Alternative Narratives of India's Freedom Struggle |
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 09. 2024
- Watch a panel discussion moderated by Hindol Sengupta featuring Kishwar Desai, Prasenjit Basu, Sanjeev Sanyal & Saradindu Mukherji at Dabur Red Paste presents Arth - A Culture Fest held at Indira Gandhi National Center for Arts (IGNCA), Delhi on February 8-9-10, 2019.
www.arth.live
Arth - A Culture Fest isn’t merely a festival, but a culture quest that will keep alive the meaning of our culture. This festival will focus on literature, culture, society, music, traditions, history and art. We are creating a platform for lovers of art and culture to learn and celebrate Indian culture across all its dimensions.
Subscribe to our channel: / arthaculturefest
Follow Arth on Twitter: / arth_live
Like Arth on Facebook: / arthlive
Follow Arth on Instagram: / arth_live
Prasenjit Basu is holding the mic like a gun, always ready to fight.
All the panelists made excellent points. We have to move away from history propagated by Congress and Britishers.
Tamil Culture -An Intergral Part of Sanatana Dharma: Aravindan NeelakandanWATCH: czcams.com/video/QryC0as2fp0/video.html
What I hate in all non-Left seminars, we take larger subjects n wish to finish in 1hour, mistake of Organisers.
On each issue, We need to week long workshops with experts on relevant subject presenting their findings followed by panel discussion and Questions.
sangam talks and indic do that the are on youtube do check out
Great great discussion!!
It's incredible, how the energy of the Indian freedom struggle; was modulated to transmit a narrative that would ensure that the people who were near the center of power would be able to cling it, generation after generation!!
Kishwar Desai..blowing the punjab trumpt was really unrefined!!
The time limit of the show is less, whenever you want to have debate on such big issues, then please conduct the show from the viewpoint of the yougsters who want to have conclusive and good debate and that can only be possible once the each debator gets enough time to express their complete view.
So kindly Extend the Timing otherwise this is just the going to be the same as we have inconclusive debates.
Its my humble request.
#Jai bharat
Yes I agree with u.m every time the moderator simply nails down both the panelists and the audience who wants to ask questions. Plz look into this.
It’s amazing to listen to all these stories. However the contributions of freedom fighters from across the country need to compiled and told. That way people from all states will understand how their native state contributed to the cause of freedom. It is important to remember the contributions of every freedom fighter to the common cause without emphasizing on any one particular state, but rather understanding the contributions of all despite the internal differences.
Make it a 5 hour discussion
Excellent panel .. loved the way the 3 gents opened and destroyed the notion that the freedom struggle started with MK gandhi
Formally rewriting history and making the masses aware of it is definitely going to take time... can we not team up with publications like AMAR CHITRA KATHA and spread true stories to children.
AMC a parallel activity but what's imparted inschools/Univ primary
no child these days r anymore interested in ur books, they have CZcams where they enjoy their favourite videos; jus like others.
Kids cartoons to spread the right history would be great.
I thought I would love most to listen Sanjeev sanyal sir but it was terrific prasenjit Basu who nailed the show.each of them including ofcource hindol sengupta were extremely enlightening and insightful.
Subhas Chandra Bose is undoubtedly greatest national leader of modern India... though I will not believe Nehru was traitor until robust and Cristal clear truth comes out.interpretation can be done to prove anything.
This new generation of historians must contemplate their opinions what type of foundation they are creating for India........
Should've been at least an hour and a half long.
Thank you, all of you and especially Sanjeev Sanyal🙏
🙏🙏🙏🙏Saradhindu Mukherjee - people like him are such bold speakers... despite difficulty in articulating fully their thoughts... they manage to drive home the point...awesome. It is a great amazement that we have people like ConraadElst and Swami DavidFrawley fighting for the cause of Bharat... they must have been some indian freedom fighters in their previous janma...
From the collaborators katha that we now hear... Sir EdwinLutyens did a good job of creating a city for such total antinationals... the same blood continues to ruin...
Tamil Culture -An Intergral Part of Sanatana Dharma: Aravindan NeelakandanWATCH: czcams.com/video/QryC0as2fp0/video.html
1962 :- KISI NHI DESH KE LIYE APNA ZAMIN WAR ME HAR JANA SABSE SHARMANAK ( REAL SHAMEFUL ) HOTA HAI ..... WE HAVE SUFFERED THIS ULTIMATE INSULT IN ... 1962.... . AND THE MORE SHAMEFUL WAS THAT THE 1962 GOVT CONTINUED .......AND STILL THINKING . AND EVEN MORE SHAMEFUL --- PEOPLE ARE USING PRODUCTS OF THAT COUNTRY
Thats a unjust thing to do to give such wonderful discussions the mere time limit of just an hour .... Because this needs a much elaborated and deep discussions and for that matter it requires 2-2.5 hour time!!!
OMG I think Congress has lost all its legacy after this
Fascinating revelations about the many facets of India's freedom struggle against the British. As most panelists said or alluded to, indeed India's freedom struggle as per crony historians of Congress, was thanks to only two people - Mohandas Gandhi and his protege Jawaharlal Nehru. Some panelists narrated shocking duplicity of these leaders, and how they were actually collaborators of the British, and were always appeased by the British as quid pro quo for their 'services'. The discussion also explains why India never setup s "Truth and Reconciliation Commission" that many countries did after they got free from colonial rule, to rewrite their history from their own perspective,not that of their colonizers or their cronies. It's high time India setup a high-level commission to review and rewrite our history books and teach newer generations about the struggles of scores of patriotic nationalists, revolutionaries, and such whose efforts actually made the British leave India, not what BS the crony historians of Congress party have dishes out over the decades. Only then will we overcome the deep-rooted colonial hangover and the tendency to mock native Indian values and eulogize the West and seek approval of the 'white man', so to speak.
The man in suit should be given more time. He had so much of excellent information, much better than other panelists womenspowerbook.org 's view
Thank you for organising such discussion which would compel any Bharatiya to rethink the sacrifices our ancestors made for our future. but Plz increase the time and plz don't abruptly stop both the panelists and the audience. 🙏
Really waiting for a book on indian revolutionary struggle for independence
I enjoy listening to Arth Conversations! Looking forward for more in future :))
Worst thing about this talk is that it ends....I want a compilation of 24hr video...probably it'll quench my thirst upto 10%
Why the hurry to end it so fast?
Thanks 👌 great video
Incredible
Very interesting facts presented .......
Hats off to Prasenjit Basu
Wonderful discussion but the rushed manner in which this was ended was a disgrace to the seriousness of the topic. Each of these speakers should be invited back to give independent talks on the topic.
Its a shame that ... He was not allowed to speak....
But we r told that it's only gandhi & Nehru because of them only we got freedom .
How BJB contributed in nationalist movement?
BJP wasn’t there back then.
@Ron Hak r u kid? 🤣😂
plz see this 👇
czcams.com/video/B9DQoe2d-0k/video.html
So what, it's not about RSS or Modi govt or BJP.
Full history needs to be told.how can we really forget such a tremendous contributions of greatest heroes like Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and just believe one single monochromatic story of how Gandhiji by using nonviolence and charkha got India her freedom....we don't need to malign congress, Gandhiji or even Nehru to uplift Netaji and other revolutionaries.
The moderator is extremely shallow and should shut quite when these wise ones are speaking. So amateur of him.
Tamil Culture -An Intergral Part of Sanatana Dharma: Aravindan NeelakandanWATCH: czcams.com/video/QryC0as2fp0/video.html
It was his job brother.and the organisers were mistaken by giving so less time for such a huge and wide topic.Btw hindol sengupta himself is no less wiser than them.read his book on sardar Patel, swami vivekanand and hinduism those are mind blowing.
They should have been given more time
Man this debate was short.
Bengalis in full force..
All Bengali except Desai madam...
What kind of an anchor ....A complete let down. Shri Prasenajit - Saradindu - Sanjeev Sanyal ...All Stalwarts
It's good that everyone is trying at their level best to invoke bit of light in people's heart but why do you all speak English ? Are you also not in colonial mindset of speaking English. Mass of India don't have that much vocabulary to indulge in this conversation
The moderator, bilkul BC hai
Who mobilzed people with padayatra? Who designed Satyagraha? Who led the Salt Satyagraha? Who was the most unselfish leader? Who did not want any job in the government? Lack of irrationality is a bane of historians. I don't think Nehru was good let alone great human. He praised Stalin in the Parliament house.But Gandhi was different.
No one is undermining Mahatma.He has his unique place as the leader who instilled nationalism among masses and United India as a nation.gandhi was revolutionary leader, political and moral thinker, social activist who perhaps more than anyone else made India as modern India we know.
But the point is Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose was more instrumental in India's independence,he was extremely popular and powerful figure who was at par with Kamal pasha,Sukarno,Leon Trotsky,Che Guevara and George Washington and he and lot of other greatest indian revolutionaries must get their due in official narrative of textbook history.their name should not be written just like footnotes in end of chapters like in ncert and all.
Nataji was liberator,sardar Patel unifier,Dr Ambedkar reformer,pt Nehru the orchitect of modern India.along with Gandhiji they must be named as founding fathers of modern India like is popular in USA
@@VikramSingh-vg7gv Gandhi was compared to Ravana. Gandhi was called stupid. Gandhi was pillorized by likes of Sanjay Dixit. If this is not putting down what else is?
The whites in the audience don’t seem to like the revelations happening here😛
he is living in imagination..
Jhaater baal, Hindol!!!
The anchor (Hindol Sengupta) ought to behave in a more masculine manner devoid of his pretentious mannerisms which through habitual repetition, it seems, has now become a sick behavioural attribute.
chowkidar hi chor hai
Pappu mutra is your theerta we know that