if death is the 4th dimension? i.e. door to the ether
6:50 to skip to monsters inc part
Thank you
@@matthewibelievethemanbonwh3445 anytime
thanks m88
Thank you 🤗
Sweet baby Jesus thank you
Neil deGrasse Tyson looks like a Red Dead Redemption character
Kind of sounds like Dutch
Tumbleweed Sheriff
Jaxon M. It’s like when you have full customization for Arthur Morgan
yo this made me crack up lmfaoooo
William Morales I wish.... he would be getting 12 rounds to the face in deadeye 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤷🏼♂️😎
Him not knowing the actual name of the desert planet in star wars was the biggest fake "I'm too cool to know" moment ever.
I respect your right to criticize things using your expertise but I also respect the fact that if they get it to scientifically accurate it's no longer science fiction.
Neil doesn’t hate science fiction/science fantasy. He’s just saying the movie could’ve been more scientifically accurate or internally consistent.
Uh no, it can be 100% scientifically accurate and be fiction if the story isn't real. If you've seen 2001: A Space Odyssey, it's considered one of the most scientifically accurate science fiction movies of all time, and is science fiction nonetheless. You seem to think that realism and scientific accuracy somehow detract from the quality of a sci Fi film but I completely disagree. That's not to say that I don't enjoy sci Fi that's not realistic if it's well done, but realism makes it better in a lot of cases. And if it's TOO lacking in realism you can really ruin a story. Science fiction SHOULD be as accurate as possible, and viewers should only be required to suspend disbelief when it is necessary and enhances the experience
@@Axiohm a ton of books are science fiction but are also surprisingly faithful to real scientific laws, for example children of time.
That op aint right
I’m gonna start using “I love me some dimensions” as an alternative way of proclaiming my love for thicc women.
Lmaooo
Sameee
LMAO
Sickness for the thickness
🤣🤣🤣🤣
7:00 so doors that open a wormhole into kids closets?
7:13 joe: do you think we will have technology like this in the future?
Neil: I hope so.
😆
Oof 😂🤣😂🤣
I completely died when he said that xD
😂😂😂
WOW
2:13 Joe doing his best Jerry Seinfeld impression
I just laughed for 3 solid minutes
The whole clip I was waiting for Joe to get cut off. Crack up
“The sun is just a spicy moon”
-Neil Grabass Tyson
Vampire or Dracula are Vulnerable to Sunlight so they comes out at night forgetting that Moonlight was just the reflection of Sun. 😂
@@69yearsago22 can you look at a 1000 watt lamp? Can you look at the reflection of the light on a stone thats covered in dust?
I realise this is a fictional concept but that is my rationalisation for it.
@@iczeky Vampires, typically, also have no reflection and physically are incapable of breaking into homes.
I scrolled past this comment three times before i noticed his middle name.
@whateveryoufeellikeman then it's not breaking in
*Ah yes, Luke Skywalker visiting his adoptive grandparents on Tattoony*
LMFAO fucking Joe man.
Thanks fbi
I don't get it
@@danewiley4215 it’s because it couldn’t be any more wrong
@@definitelynotafederalagent I don't watch star wars
You should totally use that intro when you do any shows in relation to psychedelics, dimensions, ufos! 😍🥰
Love you guys!
Love how joe always takes science fiction as fact.
I will say that the hyperdrive was a sci-fy thought that became a reality by folding space-time and making the distance shorter
@@inuyasha0413 Creating wormholes would be the closest thing to a hyperdrive, but its only thought to be possible, not plausible
@@gamertardguardian1299 you do realize that the technology is being built right now to use hyperdrives, right?
When we were little, all Sci fi was taken as fiction that might exist someday.
Now, anything you see in Sci fi you believe is fact bc there's so much science that exists about wh we don't know (like govt/military secrets).
"Tatoonie"... I guess words can hurt
Thoroughly Wet I don’t get it
Jon Cormier the planet is called Tatooine in SW
He called it tatoonie
"Sticks and stones may break my bones. But words can never hurt me.
Except for that one."
Having never cared for the Star Wars franchise; Tatoonie.
Imagine his reaction if he played the Portal series.
I’d really like to hear his thoughts on that actually
“Unrealistic, you can’t recycle oxygen in an underground bunker”
@@bluesolace9052 You can though?
Sayge Blackmon Well, there are ways to make oxygen besides plants. A scientist once made a machine to produce more oxygen than a tree. That machine and trees still produced some carbon dioxide though
@@bluesolace9052 Yeah all you have to do is have a vacuum sealed network.
where to see the full video?
how come i cant find Joe Rogan Experience #919 full on youtube?
"I love me some dimensions" - Neil deGrasse Tyson
Vladislav Kirilov I agree
Vladislav Kirilov wait I thought he said penis🤨
HAHA yes he do.
Best part of the clip.
Same
We already have access to the 4th dimension. And if my dryer Doesn't return my socks there is going to be trouble.
The fact that this happens to almost everyone is quite suspicous...
You know... my socks have been going missing for years. I started with 50, now I have 3.
@@samuraijackoff5354 and none of them match
Alex Valdivia
You just read my mind....
I had a sock end up inside a pair of basketball shorts. In between two pieces of completely sewn pieces of fabric. The sock was just twisted and bundled up towards the bottom of the leg. I showed my mother and two sisters and they couldn’t find a broken seam anywhere either and we had to cut it out! Strange things happen in our dryers, that’s for sure.
Is there a full episode, not broken up into segments
Where can I find the full podcast?
"I love me some dimensions"
i know right?
HAHAHAHA
That was the greatest thing I have ever hearf
Dakota Harris i hearf that
Pale Emperor i need at least three to exist otherwise im just not all there.
four and well ill get things done
Like #666
“How monsters inc got the fourth dimension right”
This the shit I be clicking on at 4am instead of going to bed....
Not me here at 3:47am lol
Exact 4am😂
Lol
4:59 😳
Hi! It's 4:30 AM and i just woke up
@Kane Pixels This your inspiration for A-Sync and the utilisation of the backroom dimensions?
Why don't we see the shadows or bump into partially 4 dimensional objects, because maybe there isn't a 4d? Complex theories or Extraordinary ideas, some times are just that. There is a place in science where unicorns and fairies lives, is up to us to be able to tell the difference.
UFOs? or as the US government officially calls them: unidentified aerial phenomenon (UAP)?
@@patrickwalsh9444 i want to believe, i bet we are not alone, just look at all the fauna around us, who is to say that other planet cannot develop some kind of fauna. but if a Four-dimensional space existed and UFOs/UAP were 4d beings, it will be normal to be constantly bumping into the 3d version of this space. it will be a constant clash.
Neil Degrasse Tyson needs to have his own movie critic channel hahah, I like his realistic point of view hahah.
TexTLO
Yeah, and it can be a youtube channel since it's free. I bet he would get a lot of subscribers if he posted regularly.
TexTLO He has his own podcast if you're interested. Its called Startalk
He should make a "Cinemasins: Science" youtube channel, or cooperate with Cinemasins/Jaime
TejasTerps lmao right thats something i enjoy doing to movies like its a movie i get it but its always fun to point out the real science behind things
He's not critiquing the films, he's critiquing the science. Like he said he likes gravity but talked about what they got wrong. So it wouldn't work
it took a damn Monster's Inc. analogy to make me finally understand the fourth dimension
Except it's a pretty terrible analogy.
@@hazode Give us a better one, please.
Humans are incapable of imagining the 4th dimension or beyond, we can only understand the concept
Its a place within a place that uses a medium to get over there but they're not related to each other since it bounces of to a different place and time we weren't able to comprehend it since we haven't experienced it and it defy our physical law of our 3rd dimension
YouthEnergyia imagine a comic strip. You are a character in it. Paper would be the 2nd dimension. The artist is in the 3rd dimension. You can see the 3rd dimension when the artist comes back to draw some more comics. But you don’t understand the 3rd dimension Bc you are limited to only perceive in the 2nd dimension.
“I love me some dimensions”
I lost it
Issue with the wormholes described in Monsters Inc is that wormholes cannot move in space, because they simply connect two points in space, not two objects. Another thing would be that they’d be spherical. So, while the doors exhibit the overall concept fairly well, they do not exhibit the nature of what is theoretically possible within our own universe.
Neil DeGrasse dressed like he's about to tell Joe another settlement needs his help. 😭
xcaluhbration that cracked me up, nice one
xcaluhbration War ... war never changes.
LMAO niceeee
xcaluhbration win
lol!
Neil deGrasse Tyson is the only comedian who doesn't know he's a comedian. He's so funny. I love to listen to him talk.
Neil: I disagree, and here's why,,
He knows damn well how funny he is. Every scientist talking a lot in public, pretty much know how they are coming across. They haven't gotten to be scientists by chance. They are good at thinking. Unlike most people...
Yes he is, and that is actually his role in the world.
I love listening to him talk because I learn something from him every. time.
Ynk Gzt hey man, stop attacking me.
“How much stuff can you put on a desk if there’s 3 dimensions?” kinda cracked my mind a little
I am shocked that Joe turned off Arrival not even mid way through. That movie is not only incredible but it’s the epiphany of what he finds interesting...
“Whatever desert planet that Luke was on.”
Right Neil, like you don’t know.
He was on tattoony
@@publicslum6495 made me cringe when he said that 😭
Tatooine
Definitely Tattoonie
@@CreatioNNoitcurtseD tattoniee
If Neil deGrasse Tyson did a movie review channel I would SO watch!
I wouldn't, lol
Great idea! Let him start with movie 43!
Bri-Z Ari K He does some commentary on Cinemasins for the "Space" movies; The Martian, Interstellar, etc.
@@Meatwad787 Oh I've seen. It's great!
@@ethanwagner6418 that seems like contrarian reply
Well…who would’ve thought that Monsters Inc has quantum physics accuracy but Star Wars almost has zero astrophysical accuracy
The best example is storing files in a separate file in a saved file(you wouldn't know until you open the file)
I gotta stop listening to Neil deGrasse Tyson when I’m high
Right dude. Lol
Why? Haha he's great.
I fucking slipped into that 4th dimension bro
I bought a telescope after smoking 2 blunts because of this man.
dude honestly lmao
“Tattoonie” as a diehard Star Wars fan that killed me a little
I haven’t watched any of the films for more than thirty minutes, and it slayed me too...
Star wars is trash lol
Zev Smile Thanks for your opinion but honestly I don’t give a fuck
Zev Smile says the one that plays fortnite go tell your boyfriend to buy you another pack of VBucks loll
Zev Smile fortnite boi
Where is full video?
"I love me some dimensions"
Got a chuckle out of me lol
7:54 he sounds like Rex from Toy Story
Lmao true
💀
LOL
Dude I thought the same thing I’m glad someone else heard that
😂😂😂😂
Neil deGrasse Tyson looks like a black Indiana Jones
Cleveland Jones
@@craigzilla3420 Not sure which comment made me laugh harder
Hmmm I wonder why
iTz Drop he is Indiana jones
And/or vice versa
This talk of requiring a portal, access to an additional dimension makes me rethink the things they said in that skinwalker ranch show
Omg his tweets for arrival! I would love to see those.
"Tatoonie"- Joe Rogan
Joe "Tatoonie" Rogan
Man. He went down a few notches for me after that one.
NDT literally waits for Joe to start talking so he can interrupt him.
Academics lmao...
They both try to one up each other on interrupting. This time though, Neil won.
I would wear t-shirts with Neil's tweets on them every day of the week.
Forgive me for possibly misunderstanding this. Does this mean that phones and computer screens can be considered as visual portals to the 4th dimension? Or do we define portals with the requisite of physical access, and not just visual?
Technically no since the screens are on a “2 dimensional” plane like the table would be we can make it appear 3 dimensional by adding different focus layers but it wouldn’t be part of the 4th dimension
7:56 He sounds like Rex from Toy Story😂😂😂
KIDSVEVO@ he really does! 😂😂😂
KIDSVEVO@ glad I’m not the only one that thought
Went back to find this comment after I heard it 😂😂
“Ahh! My source of power!”
KIDSVEVO@ hahahahahahahahahahaah
Neil: "So I stopped commenting on Movies..."
Neil (some time later): "#GuardiansoftheGalaxy I have to forgive the loud explosions in space, because I've already accepted the bipedal raccoon shooting heavy weaponry."
Jones Crimson and the best thing about rocket ( in the comics at least) is that he is structurally identical, or nearly so , to a racoon, he's just a lot smarter, so it absolutely makes no sense. you can't even say he's a space trash panda.
Jones Crimson well yea people wanted him to keep doing it so he started again
That’s so funny I was legitimately thinking about how this movie and quantum physics have a lot on common
It’s like an ant opening a vertical trap door into the third, that’s pretty cool.
If you watch the whole thing, Joe gets so pissed at how much he is interrupted. But stays polite.
Fr I can see that but Neil is a passionate scientist. Sometimes in deep discussions you cant help yourself.
@@izrael820 true, but it does seem just rude after a while, especially when he knows was he's doing it
@@loodlebop try having a conversation with my mum. You won't be able to fucking breathe.
@@Tokmurok ha!
Sometimes when people are very passionate and knowledgeable of a topic they might interrupt the false knowledge you are about to speak. Not out of disrespect, but to correct you before you repeat it. This is bc once you start repeating things, you start believing them. And this is also why a lot of smart people have social problems. Lol
"Tattoo-ny" lol Joe Rogan's pronunciation.
HarpManic It's Tattoo-een
Joe Rogan came from the tatoonie planet
Joe's mom is the Almighty Sarlacc
I used to pronounce it like that until I actually read the word.
its stylistically designed to be that way, its like poetry, it rhymes
He explains why 4 D would increase storage but not how we could manifest control over a 4th dimension in the first place, anyone care to pick up where he left off?
Where can I find the whole episode
Spotify 919
I only clicked on this video because Neil DeGrasse Tyson is wearing a hat
Comrade I also, enjoy the hat.
I too as well, enjoy the hat
Indiana deGrasse Tyson
I three, also enjoy the hat
Psycho Pyro, he does that fairly regularly.
I want Neil deGrasse Tyson to meet Alex Jones. I want to see how they would react to each other and the hilarity that would ensue.
you ever seen oil and water
Alex would accuse Neil of being a globalist
i feel like neil would be exasperated and a little amused by him 😂 this is a fantastic idea though! give him a safe word too for when he can’t take his brain getting rotted further
Alex would just shout and talk over him so he can’t make any good points.
@@elizabethabbott7775 exactly
Honestly, I love when he does that. One thing people forget is they have the ability to NOT consume his tweets if they don’t like them. It’s a simple function called MUTE.
What about the speed of sound in the opening scene of The Last Jedi when they look up from the planet and hear the ships from the first order at the same time as they arrive.....
Joe "tatoo-ny" rogan
Tatooine
There it is
That's a good name for a tattoo parlour in New York
Tryna sound like he doesn’t know the name
@@Americium-241 I have never watched star wars and even i knew that was wrong.
“I love me some dimensions”
- *Neil Degrasse Tyson, 2017*
I walked out of a movie theater for the first time ever when watching "Gravity"
Car keys used to be frequent travelers to the 4th dimension. Until lanyards prevented that. Socks also traveled but with the aid of dogs.
I'm totally on board with this.
Socks also travel via dryers too
Sometimes the key thing is a ghost fucking w you
And biros.
underrated comment right here!!
That's actually such a quick easy to understand concept of the 4th dimention
@Daniel Tidwell thank you!
He didn't really even explain the 4th dimension. He merely explained what a portal TO that dimension would be like (Imperceptible to us).
He's a natural educator. His whole job is to be able to explain science easily in order to spark people's interest in the subject
@@Kugrox because theres no way to explain or describe it, just like he said with the ant analogy. Its like trying to imagine a new colour that youve never seen before, our brains are incapable of doing that.
CodeX similar to the concept of eternity
The intro was trippy lmao
The beginning is like nails on a chalk board for Star Wars fans
There is actually a theory for Pixar where all the movies are in one big timeline. It starts off with Brave and at the end is Monsters Inc. The doors go back in time to the time when humans were still around.
Edit: The theory is called The Pixar Theory and there is this whole website about this.
@ITS YA BOI MIKE WAZOWSKI oops, I'll just delete the other one
The Pixar theory BITCH
@@picklechinazzboi2991 😂😂😂😂
And the monsters collect scrams from children that are produced by fear bc it is a very strong power source.... ADRENOCHROME!
How does Cars fit in to all this
6:50 the monsters inc part for those who don’t want to wait
Thank you.
There's already a comment about it now stop begging for likes
Ajmal Ks I’m not, I copied the comment cause there was only 1, with more comments saying the time stamp more people can find what they came for
🙌 thanks lmao that was nearly 66 percent of the video 😂
Thanks for posting. I didn't see any other timestamp comments. Fk that guy for trying to put you down.
Arrival was fascinating
"jamie hated it" and neil looked at him like hes a piece of shit LOL
Wade Wilson 😂😂😂😂
Wade Wilson He had that face like "Oh yeah? Fuck off noone likes you"
Wade Wilson obviously, anyone who has seen the film would do that...
Vampz0r
Oh yeah? Fuck Off Vanoz0r, noone likes you....
Sam Fonder
Listen to the dumfuk who says "noone" isn't a word, dumfuk!
Neil deGrasse Tyson said 🤠 then dipped
😂⚰
I never used to like Tyson but as I got to see his sense of humor in random tik toks and pod clips, I grew to like him. He’s now, always, a source for my research studies. Afro Indiana Dundee
Honestly, I would agree that BB-8 would skid uncomfortably in Tatooine
When Neil is on this show it’s no longer “The Joe Rogan show” it’s “The Niel Show”
LOL that is so true, he completely took over that interview lmao
Maybe when Neil gets older he will create his own podcast
I bet his brain just never stops working that's why
Stfu
@@dlo8070 he has startalk now
If Neil had been my high school science teacher id be a NASA engineer by now lol.
yup we need better teachers :/
soukupb they are just going through the motions in public school now. They will only get out of their way for those that are way above average.
LOLL this guy is such a fucking clown!
he's not a scientist! he's still talking about the movie gravity. he's talking about star wars and monsters inc?
LOLLLL you FUCKING idiots real scientists build nuclear bombs! not these fuckin pissy pop scientists that have space theories that ANY pothead or acidhead can equalize!
AHAHAHAAHH!! what a fucking joke!
all he cares about is what other people criticized him for what a petty stupid fuck ahahah!!!!!!
AR SIMMONS troll away clown
Thomas Mitchell Fuck youre face sheepie !
Dude, the way he describes wormholes, it's EXACTLY like the way the doors work in The Dark Tower!!!
Wait, what if you move the candle around to diffrent locations to contantly give it new air?
So by Degrasse's explanation Advanced Aliens might have already visited Us, and we can't tell because we don't fully grasp the fourth dimension?
RILEY FREEMAN basically aliens could look like anything. all we know is they have to have a exoskeleton to carry a brain...
RILEY FREEMAN research the Fermi paradox
joshua 6 E why would they need an exoskeleton?
ryanplzz i have no idea where he got that from lol.
ryanplzz i think he means because there brain is to big for there heads
Skip to 6:48 to get to the monsters inc. part
Marcos Avila you da best
Marcos Avila you sir are a time saver.
Marcos Avila you're a good man. Thanks.
Marcos Avila unfortunately I didn't see your comment till I was 6 min in :/
Marcos Avila thanks
title was so insane i just had to watch
Carl Sagan had an excellent video explaining 4th dimension.
"I felt a great disturbance in the Force, as if millions of voices suddenly cried out in terror and were suddenly silenced." That's what I imagine happens when Tyson talks about Star Wars.
Neil: explaining 4th dimension physics
Jo Rogan: that be awesome for hoarders lmao
I think all my missing socks have disappeared into the 4th dimension.
Make 2 versions of every movie. Make the movie. Then commentary version with experts ripping it apart. I would pay for a double feature to have this.
Starts talking about Monsters Inc. at 6:45
Etc. I finally stumbled upon your comment at 6:38...thanks for the effort...just didn't line up with my dimension in time lol
THANK YOU!!
Not all heroes wear capes
Etc. I
but you miss the part where joe says “tatoony”
After the show..
Joe: I have a portal to the 4th dimension.. Want to go?
Neil: YES OF COURSE! Where is this machine??
Joe: **pulls out a baggie of DMT**
baggie
Haha
You understand it is on the most literal level actually a portal to the 4th dimension right
@@thechosenone6255 lol yes I know! :)
4th? Thats shrooms. DMT would be like 5+
*Joe's not wearing his headphones and it FREAKING ME TF OUT!*
Would never thought to hear NDT talk about monsters inc
"Tattoonie"
"Visiting his step-parents"
Not gonna lie chief, that shit hurted
Hurted lol
That’s some toxic bs
That was rough
“It’s like- do you reali- excuse me- lady” 😂😂😂