World of Kaiserreich - Commune of France
VloĆŸit
- Äas pĆidĂĄn 22. 07. 2022
- đ Design & Print Your Own Custom Flag: flagmaker-print.comâ | đ Alt-History Merch: kaisercatcinema.com/ â | đŹ Discord: / discord | đ„ Patreon: / kaisercatcinema
--------
[WORLD OF KAISERREICH: COMMUNE OF FRANCE]
Some say the Revolution began in Paris. In truth, it was born in the trenches. Louise Lacroix details the origins of the Syndicalist Revolution born from French Defeat in the Great War. A scathing rebuttal of the propaganda of Denis and his Republican allies. But history is written by the victor, and for the people of France, the truth is yet to be decided.
--------
What if Germany had won World War 1?
The World of Kaiserreich is an animated video series explaining the lore of the Hearts of Iron mod Kaiserreich. In the alt-history timeline of Kaiserreich, a German victory in WW1 changes the world as we know it.
--------
Script: RnK, Vincent De Nil
Illustration: Hussartcore
Voice-Over: Emily Serdahl
Animation & Editing: Vincent De Nil
Special thanks to the France Rework team at Kaiserreich for their help with the video - Hry
On the surface, one is one of the Commune's top international agents, while the other a captain of one of Republican Franceâs premier special operations teams. But if you look a little deeper, if you focus on the details, you'll see them for who they are; a man trying to bring back a world long gone, one where his wife and son was still with him, where his country, his republic remained strong; and a woman seeking to bring about a new world never before seen, one where a husband's love is enough to keep him faithful, where love can keep a family together.
We aren't so different after all...
@@kaisercatcinema Hi Kaisercat. I've been studying this timeline for over 2 years now. Can you make a video on the world in the present day in a documentary form detailing the battles of this alternate ww2? If you were to ask me what the outcome of that would be, it would have to be this: Internationale victory ONLY if The Combined Syndicates of America wins the civil war and sends its troops to France to help the syndicalist war effort and also offers a lend-lease equivalent to fascist Russia in their effort to "liberate" eastern Europe from the German empire. That seems likely as the Combined Syndicates seem to be the most likely faction to win the civil war and destroy German and Canadian reinforcements. Also, who has blitzkrieg ITTL? Is it Germany, France, or Russia? I would really like to know your answer!
Sincerely,
Ken
@@kencook8819 Also the American Union State can join the Reichspakt.
@@thorpeaaron1110 They can, but they would be crushed by the syndicalists before they can do that. Operation Dagger, the syndicalist operation to cut the union state in half began on April 4, 1937 by the Combined Syndicates, supported by British and French International forces and backed up by black uprisings within the deep south chopped the country in half in less than 8 weeks. Syndicalist shock troops made contact with black partisans to further help their cause. German forces actually played an important role in the defense of Atlanta, which began on June 13, 1937 and of course, ended with a syndicalist victory. The Germans inflicted heavy losses on the advancing syndicalists, but they were eventually outflanked and encircled. They surrendered on August 8, 1937. That culminating with the assasination of Huey Long by syndicalist special forces lead to the rapid collapse of the American Union State.
@@kaisercatcinema Yeah, and then we collect money for Ukrainian tankers and say what brave they are - they kill ... Evil Ivan? In general, yes, in your... And stop, our world - kaiserreich, We can be evil by nature, lovers of incomplete fascism, but in reality, into children who are just as susceptible to propaganda. Russians are evil, Ukrainians are good. Azov is apparently also good.
I do not understand you, maybe according to yours I, a Russian from the border with Ukraine, would have died from their bomb than their soldiers in a war with ours. Well, it's just that I'm the son of a despotic country, not that he's white and good Ukrainian.
With this position, you should not make the world of the game, but posters with a call to cut Russian Untermensches. Thank you for taking sides, guys like us who wish me dead.
The best/worst part is, this probably isn't the most broken marriage in France.
Yah. Even today there are more dysfunctional one
This marriage is pretty mild compared to others in France .
That sentence could've been worded better.
If this were the least dysfunctional marriage in France, then France would be in trouble.
Tu sais pas Ă quelle point
*"I will be marching home..."*
*"And I will be awaiting you..."*
*-Dennis & Louise*
Father: Republican French.
Mother: Syndie
Son: Bonapartist?
Daughter: HOHENZOLLERNIST!?
Totalitarianism, if on mainland and Bonapartism, if on African territory.
It will make their parents mourn for the corruption of the ideals they held dear, and the fall of the nation they loved.
The daughter would probably be neutral
@duckynado not inherently. Though in the setting, the Syndicateâs in America are Totalists
@duckynado Totalitarianism is what we know as Socialist dictatorship. Like Stalinism and Maoism. Syndicalism is a more democratic form of Socialist ideology in which the Collective of the Worker's Union governs the state.
@@jefferyhanderson7849 thanks. I was thinking that I should have given an actual response so thanks for doing for me.
*There better be an event chain for this relationship in the mod.*
Me furiously conquering Germany and nuking Berlin
Event"They are Finally together"
Me:awww that is sooo sweet
French Republic: We revolted because the high class stopped caring about our well being.
French Syndies: Two can play at that game.
Also Republicans: What?! No! Traitor!
wait i dont get it
@@ericdillingham6858 ah thanks
@@opaque_totc9275 1871
@@londegel Most likely 1789
Plot twist: The kid grows up to be a monarchist...and proclaims THEMSELF monarch.
all hail King/Queen of the People, Mon-Syn i guess?
Pahlavi moment
Sounds about right for france
So a Napoleon 2.0?
"While my Mama and Papa babble with their so called ideals...of a Republic and a Commune...I look forward to a Greater France!
The Republic was weak as for those filthy Revolutionaries do not know what a true Revolution is but I will show them...
What was once France will be taken back
France will become greater and stronger, i say I am Claude Bonaparte I am Emperor!"
You know that the writing for the story is impeccable when the story not only tells both sides of the story but actually makes both of these sides understandable to support. It makes both their causes reasonable. It becomes difficult to discern who is more virtuous than the other, who is lying and who is honest, and doesnât play with the standard dynamic of good guy vs bad guy. Instead, it leaves it up to the audience to make that decision, truly a rare form of writing in a world dominated by simplistic, low-IQ writing standards.
@Bukali Kat Gaming Based MacArthur bashing.
Imagine hearing one character literally echo a fascist talking point (stab in the back myth) and thinking "OMG MORALLY GRAY! BOTH SIDES".
It's not even a competition. One narrative presents looking towards the future with hope. The other represents looking backwards with vengeance. Not to mention the fact that National France is an apartheid rogue state ruled by military junta.
Idk how I feel about them making Denis a drunkard and adulterer. That feels like a huge dumbing down of a character who must have been shaped by immense suffering, and feels like a cop-out to justify her decision
@@MrRrusiii Yeah. Him already being a reactionary shithead should have been enough reason.
@Bukali Kat Gaming there are still obvious bad guys in Kaiserreich such as the National Populists and the Totalists.
I really hope Kaiser cat does something with a exile Denis and a syndie Louise storyline. I feel the national France and commune videos have set up a twisted, heartbreaking and repressed love story that I weirdly want to see more of. It's made my current national France playthough all the more enjoyable. Time to return home......
For Denis!
I would love that while they fight they fail to see how this effected their son. And we get a scene were this reaches a climax where they both have a pistol to each and we go off screen seeing the Bloody banners of the syndicate and exiles while two shots ringing out before we cut back to see their son with a pistol having shot them both. We then see a cinematic of his childhood seems a happy child became a bitter man who rejects both his parents and their ideologies for his own.
Why is nobody talking about how the voice actress did a fantastic job
Emily Serdahl did an incredible job here! She also appears in various roles in The Divided States
Damn this video show not only how the revolution of France blossom like an plant on an spring heat, but also saw how the relationship between two lovers withered like dying plants left to die on heat.
Be positive man, once either of them fights all the way to the other's turf, they'd have a proper hatefuck.
@@Schinshikss Oh my...
I think whe' they will finish the season 1 of the divided state it will be they're project bcs it seems logic
Great to see the two sides of the story between Louisa the Ardent French Syndicalist and Denis the loyalist to the Republic.
This gives a whole new aspect to Kaiserreich,a human one so unlike that of Russia and the Fengtien Clique.
Just shows the quality of the KR team and how they improve.
Break the Chains!
The way this is narrated sounds like we are a neutral character, whoâs only trying to understand the world around them
With red chains instead? No! Long live the republic and bring back the old glory of the republic! One more round!
@@fivesormeem3219 Ah yes the red chains of⊠*checks notes* workplace democracy. How terrifying. Iâm sure the French workers are just begging to lick their old bossesâ boots.
@@fivesormeem3219 You'll never kill Hope, and Hope will always be on our side.
La Commune refleurira !
I'm just watching this from New England enjoying my popcorn and the fireworks you Frenchies spark off by fighting each other. It's absolutely hilarious, I tell you.
Ya, I am calling it.
The kid is secrete Catholic monarchist.
Le Roi a fait la France! Le Roi l'a sauvée !
Long Live Christ The King!
Based
@@crusader2112 Christus ist Iudeaum
@@iaminpain58 Mom: For the Commune!
Dad: For the Republic!
Son: Fools... absolute fools you are. France is the eldest daughter of the Church and both your "precious" Republic and Commune have destroyed it! You may laugh at me now, but you'll never laugh at me ever again when I claim my birthright and your godless ideologies get burned to the ground. Us true Frenchmen will never forget what the Republic did to the Vendee and what the Commune is currently to priests, bishops, nuns, etc. For God, King, and most importantly France!
âïžđżâïžđ«đ·
âUn jour je serai de retour prĂšs de toi,â
- Disco Elysium
"One day I will return to your side"
"I need to go to the children, Kim. Girl Child Communism. Boy Child Freedom."
This is so stereotypical of France where the revolution has two former lovers separated by beliefs and how they have a complicated relationship with each other
The voice is so believable for this video. Amazing voice acting by Emily Serdahl.
This is fantastic, it's wonderful hearing both sides of the story. Keep up the phenomenal work Kaiser Cat Cinema and to the voice actors, actresses and Kaiserreich crew I thank you from the bottom of my heart for bringing life in to the world of Kaiserreich, this has to be one of my favourite alternate history scenarios. Good luck with the Kaiserreich lore book and take care everyone, sincerely a fan from Australian.
Now I have questions why did those two marry each other in the first place.
If they loved each other, all that is left is yearning and hollow laughs.
Same I wanna know the back story of these two .
Same. And Iâm mostly interested in the stuff in kaiserreichâs us due to my nationality but the story about denis and his wife and child has me intrested. I want to know more
A lot of people at the time married extremely young and people's political views changed as they grew up
That voice is one of the most enticing, determined voices I've ever heard! Amazing!
it is funny that at the beginning of the game the French commune starts off as a democracy [and stays that way unless you go down the jacobite ,totalist, rout] but the French exile state is a rump military dictatorship
so if you think about it the French commune lives up more the the ideals of the first French republic than the actual French republic dose [at the start of the KR game at least]
Hush, you're hurting the tiny brains of the Entente stans who think the exiles would somehow maintain 'democratic' credibility in the atmosphere of revanchism, militarism, reactionary class hatred, and collaboration with the Kaiser.
Thats cause Totalism is an inaccurate and stereotypical broad representation of Marxism-Leninism
@@camaradecarter Totalism isn't Marxism-Leninism. It's Red Fascism. It is explicitly red fascism.
@@TheAngryXenite facism and communism are total opposites
@@thatrandomguyontheinternet2477 They're not, though. They're different in key ways, but saying they're complete opposites is horsecrap that they spew because neither one wants to admit they share uncomfortable similarities with the other. They're both collectivist ideologies that dismiss the value of the individual, instead valuing the will of the greater whole of the people/favored class of people and encouraging unity of purpose and a sense of shared sacrifice. They are both authoritarian ideologies which emphasize strong leadership to "guide" the people to meaningful goals and to ensure that wrongthink (read: any sort of political opposition) cannot infiltrate society. They are both populist ideologies, which rally the people against the traditional elites in favor of bringing the government closer to the interests of the "real" (insert nationality here, or Proletarian/Worker). And they are both Revolutionary, emphasizing mass politics and the cult of violence and energy in dealing with societal ills. While this is more obvious in Communism, fascism is itself a curious type of revolutionary "reaction," seeking to "recreate" a supposed golden age thay never actually existed through incredibly modern tactics and ideals.
Make no mistake, the two share a great deal of DNA, which makes sense considering fascism was developed by former socialists and national syndicalists (specifically the Sorelians. You know, those guys in the Commune of France?) who believed that nationalism was not antithetical to their struggle and that it should dominate discourse instead of class divisions. Fascismo was a reaction to socialism that patterned itself after its enemies in order to better fight them (by stealing their support base).
All of your videos are amazing but this might just be the best one yet. Ms. Serdahl was able to put so much raw emotion into every line it simply leaves me floored every time I listen to it.
Agreed
They have a child? He/She must be in their early Adulthood. They are the generation that will go through the whirlwind of change once more. I wonder if they will march the Streets of Paris wearing the Totalitarian Armband. It will be dramatic as it is radical.
I know I was shocked
Better than having some deranged womanizer drunkard of a father
Or if theyâll find their father and switch sides
Maybe theyâll switch sides enjoying their father or perhaps there will be some I am your father moment no
That is assuming whether or not she tells the child who their father is
Itâs the ex-wife of the narrator of National France
Most likely
@@sergentsnugglemuffin1543 I still side with the husband, mostly out of camaraderie as a veteran of Battlefield 1âs Verdun Heights, Fort Vaux, Nivelle Nights, Prise De Tahure, Soisson, and Rupture
@@DraftTheHippies I donât, the Great War is an example of the failure of the Republicans and Monarchs. But even my idealism makes me think the Syndicalists would bite each other one day, I just donât want another war.
@@DraftTheHippies The husband is based
@@thorpeaaron1110 Ofc he would be, you have a pinochet pfp
Finally! I was legit surprised that this work for the French factions was not done earlier, especially for the French commune, since it is one of the if not the most important player in the KR, being the in game equivalent of the USSR in OTL
But anyway
BRISONS LES CHAĂNES CAMARADES
A BAS LES RĂGIMES RĂACTIONNAIRES
CAMARADES DU MONDE, UNISSONS NOUS
LE SYNDICALISME SERA LE GENRE HUMAIN
DOWN WITH THE COMMUNARDS VIVE LA REPUBLIQUE!
@@thorpeaaron1110 This dude's preaching some truth over here
â@@i_willstealurloot273 Ikr facts
Bruh, la Commune est bien moins dictatoriale que l'URSS, c'est pour ça qu'elle est mieux !
Stunning as always
This was baddass! Thanks
Powerful and awesome stuff
Does that mean weâre getting a Sardinia video next?
Beautiful
Funny how only the syndicalist factions have perspectives from women as well as men đ€
Because french empire dont have women in the military
@@novalalwan8036 nah, it's because leftism is about freedom and equallity for all, so for the women to be free, they must take the weapons as well and protect their rights from mens who want to subdue women
I mean, considering the divided states' current events, do they really?
@@essexclass8168 I would say so. Because we can see that they have women within the lower ranks of the military as well as the higher ranks of secret police as well as in the anarco-syndicates opposition
@@robertoleary5470 at least with ep 1 they're shown as more or less drones though
I wish this kaiserreich series wouldnât end
Oh yeah vive le Francais vive le Revolution
This is the least disfunctional marriage in France
Holy shit I just realised y'all made the french Revolution into what Lenin had hoped the October revolution would be
Great video
I think that's the greatest thing you can say to a reactionary, "My chains are broken, what about yours?"
i love Kaiserreich lore but i would love more south america content even if they only mention it xd
Have they done Mexico yet?
Southeast Asia is going to be ignored, again, you know it is messed up when your country does not even have a focus tree not only in the base game but in most mods as well, can someone please make a fucking focus tree for the Philippines for once? Not a focus tree for a terrible mountain nation that will barely do anything of value in-game, Bhutan gets a focus, the Philippines who is literally in the center of the Kaiserreich, the Japanese empire, and with Syndicalists elements surrounding the country inside and out doesn't get a focus tree, amazing, oh and by the way one of us Filipinos did make a focus tree but the development was stopped, because they promised that they themselves will make one instead, well a few years has passed, where the hell is our focus tree? If they can't get us one, then they should've let us do it instead.
Good stuff
Can you guys make a WoK about the Ottoman Empire?
Ya esperaba esto, estĂĄ historia de los ex esposos en las 2 Francias me encantĂł.
No tienes nada que perder, ademĂĄs de tus cadenas
Wonderful
I wanna see Kaiser Cat continue the saga of divided families, if the italies aren't 3 brothers divided into serving the socialists, the republic, and the kingdom of sicily I will cry
Nah 5 brothers a Sardinian royalist, a catholic priest, a Sicilian, a Republican and socialist
@@Planeman516 yes, fr.
Then they get slammed in every game they play. The German AI soloed them after Mittelafrika collapsed, the duchy collapsed, most of their easter allies abandoned them and they lost singapur too.
yeah
Somehow the german AI ends france much quicker than i do ( I do full Blitzkrieg)
2:51, when Michael scofield join commune
The sassss at the end.... ^^
i love the part when a tank has a bleu heart patch drawn on the side of the tank.
Hopefully they do the ottoman empire or Egypt next
Break the Chains!!!
Dirty Syndie
@@thorpeaaron1110 Thank you đ
@@robertoleary5470 Your most welcome
Break the chains!!!
"Sorry sweet siren.... But I'm with Dennis.... Your honeyed sweet words are nothing but poison...."
This enchantress is spewing nothing but Syndie lies
Interesting situation:
In French republic Husband say, what his wife left him join to syndicaltsts.
Maybe now we are hearing a story from the outside wife?
A video about ottomans would be nice
The betrayal is avenged about every other game.
Screaming rn waiting until we see the united video
If his wife looks like this after a child, Dennis is surely an idiot to have left. And she sounds nice, standard french resentfulness towards him
She left him Don't believe her lies .
@@thorpeaaron1110 shut up! Revolution is the new era!
She literally ditched him though, when he returned home from the fighting she was gone to fight a revolution instead, so that would've sucked, imagine fighting for years in the trecnhes losing every comrade in arms by the day so you can build a future for your family then this happens when all seemed to be lost.
â@@quirinoguy8665Especially after you lost said war .
niceeeee
Men,this thing become the best love story ever heard.
can you guys add senerios to the game ruels so it can lead to a syndicate german russian or entent victory....by just selecting that choice in the game rules...I hope you get my idea well
I enjoy how itâs less about the politics and more about the story of people and their struggles
Debout! Les damnés de la Terre.
Vive la France et vive l'nternational!
Bjr c 1870 qui t'appelle et te demande de revenir
@@lo_qc Non, c'est 2070 qui lui dit de l'attendre.
Vive la France, Camarades!!!
Viva LA Republique! Down with the Syndicalist rabble !
@@thorpeaaron1110 -Says the reactionary as heâs hanged by a native Algerian mob
To arms comrades! The Internationale unites the human race!
The syndicates will defeat Germany, but they will lose the Cold War to Russia.
L'Internationale sera le genre hunain!
*(Loading Mauser)*
"Shame."
Vive la république! Mort à la menace syndicaliste!
@@mr.tobacco1708 FĂŒr den Kaiser!
"Republican" ideals represented by a Royalist lilly flower.... not very Robespierre of you, Denis
He's still based
I love this woman so much!
Vive la commune !
if my grand father was here. I would say -" down with the syndis up with national republic"
Epic
5:40
Everything is much more complicated than the usual "resistance to evil invaders".
But let's not talk about sad things! It is better to say about the good, namely about the development of the Kaiserreich. The development of Kaiserreich pleases, and in such plot videos there is an incredible atmosphere, an atmosphere that makes the world of Kaiserreich alive, only there is one minus, namely my concern about one fact. I am only concerned about the update of Russia, because the news about the update of Russia and the story clips were released more than a year ago, and there is still no update, which is extremely sad.
2:52
Why Max Verstappen fighting for the Syndies?
How did I know they had a child?
sigo esta saga hace tiempo, deberĂan hacer un libro o un comic parecido a la saga leviathan de scott westerfeld.
Unfortunately, I don't know Spanish, but I absolutely agree that anything similar to Leviathan would be amazing here.
@@beatthegreat7020 claro, saludos a todos los anglo-parlantes
Don't get what Denis' problem is tbh, I'd betray my country for a redhead syndicalist waifu boss bitch.
She should have stayed with him
I'd betray a lot more than just my country for that.
â@@beatthegreat7020 Beta
She was the one who left him
@@jwil4286 Last I checked, she stayed in France while he left for Algiers.
Maybe one about the ottomans?
VIVE LA FRANCE! VIVE LA COMMUNE!
edit: grammar
Sorry but its Vive la France and Vive la Commune
@@camaradecarter no thatâs fine, thanks for the correction.
@@camaradecarter DOWN WITH THE COMMUNE ! UP WITH THE FRENCH REPUBLIC!
Glad I didn't listen to my dad and stayed up
Vive la Revolucion
Viva LA Republique!
I find it rather ironic that she says that the revolution started in the trenches while the army held the German advance, and the revolutionaries in Paris joined in solidarity.
Can't help but wonder what if instead of making the revolution, they had sent one last round of reinforcements and ammunition.
Anyway, blindfold or no blindfold, Syndie?
Think itâs clear that there was no stopping the Germans by 1919, and I think the army revolted first (if I remember correctly).
@@dantecaputo2629 Yeah they refused the order to go overtop again.
No blindfold. I want to see my comrades bringing you down.
*shootout commences*
She addresses this in the video though, doing that wouldn't help the common people of France in any way, it would only serve the interests of the elite, so in their view there was no point.
If they âwinâ, what then? Theyâd still be left with a Bougie government which sent most of them to die to protect their interests in the first place. Nationalism is hollow when it doesnât serve the people who comprise the nation in the first place.
Anyway, how deep do you want the pit to be, reactionary?
Cool story, still a Syndie though
So this woman is Louise?
Ehem.
We need a video about the Indochinese Union. Or at least the German East Asia.
They will never make it, they don't care, they haven't made a fucking focus tree for the Philippines even now, it's about to be 2024, FUCKING 2024, and Bhutan gets a focus tree but the Philippines doesn't?
in kr mod the comune of France invented blitzkrieg...la guerre Ă©clair....
Funnily, an Ăclair is actually a sweet baked treat with chocolate on top and cream in the middle
@@kaisercatcinema
Even funnier,
Charles DeGaulle wrote a book before the war (1934) called "Vers l'armée de métier", where he wrote many ideas that will inspire the Blitzkrieg.
B R E A K T H E C H A I N S
Die Syndie
Common woman W, sheâs chosen the correct way
All I wanna see is the Italian States ;-;
Nah this is just a normal day in france
Vive la Commune
down with the Commune
Vive La France! Vive La Commune!
3:11 I thought Spain and Portugal were kingdoms.
While a kingdom, Spain has a very large anarcho-syndicalist movement that rises up in the civil war. Portugal is a reactionary absolute monarchy, but they canât change ideologies naturally.
@@tuccerjim3084 ok
@@tuccerjim3084 it happen in irl ALSO bc syndicalism is also real
When will you release the kids pov as he fights in the name of action francaise? Vive le ROI
Vive la révolution! Break the chains!
*VIVĂ LA FRANCE*
Vive *
Vive LA Republique Vive Petain!
@@thorpeaaron1110 ya un truc qui va pas dans t'as phrase đŹ
@@lo_qc Yes because French is not my first language
@@thorpeaaron1110 non non t as bien écrit juste le "vive petain" avec a cÎté de vive la république
C'est comment dire bizarre
I believe that sheâs lying. Both are obviously.
We'll never know what truly happened but from we can tell their relationship wasn't the best .
@@thorpeaaron1110 she is actually telling almost all of the truth, compared to her husband. The video explainning the Comune of France proves this.
â@@Palpad100 She's probably lying about their relationship.
This video made me feel one thing...to be Denis and now I'm going back to France and the conversation is not going to be good for her...
DOWN WITH THE SYNDIES!!!!
Eh the Syndies can keep France so long as the Canadians can RECLAIM THE BIRTHRIGHT
Good luck launching a naval invasion from Iceland lol
@@BifronsCandle It works tho
Nice based af
I have a question. Why did you remove the possibility of bypassing the American Civil War? How could you, you should restore this option.
They aren't the mod developers but the answer to your question is no the Second American Civil War is pretty much unavoidable in Kaiserreich.
that was a very nice speech red frenchie. but just remember that your state is basically western Germany extended.
vur gott kiaser und vaterland! lang lebe das reich und kaiser.
okay jokes aside... very well done KCC, this was along long time coming. and you did not disappoint. The red head nearly made me syndie...
FUR den Kaiser
Down with the Syndies. Up with the Republic! Support the Exile, support the Entente!
The microphone is really awful, the rest is good
"My chains are broken, what about yours?"
Totalists proceed to come to power like every time these intellectuals create their workers paradise and a strongman takes it out from under them
Meanwhile dudes rocking in Algiers. Dennis realizes he just wants some twink in the army who would never betray him or France, forgets about traitor wife and kid, if the retaking France thing doesn't work out, he and bf start a mercenary outfit
Yes, because France is in the exact same situation as Russia or China was. Material conditions? What are those?
Meanwhile, National France is a democratic paradise lol
@@BifronsCandle >because France is in the exact same situation as Russia or China was
war
invasion
annexation & forced germanization of Alsace Lorraine
>material conditions? what are those?
The preferable outcome of wars of Imperial competition are the defeat of growing upstart Empires, which would maintain the rate of parallel development in subject colonies, leading to sooner decolonization and a greater likelihood of peaceful transitions
if steady progress of material conditions is the best outcome, not to mention post war social progress, u want an entente victory.
also if patriotism is fine and good for Russia and China , then why dismiss French patriotism ???
National France is not a democratic paradise, but it is the French Third Republic. a functioning democracy relies on the strength of legitimate institutions. the only legitimate institution in the commune is the army, and it is an army that mutinied against the previous state authority
@@MrRrusiii
_war
invasion
annexation & forced germanization of Alsace Lorraine_
Cool story. Still not nearly the same situation the Soviet Union found itself in. The Civil War decimated what little of the industrial working class it had, damaged the meager concentrations of industry in cities, brought about famines, and led to an intervention force of no less than 13 nations. On top of that, many nations outright refused to recognize and deal with the Soviets until the Great Depression. It ended up in the Soviets being a hollowed-out pariah state which needed to industrialize yesterday to stave off invasion, as shown by 1941.
By contrast, France was already a developed country with an established proletariat (and proletarian institutions) which experienced a far less severe civil war with the Germans deliberately deciding against intervening. Also, they're redoing the war so that Alsace-Lorraine isn't the cause.
_The preferable outcome of wars of Imperial competition are the defeat of growing upstart Empires, which would maintain the rate of parallel development in subject colonies, leading to sooner decolonization and a greater likelihood of peaceful transitions_
Contrary to history. Britain and France didn't decolonize out of their own volition. They decolonized because both world wars had damaged their empires in a variety of ways, had stirred the pot for independence movements (ie the Bengal Famine in India) and led to the ascendance of two main powers, both of which (through different means) would put pressure them until maintaining their colonies wasn't worth the trouble.
_if steady progress of material conditions is the best outcome, not to mention post war social progress, u want an entente victory._
No. As we've seen, extractive colonies aren't developed for anything other than extractive enterprise. It was only when the cold war's threat of communism forced the West to actual foster developmentalism that this would change, and then receded predictably once the Soviets declined in power. As we've seen from the neocolonization of Africa today, the West has no interest in developing nations aside from profit. Turning them into self-sufficient countries which could assert themselves runs contrary to that. In fact, placing them under IMF austerity and ruining their local industries is the opposite. At best, you'd get a worse version of today's world, with some colonies still being colonies.
By contrast, the Third International expressly emphasizes developmentalism, both for ideological reasons and to develop a power base for the international socialist movement. By far, a Third International victory would be preferable for the former colonies than the likes of Petain or Goering.
_also if patriotism is fine and good for Russia and China , then why dismiss French patriotism ???_
The hell does that have to do with what I said?
_National France is not a democratic paradise, but it is the French Third Republic. a functioning democracy relies on the strength of legitimate institutions. the only legitimate institution in the commune is the army, and it is an army that mutinied against the previous state authority_
National France is a literal military junta relying on the brute force of the "legitimacy" of a government which brought about its own ruin, leading over an oppressed population which isn't even majority French nor desires to be. Fat lot of good those "institutions" would do. Also, the part about a "functioning democracy" relying on legitimacy is as far from the truth as you can get. It ignores that the first liberal revolutions (French First Republic) certainly lacked any sort of legitimacy of the old regimes to begin with, but had seized or developed their own.
Likewise, the worker soviets in the Russian Empire came to be seen as more legitimate than the old Empire and later Provisional Government, which is where the Bolsheviks derived their power from. In Kaiserreich, for France, it was the trade union federations and soldier groups which led the charge. They supplanted the old with the new.
@@MrRrusiii Denis probably has an Algerian mistress already
do one about Brazil
Everything is good, but the voice acting is a mess. It would have been better if the voice actor lowered her voice a bit.