Why is China cracking down on it's own tech businesses?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 25. 07. 2021
  • Derek Scissors from the American Enterprise Institute joins The Exchange with Kelly Evans to discuss China's regulatory crackdowns on tech and education. There's going to be a booming tech sector in China, Scissor says, but under their own rules. For access to live and exclusive video from CNBC subscribe to CNBC PRO: cnb.cx/2NGeIvi
    Two U.S.-listed Chinese education stocks plunged Friday after reports of a government crackdown on the sector that included bans on foreign investment.
    TAL Education shares tumbled 70.8%. New Oriental Education and Technology shares dropped by 54.2%.
    The reports come as Chinese authorities stepped up restrictions in recent months on the private education industry, and increased scrutiny on domestic companies listing overseas in the U.S.
    Caixin, a major Chinese financial news site, reported Friday that new Chinese government restrictions on the education sector were starting to be implemented in Beijing and other cities nationwide.
    Copies of the policy document were circulating online Friday afternoon.
    Educational training institutions are banned from raising money through stock listings, while foreign capital cannot invest, according to a copy of the Chinese-language document seen and translated by CNBC. It was dated July 19 as issued from the top executive body - the State Council - and the Chinese Communist Party’s central committee.
    One of the bans on foreign investment included variable interest entities, a common structure by which Chinese companies use to list in the U.S. Existing violations of the capital bans must be addressed, the document said.
    CNBC has not independently verified the document. The Ministry of Education did not immediately respond to a faxed request for comment outside of Beijing business hours.
    A policy document of the same name - referring to lowering costs for after-school tutoring - was among five approved at a May 21 meeting chaired by Chinese President Xi Jinping. The version circulating Friday banned after-school tutoring businesses from advertising, and said they could not operate during public holidays, weekends and winter and summer vacations.
    New Oriental Education declined to comment to CNBC, and TAL did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
    The stock plunges followed sharp declines for education stocks traded in Hong Kong, which began to drop in the afternoon.
    Shares of New Oriental’s Hong Kong-listed subsidiary Koolearn fell 28% on Friday.
    UBS analyst Felix Liu said in a note Friday the firm was putting its ratings on TAL, New Oriental and Koolearn under review “given the potential substantial impacts to fundamentals and the reported regulation pending official confirmation.”
    » Subscribe to CNBC TV: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCtelevision
    » Subscribe to CNBC: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBC
    » Subscribe to CNBC Classic: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCclassic
    Turn to CNBC TV for the latest stock market news and analysis. From market futures to live price updates CNBC is the leader in business news worldwide.
    The News with Shepard Smith is CNBC’s daily news podcast providing deep, non-partisan coverage and perspective on the day’s most important stories. Available to listen by 8:30pm ET / 5:30pm PT daily beginning September 30: www.cnbc.com/2020/09/29/the-n...
    Connect with CNBC News Online
    Get the latest news: www.cnbc.com/
    Follow CNBC on LinkedIn: cnb.cx/LinkedInCNBC
    Follow CNBC News on Facebook: cnb.cx/LikeCNBC
    Follow CNBC News on Twitter: cnb.cx/FollowCNBC
    Follow CNBC News on Instagram: cnb.cx/InstagramCNBC
    www.cnbc.com/select/best-cred...
    #CNBC
    #CNBCTV

Komentáře • 1K

  • @mohdhakim6510
    @mohdhakim6510 Před 2 lety +666

    Investing in bitcoin is the best gift ever you can give yourself at this point in time especially when you have a good and honest trader

    • @fanandofanadez3389
      @fanandofanadez3389 Před 2 lety

      Yes

    • @mohdhakim6510
      @mohdhakim6510 Před 2 lety

      Mrs maria jones is legit and her method of trading works like magic shes one step ahead of other traders.

    • @juicersreed5233
      @juicersreed5233 Před 2 lety

      wow I am just shocked someone mentioned expert Mrs Maria Jones I thought I'm the only one trading with her

    • @juicersreed5233
      @juicersreed5233 Před 2 lety

      She helped me recover all I lost trying to trade myself

    • @usmanpedro9912
      @usmanpedro9912 Před 2 lety

      I think I am blessed because if not I wouldn't have met someone who is as spectacular as expert Mrs Maria Jones

  • @lyttlebee
    @lyttlebee Před 2 lety +467

    In China the party controls corporations, in the US, corporations control the party.

    • @osamabagdadi5789
      @osamabagdadi5789 Před 2 lety +16

      In China the party control every aspect of your life. Watch everything you do and everything u spend

    • @bigbigapple7280
      @bigbigapple7280 Před 2 lety +56

      @@osamabagdadi5789 Damn. Its 2021 already bruh.

    • @wongjerry3103
      @wongjerry3103 Před 2 lety +3

      @@osamabagdadi5789 weapon your mind

    • @lyttlebee
      @lyttlebee Před 2 lety +71

      @@osamabagdadi5789 every aspect of my lfe? like what i wear and eat every day? dude, you are so brainwashed by western MSM.

    • @leeben7605
      @leeben7605 Před 2 lety +7

      @@bigbigapple7280 In your dream and fake Western media, yes. Not the reality.

  • @amandang6604
    @amandang6604 Před 2 lety +655

    Short answer: the party doesn’t want billionaires and millionaires to dictate what happens in their country.

    • @jordanhoward7629
      @jordanhoward7629 Před 2 lety +33

      Who do you think makes up the party?

    • @wei270
      @wei270 Před 2 lety +91

      but if you look at the US market where the economic rules are basely made by the large corporation, the corporation are really making rules that protect them self's at the expense of average consumers.

    • @jordanhoward7629
      @jordanhoward7629 Před 2 lety +10

      @Antonio Yun Yang Wu Chen millionaire and billionaire tycoons

    • @mindtwister1984
      @mindtwister1984 Před 2 lety +3

      @Gaussianform Only on the media. It is just a masquerade. Politicians use consumer sentiments to gain a leverrage on the jostling of power handlers.

    • @LesliePeter
      @LesliePeter Před 2 lety +30

      The US could not expect any good results of the bilateral ties with its policy of suppressing China.
      China should teach US how to treat other countries equally.
      No country is superior to others,
      and China will never accept any country
      that thinks of itself this way.
      US raised again the so-called rules-based order.
      If the rules are made by the US and it's allies,
      what justifies them to impose those rules on China?
      High tariffs the US imposed on Chinese goods
      violate WTO rules and unilateral sanctions violate international rules.
      Shouldn't the US be the one to reflect to those rules?
      Hasn't the US been trying to contain China,
      thinking that will solve its problems,
      as if the only way for the US to become great again
      is to contain China's development?
      Hasn't the US hoped that
      by demonizing China,
      it could shift domestic public discontent over political, economic and social issues and blame China for its own structural problems?

  • @fredsaga3708
    @fredsaga3708 Před 2 lety +69

    simple answer: in China, capital must work for the long term goods of the majority of the Chinese people, and the government fulfill this goal for the people. In the US, capital pursues maximizing profit, and fulfill this goal by controlling the government.

    • @winlaw3571
      @winlaw3571 Před 2 lety +2

      If you reside or live in USA it is not good for you to tell the true or bad behavior of your own arrogant government?controlled by rich idiotic guys.

    • @alexzen751
      @alexzen751 Před 2 lety +2

      Chinese government is the richest organization in the world, and they also have many privileges covered up. don't pretend that you did not knew. Power/authority is more evil than capital.

    • @winlaw3571
      @winlaw3571 Před 2 lety +3

      @@alexzen751 Do you want to say Trump is not a cheater or Lair or criminal. Trump says all American governments and politicians are lair for their own sakes but idiotic Trump does and did it openly. Capitalists control the USA governments to lie other nations or own people for their own sakes. Israel is allowed to bombs Palestinian from USA governments when USA capitalists are making money by selling weapons to Arab world in fighting each others stirred by Israel government. Israel government and people are rewarded by USA governments approved by USA capitalists under the one of the names of National endowment of democracy or different NGO.

    • @damien9683
      @damien9683 Před 2 lety

      I've seen far too many videos that show that any Chinese citizen that is NOT a CCP member is treated LESS than people (Getting their land taken away, releasing dam water in flood risk areas without NOTIFYING anyone etc )
      Plus Chinese governments are *subservient* to the CCP so the government basically control EVERYTHING....

    • @youareajackass2005
      @youareajackass2005 Před 2 lety

      @@damien9683 that is true but I gotta say it 4 x harder to control its population than US. With 1.4 billion people, even food is a problem. To put things into perspective. Just read Indian news. They are democratic FYI. Open your mind up a little bit bud.

  • @sngs9565
    @sngs9565 Před 2 lety +21

    At least, China walks the talk! Well, can't be said the same with US...All the time CEO comes to hearings...what is that for? No action after that?

  • @heinzreudigiger9485
    @heinzreudigiger9485 Před 2 lety +53

    They want to avoid building a plutocratic class like what's happened in the US. Smart move if you asked me.

    • @nzmanhdee6246
      @nzmanhdee6246 Před 2 lety +2

      The CCP officials are a plutocrat 😂

    • @maniaouri2146
      @maniaouri2146 Před 2 lety +18

      the western Governments are enslaved by Giant corporations and politicians are their puppets

    • @leeming2781
      @leeming2781 Před 2 lety +4

      @@nzmanhdee6246 You're right if people in the West were like you, I'd be relieved

    • @jerryxie777
      @jerryxie777 Před 2 lety +6

      I'm Chinese, I'm willing to immigrant to the stupid USA,will you willing to move to communism China ?🙂

  • @urbandiscipline8858
    @urbandiscipline8858 Před 2 lety +169

    China cracks down on monopolistic companies. That's a good thing.

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety +13

      Lol, it’s for CCP total power in their dictatorship

    • @jukio02
      @jukio02 Před 2 lety +36

      @@itrthho They don't want corporations or billionaires to take over China, like what has happened here in the US.

    • @ggt8194
      @ggt8194 Před 2 lety +8

      @@jukio02 They are already a communist dictatorship. The people don't even have any control there. The US is far superior to China politically, & the only people who appear to be bitter by that fact, are far left & far right parasites.

    • @jukio02
      @jukio02 Před 2 lety +10

      @@ggt8194 Well, what works for the US, may not work for China. China has said that their political system is not for everyone. I don't think there is such a thing as superior, just differences.

    • @osamabagdadi5789
      @osamabagdadi5789 Před 2 lety +2

      @@jukio02 they don’t want anyone to have as much voice as CCP

  • @mmahan523
    @mmahan523 Před 2 lety +88

    Finally someone who isnt fear mongering and knows that this happens every couple of years. Instead of these other shills saying SELL EVERYTHING.

    • @Haitatchi
      @Haitatchi Před 2 lety +6

      The more they fearmonger, the better become the buying opportunities.

    • @Mrbfgray
      @Mrbfgray Před 2 lety +6

      Partially agree but Russian example says otherwise and I have a host of reasons to avoid China stocks. There are plenty of other great opportunities. The CCP will do whatever it takes to control the ppl and preserve itself...the good side is that wealth generation is a crucial part of appeasing the repressed population, but CCP paranoia?....who knows where that goes.

    • @scottyflintstone
      @scottyflintstone Před 2 lety

      Chinese stocks are good for day trading only

    • @mmahan523
      @mmahan523 Před 2 lety

      @@scottyflintstone day trading? Only if you have puts lol.

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety

      Seal all CCP stocks

  • @guillermotraverso4112
    @guillermotraverso4112 Před 2 lety +90

    this man knows what he is talking about. First time I see somebody speaking about Chinese stocks that is talking with sense.

    • @arentube8123
      @arentube8123 Před 2 lety +2

      He is making light of the fact that they took investment funds for these tutoring companies under the guise of allowing foreigners to be shareholders and then wiped out the value of those shares by declaring all tutoring companies non-profit. They gave no warning. They might as well have just stolen those investor's money. The effect is the same. They could logically do the same thing for any security. I don't know how you evaluate that risk as an investor. You have to ask yourself, if you own Chinese stocks, do you actually own anything?

    • @InteOMG
      @InteOMG Před 2 lety +11

      @@arentube8123 As investor, you'd better understand the company your are investing. Education system in China is a public system (or say state-owned system). The after school tutoring companies are actually privatizing the system. Privatizing education and healthy/hospital industries are highly sensitive subjects in China. These companies were walking on a cord for a few years. If you have these information, you probably should have withdrew long before they are punched.

    • @InteOMG
      @InteOMG Před 2 lety +3

      @@arentube8123 The goverment in China does not represent but just tolerant of private investors. They claim they are the representatives and pioneers of the labors and peasants. Political policy risks have always been the major risk when investing CHINA. From this perspective, no need to blame the CCP actually. Investing CHINA is a gambling and everyone knows what will happen eventually. It is just someone escaped with fat money and someone captured. You don't blame the other side when you lose in a gambling right?

    • @arentube8123
      @arentube8123 Před 2 lety

      @@InteOMG The CCP should state that officially. See what happens.

    • @xinfuxia3809
      @xinfuxia3809 Před 2 lety +1

      He even casually pronounced Xi Jinping in perfect Chinese. I’ve never met a white American who can pronounces the “x” in Chinese.

  • @titansnorth7520
    @titansnorth7520 Před 2 lety +10

    Derek mades a lot of sense! He put everything in perceptive and help me understand what is going on better.

  • @robertsmart5600
    @robertsmart5600 Před 2 lety +16

    China is “preventing capital from expanding in a disorderly fashion,” which led to the USA 2008 world financial crash!
    "The Chinese state guides capital and private entities towards what it believes are national strategic priorities, rather than allowing them to simply focus on generating greater revenue."
    Jack Ma of Alipay & Ant thought he could prioritize profit, he was told this is not the Chinese way!
    Perhaps the US Government needs to outsource re-education of US corporate bosses to China and divert the obscene profits they make plus most of the overblown US defense budget to lifting Americans out of poverty and repairing the crumbling infrastructure in the USA?
    President Xi Jinping was sent to work on a farm in the country in his youth to rid him of his political delusions.

    • @isaacvitela5131
      @isaacvitela5131 Před 2 lety +1

      this is more of a power move within china specifically as the video mentions that the ccp is in charge if you do business with them. That is just gravy, but the real motive is that xi's faction is in a small conflict with jiang zamin's faction. The two hate each other to oblivion even if they had a similar goal. Since most of jiang's boys are invested or linked to the said tech companies. It seems like a smart move for xi to crackdown on those companies and remove those folks so that xi's power goes unchallenged.

    • @ironanchor167
      @ironanchor167 Před 2 lety +1

      >>> "Jack Ma of Alipay & Ant thought he could prioritize profit, he was told this is not the Chinese way! "
      That's good for the Chinese public.

    • @forgaoqiang
      @forgaoqiang Před 2 lety

      blaming China for your capitalist's greedy ?

  • @frankwiersma7980
    @frankwiersma7980 Před 2 lety +8

    Regulation in education was long overdue, just like stopping the restrictions on Chinese companies to choose between Baba and JD. Making this into a crackdown on tech is just ridiculous.

  • @scottyflintstone
    @scottyflintstone Před 2 lety +27

    Simple. Stop buying Chinese stocks.

    • @keithbrown3045
      @keithbrown3045 Před 2 lety

      Right

    • @GregACL971
      @GregACL971 Před 2 lety +10

      BS! Keep buying

    • @LesliePeter
      @LesliePeter Před 2 lety +2

      With the US' sudden withdrawal from Afghanistan
      the deteriorating security situation in Afghanistan
      could mean a complete collapse of India's investment in the region,
      which could be a heavy blow to the Indian government.
      India is dissatisfied with the US on the vaccine,
      as the US has been hoarding doses
      while Indians suffer from vaccine shortages.
      The US might promise more vaccines to the epidemic-battered country,
      it seems that the gesture would turn out to be an empty promise.
      The US has been bugging India with "human rights concerns"
      after India introduced a Citizenship Amendment Bill
      that Western voices deemed "anti-Muslim discrimination.
      ‘It may be dangerous to be America's enemy,
      but to be America's friend is fatal.’ said Henry Kissinger

    • @kevngu7256
      @kevngu7256 Před 2 lety +3

      Go ahead stop buying . So I can get even cheaper.

    • @LesliePeter
      @LesliePeter Před 2 lety +5

      Hasn’t the US tried to bring Chinese companies down
      by signing an executive order - expanding a blacklist of Chinese companies,
      claiming ‘the threat posed by the Chinese military
      through Huawei, Semiconductor and China Aerospace Science and Technology companies?
      The executive order bans Americans from investing in them
      and will come into effect on 2 August.
      Isn’t US paranoid attitude to suppress China's development?
      It doesn’t matter who’s in the White House,
      the US will keep cracking down on China and it’ll only get worse.
      The blacklist has caused nothing but harm
      causing chaos in the US after it was released.
      The New York Stock Exchange announced to delist three Chinese telecommunications companies,
      then reversed its decision,
      and then decided to delist them again.
      It's not how a mature market player is supposed to behave.
      After winning a lawsuit, Xiaomi and Luokung were removed from the blacklist.
      This proved that the blacklist lacks legal support.
      Hasn’t the US used unfair competition practices
      because it lacks confidence in having a fair competition with China?
      This is how absurd the US position is
      doesn't practise the democracy and free trade it preaches.

  • @lordlee6473
    @lordlee6473 Před 2 lety +50

    This guest actually knows what he is talking about

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety

      Nope

    • @simonking3949
      @simonking3949 Před 2 lety

      You are being sarcastic, right?

    • @attsealevel
      @attsealevel Před 2 lety

      Absurd interview. China's primary goal:
      -- to Reduce Foreign Ownership across corporate China
      Ancillary goals:
      -- to Damage Foreign Investors
      -- to Instill Risk and controls across China Exchanges,
      -- to Reign in technoChina

  • @zetajolyne3689
    @zetajolyne3689 Před 2 lety +5

    South Korea has higher admission pressure of high education than China, but the per capita consumption of the education business is lower than in China. This is abnormal, the advertising bombing and anxiety created by commercial that make parents anxious far beyond they can afford. In China, cram schools have become a burden that seriously affects the economic of regular families and the health of children, so the government has decisively performed an excision operation.

  • @mattpatrick2564
    @mattpatrick2564 Před 2 lety +28

    The US government wants to do the same with our tech companies too; they just have to dance around how they do it.

    • @MelaninMagdalene
      @MelaninMagdalene Před 2 lety +3

      They can’t do anything with tech companies but use them for all the data that will better help them control people.

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety

      Wrong

  • @davidli9457
    @davidli9457 Před 2 lety +15

    Amazon makes billions of dollars each year while paying ZERO corporate tax. Way to go in America!

    • @ironanchor167
      @ironanchor167 Před 2 lety

      Amazon also makes billions from the US govt. Microsoft got a $10B IT contract from the US govt.

    • @davidli9457
      @davidli9457 Před 2 lety

      @@ironanchor167 I don't know if Microsoft paid any corporate tax each year. I know a lot of giant corporations didn't. Now here comes the gigantic infrastructure bill...

    • @wilfredtankhoonpheow2605
      @wilfredtankhoonpheow2605 Před 2 lety

      Amazon pays billions to politicians

  • @pierren___
    @pierren___ Před 2 lety +8

    And they are right. Congratulations China 👌

  • @dread69420
    @dread69420 Před 2 lety +10

    Government is the coach. They set the rules. Corporations are players. They should follow them.
    Unlike the US, where the players make their own rules, either directly or indirectly.

  • @LesliePeter
    @LesliePeter Před 2 lety +19

    China bans ‘after-school tutoring companies’
    from raising money through stock market listings.
    ‘If the best way to get into good schools
    is by taking private tutoring courses,
    then rich kids will have an unfair advantage over poor ones.’
    The tutoring boom has worried China
    as it has put heavy workload on students and financial burden on parents.
    The average tutoring fees accounted for 30% of the family's total annual spending.
    Some Chinese parents support the policy,
    as they hope their children have more time for themselves
    and they’ll have less financial burden.

  • @ClownTrader1
    @ClownTrader1 Před 2 lety +10

    "Too big to fail..."
    Hmm. Where have i heard that before 😐

    • @user-ej9uu2jy8k
      @user-ej9uu2jy8k Před 2 lety

      Thanks for watching,
      I have something real big I’d Love to introduce you to for huge profits making.....
      T.E.X.T / \W•H•A•T•S•A•P•P•
      +•1•3•8•6•4•0•0•2•5•3•9,

    • @lazyhusband
      @lazyhusband Před 2 lety

      In an Evergrande office?

  • @beginnerquant6261
    @beginnerquant6261 Před 2 lety +29

    China just does not want to be kidnapped by capital. Companies should earn clean profits , not by unfair monopoly or hurting people or society.

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety +9

      The CCP is the monopoly

    • @BY-sf6dn
      @BY-sf6dn Před 2 lety +2

      @@itrthho idoit

    • @terriecooperman7232
      @terriecooperman7232 Před 2 lety

      That's funny cause it's america companies paying for thier forced labor camps workforce,or cheap labor. cannon Hasbro Nike,and list goes on.under Marxist only 1 percent gets the profits while the 90 percent our slaves,lie paid

    • @R3tr0v1ru5
      @R3tr0v1ru5 Před 2 lety +2

      Name me one legitimate monopoly in China other than the CCP.

    • @i0iicetea538
      @i0iicetea538 Před 2 lety +2

      China is the only one who is doing the kidnapping (journalist, reporters, doctors, people who practice Islam, Jack Ma). Trust me, my family is from HK. Nothing safe or free there under the thumb of CCP.

  • @fredpohl1352
    @fredpohl1352 Před 2 lety +5

    Why do we only get advice about China from USA writers? We want advice from Chinese people as well.

  • @robertwatling5842
    @robertwatling5842 Před 2 lety +3

    Absolute greed is absolute stupidity and this is where companies fall

  • @mr_five
    @mr_five Před 2 lety +34

    Finally someone who does not follow the herd!!

    • @mr_five
      @mr_five Před 2 lety

      @Gaussianform I don't think it will be the crackdown per SE until there is a republican senate, congress and president then and only then will one should be concern.

    • @MelaninMagdalene
      @MelaninMagdalene Před 2 lety

      @Gaussianform
      Crackdown? What crackdown?

    • @oceanwave4502
      @oceanwave4502 Před 2 lety

      The moment you realize China is a 5000-year civilization...

    • @mr_five
      @mr_five Před 2 lety +1

      @@benchoflemons398 those Chinese tech stock rallies says you are. Your internet name is fitting.

    • @attsealevel
      @attsealevel Před 2 lety

      Absurd interview. China's primary goal:
      -- to Reduce Foreign Ownership across corporate China
      Ancillary goals:
      -- to Damage Foreign Investors
      -- to Instill Risk and controls across China Exchanges,
      -- to Reign in technoChina

  • @loosabarba6920
    @loosabarba6920 Před 2 lety +7

    They are preparing for the worst. Brace the impact

  • @ikm64
    @ikm64 Před 2 lety +1

    When your enemy finds themself in a hole...make sure ya pass a shovel.

  • @xinwangjerry
    @xinwangjerry Před 2 lety +14

    What I love about this video is this dude understand so little abt both Chinese government and the new policy regarding the online education companies but he still found a way to swing this topic by saying non-sense. GOOD JOB!

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety +3

      Enlighten us, CCP Bot

    • @FrameDrumAndFlute
      @FrameDrumAndFlute Před 2 lety

      Your comment is like so many I see on CZcams. All you're saying is; "He's wrong, I'm right", but no explanation is given. Why bother?

    • @magicmagus1459
      @magicmagus1459 Před 2 lety

      Even your CCP mouthpiece global times changes their position every two seconds. No one knows what the CCP is thinking. They are not accountable to their people, they can do whatever they want. In the west, you consistently have to tell the people what it is that u r doing and people will hold u to account. NO such thing exists in China, CCP is a monopoly. This itself is an irony considering they claim "they want to bring down monopolies".

  • @fernandobenitez9814
    @fernandobenitez9814 Před 2 lety +4

    Chine doesn't want the tech companies to be in control because they hold the data, once you hold the Data you can see trends and see what could possibly be next and when that happens when Tech companies are efficient, Like Google, Amazon, Apple, and Facebook they have monopolies on all sectors cause they own the software. THE RICHER GET RICHER

  • @MegaPapa8888
    @MegaPapa8888 Před 2 lety +27

    China is trying to level the playing field that these big tech companies currently hold. We are doing the same in a more subtle way.

    • @user-rq9cs8gx5t
      @user-rq9cs8gx5t Před 2 lety +4

      Without the malicious sanctions imposed by the United States, China will become stronger at an unimaginable speed.

    • @anonymousanonymous4690
      @anonymousanonymous4690 Před 2 lety +2

      @@user-rq9cs8gx5t maybe if you guys stop eating rats and bats you’ll grow at an even higher rate 😳

    • @user-rq9cs8gx5t
      @user-rq9cs8gx5t Před 2 lety

      @@anonymousanonymous4690 The average height in China is not lower than yours

  • @kellyy5834
    @kellyy5834 Před 2 lety +1

    Refreshingly objective👍

  • @MrKT410
    @MrKT410 Před 2 lety +11

    Owning an Alibaba with an expected return of 10%/yr is probably a mistake given its risk as a Chinese stocks. But the return over the next 5 years is likely 20%/yr. The stock has no business being this cheap other than fear mongering and anti-china sentiment.

  • @orokato
    @orokato Před 2 lety +6

    China puts social interests before cootporates while supporting company and economical growth. Ying & Yang. Non-binary social policy

  • @philipjackson5671
    @philipjackson5671 Před 2 lety +36

    *The philosophy of the rich and the poor is this: the rich invest their money and spend what is left. The poor spend their money and invest what is left"*

    • @ricardoalvarez3404
      @ricardoalvarez3404 Před 2 lety

      Investing in today is priceless because tomorrow isn't promised, trading Bitcoins,gold, silver and crypto secure a better Tomorrow.

    • @edwardkenneth2088
      @edwardkenneth2088 Před 2 lety

      @Brenda As a newbie investing in crypto will be best for you, I know of a portfolio/investment manager, Mr MICHAEL WAYNE and expertist in trade investment as you don't have to under go any stress in the trades, he manages my trading..

    • @barbarahilton4080
      @barbarahilton4080 Před 2 lety

      I'm happy to see Mr MICHAEL WAYNE mentioned here, My spouse recommended him to me after investing £4000 and he has really helped us financially in thu times of COVID-19 lockdown here in Australia

    • @porterjames2220
      @porterjames2220 Před 2 lety

      Exactly, money is always eager and ready to work for anyone who is already to employ it, I was able to withdraw my profit of $17,000 after investing $3,500 with Mr Michael Wayne some weeks ago

    • @stonescholes242
      @stonescholes242 Před 2 lety

      @@porterjames2220 Please do you mind sharing any means of reaching out to him easily? I'm really interested I believe this is genuine.

  • @bruceli9094
    @bruceli9094 Před 2 lety +1

    China: All foreigners get out!
    India: Hello world.

  • @vivek78359
    @vivek78359 Před 2 lety

    Good questions !

  • @darkjohnson7253
    @darkjohnson7253 Před 2 lety +9

    more intellectual guests are normally on during kelly evans' timeslot. this guy knows his stuff.

  • @ltchuan03
    @ltchuan03 Před 2 lety +4

    Simple answer is to offload chinese share to US retail at high price then dump it. 😀

  • @loveandpeace8760
    @loveandpeace8760 Před 2 lety +2

    The Chinese government is trying to level the playing field. It's good for competition & for the long run.

    • @isaacvitela5131
      @isaacvitela5131 Před 2 lety +1

      no, it's a power move and xi mostly done it to rat out any jiang zamin loyalists that invested in those companies. Plus how is it leveling the playing field when you investment value is intentionally driven down rather than by errors of the companies?

  • @Wongseifu548
    @Wongseifu548 Před 2 lety +2

    No company likes to hear you have a ceiling and that you have now reached it.

    • @MelaninMagdalene
      @MelaninMagdalene Před 2 lety +2

      In the US you can be as crooked as Enron and fleece investors

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety

      @@MelaninMagdalene they went to prison.

    • @MelaninMagdalene
      @MelaninMagdalene Před 2 lety

      @@itrthho
      The smart Asian bailed before they went down with his $200mil, one killed themself & the ceo is out working on another business scam, I mean plan.

  • @dannyhang7482
    @dannyhang7482 Před 2 lety +4

    I hope this people know what they talk about or just preaching .

    • @williamy45
      @williamy45 Před 2 lety +1

      I'll be surprised if they do... just jokers dressed like reporters or experts, saying things that their target audience like to hear.... job done

  • @Zen-rb9pd
    @Zen-rb9pd Před 2 lety +17

    As a Chinese, I am surprised by the objectivity of the guest commentator. When you invite someone to bash China, there is zero value to the audience. This guy didn’t really say anything that is new or different from what know (from many Chinese media sources), but it felt so refreshing to hear anyone on western media talking about China without demolishing China.

    • @jongxina4908
      @jongxina4908 Před 2 lety +6

      I don't think bashing chinese people is the objective of anyone.
      Bashing CCP and their sympathizers is the goal and rightfully so.
      I really have sympathy for the normal chinese citizens(even the hyper-nationalistic ones) that they have to live under such regime.

    • @Zen-rb9pd
      @Zen-rb9pd Před 2 lety +5

      @@jongxina4908 if you are sincerely good-intentioned, I recommend you to visit China and see it yourself. Be brave to change your mind though.

    • @Zen-rb9pd
      @Zen-rb9pd Před 2 lety +3

      @@deesus1085 I am okay. I understand it is about money. The problem is, the business model is based on creating fears and hatred among people, intentionally or not. That makes it immoral.

    • @daniel7385
      @daniel7385 Před 2 lety +3

      @@jongxina4908 I guess you would be really disappointed if you went to China and found how happy people feel about their situation at the moment. There's future for young generations. And people really believe if wasn't CPC, all these couldn't have happened in the last 3 decades. The road for the team who are trying to get the CPC down is long, because no one in that team really know what the Chinese normal people really expect. CPC is like the roof of the building where Chinese all live in. If someone comes to them and say that I likevyou people, but your roof is really bad roof, so I am going to smash it. So, with the storm happening outside, do you think people in the building really trust it? Not mentioning that the roof has been continously improving itself to become a better roof covering people underneath...

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety

      Bashing corrupt CCP not China

  • @babuuaden3615
    @babuuaden3615 Před 2 lety

    Very good analysis really. We as America need to be competitive and improve our service back and abroad. America is all about good image. The government need to look on our companies abroad and give them the tools they need to be competitive.

  • @dantan8863
    @dantan8863 Před 2 lety +1

    Listening to these analyst / advisors from western world, no wonder China is having an upper hand...

  • @kaitang3666
    @kaitang3666 Před 2 lety +13

    when your competitor knows nothing about you(and they pretend they know a lot). that's good'

  • @dinotin1984
    @dinotin1984 Před 2 lety +10

    recent CCP official has mentioned that the medium & small business benefit the general population more. this leads to the thinking that the big tech's are probably too big and the government is already loosing control on them. the crack down is about to gain control of the capitals. Whether this is a good thing or not really depends on how you look at it, good for the government and small business, and bad for the big tech and their investors.

  • @jp5978
    @jp5978 Před 2 lety

    Liquidate or crash whatever market you need in order to payout for the MOASS🤷🏾‍♂️

  • @shadowpuppy9816
    @shadowpuppy9816 Před 2 lety

    space, research, information, resources

  • @bradschmittling8118
    @bradschmittling8118 Před 2 lety +4

    Because they see what is happening here dau

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety

      Nope

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety

      @@blokin5039 nope, the CEOS don’t disappear

  • @Rich_Mond007
    @Rich_Mond007 Před 2 lety +7

    Showing the U.S they do not want monopoly power like the fang stocks and no bailouts for Zombie companies. Good job! Watching and waiting in the sidelines! Lol

  • @Coach1pourcent
    @Coach1pourcent Před 2 lety +1

    Do you think , it s time to invest in ehang? I ve got an average at 42 usd

    • @maryjackson9118
      @maryjackson9118 Před 2 lety

      I will strongly advice you against self
      trading, it's really dangerous and had
      brought so many investors down, you need
      some one with the knowledge and
      strategies, someone dedicated to the
      crypto currency market buisness, and I will
      strongly recommend expert Mrs Tessy

  • @alextan6551
    @alextan6551 Před 2 lety +2

    Alibaba is undervalued now.. But upside is capped

  • @tmoney7128
    @tmoney7128 Před 2 lety +3

    I only have 3 Chinese stock, I am thinking of selling them.

    • @Mesozoic_mammal
      @Mesozoic_mammal Před 2 lety

      Best time to sell if every body hast panic and things are down. Best time to buy when every one is buying. Buy high sell low, that is the secret!
      And everytime there are bad news, it means the world is about to end.
      So better sell now, tomorrow china will amnex all companies and turn 120% communist again.

    • @generaldanielr.hokanson3768
      @generaldanielr.hokanson3768 Před 2 lety

      To who

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety

      Cell CCP stocks

    • @tmoney7128
      @tmoney7128 Před 2 lety

      @@generaldanielr.hokanson3768 you

  • @kingkemet2527
    @kingkemet2527 Před 2 lety +5

    It’s all about control

    • @forgaoqiang
      @forgaoqiang Před 2 lety

      Of course it's about control, just like the USA, the company control the government, and even how you thinks by their media

  • @rexmundi273
    @rexmundi273 Před 2 lety +1

    Simple, Chinese government doesn't want massive bubbles like the US stock market.

    • @user-ej9uu2jy8k
      @user-ej9uu2jy8k Před 2 lety

      Thanks for watching,
      I have something real big I’d Love to introduce you to for huge profits making.....
      T.E.X.T / \W•H•A•T•S•A•P•P•
      +•1•3•8•6•4•0•0•2•5•3•9

  • @kenleygilbert
    @kenleygilbert Před 2 lety +1

    How do i go about suing the Chinese government

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety

      You can try but it won’t work. Waste of money

  • @ubiquitous888
    @ubiquitous888 Před 2 lety +7

    It’s a good correction as this prevents monopoly. Isn’t this align with the western world, anti-monopoly? Just saying.

    • @kchoo1118
      @kchoo1118 Před 2 lety +5

      From reading western media, I understand that the bottom line is that anything China does is not aligned with the western world, even if the western world is doing the same thing. Recently China forced a minimum wage for delivery persons and western media reports that it is a bad thing. I would bet that if China removes this minimum wage, the media will say human rights violation.

    • @awesome9174
      @awesome9174 Před 2 lety +2

      @@kchoo1118 China also has concentration camps dude. They're evil.

    • @kchoo1118
      @kchoo1118 Před 2 lety +1

      @@awesome9174 Maybe or maybe not, I don't know. But the point is that the media should try to be objective. They can report bad things as bad and good things as good. Instead, everything is twisted to fit the current agenda.
      I am definitely sure China has done shady things, but similarly the US has also done shady things (Iraq). No country is pure angel or pure evil.

    • @hakunamatata887
      @hakunamatata887 Před 2 lety

      With the past western world, you missed a word, the president western world famous known as too big to fail, just saying

    • @JigilJigil
      @JigilJigil Před 2 lety

      @@kchoo1118 Comparison between China and US is like comparing mass murder serial killer psychopath (China) with an angel, I am not saying US have never done anything wrong as they did but CCP is pure evil, they are a country with a 1.5 billlion people at size of a continent and the level of the suppression and authoritarainism is unequaled, freedom of speech and basic human rights has no meaning for China's regime.

  • @kaitang3666
    @kaitang3666 Před 2 lety +4

    After reading the comments, clearly nobody in the US have any idea about China(but they pretend the do)

  • @deconfiver
    @deconfiver Před 2 lety

    So they can scoop up dip prices

  • @mid191
    @mid191 Před 2 lety

    Question would america halt american retirement funds from entering the Chinese stock markets

  • @chrisbentsen1
    @chrisbentsen1 Před 2 lety +8

    " regulators don't want them to become to large or profitable". Why would anybody ever invest in Chinese stocks?

    • @godzillamothra5983
      @godzillamothra5983 Před 2 lety +6

      you may not want to invest, but I would live in a nation that isn't controlled by the top one percent.

    • @chrisbentsen1
      @chrisbentsen1 Před 2 lety +3

      @@godzillamothra5983 while China as a whole has some favorable attributes such as getting things done quickly such ad building hospitals and erecting high speed rail it is not a hospitable environment for investors.

    • @godzillamothra5983
      @godzillamothra5983 Před 2 lety +8

      @@chrisbentsen1
      I think there should be a middle way between China model and the US model. Too much free wheeling capitalism isn't good either. When the tech giants become too dominant, they basically become monopoly. China cracked down on tech giants, will hammer their investors for sure, but it will be good for the market in the long run. Nobody in the western media ever reported how the tech giants in China suppressed their smaller competitors, believe me, it isn't pretty. As for the crack down on tutoring, anyone living in Asia can tell you how overpriced those tutoring are, and how dubious the return is for those students and parents who basically paid with their blood and sweat.

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety

      Don’t invest In CCP stocks

    • @godzillamothra5983
      @godzillamothra5983 Před 2 lety +1

      @@itrthho
      too late for them, LOL

  • @lexneuron
    @lexneuron Před 2 lety +7

    Smart measures to prevent corporate oligarchs from taking over the country, which the US should have done at least half a century ago.

  • @beastno8
    @beastno8 Před 2 lety

    Hope all people in your country could be as smart this commentator. 👍

  • @rayjr7417
    @rayjr7417 Před 2 lety

    The spectacle of corporate media disingenuously equivocating private capital with the state...dystopian.

  • @kaynscorpio1094
    @kaynscorpio1094 Před 2 lety +6

    In year 2077, Tech corporations will rule the city. Government can do nothing but join them.

  • @Chrisfeb68
    @Chrisfeb68 Před 2 lety +21

    I think this is good for the United States…As long as you’re not invested in Chinese stocks.

    • @weiskl887
      @weiskl887 Před 2 lety +1

      LOL Amateur. Information or data is Power. If US does not want all their Fortune 500 company data in the hand of the Chinese why would the Chinese want the US Govt to have all the data of Important and strategic Corporations in China? And in terms of Fraud or artificial fake numbers remember Enron? Massive accounting fraud is specialty of US corporations as well.

    • @weiskl887
      @weiskl887 Před 2 lety +3

      @@benchoflemons398 Goldman sachs is responsible for the Biggest fraud so far for 1mdb the Malaysian sovereign fund. Literally accounting fraud done by all US accounting firms like Arthur anderson and co.

    • @RedShiftedDollar
      @RedShiftedDollar Před 2 lety

      Name one US company that doesn’t have a factory in China. If China cracks down on their own businesses, what are they capable of doing to foreign businesses? Say goodbye to your factories soon.

    • @Chrisfeb68
      @Chrisfeb68 Před 2 lety

      @@RedShiftedDollar Palantir.

    • @Chrisfeb68
      @Chrisfeb68 Před 2 lety

      @linkzable I have a “sizable account thank you. I wouldn’t touch Robin Hood. Sounds like you have some major anger issues to work out. God bless.

  • @techcrush4450
    @techcrush4450 Před 2 lety +1

    US have to put regulation on chinese investor in american company because i think may be they can affect US tech so my humbling request to US to put more strictly regulation on chinese investor who invest in american company

  • @timestandstill
    @timestandstill Před 2 lety +1

    China should change government towards Industrial & Technological Revolution as well as welcome free enterprise.

  • @yeahyeah9856
    @yeahyeah9856 Před 2 lety +3

    Why are we asking aei for this question. They are a partisan institute that cares more about political influence than reality.

  • @apemoney6841
    @apemoney6841 Před 2 lety +7

    This dude saying it is normal to nationalize the education companies without giving a dime to its business owners is beyond believe , who would invest in any chinese company given that at any time the goverment can wipe out any industry?

    • @carlmannhard8051
      @carlmannhard8051 Před 2 lety +6

      The American model of squeezing students for profit is really the worst model ever. Look at where that has led. National student debt crisis, families going bankrupt between paying medical bills and tuition. My point is, if nationalizing schooling can make the system better and more equal then that could be a good thing in the long run.
      Some things are more important than profit. Universal education is such a thing

    • @apemoney6841
      @apemoney6841 Před 2 lety +3

      @@carlmannhard8051 read my comment properly, I am not against altruistic education policies , the issue is that they nationalized companies owned by US investors without paying a single dime for the business which basically is stealing , if they want to nationalize the company to help the kids, buy it at a fair price don´t do what castro did back in cuba. disgusting!!!

    • @carlmannhard8051
      @carlmannhard8051 Před 2 lety +1

      @@apemoney6841 Ah, right you are! Didn't catch that. Yes, that is absolutely unacceptable.

    • @apemoney6841
      @apemoney6841 Před 2 lety +3

      @@carlmannhard8051 yes horrible look at TAL education, they took US investors money and then banned their rights to the business overnight , and the US goverment just let these companies continue to trade in our exchanges.

    • @LesliePeter
      @LesliePeter Před 2 lety

      With the US' sudden withdrawal from Afghanistan
      the deteriorating security situation in Afghanistan
      could mean a complete collapse of India's investment in the region,
      which could be a heavy blow to the Indian government.
      India is dissatisfied with the US on the vaccine,
      as the US has been hoarding doses
      while Indians suffer from vaccine shortages.
      The US might promise more vaccines to the epidemic-battered country,
      it seems that the gesture would turn out to be an empty promise.
      The US has been bugging India with "human rights concerns"
      after India introduced a Citizenship Amendment Bill
      that Western voices deemed "anti-Muslim discrimination.
      ‘It may be dangerous to be America's enemy,
      but to be America's friend is fatal.’ said Henry Kissinger

  • @wric01
    @wric01 Před 2 lety

    The mass benefits from regulating these tech monopolies. Competition creates jobs.

  • @shinramx
    @shinramx Před 2 lety

    4:10 Sad Laptop, only black screen and dekstop idle and sitting for nothing .... and yet the cameramen being focus on laptop.

  • @LaudvekkysGrooveLab
    @LaudvekkysGrooveLab Před 2 lety +6

    Salute to the CCP

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety

      CCP Bot Alert 🚨

    • @bento8711
      @bento8711 Před 2 lety

      @@itrthho 🤣🤣🤣

    • @forgaoqiang
      @forgaoqiang Před 2 lety

      BTW, Actually, it's CPC, the CCP is the way of calling by the ignorance and arrogance western media

  • @robertoortega5979
    @robertoortega5979 Před 2 lety +5

    Buy buy buy!

    • @itrthho
      @itrthho Před 2 lety

      Sell, Mortimer...sell!

  • @VChong1991
    @VChong1991 Před 2 lety +1

    Why does cnbc slander without remorse?

  • @gward117
    @gward117 Před 2 lety

    NIO will probably run off of 5G. CHWRF houses almost all of China's 5G tower infrastructure. American 5G tower companies are AMT, CCI, SBAC. Can anyone address the reason why this stock is so inexpensive other than they are almost complete with the towers which was costly but also 5G isn't in full swing yet? Also Barrens is the only place I could find financials on CHWRF.

  • @method341
    @method341 Před 2 lety +3

    Remember folks, what's cheap is cheap for a reason and it can always get cheaper.

  • @hennessyblack5891
    @hennessyblack5891 Před 2 lety +3

    Should I buy these falling stocks??

    • @robertoortega5979
      @robertoortega5979 Před 2 lety +5

      Yes if you want a great return and are willing to wait.

    • @hennessyblack5891
      @hennessyblack5891 Před 2 lety +1

      @@robertoortega5979 good answer

    • @hennessyblack5891
      @hennessyblack5891 Před 2 lety +1

      @@deesus1085 asking for a friend

    • @Mesozoic_mammal
      @Mesozoic_mammal Před 2 lety

      You should not ask strangers on the internet which stocks to buy. If you are not certain yourself don't buy any individual stock, or you might panic sell during the next bad news.
      Instead go with a broad etf (dollar cost averaging) over a long time. That ways you have a save steady investment rather than gambling based on the youtube amswers you get

    • @hennessyblack5891
      @hennessyblack5891 Před 2 lety +1

      @@Mesozoic_mammal asking for another CZcamsr

  • @aidanheffernan652
    @aidanheffernan652 Před 2 lety +2

    gawd dam it Shepard Smith why u always gotta keep interrupting at the end.......im sick of that ending tbh

    • @user-ej9uu2jy8k
      @user-ej9uu2jy8k Před 2 lety

      Thanks for watching,
      I have something real big I’d Love to introduce you to for huge profits making.....
      T.E.X.T / \W•H•A•T•S•A•P•P•
      +•1•3•8•6•4•0•0•2•5•3•9

  • @ironanchor167
    @ironanchor167 Před 2 lety +1

    At least China has executed the execs who played with children's lives (I think last was a baby formula case). In the US, the corporate walks away by paying few paltry percent of their profits and execs who knew dangers and still caused many deaths are never punished. A corporation doesn't make wrong decision to put profits ahead of lives, it is the officers who make such decisions for own gain.

    • @Ex.zed.
      @Ex.zed. Před 2 lety

      Because you don't have companies putting melamine in baby formula in the US. And this is only if the many fake stuff they produce in China.

    • @ironanchor167
      @ironanchor167 Před 2 lety

      @@Ex.zed. Dvmb ahs, how about cigarettes, asbestos, Lipitor, Vicodin, Yaz, Chantix, and recently Sackler family involved in OxyContin opiods? All those execs knew the lethal dangers of their products, meaning people could and did die from their products, but they also knew the corporate structure and laws in the US will let them walk away scot free. So they made millions and billions and paid 5% to 10% in restitution or fines, while keeping the rest. Learn how corporate structure shields white collar crime.

  • @metchandara
    @metchandara Před 2 lety +7

    THe US gov is controlled by the big tech, but not in China. salute to Chinese gov.

    • @nomisage
      @nomisage Před 2 lety

      @@deesus1085 regulation is normal. they do it at the expense for the people because they don't know better such as quarantining for covid19.

    • @Wongseifu548
      @Wongseifu548 Před 2 lety

      Yeah your just controlled by a dictator who going to hurt your economy

    • @metchandara
      @metchandara Před 2 lety

      @@deesus1085 YOu have been listened by US agent NSA what ever you do. Just ask Edward Snowden if you don't believe me. much better!!

    • @metchandara
      @metchandara Před 2 lety +1

      @@Wongseifu548 you talking about a US dictator??? I believe US is going to hurt their own economy more cause they print out money from the air. Do you see inflation in the US?

  • @patsully2413
    @patsully2413 Před 2 lety +3

    Bitcoin is money, everything else is just credit. Like it or not Bitcoin is the future of asset investing.

  • @wl7427
    @wl7427 Před 2 lety

    why would a Chinese parent punish their own child? This is Asian culture, the pain of nurturing the child; tough love.

  • @kushajagarwal9761
    @kushajagarwal9761 Před 2 lety +1

    As an Indian this crackdown is helping our startup eco - investor's wealth is moving from China to India

    • @levelazn
      @levelazn Před 2 lety

      india needs a cultural shift before it can catch up to china. as does the rest of the world

    • @spider6660
      @spider6660 Před 2 lety +1

      In India, Reliance and Adani controls everything and poor people are starving.

  • @peterroberts2952
    @peterroberts2952 Před 2 lety

    The US should learn some government regulation. The monopolies will not be allowed.

  • @ronaldmcdonaldtrump4446

    Real reason they dont want the corporations to be tooo big to handle

  • @cklim3614
    @cklim3614 Před 2 lety +1

    It is Trumpet delisted Chinese companies

  • @Daniel-rj2mf
    @Daniel-rj2mf Před 2 lety +1

    FUD

  • @focusezz6947
    @focusezz6947 Před 2 lety

    its*

  • @333crt
    @333crt Před 2 lety

    Beijing is concerned about people's private data getting shared. Isn't that a legitimate concern?

  • @chaochengtan
    @chaochengtan Před 2 lety

    1, Ready for delink with the US financially
    2, Anti-trust, the techs have to be under certain control

  • @gargamelandrudmila8078

    Not a single US investor owns (in the wester sense of law) directly stock in a Chinese listed company, that operates in mainland China.
    So what exposure are investors exposed to....well not what they think they are exposed to.

  • @lokechanmun8587
    @lokechanmun8587 Před 2 lety

    These Americans seemed to know China better than the Chinese.

  • @9559tommy
    @9559tommy Před 2 lety +2

    Sold all my Chinese stocks . Won’t be buying ever again.

  • @peterkumaryadavsinghkhan1650

    Usa used to crackdown Microsoft Google atnt.

  • @MaxDangerPower
    @MaxDangerPower Před 2 lety

    its = belonging to it - it's = it is
    Why is China cracking down on it is own tech businesses?

  • @fayning
    @fayning Před 2 lety +1

    Well put, Chinese Tech comapanies become utilites

  • @nicksardelli890
    @nicksardelli890 Před 2 lety

    Its***

  • @elidyson256
    @elidyson256 Před 2 lety

    So they can see how far they can control

  • @anthonyyee8121
    @anthonyyee8121 Před 2 lety +2

    This is what a good government should do... to ensure the welfare of the people & national interest are not over exploited by private enterprises before it get out of hand.