Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.
Response to 23 Questions - Part 1 - Beard (Darhi) - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 08. 2024
- Response to 23 Questions on Religious Opinion of Javed Ahmed Ghamidi
Part - 1 - Darhi ki Sharai Haisiyat
🔴 SUBSCRIBE 🔔: www.youtube.co...
▶ About Javed Ahmed Ghamidi:
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi is a Pakistani Muslim theologian, a Quran scholar, and an educationist. Mr. Ghamidi is a student of Maulana Amin Ahsan Islahi and Maulana Abul A’la Maududi. Mr. Ghamidi has authored several books, including the bestseller ‘Meezan’, in which he presents a comprehensive treatise on the entire content of Islam. Mr. Ghamidi is a researcher and a critical thinker who has challenged many aspects of the traditional Muslim schools of thought on the basis of evidence from Quran and sunnah.
▶ About Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning:
"Ghamidi Center of Islamic Learning", an initiative of Al-Mawrid US, is established with a single purpose, to educate people of all ages about moral, ethical, and humane values as taught in Islam. Our aim is to separate history and culture from Islam and teach it in its purest form as a field of knowledge and not enforce it as a creed. We base our instruction method on argument and logic and encourage healthy criticism. An institute where traditional and historical knowledge can be understood as well as challenged with reason.
00:00 افتتاحیہ اورگفتگو کے اس نئے سلسلے کا تعارف
01:57 کیا داڑھی انبیا کی سنت ہے؟
02:20 جاوید صاحب اپنے کام کی نوعیت کا تعارف کراتے ہیں۔
06:53 قرآن اور حدیث کی نوعیت میں بنیادی فرق
09:03 سنت کیا ہے؟
10:28 داڑھی کا ذکر صرف روایات میں ہے۔
12:57 دین کا مقصد اور داڑھی
15:11 داڑھی کے معاملے میں اختلاف کی نوعیت
17:42 داڑھی کو کیا دینی حیثیت دی جا سکتی ہے؟
19:59 دین میں کسی چیز کا اضافہ خدا پر جھوٹ باندھنا ہے۔۔۔
20:36 داڑھی کے بارے میں جاوید صاحب کے نتائجِ تحقیق
23:35 کیا نبی صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے صیغۂ امر میں داڑھی رکھنے کا حکم نہیں دیا؟
28:14 رائے میں تبدیلی کیسے آئی
32:06 کیا دین کا کام کرنے والوں کو داڑھی رکھنی چاہیے؟
34:25 کیا اللہ تعالی نے داڑھی کو اپنے نیک بندوں کی ایک علامت مقرر کیا ہے؟
37:40 کیا صحابۂ کرام رضی اللہ عنھم کی بھی داڑھی کے بارے میں یہی رائے تھی؟
39:44 کیا آپ کو خواہش ہوئی کہ آپ کی داڑھی ہو؟
42:17 ذاتی طور پر آپ کو مردوں کا داڑھی رکھنا کیسا لگتا ہے؟
46:11 حدیث کو سمجھنے کے بارے میں ایک احتیاط
48:27 یہ کیوں کہا جاتا ہے کہ آپ حدیث کو نہیں مانتے؟
52:52 اختتامیہ
▶ DONATIONS: www.ghamidi.or...
▶ CONNECT with us:
◼ WEBSITE: www.ghamidi.org
◼ FACEBOOK: / ghamidicil
◼ CZcams: / ghamidicil
#GCIL #JavedAhmedGhamidi #FromGhamidiDesk #AlMawrid #Ghamidi
GET THE APP To Ask Questions and Join Community Discussions! www.ghamidi.org/app
سلام غامدى صاحب آپ وقت کے ظالم حکمران کے خلاف کون سا راستہ اختيآر کرنا چاے
He doesn't have a primary level education about Islam
So doesn't arise any need to ask any questions
مدرسے کے مولوی میں اور ایک اسکالر میں زمین و آسمان کا فرق ہوتا ہے
مدرسے طوطے کی طرح رٹا ہوتا ہے
جو غلط سلط سکھا دیا اسی پہ قایم رہتا ہے
اگر حق سمجھ میں آجایے تب بھی وہ غلط سلط کو جکڑے رہتا ہے
اسے صرف روٹی اور دکان کی فکر ہوتی ہے ایمان کی نہیں
اسکالر کیلیے ایسی کوئ قباحت نہیں
وہ ہر چیز کو عقل و دلایل پہ پرکھتا ہے
اور انصاف کےساتھ بیان کرتا ہے
کہیں کہیں پھسل بھی جاتے ہیں
لیکن بنیادی عقیدے میں کوئ فرق نہیں ہوتا
مدرسے کے مولوی تو بنیادی عقیدے اور ایمان و ضمیر سب کو بیچ ڈالتے ہیں
جسے علماء سو کہتے ہیں
علماء سو سارے جہنمی ہیں
@@razdakhatoon5740 bibi molve per ungli uthany sy phly ye zaror soch len k hamary molve janab e rasool Allha hai. To ap ka ishara kahan ja raha hy 5chon ungleyan baraber nahi
Sir excuse me lkn ye haqeeqat hy ke ap bilkul Paadri lagte hain. Shari.at zahir ko daikhti hy Dilon ka hal to Allah ko malum hy
کتنی اچھی بات کہی کہ جس چیز پر اطمینان ہے اس کو اپنا لیں۔ فہم کے اختلاف پر دوسروں کو گمراہ نہیں کہنا چاہئے نہ ہی ان پہ طنز کرنا چاہئے۔
The words does not exists to thank Ghamdi sahib for his best, detailed briefing , he is definitely a God's gifted person, a great scholar of the present time.
It's enough for me to wear a beard Cox mine beloved prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) wear it on his beautiful face.
شائستگی فہم کی اعلیٰ مثال جاوید غامدی صاحب اللہ آپکے علم میں مزید اضافہ فرمائے
I am aborn Muslim Alhamdolillah but was ghafil for a long while. Because of him I have started practicing again Alhamdolillah. Ba a better human being, help others, be tolerant and pray to Allah
Same!!!
Yes, How muslim go astry by forgetting true essence of Islam, purification , honesty , character , justice
Only well educated and open minded people understand Gamdi sahib. I love him such and impressive personality may Allah bless you with long life ameen
Not open minded, only highly wise can understand respected ghamidi sahib.
Sadia Khalid
آمین!
Ameen
A real scholar. May Allah bless him with health. I really understand my deen bcz of him.
ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha haha , prime time comedy with Gamdi
He is not only one of the most learned islamic scholars of our time but his way of explaining things is so beausitful. You can disagree with him but I dont understand how come anyone can hate him. May Allah Bless him. Enghlish sub-title is a good idea, all such informative videos should have English sub titles.
بہت خوب بہت اعلی اللَّهِ رب العزت آپ کی عمر میں برکت عطا فرمائے آمین ثم آمین
"میں دین کا ایک طالب علم ہوں "اس سے بہترین اور سادہ فقرہ آج تک کسی اتنے بڑے عالم سے نہیں سنا
Dr zakir nike bhi aise hi bolte hai
Dr zaik naik and sihekh ahmed dedat b yehe khte hain k we r student and zakir naik is the real scholar
God gifted talented alhamdulillah
aap ne kitne aur kon konse ulamae kiram ko suna he
عالم؟ کسی کی بات کر رہے ہو بھائی صاحب؟ توبہ کرو، یہ اک دین سے بھٹکا حوا بندہ ھے۔اللہ اس کو ہدایت دے۔ آمہن
انداز گفتگو ایسا ہی ہونا چاھئے۔۔۔ غامدی صاحب کے نظریہ سے اختلاف کے باوجود بھی ان کی عزت کرتا ہوں۔۔۔ داڑھی تو عشق کی انتہا ہے۔ غامدی صاحب آپ امت مسلمہ کی روایات کو اپنی غلط تشریح سے ختم نہیں کر سکتے۔۔۔ میرے نبی کی ہر سنت تا قیامت قائم و دائم رہے گی۔
His research should be translated in multiple languages. We are so blessed with a scholar like this in our lifetime. His attitude towards learning is the thing that differentiate him from conventional sub continent "ulma".
So, he can corrupt the other innocent people.
@@tahirmahmood3465 Yes definitely, that is the reason why the Muslims in West and librals in Pakistan who do not belong to religious practicing families are easily attracted to the Ghamdi Sahib ideology, because from their childhood they did not have much information about Quran and Hadith and are attracted to the 10-20 Percent of Islamic teachings leaving behind 80% of Islam . Although these educated people are well versed with worldly and scientific knowledge.
@@YasirIslam01 yes, so are so right. Allah PAK GEE SHOWS ALL OF US RIGHT PATH.
@@YasirIslam01 Sir What makes you think that people living in west are ignorant about religion and they don't practice islam. It’s just we don't label every thing as 10 % or 20 % of Islam. We think our religion is so beautiful and its all messages can be explained by scientific knowledge and that's what Sir Ghamdi is trying to do.
@@naomankhan950 Where did I say people in west are ignorant about religion, I meant to say that people are easily trapped or attracted toward Ghamdi Version of Islam or Pervaiziat as from their childhood many Muslim parents in western societies have not made much efforts in Islamic upbringing of their children in terms of practicing religion, like offering prayers and telling them importance of Quran and Hadith, telling the children about Importance of Hijab and telling them that in Islam music is not allowed. So when that child grows up and try to do self study, he will look for something which he feels is logical. Like from his or her childhood , the Hijab was not practised in his/her family and there were mixed gatherings, and Music was normal thing. So by listening to Ghamdi Sahib that Grown up child will certify that covering hairs in not important in Islam and it is fine to listen to music because he or she is used to it now. And he/she will start to blame other scholars that those Mullas are just giving Islamic information from their own mind, because we have not studied Hadith and from Hadith we will get Explanation of Islamic teachings. So Quran and Hadith make complete Islam, most of Quranist say where it is mentioned in Quran Music is Haram. From Hadith we will get explanation that Music is Haram. We as Muslims and true believer do not require science to prove that Allah message is True. Allah gave those scientific facts in Quran for the people who look for scientific facts and miracles to accept the Truth, that this message is indeed from our Creator. So what is mentioned in Quran and Sahih Hadith we should follow it without any doubt and should not look if our mind or heart accept it or not or it makes logic or not. Allah knows best.
غامدی صاحب آپ کمال کے زاویے سے دنیا کو سمجھانے کی اور کمال کی حکمت اور مہارت سے بیانات دیے ہیں مجھے تو بہت کچھ سمجھا گئے ہیں آپ استادے محترم اللہ تعالٰی اپ کو دنیا وآخرت کی بھلائی عطاء فرمائے آمین ثم آمین
how can I describe my feelings about this gem, I have no words, ghamidi is really a precious asset to humanity on earth, before familiarity with ghamidi I was just given this religion as a family belief, but now I became true Muslim
Ghamdi sb is so clear in islamic teachings,,,,, i learned alot form him...and removed many confusions.... No body should be allowed to object any mufakkar/Aalim
According to me, criticism leads to the right path.A lot of ulemas have different and even opposite opinions on different matters.Its not that they all are completelytrue.😊
اپنی تحقیق کو انتہائی جامع اور مدلل انداز میں پیش کرنا کوئی غامدی صاحب سے سیکھے ۔ نہ طنز نہ تنقید نہ تانا صرف اپنی تحقیق ما شا اللہ ۔
انداز اچھا ہے لیکن بے دینی جھلکر ہی ہے
I have been listening you throughout this video and I am literally petrified and I am really frozen to see your understanding of things and the way you describe things. I have no words to express my feelings about what kind of scholar I found you in this particular debate. Allah ajar o sawab de. You are the legend who can ignite a new revolution of intellectualism.
About Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi, I not only believe that there is no scholar of his stature profundity of religious thought and precision of its understanding and lucidity of his articulation in the Muslim word, but I also believe that I have yet to see anybody more profound just and humane than Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi sahib, when it comes to commentary on social issues including human rights. May Allah bless his countless blessings upon Ghamdi sb! Ameeeeeen.
( USTAAD MOHTARAM MAY YOUR SEED PROSPER GOD WILLING)
اللہ تعالی اس شخص کے علم میں آضآفہ کرے اور اس کی عمر دراز کرے۔ آمین
JazakAllah, I can not thank Allah enough that I live in a time where a great scholar like Ghamdi sahib is among us .I pray to Allah that he give Ghamdi sahib healthy and long life. Aameen
ہم نے اسلام کو خود تجربہ کر کے دیکھا- نور ہے نور اٹھو دیکھو سنایا ہم نے- پیدائشی مسلمان ہونا اور سوچ سمجھ کر دین کو اختیار کرنا دونوں میں جو فرق ہے وہ محترم غامدی صاحب کیُ شکل میں سامنے ہے
بہت معذرت۔۔۔۔۔۔میں بھی ان باتوں کے زیر اثر آپکے بارے میں غلط رائے رکھتا تھا۔۔۔۔۔اللہ آپ کو مزید عزت دے۔۔۔۔آمین
مہمان سے زیادہ مجھے میزبان نے متاثر کیا ہے ایک ہی سوال کو مختلف زاویوں سے بڑے اچھے طریقے پوچھا ۔
ماشااللہ
Ye damaad hain ghamdi sahib kay
being a Pakistani woman i started feeling lil disturbance from some typical concepts that are told us since childhood. I was always told by my parents and eventually i had these misconceptions that made me upset from inside but i always tried hard never to think like this but "Iztarab" was there.
1- do not ask/think too many questions about Islam, GUNAH HO GA. (my problem was curiosity became hard to ignore and suppress questions)
2- Men are allowed 4 marriages bcz they have uncontrolled sexual desire so Nikah is a way to legalize that (problem in my head: men and women both created as humans should have equal control over their desires)
3- if married man like some other woman he is allowed to get married to her as 2nd wife, but if married women like someone else her husband is allowed to hit her. (my issue was, it seemed discriminatory treatment of genders)
With these questions poking in my head all the time and no permission of asking them or even thinking about them made me have a silent shikwa that "May b Islam is all about protecting men and we women are just another animal of planet, created for men to enjoy". Y r we even entitled as humans then?!... Again i was so scared to say or even think about it too much k mjy gunaah h ga if I put question on something.
But this man Ghamidi sahb is amazing. I listened to few of his lectures and i got all my answers and got to know the actual philosophy of Islam.
Even tho I don't live in Pakistan, I had the exact same problem and thoughts, so your not alone, at one point I got so far away from Islam because of these thoughts, although some scholars like him have helped me feel closed and better about my relegion, I'm still confused about a lot of things tho.
@@mariamfaisal4896 u should search his lectures about the things u r confused, i hope u will find ur answers. I found him most logical among the others i listened. Wen i had these confusions i did search and try to find answers but most of them were like "its better to have nikah then zinah" reason for 4 marriages thing. I found it extremely illogical reason bcz then y women aren't allowed multiple marriages? They should also avoid zinaah and have nikah wth all the men they like. So at some point i became so disappointed from scholars that i stopped looking for answers, i was like "yaya i know nikah z better than zinah would b his answer, i m not interested in that." But then i accidentally listened to that of his lecture about women while scrolling fb and paused for moments. I was sooo excited and happy that day, i felt a sigh of relief that i m not some kafir thinking like this. I was just told and taught half things, partial/incomplete ayat references to prove their point, out of context ahadith etc. When he explained things wth context picture was completely different.
ALSO CHECK OUT MUFTI ABU LAYTH, HE HAS ALSO CLEARED SOME OF THESE ISSUES
@@mariamfaisal4896 Maula Ali A.S. se kisi ne yehi poocha tha keh Mard kun 4 shadiyan aik saath karsakta hai par aurat sirf 1 waqt mein aik hi kun? Iss ka jawaab Maula Ali A.S. ne farmaaya tha par yeh poora answer buhat bara hai aur iss ki example di thi Maula Ali A.S. ne issi liye main aap ko bata nahin sakta par agar aap Maula Ali A.S. ke yeh faislon waali aik kitaab khareedlein toh iss mein yeh answer zaroor hai.
@@shanzasuper please can you put a link,i beg you?
I feel proud to born in Ghamidhi saheb's era.
Same...Feel Proud
We are extremely lucky to have such a great person and genius scholar I love you sir
One of the greatest Islamic scholars of time. May Allah subhana wa Tallah shower his blessings upon you... n also i must mention Dr. Israr Ahmad was also a greatest scholar of islam. May Allah subhana wa Tallah shower him blessing upon him. Aameeen
غامدی صاحب اللہ آپ کو سلامت رکھے ۔میں نے کم و بیش آپ کی چار سو ویڈیوز ریکارڈ کر رکھی ہیں اور روزانہ صبح و شام ایک ایک ویڈیو ضرور سنتا ہوں ۔ خدا آپ کو مزید توفیق دے ۔آمین
Mashallah bahi
Mera b yahi haal hay. Dil ka Zang door karnay k liye is hasti ko sunnay se behtar koi mashghala nhi.
I feel myself addict of his lectures .
You are doing excellent job
Sorry brother!
آپ بھی اُسی کام کو follow کرہے جسے غامدی صاحب منا فرماتے ہیں
ان کی تعلیم ہمیشہ یہ رہی ہے کہ یے دین اپکا ہے اسکو ماننا اپنے ہے تو خدارا اس کی تحقیق بھی اپ خود کرے اور دیکھیں کہ جو میں کہہ رہا وہ ٹھیک بھی ہے یا نہی انکی recordings سننا ایک ہد تک ٹھیک ہے پر انکا کوۂی بھی لفظ حرف اخر نہیں انکے بکول!
تو خدارا وہ غلطی نا دوہراے جو غلطی مسلق میں اُلجھے لوگ دھراتے ہیں کے بس جو ہمارے استاد یا امام نے کہہ دیا وہ حرف اخر ہو گیا!
ان کے بیان سننے کے بجائے بزاتے خود اس کی تحقیق کرے تاکے اپ کے دل میں ان کی محبت اور پروان چڑہے!
شکریہ
No doubt Ghamidi Sahib is totally different from our conventional Ulema. He shows the real soul of Islam. After listening his research based concepts about Beard, I felt so good as I am a clean shave person and always tries to improve my behaviour and character against various aspects of life and dealing with other people which is more important than to have a beard and focussing on my apparent appearance. Thank you Ghamidi Sahib. May Allah keep your shadow upon us
Ghamdi sahab is so clear and knows his subject so well that he never stutters and never even has to think for a word to explain his view point. Amazing and true scholar.
Deen ko sahih maqsad ke sath samazhna or apni zindagion me nafiz kerna. Rewayati tauhmaat se door rahne ke liye musalsal deen ki taleem ke talabgaar rehna hi kaamyabi hae.ALLAH hamen deen ki samazh de. Ameen.
Okaay... But really, when his name is mentioned somewhere, Baqarah ayah 11-13 pop up in my head. He really helped me understand those.. He's a living example really
لا الہ الا اللہ۔ آذادیءتحقیق کا عقیدہ فراہم کرتا ہے۔ لیکن افسوس امت کی اکثریت تحقیق کو گستاخی تصور کرتی ہے۔
بقول حضرت اقبال رحمہ اللہ ۔
اگر تقلید بودے شیوہءخوب !
پیمبر ہم رہے اجداد رفتے!!
The knowledge and Wisdom Ghamidi Sahab has is Mind blowing...I really wonder Why many People are against him, He is throwing Real light on Islam, People say he is Innovating things in islam, In reality he is teaching us real Islam....People Who Believe Imaam Mehdi will Come and if he comes, I wonder how People like us will accept him...We lack sense and Acceptance for truth
Javed Ahmad Ghamidi Saab is the true Theologian and great scholar of the time
گفتگو کا اداب، اختلاف رائے کا خوبصورت طریقہ اپنی بات کو سمجھانا اور دوسرے بات کو مکمل سمجھنا. یہ چیز غامدی صاحب کے علاوہ بہت کم لوگوں میں دیکھی ہیں
Jazak'Allah Ghamidi Sahib! You're a true scholar.
excellent 👍🌺🌸🌹💐🌻🌕💖غامدی صاحب دینی راہنمائ کرنے پر امت آپ کی شکر گزار ھے ۔
One the strictest yet sweetest scholars, we're blessed to have him,one may disagree with him as nobody is perfect.
Enlightening discussion .whe next?
Next programme ?
In off
Ma sha Allah...1 e topic py itni tafseel or daleel or us ko asan lafzo mai samjhana yai kch e aalim kr patay h... Bht shukriyaa Sir ❤❤
غامدی صاحب اور دوسرے علماء کی اکثریت کی سوچ میں بنیادی فرق یہ ہے کہ علماء کی اکثریت اندھی تقلید پر یقین رکھتی ہے جبکہ غامدی صاحب کھلے ذہن کے ساتھ دین کو دیکھنے سمجھنے پر یقین رکھتے ہیں اور یہی درست رویہ ہے۔ اندھی تقلید کا سب سے بڑا مسئلہ یہ ہے کہ اگر پرانے علماء نے کوئی غلطی کر دی تو وہ ہمیشہ جاری رہے گی اور اس کی تصحیح اور درستگی نہیں ہو گی۔ ہمیں مذہبی اور دینی معاملات میں بھی تنقیدی سوچ اختیار کرنی چاہیئے تبھی غلطیوں کی نشاندہی ہو گی اور سچ کو کبھی بھی تنقیدی سوچ سے کوئی خطرہ نہیں ہوتا خطرہ صرف غلطی اور جھوٹ کو ہوتا ہے۔
Logical explanation, Ghamidi Sahab and Hassan Sahab thank you Very very much for this work...🥰
May Allah bless both you....🥰
Apne Dari baro moche Cato hadis se ye tu nikal Diya k is mochu se takabur zahir huta hai . Yekin dusri bat b tu AP s.a.w k hukum k Dari barao. Husakta hai k nabi s.a.w k is hukum se insan me ajazi beda huti hu ju takubir ki zid hai is k bare me apka Kiya khyal hai. Ye tu apki apni tashre hai jis se apne ye nikal deya man Lita k ju rewayat ka wakaq AP Bata rehe hu k us waqat us insan ki Dari choti ti moche badi ti. Leken nabi ju hukam Diya hum tu uspe Amal karenge na. Agr nabi s.a.w farmate k Dari moch 2 nu shve karo . Is se ajazi peda huti hai tu ham wahi krte. AP ne takubar ka Matlab tu nikal Diya ju baqol apke Deen me ikhlaqiyat ka hukum hai tu ju rayi nabi s.a.w ki ti husakti hai na janb usme ikhlaqiyat ki hadis hum man b le tu nabi s.a.w apse behater jante te k Ajazi is me hai insan ki Dari bare aur moche Kate kuch samje Zara is piont b bi socho aur fikar karlo. Take apki waje se Kai log is PR Amal Kare aur Sara guna AP k Kate me ayi. Qabar me b Jana hai jannab socho o fikar kalo mazeed aur rujo karlo . Kiyu k srif AP hi sahi hu baqi jitna ulma mohadiseen guzre inko ye pata bilkol nahi ta. Allah hum sub ko hedayat de Ameen
He has much tolerance while replying ..great scholar 👍
really it's great explanation by ghamidi sahib with morality. Thee are lot of positive changes in my life due Ghamidi sahib.
May Allah blessed on Ghamidi Sahib.
Muhammad Tayyab
استاز کو غور سے سنیں انکے ہروگرامز کو سنیں اور خود قرآن کو پڑھیں تو آپکے علم میں حیرت انگیز اضافہ ہوگا
Alhamdulillah, you are very grate Islamic scholar in the present world.
ماشاءاللہ غامدی صاحب بڑے آدمی ہیں اللہ تعالیٰ ان کو ہدایت عطا فرمائے ( اللہ تعالیٰ جس کو چاہتا ہے ہدایت دیتا ہے ()
Jazak ALLAH.....MAY ALLAH BLESS GHAMDI SB WITH BEST OF HEALTH, AAMEEN
اپنا نقطہ نظر تہذیب کے دائرے میں رہ کر کسی پر طنز کئے بعیر پیش کرنا کوئ غامدی صاحب کے مثل کوئ نہ دیکھا نہ سنا جزاک اللہ
Respect gambdi sahab i disagree with your argument about beard
Ilmi pont 1 beard is a sunnah of all the prophets peace be upon them
Ilmi point 2 Hadith of sahi Bukhari
May allah bless you give hidayat to me and you and also no one will disagree on me that you are present philosopher, think tank,leader of Muslim youth
Jajakallah Khair
The only living legend between earth and sky who knows the actual
Islam and he describes it.
You can accept or deny him, but cannot ignore him.
No doubt
General ulamas talks according to ones own firqa, while ghamdee sb is a researcher n philosopher. His views are tested n verified.
He is not a philosopher btw
Aqeel Hassan so what do you call someone who has done his bachelors in philosophy? An engineer?
@@faryalnajam7348 not engineer but being a philosopher means one have command over Aristotle , Platonian, Bu Ali sina ,Suharwardi and Mulla Sadra Shirazi etc, these were philosophers
Philosophy is a special subject which deals with existence qua existence
وجود بما ھو وجود
فلسفہ کا موضوع وجود ہے چاہے وہ ماقبل الطبیعت ہو یا ما بعد الطبیعت ہو
Hope you understand
غامدی کو ghamdeeلکھا اسکا مطلب یہ ہے کہ آپ بھی زبان، مکان، علاقہ کے مطابق فرقہ بنالیتے ہیں۔
@@faryalnajam7348 .
جزاک اللہ
اپ کی کاوش کو اور ہمت کو سلام
واقعی اپ قابل رشک ہیں
اللہ کریم اپ کو ہمیشہ سچ کا حق کا ساتھی بنائے اور شاد و کامران فرمائے
سب کو سلام دعا پیار
Deen ka ilm rkhna tw aik Bari Bat ha lkn us sa bhi behtreen chez us Deen ko intehayi khobsorat or jamiya Andaz sa or ilm o fehm ki roshni ma boht hi logical Andaz ma logo tk pohnchana ha ...jo GHAMIDI sahab sa behtreen koi ni krskta MashALLAH bhot khob❤️
The most inspiring and rational Islamic scholar in present world. May Allah bless him long life. It’s so unfortunate that scholars like him are not safe in their own Islamic country. Few others are killed by extremists. I wish to meet Ghamidi Sahab and will definitely try to visit his maktab in Texas.
Allah swt has blessed this man with such a great knowledge and wisdom May Allah swt protect him preserve him increase him further knowledge and wisdom Ameen- May Allah swt accept his services for ISLAM. Every Muslims must listen and learn from him
Ghamdi sahib is highly educated scholar.
May Allah Rabul Aleem bless him with health and prosperity.
Ameen ya Rabul Almeen
As salaam Alaikum. Thanks a lot for providing the closed captions in english! Great work , Jazak Allah khair!
What is name of beard or dadi. In Arbi language, please tell me
Only genius of Ghamidi could do the work on reconstruction of religious thought!. Salute to Ghamidi sahab
From prophet muhammad saw....this man is only against the beard... reincarnation of Jesus... denying the meraj....brother Allah aapko Shi salamat rkhe
@@mohammadrashidansari3750 He is not against beard. He just says it is not sunnah. His definition of sunnah is more comprehensive. Regarding his views on jesus and Mehdi, they are already there in our classical literature by some scholars. He places more emphasis on tawatur of amal than akhbaar e ahaad. Do listen to him without prejudice
خالسار زرا مختلف مکتبہ فکر سے تعلق رکھتا ہے۔
مگر خاکسار اپ کے فکر سے ململ طور پر اپ کے ساتھ ہے۔
بلکہ اس وقت میرے مطابق اسلامی دنیا میں اپ سے بہتر کوئی بھی سکالر نہیں ہے۔
جس قدر ہمارے علماء نے اسلام کی خوبصورت شکل کو اس قدر بدصورت بنا کر پیش کیا ہے۔ جس سے پوری دنیا میں بدنامی ہی بدنامی پیدا ہوگئی ہے۔
ان علماء سو سے اللہ ہمیں بچائے۔
اور جو ان کے پیرو کار ہیں اللہ تعالی ان کو بھی ہدایت دے۔ امین
اللہ تعالی ہمیشہ اپ کے ساتھ رہے۔
Due to Some Ulama week points you can not accept Ghamdi and Pervaizi ideology as correct ideology as neglecting Sahih Hadith is same as rejection of Sahih Hadith and not following Prophet's way of spending life and what he told us to follow. And following Ghamdi Sahib misinterpretation of Quran according to Ghamdi logic is total misguiding and going stray from Deen -e - Islam. So beware of such wrong interpretation of Islam.
Allama Tahir ul qadri shb k paon ki joti k bhi barabar nahi
Ameen
A R Ahmed ghamdi sahib is big Islamic scholar, God bless him.
Imran Shah bahi deen kisi ki meras nahi ap gulv ker rehay han , man bhi tarhir ul qadri sahib ko qadr ki niga say daikta hon unho nay buhat acha kam kia hay , laikan kafi galtian bhi ki han , na man gamdi sahib sat is mozo pay agree kerta hon
Very nice man. I love the way he explains. May Allah bless him Ameen
جاوید احمد غامدی اس دور کے بہترین مفکر ہیں جو اسلا، اور جدیدیت پر بہت بہترین فکری کام کر رہے ہیں
غامدی صاحب کو سنا ہے، اور علماء کرام بھی سنے ہیں،
دین کا سب سے مشکل پہلو جس پر ہم بالکل ناکام ہیں تقریباً 99.99 فیصد وہ اخلاق ہے.
کیا چھوٹے کیا بڑے 😪😥😪😭
اللہ تعالٰی کا دین بہت پیارا اور آسان ہے ہم نے خود مشکل بنا لیا ہوا ہے...
I feel Myself addict of his lectures & MashaAllah ghamdi sahib is doing wonderful job..
Advocate For YOU true
Same here :) Even though I only understand probably 50% of urdu!!
بہتر دین بال سے زیادہ باریک ہے اللہ تعالی ہر مومن و مومنات کو دین کی صحیح سمجھ عطا فرما دے نبی پاک صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے فرمایا قرآن کے علاوہ اور بھی بہت سے احکامات نازل ہواوے جو ہمیں سیرت پاک سے ملیں گے
السلام علیکم. آپ کا یہ نقطہ نظر کے آج ہمارے بہت سی مذہبی شخصیات اور علماء جو پہلے علماء نے دینی تحقیقات کی ہیں اسکو ماننا اپنے آپ پر فرض کیا ہے پر دین اسلام میں اور قرآن میں فکر و تدبر ضروری ہے اور تحقیق اور جدید توجیہات نکالنا چاہیے، میں آپ سے بالکل متفق ہوں.. اللہ تعالیٰ سے دعا ہے کہ اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کے اس مشن کی اعانت کرے اور آپ کو جزائے خیر عطا فرمائے آمین یا رب العالمین 🌷
Jazakallah Kairan
Allah Kareem Ghamidi sahib ko Ajaray Azeem ata farmaay.
Well he is forward and logical speaker. He is great scholar. I have some objections but he is a decent man.
He's brilliant and we need more scholars like you you say the right thing without emotion but that what is true
Ghamdhi is a great scholar and teacher. May Allah protect him. Allah Bless you and forgive your faults. May he give you high ranks in Jannah.
Great & Most Inspiring Person... Stay blessed. Ameen!
Love and Respect for this great scholar 🙏🏻 May Almighty Allah bless him with a long and healthy life!
The interviewer has to be like this. His style of asking querions, framing of questions, tone, respect towards Mr. Ghamidi, his way of showing disagreement or doubt according to the view of the audience etc is just perfect. I really appreciate him. And I really like Mr. Ghamidi's deep study and his perspective about the religion. May Allah be kind to all of us.
Ghamdi saahib we love you aap ki waja se Allah ne mujhe seedha raasta dikhya Allah ap jese ulmaa ko salamat rakhe
Her kism k taasub'aat se buland ho ker apne aap pr tanqeed ko civilized manner me sun'na aur samjh'na, aur phir khalis ilm aur daleel ki roshni me jawab dena, ghamdi sb ka khasa hai. Werna humare haa'n k so called ulamas apne galat rawaey se deen ki Reactionary interpretation krte nazer aatey haie. Masha'Allah. Allah Ghamdi sb ko duniya aur aakherat me asaniyaa'n aur jaza e khair ataa ferma'ey. Ameen.
These so called ulama cant reach his wisdom and knowledge. He put the real face of religion in front of the world . A great scholar.
Absolutely correct analysis
Not put the real face but he changed the real face of Islam for his self - wishes.
Jazakallah…iss bayaan se maine daarhi ki haisiat ke ilaawa deen ka insan ki zindagi mei asal maqsad aur Allah SWT ki khwahish ke mutabiq insan kaese hona chahiye seekha…meri boht se shukok o shubhaat jo main deem ke hawaale se sochta tha k humaara deen itna tang nazar kyu hy ? Alhamdulillah iss bayaan ke baad maine jaan liya k deen tang nazar nhi blke Allah SWT ki demand kuch oor jo loogo ne ghlt ta,assur liya hy awr usay deem smjha hy
I am satisfied
Kal main iss topic ka part 2 sunoonga
Allah aap dono ko apni khaas fazal mein rakhein
MashaAllah. Very nice and informative lecture. Allah ap ko bohat ziyada ajer ata karay. Ameen
One of the best Scolare Mr Ghamdi is. May Allha give him the rewards for his work.
Ghamdi sahib sood ya interest ko jaaez qrar dete hain. Aap apni aakhrit kharab na karein
Allah apka saya ham sb muslmano py qaim o daim rakhy sir👍❤❤❤
Ghamdi sahab Allah Ta’ala aap ko lambi zindagi ataa karay.
السلام علیکم ورحمۃ اللہ وبرکاتہ غامدی صاحب اللہ آپ کا حامی و ناصر ہو اللہ آپ کو جزائے خیر عطا کریں اللہ آپ کو اجر عظیم عطا کرے اللہ آپ کی محنت کو ضائع نہیں کرے گا
I really appreciate patience Ghamidi sb shows while replying to questions
Jee aap ghamdee sahab kee tahqueequ ko saheeh kehte ho kyoke woh aapke nazriyaat ke akkasee karte hai,aapko bhee dadhee rakhne se nafrat hai ya majboore hai aur unko bhee!!!!!!
@@anwarahmad6816 aap ghamidi sahab ki baat dehan aur tahamul se sunay jis tarha wo tahamul se baat ker rhay hai.
Ghamidi Sir You r a learned man. Proud of you.
Ghamdi sahab ka bat kerney ka andaz bohet hi khubsuret hey
MashaAllah
Molvis of Pakistan has left no stone unturned to break ruin our religion into pieces
Mashallah Ghamdi Sahab has reunited our religion 👍👍
We are blessed to have him in our midst. May Almighty Allah bless him and give him strength to serve his Deen more.
Ghamdi sahib sood ya interest ko jaaez qrar dete hain
@@sidsid9808 No he doesn't. Get your facts straight
@@4311446 Yes he is . not only interest many other islamic teachings and aqeedah he is not accepting as he do not follow Sunnah and Hadith and do interpretation of Quran from his own mind.
@@YasirIslam01 buddy I have studied all arguments against him in detail. I am convinced he is right after listening to his counter arguments. You do your own research instead of following anyone blindly.
@@4311446 Bro , i am not following anyone blindly, I just follow Quran and Sunnah. But the followers; and lovers of Ghamdi sahib seem to follow him blindly. Thats called Shakseeyat Parasti. Giving not importance to what Prophet Mohammed ( peace be upon him) asked from us in Sahih Hadith in love for Ghamdi Sahib is not acceptable. How come your research and my research have different results because you are wearing Ghamdi Sahib Glasses. You have to take of those glasses and then study those point from Sahih Bukhari and Sahib Muslim which he is keeping aside. The agenda of Ghamdi and Pervaiz Sahib will be exposed. And the agenda is to bring youth and intellectuals to wrong ideology and 90 percent of Islamic teachings are kept aside. So everyone will be happy to just follow 10 percent of Islam, as this is Human nature to stay in comfort zone. But as Prophet Mohammed said, for a believer or Momen this world is like a Jail. So for you definitely this world will be full of entertainment as according to Ghamdi Music is Halal, females can have mixed gathering with males, not covering hairs. I can give here many points which are mentioned in Sahih Hadith but Mr. Ghamdi is not accepting those facts, why because he said they are not part of Deen since they are in Hadith nor Quran. What is practised since 1400 in the whole world Ghamdi, Ghulam Ahmed Pervaiz and Sir Syed Ahmed Khan is denying all that. May Allah give strength to us and our youth to do research with open Heart leaving behind Shakhsiyat of Ghamdi. As he will not come in Akhirat to save us. We have to be answerable to Allah for neglecting Allah commandments and Prophet teachings.
He is an educated person he is not a typical molvii I think he explain everything beautifully and simply
For this excellent public service
Allah SWT bless you and your beloved ones with health happiness wisdom compassion and tranquility and serenity and love Ameen
ہمارے علماء نے یہ اصول اختیار کر لیا ہے۔۔۔۔۔کہ جو کچھ ہم نے اپنے بزرگوں سے سنا ہے اپنے اکابر سے سنا ہے اس کو ہم چیلنج نہیں کرینگے۔۔۔۔ تو میں تو یہ کہتا ہوں کہ میں نے یہ کام کیا ہے۔۔۔۔اور میرے نزدیک یہ دور حاضر کی ناگزیر ضرورت ہے۔ غامدی۔♥️
Sukriya my honorable teacher Javed Ahmed ghamidi .
I like to thank almighty Allah that I have been receiving the real knowledge of Islam through Ghamidi sahab in 21th century.
I also pray to almighty Allah that Allah give long life to ghamidi sahab.
Thanks from India
Ghamidi is the best ever. I couldn't find any renowned scholar who has good conduct, knowledge, dim accent, a dignified character, unnecessary and avoiding non-standard conversation etc. etc.
Ghamidi sahab is ABSOLUTELY correct in his articulate analysis of the hadith related to beards. Note that even Abu Jahl had a beard. He was not a Muslim. Sikhs and Hindus grow beards too. They are not Muslims. The main difference between the outward appearance of bearded folk in all faiths is that (except for Amish) , the Muslims should NOT wear long thick moustaches, the beard (lihya ie the chin beard or goatee) may be grown to the length of a fist IF DESIRED. The wujub in the hadith points to shortening or trimming the moustache, not to the growing of beards.
That he offends the Sufi or tasawuff inspired Islam as well as Shias as well as Deobandis as well as Qadianis is reason enough for me to believe that he is right. Problem is most people don’t have the brains to understand what he is saying. They just need stories using provocative words and attacks on other schools of thoughts. Ghamidi sahab is above all that.
Ghamdi is matchless Islamic epistamologist,deep thinker nd great Scholar of the time
May Allah bestow more blessings on ustaz
Amin
Ameen
Very well explanation...depicts real picture of islam...not traditional deen...May Allah bless him always...
mjhe ziyaada tu nhi maloom Javed shb ke baare mai lekin jis tarah Sir ne smjhaya buht pyyari tarah explain kiya hai... Allah pak Javed shb ko sehat wali zindagi aata kre...
Please try adding English subtitles so non-Urdu speaking can also benefit from his immense knowledge
One of the greatest mind of our time. Pure genius Ghamdi sb.
اس شخص کے بارے میں ایک ہی جملہ کہوں گا کہ یہ شخص "عقلانی" ہے. اور عقلانی منکر سنت ہوتا ہے، اللہ اسے ھدایت دے.
MAN YOU ARE SUCH À GREAT GENIUS MAN OF THIS ERA😘
TOP LEVEL INTELLECT😎
U r the man who should come in Pakistan's politics and you are the man who can change this corruption çulture
U are a precious gem of Pakistan
You should çollabrate with fellow people fighters and step in Pakistan's politics
Like this comment so this appears on top