As amazing as this performance is here is my 'what if' question: What if the two male lead actors Tim Minchin and Ben Forster did a performance where they reversed their roles? That is, Minchin plays JC and Forster plays Judas.
I am a huge fan of Tim's but I honestly think that lightening would possibly hit the stage. /s Seriously, it could be interesting, I do believe Tim could kill it.
Would loved to have seen this, but the Ted Neely / Carl Anderson film and theatre performances were such a profoundly powerful experience for me (mum and dad took me to cinema at 3 yrs old in 1973) it will always be the version against which all others are judged. Plus I think the original album had a great funk / rock vibe which really helped to develop the underlying tension and passion. This is the way it should be played IMO. In short, if you are going to produce "your new vision" of JCSS, it better be REALLY, really good. Otherwise, you are essentially disrespecting what time has proven to be a very inspiring, moving and important masterpiece.
I mean, it was the composer's "new vision" so I guess he gets to do what he wants with it, and it's kind of weird to say that the composer is "disrespecting" his own work. Especially as the composer himself thought the movie was a "vulgar travesty" in his words. So YMMV but just sometimes, the newer version is better (and I say that as someone who was born in the 70s and grew up on musical theatre).
I listened to the original cast record hundreds of times as a kid. But there’s a 2005 remaster of the 1996 revival cast that has a fuller, funkier orchestration that I think is even better than the original.
Tim 'Autotune' Minchin was the absolute worst Judas I've ever seen in 40 years of watching this show.....to think he took up a place that might have gone to an unknown but talented performer, and changed their life and career.......such a pity.
I personally think he did an amazing job. His acting and singing was on point and it’s unfortunate that they made the decision to auto tune him when he didn’t need it. (Also he said he wasn’t happy about the auto tuning)
What did you dislike about his performance? I thought he was brilliant and gave a nuanced performance as Judas. He did not want auto tune and was quite unhappy when it was used.
Is this Twitter? All the worst takes in the history of existence belong there, leave CZcams alone, seriously, Minchin nailed it, he's not the best singer among all the Judases (he still can sing quite well, obviously) but the emotional interpretation was superb.
Judas’s death is so sad now that i actually saw it. Like, the sunset/rise and everything... it pulls on my heart strings
It literally took my breath away the first time I saw it, I couldn't breathe and there may have been ugly sobbing.
Thank you!
This behind the scenes footage is wonderful!
I was lucky enough to see this Live in Melbourne, Australia
This is really intriguing
As amazing as this performance is here is my 'what if' question: What if the two male lead actors Tim Minchin and Ben Forster did a performance where they reversed their roles? That is, Minchin plays JC and Forster plays Judas.
Tony Finoro Tim would have stolen the show whatever.
@@torideffee3192 I agree. Tim definitely has the talent for it.
@@torideffee3192 Tim and Ben are both very talented and work very well together especially in their given roles.
I am a huge fan of Tim's but I honestly think that lightening would possibly hit the stage. /s Seriously, it could be interesting, I do believe Tim could kill it.
I love this ❤️
Poor Judas...beautiful☺
Would loved to have seen this, but the Ted Neely / Carl Anderson film and theatre performances were such a profoundly powerful experience for me (mum and dad took me to cinema at 3 yrs old in 1973) it will always be the version against which all others are judged. Plus I think the original album had a great funk / rock vibe which really helped to develop the underlying tension and passion. This is the way it should be played IMO. In short, if you are going to produce "your new vision" of JCSS, it better be REALLY, really good. Otherwise, you are essentially disrespecting what time has proven to be a very inspiring, moving and important masterpiece.
I mean, it was the composer's "new vision" so I guess he gets to do what he wants with it, and it's kind of weird to say that the composer is "disrespecting" his own work. Especially as the composer himself thought the movie was a "vulgar travesty" in his words. So YMMV but just sometimes, the newer version is better (and I say that as someone who was born in the 70s and grew up on musical theatre).
I listened to the original cast record hundreds of times as a kid. But there’s a 2005 remaster of the 1996 revival cast that has a fuller, funkier orchestration that I think is even better than the original.
Thumbnail looked like Rob Zombie.
Rob zombie does look a bit like Tim Minchin.
@@jmp_fr Thumbnail. Small. Little detail.
20:09 Name?
Not 1p0% sure but I think its melanie c
It's Samantha Jackson. She is the redhead dancer/ensemble
yees
Dyamnod
8:13
Tim 'Autotune' Minchin was the absolute worst Judas I've ever seen in 40 years of watching this show.....to think he took up a place that might have gone to an unknown but talented performer, and changed their life and career.......such a pity.
I personally think he did an amazing job. His acting and singing was on point and it’s unfortunate that they made the decision to auto tune him when he didn’t need it. (Also he said he wasn’t happy about the auto tuning)
What did you dislike about his performance? I thought he was brilliant and gave a nuanced performance
as Judas. He did not want auto tune and was quite unhappy when it was used.
Well, aren’t you stupid.
Is this Twitter? All the worst takes in the history of existence belong there, leave CZcams alone, seriously, Minchin nailed it, he's not the best singer among all the Judases (he still can sing quite well, obviously) but the emotional interpretation was superb.