Investigating Marshal Johnson's Secret - Red Dead Redemption
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 05. 2024
- Kid Colt: / @kc.45
Kid Colt’s own video: • Is Marshal Johnson ACT...
The original theory: reddead.fandom.com/f/p/440000...
Subscribe to our history channel, Decades:
/ decadesvideos
Twitter: / decadesvideos
Instagram: / decadeschannel
Support me on Patreon: / fishyyarpster
Twitch: / fizhye
The Four Pillars Network:
/ @fourpillarsnetwork8730
If you feel like tipping, go here: streamlabs.com/XN3RDXD3RPXaka...
Channel merch:
- teespring.com/stores/fizhy-store
- shop.spreadshirt.co.uk/FishyYa...
Four Pillars:
LazerzZ: / g4m3rv1dz
Tynamite: / ac3follower
LongEaredFox: / longearedfoxgaming
Join the Union for Gamers: www.unionforgamers.com/apply?...
My second channel: • Video
Snapchat: cabbagefishd3
Follow me on Twitter: / ejwoodgates
Woof: / doggoofhappines
Like my Facebook page: / fishyyarpster
Thanks for watching!
Please:
Like
Subscribe
Share
Comment
TELL YOUR FRIENDS ABOUT ME (please?)
NO SELF ADVERTISING WHETHER IT BE OF PRODUCTS OR CHANNELS (if you want me to notice your videos/products then be sure to privately message me)
I hope you enjoy the video!
Music from Epidemic Sound: www.epidemicsound.com
#rdr2 #reddeadredemption #rockstargames - Hry
Holy shit... you actually did it. Oh God I need coffee.
I was just about to shoot you an email to let you know, it was a brilliant theory and I didn't have much else on so it was perfect. Thank you brother!
@@Fizhy You did brought up an interesting detail: Walton Lowe. I thought the newspaper article covering his death meant he canonically died but now that I'm rewatching that bit, it does feel weird considering in GTA 4 some police records of minor antagonists change depending on whether the player spares them or executes them. And just like Red Dead 1, that Rockstar game is loaded with an immense amount of details.
Edit: My initial reaction upon seeing this video lays in the fact not many people are fond of theories regarding memorable characters of the Red Dead series. So seeing that to another person it made sense to some degree, made me question the theory since I thought it wasn't that good at first but gave it a shot anyway.
Okay
Indeed
you did it.
This is a video worthy of being watched while I eat my dinner
Yes
I’m on the toilet with it😂
It's breakfast here lol
@@juliangrant6181 same here
@@juliangrant6181 Cheeky
He definitely gives off shady vibes but as the valintine sheriff said "You don't hire a saint to catch a sinner"
Facts
He’s my favorite rdr character so I’m glad it’s just vibes and not anything confirmed
That is a good line.
@@Sam81537Even then just because he’s shady doesn’t make him “bad”. It just means he’s willing to use unconventional tactics to keep Armadillo from becoming chaos. He’s basically a firm believer of “the ends justify the means”. It’s likely he was an outlaw himself that started using his talents for the law instead, which if anything makes him even more badass. Like Malloy said “you don’t hire saints to catch sinners”
@@Sam81537He even left John aline until Ross came
Marshall Johnson is such a grounded and honest character, probably one of the most down to Earth NPCs in a Rockstar game. He scratches John's back because John scratched his, no ulterior motives. The idea that he was a criminal in a past life just makes me like him more.
I like the idea of criminal turned lawman in a setting like RDR. As another commenter pointed out, the Valentine sheriff in RDR2 said "you don't hire a saint to catch a sinner." A former outlaw who became a lawman to seek redemption would understand these gangs and their motives far better than some goody two shoes who became a lawman or bounty hunter simply to show off how good they are.
@@lsswappedcessnaJohnson is John without Ross factor
Johnson is john without a son@@lewisaino
Marshal Johnson reminds me of the real life exploits of the lawman Wyatt Earp. Earp was a shady character that found himself in the lawman game.
Wouldn't be surprised if he's based off of Wyatt Earp.
Wyatt Earp made a deal with Cowboy Gang member Ike Clanton to capture known suspects of a stagecoach robbery, also members of the Cochise County Cowboys. But when a third unknown party killed their suspects, Ike Clanton became paranoid at the possibility of him being misunderstood for a rat (he technically was going to be, but anyway), so he spread rumors surrounding this robbery, particularly ones implicating Doc Holliday and Wyatt Earp himself in it. Wyatt Earp made that deal for political reasons, he wanted to win the elections and become Sheriff, I think it was? The main idea here is that they both share some similarities.
He was a rather complex person. Some would call him a hero, and some would call him a crook. Depends on your perspective.
Or that’s just a thing they did back then. Earp just happened to clearly get some attention for doing it.
He made some bad decisions after his first wife died but once he started, Wyatt Earp was the best lawman in the west, (he tamed Dodge City) until criminals crippled one brother of his and killed another and the justice he defended for so long failed him. So he handled it himself. I can't condemn him, especially for the time he lived in.
I love Marshall Johnson, he's such a cool character. I remember when I first played RD:R1, and that scene where John first met him played... it was so good, the acting, everything. That's when I realized this was a real Western, this was cinematic. Great scene.
Agreed. The actor portraying him had a great voice, too. Great line delivery.
Certainly alot more kooler than Sheriff Freeman!
He's fast too.Probably one of the only two guys that can outgun Marston
"You must be the Man from Blackwater."
No matter how long it's been, a good ol fizhy Red Dead video always brings me back
I think the reason the Mashal killed the Walton gang leader is probably to avoid something like what the O'driscolls had done so many times. Think about it would you want your town attacked brutally like even Saint Denis was going to be and other areas were.
Perhaps an Outlaw is the best person to catch an Outlaw, like with John Marston.
Yes always wonderd why Ross killed off John at the end I mean he could still have been useful to catch future outlaws and if they made him a sherriff well then that might made him also loyal to his town I mean we know John had good in him to protect the innocent just look when he was a rancher and protected all of them
We appreciate you keeping the Red Dead franchise alive. Keep up the good work. 👍
wish there was more content down here in the sequel, thanks for bringing us back to the original story
Bout time someone is making new content about the redemption series. There’s so many subjects and info that hasn’t been touched up on
Just to add to the conversation, RDR1 had many reoccurring random encounters that would often spawn riding around, and could be done multiple times.
One of them that comes to mind is the lawman who has prisoners escape from a prison transport wagon. It's always two prisoners going in opposite directions while fleeing the scene when you pull up. The lawman is usually in an injured stance requesting assistance. You can usually kill them both, kill one, and capture the other, and or possibly capture both before they get too far away.
Upon completing the encounter successfully in which you've captured at least one escaped prisoner, the lawman will thank you and then proceed to execute the recaptured prisoner(s) with his gun.
I bring this up just for the sake that the game's own world implies that it wouldn't be a stretch for Johnson to have "Defended himself" from the leader of the Walton Gang, and fabricate a story in which the gang leader was killed by Johnson after capture.
It also makes sense in a purely pragmatic way
He has a lot on his plate. "Clearing" a bit off said plate makes his life easier and means he can give more attention elsewhere.
In this time, all you need is a good lawyer in some country courthouse to get the criminal off f the crime, so this could also be a way of "taking out the trash" before it gets to all the red tape & procedures of standard law
Thank you Fizhy you are such a hard worker between decades and your channel there never seems to be a end of the content flow you have to be constantly editing and recording just know we appreciate all the hard work
I appreciate it but I'm far lazier than it looks for sure
Waltons reported death by gunshot even if he was captured alive is likely just a developer oversight but there's a possibility you didn't consider and that's Walton could have tried to escape on the ride back to Armadillo, forcing Marshal Johnson to shoot him
I love when the lore crosses over both games!
9:27 I see M.28 not sure if that number is of any significance in the game or lore. It doesn’t look like an LJ though.
It looks like M.28 to me too, my first assumption was it's a date maybe, like May or March 28th
One of my fav characters from the original game. I remember the game being bit slow at the start on my firs playthrough but as soon as the Marshall showed up I really fell in love with the game.
Please do more RDR1 videos, there is something really special about them
Agreed!!!
I would just like to say. If I was in an outlaw gang. I would spread rumors about the Marshall to get people not to tell him things about the gang because they think that hes on the take. Also if everyone already things the Marshall is with the gang it might make it more likely for him to actually take the money and be on the take.
I'm so happy to see a Red Dead 1 theory!! I know RDR2 gets a lot of attention, but RDR will always be my ultimate favourite and I love seeing all these interesting theories
I believe the writing on the Rio Del Lobo map actually begins ... M.28 At New Orleans, I've got our goods past the house officer...
Good luck deciphering those hieroglyphics. My best attempt came out similar to yours with the difference I put "Austin" instead of "Orleans" because it looked a bit odd considering New Austin is in the southwest lol. But yeah, it does say "I've got our goods past the house (officer?)" -- the house being the one depicted in the map.
There was a lawman/outlaw by the name of Henry Plummer who jumped both sides of the fence until he got caught extorting people and was killed in Montana. I suggest you look him up because it’s an interesting story and there’s no shortage of guys like him.
Well that's the story, but it isn't necessarily the truth
@@doughboywhine It is, he was a thief, a murderer, a crook and a bad person.
Fizhy is such a great CZcamsr, anytime he posts a video it’s phenomenal.
Johnson says that he would want to have the guy hanged if you were to kill the gang leader
I Feel Like Marshall Johnson Is Somewhat Based On Wyatt Earp. Wyatt Earp Was An Outlaw At First, And Then Became A Sheriff In Multiple Towns, Including Tombstone, Arizona, Dodge City, Kansas, And Others. He Was A Good Sheriff Who Aided In The Takedowns Of Several Gangs, Including The Cochise County Cowboys, A Notorious Gang That Roamed Over Most Of Southeast Arizona In The 1870’s And 1880’s.
This is great content! Please do more videos with the first Red Dead as subject matter? I really enjoyed this!!!
Thanks for this video. One aspect I’m glad you mentioned about Johnson early on is to quite rightfully question what allegiance(s) he would need to have if he (a) is lawman paid by the railroad/enterprise and (b) clearly needs to compromise based on the lack of resources required to maintain order. I agree with that these points are probably out of the scope of your video but also are important and are explored elsewhere e.g. look at the landscape that inspires the narratives behind Robocop and much cyberpunk (where OCP and large corps are effectively the railroad) and issues faced in most modern police tv shows (public perception, resources etc). It’s good point that RDR and RDR2 in a small way were able to emphasise that these were issues faced in the old west as well as in the modern day /later fiction.
And I just started playing red dead 1 on a whim a week ago after getting my first job. Spooky timings in my lifetime.
We need a video on Micah’s gang
Marshal Johnson's dialogue is frickin great and really sets the atmosphere of the world state in the beginning of the game.
Fizhy uploaded a new red dead video what a time to be alive.
Thanks for the great content, keep up the good work!
Damn didnt know he had a secret
You should do more from just red dead redemption. There are a lot of hidden mysteries in the first one as well. I'll submit a couple when I get the chance, awesome video.
Great video like always!Enjoyed watching it
FIZHYYY POSTED AGAINNNN YESSS. Been fiending for a rdr video man idc if it's 2 or 1 but these games are still so interesting
You always make the best videos. Keep up the great work.
This reminds me of the same sort of thing with fallout 4 and Preston Gracy missions is speculated where he’s with the raiders or something like that but also taking all of them out fraction by fraction. But nonetheless I don’t think I’ve ever commented on one of your videos but I’ve been a subscriber for a while now and you post nothing but greatness guy and it’s something to think about and informational at its finest. So thank you for that. I hope you and your are all doing well too. 🙏🏼🤜🏼🤛🏼
I never heard that theory. It doesn’t really make sense tho because Preston is very honorable and instantly hates you if you become a raider yourself. Regardless it’s kind of confirmed that the Marshall was actually taking bribes from local gangs but he only did it for Armadillos safety on top of personal gain, so he’s meant to be both good and bad
bruv u make the best rdr2 videos i cant lie ygm
Your videos are top shelf! Love em!
All Star RDR content as always. All I want for Xmas, or a Birthday, or before I ride off into the sunset, is an RDR 2 & RDR sequenced production remastered for PS5. If it had added content like a fleshed out Guarma and/or an expansion of some story lines like the Mayor of Strawberry etc., that would be icing on the perfect cake & I'd pay large for it. I'd play that game regularly until I can no longer pick up a controller.
Videos like these make me so sad that I didn't get to play RDR. I have only played RDR2, and after falling in love with John, I feel incomplete without playing RDR lmao. John's story (and RDR) is just much more real and badass to me.
Great video as always!!
Another RDR video from Fizhy??? I MUST WATCH!!!
I had to do a quadruple take, I thought there’s no way I’m lucky enough to have a new fizhy video
9:41 looks to me more like M.28 rather than M.LJ, but that's just my perception. That aside, great video! Wish they would do a revamp of this game for PS5.
That was my first thought as well but the more I thought about it the less it made sense because if it was a date it'd be Mar, March, or May no?
@@dracoforce47 there is also a very faint period/full stop after the L/2. I can see it as a cursive L but the J looks like an 8.
it would also make more sense to start a message with a date, usually people sign at the end
The gang's money being hidden in the same place the marshall hid "stolen goods" could mean he put their money (which is stolen) away there for safekeeping.
The gold you find is what they were talking about I think on the treasure hunting challenges
Great video, Fizhy!
Thank you for the video! ❤
A Great Video Again Keep Up The Work!
This character has intrigued me since I met him the office. It’s hard to know if he’s genuine or not. He has combat experience and probably had a story similar to John Marston.
Marshall Johnson was one of My favourite characters in RDR 1
Very well written
How come Leigh Johnson has been the Sheriff for 17 years if in 1907 we see the Armadillo sheriff resign?
Modern armadillo is probably just a cracked concrete parking lot hellscape full of meth and dollar stores and like one Wild West history museum desperately cashing in on the fact that John Marston went there.
i dont know what you did but the editing in this video looks really good
Only real difference is I decided to apply a LUT on the RDR2 footage to match the more washed out colour scheme of RDR.
Looks more like M. 28 to me on the treasure map
Yeah, that's what I see too.
16:10 I think when he says yes you do deals with outlaws, he was referring to John. Because canonically, John was supposed to get/is famous in the RDR world. Even before the end. This can be known by Seth, and Nigel west dickens saying people have been talking about him.
I think at 9:42 the “M. LJ” is actually “M. 28” it just looks more like numbers than letters even in that cursive ass writing
This is really reminding me of the RDR2's traitor situation, I never known about this detail.
Man I wish I they would release this game for PS4 or PS5 no matter the graphics. I've thought about getting a PS3 just solely for RDR1.
What 😳 bro you can play the older game on your new generation though so just buy the game
I'm almost positive it's for sale on all 3 platforms
I got an Xbox one back in 2018 just to play it again lol, a shame sony didn’t bring it back for ps4/ps5 as well
Better yet, save up for a PC so you can have all your games on one system! They can be pricey depending on the specs you get, but if you build it yourself (find a tutorial or see if any of your friends know how) you'll save a good bit versus a prebuilt.
Would love to see a rdr3 following the story of marshall johnson where he was a gunslinger, who indirectly brought the demise of his own town. As the game progresses you see the town slowly turn into the “living hell” he works so hard to avoid. This may happen around the time of rdr2. Eventually, his redemption is establishing, or rescuing, Armadillo where he ultimately becomes sheriff. Would be fun to see a repeat of some missions from rdr1, but playing as johnson. Also a good reason to bring back both the Mexico map, and the entire rdr2 map.
RDR2 map plus Mexico on the modern RAGE engine would be awesome. RDR2's version of New Austin looked great but I'm certain they've made even more upgrades to the engine's visual fidelity capabilities during the development of GTA 6.
2:19
I legit thought I was gonna start hearing Nick Cave telling me to take a little walk to the edge of town and go across the tracks…
🤣
Another great video
There is so much content for RDR1 that no youtuber has made videos on.
I love this, more videos about rdr1 just like your RDR2 videos please!
"The difference between a government official and an outlaw is who is accepted to have money and power and who is not". Keep blessing us with your philosophy lessons man. The world really needs people like you.
Great Video!!
Great stuff!
I just started playing this again today and i heard the dialogues and then i see this new video here
Secrets or not, Marshal Johnson is one of my top favorite RDR characters.
Your voice is very pleasant on the ears
okay that's it.. im paying a visit back to rdr1. Great video.
I’m pretty sure in rdr 2, if you kill everyone in the del lobo hideout you won’t get any bounties for del lobo. Mind you I went with John after the last mission to kill somebody if yanno what I mean. It’s rlly weird like I haven’t even seen any at tumbleweed either
There’s only 2 Del Lobo bounties and they’re both in Tumbleweed. They also don’t really relate to gang hideouts
how do you get marshal johnson in armadillo? i cant get it to activate the fort mercer mission. or should i just assault it on my own?
He definitelly reminded me of Sheriff Cobb from Silverado
Even though he isn’t really a major character in the rdr series he is one of my favorites
Love rockstar 10+ years after playing a game you find out new things or new myths
Marshal Johnson having been appointed to Armadillo for 14 years doesn't make sense though, since we would and should have seen him both in 1899 and 1907 at one point. This should bring into question how old the treasure is, and if he had any involvement with the Del Lobo gang before 1911. Wish Rockstar had furthered his story in RDR2 even if we didn't get to see him. To my knowledge, there's no newspaper scraps or NPCs that even mention him in New Austin.
There’s a letter in his office in the epilogue you can happen upon and it says that Marshall is “on vacation” while the Cholera breakout blows over. So it’s still consistent but obviously they needed an excuse for him to not be there so John doesn’t meet him before 1911 and cause a paradox. And New Austin in 1899 also being affected by cholera is non canon since it was obviously scrapped and the game tries its hardest to avoid the player going there before the epilogue
and I take online with a grain of salt bc it’s clear Rockstar stopped paying attention to all continuity details when it comes to Online (like Sadie owning the very first horse Arthur gets despite it being explicitly said in the story that it wasn’t hers and belonged to one of the Odriscolls)
I found the treasure by Rio Del Lobo on the first try but it was also the hardest one to find of all the treasures.
Marshal is the goat. He knows he has to do politics with outlaw gangs to save the majority of the town.
I’m honest surprised you didn’t bring up Slim Grant during the video.
Was playing his videos on autoplay and then heard this and thought to myself: hey, I don't recignise this, this is good.
14 years later... I can finally find out what the fuck is wrong with Marshall Johnson.
Your videos are so good to eat and sleep too. It sounds disrespectful about sleeping to them but your tone of speaking is very calming and videos don’t have any loud noises Instead with nice ambiance.
Glad I'm not alone here , something about these videos help me sleep same with some other rdr2 youtubers
@@pyrogunslinger1877 same, so many people say it’s rude or disrespectful but we are still listening to the video and actually, I sometimes don’t sleep and watch it instead if I’m not tired.
@@Sopranos990 definitely, have you tried watching real pixels videos on rdr2, they always help me fall asleep. For some reason Video game analysis videos have been helping me sleep for a year now
@@pyrogunslinger1877 kinda, i usually watch DarkviperAUs pacifist currently.
@@Sopranos990 ah does that help to go sleep? I've watched his lore videos before and those are great
Hey Fizhy, you know anything about if Lake Isabella has connections to the missing Isabella girl that noone can find? That would maybe make a good video if so.
Yeah, new Fizhy RDR video!
9:59 i see M.28, March 28th. Its in the spot were you could find the date
You plan on doing one about Cornwall?
Marshall Johnson could have just seen himself as judge, jury, and executioner like the Sherrie from tumble weed, so could of shot Walton when he got back (like that scene in tumbleweed with one of the bounties), but it is pre sus. Maybe he was just tying up loose ends. As it was said, you'd have to make some compromises being in that position in that environment and world
My thought is when Johnson was younger, he once rode with the Walton gang so he knew members of the group, thus his seeming unwillingness to engage them without backup. This would also explain why he’s good in a shootout and why the map might have his initials on it. He was tasked with burying the stolen goods but before the gang could collect, something happened and they had to split up. He and a couple others made a map to the treasure and hid that map, but in the breakup, Johnson took the opportunity to ditch the gang. Because of his skill and knowledge of the area, he was hired as sheriff and now that he’s a lawman, he has no care to collect the stolen goods but also can’t let the Walton gang get it
Yeah you could tell he has a shady past the moment you meet him. At this point, nothing will surprise me at all
I love your content Fizhy. Not everyone can spend their days on TikTok all the time.
This sounds like a CSI Investigation 😂😂
"Life... without laws"
I see what you did there.
9:40 Pretty sure that says "M. 28", which would make me think March 28th
the first mission Marshall ~Johnson stays back and dont shoot at the Waltons. hmmmm i remember a hood where we use to say let the good gang stay to keep the other idiotas out. He for sure has something going with the the gang, Waltons and Johnson have a defense treaty of Armadillo
You should do more RDR1 vids
*I think Marshal Johnson is mostly a no-nonsense realist.* If he were a moralist he would have tried to directly stop Walton's gang or gangs before it even if he was outnumbered, probably resulting in the death of him, his sparse deputies, and many of the residents of Armadillo.
Because Marshall Johnson can see things clearly as they are, and seems intelligently reserved enough to calculate the powers he has, and hasn't over the situation; I think he mostly tolerates the Walton's gang as long as they don't push it too far in his town. He has no power to completely stop them, so he compromises to make at least some deals to keep the citizens of Armadillo safe until he feels he has the power to make changes.
In the end his main objectives are this:
1. Keep the citizens of Armadillo safe
2. Clear the county from outlaws
3. Gather a little pension for his old days to never have to do this line of work ever again
So Marshal Johnson is a *good but corrupt Marshall* who tries to do good, but accept he has to be as dirty as his surroundings makes him to be to at least make some positive changes in the end. Which he eventually succeeded in. He would have not survived Armadillo if he only tried to make positive changes but did not accept the reality he faced.
I had a gut feeling from the dialect and townsfolk talk, that there is more than what it appears for Johnson. Some things are also contrary to what popular culture tells with western lawmen. Not all towns had a jail, as it costs a lot to build so some lawmen would have outlaws and captured fugitives roped tied to a tree when transporting to the law, also in part as not all lawmen had access to very early hand restraints. Some even are imprisoned and being under watchful eye in their own homes. Some lawmen did have a past in crime and so it does give them an edge in gunfights, insight in catching criminals or tricks used by some.
You should make videos covering the gangs of the first game since you covered all but one for the second.
Which one did I miss?
@@Fizhy the foremen brothers
@@Kyle-nz8fu Note sure if there's enough background to cover.
@@KC.45 never stopped him before. Considering what little he’s had to work with on other topics like the Watson boys.
@@Kyle-nz8fu True. Fizhy could add that Anthony Foreman's facial structure is similar to Red Harlow's from RDR1 multiplayer and no one would complain lol.
to me the beginning of the passage of text looks like M. 28