That’s what I’m saying they judged her so hard for her pics that she picked for the show but none of them were singers or even good singers even be judging her on how she should be singing just doesn’t make any sense to me why they put people on herethat isn’t even good singers or even knows how to judge somebody, especially if they’ve never picked up a microphone before in their life. Simon Carroll hasn’t even written a song or even sang a song that guy can’t even hold a damn note.
I can't agree with two of the judges on this one. You know, Pat Benatar is one of the most difficult singers to emulate because of her incredible range and style of music. However, I am very impressed by this old performance from Carrie. In my opinion, she did a fantastic job and nailed it as well as anyone ever could! She can sing just about anything and do it well.
Not a HUGE Carrie Underwood fan, but honestly I have to say she rocked the shit out of this song, and only partly because she was wagging her ass so well...
tangled55 actually as far as girls from American idol go Carrie Kellie and Kelly are all three equally incredible. Whatever you're smoking AND.drinking.to make you say that needs to be thrown out. Then you can hear how wrong your statement is
First she killed it with Alone by Heart, then this Pat Benatar classic. I have loved her since the first televised audition. She also reawakened my favorite show. I had lost interest the previous 2yrs. I was ready to accept that after Kelly Clarkson's voice and success tgat the format couldnt be replicated consistently and that we had seen the best already. I kinda expected the talents to continue to dewindle for another couple seasons till eventually closing the doors voluntarily, or being cancelled. Then season 4 started! 🥰🌹
"Watching a kitten who wants to be a tiger"? I'd love to hear the judge's thoughts on Carrie rocking out to Paradise City. :P I love her as a country artist and that's where her heart is, but girl definitely knows how to rock out.
She nailed it, I don't know why they said that. I think the show is the one who rushed it for her because of their time. Leave her alone to do that song in a real concert and she will blow the house down!
I love Carrie Underwood .Her and Kelly Clarkson are my favourite singers from American Idol. I never heard of Carrie until 2007 when I heard her singing that song Ever Ever After from Enchanted.
WOW never expected that Simon... never saw this I thought she was great... and it was Pat Benatar for crying out loud, probably the greatest female rock voice ever
My reaction to the judges reactions: Well now she has several Female Entertainer of the Year awards under her belt. Good for you Carrie! #provingthemwrong
Gosh. I think Pat would be VERY happy with what 60 to 90 seconds of Idol time did your her song and Carrie... Flubbed words? Who gives a flip. Carrie kept on going, played it as well as if the song was written her way. GREAT charisma and courage here. Love ya Carrie! Randy C-17A :)
I think this girl might have a future Best singer/ Artist American Idol has ever had own the show. She is AWESOME compare this to the present day idol contestants,,,,wow soooo much better
Carrie has got the chops to sing anything including Pat Benatar (difficult). This is not her genre but I thought she was very good considering most Country stars can't make that leap to hard rock except maybe Luke Bryan. He is versatile too.
I can not believe he said that!!! I cant believe he thought that too...... I sure 99% of any one hears this will disgree with him, Carrie freaking rocked that song! that is why she where she is at now .... I wondering if he just said that for tv drama to stir things up a bit
Carrie is not a convincing rock singer....at all. She lacks the heart for rock (she has it for country) and the grit. You can tell she was just singing the words, not much emotion behind it.
I remember this...it's when I said she is going to win. I thought she sounded amazing even though the judges said she didn't do great. Her voice was amazing for a very distinctive sound from Pat
i love when carrie sings pats songs, she is an amazing singer as pat was. Loved Simons comment though a kitten trying to be a tiger......Carrie is the girl next door and the kind youd take home to mama...........Love HER
Sorry but I have to disagree with a lot of ya. I loved Pat Benetar when i was 15 or 16 and she was the first concert I ever went to. And while she has amazing vocals, i would give Carrie the thumbs up every day of the week. I want to hear Carrie sing Hell is for Children, that is the Pat song for her
Carrie is a fantastic singer and though she does a great job on this song, it just makes me realize all the more what a phenom Pat Benatar was. She really had no equal.
One of my favourite performance from her include Alone, Independence day, god bless the broken road, angel brought you here, inside your heaven and many more.
![[07] Pat Benatar - Love Is a Battlefield - Live 2001](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NBIQGoayN7Y/mqdefault.jpg)
![[07] Pat Benatar - Love Is a Battlefield - Live 2001](/img/tr.png)
NO ONE can sing like Pat Benatar - but this performance has the same guts, passion and dang if she didn't hit the notes.
Hav e Carrie sing it now when she’s not sick, she sing it just as good
This is an old video. Looking back it's easy to see some people are just born with great talent. Carrie is one of them.
“It’s an older code, sir, but it checks out.”
Now years later she’s a multi platinum recordist and multi time Grammy winner. Take that judges.
Take that? They helped give her the win and how should Paula take that when she’s still more successful? You sound retarded 😂
That’s what I’m saying they judged her so hard for her pics that she picked for the show but none of them were singers or even good singers even be judging her on how she should be singing just doesn’t make any sense to me why they put people on herethat isn’t even good singers or even knows how to judge somebody, especially if they’ve never picked up a microphone before in their life. Simon Carroll hasn’t even written a song or even sang a song that guy can’t even hold a damn note.
I can't agree with two of the judges on this one. You know, Pat Benatar is one of the most difficult singers to emulate because of her incredible range and style of music. However, I am very impressed by this old performance from Carrie. In my opinion, she did a fantastic job and nailed it as well as anyone ever could! She can sing just about anything and do it well.
Not a HUGE Carrie Underwood fan, but honestly I have to say she rocked the shit out of this song, and only partly because she was wagging her ass so well...
Saigon1975 DO IT GOOD NOT DO IT WELL
ChildOfThe1970s agree! She was amazing!
Well simon felt like an ass the next week bcuz carrie had a bad cold durin that performance and got up there and wuz awsum anyway
I agree! Carrie did just as well as Pat! Excellent!
I love Pat Benatar and if I could relive the 80's I would, but Carrie rocked this down and made this her own version. Fantastic!
007jimmymac She sang it strong!! She rocked it!! The way it should have been!
Don't let the judges get you down Carrie I think you can still win this show.
bruh you dumb as fuck. This shit was like 10 years ago.
I really hope Carrie wins.
+EliteG3 kkkkkkkk
He was being facetious.
Dat_boi1337 lol
I think this girl might have a future
Don't let the judges get you down Carrie I think you can still win this show.
😂😂
I think this girl might have a future
This just shows that Carrie can do ANYTHING!!!! She is awesome
She totally rocked the song,powerful voice ever.
One of the best version
Best singer/ Artist American Idol has ever had own the show. She is AWESOME
Barbara Carroll She is certainly not the best singer from AI. Not even close.
+tangled55 she makes the most and has the longest tour from AI
tangled55 actually as far as girls from American idol go Carrie Kellie and Kelly are all three equally incredible. Whatever you're smoking AND.drinking.to make you say that needs to be thrown out. Then you can hear how wrong your statement is
I like this just as much as the Pat Benetar version tbh
You fool
a tip: watch series on instaflixxer. Been using it for watching a lot of movies during the lockdown.
@Joshua Owen Yup, I've been watching on InstaFlixxer for years myself =)
It's hearing how hard Carrie works to sing this, that makes you appreciate what an incredible vocalist Pat Benatar is.
my favourite Carrie performance on Idol!
compare this to the present day idol contestants,,,,wow soooo much better
she nailed the song! way to go!
she really knows how to sing and bring out the lyrics
Man, she killed it. the judges were Trippin'...
That hip movement and that stomp have not changed one bit
Yeah she nailed it, And Love is a battlefield and Shadows of the night are very personal to me
First she killed it with Alone by Heart, then this Pat Benatar classic. I have loved her since the first televised audition. She also reawakened my favorite show. I had lost interest the previous 2yrs. I was ready to accept that after Kelly Clarkson's voice and success tgat the format couldnt be replicated consistently and that we had seen the best already. I kinda expected the talents to continue to dewindle for another couple seasons till eventually closing the doors voluntarily, or being cancelled. Then season 4 started! 🥰🌹
Carrie rock soul is always there. See her performance with Guns n Roses. She rock!!!
"Watching a kitten who wants to be a tiger"? I'd love to hear the judge's thoughts on Carrie rocking out to Paradise City. :P
I love her as a country artist and that's where her heart is, but girl definitely knows how to rock out.
She’s awesome
She cracked all their faces tho...That's Carrie "Got me 120 awards and 6 are Grammys" Underwood to you now, Randy, Paula and Simon...#boom
She nailed it, I don't know why they said that. I think the show is the one who rushed it for her because of their time. Leave her alone to do that song in a real concert and she will blow the house down!
I agree, I only heard it for the 1st time, and I'm a Big Pat Benetar fan, she did it GREAT!
That was really good. It's like the judges already pre planned there comments.
+Sam King Great cover. I think Pat Benatar would be proud!!
RVL480 Van uucnd
Good to see that the style of jeans hasn't changed since back then.
One of the best enough said
I love Carrie Underwood .Her and Kelly Clarkson are my favourite singers from American Idol. I never heard of Carrie until 2007 when I heard her singing that song Ever Ever After from Enchanted.
WOW never expected that Simon... never saw this I thought she was great... and it was Pat Benatar for crying out loud, probably the greatest female rock voice ever
This was really one of the top 10 performances ever on American idol!! Randy was tripping!!!
Amazing performance! Go Carrie!
Just so everybody knows...this woman has sold 40 million records to date. Incredibly talented!
One of the most respectful version between all I been seeing.
My reaction to the judges reactions:
Well now she has several Female Entertainer of the Year awards under her belt. Good for you Carrie! #provingthemwrong
Come on y'all, she rocked it. She's a hot kitten.
I'm still laughing over simons "a kitten who wants to be a tiger" LMAO!!!
NO ONE can sing like Pat Benatar - but this performance has the same guts, passion and dang if she didn't rock it OUT! Props.
She's incredible. And gorgeous. And just the nicest person
loved it.....
Carrie you where stunning don't listen to negatives. My favourite performance ❤ 💖
Gosh. I think Pat would be VERY happy with what 60 to 90 seconds of Idol time did your her song and Carrie... Flubbed words? Who gives a flip. Carrie kept on going, played it as well as if the song was written her way. GREAT charisma and courage here. Love ya Carrie! Randy C-17A :)
well, the 80's was my prime and You rocked singing this song! You can do rock Carrie...big time: just do it your way girl.
I strongly Agree!!!
she nails every song she sings. and she looks gorgeous all the time!
I loved it! I think she was excellent!! Best rendition of the song i've ever heard.
This was amazing and a different side to Carrie then were used to
Under STOOD 👑💎
I think Carrie did an amazing job vocally and live to the rock theme. Nice job
she sounds good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
All time favorite winners: Kris, Kelly, Cookie & Carries.
I say this as someone who isn’t a Carrie Underwood fan, but she fucking delivered here. Hands down.
I think this girl might have a future
Best singer/ Artist American Idol has ever had own the show. She is AWESOME
compare this to the present day idol contestants,,,,wow soooo much better
love carrie underwood. she deff deserved to win that season!
Come on y'all, she rocked it. She's a hot kitten.
Carrie has got the chops to sing anything including Pat Benatar (difficult). This is not her genre but I thought she was very good considering most Country stars can't make that leap to hard rock except maybe Luke Bryan. He is versatile too.
"They were good this season but there WILL NEVER be another Carrie or Kelly!!! "
Did you forget about Adam Lambert?
Couldnt even win his own season...
Yes, I did.
I can not believe he said that!!! I cant believe he thought that too...... I sure 99% of any one hears this will disgree with him, Carrie freaking rocked that song! that is why she where she is at now .... I wondering if he just said that for tv drama to stir things up a bit
+Stephanie Salazar That's not why she is where she is now. Have you seen her sing a rock song lately?
Carrie is not a convincing rock singer....at all. She lacks the heart for rock (she has it for country) and the grit. You can tell she was just singing the words, not much emotion behind it.
Absolut amazing thanks God for you
Love is a Battlefield is one of my favorite songs. Even though she isn't as good as the original, it's great.
Carrie rocked this song!
Incredible- you are truly blessed!
Wish I could see Carrie cover the whole song. She would kill it!!
Grandiosa!! Poderosa voz
I remember this...it's when I said she is going to win. I thought she sounded amazing even though the judges said she didn't do great. Her voice was amazing for a very distinctive sound from Pat
i Know you were i am reading a Book all about you and i am your bigest fan ever me and my Sister always listen todo your song blone away😂😇
How old r u?
no one can tell us were wrong, searching our hearts for so long. she said , no one can tell us were wrong, then skips to no promises no demands.
Excellent performance.....Thanks for posting
i love when carrie sings pats songs, she is an amazing singer as pat was. Loved Simons comment though a kitten trying to be a tiger......Carrie is the girl next door and the kind youd take home to mama...........Love HER
Great workmanship ❤
Wow greatest cover of this song I’ve ever heard...
carrie is seriously so amazing there is no one better then her on the planet
Simon, Carrie is a TIGRESS!
I'm still laughing over simons "a kitten who wants to be a tiger" LMAO!!!
Good rendition.
Sorry but I have to disagree with a lot of ya. I loved Pat Benetar when i was 15 or 16 and she was the first concert I ever went to. And while she has amazing vocals, i would give Carrie the thumbs up every day of the week. I want to hear Carrie sing Hell is for Children, that is the Pat song for her
dame she rock it out,
mop the
I've always thought Carrie Underwood sounded like Pat Benetar. It was cool to hear her do one of Pat's songs.
Victor R. Pat is not even close to better. Both are EQUALLY as perfect as each other
Wow, i didnt know she had such a powerful voice. Nice
Her rebuttal to Cowell's "Kitten" remark can be found at the ACMs in her duet with Steven Tyler on "Walk This Way."
That was freakin' amazing. so powerful.
Wonderful voice. You sound great
gorgeous!
omg, she really is a talent
amazing!
I called her as the winner when I saw her audition. It was so obvious.
sweet bass run at the end.
I think she SLLLLAYYED IT!
she was awesome, no matter waht they say
Perfeita!!!
she is great!
excelente cover
Carrie is a fantastic singer and though she does a great job on this song, it just makes me realize all the more what a phenom Pat Benatar was. She really had no equal.
Omg....she nailed it.
Amazing!!!
AWESOME!!!!!
Love it !
how the hell did they not like it? she did an amazing job I swear this girl can sing any song and make it sound good
One of my favourite performance from her include Alone, Independence day, god bless the broken road, angel brought you here, inside your heaven and many more.
Carrie underwood can sing every song she hears and every song she pick up