Scott's era was always my favorite. Those couple of albums had a fair number of duds, but the high points were impossibly good... I suppose you could say the same thing about every Descendents/ALL album other than Milo Goes to College, though, to be fair. Songs like "Scary Sad", "Simple Things", "Mary", "She's My Ex", "Fool"... they're utterly impeachable, even to this day. Helped get me through some extremely tough times in my early twenties. "Mary", in particular, still gives me goosebumps every time I listen. I know this was a few years ago now, but it's great to see these guys are still playing and still loving every second of it. The world needs the music of Bill, Karl, Stephen, Scott, Milo, Dave, and Chad more than ever.
@@buzzardsinuses4780 Do not get me wrong, Chad;s tenure is some of the best songwriting the band ever saw. Scott just sounds more... honest? You ever heard him in other bands? He kicks ass
Rick Bannan when Chad sings Scott’s songs, something’s missing from it. It still sounds good though. You might be onto something with that. But I don’t think I can hear Scott singing Original Me, Long Distance, or Fairweather Friend. Different vibes I guess.
I discovered All in 1990 around Allroy’s Revenge , which quickly lead me down the Descendents/All rabbit hole. The debate was going on back then (I.e, who’s the best singer Milo, Dave, or Scott)? Of course Chad wouldn’t enter the debate for a few years. I actually saw All do one of their first shows with Chad in early November of 93, and he was literally still green but did a great job that night at the Night Awl in Pensacola, Fl. Dave’s band Down by Law was one of the openers, and he sang a few with All that night. Anyway at the time and for years Scott was my favorite, and in some ways still is. I love that era. Percolator is just punk rock perfection, and Mary? Come on! Freaking iconic. But now in 2024 it’s like asking me which version of the Beatles was the best, to which I’d reply, “all of them” Chad is a phenomenal singer and brought his own contributions and style that fit the band perfectly at the time. Over the past 30 years Milo has become a better singer than he was in the early days. We saw the Descendents in March of this year, and Milo killed it. All are great, and we should All strive for All. All are the Descendents of greatness, and the two are one in All.
For my tastes vocally it was ALLways the Scott years. Being born in 1972 I’ve seen a lot of great songwriters and singers come and go, but my top three for their word-age and melodic skills and play on words and use of creative verbi-age is 1. Scott Reynolds, 2. Greg Graffin, 3. Dicky Barrett… Raw awesome talent and style from those guys.
Me gusta ALL con cada uno de sus vocalistas. Con Dave tienen algunas de las canciones clásicas. Chad es realmente un gran cantante, amo su voz. Y Scott es Scott... ALL, Boca y vino para todo el pueblo Argentino, salud! Saludos desde Monte Grande, Argentina!
ALL is ALL with Scott. He had such a cool voice. He does not seam to be able to sing it like he used to. When did he get buff? Super cool to see them together again. Thanks for posting.
It seemed like it was as much that he had a hard time hearing himself. On the 'quieter' songs even late in the set, he was hitting the notes. That plus probably not having to belt out those songs (which are super hard to sing) for so long probably didn't help. But I agree- ALL is ALL with Scott. He's such a great singer.
I guess I am in the minority. I was the hugest Descendents fan. I only played the Descendents in my car. I saw the Descendents a few times in the 1980s. All came and I adjusted to Dave Smalley. I then travelled to see All in Phoenix (I live in Orange County, CA) with Scott singing and I was so turned off I missed the Chad Price (my favorite All singer) years. I didn't come back until the Descendents reformed. Milo / Chad/ Dave / Scott is my hierarchy. I missed a lot of great music because of that guy.
This is my favorite ALL line up, though either Scott has not sang much recently and his pitch control is rough, Flat on nearly everything... or he can't hear shit in his monitor mix (which is fairly unlikely at their level, plus the other 3 are playing spot on so that says their monitors are pretty well mixed). Still cool to see them together again.
Good observation. As much as I love Smalley, this lineup might be my favorite as well. I'm a huge DAG NASTY fan so I have a soft spot in my heart for Dave, but "Allroy's Revenge" was the first ALL stuff I ever heard in 1989. "Sum" is probably one of the best songs they wrote with this lineup.
he's flat on the louder songs because he can't hear himself. You can see him plug his ears before each song to hear himself first. Matching voice pitch is hella difficult when you can barely hear yourself sing
Scott's era was always my favorite. Those couple of albums had a fair number of duds, but the high points were impossibly good... I suppose you could say the same thing about every Descendents/ALL album other than Milo Goes to College, though, to be fair. Songs like "Scary Sad", "Simple Things", "Mary", "She's My Ex", "Fool"... they're utterly impeachable, even to this day. Helped get me through some extremely tough times in my early twenties. "Mary", in particular, still gives me goosebumps every time I listen. I know this was a few years ago now, but it's great to see these guys are still playing and still loving every second of it. The world needs the music of Bill, Karl, Stephen, Scott, Milo, Dave, and Chad more than ever.
Thanks for sharing this great performance!
Agree there were definitely duds during the Scott era, but Revenge is a good album from front to back. Better than a lot of Descendents albums too.
Allroy Saves is in my top 5 albums of all time. That album is so underappreciated
Such a fun night.
Scott will forever be my favorite
Rick Bannan as much as I really love chad, I honestly might like Scott more.
@@buzzardsinuses4780 Do not get me wrong, Chad;s tenure is some of the best songwriting the band ever saw. Scott just sounds more... honest? You ever heard him in other bands? He kicks ass
Rick Bannan when Chad sings Scott’s songs, something’s missing from it. It still sounds good though. You might be onto something with that.
But I don’t think I can hear Scott singing Original Me, Long Distance, or Fairweather Friend. Different vibes I guess.
@@buzzardsinuses4780 Yeah those should be "Price" songs (I'd say 'Chad' songs but given current memes, not the best)
Me also, Scott is the best!
I discovered All in 1990 around Allroy’s Revenge , which quickly lead me down the Descendents/All rabbit hole.
The debate was going on back then (I.e, who’s the best singer Milo, Dave, or Scott)? Of course Chad wouldn’t enter the debate for a few years. I actually saw All do one of their first shows with Chad in early November of 93, and he was literally still green but did a great job that night at the Night Awl in Pensacola, Fl. Dave’s band Down by Law was one of the openers, and he sang a few with All that night.
Anyway at the time and for years Scott was my favorite, and in some ways still is. I love that era. Percolator is just punk rock perfection, and Mary? Come on! Freaking iconic.
But now in 2024 it’s like asking me which version of the Beatles was the best, to which I’d reply, “all of them” Chad is a phenomenal singer and brought his own contributions and style that fit the band perfectly at the time. Over the past 30 years Milo has become a better singer than he was in the early days. We saw the Descendents in March of this year, and Milo killed it.
All are great, and we should All strive for All. All are the Descendents of greatness, and the two are one in All.
I love the Dave Smalley shout out he did in the beginning. Pure class
For my tastes vocally it was ALLways the Scott years. Being born in 1972 I’ve seen a lot of great songwriters and singers come and go, but my top three for their word-age and melodic skills and play on words and use of creative verbi-age is 1. Scott Reynolds, 2. Greg Graffin, 3. Dicky Barrett… Raw awesome talent and style from those guys.
This is so great... I wish this lineup played more.
0:35 - Charligan
2:34 - Fool
4:27 - Crazy?
6:20 - Box
9:47 - Scary Sad
12:42 - Can't Say
14:55 - Mary
18:16 - Nothin'
20:12 - Cyclops
22:23 - Dot
24:45 - Copping Z
27:52 - Educated Idiot
31:56 - Wonder
33:33 - Crawdad
35:19 - Carnage
38:01 - She's My Ex
41:23 - Birds
Thank you!
thanks eli
@@shenmuelandlord
What's that end song birds from ?
@@ScumBagInFL Birds is on Percolator
Me gusta ALL con cada uno de sus vocalistas.
Con Dave tienen algunas de las canciones clásicas.
Chad es realmente un gran cantante, amo su voz.
Y Scott es Scott...
ALL, Boca y vino para todo el pueblo Argentino, salud!
Saludos desde Monte Grande, Argentina!
totalmente
Que bien
Scott will alway be ALL to me!
I'd pay good money to hear them play "Sum!"
How do they remember so many songs With 3/4 singers this night?? They must have a couple hundred songs they could play from!!
やっぱALLは曲が良いそしておもしろい scottのALLが一番聞いてたし途中涙が出てきたわ
Hell yeah, Scott era ALL is the best ALL
Thank you SO much for documenting this entire evening! I've enjoyed every set to no end...
PLEASE COME BACK FOR A 30th !! 🖤
Goosebumps. I'd love this being a worldwide tour (Paris France please 😉😉)
Love!
i love all 🖤
GREAT!
ALLほんと大好き、来日してくれ
ALL is ALL with Scott. He had such a cool voice. He does not seam to be able to sing it like he used to. When did he get buff? Super cool to see them together again. Thanks for posting.
It seemed like it was as much that he had a hard time hearing himself. On the 'quieter' songs even late in the set, he was hitting the notes. That plus probably not having to belt out those songs (which are super hard to sing) for so long probably didn't help. But I agree- ALL is ALL with Scott. He's such a great singer.
the almighty ALL
Scott was the best signer on the records but these days Chad and Milo sound the best .IMO
Love all All !!!!!!!!!!! What about a new All record????????????? Been waiting for ages !!!
I guess I am in the minority.
I was the hugest Descendents fan. I only played the Descendents in my car. I saw the Descendents a few times in the 1980s.
All came and I adjusted to Dave Smalley.
I then travelled to see All in Phoenix (I live in Orange County, CA) with Scott singing and I was so turned off I missed the Chad Price (my favorite All singer) years.
I didn't come back until the Descendents reformed.
Milo / Chad/ Dave / Scott is my hierarchy. I missed a lot of great music because of that guy.
Jesus these dudes play their asses off.
I'm ppl happy rightnnow!
For me there is no better vocal than Chad Price.
She'll always be my Exene! 😁
Scott must've blown his eardrums out somewhere along the way.
This is my favorite ALL line up, though either Scott has not sang much recently and his pitch control is rough, Flat on nearly everything... or he can't hear shit in his monitor mix (which is fairly unlikely at their level, plus the other 3 are playing spot on so that says their monitors are pretty well mixed). Still cool to see them together again.
Good observation. As much as I love Smalley, this lineup might be my favorite as well. I'm a huge DAG NASTY fan so I have a soft spot in my heart for Dave, but "Allroy's Revenge" was the first ALL stuff I ever heard in 1989. "Sum" is probably one of the best songs they wrote with this lineup.
I’ll take Scott “flat”,as you say , hands down anyday
he sounds fuckin great for a live performance at his age man!
I don't he think he sounds flat. Just listened to Dot and he was on point.
he's flat on the louder songs because he can't hear himself. You can see him plug his ears before each song to hear himself first. Matching voice pitch is hella difficult when you can barely hear yourself sing
She's My Ex is a perfect pop song.
2:57 I think Scott flipped someone off lmao
Scott said the guy in the crowd sounded better than him LOL
@@SeanOkitathat was me!
@@beberle2 ben! you legend
I’ve always loved all 3 singers, but chad is by far the best
What I said was I'm so happy
Who in the hell is "ALL"? lol
the crowd is so dead these days, what the fuck
Because ALL never got credit...did you not see the movie?
Scott era was best. I always hated Chad's hyper-masculine vocals, made the music sound way too aggressive.
I don't imagine you had any control over the mix, but the bass is barely audible.
Trevor Lambert um... yeah. I’m putting this out for free, with an out-of-date iPhone. So...
@@pauldsisson We forgive you 🙏
Depends on what you're listening on. Bass sounds pretty even to me on my speakers