Exclusive: Metro Exodus Enhanced Edition Analysis - The First Triple-A Game Built Around Ray Tracing
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 06. 2024
- The first triple-A PC game that will only run on ray tracing equipped PCs (and next-gen consoles to come), Metro Exodus Enhanced Edition is a phenomenal improvement over the 2019 original release. In this extended video, Alex Battaglia reveals the new RT effects, shows off the benefits for developers, checks out DLSS, VRS and TAA upscaling and analyses performance on both AMD and Nvidia hardware.
00:00:00 Introduction
00:02:13 New Feature Analysis: Global Illumination from All Lights
00:11:02 New Feature Analysis: Ray Traced Emissive Lights
00:16:50 New Feature Analysis: Unlimited Light Bounces
00:20:30 New Feature Analysis: Ray Traced Reflections
00:22:56 Exclusive Behind the Scenes: Developer Tools and Process
00:27:40 Ray Tracing Trade-Offs
00:29:40 PC Performance: New Ray Tracing Options (Ryzen 5 3600/RTX 2060)
00:31:45 PC Performance: Metro Exodus 2019 vs Enhanced Edition 2021 (Ryzen 5 3600/RTX 2060)
00:33:10 New Feature Analysis: Variable Rate Shading, DLSS 2.1, Temporal Upsampling
00:36:25 Alex's Optimised Settings
00:37:26 AMD Radeon RX 6800 XT vs Nvidia GeForce RTX 3080
00:39:03 Conclusion
Join the DF Patreon to support the team more directly and to get access to everything we do via pristine quality downloads: bit.ly/3jEGjvx
Subscribe for more Digital Foundry: bit.ly/DFSubscribe
Want some DF-branded tee-shirts, mugs, hoodies or pullovers? Check out our store: bit.ly/2BqRTt0 - Hry
16:11 compared to 16:13 is quite a huge difference. Almost like going from low to high graphics settings. Impressive stuff, too bad I won't get an RTX capable card until the actual time Metro takes place in.
LMAO :D
GeForce now if that's work for you is the way.
@@pacooman96 not supported with this, only the old version
@@Bounty2223 they officialy said on steam for mac/linux user. The only way to play the game will be on GeForce now. Check it by yourself
good thing I saved 4 bullets for that rtx 5070
*2019* "Lets release the most graphically detailed video game to date*
*2021* "We felt we could do better, so heres a graphic upgrade on the most graphically advanced game ever made"
Metro devs have reached mid to late 90's id software levels of graphics improvements over time.
They didn't have to do it, yet they did it and it's free
@@neraklh1017 pretty awesome if you ask me
Best part is the graphics aren't even the best part of the game. The gameplay and story are both better aspects of it
@@HugoStiglitz88 The game is widely recognized as being the biggest waste of potential these past 10 years, but ok...
To each their own i guess. Graphics were and are even more mindblowing tho, theres not amount of praise that art department doesnt deserve. Too bad nothing similar can be said about the writers and core gameplay design.
Now THAT'S a worthy of the title Enhanced Edition.
Definately
It's pretty and all but is there any way of disabling it? I'm scared it might be a little too bright and I thought I'd might wanna play it in a colder darker atmosphere.
Will I still be able to play Enhanced Edition, w/o RTX... Is there a way to disable ray tracing so I can play the game? I don't have RTX GPU!
@@hapwn In that case, you can play the base version of the game. Enhanced Edition is a different version altogether. You have the option to choose between the base and the Enhanced Edition.
Will I still be able to play Enhanced Edition w/o an RTX GPU... Is there a way to disable ray tracing?
Watching someone have to manually manipulate the lightning to a single room makes me realize how much work really goes in to a game. Imagine you clock in at 8am and all day you're just tuning and retuning lighting variables for each and every location in the game for a setting not everyone will be able to experience.
Then imagine this person being told there will be an enhanced edition but everything can be done by toggling a single setting. Crazy how far we've come in two years.
Actually it's the thing you described - 9.00 you load a single project ( like this room) tweaking it to 21.00 with a constant doubt if its a right setting. The next day is the same, sometimes its a whole stress week on a single stupid scene with tests like in the video. 3D game development is the same as building a Skyscraper on Government money - a very stressful job.
Hoperfully a more widespread implementation of raytraced GI will alleviate that part of the job for artists in game development.
It’s actually insane how fast technology is going forward
Sounds like a shitty job tbh.. 😒
Then you watch ign give you a 3 out of 10 or something.
I can imagine. I'm a modeler and texture artist and occasionally do lighting. Digital artists spend hours upon hours tweaking and perfecting our work. Metro was made by a team who clearly loved their work and had great passion for the project. In my personal work, I'm used to using ray tracing and GI in VRay renders which take a very long time to calculate (two hours for my last project) and that was just for a still image. I never thought we'd get real-time light bounce like this. The quality is going to rival pre-rendered cinematics very soon.
This looks jaw-droppingly gorgeous.
What a surprise I'd find one of my favorite CZcamsrs on a random video
It actually does ngl
@@BigChungusWhale lol wtf
Finally something to test my 3090 on, cannot wait.
imagine getting DXR for SFM lol
This is so insanely cool and interesting! Thanks for putting together this whole showcase/analysis video!
Honestly, if Alex Battalia was a professor in any school. The grades of those students in his lecture would have triple A ratings.
I watch your stuff
This really shows as well how much faster development can happen for all games. Baked ray traced shadows work for most games that don't have a day night cycle and create amazing lighting.
Another proof that Alex is the best graphics analyst.
Oh hai Gehab
I remember playing Metro 2033 when it came out in 2010 and being extremely impressed. This right here is just absolutely stunning. Wow.
@Qimodis not only the graphics, even the world building was outstanding, you could feel despair, dread, hopeless by just looking at what was left from the environment after the war, not to mention Dead city and Panthom City, metro games are the personification of the world "Apocalypse", not to mention the mutants being the only species, besides the dark ones, to be able to live on those conditions
_"I went up again, to the gloomy charm of post-apocolyptic Moscow"_
@@micha3624yes you are the only one
The future is that artists have to plan where to NOT have lighting.
...which is FAR easier.
I dont think it will be easier to make beautiful realistic lighting. The thing with reflected light taking colour of the object will mess up colour tones of other objects. It is probably a b to balance it.
@@tiortedrootsky this happens in real life as well, and the human visual perception is pretty good at handling this, so it shouldn't be much of an issue
@@seritools i hate the green tint everything got when flashlight hit the green wall. With normal lighting it wouldnt have happened. Everything could be carefully constructed to look perfect in any circumstances. Now npc can come in the light and tint everything at any moment. Its just too much variables, that ruin possibilities for making colour scheme perfect. Maybe they'll figure out the right way to limit tinting and such and it will actually be positive thing over all.
@@Rokmononov realistic is not inherently better. Perfect colour scheme is valuable. Realistic lighting is in the way of that.
I mean it was ridiculously stunning even without RT. One of the most atmospheric games I’ve played.
Yeah I played it on a base PS4 through ps now, and still thought it looked stunning lol
THE MOST atmospheric game. Nothing else comes close
@@HugoStiglitz88 Half Life: Alyx would like a word.
True it looking amazing at ultra on pc but now with all these rtx stuff it'll look ever better
@@Skrenja clearly you didn't make it to novisibirsk
Just seen the release date announce and thought "cant wait to watch Alex nerding over that next week"... We are blessed this day instead
Tomorrow there will be more to nerd about lol
When's the release date?
@@jarethanstey7566 May 6th
I'm really looking forward to seeing how they handled the PS5/Series X versions. They promised a lot in their spec sheet, almost to the point it sounds too good to be true.
I believe they stated native 4k 60fps with all RT on aside from reflections. I played some of the game on the PS4 Pro and I just couldn't get used to the weird input delay. It's the only AAA FPS game I've played that had such a bad input delay, hopefully that won't be a problem with the next gen ports. Fine aiming was impossible on consoles, no idea if they ever fixed it because I ended up playing on PC instead.
@@arbiter- They never said native 4k, just 4k60. It will probably be DRS and looking at the 6800XT perfomance, I'm guessing it will be 1440p upscaled and lower RT quality. Which I think is fine and great to see the devs target 60 FPS.
Feels like the 2000s again where there were huge leaps in graphical technology in short periods of time
Ray Kurzweil calls that an s-curve of progress, if his predictions are accurate (supposedly 86% accurate thus far) these will happen more and more where you will have lulls and then larger and larger leaps in progress each time. Politics and other factors can inhibit or accelerate progress, but his arguement is that it happens regardless as this is an exponential effect. He wrote a book called "The singularity is near" in 2005 ish, and has another book end of this year called "the singularity is nearer". So if you continue on for many years, that "2000's" feeling will probably return. Again, if his ideas are accurate, looking forward to see his thoughts in his next book. Which he says has been difficult to write because of the speed of progress.
@@cth0nic668 thats true
@@cth0nic668 He should hold off on his new book until disclosure comes then because its gonna blow his S curve theory out of the water.
T&L was the RT of the early 2000s.
Can't wait for what this means for VR. DLSS and eye tracking will make amazing VR affordable and accessible to everyone.
As a game dev this stuff just makes me so happy, seeing companies allowed to push things to the limit!
16:05 is an extremely impressive enhancement.
yeah it almost look like ray tracing off vs ray tracing on comparison rather than different levels of ray tracing
The TF2 medic received a visual makeover :D
Yeah that looked dramatically better. But the standard shadows just seem to be a bit poor. I've seen plenty of non RT games shade and shadow things correctly in scenes like that. Part of the enhancement seems to be dramatic in general just because of the originals substandard efforts. Mainly in darker areas where it just does look too dark. Outdoor or bright areas don't suffer as much at all.
@@Arcona You're going to have to give some examples because the exact things he's talking about are extremely common across many many games where things just don't look grounded due to shadowing.
@@Arcona Could be, but also could be that you are used to it and lack of ray tracing in those games might not give any baseline comparison. Also ray traced global illumination is perfect feature for such a dark game and it compliments more than other games does.
Incredible. This is the first time I have seen real-time ray-tracing look considerably better than traditional lighting in a video game. I love how natural the scenes look.
Move aside Crysis, I’ve found a new way to explode my rig with.
In Russian Accent : Can it Run METRO!!!
@@CAPEDCRUSADER3900 weren’t the original games used as a bit of a benchmark back in the day?
@@nosrah9660 indeed
The heat coming put of my evga hybrid 3080 ftw3 is hotter than any game ive played so far lol the air being pushed out by the rear fan is still cool at least though
It actually run very well
The next splinter cell needs this global illumination.
Everything would be green 🙊
Even if it doesn't, we just need another Splinter Cell.
We need an old styled Splinter Cell game again ❤️
Do you imagine how a remake of Chaos Theory would look like????
@@Manganization was going to comment the same thing. They need to give the people what they want
@@jacobleukus6930 I was also going to comment the same thing.
Was not expecting this to be 40 minutes long but boy I do love it when they nerd out on these features
This is why Digital Foundry is the best.
I didn't even notice it was 40 minutes long until I glanced at the timestamp when I was done watching
Same, dude! There is not a lot of videos over 10+ minutes I manage to get through but this is the stuff I can watch for hours. Super interesting stuff and perfectly put together.
I didn't even notice it was 40 minutes till this comment, just opened the video and watched! Damn
I bet we’ll be seeing more once the official release comes, the benchmarks will be wonderful.
THIS is the ray tracing I've been waiting for. As an architect and 3D artist, I know this is VERY expensive processing, can't wait to see how they've pulled that one off
@@aweigh1010 expensive processing as in slow, also don't talk about something you don't understand
@@aweigh1010 Well, it is expensive NOW, but imagine in a long term run, when we will finally have full RT technology, only then games will truly looks realistic. Also, time saving shortcuts are important for studios, as they have more time to polish or even develop new IPs. But I get your point, you are not wrong, it's just a matter of perspective
@@aweigh1010 You literally don't have a single clue about game development do you? "Duh, just waste 2 additional years of development and a ton of money on optimizing this game a little more so Ivan living in Svetlojarks with his PC from Commie times can still play this game
Yes, there are quite a few examples of terribly optimized games which could have benefited from a little bit of extra optimization, but there's only so much one can do and there'll always be a certain minimal hardware level needed.
Can't always keep on including the weakest link, in today's world, especially technology, you gotta make advancements.
I already know that I'm the fool here for replying to this comment, winning an argument against an idiot is impossible, but hey, my heart didn't want me to scroll past it without adding my BS
@@aweigh1010 You're kind of an asshole with that comment, mate. Also, I hope you realize that less time spent on one area (like lighting) means they can spend MORE time in other areas.
@@aweigh1010 here's the thing, if the GPU shortage hadn't existed, a lot more budget PCs would've gotten access to RT.
Ray Tracing and DLSS, the two most important new tech features in a decade (I think). Finally, a game that seems to implement it not just good looking, but in a way mortals can run it.
I think it is really lame that you have to use DLSS if you want to play with Ray Tracing. A desktop 3090 is still not strong enough for Ray Tracing natively at 4K resolution. Nvidia released this technology way too early. Maybe the 4000 series cards might just be able to game at 4K RTX without a performance hit and without DLSS crap.
@@cemsengul16 this has to be one of the dumbest comments I've read in a while. This is how technology works. You put out something new, this gives devs the opportunity to work with it and build better software for it. And it slowly gets better over time, both the hardware and the software improve. Getting raytracing to run in a performant way does not only depend on the hardware but also more efficient software. Also, native 4k rendering is obsolete, there is no reason not to use DLSS at least in quality mode as its actually looks better than native rendering in many instances.
@@cemsengul16 This game proves beyond a doubt that Nvidia DIDN'T release this tech too early. The visual upgrade provided by RT in this game is so huge, there's really no argument here. DLSS is an amazing tech that is helping to move us to a "post resolution" era, as the DF guys would say. The image quality in DLSS quality mode is great, better than native for a lot of fine details. If you don't like it, you can play at 4K native with no RT features, so what's the problem?
No, it's PBR, but you don't know what it is cause it's not being hyped by marketers.
@@barulicksama3838 ok
That's the REAL new generation graphics: Multibounce GI and the Mesh Shaders that we are waiting yet.
One of the best DF videos to date. I really appreciate all the hard work it must have been to make this video. Also shout out to 4A for this release and for helping Alex with some behind the scenes looks.
I agree ☝️
And with that, Metro Exodus has once again become my most anticipated game of year!
Agreed.
I'm so glad I got Exodus a few months ago. This upgrade is free!!!
2019 Metro rasterized
2020 Covid 19
2021 Metro RT
The first upgrade was being available on steam!
Nope, same old shit just prettier.
Damn, this was really a great deep dive. Great job Alex!
Hopefully the new patreon will be able to support such content more often.
I really hope that Stalker 2 will look like this. Including EFT gunplay, animations and survival. Would be instantly my personal fav game of the century.
Please keep the hype down. Cyberpunk wouldnt be such a disaster if it wasnt SO overhyped.
@@tiortedrootsky Cd Projekt is the one that hyped cyberpunk, fans still definitely had stuff to do with it, but that game had literal weekly direct style shows about it up to release
@@nickwood502 for whatever reason expectations were very high which made the fall much harder. We should brace ourselves for (inevitable) bumpy start and we could just laugh and think of it as homage to the original games, joke about green bugs and wait for patches more calmly.
@@tiortedrootsky lol what. I just meant the company is the one that overhyped their game. Stalker 2 hasn’t even run ads about it so there isn’t much hype
@@nickwood502 in stalker comutity there is. At least it seems like it some times.
Not a big fan of the Metro games, but you cannot deny the studio's technical prowess. Every single Metro game has seriously pushed the boundaries visuals, especially in terms of lighting and this is one of the most impressive implementations of raytracing to date.
What don't you like about the games? I think they are the best when it comes to immersion and the story is pretty dang good. The resource management is one of the best as well and really helps reinforce the immersion for me. Like you said as well, 4A is always pushing technical boundaries with the Metro games.
Even 2033 and last light still hold up fantastic tbh
@@nighttimestalker I agree 100%. 4A is a lot like ID was back in the day with Doom 3. I love what these guys do.
@@sgtcoffman
I restarted 2033 redux last night on my one X. And it still surprised me just how good it's held up.
Last light has held up even better
@@sgtcoffman For me Exodus was a great and fun game but the acting was corny and horrible... :D
Extremely impressive. This version really shows off the huge potential of ray tracing in video games.
At what cost.
@@Clay3613 nothing
Man, really excellent writing on this, Alex!
This is such an amazing look into the future of game rendering! Thanks for going as far as getting dev footage to help explain the new tech. The future is bright!
This is incredible work Alex! (as always)
Lighting is on another level these devs got chops
Wish they had spent more time on the actual gameplay instead.
@@ifstatementifstatement2704 that's what I hate about games that revolve around "muh graphics and realism", they're basically glorified tech demos with atrocious gameplay and atmosphere..
@@wallacesousuke1433 yeah. The graphics are nice and all but you can quickly get used to it no matter how awesome they are. And the only thing you are left paying more and more attention to is the gameplay.
I remember when the ps4 released, ps3 graphics were looking really old compared to pc and I was following radbrad on youtube who played on console, and was thinking he's going to be blown away by the graphics once he starts playing on the ps4. When he first played a game on the ps4 he thought the graphics were amazing but quickly got used to it. It became standard and he didn't care much for it after the first two weeks of gaming on a ps4. And I saw other console streamers who also did the same, they got used to the graphics very quickly.
So in my opinion graphics are not as important as gameplay. Although it is always cool to see a game with great graphics.
@@wallacesousuke1433 Errrr, Metro games are pretty renown for having really great atmosphere. It's one of its biggest selling point. Good gameplay is kinda subjective but alot of people like Metro for it's slower paced and more realistic gameplay.
@@MrBurtbackerack there is literally nothing realistic about crouchwalking around in broad daylight "distracting" trained soldiers with soda cans, and then laying waste to twenty dudes by yourself. Doesn't mean it isn't fun but let's be real here lmao, the gameplay is pretty cliche
One of my favorite studios, and one of the few that pushes technology HARD while also making fantastic games. Slav Magic truly does exist... because 4A created a studio full of wizards!
They are okay, haven’t been able to play more than 5 hours of their previous 2 Metro games because of game breaking bugs
quite a few of them came from stalker dev studio, which explains allot they were pushing boundries with ai before everyone else.
@@spenny2cents I've never experienced one bug in my hundreds of hours played, spanning all 3 games....idk what you're talking about
@@funtourhawk Yeah, I finish Metro 2033 Redux about a year ago and didn't experience even a single bug. I don't know what's he talking about.
@@funtourhawk still, the games has a lot of bugs, it may work for you on one system, and won't start on another
Seeing as your first ray tracing vid on Metro Exodus was the first DF vid I ever watched, this vid came as a highly appreciated surprise. Sehr gut
We've all been trained to see very two-dimensional shadows as "correct" in games. Now that global illumination and shadows are being fully Ray Traced, we have to literally retrain ourselves to see this as the correct lighting model. Artists have gotten quite good at faking local lights in a scene, so our eyes tell us that it's all prerendered and drawn by an asset artist. But once you realize that it's all being calculated in real time, it changes everything.
It looks so good, that our eyes tell us that it looks weird. How strange is that?
This has to be the best lighting we have ever seen in a game so far!
Those RTX cards in minimum requirements are put there for a reason, apparently.
In AAA sphere, this and Cyberpunk are most advanced to date. In non-AAA, there is also Quake 2 and Minecraft RTX. In non-realtime, there is AC Unity and lot of other games with prebaked RT lighting.
@@8Paul7 Quake 2 RTX and Minecraft RTX are arguably more advanced because they're fully path-traced without the traditional rasterisation at all.
@@antonkirilenko3116 That's true, although both of those are only _slightly_ more advanced than Metro Exodus. Exodus has infinite raytraced bounces and raytraced reflections which help make it so realistic - the only thing left is removing the rasterization. That will probably be in the next Metro game 😊
@@antonkirilenko3116 2060 is a mid tier card from 2018. What are you talking about? Three years have past.
The improved performance surprised me the most.
DLSS2 brings a lot. I'm not an Nvidia fan but they really are the driving force of the technology.
@@Goeker Dlss 2.0 is amazing, but the performance increases were tested without using dlss! The game is just more efficient in every ray, and turning dlss on will get better fps than was seen even herr
DLSS is a real game changer...
This is honestly the approach every developer should take this gen. nothing adds more to realism than global illumination. I'm fine with screen-space reflections and normal shadows. but this... this will make games more beautiful and easier for developers as well. It's a Win-win! I hope developer toolkits for console start implementing this technology in some form, (almost) every game needs to have this!
@@hamstek3810 Depends really. GI is something that's better in games with a dynamic time of day but for a game having shiny surfaces and having baked lighting, I'd pick better reflections over GI any day.
40 minutes of just pure, jaw-dropping, eye candy.
To watch Alex nerding out on Ray tracing is always enlightening :)
Imagine having a prettier game than a game that is already pretty
I think, however, they overdid it on the bounced lighting on way too many surfaces. Dull surfaces don't bounce light back as much as this game makes them, in some cases the contrast between light and dark should be much more noticeable. Shadows are a bit too bright now. At least, to be realistic I mean. Artistically and stylistically it is gorgeous.
Best graphic of 2019: Metro Exodus.
Best graphic of 2020: Metro Exodus.
Best graphic of 2021: Metro Exodus.
not on consoles
Dunno man, no matter how many flaws Cyberpunk 2077 has, the visuals aren't one of them
@@MrVoland44 lmao what? Series X/Ps5 is gonna run this at 4K60 with RayTracing.
Can YOUR pc do that?
@@BroadFame What are you smoking?
@@belland_dog8235 Lmao.
those videos are so wow. congrats guys
As always, this video was a pleasure to watch and you guys at DF are absolute experts in graphics & performance. Thank you!
This is the game that made me understand how game-changing RT global illumination was.
Really? When I was playing with non-RT, I never had the feeling that lighting was missing. How is that game-changing?
@@termitreter6545 It seems that you do not understand the point of this, RT GI is a game changer since with this technology the light and its effects are generated in real time in a physically correct way, thus avoiding that the developers spend time simulating this kind of lighting, making the development easier and occupying the time in other sections.
@@secoTheSonicFan This doesnt really save ressources for devs.
If you go full raytrace rendering, then theres some stuff devs dont have to do anymore, but we're a decade away from that.
@@jerchongkong5387 You mean this? I very much doubt that this global illumination stuff saves much time at all. This kind of "raytracing" is extremely limited, and has to be specifically set up by the devs.
If this was actually "physically correct", then no machine could run it.
Not to mention, do you know how much time devs actually spend on optimizing games to look nice and run well on your PC?
This type of RT makes most of that effort moot, because it takes a huge amount of ressources for little gain.
For now, real time raytracing is a gimmick. Im sure its useful for developers, to simulate how to do baked/classic lighting etc, but not in a real time application.
@@BH-ln5pt Im looking at this vid and the comparision pics, and its really not a big difference. Frankly, the most improved scenes look better because they changed the visual direction, and not because of the tech.
And PS2 games dont really compare. Back then, graphics seemed to improve every year, bit by bit.
Yet in the last 10 years, the visual improvement in terms of graphics has been pretty limited. Which hardly even bothers me; considering those games look great either way.
this stuff makes me want to upgrade my pc ... TOO BAD ITS IMPOSSIBLE NOW
that's it's purpose , spending money , and you will be disappointed to spend so much money for so little change
By the time you can upgrade, every game will be fully developed with ray tracing....so 2045
It is possible, but for what cost....
Ray tracing is too taxing, better methods will surpass it
I’m already planning for 2023 😂
one of the best DF video recently. Amazing work Alex.
That is the detail I was looking for. Thank you.
I don't know about ya'll but digital foundry uploads make my day. They are so easy to listen too, knowledgeable, and relaxing.
I barely know anything about video game development and try my hardest to follow the very technical stuff but its always entertaining
oh man oh man oh man, how we have waited. The first release was SOMETHING to flex on 2000 series cards, but DLSS 2.0 has been needed for a long time, not even to mention the tons of other upgrades!
It's 2.1
@@Psycho-zb4ee It WAS 2.0. The comment owner talks about the past times. 2.1 is relatively new
Oh man of God oh man OH GOD OH MAN OH GOD
@@Psycho-zb4ee that's right, I was misremembering the original post and commented before I watched the video
Thank you for releasing this in widescreen!
When I played through the enhanced edition I found that I needed to turn down the brightness a lot to maintain the intended dark style to most of the indoor areas. That seemed to work pretty well without ruining brighter scenes.
It's just different. The scenes that should be dark realistically, are still dark. It's just that the game wasn't originally made with this in mind. So the distribution of light sources is sometimes not adiquate for these scenes.
This is a huge step forwards in real time rendering history! Great video 👍
I think Todd Howard is ready for the new ray traced only version of Skyrim lol.
I ain't mad. Won't fix the terrible animations though :P
16 times the RT.
it actually does need that though because the engine only supports 4 active light sources casting shadows at the same time. So Light sources outside of this wont cast shadows. With there being so many light sources in the game(torches, lamps, windows ect.) it is so apparent oce you notice it. There is pretty much no way around it other than a mod called enblightpatcher which allows you to manually add all light source in your game as enb-lights(which arent affected by the limitation), but it takes absolutely forever and is so complicated. This is coming from someone who has a somehow-stable game with 900 mods lol
@@paddington2063 thanks for mentioning that I don’t know much regarding the so called creation engine but I’m sure it would be way more efficient. I imagine if fallout 4 had it a 3090 would explode the moment someone goes to the downtown Boston area. Any experience with the uncapped frame rate mods by they way?
@@johanromero5354 eh these engines just iterate on top of one another, it honestly makes no sense to me that they keep it instead of just building in UE. God, yeah, Boston is just a nightmare. I actually couldn't bring myself to keep modding Fallout 4 because that area is just impossible to fix 100%.
Also yup the old mods used to create all sorts of physics bugs but people have figured out how to unlock it in the ini files and I've never seen any issues with it. Although honestly, I'd rather push the visuals harder than framerate for that sort of game. I recommend looking into modding it now if you're interested though, there's been a lot of huge visual and animation breakthroughs in the last 6 months of so. Truly looks great!
Great Video, thanx Alex
Fantastic video and fantastic looking game! Glad I didn't get around to play Exodus yet and happy that it's part of the Humble Bundle this month 👍🏻😊
And here I am playing Metro 2033 and already thinking it looks incredible
It does. Obviously not as good as exodus, but many new releases don't have lighting and volumetrics as impressive as the original Metro.
@@michaelsteffensen6844 it's awesome game. But I got scared and didn't finish it. Yet
remains to be seen if they do a second remaster of the old games with raytracing.. shouldn't be all that hard to do
@@raxxor18 they might have to change all materials if they aren't already physically based.
@@raxxor18 not a big fan of this "graphics only" remasters, i would love to play metro exodus ED, but i allreaydy playes Metro3 3 times.... they should implement some gameplay changes, new levels/weapons or creatures and sliders like "only rain weather" etc. i dont play a game 4 times only because of better raytracing.
'It's so stunning!'
* Fires up Oblivion *
Such a good video Alex, my mind has been blown by how good this game looks with the new RT update 😍... it runs better too!
I am so excited, I played metro when it released back in late 2019 and have over 200 hours in it, I absolutely love the way it looks, its gorgeous as hell, and to see a more fleshed out version of RT being implemented into it? I'm gonna put another hundred hours into metro when it releases.
I remember when Tessellation was a new thing in games and everyone was talking about it. :D
I remember when games started not being just in black and white. Am...am I old?
I remember T&L and the arrival of something to replace the TNT line called, weirdly enough, "GeForce." What kind of name is that?
Answer: easily copyrighted.
lol. My first console when I was about 5 was a black and white system with 10 built in games. Basically two white blocks, called bats and a square ball on a black screen. It was really responsive though with those analogue wheels on the controllers
@@ArcanePath360 Same here. Ricochet Pong Clone followed by the Odyssey2 then the C64. Crazy how quickly time passes.
Stil waiting for my tesselated asscreed unity roof tiles ;(
Raytracing is the next big step in graphical fidelity. This is absolutely mind blowing.
Yeah once those engineers figure out how to make it less taxing, or create significantly more powerful hardware, gaming is going to be have another revolution. RT isn’t limited to reflections, it affects almost all aspects of playing a game, I have very high expectations for the future.
they have to find a way to make less power hungry otherwise no one will leave it on
@@Saint_Arod i wouldn't really count on devs finding ways to make it less taxing. Better hardware is pretty much the only way forward at this point
@@GeneralKenobi69420 Couldnt agree more. The ps4 and xbox one are holding us back significantly now
@@user-rm8by9fm well thankfully, nextgen-only games have been popping up left and right since recently...
Thank you for this video, so in-depth and detailed
Wow amazing work Alex!
I can't wait till this level of Ray Tracing is the standard across all Triple A games
2 more gens
@@joaodebarronego at the rate its all going, I'd say only 1 more gen
@@MrOuttheir It took to have games runing on 1080p or more
@@IamJakeToo gpu availability needs to improve though, games would miss out on a lot of sales still if they can only run on rt capable hardware
"You need a ray tracing GPU to run this game."
LowSpecGamer: "Is that a challenge?"
Well, technically, RTX features do work in "software mode" on GTX GPUs...
@@antonkirilenko3116 I'm talking about what they say in the FAQ
Well unless he can spoof an ID of another gpu so that it thinks its a raytracging capable gpu and then it wont be able to render any lighting even if it does spoof correctly.
No more challenging than purchasing a compatible card ... oh, wait.
@@WayStedYou even if you spoof it, what then? GTX doesn't have the RT cores to process the RT in the first place.
Great video!
Thanks, useful video. Great job
This is what you were teasing in the Weekly! Awesome :)
The comparison with the candles and the doctor is impressive, it looks generational almost.
yeah which as he said is crazy cuz the standard raytracing version is like a generational leap from rasterization.
I completely agree
Because it is =)
Totally agree. This and the dead soldier lying in the door entrance.
This was the most impressive example from the whole video, imo.
Also, i love the excitement in his voice! That's exactly how i feel when new tech comes to game design 😊
love the analysis, great job
This is why I love this channel the most.
DLSS is black magic as far as I'm concerned. I can't wait for direct ml to come out. It'll be good to have a competitor to DLSS.
I just hope the other alternatives are good enough to compete in order to keep pushing each others implementation to be better & better. Although on innovating DLSS, Nvidia did not disappoint even without much competition. 1.0 was pretty "meh" in quality though but they could've just stopped at 1.9 with a good enough. Instead they went ahead with 2.0 & 2.1 and decoupled it from system load to be used wherever the user wants (even low/very low settings).
It's also definitely not magic, there's a lot of work from Nvidia in AI & every single thing is actually mindblowingly impressive. I'm just glad they decided to push it to consumers as well even if pricing increased not insignificantly as a result.
@PennywiseTheDancingClowN ! Let's just hope they do or if they don't that Nvidia cares enough to keep improving DLSS
Yeah I literally can't tell the difference with DLSS on. It's insane.
it'd be even nicer if DLSS was made into some kind of open standard, like freesync is. granted, i dunno how that'd be possible based on the way DLSS works, but still.
@@uzimyspecial direct ml will work on AMD cards and Nividia cards, well any GPU actually, so I guess that's a start!
Only problem is the PS5 can't use it because it's based on Direct X 12.
Amazing vid 👍
Thank you for showing performance on lower end RTX cards. Mine is a 2070 and it seems like most DF videos are done with much much higher end GPUs, especially the 3080 and obviously I can't get anywhere near those settings. So this specifically is VERY helpful. I've also used recommended settings on many other games and noticed greatly improved performance without noticeable visual downgrades.
Oh, and this game looks absolutely amazing. Phenomenal.
Okay. I get it now. I haven't seen a justified implementation of Ray tracing since it became a thing, but holy shit this looks absolutely incredible. Completely transforms the atmosphere.
Kudos to the devs for putting in the passion to make this a reality. Maybe one day I'll be able to soak this in for myself. Wow.
Euhm.... Control?
@@uccarpiyuz I was just going to post this. Control's implementation was the first real "Oh damn, this is going to change everything" moment for me with RT.
I have been totally behind it since I found out about it two years ago. Playing RDR 2 currently, and often in shaded areas and indoor areas, the lighting looks quite video gamey, and that can only be solved with ray tracing.
@@akashmakkar7187 i really want them to add DLSS and ray tracing to RDR2. would make the game so much more playable for the rtx 2060
@@uccarpiyuz Ahhh yes, I do remember seeing some jaw-dropping visuals there. Right. This implementation though shows how crazy photo realistic they can get. Like the tiny little things.
The original DF metro exodus ray tracing analysis is one of my favorite youtube videos, this is amazing!
Awesome video, Alex! I actually bought this game because of it when I have a zillion others waiting on Game Pass. It was my test bench for playing something that required RT with my new 3080 (130TGP) laptop. (desktop 2070-2080s/3060ti equivalent I think). The gameplay is so good I missed most of the things you pointed out in the video. It's been fun to watch! I kept thinking, they should totally go dark and eat the Colonel in this scene. You pointed out the flames and skull shadows. I was totally distracted by the plot and writing, ha!
A masterful treatment as always. Kudos Alex.
Me : wow beards don’t glow in the dark anymore
Its great that you were able to show how it affects the workflow for the devs, they must be so happy now. You can just play around with lights and objects and everything updates realistically and dynamically in real time. Can't wait for this to be standard in all game dev.
"Can you see this noise on CZcams?" Yes. Glad you explained it, cause I wasn't sure what was going on earlier in the video. Thought it might be light reflecting through water at first.
wow, I am stunned that the video was 40 mins after watching it without noticing! Good content passes time quickly.
This is honestly the first RT implementation that gives a big enough visual improvement to make RT worthwhile for me.
This is absolutely mind-blowing! Very interested to see how the console version turns out
Just played it for about 5 hrs on my 3070. What an amazing improvement it is! I honestly can't believe how good the performance is as well considering just how much is raytraced at once.
im more impressed that this runs on my cheap ass xbox series s.
@Josua Meyer true. and i get to see all this ray traced GI goodness albeit at a low resolution lol. i cant justify the power consumption of gaming on pc consoles are just so much more efficient.
@@JudeTheCZcamsPoopersubscribe Yeah it's pretty incredible what the Series S can do for 300 bucks. Definitely one of the best deals in gaming, especially when paired with Game Pass.
It really brings out the material based rendering I’ve noticed
The more realistic lighting interacting with certain materials makes them very convincing
looks amazing, it will be interesting to see what they do with consoles for the enhanced edition
So far this has been the first time I have seen Raytracing in action for a game and thought, "I need this" as now I can actually see significant differences and how this RT Tech should be implemented.
I really enjoyed it on Exodus. Much like VR it really is something that needs to be experienced directly. CZcams compression dumbs down the vibrancy of RTX a lot.
16:12 WOW the difference here is extraordinary.
holy shit
Great video
The skull noise is really noticeable... it looks like moving water reflections.
Don't think that's happening in game
I wonder if a film grain effect could mask that well enough, even if I know it's not everyone cup of tea, it would at least make the whole image more consistent.
One of my favourite games of all time. Immersive gameplay, beautiful graphics and art design, emotional story, rewarding exploration, thoughtful combat and fantastic world design (it feels truly alive). I can't wait to replay it again once I get an RTX card. Also I hope they adjust the sensitivity curve and deadzone values for controllers.
Awsome ! Thank you !
This series is truly a work of art. They play and look so well.
This is just polishing a gem
I clicked on this video only expecting to watch for a few minutes, 5 minutes later, I had watched the whole thing. This was insanely interesting. Can't wait to try it myself.
How did you watch 40:45 minutes of content in 5 minutes? 😂
@@ux2099 that's the joke. I only intended to watch the video for 5 minutes or so, but the content was so interesting that the 40 minutes seemed to fly by in a span of only 5 minutes.
This game was such a amazing experience! Such amazing story telling and soooo immersive.
Your profile picture is immersive. Really makes you feel like you're looking at a pretty girl. 8/10, IGN
@@DravicPL Simp
@@mediocrecorps
You're just jealous that the women want to be with me, the men want to be me and the children learn about me in schools.
Damn... Exodus came out two years ago? Loved the game. I replay it every few months just for the graphics.
As a 3D artist: I'm stunned. This looks like an octrane render now thanks to the multi bounces. Stunning.
Download the latest version of Unreal editor (if you have a rtx card) and play around with real time ray tracing! It's so amazing!
With a ton of noise and typical temporal artifacts. Aight
@@branchprediction9923 which you won't notice during gameplay.
@@gavinderulo12 i do
@@branchprediction9923 so you would rather have rasterized lighting with way more artifacts and light bleed instead?
Now the game looks like a Love death & robots animation running in real time! how far we've come…
Fitting youre saying that cause season 2 is dropping soon
Which episode did it remind you off of?
@@ptrcrispy I didn't know it was dropping soon. You just made me happy brother. Cheers
LDAR is so good! Can’t wait for season 2
@@ptrcrispy reminded me a lot of the episode The Secret War, because of the game taking place in a post apocalyptic russia with creepy creatures
There's still lots of downsides... We're sadly still pretty far away from a quality and full feature raytraced game.
This is awesome! It surely looks like baked lighting on stills, but it's all realtime! This is great, this is what RT is going to mean for the future of real time rendering!
29:30 Yes, we can and I also spotted it earlier when you showed the same clip.
I finished the game a few months ago. Today I started all over again and wow, it’s beautiful!