YT56 Surah Al-Kahf(Surah 18):Does the sun set in a muddy pool? Exposing some misguided Quran tafseer
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 07. 2024
- We provide a detailed analysis and interpretation of Verses 18:86 to Verse 18:91 of Surah Al-Kahf (Surah 18) of the Quran, including the first two scenes of the story of Zul Qarnayn...
We use the Abrahamic locution and the nested interpretation concept, both of which are part of the Quranic methodology that we use for interpreting the Quran using the Quran.
Some of the video segments that were referenced in this segment are:
Who were Cain and Abel? • YT52 Surah Al-Baqarah ...
How Zul Qarnayn became powerful? • YT53 Surah Al-Kahf (Su...
Does God stit on a throne? • YT54 Surah Al-Kahf(Sur...
Timestamps:
0:00 Intro
0:33 Does the Sun Set in a Pool of Mud?
0:57 A Quick Reminder
1:34 Āya 18:86
3:08 Traditional Problematic Translations
4:28 The Origin of the Problem
12:38 What is “Ɛaynin ḤamiꜤah” عَيْنٍ حَمِئَةٍ?
18:08 Āya 18:86 (cont.)
25:12 Āya 18:87
26:18 Āya 18:88
28:17 Āya 18:89-91
31:59 Outro
To learn more, Please follow us on
Facebook Marvelous Quran
Website www.marvelousquran.org
You may contact us at
Gmail MarvelousQuran@gmail.com
Please Share, Subscribe, and Like
Quran Translation and Commentary by Dr. Hany Atchan
Salaamun Alaykum Dr. Hany, I’m a level one Arabic student to improve my understanding of the Divine message. However, you brought to my attention meaning of أَتْبَعَ which is clearly explained in the Arabic text as a form IV verb. For days I was struggling with the traditional translation “he followed” in our Quran to your given meaning “to have others follow”, when my husband showed how to interpret this derived verb. I do not follow your explanation blindly, but checkout evidence. When your explanation is different, I have so far always successfully connected your findings with evidence. I’m very fortunate that I have come across your research and interpretation in my lifetime. May Allah keep guiding us to interpret and apply message of Quran.
Alhamdulillah. This is exactly what we teach. Always check the evidence yourself!
Alhamdulillah
This makes perfect sense to me alhamdulillaah. This warning of the 'threat' to a muslim and muslim ummah is so alive. Muslim is encouraged to read this surah at least every week. After a long struggle and unaddressed queries of many terms in the Quran now been relieved and felt this is divine. Allaahu akbar against wrong interpretation. May Allaah protect and reward you Dr Hany, and forgive and reward the earlier scholars whose clean and pure in their intention. Maa shaa Allaah, it is so rewarding reading/learning alQuran this way, through your way taking me/us step by step, huruf by huruf, word by word, and ponder and question and wait and trust Allaah that He will guide us the answer/meaning. This way, huruf of the Quran would stick to my heart firmly. Alhamdulillaah alone who puts patience, brevity in your heart to shake the world, and I believe and pray Allaah will protect you and your family j team and us all. I pray, may Allaah puts more love to in our heart and our children's heart to learn alQuran this way, hence live by its teachings. May, sooner or latter, this becomes a channel or institution that gathers others similar effort to work together/synergize to revisit and apply this divine method of understanding the Quran. Thanks and jazaakumullaah akhiy Dr Hany. Alhamdulillaah
AL hamdu liL Llah for the detail historical analysis of this Ayat of the Quran. Thank you Dr. Hany. May Allahh grant you more insight
What I understood when I read this ayah is that, when a person standing on the sea shore and watching the sun setting he feels that the sun is setting in the sea because Quraan says ' they found it' setting in the sea, it speaks about their views, their feelings. This is the beauty of the Quraan.
you are right abouat the setting of the sun onthe horizon but not of the sea but the big (michigan)
Such a perfect translation you offer Dr.Hany
The beauty of it is that it makes sense with the earlier verses and the verse following it.
May allah increase you in knowledge
Aameen. You too
@@MarvelousQuran Insha Allah💗
The historical context of Tafseer is very important to understand and consider if we are seeking to be truthful.
Alhamdulillah br I really learn a lot just listening this particular ayah 86 surah AL KAHF I memorized I red translation words by words , many times I have more graped to understand this ayah please create more massage for shake of learning this Deen. wich I strongly believe in, make my foundation Iman stronger
Subhanallah. Allah reward you.
Your explanations and grasp of the language is impressive and assists us
Alhamdulillah, Al-Quran will always reveal more information when people gain more knowledge. Insyaallah.
Prophet Muhammad pbuh did discuss with Sahaba how to call for Prayer, indicate that the call of Prayer (adhan) was not direct in Quran, but interpretation of Muhammad and Sahaba and put into practice.
Thank you for your perfect translation, i simply do not know how many doubtful muslims left islam just for this single mistranslated verse, may allah grant you jannah, jazakallah khayr
Alhamdulillah. This interpretation is very coherent and releven than all the previous tafsir/translations.
Jazakumullah kharan. Thanks for sharing it with us.
🙏Grazie. You're the only one who's teaching is always connect and make's "we your qawm to see the shams mubinan with good yusiran" Without any confusion. Baraka ALLAH alaika ya imam al Bayan al mubin 🙏🙏🙏
Wow, thank you... I am soooo impressed by your mastery of these concepts
Alhamdulillah alone. He gave us this way to connect with my Qawm whose hearts are ready to be quenched by His direct guidance
Baraka ALLAH alaika you too brother (or sister)
@@MarvelousQuran am a brother😃 ya Sheikh
Marvelous brother...
Another very interesting lecture, Dr. Hany! MasyaAllaah! Tabarakallah!
Your explanation of the ayah (18:89) at 28:40 makes me think that the whole story of Zul Qarnayn is about describing the two conditions or reality of the field of da'wah and how to deal with them.
I can't wait for the sequel of this topic! Thank you!
Yes, exactly... Again, sooo perceptive...
But there is a reality to the story itself that we will expose insha Allahh
@@MarvelousQuran I'm waiting.... :)
Mashallah, the best interpretation of this verse, I have seen many different interpretations of this verse but one of them which was comparable with you is this" when Mr Zol reached he looked at the sun as much as that one of his eyes became murky and muddy that he couldn't see no more, however most interpreter interpreting his eye was his right eye but som said no it was left. Any way Mr Zol lost one of his eyes because he looked at the sun for a long time. They say one of the reason of blindness is looking at sun without a murky sunglasses."
Very inspiring, please keep it up!
Insha Allahh
Salaamun Alaykum. Revisit this segment and learn new things. Alhamdulillah.
I think the word wajadaha means that; that was what he( Zulqarnain) saw, or what it seems to be, in his perspective, NOT in Allah perspective.
I think Allah did not means to tell us that the sun is setting in the muddy water, but instead, Allah is telling us what Zulqarnain saw during that time. NOT what Allah saw!
When we discuss about DzulQarnain, we need to find out when this happened and how he travelled on earth from one point to another point ? Would anyone can tell answer the above 2 questions before we could interpret the verse.
Alhamdulillah. I learn a lot.
Thank you Dr. Handy for opening mine and hopefully many Muslim brothers and sisters who has no knowledge of the true meaning of these ayahs .
To assume the sun means the messenger is NOT right. The verse is clear. The problem is that that people are taking it literally instead of understanding it's poetic rendition. All it means is that the messenger(Dhul Qarnain) arrived at the place of murky waters at sunset or maqrib. No stretching it further.
Plz watch all the videos in the series, from the beginning.
We answered this specific question in the last segment. We also demonstrated the fact that shams indicates messenger in an earlier video...
You are missing some facts that we covered
Regards
Never heard this explanation, interesting.
@Tabish Gawai Is he? Let´s hear your explanation then.
In my language Oromo of Ethiopia which is an Afro-Asiatic categorized language, "Ija Hama" which it means bad eyes has similar explanation as Dr. Hani. Amazing.
Assalamuaalaikum Dr Hany Atchan
I just had a question on these verses :
18:85 So he travelled a course
18:86 until he reached the setting ˹point˺ of the sun, which appeared to him to be setting in a spring of murky water, where he found some people. We said, “O Ⱬul-Qarnain! Either punish them or treat them kindly.”
What if, its not what QzulQarnain seeing as if the sun set in the black muddy spring water but actually it was he himself that submerged in a the black muddy spring water?
Regards
I've found out a phrase in English that describes in my opinion what the equivalent of the muddy pool you described as indicating a certain place with certain people with unlikable ways
They say in politics , the swamp and draining the swamp meaning getting rid of corruption in politics
salaamun alaykum,could you please provide sources for books and references you got these conversations and narations from,and authenticity.thank you.
Intellectual intuitive spiritual Insight.....Great work Dr. Hany
Who is Zhul Qarnayn and what is Zhul Qarnayn? My understanding the events may repeat and the mission ends with Dawah...
Is Qarnayn referring to 2 horns or 2 epochs?
جزاك الله خير
dua for you sir. and the muslims of the world. it may be guessed but i think it's more pleasant to remain with an extreme quiriosity with an assurence which is completely unknown will be revealed.
Thank you
Salamun alaikum, Alhumdulialh.
May Allah guide us to self-correcting methodology.
Great tafseer, thanks. could you please tell me how many meanings the word " ardh " has in the quran?
The Quran has several layers of meanings, and for each layer, there may be different vocabulary
We discussed this, partly, in this video...czcams.com/video/noBa4w76O58/video.html
Please watch it all the way until the end... Regards
I always felt murky pool referred to the Black Sea ie he was east of it.
Have you got any feedback from the contemporary ulema about such a unique Interpretation of the verses??Do they agree with it?
Alhamdulillah many respected scholars whom I respect have written to us in private with strong support. However, there will be many who see this approach as a threat, and will never agree to it. Such is the way of all new 3ilm.
Assalamu alaikum. Dr Hany, JazakAllah once again for describing these beautiful Signs of Quran.
So according to this, Dhul Qarnaen was a prophet? Am I right?
Is that were you asking?
Brother you are rght but messenger means having a message but a prophet prophesizing futures. So Mr Zol is messenger that one of his eyes because of looking so long at the sun became blind.
Black Sea. It is dark and murky. Simple. That's where the sun was setting
Masha'Allah amazing work as always brother, Allah reward you. Is Dhul Qarnain the same man that was with Musa and the boy?
i think it was king sulaiman
Yes, it goes without saying. It is better never asking a question that one knowing the answer brother.
muddy pool ....... i can't believe this. that "muddy pool" got me really. what was i thinking throughout the whole time? May Allah(SAT) guide us to the truth.
Excellent insights... Keep up the good work Sir. Salamun Alaikum.
Thank you, I will Insha Allahh
Hello Sir.. Thanks again for this wonderful presentation on the topic which has kept almost complete muslim community in a confusion. Seems to be something relatable. I am thinking this must be Suleman AS as some qualities mentioned in quran matches to his like he was give quality of judgement, it seems he was also on mission to remove all impurities from the message of rasool from the mindset of people as appeared from the last video on Suleman and Queen of Sheeba. Also he was given some knowledge related to copper which he has used in the story of Zulqarnain. But thats my guess and opinion. Definitely waiting for the next video.
Good thinking... But Alas, you fell into the trap I have been warning you guys about... I manipulated your Weltanschauung in earlier videos, and now your mind is primed to think I was still talking about the same thing .... You get it? ;) ;) ;) :-) :-)
Amazing amazing amazing
Salam, every school boy knows that the sun doesn’t set in a muddy spring or murky water. That’s the reason allah said “HE” found it setting in a muddy spring or murky water’. In fact sun doesn’t set anywhere, it is appeared to be set only… as per the relativity theory (physics)it is correct. All the above translations are true because they didn’t said that it sun sets in a murky water rather they said ‘it appeared to him or he found’.
My friend there is no problem with 'he found it setting in a murky spring", because it's a poetic and allegorical expression not a scientific one, very simple.
The Quran is NOT poetry... Did you watch the video about "the relevance principle"?
When poets has become mainstream at the time.. Yes, there was no problem.. Now, we have a tafseer that better suited for our times.. The Qur'an is a living miracle, brother.
Exodus* Prophet muhammad [may Allah be plesed with him] was not a poet.Allegorie in quran? yes but not poetry.Dont get it confused with European writings writing.
Salaam everyone 1st time ive come to this channel can somebody plz advise me where do i start in learning the quran in this new method
Salaamun Alaykum
I recommend the two key playlists: Abrahamic locution, and then the Methodology
All the videos build on each other. So if you start from the oldest and move forward in date of release, you will get the most benefit.
We are here if you have questions
Welcome aboard
Regards
@@MarvelousQuran jazakAllah khair
30:04
Quran {18.90} Confused about "He found it rising upon a group", why is there "it" preposition ? (I do not know arabic)
pronoun
@@MarvelousQuran Sorry to keep bothering but, why is there "it" in the sentence? "It" is used for objects, not living things, it sounds like its talking about the sun. He found it rising, sounds like he (zulqarnayn) found "it" rising, as if its something other than himself.
"It" represents the sun in the metaphorical linguistic composition of the sentence. The semantic indication then takes us to understand sun as messenger. I hope it's clear
Thanks. I have been challenged few time by Christians who say the quran is not scientific as Allah says the sun sets in water. My reply is it never said that, but what Zulqurnaim sees, as it appears to him that it sets in water. Like for instance a child not understanding will say the sun set in ocean. So it is refering to what he saw, Zulqurnain. But thanks for further ellevoration, which I found very useful.
A Pakistani Islamic preacher Sahil Adeem also shed some light on this topic. He interprets that the events that happened with Zulqarnain are not of this world and belongs to some intergalactic journey of his. The setting of star (i.e sun) refers to the death of a star in a black hole and ways of travelling of Zulqarnain are the portals in which a person can travel with the speed of light and travel throughout galaxy
Any Quranic evidence for this fantastical hyperbolic opinion?
We are not presenting opinions... We are using a clear, rigid, and careful Quranic methodology
Again interesting interpretation Dr Hany, but I dont see a problem with the sun setting in muddy water. Of course most readers arent going o think zul qarnain literally saw ot set in the water. Only Quran critics have said that, but does it really matter if enemies of Islam question its meanings? Dr Hany do you think this verse could have 2 meanings, one literal as universally understood and the another more allegorical as yours?
Where does the sun set?
I understand this verse to be saying that Al Qarnayn was in the spring when he found the sun setting.
if you heard the saying, The sun sets in the bey, same meaning, its being seen from afar
@@scottiefranklin2147
The verse says he (Qarnayn) found it (the sun) setting in a murky spring. So he found the sun setting while he was in a spring.
@@thesignsofgodareamongyou8306 its details in dirrection on how to find the place.
Isn't there a possibility Super nova is being mentioned here ain ul hamiya black mud . Mayb its physics ayah
Please make an interpretation on the verse that says
"Lord of the two sunrises and two sunsets"
We will insha Allahh in a future series, coming soon
I stopped in between to look at translation. I could understand Ard and sabbaba and sun (illuminating with knowledge) as it was already explained. However, I still don't understand why the people where the sun was rising (people ready to accept the teachings and scriptures) were unprotected. Or no further info on them as the salient points have been made.
The third part of the story is about Gog and Magog. Waiting for that...
As you reminded a couple of time to guess who Dhul Qarnain would be, I began to think of Isa (AS). Now I am wondering if the last section of the surah Kahaf is linked to the first section (people of the cave).
I did read comments of other people before writing down mine. I found someone identifying Dhul Qarnain as a person of two epochs.
The clear verse where Isa (AS) would speak to people in young and mature age (3:46)...I have started to contemplate on it.
I think the people who were unprotected refers to the group of people who live in a place where sun does not set for a long time. As Allah says in the Quran “ And made the night as clothing”78:10. Allah knows the best. Salam
can someone link this guy's qualifications? who is he really? I can't find anything on him.
Do you mean "You can't find anything bad on him?"
What, exactly, is bothering you about this guy?
Timestamps:
0:00 Intro
0:33 Does the Sun Set in a Pool of Mud?
0:57 A Quick Reminder
1:34 Āya 18:86
3:08 Traditional Problematic Translations
4:28 The Origin of the Problem
12:38 What is “Ɛaynin ḤamiꜤah” عَيْنٍ حَمِئَةٍ?
18:08 Āya 18:86 (cont.)
25:12 Āya 18:87
26:18 Āya 18:88
28:17 Āya 18:89-91
31:59 Outro
Thank you very much. Uploaded
zulkarnain story. a story of yakjuj makjuj. can u explain why majority scholar refer to ayat 96-97 in surah al anbiya? it is clear that 95 verse also included. 95-96 verse is the the key. why nobodys talking about it?
Assalamualaikum Dr.
When you said, when he reached or reaches (later in FUTURE) at his final destination. I can only think about 'Isa AS.
Dzul qarn ayn, the man who posses two epochs. Isa AS. Wallahu A'lam.
Zul qarnayn - Muhammad ﷺ
Alhamdulillah!
i saw in my village sun was setting sink at red ocean, except during raining ...
come to my village to felt amazing sunset...borneo west coast..
Watch the whole series please.
Thank you
You're welcome
Alhamdulillah
Assalamualaikum Dr,
This is a very interesting interpretation. But, I have a question that I find quite puzzling. Why does the verses stated that Zul Qarnayn reaches a location where the messenger completes his mission first and then afterwards he reaches the location where his mission begins? Shouldn't it be the other way around? Hope you clarify this in the next video. Thank you.
It will become clearer in the next and final segment on Zul Qarnayn
What I think is, while trying to study about zul quarnain in the Qur'an,one should also have to study the verses in surah Al anbiya where there is a second reference of yajuj and majuj because the story of zul quarnain in surah Al kahf where there is a first reference takes us to the subject of yajuj and majuj... I believe that this is the right approach....
Keep watching the whole series because what you propose is exactly what we did. Thank you
@@MarvelousQuran , if it is so, which town Allah swt is talking about in surah Al anbiya that he destroyed and who were the people expelled and most importantly those people can return to the town only after yajuj and majuj are released ?
Which aya specifically are you referring to?
Sir.u r correct.
Dear sir, please upgrade the volume of the sound of your channel. I found that sound is much lower compared to other channels.
Salaam Alaykum
Could you please check the video on another device... Is it the same problem?
@@MarvelousQuran
Yes if we compare with any other videos on CZcams your volum is low
You are doing hard work please record with high quality sound
OK... Please try our videos on other devices. If it makes a difference, plz let us know what kind of devices the audio is low
Because only a handful of complaints have been received so far
@@MarvelousQuran
Now your latest vedio has very clear and good Volume and it is not very low volume As earlier recording
Wajadaha tagrubu fi aynin hamiatin.
Doesn't it suggest that dhulqarnayn was (wajadaha) witnessing the sun (or say messenger as u transltated in the video) setting, declining, in aynin hamiatin.
How do u get that this was the place where dhulqarnayn witnessed his own life end. Then comes summa atba'a sababa. He reached another placed after this magribash shams incidence.
Please watch the series from the beginning... We remind you at the beginning of the video that this is a continuation of prior videos.
Let us know after you watch the other videos
Today train 🚆 crashed near Gotki district Sindh Pakistan. Please pray for departure souls May Allah grant them in jannah and give patience to their families 😥
إنا لله وإنا إليه راجعون
ربنا ارحمهم واعف عنهم واجعلهم من المقبولين
If I am not wrong, the first scenario refers to the Jews and hypocrats in Medina. The second scenario refers to the Qureish in Mecca (Fathul Mecca). But Allah knows best
Why is hard to understand the verse? Whenni was at beach i saw sun setting into sea. When i was on top of mountain I saw it setting on mountain. What the verse means is the geographic location of that place where he the zulkarnain saw the sun was setting into mud.
Please watch the whole series about Zul Qarnayn, and you will understand why this is the wrong interpretation
@@MarvelousQuran i am not an arab but i understand arabic. I am a malay come from malaysia. In our classical language when we describe a place, that is foreign, we often use the words like " the place that sunrise from the end of branch of tree" or " go to the place where sun is rising between black rock". We know this does not actually means sun reside in the rock. We describe a place or based on the chateristic of sun and moon that uniquely of that place. The reason because we dont know the name of that place like london, new york. When this verse 18:86 is used as a verse to disproved quran, i really dont understand why. Because from the face of the ayah its clearly talk about specific location
@@MarvelousQuran i am not saying you are wrong but in the same time i am not agree with your interpretation.
Thank you for your deep investigative work and showing us how biblical and talmudic concepts/stories where injected into the quranic interpretations.
I am shocked that no scholars for the last 1400+ years did not realize this fact! Please continue your work and may Allah SWT increase your knowledge, wisdom and grant guidance.
This is also an overwhelming task to re interpret the Quran based in this methodology and this challenge may end up taking a few lifetimes to do so. But I pray that Allah SWT makes it easy for us all.
Thank you. Insha ALlahh we will make a significant impact in the right direction
the story is not for people of the begining oftime . this story is for our time
Great
الحمدلله الذي هدانا لهذا وماكنا لنهتدي لولا أن هدانا الله لقد جآت رسل ربنا بالحق
Salaams, I am saying is it probably prophet Moosa As. peace and blessings
Please make a translation as soon as possible.
Many of us are unable to study the quran the same way you can.
Insha Allahh
Working on it
Salaamun alaikum, Alhamdulillah.
I think its scientific translation is different, why dont we think zulqarnain was person who was given special powers to ascend or travel through the doors of sky which Allah mentioned multiple times in Quran, if we translate the meaning of سببا ways of those doors where angles come from سببا also used in surah yaseen in same context and عين حمئة a black hole, bcoz it looks like an eye its look like muddy eye, now proven sun revolves around black hole in milky way and rises and sets into there, so it could be a portal or way where zulqarnain faced yegog and megog, one more reason is that he also built copper and iron walls that doesnt make sense that he built huge mountain like walls on the earth obviously he would do on the earthy that must be some rocky and cement material, so conclusion is that this all happend on another world or earth, and yegog and megog are using some eletromegnetic forces to escape from that portal سببا, and copper and iron together exibhit electromegnetic properties, Allah say فتحت , its mean some kind of doors or portals will be opened for yegog and megog they will be freed and they will come through every ascendant...all this story looks like intergallectic story and yegog megog dont look like the creature of this earth, as there are 7 earths and heavens, Dajjal as well and Daabat ul Arz...باقي والله عالم
Really? Wow!
@@MarvelousQuran yes sir, black hole is proven reality, and black hole is also called dark matter, and now scientific reaseach shows that black holes could be intergalactic doors through wich we can travel from one galaxy to another galaxy, so it fits very well that zulqarnain was the king who was given the keys of theses portals and he faced nations along these paths سببا, and protected them and also he protected our earth coz he built the walls on both sides of صدفین that usually traslated as mountains but how جبلين was not used instead sadafein, and if we accept he built walls on earth then yegog and megog could come from sides of sadafein, but this didnt happen and still they couldnt escape coz its not walls on the earth..also ahdith tells us their population that is 999% of our earth population and tgey will come in waves like wasps, so it fits very well that all happend on another earth..
Myb it was just a representation of what they were seeing this is normal when u travel in the sea
Dr. Hannay, recently a lot people are redeeming muddy water to black hole and zulqarnain as being performed galactic journey. All this is linked to portals, yajaoj majooj and at the end engender time of dajjal when these closed portals will be opened. I know it sounds crazy at first but, kindly clarify have come across such literal meaning of Quran, sahi hadees.
The interpretation that we provided is very consistent with dozens of other concepts and especially consistent with the Abrahamic Locution which is used extensively throughout the whole Quran.
Is it.. That, Dhul Qarnain.. Is meaning, possessor of two qarn (qarn means age?? Or external and internal sight?) ... So now putting what you explained together .. I am understanding that it is the beginning of the message of Allah swt to the end of that message of Allah swt, which is the current age where yajooj and majooj are the ones who are only one eyed that is without insight and only external sight of physical eyes (locked into materialism) and are everywhere coming in today from every side in every field,
Well, this what I am understanding alongwith the help of your explanation..
t will make more sense when we reveal who ZQ is/was insha Allahh soon
Keep watching
@@MarvelousQuran Insha'Allah..
So u ar telling us that we ignore the best of generations and believe u. Where did u get this
That is NOT what I am telling you.
I am telling believe the evidence from the Quran before you believe me or anyone else
We have a Quranic methodology that we use... Do you know what "methodology" means?
When the Medina people sang anta shamsu, anta badru are they saying You are messenger, You are Nabi (prophet). ?
Mashaa Allahh... It's possible
"We provided no shelter from the messenger" what is this? 29:28 Sound illogical with new translation you did.
Watch the whole video plz.
The expression "Min Doon" means "in between"
Watch this video to learn the full explanation czcams.com/video/RzYVUyq1-Fk/video.html
Wow all these scholars and shaykh’s. I do believe that as we get further away from the prophet (saws) we are more in error. This is why dajjal will appear and only Isa Ibn Maryam can clear things up. How will all this make our ibaadah better. Too much google scholar’s.
Aya 41:53
I think this appropriate translation
Do you also doing interpretation about prophet narative..?
Yes
It's like watching a Thriller movie. I thought of that Messenger already. May be I am wrong. Zul Qarnayn = Man belongs to two epoch??? Please release the next video asap.
yu are right isa as
@@mohdazizmohdsaad2864 Subahanallah, I revisited the whole history surrounding Surah Kahaf. it's very fascinating that Jews were the one who asked 3 question. I personally believe that what Jews were referring to Zul Qarnayn who may be a person who travelled geographically. Which I believe in between the valley of Black Sea and Caspian Sea and in Caucasian mountains. It's astonishing that Allah replied the answer with two parallel story, hidden inside one inside the other layer of geographical Zul Qarnayn. Allahu Akbar, Only Allah can do this. my heart is shivering...I am very Thankful to this channel.
We need dictionary of abrahamic locution.
Yes, I agree with you.. For all abstract understanding of the roots
Exactly we need to know more about Abrahamic locution because all terms which is being used are used as foundation. It has to be conveyed to people at earliest. Its a request Dr Hany please make some elaborative video to at least tell the technique so that we can apply and check.
@ FARAZ AZAM VERY WELL! Now you understand why we have been slowly, providing a bit at a time, getting you used to the methodology and the Bayyinaat... Had I given you the answers, as you all have been asking me to do, you would not have believed me...
You need to understand the methodology, so that you learn it, and so that you trust its results and answers
@@MarvelousQuran insha'Allah, please do consider some type of platform.. Where we can ask questions (as there are many I have, like for example the story of ayyub AS or the ayah where it is said Isa AS is the sign of the hour.. And many other verses) so we can share/exchange our researches and understanding..
I think we "the qawm of Sheikh al Bayan ul mubin" Should first comprehend (yasiran) the methods and terminology (Amal alsualihan) before we can do self study. I think Dr. (Sheikh) should have for us we the interested qawm a course (guide) in at least 3 levels with materials and references to the Ibrahimic locution and deep understanding of the glorious QURAN.
Sir, in Indonesia we have Fahmi Basya. He is a proffesor of Math.He carefully point the meaning of words of Quran by Quran Itself.
But mainly he make clearer the puzzles of math hidden formulas in Quran.
I trully eager to learn deeper meaning of Words of God, like mentioned in surah 73:5, although i don't speak arabic at all.
Keep Up Sir. I badly need to learn more 🙏🙏🙏.
Once more, as suggestion, in order to spread much more quickly, please subtitle your video to Bahasa Indonesia where more than 200 Millions " called muslim "live , but have a very little knowledge about the magical and magnificant deep meaning of Quran Words.
They prefer funny and entertaining Da'i 🙃, while Allah created universe not for funny things. 😣
We are short on resources to translate into other languages...
If you or others can help, we welcome that.
Regards
@@MarvelousQuran , Insha Allah Sir 🙏🙏🙏. I will try the best
I'm not sure they're ready to see these kind of stuff, brother. I mean, i couldn't stand when Dr Hany thrown by words like 'bid'ah' and 'kafir'. Just kidding :D Great idea.. But would need a lot of effort, I believe.
@@yasfi5196 , yes sure Brother. But as we are grown up, getting older , we have to avoid conflicts wisely. We as muslims have to share the truth, nothing more nothing less, the rest is only on Allah will.
I can imagine public's anger whenever mentioned about women in menstruated period should avoid anything about God trully only following corrupted bible's traditions :(
While Quran never ever mean distancing women to the their God :(.
Salam Brother 🙏.
Shukern Dr. Hani. May you be rewarded for your tireless efforts. I am still trying to understand your innovative approach.
Allow me to comment on the topic of this lecture.
I agree with you that it is totally wrong to comprehend/perceive the aya (as many do) as if the Quran actually states that the sun sets in a muddy spring/pool.
1) First an absolutely universal fact: the Sun is a heavenly body OUTSIDE the earth. It cannot rise from, or sets on planet Earth. The Quran is in absolute agreement with that. It states that the Sun en Moon cannot transgress their prescribed orbits.
2) All that the Quran states, is that the Sun ‘appeared to him to be setting in a spring of murky water’ (Seyyed Nasr’s comment in your lecture). In this statement, the Quran refers to a view of a person. It is NOT the Quran’s description of the actual conduct of the Sun.
3) Empirically, anyone enjoying sunsets and sunrises near the sea, have seen the “appearance” of the Sun ‘really’ rising, and setting on the sea. In short, the sun setting in a muddy spring, is a description of the VIEW THE PERSON (the perceiver) ‘appear’ to see, it is NOT description of an act of the Sun. The Sun is ‘VIEWED’/‘perceived’ as setting in a muddy pool/spring. The undertone is, that “views,” “appearances” (and sloppy readings), can be deceiving. Such views/appearances can be illusions of the eye/mind. This a somewhat similar with what Hindus can maya, and philosophers call a phenomenal ‘appearance.’ The ‘sun setting in a muddy spring,’ in the aya is a depiction of a “maya,” an illusion of the eye/mind: Not the a law of nature, Not the conduct of the Sun. That it is not the Sun that rises, and sets, in this case, hints subtly to a mere human view in a pre-Galilean age.
We provided a detailed reply to this issue in the segment that followed this segment. Please watch the whole series.
when you said "not sure where he got sea or black" around 3:55. They literally mean The Black Sea. The geographical Black Sea on the map today. As few people have identified D Q's traveled region mentioned in the Quran between the Caspian Sea and the Black Sea. That should clarify
What we meant was: "Not sure, based on the language of the Quran, how he decided that the translation is black sea"
@@MarvelousQuran Not based on the language of the Quran. You know how you mentioned "murky water, dark body of water etc..." Some have derived that body of water to be literally the Black Sea. As in that is where DQ was when the sun set. From his POV, the sun did set into that body of water. Side note, the Black Sea is called the "black sea" for its appearance. This isn't my look on it, I was just giving an explanation on why you may have heard black sea from people.
I understood what you meant, and I know it was not your opinion... But we need Quranic evidence, not external knowledge. This is what we use in the methodology: Quranic confirmation
@@MarvelousQuran Agreed, I find your interpretations interesting to make note of. I'm going through your videos and seeing what else I can learn. Keep doing what you do
black is refer to people
Sorry for some of the typos!
ALL TRANSLATORS ARE WRONG EXCEPT YOU IS THAT OKAY? BUT WHY REFERENCE OF ZULQURNAIN REQUIRED HERE? WAS HE A NABI, A MUSLIM FELLOW?
Watch the whole series before you judge.
Your first question we have answered in so many other segments
16:00 in my language (malay) the word `hama` [spelled like the way you said it in arabic] means `pests`, an invasive organism that destroys crops and contaminates the ecosystem [weltanschauung] with harmful pathogens. they are bothersome , pesky and a terror for farmers.
19:00 `hostile stalkers` kinda make sense, but i don't get why these people are described as water silt / sludge. `pests` is better imo.
Alhamdullilah
Although it is very heavy for me but some light has open. Possibility of Quran interpretation has been tainted by munafiqun. I has to pause and find your 1st video . It seem that your interpretation satisfy my hunger.
Sound like Mohammed PBUH
Mecca and Medina
If this is about group of people explain word endaha
At that location
Al7amdoelillahh Al7amdoelillahh!