Untold Stories Of Politicians And IPPs Revealed | Pakistan Economy's Dark Secrets
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 09. 2024
- Explore the intricate web of Pakistan's economic landscape with economist Munazza Siddiqui in this insightful podcast. Delve into the inside story of IPP agreements, uncovering the complexities of electricity production and distribution. Gain valuable insights into the factors driving inflation and the ripple effects on the country's political stability. Join us as we unravel the hidden truths behind Pakistan's economic challenges and political crises, offering a comprehensive analysis that goes beyond the headlines.
Please support us by subscribing to our channel, sharing our content, and engaging with us. Even if our work doesn't resonate with you, we'd appreciate your feedback. Raftar is not merely a content company that produces meticulously researched, high-quality videos about the economy, youth issues, gender roles, and sports. More than that, we represent a movement for social change. We cannot make a difference without your participation and support.
For more amazing content, SUBSCRIBE NOW!
CZcams
/ @raftartv
CZcams
/ @raftarnewsofficial
CZcams
/ @raftarsports
Website:
raftar.com/
#untoldstory #economy #pakistan
![[Video] पाकिस्तान का आर्थिक सफ़र। Understanding Pakistan's Economic Challenges ft. Uzair Younus](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5c4DZhGYNrA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Video] पाकिस्तान का आर्थिक सफ़र। Understanding Pakistan's Economic Challenges ft. Uzair Younus](/img/tr.png)
What a lady, described truth in a very well-mannered way, Salute to you Madam
First pakistani journalist who is well spoken and have great knowledge, really impressed
حق صحافت ادا کیا ہے منزہ صاحبہ نے ،آئی پی پیز کے معاملے پر سب سے مفید اور دوٹوک معلومات دی ہیں محترمہ نے
Just checked my electric bill. I am paying 22 Pakistani Rupees(8 cents) per unit in the United States. What the hell is Pakistan doing charging 70 Rupees per unit of electricity?
Plus Including Of Unfinished Detection
And
Electrical Department Is Deaf And Reach
Because my country is Banana Republic 🙁.. my dad pays PKR 16,000 every month
Charges itself not the problem,,,It’s much easier to earn 22 cents US than 70 Rupees in Pakistan
it is not electric cost it is how govt collecting taxes and off course help Nawaz Sharif buy more apartments in London lol
I wapis maat anaaa
1. Consolidate/reschedule foreign loans
2. Renegotiate IPP agreements.
3. Cut the Napak foj to size, reduce their budget and start trading with india. No funding for ISI or any military agencies.
ماشاءﷲ بہترين ۔یہی عوام کی آواز ہے آجکل اتنا سچ کوئی بھی TV پر بیٹھ کر نہیں بول سکتا جیسا میڈم نے بولا
Thanks to independent journalism. Pakistan is now waking up and asking questions against the atrocities of elites
Salute to this lady .what a verbosity and proficiency she have in explaining the matters...Seldom seen such journalism
Please share this interview as much as possible
Hats of to Munaizza for speaking the truth and in very simple language the masses can understand. She needs to be in the government at some level to bring change . Shabbar Zaidi also speaks the truth and in with clarity.
True anylises great woman
This lady is intelligent and analytical with best intentions. Kudos from India
SHE HAS AMAZINGLY EXPLAINED EVERYTHING AND GIVEN AMAZING SOLUTIONS.
Digital Economy is a must. Everyone should only use a bank account to transfer. Then you know who is having how much. People should be taxed according to their bank balance and their income.
ماشاءاللہ، بہترین تجزیہ۔ محترمہ کی سچائی کو سلام
ڈیجیٹل دھشت گردی کو چھوڑو کے الیکٹرک کی برقی دھشت گردی کے خلاف *عزم عالیشان* اپریشن شروع کیا جاۓ اپ کے موضو عات عام پاکستانی کی بات ھوتی ھے شکریہ
بہت سے سوالات جو بطور عوام ہمارے زہنوں میں محفلوں میں گونج رہے ہیں ,محترمہ نے عوام کے دل کی بات بہت آسان پیراۓ میں بیورکریسی اور اعلیٰ طبقات کی اخلاقی اور معاشی کرپشن کو بے نقاب کردیا۰
What an intellectual lady, she has a great knowledge of each and every problem pakistan is currently facing and the valueable solutions she gave, big salute to you mam 👏
Instead of burdening SCP with political matters, someone should approach the SC, to make public, name of owners of IPPs, including those owned by Foundations and Trusts.
Madam is 100% right about digital economy. I am part of it. I urge all my fellow youth to learn digital skills and become a part of the international marketplaces as well as build personal brands in their respective fields. I am a 3D product animator, so I export my services to US and my earnings are in USD while sitting in Pakistan, also the tax is lowest as compared to local jobs. We need more software houses, design agencies, digital product builders and digitally talented people who can lift Pakistan. There is no hope from anyone in politics or establishment - naked fact. Our politicians are corrupt (IK is no exception), army generals are on another level. We the people will have to do hard work and create jobs here while exporting our skills. It is the best choice for people who can't leave Pakistan and want to earn in USD.
Sir which field is better in digital side
I really don't understand how with so much poverty the restaurants are full, the bazaars,tailors are busy and grand weddings by even middle class people. I visit Pakistan from Canada and I feel I am poor
Only for privileged class 10 to 20^ ; rest r dying : this country is been captured by shariefs ; zardaris : & generals : all the big businesses r run bythese three categories: khan saheb has taken a fight with this powerful trike without bothering for his life :
I think only 8 to 10% of high class
The entire country
Politicians
And citizens are equally hand in glove in corruption
All the crying and dying you see from citizens in media or real life is the bigger corruption and scam
Even bigger than politician
Institution
DNT be fooled this is an evil corrupt ungodly
Sick people
They are not decent good
Godly ppl
It is conflict of mind set, if you see people you can observe they are suffering and getting no support from current government.
salam ho munazza medam apko salute you itna khul k sach bolney pe
This madam has very good knowledge of Pakistan IPP Intricacies. How Politicians of Pakistan are looting their people, I wonder.
زبردست تجزیہ ماشاءاللہ بہت اچھے مشورے- حکومت وقت کو سننا چھائیے انہیں
rafter team should also produce a program on a very dangerous "Mafia" of Pakistan and that is "Pak Afghan Mafia" active from Karachi to chitral and Peshawar. giant leaches messaround the thin body of Pakistan economy. Pak establishment will soon see how it will destroy our Pakistan.
Children of Pakistani army
Kamal ki khatoon hn, kamal bat karti hn.
78% of these IPPSs are owned by the Sharif family members Zaradari family, their friends and political allies. Army owns a certain portion as well. Pakistanis are being scammed by its Establishment. it's so painful to see Pakistan with so much potential being destroyed from the inside.
بھائ جان لگتا ہے کہ آپ کا تعلق تحریک انصاف PTI عمران خان پارٹی سے ہے یعنی کہ آپ یوتھیے ہیں کیونکہ آپ نے لعنتی جرنیلی ایجنٹ نواز شریف اور آصف علی زرداری وغیرہ کے نام تو لئے ہیں مگر آپ نے لعنتی جرنیلی ایجنٹ عمران خان اور تحریک انصاف میں شامل لعنتی سیاست دانوں کا نام نہیں لیا حالانکہ تسلیم شدہ حقیقت یہ ہے کہ اس وقت پاکستان کے تمام مذہبی, لسانی اور سیکولر سیاست دان اور سیاسی پارٹیاں یعنی لعنتی کرپٹ پیپلزپارٹی آصف علی زرداری, لعنتی نواز شریف ن لیگ, لعنتی عمران خان تحریک انصاف, لعنتی مولانا فضل الرحمن جے یو آئی, لعنتی ایم کیو ایم MQM الطاف حسین, لعنتی سنی تحریک, لعنتی تحریک لبیک پاکستان TLP, لعنتی جماعۃ الدعوہ لشکر طیبہ, لعنتی تحریک طالبان, لعنتی سپاہ صحابہ دیوبندی تنظیمیں, لعنتی سپاہ محمد شیعہ تنظیمیں, لعنتی بریلوی تنظیمیں وغیرہ وغیرہ سب کے سب لعنتی کرپٹ جرنیلوں کرنیلوں ملٹری اسٹیبلشمنٹ کے پالتو پٹھو ٹٹو ایجنٹ ہیں 👈لہذا 1947 سے لیکر آج تک لعنتی کرپٹ اور ظالم جمہوریت دشمن اور آئین دشمن جرنیل کرنیل اور ان کے تمام پالتو پٹھو ٹٹو ایجنٹ سیاست دان ملا مولوی باہم مل کر پاکستان اور پاکستانی سویلین عوام کا خون چوس رہے ہیں, لہذا ان موجودہ سیاسی جماعتوں اور سیاست دانوں سے بہتری کی کوئی امید نہیں,,, ان شاء اللہ پاکستان میں ایک بہت بڑا انقلاب اسلامی انقلاب سر اٹھانے ہی والا ہے.... تمام لعنتی کرپٹ جرنیلوں کرنیلوں اور ان کے تمام پالتو پٹھو ٹٹو ایجنٹ سیاست دانوں کو سویلین عوام چوکوں چوراہوں پر اسی طرح قتل کریں گے جس طرح کہ انقلاب فرانس میں فرانسیسی عوام نے اپنے کرپٹ حکمرانوں اور جرنیلوں اور ججوں وغیرہ کو قتل کیا تھا, ان شاء اللہ.
Your comment is factually incorrect. Most IPPs belong to China and Government. Also IPP owners belong to all parties. Even the Pak Army indirectly owns some IPPs via Fauji Foundation. Sharif family has only one IPP in the list.
So please tell the truth even if you don't belong from that party
It was a privilege for Raftar calling such Brilliant Mind into spot light with such chilling facts. May Allah Rabul Izzat protect you from evildoers.
Mam i have a suggestion Dual nationality should be ban on all government official including there families because they can easily migrate through there families and a audit must be done on the net worth of all on service and retired personnel including there families members.
i want to listen shabar zaidi
Very informative session. Moniza sahiba view point is critically precised. Country have become food insecurity. Hubco power was foeigner IPPs for 30 yrs. Lip service of 75 % indigenous IPPs; upna kaam bunta ore baqi bharr me jaey juntta! DISCOs promptly should be privatised to control theifts/ roberry.
One year capacity payment be stopped and people are given loans for solar panels and recover as bill.
This lady is indeed provided a very clarity of the current problems, but also the solutions. Well done.
Excellent analysis! Hats off for speaking the truth but will the people come out to snatch their rights from the corrupt politicians and generals?
We need patriots to run Pakistan who keep the best interest of the country. We dont need traitors like Bhuttos, Zardaris and Sharifs
Correct
Bilkl
You are in the US. You need to focus on the November election and nothing else. There is no we here. There is no difference between PPP,pmln and PTI.
@@WashainNotkani Many of us would love to return to Pakistan. Especially those who are retired. I would rather take my last breadth in Pakistan than anywhere else. However the social and political environment is very toxic. Free thinking and free expression is not tolerated in Pakistan.
Good one, keep it up 👍
Ms Siddiqui's command of the subject and her courage to call a spade is commendable. May Allah bless her.
A wounderfull and usefull talk on Politicians, PPs , and Pakistan Economy'. I learn a lot specially thankful to Guest Mrs Munazza Siddiqui
Ban SUV’s of government servants. Stop all freebies, grants, subsidies to government servants. Monetize 5000 rupees notes and digitalization of currency. Close down money changers.
Bhot afsos hota h pakistani hony pr halat bhot zda bury hn koi job ni h mi khud just house ya company mi driver ki job dhond rha hun halat asy hn koi job he ni h pr oupr bethy zalim drindo ko kiya prwa koi mry ya jey kash ky Pakistan mi peda he na hoy hoty km sy km achi life to milti Pakistan sy bahr 💔😞
How beautifully she explained things..loved to hear her..
Thoroughly enjoyed her views on multiple topics, excellent
Thank you for sharing the Information. Also spread this information to the common people
good presentation by Munazza Siddiqui and great information....
Ya bat to har program ma horahy ha Kindly detailed program karen ipps par kon owner ha agreement kitnay years ka ha kitni dafa renew hoa agreements jab tak details samnay nahe aigen ya politician asai pagal bnaigen awam ko like KElectric aik distribution company ha log preshan ha KE sa lakin agreement renew kardia oska kisnay kia kun kia.
Insha ALLAH Pakistani awaam n logoo se sahee tareeqy se nemtengy aur haar n ke muqaddar hai
Very intelligent discussion. This educated lady is talking sensibly well.
Mera dil apnay mulk aur is k mulk k logon per honay waly zulm ki wajah se Khoon k ansoo rota hai.😢😢😢
Manza sahiba, wondergil proposals have been floated (despite being not having expertise in respected field) by you for getting rid of IMF. The suggestion of transforming governance to digitization is a superb measure, which would eradicate corruption as well. The most important issues need to be resolved are renegotiation with IPPs stateholders for revisiting contracts, secondly, austerity measures be inforced especially withdrawing of facility free issuance of units of utilities and free issue of petrol ltrs etc. These measures have become inevitable as a clerk, farmer and guard pays bills out of their meager income, why can't ruling elites.
Salute to this lady
Nice analysis this lady
Truth
kuch nahi hoga jab tak log bahar nahi nikleinge its time now
Wow, such an elegant personality. Amazing explanation. I was today years old when I understood how IPPs worked.
well done madam. sab ko sab pata hay magar karta koi kuch nahi, because aap bata chuki hen kay 75% share IPPs men kin logo ka hay. Pakistan ka Allah hi hafiz.
This podcast is next level.
A great lady, may she be blessed, aameen 🤲🤲🤲❤️❤️❤️
The interviewer is not pronouncing her name correctly. He is say "Muneeza" instead of "Munazza."!
Great analysis by this lady!!
Excellent Expert
Digitalization of economy is a must and ban use of cash
Munza sidiqui is always great...
She always speaks truth and stands with it..
She is much much better than many famous anchors and renowned journalists..
Well describes
Very deep conversation ❤️
Great information provided by this journalist. The IPP contracts should be renegotiated. Also, not surprised to hear that during Benazir’s government, the IMF & WB (both are backed by the US) encouraged Pakistan to install IPPs to increase the capacity, because the US was lobbying very hard against the Iran-Pakistan Gas pipeline. India was promised sweeteners to drop out and was awarded years later in terms of lifting of nuclear technology related sanctions.
خوبصورت لفظ استعمال کیا ، محاذ آرائ
She's Genuine , you should invite her again. 👍
What is Bajwa and other retired army chiefs outside Pakistan? Bring them back and make them accountable
No , Bajwa , no munir ,this is system 10 percent vs 90 percent
PAKISTANI Poor People paying the Cost of Headless PLANING, POOR MANAGEMENT, Badly Operated GOVERNANCE etc etc.
1. Has this IPPs Model adopted Rest of the World which Pakistan has adopted, ie. TVL FEE, Fuel Adj Ch, Variable Ch, Fixed Ch, Add Surcharge, Uniform Quart Adj, Sales Tax Electricity Duty etc etc Added in Electric Bill where these IPPs Operated in Rest of the World.
2. When was Fuel AUDIT of these IPPs Conducted & what was it's CREDIBILITY.
3. What is the Useful/Expected Life of these IPPs ie DEPRECIATION of Plant & Machinery Generally it is 20 Yrs, Technically 50 % IPPs has completed their Useful Life, then why they haven't be RETIRED, instead of DEPRECIATING they are APPRECIATING, AMAZING VERY AMAZING it is a Violation.
Allah Tala Pakistan ka logon per apna reham or Karam farmay.
let me answer you , these kind of Power generation are the fruits of Pak Afghan joint venture.believe me, yes the predecessors of francfurt pak embassy attackers. more is coming soon.
بہت زبردست تجزیہ
I’m really impressed with your cool, frank and constructive interviews on burning issues in Pakistan. Salute to your guests also who speak their hearts. Fully agree with Munazza Siddiqi’s suggestion that dual nationality of bureaucrats needs to be stopped. Another equally, or perhaps more important,step would be to deny perks and privileges like chauffeur-driven cars, free or subsidised fuel, and housing phone, gas, electricity etc. No other countries has these white elephants. Btw white elephants includes entire elite comprising politicians, bureaucrats, security personnel, and judiciary.
We need patriotic people in government not chor or dacoits
AOA. Those who are involved in this massive corruption declared as Nation Criminal what's so ever. Otherwise the system collapsed. But the big question Who...Who... & WHO will done? Because in the current senerio our P.Parties, Judiciary & Estab
All are involved in this loot.
Nationalize the IPPs is one of the solutions
So many brilliant minds we have here in Pakistan yet we are unable to utilise the true potential of our own people. Greed has plagued the roots of our existence that's why we are blind to see our true potential. Ya ALLAH! please help us get rid of these mess called greedy politicians.
@45mins
"Our currenct is pegged to the inflation of the USD", it is not just ours there is an entire list of thrid world countries whose assets are locked in this way.
Best example to oberver the impact was post Covid when America was printing money and our currencies were getting devalued and inflation was going up like crazy.
A very well articulate discussion on economic issues specially IPP’s.
One of the finest Pakistan youtube channel
Unfortunately we have a lame judiciary and lame finance minister who wants status quo and don’t want to bring real reform.
What an amazing analysis.
I asked many about the length of ipp contract
Finally got the answer good podcast. PM went to China and he was proposed a couple of more ipps can anyone stop this ?
No austerity measures - on the contrary they have been rewarded for doing corruption!!
She is brilliant
Please explain why the government is taking time to renegotiate the terms of ipps and taking tìme to privatised pia and other departments and what is the guarantee that the right term in benifits of people Pakistan will be part of contracts..
Sanctions on Iran restricted imports and helped local manufacturers to invest and increase local manufacturing . 70 percent of the small home appliances are currently made by domestic producers. The increase in the production of home appliances was achieved in a situation where two international companies (LG and Samsung) which held nearly 80 percent of Iran’s market reduced their production in the country and left Iran under U.S. pressures.
Its not only IPP many other aspects from oil, sugar to electricity...only tip of the iceberg!!😮😮😮
Mam hats off to you.. May ALLAH SWT protects you from all evils. I feel that someone give oxygen to this Country in form of you. this is not an EASY JOB. to expose MAFIAS in Uniform or in Anyform.. ALLAH aapko apney Amaan mey rakhey.
I think Pakistan should declare insolvency or default and start on a new slate with a government of technocrats and the best brains of the country and corrupt politicians should be behind bars
مہنگی بجلی، آئی پی پیز اور ظالمانہ سلیب سسٹم کے خلاف عوامی دھرنا انشاء اللہ 26 جولائی کو حافظ نعیم الرحمن کی قیادت میں ہوگا، میری تمام پاکستانیوں سے
گزارش ہے کہ اس دھرنے میں بڑی شریک ہوکر اس ظلم کے خلاف آواز بلند کریں ۔
آپ کی پوسٹ کو بے غیرت پاکستانیوں نے endorse نہیں کیا ۔ اس سے اندازہ لگائیں کہ پبلک کے حالات کیا ہیں ؟
حافظ نعیم الرحمان اور جماعت اسلامی محض ڈھکوسلے بازی کرتی ہے ۔ ایک دن کے احتجاج کے بعد چپ سادھ کر بیٹھ جاتے ہیں ۔
Pakistan aik Dukan( shop) hai jis k owner politicians hain.aur awam purchaser.
Get someone from ntdc or kelectric who can actually tell us with backed up data. Whats our baseload demands vs leakages/losses
brilliantly describe the challange and problem in very simple way.
Agar conventional warfare ke chances nahin, aur Atomic power hoty howy humain 7 lakh fauj ki zarorat hy?
Heart knowledge Allah bless both of you
Aameen
Intelligent lady.
Salaam dollars and fuel stability required every 15 days prices became high, so inflation rates fluctuations
*China is all weather tested Friendly country of Pakistan*
*China have Forex Reserves $ 3200+ Billions, but not ready to give $ 3 Billion for his yearly Debt friend*
*Pakistan*
*We have our own interest in Pakistan - Chinese Foreign Minister(Global Times)*
😁😂🤔
ومن اعرض عن ذكري فان لله معيشة ضنكا
اور جو کوئی اللہ کے ذکر سے منہ موڑے گا، اس کی معیشت تنگ کردی جائے گی (سورۃ طہ 124)
The only alternate solution is to implement Islamic economic system through the establishment of Khilafah
This RAFTAR has great future vision and it's gonna be one of the most viewed channel in few months ....thanks, show some particular topics for global needs too ❤❤
Very well said. You said all the things that very 1000% true 👍🏻
Will Islam allow "Out of the Box" thinking??
Will Vahabhi Generals allow that to happen???
Life is miserable for 70% of the population and the rich are getting richer
She is very knowledgeable.