Medical Mystery - Someone They Knew with Tamron Hall

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 3. 06. 2022
  • Rosemarie Essa appeared to have died in a car crash. But when police learn this was no more than a low-speed fender-bender, they begin to suspect foul play-by someone who knew what they were doing.
    #SomeoneTheyKnew with #TamronHall | A #CourtTV Original Series court.tv/FindUs
    COURT TV IS BACK! 24/7 LIVE gavel-to-gavel coverage, in-depth legal reporting, and expert analysis of the nation’s most important and compelling trials.
    WATCH COURT TV LIVE:
    www.courttv.com/title/court-t...
    WATCH TRIALS ON DEMAND:
    www.courttv.com/programming/t...
    WHERE TO WATCH:
    www.courttv.com/where-to-watc...

Komentáře • 820

  • @mariadavis8745
    @mariadavis8745 Před 2 lety +107

    He couldn’t have cared about the custody of his children, so that shouldn’t have been mentioned in the list of his possible motives. He up and left the children and was living a carefree life. Also how does he get the possibility of parole with no confession, no apology no remorse? I don’t understand the judicial system.

    • @ailleananaithnid2566
      @ailleananaithnid2566 Před rokem +5

      Here’s what’s ever more tragic… Healthcare professionals (doctors and nurses) know how fragile human life is. And they see the consequences of trauma like this (loss of both parents) and how it weighs on their children for the rest of their lives.

    • @ailleananaithnid2566
      @ailleananaithnid2566 Před rokem +10

      I was a trial lawyer for decades; so I do understand the justice system. The legislature passes laws. The people elect the legislators. The judicial system isn’t cut off from the public. If we don’t vote responsibly, we end up with the politicians we deserve.
      Try to remember that the “possibility” of parole does NOT equal mandatory parole. To be granted parole, an offender MUST take responsibility for (and admit) his/her crime. S/he also must demonstrate GENUINE remorse. I don’t see that as a likelihood in this offender’s case, do you? Prosecutors do a very good job at appearing at parole hearings to remind parole boards of the crime that sent an offender to prison. These days even offenders that work hard at rehabilitation are denied parole. He’s not going to taste freedom as long as Rosie’s family is alive.
      As the US has tacks further & further right, we have removed sentencing discretion from trial judges. The direct consequence is that the US incarcerates more human beings than any other country in the world. That’s not cheap. It means diverting money from critical services like education. Health care. Elder care. Medical research. Our kids no longer compete with college graduates from other countries bc our education system is underfunded.
      Many offenders are illiterate. As our world becomes increasingly complex, can you imagine trying to support yourself and your family when you can’t read & write? And as we abandon rehabilitation, we no longer offer education in correctional facilities. To me, it’s almost criminal to parole someone after a decade of incarceration but haven’t bothered to offer basic skills like literacy!
      The cases you see featured in true crime programs are the EXCEPTION and not the rule. This offender is a psychopath. Only about 1% of the population is psychopathic.
      Not every incarcerated person is an habitual offender. Judges should have the discretion to provide the possibility of parole for those with the potential for rehabilitation. Especially when it’s mandatory for them to demonstrate actual remorse. None of us wants to be defined by the worst moment in our lives.

    • @nimue4325
      @nimue4325 Před rokem +3

      @@ailleananaithnid2566 The problem is the seemingly randomness of some people getting the probabilty of parole and some do not, especially the younger offenders, etc.
      Regardless of the process and the guidelines, it all seems to comeback to the judge's discretionary powers. The average person can't help but notice this discrepancy in sentencing. Anyway, this guy bragging about his crime should qualify him for no parole eligibility (according to America's very punitive legal system.)

    • @tyrellanderson4722
      @tyrellanderson4722 Před rokem

      As a trial lawyer, that information wasn't exactly new.

    • @sueme1954
      @sueme1954 Před 11 měsíci

      This weed claimed that he would never get a fair trial in the U.S. because the U.S. is "racist" against Lebanese.
      Yeah right.
      Thank goodness for that last call to her friend.
      Maybe irony in the pen will bring disaster around the ears of this weed in the form of a vendetta.

  • @greengreen3961
    @greengreen3961 Před rokem +76

    Salute to Ms Eva McGregor. A brave and beautiful soul. If not for her coming forward with the last phone call made by the victim, the murderer could have evaded punishment.

  • @RLU-wt8vi
    @RLU-wt8vi Před rokem +62

    Update: Further reading on this case states his first parole hearing would be 2028. I've no doubt that Rosemary's family will be present and remind the parole board his total lack of responsibility or remorse. I truly feel so sorry for her friend who literally heard the last words she ever spoke, and they were of her being sick and in pain. Thank God she mentioned the calcium pills.

  • @karengiorella2690
    @karengiorella2690 Před 2 lety +112

    This man is a monster! The tip to the FBI most likely saved another woman's life. He's a cold, callous killer. A coward. Killed his wife at a distance with poison. She didn't even have a way to defend herself. He would do it again. Tamron hall delivers. And the most courageous and epic victim impact statement ever. My heart goes out to the family.

    • @joshuaben5665
      @joshuaben5665 Před 2 lety +1

      Hello Karen

    • @joshuaben5665
      @joshuaben5665 Před rokem

      Hello Karen

    • @portialucombe2667
      @portialucombe2667 Před 11 měsíci

      What a creep may u go to hell fool

    • @birdieorourke5507
      @birdieorourke5507 Před 11 měsíci +1

      Agree 100% A monster to do what he did. Premeditated. He was a serial adultress. T.G his brother and man who helped him in Beruit told the truth.

    • @whoswhoatthezoo9372
      @whoswhoatthezoo9372 Před 11 měsíci +2

      @@birdieorourke5507 Monsters walk amongst us, masquerading as normal, everyday people. I know, I was married to one. By the grace of God he didn’t destroy me and I lived to divorce him. It was years ago and I was able to not only get custody of, but raise my children to be adults. ❤

  • @Rhombohedral
    @Rhombohedral Před 2 lety +145

    Heartbreaking to see the parents of Rosemarie Essa 😢

    • @tothelighthouse9843
      @tothelighthouse9843 Před 2 lety +10

      Yes. All they did was tell the truth about how they've been impacted...and it was heartbreaking.

  • @tothelighthouse9843
    @tothelighthouse9843 Před 2 lety +122

    Yazeed Essa was working his shift at the Emergency Room Rosemarie was rushed to after the accident. He would've known that's where she'd be brought once the cyanide kicked in while she was driving. He literally stood in the ER & watched as a team worked on Rosemarie. The ER doctor who worked on Rosemarie testified that he attempted for 30 minutes to revive Rosemarie, until YAZEED said to him "Just call it". The doctor then ceased his attempts & called her time of death.
    For that final meeting to be part of Yazeed's plan...wow, that's as cold as it gets.

    • @IndianOutlaw1870
      @IndianOutlaw1870 Před 2 lety +3

      This is erroneous. He had lost lost his medical license long before the murder..

    • @tothelighthouse9843
      @tothelighthouse9843 Před 2 lety +8

      @@IndianOutlaw1870
      Essa was a practicing doctor at the time of the murder. He'd had his medical license suspended in 2004 but "according to the Akron Beacon Journal, Essa's license was reinstated a month later on a "probationary basis." (from murderpedia). Essa was described as a prominent doctor in all the court documents, & most online articles specify that he was an ER doctor.
      Testimony of Dr Eric White, doctor on call that night in the ER when Rosemarie arrived:
      "Eric White, D.O., testified that on February 24, 2005, he treated Rosemarie at the emergency room of Hillcrest Hospital.
      Dr. White testified that Rosemarie had arrived by ambulance and had reportedly been in a minor motor-vehicle accident...After 30 to 40 minutes of attempting to revive Rosemarie, Dr. White saw no signs of improvement. After a discussion, appellant (ie Yazeed Essa) told Dr. White to “just call it,” and
      Dr. White agreed to stop trying to revive Rosemarie". (quoted from The Court of Appeals of Ohio, 'The State of Ohio v Essa' Number 94826, May 26, 2011, page 4).
      Now it's certainly possible that Essa told Dr White to "make the call" despite not being on call that night, but Essa was definitely a doctor at the time, & almost certainly an ER doctor. The testimony of Dr White made it sound like they were working together, but I guess it's possible that Essa said "Just call it" & Dr White conferred with him & agreed, despite Essa's being an ER doctor at a different hospital.

    • @wrayewenigmann3696
      @wrayewenigmann3696 Před 2 lety +16

      I remember this from another show- he was expecting his wife would take the quickest, shortest route to the cinema which would have been via the motorway. She would then have been involved in a high speed crash, possibly even with other cars, and there would not have been an autopsy. He didn't think she would take the slower road and take time to call her friend. Think about that. May he rot in hell.

    • @vernareed2692
      @vernareed2692 Před rokem +4

      What had he lost his md license for?

    • @whyohwhy9679
      @whyohwhy9679 Před rokem +5

      @@wrayewenigmann3696 Man, that's heartless. So many other people could have been injured as well. What an awful "person."

  • @MichelleLee-
    @MichelleLee- Před rokem +45

    I remember watching this trial. My heart broke for Rosie's family. I'm glad that Rosie's brother, Dominic DiPuccio and his wife have adopted the children & they even changed their last names to DiPuccio.

    • @2034916
      @2034916 Před 10 měsíci +4

      I wish I had a family and/or in-laws like the Dupuccios. Really. So tragic and unnecessary.
      This man, with all his brilliance and education, didn’t think of the consequences to his in-laws, which appear to be such lovely people, his children and, lastly, to himself if he was found out?
      What a horrible excuse for a man.

  • @cindylang7402
    @cindylang7402 Před 2 lety +152

    I'm so glad they made his brother understand that he didn't have to lie on the stand for his brother and I don't think he even wanted to lie on the stand after hearing what he said to him when he found out he had killed Rosie... he loved her and he thought he was stupid for messing everything up. Even the parents looked shocked at his testimony. His protector was hilarious about his bragging about killing her every damned day! This is exactly the stuff the jurors needed to see. Also, I forgot to mention that his brother looked like a deer in the headlights when he realized their phone conversation had been recorded. Looks like Rosie ended up with the wrong brother.

    • @tothelighthouse9843
      @tothelighthouse9843 Před 2 lety +33

      Actually the DA made it clear his brother COULDN'T lie on the stand.
      The brother cut a deal with the DA to avoid prison time on the charges he faced for aiding & abetting a fugitive, as well as other charges. It was made clear to him that if he lied on the stand, the deal was off & he'd be facing over 10 yrs in prison.
      So he told the truth to avoid a lengthy prison sentence.

    • @julieuk5855
      @julieuk5855 Před rokem +6

      Well the brother lied on the stand regarding the $35k. You can't un-ring the bell.

    • @joshuaben5665
      @joshuaben5665 Před rokem

      Hello Cindy

    • @user-pr7yk5hn6k
      @user-pr7yk5hn6k Před rokem +1

      THE SHOWS THAT THE MEDIA, THE JUDGE & EVERYONE PUT ON AND PLAY IN THESE HIGH PROFILE CASES IS SO PHONE , But A regular person who does way less get the more severe punishment quick and swift , But they parade this for weeks & thy all talked about how evil he was after he was convicted and talked about how hurt rose Mary’s parents were But yet he gets out in the next four years , coming home healthier then before and even wealthier , what a parade and a show but what a slap in the face to Rose Mary. He’s going to get out have years to live his life I’m sure with a beautiful woman becus he has the money also & his kids still are going to want to be in there dads life.

    • @user-pr7yk5hn6k
      @user-pr7yk5hn6k Před rokem +4

      No she saw wealthy doctors 🥼 that’s all DIDNT matter which one she got , I work at the hospital there wives are just basically someone to clean up there house cook for them and raise there children , I see it everyday these doctors sleep with the most beautiful nurses and other women , one just got back frm vacation with a nurse that barely been working here at the hospital I mean she’s beautiful but the trip was a business trip just the two of them , now u do the math

  • @Magna_Carta5
    @Magna_Carta5 Před 2 lety +199

    How senseless. Just goes to show that some people can have it all, and still not appreciate it. He had a good career that he had worked hard for, a beautiful wife, the mother to his children, and there was no reason for what he did. Okay, he didn't want her to take anything in a divorce, but in his selfish disregard for her he didn't just lose a percentage, he lost it all then some. Just senseless.

  • @pickledragonrebel
    @pickledragonrebel Před 2 lety +55

    Nothing says "not guilty" like fleeing the country ! Lol. Seriously though, what a vicious pos. Rip to that wonderful woman....

    • @rw8990
      @rw8990 Před 10 měsíci

      Nothing says Guilty,like fleeing the country.

  • @deeceepnw
    @deeceepnw Před 2 lety +89

    No parole for this guy ever! I hope women everywhere are warned to stay away from this toxic monster.

    • @TheRight-handedStranger
      @TheRight-handedStranger Před 11 měsíci

      Well he is going to be released in 2029, why?

    • @deeceepnw
      @deeceepnw Před 11 měsíci +11

      @@TheRight-handedStranger he could be eligible for parole at the end of 2028. His sentence is life with the possibility of parole after 20 years. I don’t think he should ever be paroled. May the parole board see him for the toxic piece of flotsam of society that he is and keep him locked up in max security.

  • @traec8729
    @traec8729 Před 2 lety +95

    Heartbreaking for the victim. Her children are now motherless.

    • @leisbookoflife1749
      @leisbookoflife1749 Před 2 lety +15

      Essentially orphans, thanks to the greed of their father.

    • @Papadoxwife
      @Papadoxwife Před 2 lety +9

      And fatherless, too!

    • @kennethallen809
      @kennethallen809 Před 2 lety +6

      And fatherless

    • @joshuaben5665
      @joshuaben5665 Před rokem

      Hey Tracy

    • @2034916
      @2034916 Před 10 měsíci

      And they have to live with the knowledge that their father killed their mother. Thank goodness they have a wonderful support system.

  • @morganphillips8634
    @morganphillips8634 Před 2 lety +37

    He deserves no parole.

  • @Ziko577
    @Ziko577 Před 2 lety +160

    There wasn't a dry eye in that courtroom at all. My hearts go out to the family and for this piece of human waste to do this to a woman who loved him dearly is just evil.

    • @rhondaalbrecht
      @rhondaalbrecht Před 10 měsíci +1

      There were two dry eyes... the murderer's.

  • @christinerobinson890
    @christinerobinson890 Před 2 lety +51

    Only 20 with eligibility for parole? How about life without parole?

  • @dawgmaw
    @dawgmaw Před 2 lety +26

    This guy's eyes scare me.

  • @nyrobisingapore4204
    @nyrobisingapore4204 Před 2 lety +33

    Eye for an 👁. He's a coward, I hope he NEVER gets out of prison.

  • @Conservativelady
    @Conservativelady Před rokem +10

    It should have been life without the possibility of parole smh 🤦‍♀️

  • @amazingsupergirl7125
    @amazingsupergirl7125 Před 2 lety +29

    Of 30+ trials I’ve watched, this was the most shocking, dramatic one with twists. This report doesn’t give it justice. He’s fugly and horrid inside and out.

    • @ramonaradu1921
      @ramonaradu1921 Před 11 měsíci

      Hi! Can you please share a top of trials that are worth watching? Thanks!☺️

  • @sierraechopnw4228
    @sierraechopnw4228 Před 2 lety +528

    Tamron is such a classic beauty, poised & graceful and I feel empathy in her reporting.

  • @crossedwires2629
    @crossedwires2629 Před 11 měsíci +9

    wait... 20 years? AND the possibility of parole??? I'm dumb-founded. How is he not in prison for life with NO chance of parole???? unbelievable.

  • @NadineMiller1974
    @NadineMiller1974 Před 2 lety +37

    What a disgusting mouth breather! I cannot or will never understand how someone who seemingly has it all can just callously wipe it all away like a runny nose.
    He may have been a educated and successful man, but he wasn't the brightest crayon. Handing over the item you murdered your wife with...real genius my guy🙄
    Rosemarie's voice was heard!!!

    • @joshuaben5665
      @joshuaben5665 Před 2 lety

      Hello Nadine

    • @Froggydoggy13
      @Froggydoggy13 Před rokem +1

      If he would've said no I don't have the calcium pills anymore, they would've instantly knew he did something. And he knew they would know that. They would've asked more questions.
      He *was a doctor. He knew it would take a few days for the labs to come back- which bought him time to flee the country.
      He is a very smart piece of sh*t.

    • @bluefaery1865
      @bluefaery1865 Před 11 měsíci +4

      ​@@Froggydoggy13If he was smart, he would have had an extra bottle of non tampered vitamins to hand to the cops.

  • @loreebrew38
    @loreebrew38 Před rokem +27

    I'm shocked he got the possibility of parole in only 20 years. Did the judge have to give that possibility to him? Outrageous!!!!

  • @allisondynamite
    @allisondynamite Před 2 lety +167

    Go back to minute 42:10. Seeing a member of Yazeed Essa’s own legal team wiping away tears as Dominic Dipuccio directly confronts his sister’s killer in court really echoes just how many people were affected by this crime and it’s sheer depravity. It definitely stood out to me as a powerful moment.

    • @frenshayrequeno4780
      @frenshayrequeno4780 Před 2 lety +1

      Yes I remember this murder crazy people never heard of divorce!!!!!

    • @cynthiatolman326
      @cynthiatolman326 Před 2 lety +15

      Wow. It wasn't difficult to see, he had a tissue in his hand and he wasn't trying to hide it. He believes in what our justice system is all about, that everyone has a right to a fair trial with good defense attorneys. He did his job well, and truth prevailed. Amazing he didn't care if even his client saw it.

    • @sgtmajortodd
      @sgtmajortodd Před rokem +14

      Well the judge wasn't moved. She's giving him a chance for parole after a measly 20!

    • @TheGoogilly
      @TheGoogilly Před rokem +14

      She gave him the maximum sentence under the law. I'm certain she didn't enjoy that fact.

    • @algimante2097
      @algimante2097 Před 11 měsíci +7

      @@sgtmajortodd it's not her fault. This is maximum he can get in the state.

  • @InMyPOV2u
    @InMyPOV2u Před 2 lety +40

    When you see how all this ends, it's clear how her death was senseless. I wonder what HE thought at this point.

  • @mikkibubble4711
    @mikkibubble4711 Před 11 měsíci +7

    Why oh why did that unremorseful killer get the possibility of parole ? How unjust a “justice” system !

  • @ceilconstante640
    @ceilconstante640 Před 2 lety +48

    Narscissist, Sociopaths, Psychopaths..... whatever you want to call them walk among us. Empathetic people are the preferred targets.

    • @thatcatboab
      @thatcatboab Před 2 lety +6

      So true 💔

    • @michaelfant4052
      @michaelfant4052 Před 2 lety +10

      @@thatcatboab That's why I Thank God Johnny Depp is still alive.

    • @earth0128
      @earth0128 Před rokem +1

      Spot on 👌

    • @elenalatici9568
      @elenalatici9568 Před 11 měsíci +1

      Absolutely. And there are a lot of them. They always go for empaths. The scariest thing about them is that they can live a double life and you'd never suspect a thing. Then, when you find out, you condemn yourself for being stupid. That stays with you for the rest of your life.
      Women who manage to escape with their lives are the lucky ones in spite of the emotional damage.
      What he did to his wife was so evil there are no words, in English anyway, to put a name to it. Death by cyanide is supposed to be agonizing.

    • @samantham8696
      @samantham8696 Před 10 měsíci

      “Empathic” people are the result of childhood abuse. So they are both drawn to each other unfortunately.

  • @gingermiller8609
    @gingermiller8609 Před rokem +7

    parole in 20 years???!!! Whar in the heck are you thinking, judge??!!

  • @krist5860
    @krist5860 Před rokem +7

    Don't let narcissists know you're leaving them, they'll have a complete meltdown

    • @earth0128
      @earth0128 Před rokem

      Fact

    • @elenalatici9568
      @elenalatici9568 Před 11 měsíci

      Better not even to divorce unless you have children to protect. Otherwise, just get on a plane and disappear.

  • @oliviag2494
    @oliviag2494 Před rokem +17

    The hurt on her Mom’s face when that witness said he bragged about poisoning her 😔

  • @L.C._2012
    @L.C._2012 Před 11 měsíci +5

    Spineless poor excuse of a human being to murder the mother of his children. even in such a horrible way

  • @eugeniaarmendariz9489
    @eugeniaarmendariz9489 Před 2 lety +27

    This story made me cry!! 😭😭😭😭😭 Money the root of all EVIL! Why not divorce her? he was educated could of rebuild his money.

    • @sducote6806
      @sducote6806 Před 2 lety +8

      Money is not the root of all evil, it's the love of money.

    • @joshuaben5665
      @joshuaben5665 Před 2 lety +3

      Instead Of Violence They Better Divorce 😭.

    • @joshuaben5665
      @joshuaben5665 Před rokem

      Hello Eugenia

    • @elenalatici9568
      @elenalatici9568 Před 11 měsíci

      ​@@sducote6806
      Was just going to write that. People so often get that saying wrong. I would add that money is often what defines such a person.. Without it they become who they really are: small, pitiful,, enraged and vindictive in the extreme. They don't even have to lose the money. Just the fear that someone --usually the wife-- will take it all can lead to "accidents"

  • @lillyanderson3623
    @lillyanderson3623 Před 2 lety +40

    I remember watching this in real time. What a tragedy!

  • @felicityholmes9072
    @felicityholmes9072 Před 2 lety +19

    Possibility of Parole????? WTF???????

  • @ScienTeka
    @ScienTeka Před 2 lety +18

    This is a clear case of first degree murder. Why should he be eligible for parole after 20 years? Life should be life.

  • @SaltyPug
    @SaltyPug Před rokem +26

    Life WITH possibility of parole in 20 years??? He’s a disgrace & should never be released. I hope that parole board denies him forever. Rosie’s poor family & kids. What a tragedy

    • @emmyemmy8669
      @emmyemmy8669 Před 11 měsíci

      i’m shocked because that he end of this video, the presenter said he will be eligible for parole in 2029. that’s in 6yrs.

    • @bettyjw53
      @bettyjw53 Před 11 měsíci +2

      I don't know what year this happened but it was probably years ago. I'm shocked he only got 20 years! She should have given him at least 30... He probably won't even do the whole 20!! He's an evil man..

    • @kitlee172
      @kitlee172 Před 11 měsíci +2

      @@bettyjw53In 2010, he was sentenced to life WITH possibility of parole in 20 years. The murder happened in 2005.
      So in 2029, he will go before a parole board. I feel this man is so arrogant he won’t be able to stomach being a “model prisoner”.

    • @bettyjw53
      @bettyjw53 Před 11 měsíci

      @@kitlee172 Let’s hope so!! He should NEVER see the light of day, or walk the streets as a free man ever again! He is right where he belongs.

    • @RachelDoesntknow
      @RachelDoesntknow Před 10 měsíci

      For what it's worth, parole boards almost always deny people for a long ass time even the people who aren't dangerous to society still get denied for like. Decades

  • @stacyneuman8619
    @stacyneuman8619 Před 2 lety +22

    Those poor children should not be without their mother,the jury got this right! No excuse for this guy,love and hugs to all of her loved ones.

  • @2ndround415
    @2ndround415 Před 2 lety +32

    That ADA Anna Faraglia is amazing, I’ve caught a few cases of hers on CZcams before. Someone needs to do a movie on her.

  • @muse7746
    @muse7746 Před 2 lety +14

    Warning. Graphic images. Yes, a bottle of Calcium, 😖😲 a court room, 😳 a murderer in an orange jumpsuit! Scary graphic images alright. Terrifying in fact. 😳🤯😱

  • @v.polonez5945
    @v.polonez5945 Před 2 lety +31

    Heartbroken for her parents and most of all her poor kids he’s a monster there is no call for the possibility of parole for this evil bastard what a horrible story

  • @SuzieQGirl
    @SuzieQGirl Před 11 měsíci +6

    Equally shocking that he gets out of prison in 2029. Life should mean life.

  • @Kari.F.
    @Kari.F. Před 2 lety +17

    Punishment in the US is usually very hard. He got 20 years?! That's a more common sentence for this type of murder in my country of Norway. Well, in fact: We had a murder trial involving a chemist who poisoned his spouse to death about 20 years ago. His sentence was far stricter than this! I highly doubt that he's going to walk free anytime soon.

    • @shellos8
      @shellos8 Před 2 lety +7

      20 to life. It just means he can apply for parole after serving 20 years. Nobody's gonna let him out.

  • @pinrod1
    @pinrod1 Před rokem +11

    Something they didn't mention about the planned car accident. He thought she would take the shortest/usual route to the movie, which would be on a highway with higher speeds. She foiled his plan by taking a different route, with slower traffic.

    • @elenalatici9568
      @elenalatici9568 Před 11 měsíci +3

      That shouldn't have been left out. Even if she had called Eva, no one would have thought about an autopsy. A high speed accident could have her in such condition that accidental death would have been the only conclusion.
      That piece of information, that cunning detail, is chilling.

  • @dorindadouglas2847
    @dorindadouglas2847 Před 2 lety +22

    I don't understand how this judge seems so disgusted with him, yet gives him the possibility of parole in only 20 years. Maybe that's the max in that state? I hope his parole is denied until he's like 80!

    • @Froggydoggy13
      @Froggydoggy13 Před rokem +3

      The possibility of parole doesn't guarantee parole be granted. Possibility.
      They have to admit guilt and show genuine remorse to be considered to be released.
      Does he seem like the type that's going to do that?

    • @claire9906
      @claire9906 Před rokem

      That's what I thought can only hope he's denied parole. Her brother was right he's a coward and the only way he'll get out is to fake remorse heartbreaking for her family especially their kids growing up and finding out how evil their father is

    • @jkshanahan007
      @jkshanahan007 Před rokem +2

      Yep, she talked a good talk, right up until the sentencing.

    • @dorindadouglas2847
      @dorindadouglas2847 Před rokem

      @Lyly Yes, I'm aware of how parole works. My point was she seemed like she was going to give him life without the possibility of parole, which is what he deserved. I don't remember the details of this case at this point, but maybe that sentence wasn't an option.

    • @judistocker1811
      @judistocker1811 Před 11 měsíci +1

      Blame it on the legislators who are soft on criminals

  • @aridyaacob3172
    @aridyaacob3172 Před 2 lety +26

    I watched this some years ago either on Forensic Files or FBI Files and it was fascinating then as well. Condolences.

  • @angelapowell7205
    @angelapowell7205 Před 2 lety +19

    Damn he killed his own wife how many patients did he probably kill. I wished she had married the brother. His brother testimony made me cry that was his sister n law.

  • @matthewramsey5239
    @matthewramsey5239 Před 2 lety +63

    My new favorite program! Tamron always brings it! Such a gem she is and stunningly gorgeous 💎

  • @coreypatrick7230
    @coreypatrick7230 Před 2 lety +8

    This guy literally had it all, but none of it mattered. It’s the Pride of it all for me -this guy is sick and completely self absorbed.

  • @selenasanchez7336
    @selenasanchez7336 Před rokem +6

    My God i am crying for these parents of Beautiful Rosie and all her family and friends her babies. Parole in 20 no way judge what?????

  • @Songshare
    @Songshare Před rokem +11

    It’s sad and terrifying that there are men in this world that are completely selfish, cold, and evil. I don’t understand what makes these monsters do the horrific acts they do other than to say they deceive themselves by thinking they are gaining something.

  • @felicamoore8793
    @felicamoore8793 Před rokem +18

    A voice from the grave! Telling her friend that he gave her a pill was In God’s plans! If it had not been for that. This guy would have killed again! Thank God the policeman took her seriously and passed along the information. Teamwork

    • @AllergicToMakeBelieve
      @AllergicToMakeBelieve Před 11 měsíci +1

      It's a shame that it wasn't God's plan for her to marry a decent man, seems like it would have been more compassionate than leaving children without a mother. Or perhaps God's plan could have involved the husband getting killed in a car crash the week before he decided to off his wife... Or perhaps God's plan could have involved the evil husband failing in his plot in some other way. Just sayin'.

  • @dannschmit8604
    @dannschmit8604 Před 2 lety +12

    One thing that really pisses me off about the justice system is the sentencing. Murderers get life. BUT... then most get "eligible for parole in 'such and such a time'." Sorry, but parole after any time of a life sentence is not a life sentence. Life should mean exactly that. LIFE. No parole for murderers. PERIOD!!!! You take a life, you forfeit the rest of yours to spending in prison. If they are filling up the prisons, then maybe they should remember that prison is for VIOLENT OFFENDERS!!!!! Non violent can be dealt with in other ways, depending on the situation and severity of the crime.

  • @oilliecelt
    @oilliecelt Před rokem +25

    First of all the presenter miss Tamron is such a lovely lady, and yes to watch the parents was very very emotional.

  • @MJ-sz6ys
    @MJ-sz6ys Před rokem +5

    Why did he get parole?? That's the big question?! That poor victim family will not rest if they have to worry about his parole!

  • @brigman18
    @brigman18 Před 2 lety +16

    The parents just broke my heart. They should be enjoying their daughter and grandchildren. I’m praying for them. Just heartbreaking someone you trust and love will secretly hate you and even kill you. ❤️‍🩹

  • @Hope44903
    @Hope44903 Před 2 lety +13

    Nothing is perfect...He should stay for the rest of his life in prison...

  • @maburg713
    @maburg713 Před 2 lety +33

    I will never understand why people choose murder over divorce. And I will NEVER understand these "women" (not my first choice of wordage) who insinuate themselves into other people's marriage.

    • @peggypeggy4137
      @peggypeggy4137 Před 2 lety +15

      I agree. Plus when Essa was on the lam. he kept bragging about how he was a murderer. He was dating all kinds of women when he was in Lebanon. What kind of woman would want to be with a man who would kill his wife and abandon his kids? Plus he just looks evil.

    • @SickandTired95
      @SickandTired95 Před 2 lety +11

      @@peggypeggy4137 It’s insane. Some of the the worst killers in history have found women to marry from prison. I’ll never understand it.

    • @peggypeggy4137
      @peggypeggy4137 Před 2 lety +1

      @@SickandTired95 I have heard that it is because they like the "bad boys" alpha males (or so they think) When they get older and smarter, they see their mistake.

    • @Fti193
      @Fti193 Před 2 lety +5

      Money the root of all evil.

    • @sexytrinny52
      @sexytrinny52 Před 2 lety +5

      On word: MONEY

  • @c.erine78
    @c.erine78 Před 2 lety +10

    There is nothing to say, that her brother's didn't already say...

  • @lauriaendy4595
    @lauriaendy4595 Před 2 lety +11

    I wonder what his motive was? What an evil man, he had everything but couldn't control his pride and vindictive nature! The brother did the right thing by telling the truth. Never cover a murderer it's not worth it!

    • @elenalatici9568
      @elenalatici9568 Před 11 měsíci +1

      Money. He wasn't about to lose a cent through divorce. He loved his money more than anything else, surely more than his wife or children. The only thing he had a relationship with was his money. The thought of him in prison in his orange suit instead of his fashionable expensive clothes, eating prison food instead of $500 dinners, and no grand cru wine ever again in his life is heartwarming.

  • @doseofhope3481
    @doseofhope3481 Před 2 lety +16

    Terrible tragedy…… Class “A” judge!!!!

  • @koisneurotypical
    @koisneurotypical Před 2 lety +5

    wow he’s up for parole in just seven years... how unfair.

  • @gagagoose2878
    @gagagoose2878 Před rokem +5

    Isn’t it funny how almost every time a spouse get murdered, they were described as “the perfect family?”

    • @gagagoose2878
      @gagagoose2878 Před 11 měsíci +1

      You’re right, as soon as we hear
      “perfect” we know someone is going to end up dead.

  • @hahadarrie
    @hahadarrie Před 2 lety +5

    His attorney should have stepped in before the judge had to instruct him against self incrimination.
    Imagine having an affair with a man, him asking you to babysit along with his other mistress, only to find out that he will not be returning and has fled the country for killing his wife.

  • @stephanienelly90
    @stephanienelly90 Před 2 lety +7

    Her parents 💔💔 oh my, they were fighting back tears.

  • @mpalmer7800
    @mpalmer7800 Před 2 lety +11

    Look at the evil eyes

  • @lidyanaredeemed9848
    @lidyanaredeemed9848 Před 2 lety +25

    So sad to see someone destroy their life for women! The woman whom he had an affair told him to separate from his wife in order to continue his relationship with her is also responsible and should be accountable! Knowing that he is married and continue to have a relationship with him is also evil. She wants his money. It’s a sick world out here we all need to be carful. God is supreme!!

    • @Kenzingo
      @Kenzingo Před 2 lety +3

      Wtf are u talking about

    • @saltwatertaffy7020
      @saltwatertaffy7020 Před 2 lety +7

      Yes, and one of them had just gotten married and still continued the affair. In fact, they were both newly married, when they continued the affair. Which means during their respective engagement periods, they were cheating on their partners, NASTY!

    • @virginiawanjiku5106
      @virginiawanjiku5106 Před rokem +3

      Wtf???? She didn't kill Marie

    • @vernareed2692
      @vernareed2692 Před rokem +2

      Right! And they kept her face blurred "to protect her" on the stand!!

  • @sandibaker5298
    @sandibaker5298 Před 2 lety +5

    Why in the heck do so many people kill their significant others instead of just divorcing them? …playing fast and loose with their souls.

  • @ortizmusic7115
    @ortizmusic7115 Před 2 lety +13

    He be home in 7 more years, only if he says the right things to parole, parole really looks at your remorse, if they sense you have not taken accountability, they will hit you with a few more years to think about what to say on the next parole visit.

    • @shellos8
      @shellos8 Před 2 lety +4

      I promise you he isn't getting out anytime soon. Maybe when he's 80, if he lives that long. 80 is still nearly 30 years away though. Let his dreams continue to torture him. She never let's him forget

  • @dravenhawktoland1127
    @dravenhawktoland1127 Před 2 lety +5

    I hope that when he comes up for parole. He doesn't get out. Because he doesn't deserve to be a free man.

  • @DustyFae
    @DustyFae Před 2 lety +13

    SOME TIMES WITH LIFE IN PRISON IS ALSO A POSSIBLITY OF ESCAPE THEY GET 3 MEALS AND A COT . THE VICEIM IS FOREVER DEAD

    • @viffey
      @viffey Před 2 lety +3

      You're completely right! They don't have to worry about paying the mortgage, earning enough to feed their families and so many other every day bills! Somehow seems unfair

  • @cottoncandy4486
    @cottoncandy4486 Před 2 lety +7

    He may have been a doctor but he was pretty dumb about covering any tracks. He never even tried, he was evil. and arrogant. So so glad he eventually got cought.

  • @tracievendetta1908
    @tracievendetta1908 Před 2 lety +25

    Love the female prosecutor! I’ve watched her on other cases!!

  • @cynthiatolman326
    @cynthiatolman326 Před 2 lety +7

    The defense team didn't have a chance, this case was a slam dunk for the prosecution. He told everyone what he'd done, and though his family did help him, they didn't approve and I believe were relieved to be forced to tell the truth. I just heard the sentence, 20 years? Where was the 'without' parole? He didn't kill her in anger, caught up in a rage. This was a planned, and prepared for, execution. Life isn't life when he's allowed back into society to walk among us. And he will be, if parole boards previous histories are considered, he will be. May the family have found peace raising her beautiful children. Rest in Peace Rosemarie.🌹🙏

  • @anisezettecarey2448
    @anisezettecarey2448 Před 2 lety +8

    You Cant Make Me Believe That Was Love.

  • @thomism1016
    @thomism1016 Před 2 lety +27

    This show is truly awesome. I think Yaz is exceedingly lucky to have the possibility of parole to look forward to after his atrocious pre-meditated crime and all the harm it caused.

    • @shellos8
      @shellos8 Před 2 lety +9

      He won't ever get parole. Certainly not the first couple of tries. Someone like him who is very intelligent, has plenty of money and friends who will help him, is far too dangerous to be free again. His own kids still don't want anything to do with him. We're safer with him in the supermax prison he resides in.

    • @thomism1016
      @thomism1016 Před 2 lety +9

      @@shellos8 Michelle, I couldn’t agree more. The fact he was bragging about it, speaks to who he really is. Scary guy who ran but couldn’t hide and eventually got what he deserved.

    • @roxygirlwinston4405
      @roxygirlwinston4405 Před 2 lety +1

      I am utterly stunned that he was given the possibility of parole. I'm certain his chances are slim to none of ever receiving it, but I'm confused it was even part of his sentence. He should have been sentenced to death. PERIOD

    • @elenalatici9568
      @elenalatici9568 Před 11 měsíci +3

      He should never EVER be able to set foot out of that prison again. He will never change, he's incapable of change being the malignant narcissist that he is.

  • @Mainaed
    @Mainaed Před 2 lety +4

    This man is a monster.... 😡

  • @Goobijunga
    @Goobijunga Před 2 lety +9

    Condolences to her family, He should of got life for the beautiful life he took,

  • @TheSybil47
    @TheSybil47 Před 11 měsíci +3

    Another case, that had me in tears. My God, I was crying with this family, and friends, and thought that their victim impact statements were very powerful. That monster will never forget their words. Never. "Are you man enough to tell us the truth. Forget about an appeal. Don't waste anymore of your father's money. Be a man." Wow! The parents were actually stronger than I thought, because, that mother gave him such a great farewell wish.
    Then, to top it, the judge expressed how glad she was that he was leaving her courtroom, and hoped that she will never see his face ever again. I mean, can it get more powerful.
    If Rosie didn't call her friend, I just wonder what would've happened. But, I don't even want to think of what this monster might have done, if he got away with this murder. R.I.P dear Rosemarie, and may his family, and friends find peace, and fight against his ever getting out, everytime there is a parole hearing.

  • @JS-qy3dk
    @JS-qy3dk Před 11 měsíci +4

    26:20 what the heck?!!!! Judge cuts him and advices him AFTER he lied in front of everyone under oath?!! What was she thinking....?!

  • @lerniewojack8348
    @lerniewojack8348 Před 2 lety +35

    Thank you Tamron for sharing this investigation with us
    You do an outstanding job

  • @bunnylover6481
    @bunnylover6481 Před rokem +3

    Throw away the key keeping him in prison the rest of his life.

  • @sherrykrause3410
    @sherrykrause3410 Před 11 měsíci +4

    He brought his two women/nannies in to take care of their children because he is sick, and found it amusing his two women were doing his “bidding” and he used them for whatever he needed. He did not care who he stepped on. He loves no one but himself.

  • @cheerlynstovall5506
    @cheerlynstovall5506 Před rokem +2

    His arrogance got the best of him.He fell on his own sword.

  • @beautifulone5509
    @beautifulone5509 Před rokem +2

    Absolutely disgraceful!! He should never be given the possibility of parole after 20 years! Clearly the judge didn't care!

    • @elenalatici9568
      @elenalatici9568 Před 11 měsíci

      At the end it was declared that he would be eligible for parole in 2029. That's 6 years from now. I seriously doubt he will ever get parole. He would have to undergo such a radical character change to convince a parole board. He could probably fake such a change, narcissists can easily present themselves as someone the antithesis of who they really are. But they can't do it under constant observation for 20 years.

    • @elenalatici9568
      @elenalatici9568 Před 11 měsíci

      I don't agree at all that she didn't care. I think she knew, and still knows, he'd never get parole.
      OTOH, maybe she gave him the possibility of parole at 20 years, believing that upon being released, he might receive another, more permanent kind of justice.

  • @ruthallen1159
    @ruthallen1159 Před 2 lety +8

    I’ve seen this on another news program but this one, by far, went into more detail.

  • @wendiyee6442
    @wendiyee6442 Před 9 měsíci +1

    This is one of the most intriguing murder-mysteries. The DiPuccio Family are such articulate, sharp people. Hopefully, Rosie’ parents, & the rest of the Family, are doing well, & enjoying their Grandkids.

  • @susankoeppe
    @susankoeppe Před rokem +3

    How is this only a 20 year sentence?

  • @viffey
    @viffey Před 2 lety +6

    Tnx for the upload 😁 I love this show!

    • @COURTTV
      @COURTTV  Před 2 lety +4

      Our pleasure! Thanks for watching! New Episode tonight! court.tv/FindUs

  • @DDee-oi6kn
    @DDee-oi6kn Před rokem +2

    There should be no parole.

  • @johnkubik8559
    @johnkubik8559 Před 2 lety +21

    I just don't understand why he gave the cyanide laced pills to the police, it would have been so easy to give them a bottle of clean calcium pills.

    • @kaykwanu
      @kaykwanu Před 2 lety +3

      Beats me.

    • @pickledragonrebel
      @pickledragonrebel Před 2 lety +4

      I think he thought they might think it was a product tampering situation? It's the only thing I can think of. You know, like the Tylenol case..... sets it up to think well he couldn't be guilty if he offers up this evidence?

    • @lobsangtendron1808
      @lobsangtendron1808 Před 2 lety +3

      Or just take the cyanide pills out. The person who did the analysis on the pills said there were nine that didn't look like the others.

    • @traec8729
      @traec8729 Před 2 lety +18

      Probably a narcissist,, didn't think the police were smart enough to catch it!

    • @tothelighthouse9843
      @tothelighthouse9843 Před 2 lety +2

      He really didn't think the cops would collect the calcium bottle.
      His mistress testified she was babysitting his children at his home the night he arrived with cops to get the pill bottles. She said that after the cops left, Yazeed 'flipped out' & was raging & swearing. He literally hadn't anticipated the cops would want to collect the pill bottle as evidence.
      Something very interesting: his defence team said they were trying to have another child--as evidence of Yazeed's devotion to his family. However, the calcium pills were actually part of a whole regimen of prenatal/pre-pregnancy vitamins & supplements he'd devised for Rosemarie. I think 'let's get pregnant again' was actually just his ruse to get Rosemarie to unwittingly ingest cyanide.

  • @sherry8894
    @sherry8894 Před 11 měsíci +2

    The good doctor wasn't as smart as he thought he was. Poor Rosemary didn't deserve this, or the children! What a monster he was !!!

  • @thisbushnell2012
    @thisbushnell2012 Před 11 měsíci +1

    We have an overabundance of malignant narcissists currently free to cause mayhem among us. It is better for humanity that Essa stay where he is until he serves his full sentence, completely.

  • @brendawilley3202
    @brendawilley3202 Před 10 měsíci +1

    Great insight and complication of events. Ty for your coverage.

  • @gena7219
    @gena7219 Před 2 lety +7

    I remember watching this trial. I wish it was on youtube.

  • @truecrime_and_everything_else
    @truecrime_and_everything_else Před 6 měsíci +2

    Eligible for parole in 20 years is shocking?!!! This was a henious crime...

  • @brandysnaps9221
    @brandysnaps9221 Před 2 lety +4

    Thk you Tamron and team.
    I love the show and glad to see back after a few weeks.

  • @junglekutz5625
    @junglekutz5625 Před 2 lety +4

    It's better to appear like a failure to wandering eyes, than to actually end up being one. He could have gone about detaching himself from her and the marriage he no longer wanted in so many ways. Instead he killed her, abandoned the children and basically mocked the entire experience the moment felt that he was far away and untouchable. It doesn't matter your profession and who you appeared to be in others eyes. After doing some bs like this, people (even on a superficial level) will look at you like 👀You're way off aren't you?!

  • @felicamoore8793
    @felicamoore8793 Před rokem +2

    The brother on the stand looks scared of his brother bc he thinks he could be his next victim

  • @sherridillon2767
    @sherridillon2767 Před 11 měsíci +8

    His face and eyes just looked cold stoned evil. There was evil in his eye. I never saw such coldness and evil. I feel so sad for the victims good family. They are such kind good people- you can tell

  • @snsn7251
    @snsn7251 Před 2 lety +3

    That guy who flew from Lebanon is something else