Pakistan The Land of Elite? How Government Burdening Public
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 07. 2024
- Pakistan The Land of Elite? How Government Burdening Public @raftartv Podcast with Miftah Ismail
In this compelling episode, we sit down with Miftah Ismail to explore the intricate role of Pakistan's elite class in shaping the nation's economy. Ismail, a prominent economist and former finance minister, provides an in-depth analysis of how the wealthy and influential in Pakistan drive economic policies, business trends, and development initiatives.
Discover how the elite class's decisions affect everything from local markets to international trade. Ismail sheds light on the economic disparities and the power dynamics at play, offering valuable insights into the challenges and opportunities within Pakistan's economic landscape.
Join us for a thought-provoking discussion that uncovers the realities behind the wealth and power in Pakistan, and understand how these forces impact the lives of everyday citizens. Whether you're interested in economics, politics, or social issues, this video offers a comprehensive look at the factors shaping Pakistan's future.
Please support us by subscribing to our channel, sharing our content, and engaging with us. Even if our work doesn't resonate with you, we'd appreciate your feedback. Raftar is not merely a content company that produces meticulously researched, high-quality videos about the economy, youth issues, gender roles, and sports. More than that, we represent a movement for social change. We cannot make a difference without your participation and support.
For more amazing content, SUBSCRIBE NOW!
CZcams
/ @raftartv
CZcams
/ @raftarnewsofficial
CZcams
/ @raftarsports
Website:
raftar.com/
Huge respect for people like Shabbir Zaidi and Miftah Ismail, courageously telling the ugly truth about this failed state.
Oo oo 8oœ😊)oóó0😊😊pp
Bht bht shukria Raftas aese intellectuals ko interview ky liye invite krne ky liye!!! Keep it !😊
@@HammadKhan-ik8ru ye khud finance minister bnkr loot chuka mulk ko ye bhi beneficiary h is system ka isny bhi bht compromise kiya apni bari k doran! Shakal h iski intellectual wali??? Dakait h ye
If you believe this man to be an intellectual you really need to go back to prep school and try getting an education.
he is an intellectual man, lol
Agar aaj iss ko PMLN mein koi achi si post mil jaye to yeh issi budget ko one of the best budget keh dey ga. Besharam log hain yeh just like Besharam PMLN aur Besharam establishment nothing else.
@@Truth6409 hahaha jese is chor k cocomo packet mai kam hoty hai isi trah intellectul h bas ✋
Log shapar hai chor se Kam ki batain sunrhy in bgrto ne Kam Kia hota to aj ye hal ni hota pyary watan ka 🇵🇰💖🌾
Well said Mr.Miftah. His opinion and suggestions make sense. Government should curtail its expenses. Rulers and bureaucrats should also practice frugality and simplicity. No justification o increase salaries and perks of corrupt bureaucrats. Rulers and bureaucrats should be cut to size and free electricity, free gas, free petrol etc.should stopped. Everyone is paying indirect taxes in Pakistan.
Very informative podcast.Before the 2024 general elections, many scholars and professionals wrote in various newspapers, including Dawn, about the slogans of political parties. They noted that the slogans of almost all mainstream political parties were similar. However, the methods for implementing these measures were largely absent. What was most interesting about this podcast was that, apart from clearly pointing out the issues facing Pakistan, Miftah Ismail provided viable solutions and remedies for every sector.
This is why a genuine economist can give a bearable budget.
Khaqan abbasi and mifta ismail is one of the most educated and well mannered politicians of Pakistan.. we wanna see their premiership in Pakistan.. best of luck for your new political journey.. May Allah grant you success
@@comradeanas4228 what use of all this when they are also looters of the same system…
After listening to Miftah Ismail and Shahid khaqan, I am seriously considering voting for their party because they do know what our core problems are and what needs to be done rather that pti, ppp,pmln who are just fighting for the throne of becoming pm.
@@munhibmazhar1748 but result will be decided by Army only..
I loved Miftah's idea about schools vouchers, I think that this is a great idea, Capitalism will automatically scale up and provide great value.
first person who gives a way out how to control economy. every one do talk but never give suggestion. Hope we have people like him in governemnt.
@@sherryyar5511 itni dfa to ye rha h govt mai ✋ finance minister lgkr compromise krta rha h ye dakuo ka sathi dakait h ye bhi phir se akr kia ukharna isny???
@@baburao1243 he already admit that Senior leadership was not allowing to do the right things for country saving vote bank. Or suggestion us ne day diya ha kam se kam jo aye wo yeh use kar lay. or abhi election b 4 saal bad ha . but every suggestion was worth if we understand
@@sherryyar5511 ye pir unka sath deta but inko sideline kar diya ishaq dar ko lane k liye ab ye bol raha hai ye sb elite class k log hai sirf baty kar k apko mujhko pagal bna rahe hai is mulk ko ap tek he nhi kar sakte apko tek karne dengy nhi ye sab implement hogya aur hmry brilliant bache parh gye aur wo thore b imandar nikal aye tu kiya pir in logo ko moqa milega. Ye sb ye elite class implement dengy he nhi
Inqilab ap la nhi sakte at least hamari generation tu nhi la sakti hum sab confused hai k kare tu kiya kare. I have better ideas than him for education kiya mujhe koi vote b dega? Agr de b de tu koi jeetne b dega form 45 to 47 me he har jaogy ye pti ppp pmln kiya vote sa jeet jate hai? Nhi
@@CMHearts brother such TU yehi ha par Jo b government ati nafrat Sath lay k a rahi. First of all one man government honi chaheye no ministry he is she only should be answerable to nation. Second there should be law implementation like Dubai tabhi hm sab insan banaye gaye.
Our respectable Miftah Ismail sir
It is requested to you if you come to power again, for God sake, do something good for this country and and for us who are abandoned and betrayed by the governments and political parties again and again.
Free Meals for children at the school is a good idea…
Reverse socialism in Pakistan - collect TAX from awam but elites getting benefits
Jo kuch bacha hai woh bhi PIA jesa ho jae ga..
کون کون جائے گا
11:39 11:42 11:44
اِن شاء اللہ 12 تاریخِ کو ڈی چوک پر دھرنا ہو سب جاگ جائے اور پہنچے اپنے حق کے لیے
This country can not develop until the justice is equal for everyone in Pakistan. Rich people have no fear of doing corruption because they know this fact that if we get caught we will buy the justice system and no one will ask anything
Privatise justice literally. It would perform well😉
Well said Miftah Ismail. 100% agree with everything he said.
currently eating chocolate chips biscuit and watching miftah ismail, lol...
Final question for 7 crore : Coco mo 3 ya 4?? 😂
@@baburao1243 Le Miftah: After budget ab sirf hawa hi mile ge 10 wale pack ma
Where is shabbar zaidi
Please Invite him and do a podcast with him.
Woh kya karlegA?
CM Modi had only 1 Policy, Government has no business being in business
ھمارے سارے ہی سیاستدان بہت امیر اور طاقتور ہیں ؟ صرف انسانی ہمدردی، حب الوطنی اور غریبوں کی خدمت کے بہانے سے حکومت حاصل کرتے ہیں انہیں سرکاری تنخواہیں ، مراعات، پینشن، پروٹوکول اور توشہ خانہ تحفے نہیں لینا چاہیں ؟؟؟ بس اب بہت ہوچکا تمام سیاستدانوں کو عوام سے چندہ لے کر خدمت کے ڈرامے نہیں کرنے چاہئیں بلکہ اپنی جیب سے پیسے نکال کر عوام پر خرچ کرنے چاہئیں ؟؟؟
ھمارے سارے ہی سیاستدان بہت امیر اور طاقتور ہیں ؟ صرف انسانی ہمدردی، حب الوطنی اور غریبوں کی خدمت کے بہانے سے حکومت حاصل کرتے ہیں انہیں سرکاری تنخواہیں ، مراعات، پینشن، پروٹوکول اور توشہ خانہ تحفے نہیں لینا چاہیں ؟؟؟ بس اب بہت ہوچکا تمام سیاستدانوں کو عوام سے چندہ لے کر خدمت کے ڈرامے نہیں کرنے چاہئیں بلکہ اپنی جیب سے پیسے نکال کر عوام پر خرچ کرنے چاہئیں ؟؟؟
Bhai Ye Interview Wala Banda Mujhe Salman Khan Ka Bhai Arbaaz Khan Lagta😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ye Arbaaz Khan ka cousin hai. Is ka baap aur Salim Khan mausere bhai hain. Dosra vyakti Miftah Ismail Indian Gujarati hai.
😂😂😂❤
Hahababa right
@@bhadwamodi8294are u an Indian??
Brilliant program
بہت خوب تجزیہ
Excellent Podcast. Great Job Team Raftar
Bohat achi batain ki lar jab ye log khud hakoomat main hoty to ye chezain bhol jaty lekin bahir aa k syany ho jaty
everyone becomes a Raja when outside. when inside... does the same thing.
Thanks raftar .very good podcast
Since Miftah Ismail and Shabbar Zaidi both are enough wealthy persons and both are focussing on education of poors, I would recommend them to take initiative themselves at first end to prove the nation that they will deliver if they are elected.
AA. Please make a video on whether Pakistan should declare default in light of the following arguments:
1) Our interest payments on debt this year will be 9000 Billion Rs and are thus more than 50 percent of our federal budget. This is unsustainable because we don't have enough left for other segments. For comparison, this amount is almost double the entire provinicial budget of Punjab and around 4 times our defence budget.
2) In order to pay this massive debt interest, the masses are beimg forced to pay colossal taxes which is making the lives of everyone miserable
We would also like to know what the actual impact of default will be. Will our debts be written off? Will be able to import necessities like petrol, medicines etc? What other consequences will there be for the country?
Thank you so much!
I like Miftah, he’s a good honest and sensible politician one of the few ones. But privatisation can not be the solution for every single problem. Education and basic utilities are a necessity for every citizen. Private industry is only interested in profit. There will be no incentive to invest in badly run industries. Privateers will bleed them dry and then walk away with their profits. These government run entities need to weed out the incompetent box tickers who are only interested in holding onto their job for life and not running their departments correctly. If you run a nationalised industry like a private corporation where policies that are actually good for the industry instead of the people with a vested interest, where poor management gets you fired instead of a slap on the wrists there is no reason it won’t succeed
Sorry to say I belong to a lower middle class family living in a rented house throughout my life We are three siblings my one brother is a software engineer , my second brother is a medical specialist and I myself have done MS in Chemistry.How could you say there is no chance of middle and lower middle class to excel.
بہترین بات۔۔۔ یعنی جن کی آمدنی برابر ہو ان سے ٹیکس بھی برابر لیں۔ کسی سے زیادہ ٹیکس تو کسی کو استثنا دینا ظلم ہے۔
Tell Mifta to consult me. I have better plans for education, health economic crisis and better value for investment
Boht behtreeen baat kahi apne miftah sahab
Miftah! Awesome!
kudos to interviewer. really impressed by his confidence someone had to question them ministers
Raftar, could you please create a video on the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC)? Specifically, I am interested in understanding why the progress of CPEC slowed down during Imran Khan's government.
Our roots are destroyed and we can not grow now so this is the bitter truth but there is one way left for us but that is impossible so just Carry on this momentum no one want to change in this country
next year my vote goes to ur party sir
Very informative Miftah sb
His suggestions absolutely make sense lekn yeh sb suggestions Govt. se bahar reh k farmae jatay hain. Govt. mein aatay hi yeh log woh rehte hi nhi hain. PDM 1.0 mein toh khushi khushi aa k fuel prices aur taxes barhate thay, this same individual.
ask miftah bhai. Nuclear power provides baseload generation. Solar and Wind power are not sustainable based load generator. How can he counter that. Also bring is someone from PAEC or a grid expert who can answer this question.
Miftah himself is a beneficiary of the system aka the elite. He needs to admit how much he benefited from it and then he can plan to be a leader.
Agreed, he only started this imaandaar aadmee mode after getting fired and that too being part of an illegitimate govt.....
@@safdarakbari that includes shahid khaqan abbasi and mustafa khokhar too.
He admitted this on many platforms
@@danimalik7078 when are these thieves returning their ill gotten gains
@@smalik0786 You're free to point out how Miftah has made money from illegal means?
He's always readily admitted numerous times how he's part of the elite.
Really nice explanation sir!
Good analysis Sir
Great man Mifta Ismail
IMF loans move the wealth to the rich who then take ot out of the country. The debts is left for the country which is extracted from the poor.
One more interview with Sir Miftah Ismail related to electricity issues
Education, health, public security, kooo concurent list mee daalnaa chahyeeahe.........
privatization is better solution you're right
Best insan mufta ismail
He is saying truth.
Good luck
Cut the defence spending by half . Orchestrate across the board strategic readjustment. investment in human capital
He is a good finance minister but not good politicians
miftah ismail mera vote apka hai ab inshallah.
Miftah ager itna achah hai to jab ye wazeer hazana tha to us wqat ye besharam quo hamoosh that.
Education first but quality Education 🎉
ONE Suggestion please add summary at the end Nive talk...
میں مفتاح صاحب کی کئی باتوں کی وجہ سے عزت کرتا ہوں لیکن سرکاری سکولوں اور انکے اساتذہ کے بارے میں جو مفتاح صاحب کے ویوز ہیں وہ ازحد منفی، متعصبانہ اور تکلیف دہ ہیں- یعنی کلی طور پر منفی- حیرت افسوس اور دکھ کا مقام - ہماری اشرافیہ ایسی ہی رائے رکھتی ہے عوام ، علماء اور اساتذہ کے بارے میں-
Sir with due respect, private school wale didn't even pay the minimum wage to the school teacher.
2:24 IMF primary surplus
Ismail Saab Mosley right,
Wow wow good job Islamic republic of Pakistan.
I want to talk on your channel regarding pakistan foreign,financial and political issue as guest speeker
Even a sharp mind like MI too is scared of the army. Being critical of govt expense increase is valid, but does anyone dare to mention the extravagance of the defense budget.
Pori zindagi Tattay utha ta rha ab shareef ban gya hai mager ye achi baat ha appreciated
I would Highly Recommend Raftar to Record a podcast with Rafiullah Kakar he has a strong expertise About Balochistan and contemporary Pakistani Politics ❤❤
@raftarr
China share in electricity production is less than 20%.Nawaz Shareef family has share 27% . Zardari family has share 18%. Muslim League and PPP rich people and establishment have 25% share. The rest shares are from Qatri shaikh. Like Mansha is getting payment for capacity charge. Mufta will not speak about the people getting capacity charge.
Where a minute!
If Mr. Miftah were to continue as finance minister ---- The Memon Cult would raise the Dollar up to 400+.
Now, he has been thrown out of the position disgracefully --- So, he is talking like this. We remember Mr. Miftah; the Dollar was 180 around when you took the charge --- And when you were ousted from the office, it was nearly 250 around and the rest was "Mr. Samdhi" did and take the flight to 330+.
In short, the flight of dollars from 180 to 330+ was a gamble of different banks, money exchange, and businessmen alliances.
I was watching a podcast where former FBR minister Shabbar Zaidi mentioned that General Bajwa asked him not to impose taxes on properties because many of his associates are in the property business. It's disappointing to see how Bajwa overlooked the plight of poor people, who bear the burden of this non-taxable or least-taxable property income. This clearly illustrates why the country is suffering. sare decision makers hi nikamme hain pakistan ke
Not a single word on the parallel economy being run by Pakistani military
Do you want his software to be updated?
@@SyedKhuzaimaAli-xh6fl 🤣🤣
Even with a phd from wharton, he couldnt remove the patwari from him and didnt talk about the curroption of N leaugye but ring was important
It's very simple the money Pakistani governments and army borrow from the IMF most of which returns to international swiss accounts. The people of Pakistan have to pay that money back with interest by means of extremely high electricity and fuel prices also making the cost of basic neccessities sky rocketting. But people like this man will complicate things just to avoid telling the truth to keep you in the loop and keep the blame on everything else other than their own incompitence.
ye duniya badi ghinaoni jagah hai... har qadam par jahannumi raah hai... sahi misaal par yeh pul siraat hai...
Ye mind set ho change Krna ye duniya hi practical h baki aage pichhe kuch nhi h
Sir mashwara😂 establishment ni deti usay oder khty hain
The reason why the power plant is in Sahiwal is because it's our money, and if in the future Punjab has to separate, we cannot be left with nothing in hand when our money has previously been misused to build dams in KPK, a province that rarely pays its electricity bills. Punjab is responsible for 54% remittances and exports. The next biggest contributor is Karachi. Rest of Pakistan has negligible contribution.
He has been part of the politics for a long time. I don't understand why he didn't share thoughts with his party? If he wasn't listened he should have separated his way from that party.
Maharashtra has a budget bigger than Pakistan and Bangladesh put together. Beat that !
sir,you don't know nuclear is the cheapest source
Indifference is the final form of hate
Do we have the right to claim our rights. Is there any place to register/record our complaint. Why
موجودہ معاشی حالات کو سدھارنے کا کسی کے پاس کوئ قابل عمل حل موجود نہیں، سوسائٹی مکمل طور پے استعداد کار سے محروم ہوچکی ہے، ایک حل ہے کہ چھوٹے چھوٹے صوبے بنانے جائیں مکمل آزادی کے ساتھ عوام کے مسائل عوام خود حل کرے، جب تک عوام کو حکومتی معاملات میں شامل نہیں کریں گے عوام میں آگے بڑھنے کی خواہش پیدا نہیں ہوگی جبکہ عوام تو محض ٹیکس دینے تک ہے۔
Karachi walay ko sideline krnay ka silsila aj bhi political elite (sardar, wadera, chowdhry) parties me mojood hai.
UK me b free meal milti he khaas age tak .
App apni defense or beaucracy ka budget kam kra in ki ayashi ko roka sab sai ho jaha ga
عوام حکومت سے لڑ سکتے ھیں۔لیکن اسٹیبلشمنٹ سے نہیں لڑ سکتے۔
Am I right according to him as there is amount of 7500 crore for 342 MNAs each having 22 crores but for what???
Bijli keee problems kaa solution yee hain kee saree households gharooo kooo solar panel lagawadeee govt appne paisooo seee or govt large dams jeseeee dasu dam, katzara dam, kalabagh dam jese bade projects shorooo kareee or usse annne waleee power generation koooo industryies ko free or commercials dukanooo koo
tax keee hisab seeee bijli beecheee
Sahil Adeem ko Bulain next podcast mei. wou aapko bataingay kaise sae hoga nizaaam. Education Sector sy leke Energy, dude knows a lotta stuff
😂😂 educated
He is jahil azeem
Every shop retailer shop in 🇵🇰need QR code payment system along with their tax NI so every transaction goes via account and FBR can check the transaction in india is common like UK there is basic 20% tax on upto 40k a year then it goes to 40% deducted from your salary 🇵🇰can start this and put every one in tax system too to bottom more you earn more you pay and use those tax in education health development etc and cut all TDA from govt officials no govt car like europe all MP have own transport not govt provided no free medial or foreign trips or education free for MPs families we need basic straightforward tax system to ease burden on common citizens etc
Shabbar zaidi sir ko bhi le kar aayen
Hal Sirf jamateislami ❤️
Everything department is messed up in this country 😔
Leader of country should not have any business so that he can only focus on improvement of country. In Pakistan all leaders are business tycoons so they interest to grow only there businesses. They make those policies that can help there businesses to grow
Solar and wind point is wrong
Dreamer Mr mifta. . Never happening in Pakistan . Allah ki lanat on display
property tax municipal govt kooo or agriculture tax federal govt kooo dedeyen
RAFTAAR IS A SCAM! Their videos show soo many ads and most of them keep playing until you dont skip them. I listen their podcasts with my phone in pocket and every 2 minutes I have to take out my phone to skip these ads. I also listen to podcasts on other channels, there are barely 5-6 ads in whole video but Raftaars videos are flodded with extremely long ads.
He wakes up now!?!?! Not a word when he was Finance Minister...
He is just like other Politicians nothing new
Mafta Ismail good❤
Why would I pay tax to chor, daku, fauj?