What REALLY Happened To The Man Who Saved Arthur Morgan's Life In Red Dead Redemption 2 REVEALED!
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 09. 2024
- What REALLY Happened To The Man Who Saved Arthur Morgan's Life In Red Dead Redemption 2 REVEALED!
►Cheap GTA 5 Shark Cards & More Games: www.g2a.com/r/...
In today’s Red Dead Redemption 2 video - I'll be showing you what REALLY happened to the German man who saved Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Redemption 2 back in 1899 and where he is now in 1911!
►My Facebook:
/ mrbossftw
►My Snapchat:
/ mrbosssnaps
►My Twitter:
#!...
►My Instagram:
/ jamesrosshudgins
Hope you enjoyed this video! See you guys in the next one! ✌🏻
What REALLY Happened To The Man Who Saved Arthur Morgan's Life In Red Dead Redemption 2 REVEALED!
make better content
make better content
make better content
bf5 Peter Mueller from war stories hes a German tanker relatives
If he is maybe his wife died of tb helping Arthur and his children are gone
3:17 “VAMOS vamos”
always liked that part😂😂😂
wrong language Arthur
C mama el Arthuro :v
Did he just talked "Brazilian Portuguese"?
MA LANGUAGE?
@@manoelluiz7716 acho que foi em espanhol já como Javier fala de vez enquando com os membros em espanhol, como na missão bratwaite,(vamos a matar a todos) ou no bar quando eles lutam com o Tommy
@@alankeven5091 Não lembrava disso, valeu por me recordar amigo :D
@@ipadsgameplayshn2078 el que cago un sorete duro xd
Just imagine if Arthur accidentally gave the mans family tb and so the man lost them, became bitter over losing his family because of an American
Actually that can be a possiblity didnt think of it that way
@@pabloescobar7109 feel like blaming it all on arthur seems too simple. I like the idea that the messed up world of rdr screw him over multiple times, not saying this couldnt still fit. But i dont feel like it would be solely the reason.
Exactly what I was gunna make a comment about lol.
That is exactly what I was saying yes
That’s deep bro
“Easy there Germany. Calm yourself down” 😂😂
That's what actually started World War II
As you wish Germany..... as you wish
I know exactly what i did.....which was nothing
I read this comment as he said it
it ain't funny john marston overrated
Germans:
Arthur: *VAMOS! VAMOS*
Talking spanish to a german
@@user-oi1ni7pj3k ikr
Agustin Rossetti I know it is Spanish but it could Portuguese as well. They are similar
@império Brasilmano Hahahah come on man, It is Spanish, there are very similar or exactly the same words between Spanish and Portuguese, you could say that they are sister languages, but the truth is, do you think that a Brazilian or a Portuguese taught Arthur words? Of course not, these countries are not even mentioned, and Mexicans and Latinos appear many in the game, obviously Arthur would have learned some words from Javier, because once they sang "Cielito lindo" a Mexican song and Arthur sang it in Spanish.
It makes no sense that Arthur speak in Portuguese hahahaha
Não fique com ciúmes porque sua língua não aparece
Bruh
Can we all take a moment to appreciate how kind hearted Charles is 😄
What about sadie
@Jeremiah Pickens She was definitely a member of the gang. She didn't get the Pinkertons attention with her crimes, however, she still provided for the gang and therefore became apart of it. She and Arthur went on several missions together that turned into slaughtering O'Drisscols. She even went with the rest of the gang to attack the oil factory and she helped rob a train. The feds would of most likely went after her if she hadn't left the country after the events of the epilogue. John was the only one in the group that went after Micha that actually stuck around, so Ross went after him.
He's a douche. They just wanted to paint a native in a positive light.
i miss charles and lenny 😭😭
@@occiferfigpucker4840 How exactly is Charles a douche? He wanted to save that German family when Arthur didn't at first, he helped the natives out, he was loyal until he saw how corrupt Dutch became and stuck with Arthur, and he helped John build his house, and go after Micha.
"How many germans are in Mexico."
Allot actually in 1911
@@IanMalcolm-rw5pn nope
nobody recalls anything about Zimmermann Telegram, seriously?
@@IanMalcolm-rw5pn Literal nadie hablo de Argentina
I don't think the are the same person
The Mennonites
It's most likely not him, purely from the time period this occurs in. In 1911, Germans had moved all over the US, centered on the midwest, and spread just about everywhere from there. Mining for precious metals was a very popular profession amongst the immigrants that didn't stay in the midwest and become farmers. Andreas is also a fairly common name for the time period we're talking about, deriving itself from a greek hero, born of a River God. I think this is just an example of coincidence in thought between RDR1s writers and RDR2's.
Andreas is a pretty common name in Germany even now
@@MrTimurLP I agree, I don't think a gold dealer would move to mexico to start dealing in silver. You'd think it would be the other way around.
More silver in the world than gold...
so, if profit is your thing, you might make that switch
@@phredphlintstone6455 that makes no sense.. Gold is worth more than silver, one reason being *because* its not as common
@@damondriver6363 you don't understand it sir
Will they just remake red dead with rdr2's engine already.
That would be... Amazing
You realize how long that would take right...
GraveDigger9383 X yes which is why starting on it soon would be a good idea 😭
Fun fact: I read a news article (which is most likely completely fake) that this person on Reddit has a friend who works for Rockstar. He said that they are making a DLC for Red dead, where it’s a lot like undead nightmare, but with aliens instead. They also said they are planning on remastering Red dead one, but with Rdr2’s engine. Remember, this is most likely fake, but, we should have a bit of hope.
Alpha Aries cool!
I love the guy who says “there must be a name for this” during a Mexican Stand-off in Mexico
Me too! I was looking for someone else that picked up on that 😂
And then he says “an impasse” instead of “a mexican standoff” SMH
This ain’t a Mexican standoff, that’s a duel. Ricketts is right, it’s called an impasse.
@@joshreeves1036 How is it a duel when there are clearly 3 people pointing at each other?
@@SilverWave64 no🤦♂️ a duel is the one on one gunslinger thing, thats a Mexican standoff. An impasse is the multiple people standoff thing🤦♂️
“Easy Germany calm yourself down” lol if only John lived to see the future.
?
200 Subscribers from commenting and no videos John died a few years before WW1 lol.
They should make a red dead in world war one
@@speechculture9691 ??
@@jimbob7072 Red Dead Redemption 3 with Jack as a main character? I mean... That would be awesome.
I love that Charles can just see through Arthur's exterior facade
Arthur: breaths
Mr boss: ok so we are going to solve the mystery of arthur breathing
Not breathing anymore
@@ghostlygraverave3208 no breth, only coghu
@@domcam6650 I have no idea what you just said
I’m honestly surprised there isn’t a title like “Best award in the game”.
Kinda weird comment to put on a video that’s not even like that. There’s actually a pretty decently solid and seemingly well thought through reasons. This honestly is a video I could see someone like fishy or any other RDR lore content creators would make.
The sad thing about his TB is it is so curable today
it was curable by 1921. he missed the cure by about two decades :(
ب
Nobody:
12 year olds when you kill them in Call of Duty: 8:51
Ha
8:55
yes
THE WAY HE SAYS IT THINBHSHSHAGSS
LMAO 😂
Vamos when they speak German 😂
Lol VAMOS
Ah, si, mi palabra favorita del Alemán: Vamos
He dunt knu
Are you surprised? This is the same man that didn’t believe dinosaurs existed 😂
Moin Servus Moin, Deutsch ist eine Tolle Sprache 🇩🇪
I enjoy it when Arthur tries to talk to them by speaking Spanish. That man.
Lmao 😂😂
13:00 While it may seem out of place for a German immigrant to be living in poverty-struck Mexico, this was rather common at the time. Mexico was a destination for many non-Spanish European immigrants in the 19th and early 20th century, particularly from Germany and other Central European countries (especially northern Mexico). Mexico was a heavy immigrant nation, although not to the extent of countries like Canada, America, and Australia. - whoever writes the read dead wiki
It sorta still is only because texas is a little easier to get in then any other state along the u.s but still hard to get in the u.s
Tejano and norteño (genres of Texan-Mexican folk music) have roots in German polka, due to German immigrants who settled in Mexico and Texas during the 1800s and brought their instruments with them.
At the end it’s called red dead wiki not read 📚
@@MarthaRodriguez-mp4uo it's a typo
Another young actor's life destroyed by drugs and alcohol
Dutch Van Der Linde Dutch one more score and we’ll be the richest men of the world
@dutch van der linde I thought you have a plan for this
Just Ahmed HE DOES YOU JUST GOTTA HAVE FAITH!
No I have a plan and it's a good one
@@Danielle_Diaz of course we just have to have faith
Every good deed that Arthur did in his last days were because of Charles. Charles was the only one who saw a good man within Arthur and always tried to bring out his good man side instead of his Outlaw side.
Hosea saw good in him, too, I think. Some of the women, like Mary-Beth, could also tell he's just putting on an act.
9:11 *America talking to Hitler after finding out about their "miracle camps" 1944, Colorized*
and the timestamp is 9 11
Ah yes two German characters gotta be the same guy
There are a few more similarities than just their country of origin. The two most notable are that they share the same name, and they're both Mining Prospectors dealing in precious metals.
Now I'm not saying that I believe these two men are one in the same, but let's not pretend that their ethnicity is the only similarity they share..
You’re totally undermining all the supporting evidence
Are you dumb?
eeeeexxxxxxactly lol, this dude smokes way too much weed and starts coming up with ferry tails
Damian Flores fairy* Are you sure you haven’t been smoking?
Arthur: "How did someone even come up with them (those) words?"
He doesn't yet know that German is actually the closest language to English. He'll have a bad surprise when he meets the Chinese in St Denis! :))))))
English actually came from the west germanics aka Anglo Saxon there language is old english
If you go that far back in history, you are right about German closeness to english👍 But today it's for sure Dutch. The written Dutch is a mix of German, English and Danish. But it wasn't back then, cuz Dutch is a much younger language. I'm Danish and I can't understand much of the spoken Dutch. But because I speak German, English and Danish is my native tongue, I can read Dutch almost perfectly. But you are right about the Anglo/Saxon issue. Though Dutch is of course closest to German. I don't disagree with you, but state how it is today.
Arthur is dumb when it comes to not fighting
What? That doesn't sound logical.
Technically Frisian would be the closest to English (if Scots isn't considered a language) but dutch is the closest major language. I find dutch easier to understand tbh.
6:45 : I belive they're the same Andreas !
11:40 : I think they're not the same !
12:50 : I kinda belive they're the same xd
DIRANT 😂😂😂
Mrboss' videos in a nutshell
Oh dang.
The magic of speculation
Wow
I' am come from Germany and its was very funny to hear my language in the game 😂🇩🇪👍
J. M. ja irgendwie schon 😂
@@feinstesleergut ja habe es gefeiert😂
Calm down Germany! 😀
Guten Abend von texas!!
Lol me here with 3 years of us German learning and 1 year of foreign exchange: ah yes sprechen sie Deutsch!!
Maybe Arthur gave his family tuberculosis and he could not forgive Americans
Riley Rutstein wow I just thought was his twin brother or cousin or something but that's crazzzyyyy
Or maybe they're not even the same person, and Mr full of shit is just pulling information out of his ass again.
@@jamesroper4952 or maybe he is having fun connecting events and is actually talking some interesting stuff.
Ghutts McKenzie No. No. That doesn’t sound like him.
Charles is my favorite character “you may not be as tough and dense as you think” he helped Arthur to be a better person especially after returning Eagle Flies back to his reservation so Rains Fall can see his son the last time
I love how Arthur sais vamos when their language is German 3:17
Or "Come on"
To be fair spanish was a common trade language. Alot of people who didnt speak English like natives or european immigrants learn/know spanish
How come even after I block mrboss, he still shows up in my notifications?
Marshall Leigh Johnson why did you block him? Just curious
Japurdo could just not be his type of CZcamsr, I have a few I don’t like myself that other people adore. Just a matter of perspective
Japurdo probably cuz a lot of his videos are him jumping to crazy conclusions and rambling on so he can hit the 10 minute mark on his videos. This video is an exception however. I don’t think his theory is too crazy in this one.
Marshall Leigh Johnson just don’t click his videos
The CZcams notification system works like this: If you watch a video all the way to the end, CZcams will suggest more videos similar.
To be fair, there is actually a decent number of German-Mexicans, who were either German Immigrants, or of German Immigrants, that settled in Mexico during the late 19th and Early 20th centuries. So, seeing a Mexican with a German name, or a German who became a Mexican citizen, isn't too unbelievable.
I've heard theres pockets in mexico of russians too
Yes, they guest-stared in an episode of "The Rifleman".
Yeah... Some Germans were fighting for the revolution in Mexico with Pancho villa and Zapata
Jeez he straight up treated him “easy there Germany calm yourself down”
"
you ain't that tough and dense" Charles predicting the future in a few words
True XD
I (a german feller) am just so excited every time I hear german in english Video games.
Ich stimme dir zu
The German miner in Mexico is a bit more common than you’d think. Before WWI there was a lot of German immigrants to the south especially Texas which is a state that’s commonly traveled through to get to Mexico. So the possibility of another German by the same name with a similar occupation is far more plausible than them being the same man.
Based off this, they don't call him anything but "Muller" so how is this even a theory?
They have the same first name
@@vladdythebear5872 When do they call muller from the the last one by his first name?
Nugsy Malone In the Red Dead wiki on each character
@@nugsymalone1247 Also when he speaks the subtitles say "Andreas"
That’s not the same man he ain’t a gunslinger
But what if he turns into one lol
Not The Real Jensen Ackles they don’t even look the same
@@Uchiha_Teivan maybe he shave his hair to bald
john martson every returning character from rdr1 to rdr2 looks the same except that guy? I doubt it
So these replies are supposing this guy:
Shaved his hair
Trimmed his moustache
Learned perfect English
Emigrated to Mexico
Lost his entire family
Became a gunslinger
In 12 years. Bullshit.
One thing I didn’t like about RDR2 was the lack of the Wild West feeling RDR gave.
Because they took out cliches from spaghetti westerns or westerns in general. This is a more developed story than:"ight imma kill some guys to see mah family and then be betrayed and die while looking cool and having a cool soundtrack"
It's also because the era of the Wild West is coming to an end at the time the story takes place.
But I can understand you.
Phönixritter Rdr takes place after rdr2
@@masonblom6121 Oops you're right. I misunderstood his comment.
Phönixritter well RDR 1 plays even later in 1911 but it has more that clishe western
10:12 Rest of the World after Germany bombed Poland in 1939 after WW2 started.
Maybe his family got tuberculosis from aurther
Maybe
iHybridz i Arthur did
bruh do you guys play the game? arthur doesn't cough or spit blood yet in chapter 3/2
Jamsquirrel or maybe it was LUMBAGO
But he does when they rescue him in chapter 6
Why couldn’t have Downes given you TB instead of Arthur
LMAO damn that's cold😂😂
Jacob Frye bro no it’s not. The youtubers that do rockstar games are literally the worst and most scum filled pieces of vomit you could EVER find on the int
Jacob Frye it would be great 😂
@@MrWumpa-tn1ib Someone could always slip him an ebola infected letter.
Mr. Wumpa I don’t know if their all bad but yeah.
Jack mataron could live to see the 80s. That’s crazy
Who's Jack mataron
@@rossgam1ng216 john mastens kid
I- It never said his name was Andreas and he doesnt have to same hair color or anything, it also never said he was a miner
His name was Andreas if you read the text when he speaks german, and his family owned a Gold mine. Doesnt mean hes a miner, but means he might run one. However I find it far stretched that Muller is the same one as from RDR2. Doesnt look anything like him.
TheBigTopNinja Look on the Red Dead Wiki pages for both characters. It backs up everything...
@@vladdythebear5872 Well it makes no sense because Andreas would be like 50 - 60 or something in RDR2 and he looks 40
His name is Andreas his wife said it if the read the dialogue
Next episode suggestion: what happens when you eat a can of baked beans instead of kidney beans??????
It just feels good when you hear your own language in a video game from a different country!
Arthur: has TB fit
His horse: 👁👄👁
"There must be a name for this" Mexican standoff but Landon calls it an impasse
I’m glad someone said it! Lmoa
It isn't a mexican standoff. If everyone shot their guns there would be some people walking away. A mexican standoff means that everyone has at least one gun trained on them. This is an impasse
nobody:
Arthur while being pointed at with a double barrel shotgun at point black range: GET THE HELL OUTA HERE!!!
"How did someone even come up with them words" 😂😂😂🤣🤣
Einfach eyse
4:26 love how he helplessly just looks at his horse as if he’s going to help him
"look I'm sorry friend i can barely speak English"
I notice he's by himself in the first game. His personality change could have come from him possibly losing his wife & child. Maybe an American killed them, which would explain his racism. Him & his family were kidnapped once, maybe it happened again, only this time Arthur wasn't there to save them...
Pretty dark, but I'm trying to connect them lolz
I get what you’re saying my friend, but then again how could anyone be racist towards Americans or Mexicans? Anybody could be an American or Mexican
Hey MrBoss i’ve done this and i think u should do it too , When the German family is taking care of arthur on the Cutscene IF u open the map it will show u in a house in AnnesBurg and once i tried to get in the house I think u should give this a try ??
Nima .A I just broke in. Turns out they’re early Nazis
@@ima_psykopathpsn8411 wtf?
BigMacBlackNiggaWeenyPooCancerCockFistingAnuses that’s right. I broke in and they were bowing down to a flag with the Nazi logo on it
@@ima_psykopathpsn8411 ok lol😂😂
Hm, genau, weil alle deutschen Nazis sind du Kek
This guy will somehow do a 10 minute video on what will happen if you shoot a gun
“I’m sorry friend I barely speak English” - Arthur
He never went to schools he learnt from the gang
They speaking German and Arthur says vamos?? Lol classic
" Meiner Familie gehört eine Goldmine " Arthur: 🤑
My grandfather had tuberculosis at 16 years. Almost died, but survived and now I am writing here. yeeey!
“Mortally wounded.”
I’m fairly certain a chronic illness doesn’t occur from being mortally wounded, but ok.
It can flair up when your immune system is weak.
Gang green?
Im pretty sure he meant Eagle flies was mortally wounded..
Well, to be fair, there is a chronic illness that is likely to occur *when* mortally wounded.
It’s called death.
‘’Sorry my friend I barely speak English’’ Arthur is a savage and he also is a mood
Arthur is a mood 🤣
2:35 is incredible 😂
I love the one guy in the background just casually joining the stand-off when not even slightly related to the situation
I have one more reason. We find out his first name in the newspaper from Mexico after Mr. Müller's death. His name is Andreas and that is the same name from the german guy in RDR2.
This video was actually interesting
Gold runner 11 the only mrbossftw video that is actually interesting
I guess hating is easier than facing reality as an incel, apparently
@mediumsocial772 ?
@mediumsocial772 well this one is but most of them are trash
@mediumsocial772 well it is to me
When Arthur says "Vamos" i cant hold my laughter 😂😂😂
We can never forgot that Arthur said vamos to the German family 😂
9 views, 27 likes, 11 comments
@mediumsocial772 Okay, and what do you deserve?
@mediumsocial772 *fangirl
And usually when people evade a question, it's because they're embarrassed by the answer.
Arthur, oh, Arthur.
Arad Cruyff oh god not another one of these
They should bring him back.😥😥😥😥😥no fair.
In spanish its...ehem,Ay arthur... Ay arthur, it doesnt lets me sleep Well :v
It could be a family member from the same family, cousin, brother..whatever, but it ain't the same person
14:04 is still the best spot
Stop hating
King skull your just a hater
No your just an idiot
I mean it is truth so
@@tokeley2581 yeah
Me as a german was so happy to see a german family in rdr2 because i finaly dont need subtitle anymore to understand something
The stress of losing his family could have caused him to lose most of his hair
Also the fact that it was 12 years later and he just naturally went bald
One little thing you miss in red Dead redemption you don't have to kill the German man to win the duel if you shot his gun
I've been doing a lot of research of my own family history and turns out in those years a lot of children where named after their parents and their parents siblings so much to the extent there would be 4 cousins all with the same name and they all tended to stay in the family business so if rockstar was being really accurate he could potentially be a relative of the one from rdr. Or they just like the same names and had no clue on the subject 😂
I love how one of the guys playing card looks confused and doesn't know who to aim his gun at
YOU GOT CALLED OU BY NED LUKE MICHAELS VOICE ACTOR
I know I’m responding late but yeah even if rockstar post a comment in one of his video he would continue
@@Gabriel-nd6bv i wouldnt give a shit if he did
Mortally wounded means you suffer a wound that kills you...
I like Charles with his calmness even when he is fighting he is calm and deadly which in away really makes sense because if your calm your less likely to make mistakes. Also I actually didn’t think of that theory of the German man who Arthur saves is in Red Dead 1 but it makes sense and he could’ve accidentally given his family TB which ended up making the father a bitter and angry man
#3:20 It was him whose act made Arthur realize that there is a reward in being good as well and the start of his Good ARC. Nice touch guys, nice neat touch.
14:04 is the best spot
@John Kelly, Thank u so much. That really help me out🤣😂. (That vid, was horrible)
Thks so much
That was just the part I was lookin for
No bother bros, knew you’d need some help😇
Ohhh nooo. I had no idea i was watching MrBossForTheWin well, best be off!
His mustach is dark brown in this and grey on rdr2
He's like 40ish in RDR2 and 50ish in 1.
That alone kinda disproves this 😂
I feel Andreas Muller isn't the German, but his son, since it is quite a lot of time later. Like you said a lot of time could pass. He takes up his fathers company after an inheritance, gambles the money away and meets his fate at the hands of Marston. Is there anything that goes against this theory?
Not alot of time really.
RDR1 is set 11 years after RDR2 Prologue. RDR2 is set in 1899 whilst RDR1 is 1911.
Andreas looks older than he was in RDR2. Looking about in his early 40s.
Maybe gold ran out and so he moved to Mexico and tried to mine silver after losin his family circa 1899 or 1900
The Gold Rush did end in 1899
>They're in Mexico
>Mexican standoff
"There must be a name for this." "An impasse sir. An impasse." I loled.
tens of thousands of Germans moved to Mexico in the early 1900s
You popped tf out of Germany...whoops that...slipped my tongue.
I dont think he is the same in rdr2 he have dark blond/brown hair, and in rdr1 he have black hair
"How did someone even come up with them words?" i ask myself that everyday in school so much writing my hand is falling off so many rules if you want to write one word
Isso man
10:10 - 10:24
That's called foreshadowing!
Hahahahaha Germany wanted to be allies with Mexico in ww2 🤣🤣🤣
@@I-Holy.Knight-I Exactly. But originally in WW1 as well.
Jaqueer? Don't you wanna harass us? Oh shit, you already did...
and they just throw the man in the middle of the town 😂
Lol
Funny as hell when Ricketts says "there must be a name for this?" classic Mexican standoff.
I just want a remastered Red Dead Redemption, they literally have 90 percent of the new map. But alas I do not see that happening.
Exactly!
The code for red dead redemption 1 is too cluttered and too much of a mess for them to even do, sure it may be possible to just change the textures, shadows, graphics.. but the game is probably so outdated and cluttered that it probably wouldn’t be able to handle a remaster, unless of course they start from scratch, but keep the level, voice acting and animations, but completely redo everything else.
@@Noname-bo3xm if a company like saga can remake yakuza 1 and 2 ps2 games then rockstar can just as remake rdr1 a ps3 and xbox 360 game and don't use the fact well the yauza 1 took place in one city and yakuza 2 took place in just 2 cities .......... in rdr1 towns are are small all the town put together are most likely just s big the yakuza 1 city even if they brought the rdr2 towns in to a rdr1 remake they would most be a little bigger than the are the first city in yakuza 1
@@Noname-bo3xm yeah realize its not gonna happen just a shame maybe rockstar will star some remasters next gen /shrug
That‘s funny, that Andreas was born in Nürnberg. Me too! I live next to Nürnberg!
Hey Mr. boss this is so weird when ever I was at armadillo I was looking for my Horse and whenever I was looking around for it I passed by this wrapped up person well it looks like a little room it looks like something like it was all wrapped in white and I can’t send you a picture because I but you can find it somewhere in armadillo it’s real creepy like real creepy I saw this like it’s wrapped up in like something white and I don’t know what it is anyways you can look at for yourself
Dead body, most likely
This rdr2 makes alot sense when I play rdr1 because the story how it goes
This video could have been literally less than five min. Oh wait, then you won't reach your 10 min mark huh.
And?
@@mestopheles369 My statement ended there. Try again next time.
@@edwardsbaron3935 because you have nothing. Hahaha
@@edwardsbaron3935 I am. But thanks for deflecting. Hahaha
@@mestopheles369 Yep. Definitely not ok.
I actually don’t think it’s the same guy, there were so many Germans that went to America ( which makes ww1 even more tragic, since they were basically killing their own kind a some sort of way. )
Also his face is very different except for the mustache.
"Saved Arthurs Life" Arthurs dead thats the joke lol
It was a time paradox, since Arthur was not in Rdr he was not there to save the mans family or him from the kidnappers, and his family died in Rdr and he was bitter at Americans for killing his family