YT57 Surah Al-Kahf (Surah 18): Who was Zul Qarnayn? What is Wahy? Purposes of Quranic stories
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 07. 2024
- We continue with the interpretation and translation of the story of Zul Qarnayn from Surah Al-Kahf (Surah 18).
We reveal who was Zul Qarnayn
We also provide detailed evidence for our determination
We also provide a clear definition of Wahy وحي
We also provide a novel way to determine if some parts of the Seera of Prophet Muhammad is correct or not
This is Part 5 in the series aboyt Zul Qarnayn
Some of the video segments that were referenced in this segment are:
Does the sun set in a muddy pool? • YT56 Surah Al-Kahf(Sur...
How Zul Qarnayn became powerful? • YT53 Surah Al-Kahf (Su...
Does God stit on a throne? • YT54 Surah Al-Kahf(Sur...
How to determine if you can trust Quran translation • YT55 How to Know if yo...
Timestamps:
0:00 Intro
1:16 By the End of This Segment, You Will Learn:
2:35 Important Points to Consider Before Proceeding
3:30 Āya 18:83 - What is Qarn قَرْن?
5:56 Āya 18:84-86 - A Summary of Prior Segments
12:21 Responding to a Few Questions
16:32 Key Discoveries so Far
21:48 Who Was Zul Qarnayn?
25:15 Gift #1: Did Allahh share future Ghayb with Prophet Muḥammad (PBUH)?
34:56 Confirmation from History
41:13 Recognizing a Few Comments
43:42 Gift #2: Hiding Info in Plain Sight
52:55 Gift #3: A New Way to Validate what was Reported in the Seerah of Prophet Muḥammad (PBUH)
56:33 Gift #4: What is “Waḥy” وَحي?
1:04:41 What We Learned?
1:05:40 Closing Remarks and DuƐā'
To learn more, Please follow us on
Facebook Marvelous Quran
Website www.marvelousquran.org
You may contact us at
Gmail MarvelousQuran@gmail.com
Please Share, Subscribe, and Like
Quran Translation and Commentary by Dr. Hany Atchan
Assalamu alaikum wrwb, as much as I enjoy your insightful videos, this one is quite heavy indeed. I do regard without shadow of a doubt that Qur'an contains absolute truth and that your methodology is very logical. But a single person is easily manipulated by the shayateen, especially nowadays. There is fitnah everywhere. But I am sure you realise that alot more than I do. You need to present your findings to the open minded ulamah (might be a little challenging) or someone like Nauman Ali Khan who is very well grounded in Arabic I believe. Have a group meeting for the sake of Allah and the ummah. We really need unity! Until then I'll be sceptical. The way I see it is you either are a blessing or another dajal. Please forgive me, but I hope you understand where am coming from. If you really are doing this for the sake of Allah, then may Allah make this immense task easy for you and raise your status in this world and the next! Amin!!!
@Alisher Adilov
Salaamun Alaykum brothers (or sisters)
You say "If you really are doing this for the sake of Allah, then may Allah make this immense task easy for you and raise your status in this world and the next! Amin!"
Yes! Aameen. Plz keep making this Duaa
My brothers (or sisters) :
With every claim I make, I offer detailed evidence from the Quran... Do I not?
Every other sentence that comes out of my mouth, I tell you "Read the Quran with an open heart and mind"... Do I not?
In every presentation I make, I ask you to reflect and ask Allahh for direct guidance from him, alone... Do I not?
I point out the errors in what some human beings have claimed (regardless of their intentions), based on their unacceptable sources, and that have caused terrible disservice to the Quran and to the reputation of our beloved (SAWS)... Do I not?
In every presentation I make, I show you how to have confidence and absolute trust in the veracity of the Quran, and the truthfulness of our beloved messenger (SAWS)... Do I not?
Never once did I ask you to believe in me or be my blind followers... Did I ever?
What else is needed to have you open your eyes and ears and hearts to the truth from Allahh alone, for your own sake?
Do you think that our Ummahh (community) is not capable of making the same mistakes that prior Ummahs have made? Why? Do we want to claim that "we" (look around you! There are no "We") are God's favored people, just because of the label we take for ourselves, like some others have claimed?
Didn't our beloved (SAWS) warn us that we are liable to make the same mistakes? Didn't the Quran warn us the same?
Did Allahh promise to preserve the infallibility of our Ummah, or did Allahh promise to preserve the infallibility of the Quran, for those who want to seek the truth?
I invite you to take Wuduu', and then watch these two videos in full (all the way to the end):
- Will God Expose His Leg? czcams.com/video/noBa4w76O58/video.html
- Does God Sit on a Throne? czcams.com/video/UoASnmEc4Hs/video.html
Then pray to Allah to show you the truth.
Then connect via email if you are serious regarding some of your suggestions.
Allaahu Khairun Haafizan Wa Huwa Arhamur-Raahimeen
Regards
With regards to exposing this knowledge to "scholars"... Here's our response:
Thank you brother... Rest assured: We have barely started! Many more New discoveries are coming!
So hold on to your seat, and enjoy As-Sarh with us!!!
Regarding the scholars: Please know that some are watching this channel... We know for sure. Some of them have encouraged us via e-mail, to keep going, while hiding behind screen names...
But what do you expect them to say: Yes! we agree with Dr. Hany's discipline of Abrahamic Locution... AND BY THE WAY: Yes! Everything we thought was correct (based on our man-made Ussool al-Tafseer - principles of interpretation) should be re-evaluated in light of the organic Quranic methodology that Dr. Hany uses?
Are you aware that, if you graduate from an Islamic college or have an Islamic Ijaza, you would risk losing your license or Ijaza if you deviate from what they taught you and what they think is correct?
How many "scholars" do you think would invest the time necessary to learn this new 3ilm, knowing that it could undermine their whole world: Their reputation, their positions, and their livelihood?
How many Muslim scholars do you know who have studied philosophy, mathematics, history, sociology, psychology, cognitive sciences, etc etc... And how many are considered "scholars" after just completing 4 or 6 years of undergraduate school, basically learning what's in the ancient man-written books?
How many Muslim scholars do you know could explain the details of what a methodology mean? or even the basics of scientific method? or the principle of relevance? etc.
Most people, my brother, are NOT early adopters. The vast majority only follow the crowds, unfortunately!
Nevertheless,,, I am hopeful that Allahh will open the hearts of a few sincere people in this Ummah to receive this new 3ilm, and to carry it forward a lot further than I could...
Please help if you feel you can. Keep the faith and enjoy As-Sarh my brother.
Regards
Dr. Hany, I think many of us are in similar position as @Alisher Adilov, I see this comment as an appeal. Please make some distinction between the tone of your videos and responding to this kind of lamenting voice.
Thanks
@@MarvelousQuran What is "As-Sarh" that you use as your refrain?
@ ashokaagni ashokaagni
Plz watch this video
Will God Expose His Leg? czcams.com/video/noBa4w76O58/video.html
May Allah guide us to understand the Qur'an clearly and make it the spring of our hearts and happiness of our lives. Ameen 🤲
Jazaqall khir I am eagerly listening with tearful eyes and trying to clean my arsh
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Alhamdulillah
Thank you very much for this tremendously insightful Lecture. Bad at Arabic, struggle to learn about the proper understanding of yhe Qur'an as carefully as possible. Your presentation of how to understand wahy is priceless. Jazzakallahul khair. May Allah guide us to understanding and protect us from all evil, ameen
Alhamdulillah alone
Salaamun alaykum. 51:33 minutes brought tears of joy in my eyes at how precise Allah's guidance is, subhanaAllah :') Tears of happiness were building up throughout the nuggets we were collecting in this series, and it just bursted into tears at that moment.
I truly understand what it means to taste the sweetness of iman, once you taste it you can't get over it anymore, period. I had/have a personal crush on Ali radiyallah anhu, how lucky he was that he was able to taste the sweetness of iman from his childhood :')
Lol Ali who's been dead for over a thousand years 😭? I'm not making fun of you I think it's cute 😄.
Had a teacher once say she was madly in love with the ghost of Elvis Presley.
This video is a total gem, it's necessary to know and understand some concepts in sura Yussuf. Alhamdullilah alone!
I'm in shock and smiling at the same time. Let me go do my finals first, then I'll come back to this playlist later :D
JazakAllah khair! I always start your videos with so much confusion and it grows until it all starts to make so much sense and I end the video with the thirst to have more. SubhanAllah
Glad to hear that. Keep watching. Regards
Thank you, Dr.
This video has greatly explained my previous puzzling question from the first video. Looking forward for the next video about Yakjuj and Makjuj.
You're most welcome!
Assalamualaikum. By your methodology, you have identified Zulqarnayn with Prophet Muhammad pbuh. Ayah 18:83 sets out the starting point of the narrative regarding Zulqarnayn in the Quran. This ayah tallies with the seerah in this regard; ie some unbelievers asking the Prophet regarding Zulqarnayn.
Within the context of this ayah 18:83, the question from the unbelievers gives that they either;
(1) knew details about Zulqarnayn (being a person other than the Prophet), and that they wanted to find out whether or how much the Prophet knows about that person (ie a test question, as per the seerah),
OR
(2) had heard something about Zulqarnayn and wanted to learn more about him from the Prophet (a true question).
Scenario (1) unquestionably refers to a person other than the Prophet. Even if the case was the latter scenario (2), it is reasonable to still think that it is not about the Prophet. This is because the unbelievers are contemporaneous with the Prophet in time and place and they must have known fully well about his (the Prophet’s) identity, message and actions, especially him being their “enemy” as it were. So, even if questioning in regard to a little known Zulqarnayn (scenario 2), that too must not have been about the Prophet, since they already knew him fully well.
It follows then, that the answer as provided by the revelations (ayaat 18:84-98), would make meaningful sense to the unbelievers only if they are describing matters relating to a person other than the Prophet. Otherwise, I believe the revelations would not be answering their question.
By your understanding, how then would you reconcile this ayah 18:83 with your indentifying Zulqarnayn with Prophet Muhammad pbuh?
What makes you so sure that the Quran is obligated to answer questions from Jews? Is the Quran a FAQ book? Is that how little you think of the words of Allahh?
@@MarvelousQuran السلام عليكم اخي الكريم, اذا كان ذو القرنين هو سيدنا محمد صلى لماذا لم يتم ذكر اسماء الصحابه الذين ساعدوه ببناء السد الذي بين الجبلين في السيره النبويه؟ ولماذا خصصت منطقه تبوك لتكون تلك المنطقه و الى الان لا احد يعلم اين مكان ياجوج وماجوج. غير ذلك لماذا تهجمت على الشخص الذي سالك سؤال منطقي وعقلاني؟ ادعائك ان ذو القرنين هوه سيدنا محمد خاطىء لان السؤال واضح وصريح (وَيَسْأَلُونَكَ عَن ذِي الْقَرْنَيْنِ ۖ قُلْ سَأَتْلُو عَلَيْكُم مِّنْهُ ذِكْرًا) لو كان المقصود بالسؤال عن سيدنا محمد لكان الامر بالاجابه ببساطه حدثهم عن نفسك دون الغاز. والرجاء لا تحقر من اي سؤال بادعائك اننا نستصغر اسم الله وكلمات الله.
سلامٌ عليكم
من أين أتيت بفكرة السدّ؟
الجواب: من التفاسير التي لا ننفك ننتقد آراءها غير المنضبطة في هذه القناة
لم نتهجم على أحد، ولكننا أجبنا على سؤال بسؤال. والسؤال هو: لماذا تعتقد أنه إذا جاء شخصٌ يسأل الرسول سؤالاً فإن القرءان مضطر للإجابة؟
الجواب أيضاً من أوهام التفاسير
كون القرءان أجاب عن بعض الأسئلة في المواضع الأخرى لا يعني أنه أجاب على السؤال في هذا الموقع.
القرءان لم ينزل لموافقة على ادعاءات اليهود ولم ينزل لتكريس أوهامهم او اوهام بعض العصبيات الأخرى
ونهاية: أرجو منك مناقشة الأدلة التي قدمناها في الفيديو، وهي قاطعة وقرءانية. أم أن القرءان لا يفسّر بعضه بعضاً؟؟؟
Allah Akbar! Already watched it 2 times and will be returning back again 😃
Baraka ALLAH alaika🙏
Thank you again. Baraka Allahhu Laka (not Alayka) ;) Regards my brother
'Alaika is approximately = upon you or to you....so how can we "send" back the Baraka to Him?
AsSalama'laikum dear brother! JazakhAllahKhair for sharing this with us. This is a TOTAL paradigm shift for me, mash'Allah!
Salaamun Alaykum... Wa Iyyakum. Not many people would appreciate the shift as you just did, Wonderful to hear!
Ma Shaa Allah. All so enlightening 💚
Alhamdulillah
Spell bound....MashaAllah
Excited to be in the part of Earthly Jannah.
Alhamdulillah
ALHAMDULILLAH.........thank you once again for the unveiling. Certainly a much richer explanation, beyond what otherwise would have been left as a "superficial historical" exposition........yet in it was the complete spiritual narration of the Mission.
Alhamdulillah alone
Salaams I can't thank you enough for your excellent explanation may the Almighty guide us all to the straight path.
Alhamdulillah alone
@@MarvelousQuran Critical thinking and understanding has always been 'For the few' Peace and Blessings
@Zubeda Moosa Here's to hoping for the best! Thank you
Allah Subhawata'la guides whomsoever He wills, but that definitely based on efforts and every individual's indepth understanding. We are witnessing a totally different interpretation if Glorious Quran, that open the doors to review the tafsir doing close research on each and every word
Allahu Akbar Quran is mother of all miracles. Masha Allah
Alhamdulillah
Alhamdullillah,wonderful knowledge sir.
Alhamdulillah
Masha ALLAH!!TabarakaLLAH!JazakaLLAH kheir!!!
Alhamdulillah
As a person who was led by Allah to discovered Islam only few years ago and tries to understand the Quran from English translations, while English is not my mother tongue, is indeed very underwhelming task. I have been secretly hoping for guidance and inspiration to turn to this marvelous Quran with real understanding. I feel like this work is the answer to my wish and cannot remember last when I was fully attentive for a full hour on any topic.
Alhamdulillah. Feel free to connect via email marvelousquran@gmail.com with any question
18.83 (وَيَسـَٔلونَكَ عَن ذِى القَرنَينِ قُل سَأَتلوا عَلَيكُم مِنهُ ذِكرًا) thanks a lot for your wonderfull
Assalaam alaykum, thank you very much for your detailed explanation on the complicated topic of Zul qarnain, I had so many questions but they are now fully answered.
You are most welcome
Great work thx
Alhamdulillah
Thank you so much
The fact that Prophet Muhammad ﷺ himself is mentioned in several part of the Torah and also became well known prophecy among the Jew's and Christian's circle at that time somehow supporting this interpretation. But I guess, I should wait for a final segment to decide, especially about who Yajuj Majuj are and what's the 'Wall' about. Jazakallah, anyway
Could you please give the references and those verses in the Torah or anywhere in the Bible where Mohammad is mentioned. As far we know that Prophet Mohammad himself didn’t know that he was a prophet until the age of 40. And that news was given to Mohammad by Warqa bin Nofal a Jewish guy brother of Hazrat Khadijah 🤔
Brother it seems like you're giving your own interpretation to the holy book quran, i don't have much knowledge of quran but what you're doing is trying hard to change the meaning of the scriptures,ur not teaching or educating ummah but instead your coming with confusions,prophet was asked to tell about the person of the past, how could it turn again to be himself.
@ Hamso Uledi
Plz watch the whole series on Zul Qarnayn, and watch the video segments in full... It's obvious that you did not!
Dr Hany. I'm interested to get the answer to the same question. Pls tell me in which video of yours the answer to that question is hinted/answered.
@ NOOR AZAHAN OTHMAN
What makes you so sure that the Quran is obligated to answer questions from Jews? Is the Quran a FAQ book? Is that how little you think of the words of Allahh?
They asked, yes! But it does NOT mean that the Quran dignified their conceit or their ill-motivated question.
Seriously mate, with your knowledge of Arabic and a good methodology I expected much better than that. I am sure it really is an honest effort and you have best intentions at heart I just pray that you keep at it. It really is a riddle. And if I have ever learned one thing is when it comes to Quran and the ways of Allah the best way to get the answer is to keep asking the question and keep a very very very open mind because one day Allah will give you the answer but only if your mind is COMPLETELY open.
Having said that still respect to you for trying to find a better explanation that our current mulla party and call him Cyrus or God know what.
May Allah guide us all.
What is your exact objection?
@@MarvelousQuran let’s just say that time is a constraint only for us mortals NOT for Allah, if a mortal like Dajjal can change times then it’s not hard for Allah to change something that’s is His own creation. When we get stuck with past present and future as we understated it we miss the beauty of Allah’s amazing plan. Till now it was understandable for people not to be able to rightly identify DQ as they were bound to the understanding of time as a constant hence the laughable comparison with Cyrus who was an open Mushrik, but a lot of Quranic Ayats can only be understood in the end times when understanding of time and space has evolved.
The reason Jews of the time had put these 3 questions to the prophet as a test out of which one question was about the Great traveler was because they have always consumed with the end times exactly as they are now. It’s the key to understanding why were they sooooooo interested to know firstly who ZQ was and secondly why would only a true prophet of Allah can only know the answer. If the answer was in the past a good historian can also give the answer but only a true prophet can give the answer if it’s truly from Ghaib. I am no scholar and my knowledge is not even 1% of many people like yourself and many others who have dedicated your life to unlocking the riddles of Quran but all I can tell you is if you use that same knowledge of Arabic and the methodology that you have with a much more open mind the results would be very very different.
You are very right as to the bloodline of ZQ with your understanding but you are missing a lot more. I am sure a person with your abilities will get there if you keep asking Allah to guide you even more.
JazakAllah Khair brother
I emptied my cup for the next upload, regarding Gog and Magog.
Meantime I need to listen repeatedly to get the sticky essence.
Love it
I had 2 candidate prior to this video. 1. Muhammad(sal) 2. Isa (sal). I choose to believe Isa(sal) because of Ya'juj Ma'juj . Anxiously waiting for the next video.
Alhamdulillah 💡
As- Salamulikum brother Hany Atchan,
It was my great pleasure to listen to your lecture on the Abrahamic locution and meaning of the Quranic ayat. Alhamdulillah. I am not an Arab and I also don’t know Arabic other than reciting the Quran in the Quranic or Arabic language and looking for English or Bengali translations to understand. However, I was aware that there is a huge difference between modern Arabic and classical Arabic during the period of the 5th century.
As your lectures are eye-opening and exciting to me, I felt compelled to share some of my understanding with you.
1. Allah swt uses Quran to manifest the reality of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). So we will find the meaning or implementation of the Quran through the life of Prophet Muhammad pbuh. You have explained that nicely. That is why the essence of the story of Zul Qarnayn existed in our beloved Prophet's life. The essence of the story of Zul Qarnayn that existed in the Prophet's life does not mean it has no representation of a past story or character. My understanding is that Allah swt used His attributes (names) from the past stories and attributed to him (our beloved prophet) or manifested within Prophet Muhammad pbuh, and He used past incidents and created the reality of the Prophet's life. So, I think Zul Qarnayn is a historical character, but that the attributes of the character and the essence of the story are also manifested in Prophet Mumahhad's (pbuh) life.
2. My understanding of the Quran is that all Ayats in the Quran have two types of meaning - 1) Inner or invisible or spiritual or 2 dimensional or zikr and 2) Outer or visible or physical or 3 dimensional or fikr. Only Allah swt knows the actual inner meaning of the Ayats, we can assume but we may not know the exact inner meaning, but the outer or physical meaning is interpretable. A knowledgeable person whom Allah swt has guided can translate and interpret both the inner and outer meaning. Since the outer reality of the world evolves and changes, therefore the outer meaning or interpretation of Ayat can be evolved and changes in order to make sense of our 3-dimensional reality. But the inner meaning will never change. What I underwood that you are exploring and explaining the inner meaning of the quranic ayats and comparing it with the people who have used the outer meaning of the Quran. I do not think it is an appropriate way to compare with other scholars' understanding or interpretation of ayats. I also do not think it is an apple to apple comparison. However, you are right that most Islamic scholars do not read the Quran to understand, they learn from others, and they look for the meaning or interpretation in the Quran to explain what they already know.
Jazāk Allāhu Khayran,
Thanks
Tariq
@Tariq Alam
Salaamun Alaykum Brother. Thank you for your kind words. May Allahh keep us guided...
The Quran used a descriptive label, Zul Qarnayn, to refer to the primary character of this story in Surah Al-Kahf.
We demonstrated that this man, in this story, is none other than our beloved (SAWS).
Beyond that, the Quran did not make any reference to historical details that are relevant to us... In other words, what Allahh told us about this story is what matters, and what Allahh did not, is irrelevant to our understanding of the Quran.
If some preachers, contemporary or past, want to please their ethnic or nationalistic or regional followers by making certain historic claims based on this story... Well, they are not justified, nor should they be allowed to get away with it!
As to the layers of meanings of the Ayats... There are 8 layers, not just two, and we will discuss this in a future segment insha Allahh. And you are correct in stating that it would not be fair to compare one layer to others, claiming that one is superior or more valid...
But this is not what we do. We object to the insistence of the majority of so-called scholars of today and the past, that the correct interpretation is exclusively based on the books of Tafseer that were initially penned during the third Hijri... That theirs is the only valid interpretation. This is why we focus so much on the errors in these books of Tafseer, and we demonstrate that there are other interpretations that are, to say the least, more plausible or more justified from within the Quran.
Thank you so much for taking the time. In the future, feel free to share such detailed discourses with us using the email marvelousquran@gmail.com
Regards
@@MarvelousQuran Thank you for taking the time to read and answer me. Inshallah, we will have more discussion. May Allah SWT guide us.
I'm shaken to the core, indeed that human brain is actually the most powerfull information processing device given by Allah.
It reminds me of my past, where my aunt annoy me and keep restricting me from things that im interesting, she said "those things will make you dumb!"
The one that loves you the most, is the one that annoy you the most. It is, indeed, is true. 😭
Very clear and candid explanation with rich language. 👍
Alhamdulillah
@@MarvelousQuran our Quran is one but still Muslim umnah is divided so badly and became weak and being heavily insulted, persecuted and exploited. I perceive the reason for all this is that our ummah gone hay way only when our religious people joined political forums rather than than holding the spiritual path. Because spiritual persons know the truth and truth never divides instead it unites. Tge other reasonnof division is interest of so called muslims who have more interest in power and self than the faith in Quran and our last Prophet and they turned munafiqs.
Nice Started
What a triumph, this interpretation!
Thank you for sharing. We are eager to learn the entire Quran part by part.
Insha Allahh. Plz make duaa for this effort to succeed. Regards
@@MarvelousQuran InsyaAllah. We pray for the best.
This is indeed very deep, MashaAllah this is so unique that a proper scholar is thoroughly analysing the Quran, as is its right, hope more scholars can join you in completing this noble task, May Allah protect you and opens up more doors for you, Ameen
Aameen
Shukran Jazeelan..
jazaakumullah khairan
Ma-Shah-Allah. I got my all answers form your content. When I ask you some thing. I got feedback quickly.
Welcome
Can you summarise this please. I did not understand anything
SUBHAAN'ALLAH
ALHAMDULILLAH
ALLAHU AKBAR....
Alhamdulillah
InsyaAllah. We will meet him in Jannah.
Insha Allahh
Thank you
May Allah guide you
Thank you brother. We all need this Duaa
Thank you Dr
Welcome
Dr Hany what do you think 27:82 refers to, dabbatul ard? Since samawat doesn't mean only heavens in the locution? Dabba and forms is usually translated as living/moving creatures.
Is there any way in the Abrahamic locution to extract information about the letters such as "alif lam mim" as to why these letters have been included in some surahs and what exactly they mean?
This knowledge has not been made accessible. Allahh know more
@@MarvelousQuran I think you will like Sam Gerrans' breakdown and evidence, especially being a computing/logic person as you are - even if you don't agree with anything else he says.
Mashallah thank you Doctor Hany looking forward to next video.
Insha Allahh
I'm in the process of rewatching your videos in order, as I initially discovered your work out of order, which naturally made it much more difficult to follow. I continue to find a rich body of disocvery and insight, which I greatly appreicate. That being said, I'm still not clear as to how precisely you derived "had others follow" from "fa-atba'a", in the third person singular. Are the singular and plural of this verb the same in Arabic?
It's basic verb morphology.
Why can't Allah just say, Dhulqarnaun is Our beloved prophet Muhammad (SAW)?
The answer is inside the video. Please watch the whole video all the way until the end
@@MarvelousQuran I've watched it and not satisfied with the answer
Im so confused, prophet Muhammad saw built the dam of yajooj and majooj?
There is no dam. Where do you get the concept of the dam? It is not mentioned at all.
ا سلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
First of all I would like to thank you for opening the channel. Secondly, I heard and saw that traditional Islamic scholars tell us to stay away from secular sciences. My question is did Allah tell us anything about staying away from learning from other sources ? I was a born Muslim. But I think secular sciences is the one that drew me nearer to Qur'an. Alhamdulillah. I am learning about Islam now Alhamdulillah. And I strongly feel that the false messiah can easily manipulate and drive people away from Islam if Muslims of this world don't have enough knowledge about science and technology of today's world. This is what I felt. And I felt that memorizing Qur'an should be made mandatory for every Muslims. Simply because it contains the answers to every question that man has ever asked and a source of guidance and mercy from Allah Subhanallah. May Allah protect scholars like you from every direction and make it easy for you to make known what you have learned by the mercy of Allah Subhanallah. Ameen
Salaamun Alaykum
Thank you. May Allahh increase you in sincerity and bring you closer to him alone
Sir, have you written books on these topics? If yes where I can I ibrahim them?
Coming soon Insha Allahh
Assalamu alaikkum,
What is the two lineage ?
Is it the lineage of Ismael (as) and Ishaq (as) ?
Or something else ?
Prophet Muhammad’s father is a Qureshi from Mecca and his mom and uncles are from Madina
Alhamdulillah great work once again brother, the fountain head of stalkers are spies and you'll find many of those in mainland europe putrid water and hostile stalkers, reminds me of the UK. Only Allah knows best. Thank you.
Alhamdulillah
Subhan ALLAH
Alhamdulillah
A,alykum. Sorry for we students of knowledge. is there possibly that we can get the PDF you presented ?
In the future insha Allahh
Timestamps:
0:00 Intro
1:16 By the End of This Segment, You Will Learn:
2:35 Important Points to Consider Before Proceeding
3:30 Āya 18:83 - What is Qarn قَرْن?
5:56 Āya 18:84-86 - A Summary of Prior Segments
12:21 Responding to a Few Questions
16:32 Key Discoveries so Far
21:48 Who Was Zul Qarnayn?
25:15 Gift #1: Did Allahh share future Ghayb with Prophet Muḥammad (PBUH)?
34:56 Confirmation from History
41:13 Recognizing a Few Comments
43:42 Gift #2: Hiding Info in Plain Sight
52:55 Gift #3: A New Way to Validate what was Reported in the Seerah of Prophet Muḥammad (PBUH)
56:33 Gift #4: What is “Waḥy” وَحي?
1:04:41 What We Learned?
1:05:40 Closing Remarks and DuƐā'
Salamun very interesting, however I must say in surah 23:97,98 allah tells us the words for seeking refuge,
It is so complicated for me to understand this topic. Is it necessity to interpret using whatever locution when the aayah is clear and straghtforward?. With all due respect, Sir, I cannot agree with this kind of your interpretation about the story of Zul Qarnain.
Even me I didn't saw anybody interpreting like this before
Alhamdulillah the video is fully great research output I very greatful to you for such beautiful interpretation. Sir I am from Kolkata, India , we are very little knowledge about Arabic most of the people don't have sufficient knowledge of Arabic and English so if you kindly arrange to narrated version in Urdu, Hindi,an Bengali then millions and millions Muslim will benifited and I very much sure that in a very short period of time subscriber of this channel will be I millions. Thanks once again for such beautiful interpretation. May Allah bless you and give you more knowledge
HELP!!!
As Salam Dr Hany Atchan. The early part of your slides the ayat you quoted at 18:82 , should actually be 18:83.
However For 17:17, I cant find any reference to the meaning of familial lineage or Descendants
They are included in the video
The question was asked by Jews delegates to our prophet, that means Zul qurnain came before our prophet.
Or so they thought... Or,as we explained in the video, the Quran did NOT answer their question, but provided different info to Prophet (SAWS)
Please watch the following video for more info
Dear Sir
You are trying to adapt a story of DzulQarnain into the real life of prophet Muhammad PBUH. What if you are wrong about it, do you think this would mislead words of Allah.
Plz watch the complete series. You are missing some points that we made
If I am not wrong.The juws ask about a traveler to muhammad sallallahu alaihi waya sallam. and he answered them. Why ?
السَّلاَمُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ
Can you do more videos explaining for the sake of Allaah. about the Law of Allaah. Where Allaah said 'Inil Hukmu illa Lillaah' can you explain this one in details?
May Allaah guide us Ameen.
Barakallaah!
Dear doctor hany please correct the part at 50:39 where ayet number is 83 not 82. I lost my concentration as I was trying to follow the logic here, because I do not purely listen but verify correctness as well, while I watch your videos.
Can I get what translation version is the quran? I see the translation of ayat 86 is quite different with standard English translation
until he reached the setting ˹point˺ of the sun, which appeared to him to be setting in a spring of murky water, where he found some people. We said, “O Ⱬul-Qarnain! Either punish them or treat them kindly.”
Plz watch the whole series on zul qarnayn... The complete playlist
I thought that the shelter Allah is talking about , were like our skies protecting us against the sun ..
And... ?? What do you think now?
@@MarvelousQuran I think that I need to read whole sura again 😁 . I am not being really consistent in reading the Qur'an , that is why I forget a lot . But this Sura gives me a strong impression that maybe all this occurred in another galaxy . Maybe , because of the translations . It's nice what you do , makes us think more deeper about The Qur'an . I wil stay tuned . Peace be up on you .
How did بلغ مغرب الشمس translate to 'complete his mission' ? It translates to 'the time (or place) of the setting of the sun'. What Quranic translation are you reading from ?
how to verify this abrahimi locution...
Just like you verify that gravity is true.... By observing...
Keep watching... With more and more examples, you too will develop the same certainty as you have about gravity... Insha Allahh
In future segments, we will provide direct evidence from the Quran insha Allahh
Dr Hany, I liked your logical methodology and a lot of what you presented makes sense and adds up (thanks for the evidence ) but I have some essential questions:
1) who is asking the question (Who is they )? Assuming it is the Sahaba (R.Am), 2) did they not know who ZulQarneyn was? 3)Where did the name come from in the first place? Per your methodology are we interpreting (يسئلونك) wrong? 4)How can they not know the beloved?
5) If they knew, why did you say some of them did not know in Hudaybiyyah?
Answers:
1) Who is asking the question (Who is they )?
Allahh did not name them, which is a strong hint to us that they don't matter. It's also a hint that their knowledge or their assumptions are irrelevant.
2) Assuming it is the Sahaba (R.Am), did they not know who ZulQarneyn was?
Why do you assume that they were Sahabas? It could have been people from other tribes or people who follow versions of prior scriptures, but assumed that their legends and myths were true. In other words, who cares who they were?
3)Where did the name come from in the first place? The term Qarn is clearly defined in the Quran. Qarnayn is "two".
Per your methodology are we interpreting (يسئلونك) wrong? "They ask you", in the present tense, just as you are asking now! Think about this!
4) How can they not know the beloved? Who? The closest Sahabas knew that the one reciting the story is himself Zul Qarnayn. It's so obvious, linguistically, as we demonstrated in the end of the video.
5) If they knew, why did you say some of them did not know in Hudaybiyyah? Not all Sahabas were close enough to the prophet SAWS, and thus some of them objected, but others yielded unquestionably to the prophet's decision.
Regards
Please forgive me for my ignorance. But, why is the name Zul Quarnayn used & not actual name. ? .
Salaam Dr.
My question is, how "the two specific lineages" is apply to Muhammad saw?
Thank you.
Excellent question my brother. I was wondering why no one noticed to ask about this..
Review Aya 12:6... Who do you think it is addressing? What 2 lineages is it referring to?
Answer via e-amil plz
Regards
@@MarvelousQuran 12:6 ibrahim n ishaq is one lineage, and this is a story of yusuf
@@MarvelousQuran You said the ones with commonality was the maternal lineage so... 🤔
I am somehow relieved to hear that Dzul Qarnain is in fact our beloved prophet...I been pondering who this person really is coz the tafseer that I have read on this ayat doesn't seem to jive with the tafseer on the rest of the Quran.
Assalamualaikum Dr Hany
Related to 18:83, I believed in the bible, there is a story mention about Zul Qarnain and also the last prophet will be sending down. My question, does the story in the Injil about Zul Qarnain already happened or NOT???
If the story about Zul Qarnain mention in the Injil is NOT happen yet, any reference or evidence that we could rely?
The bible is a corrupted source that must never be used as a reference for us in understanding the words of Allahh. PERIOD!
Please watch some of the earlier videos on this channel to clarify
Well, very hard to accept this presentation. I think such interpretation must be discussed with scholars first and then be published for the public. With due respect, i am no more going to listen you.
Fair enough! Plz watch a few more videos and learn, so that you decide if you want to follow or to have a direct connect with Allahh
@ Khawaja Asif Naeem, this man has spoken rubbish. He says Dhul Qarnain is the Prophet Muhammad[saw?]
Salamun Alaikum. Keep up the Good Works that you are doing. May the Good Lord keep you safe and healthy and give you strength to finish your translation of the Quran. Thank you very much.
Thank you
after viewing your videos, these stories were included in earlier revelations/scriptures but were changed by those who created religions. And when the Quran was sent down, those with religions made enquiries about the message they corrupted like the message of Ibrahim, Musa, Yusuf, Isa, etc these messages were sent down again in the Quran to correct the corruption done. And of course, the correction will nullify their created discord through religions, and from the Quran itself we can see the people during the prophet's lifetime were pretending to follow or have abandoned him, and it is no surprise that right after the prophet's death, political discord took precedent. Love your work, thank you and Alhamdulillah.
Salamun Alaikum......I am Speechless...Marvellous indeed, your Explanation too is understandable ....After watching this Video I read the passage of Sura Kahaf, about Zul-Qarnain and it felt like we used to wrongly Interpret entire incidence before. As what you rightly said.. the translators has understood wrong and we follow them.
While reading I also read by your Terminology Some words defined by you, (The Abrahamic Locutions ) is the story of People of the Cave is too related to life of Our beloved Prophet Muhammed(SAW) Like Zul-Qarnain ? as the close companion or Ahle Bait of our prophet stayed in their mission for 309 years..... Hope we will be Getting that video soon. i may be wrong.
Allahh Help you Dr.
Thank you. And You are welcome...
But your definition of Ahlel-Bayt may be not necessarily Quranic. We will deal with issue later... For now, this would be too controversial, and we are building bit by bit insha Allahh
I would love to see you debate with an Islamic Scholar Christian Scholar on CZcams on this Topic or any other topic of your choice 🤔
Why?
So, when they came to ask our Prophet, peace be upon him, who zul qarnayn was, what was the context of their question? Also i dont want to jump the gun but when Nabi sallahualaihiwasallam once got up f from his bed to say that yajuj majuj hace made a hole in the wall of zul qarnayn, what does that mean?
The Quran was not revealed as a FAQ. Who cares why they asked and who they were. Allahh teaches us WHAT HE WANTS, WHEN HE CHOOSES
In this case, he was providing Prophet Muhammad (SAWS) and us a revelation that helps us in our mission
Regarding the Hadeeth, we should not worry so much about that one, because most Hadeeth were transmitted with meaning that transmitter understood, not necessarily with exact wording
@@MarvelousQuran thank you Dr Hany. I do think its fascinating the way you analyse by unravelling and unpacking (hur) and reveal the proper meanings of words. But please tolerate some of us if we take a little more convincing indeed if it is to do with our wultanstein. The W however has been challenged by others such as sheikh Imran Hosein, who has made an impression with his analysis re zul qarnayn and yajuj majuj but which is quite different than your analysis yet equally compelling.
@@yusufk5298 Good connection and I think we'll find they intersect/overlap.
MA sha Allah
Amazing 🥰
Can u share this PDF file
please ?
Contact us via email at marvelousquran@gmail.com
As Salaam U alaikum Dr Hany. Sir everything i know is being put into question. i always thought Zul Qarnain was someone who impacted on 2 ages, given as an example for us to be able to decipher the end times. Never thought he was a messenger, nor a nabii, nor Prophet Issa AS and least of all our beloved Prophet Muhammad PBUH. Dr Hany why don't you share your information with other scholars of Islam to see what they think, because according to me you are providing good evidence to prove your point. I need to re watch this and to re-watch all your prior videos.
@ Tabrez Gangee I know that NOT everything is being put into question... You are exaggerating, right?
@@MarvelousQuran No Dr Hany, not at all. The dream of Yusuf AS, Musa AS greatest miracle, Virgin in Paradise, The Account Sheeba, Abel and Cain and now Zul Qarnain. All these are not as understand them to be. Sir you really need to share your knowledge with different scholars of Islam.
@ Tabrez Gangee
Thank you brother... Rest assured: We have barely started! Many more New discoveries are coming!
So hold on to your seat, and enjoy As-Sarh with us!!!
Regarding the scholars: Please know that some are watching this channel... We know for sure. Some of them have encouraged us via e-mail, to keep going, while hiding behind screen names...
But what do you expect them to say: Yes! we agree with Dr. Hany's discipline of Abrahamic Locution... AND BY THE WAY: Yes! Everything we thought was correct (based on our man-made Ussool al-Tafseer - principles of interpretation) should be re-evaluated in light of the organic Quranic methodology that Dr. Hany uses?
Are you aware that, if you graduate from an Islamic college or have an Islamic Ijaza, you would risk losing your license or Ijaza if you deviate from what they taught you and what they think is correct?
How many "scholars" do you think would invest the time necessary to learn this new 3ilm, knowing that it could undermine their whole world: Their reputation, their positions, and their livelihood?
How many Muslim scholars do you know who have studied philosophy, mathematics, history, sociology, psychology, cognitive sciences, etc etc... And how many are considered "scholars" after just completing 4 or 6 years of undergraduate school, basically learning what's in the ancient man-written books?
How many Muslim scholars do you know could explain the details of what a methodology mean? or even the basics of scientific method? or the principle of relevance? etc.
Most people, my brother, are NOT early adopters. The vast majority only follow the crowds, unfortunately!
Nevertheless,,, I am hopeful that Allahh will open the hearts of a few sincere people in this Ummah to receive this new 3ilm, and to carry it forward a lot further than I could...
Please help if you feel you can. Keep the faith and enjoy As-Sarh my brother.
Regards
Salam dr Hany you mentioned here “Asshams” means the messenger . Does this apply to ayat 17 in surah kahfi too. ….Wa Tara ssham sa Iza thalaat…
Assalamualaikum sir,
Alhamdulillah and kudos to you for doing a superb job.
My question:
The people that came to prophet Muhammad (SAW) and asked the questions about people of the cave and the other quesrions as well, they must have prior knowledge or must have heard or read about it somewhere beforehand regarding the matter, else they wouldn't have able to ask them.
So, when they asked about ZQ, did they knew about this ZQ figure beforehand?
From my understanding from your session, am i right to assume that they (the people who asked the questions), has been foretold about ZQ in their scripture or by the respective massenger send to them before prophet Muhammad (SAW).
Thanking you in advance.
Assalamualaikum
Salaamun Alaykum
You say "they must have prior knowledge or must have heard or read about it somewhere beforehand regarding the matter, else they wouldn't have able to ask them."
Even if that was true, it does NOT mean that the Quran would be revealed for satisfying such people.
The Quran is for all time and places. It is not an FAQ manual. What matters is what the Quran itself said, not what the questioners knew or though or needed to know.
Sorry. Is the name Zul Quarnayn used a descriptive reference to explain the genealogy ?
yes
Jazaallah.
AoA, great in depth work by you, really appreciate it, although i disagree with your understanding but still it provides a good alternative to existing interpretation. The word "Sababa" used in Quran means a vertical journey, in my opinion Zulqairnain was a prophet of God who took journey to other planet through portals.
It's ok to have opinions. But we need evidence from the Quran. And then we need to verify that there are not other explanations that provide a better fit for the rest of the Quran.
@@MarvelousQuran Thank You for the reply, my opinion is formed based on the following reference from Quran.
In Quran 40:36 and 40:37 the word sabab is used in the context of vertical path, where Pharaoh is asking his minister to build such a pathway or portal for him so he go the see Moses’s God.
We addressed the concept of "Asbab" that was used by Fir3aoun as a mockery of the concept of raising our arms in supplication. It is not a real path vertically! Come on man! Work with me here!
Again! Any direct evidence from the Quran?
@@MarvelousQuran
Well, there is any verse 22:15 in which “Sabab” is used as a way to the heaven. Which cleary tells us that to heavens there are ways “Asbab” plural of “sabab”.
I am a minuscule student of Quran I don’t have scholarly knowledge. I really appreciate your effort to explain the Quran as you have understood.
In my opinion if one is convinced that they were wrong, one should change the established opinion, i have done it many times.
@@MrZubi02 Have you found anything do tell me i need to know and most importantly what is your opinion about who muhammad is.
Can you comment more on the verse 83 and 93 of Suarh Khaf and the hadith relating to when Mohammed (pbuh) woke up startled because of a hole that has opened up in the wall of Gog and Magog please?..
We said what we wanted to say about these 2 ayats.
Regarding the Hadeeth, this is not the channel to explain hadeeths. Our focus is on the Quran. This is what Allahh expects of us.
Indeed im curious to knw what hv u gather infos abt Yajuj Al-majuj
I am patiently waiting for the video on Isa (AS). Very excited
This man is a perfect example of " Why we should never take our religion from an Arab or follow any religion they have constructed'.
Is this what Farid taught you to say?
Do you have a book or a blogs? Because you just offer this in a video without a document that we can refer to!
Salaamun 3alaykum,
Whats the possibility that DQ could be EIM considering the whole lineage secret being a whole deal in the EIM series? Somehow the label Dhul Qarnayn seems relevant to him, right? 18:82 could be Muhammad asking FQ, right?
Additionally in 18:86 he’s told he can choose to ‘punish’ or ‘use insight’ and EIM used their “insider speech” as a sign.
If not, then who is Muhammad’s (SAWS) second qareen? Is that not also a possible way to understand the name DQ?
I appreciate your patience with me, these are just queries in my head.
Wallaahu Ta Alam
Salamun
Thank you.
Very GOOD
However
In surah 16:98 we are told what to do, amr
And in surah 23:97,98 here we are told what to say
16:98. AND SAY 23:97,98
This may be a silly question Dr Hany, but is it possible the people of the cave, and more specifically the ayat 18:17 is a future event? And thats why the story 'seems' so obscure? Have you already covered these ayat and I have missed it?
@ Sal Tay
We have not addressed it yet.
An no! It is not about something in the future.
15:15 what it mean?
Assalamu'alaikum brother. Please give hadith reverences attached to your interpretation. Jazakumullah. Thank you.
17:46
@@MarvelousQuran sorry i didnt find it.
Salamun Alaykum Dr. Hany, As I was listening to this video and came across the 94:4 explanation, I got bit confused. Please help me out of this. In this video about the Ayah you said it is about our beloved Prophet Muhammad but if I remember correctly in one of your other presentation you said this ayah is about Musa. I tried to find the other video so that I sort out without asking you but couldn't find. I hope you will me help to get clear about this. Jazak Allah Kharun.