West Side Story (2021) - Review!
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 06. 2024
- Steven Spielberg sets out to remake an all-time classic. Is this a challenge that not even the Beard can overcome? Find out in my review!
YOU CAN GET ALL MY REVIEWS ON AUDIO NOW!
APPLE: tinyurl.com/t736rphc
SPOTIFY: tinyurl.com/u7p5pfk
AUDIBLE: tinyurl.com/yrffy95s
AMAZON MUSIC: tinyurl.com/9a278znb
STITCHER: tinyurl.com/4yzrntjs
JOIN ME ON PATREON: / danmurrell
FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER: / murrelldan
FOLLOW ME ON INSTAGRAM: / murrelldan - Zábava
It's not a remake. It's another film version of the Broadway musical.
Just like Baz Luhrman's Romeo+Juliet is not a remake of Zefirelli's Romeo and Juliet. The 1992 Dracula is not a remake of the 1931 Dracula. The "original" source being remade is not necessarily the preceding film, even though it may look like it and sound like it.
A Star is Born is a remake. The Disney live-action films are remakes. That's not what this is.
A technicality in this case. They wrote a role specifically for Rita Moreno, Anita in the 1961 film -- and she's getting Oscar buzz for it right alongside the new Anita, Ariana DeBose. Just singing "Somewhere", the musical's most famous song, at almost 90 (the movie drops the day before her 90th birthday) may itself be worthy of another Oscar nomination.
At first I was scared shitless that this classic would be ruined... but the moment it opened I knew it was going to kick ass, from the choreography, to the songs, all of it made me very happy. It's literally like you're back in time. The scenes and atmosphere just capture that old school style film.
Rachel Zegler getting all the praise she deserves! 👏🏽 Imagine booking such an iconic role straight out of high school!
Right after they went to Puerto Rico for a massive casting search only to hire a white passing American ☺️
@@theaudjob3267
About to say the same thing... They still used a white person to play Maria. If you couldn't change that what is the point of a remake.
@@cashaetaylor7466 don’t even get me started on hiring a r*pist as Tony
@@cashaetaylor7466 she is half colombian, what are you talking about? Just because her skin is not that dark doesn't mean she is not latina
@@melissasalazar151 again, they went to Puerto Rico to cast Maria only to turn around and cast a white passing non-Puerto Rican
Well this movie went from, “Eh, might be okay?” to, “I need to see this as soon as possible,” REAL quick.
This movie looks like it was recorded on film rather than digital. It has that gritty, vintage look you don't really see anymore.
Not enough people care about that kind of thing, glad you brought that up!
This film was shot on 35MM film stock.
It's also because they kept the "studio" look on purpose. To add to the aesthetic
@@christopherbrown5023 I also noticed that different kinds of 35mm film stocks were used, according to the end credits (specifically right below the Kodak logo).
Just saw this on opening day! FANTASTIC! One of the best movies I've ever seen! My personal kudos go to Mike Face's characterization of Riff, grittier and with so much more depth than Russ Tamblyn ever gave it! All the acting & dancing & singing is top notch!
Faist deserves an oscar for that
I notice a lot of directors only care about a movies look cool visually but they don’t care about story or characters. So it’s amazing to see s movie with the whole package
I mean it's Spielberg we're talking about
I'm looking forward to this not because it's being directed by one of the best directors ever, but also because I'm a fan of the late Stephen Sondheim who gave this remake his stamp of approval
Yeah, so even that wasn't the thing to get me totally excited for this movie, since even the creators of certain anime have given their stamp of approval to pretty profusely hated live-action adaptations in the U.S. Yeah, I heard he worked on some of it with Spielberg for this new version, but it still meant jack up until I heard some early reviews. Plus, the soundtrack for this one at least to me, didn't sound as good as the original up until I actually saw the film. I am glad to say that this film is as good as it was, because even the trailers are something I felt did this movie kind of wrong. It showed the bare minimum in terms of the quality of the musical numbers and the dancing.
@@thefirstbourne149 Well I think the marketing team might have overlooked that oh we're we are making a trailer to a Steven Spielberg movie where they probably should've realized no we need to make a trailer to a film adaptation of a Stephen Sondheim musical. Because when you compare this to let's say Tim Burton's adaptation of Sweeney Todd or Disney's 2014 adaptation of Into the woods. The marketing teams for those movies knew how those movies needed to be marketed.
That said the soundtrack was incredible especially the America number which had the best dance sequence in the film.
When I first heard about this, only one word came to mind: sacrilege. Now I can't watch a single clip without weeping and at the same time aching for my youth. I couldn't have been more wrong.
Bravo Maestro Spielberg!
@lucky leprechaun Come to Rochester and we'll see it together. :)
You must have drunk a LOT of cool aid.
@lucky leprechaun Most often it is a passive-aggressive way of saying "you'll believe/buy into/follow anything" used by ignorant trolls who in most cases have a brain (much like their penis) that is too small or inferior to be of any practical use and as a result have an unfulfillable, insatiable need to elevate themselves beyond their impotence.
@@tomsmith2013 the greatest roast of all time award goes too...
I'm so glad this is getting great reviews. I too am a big Spielberg fan and like you Dan have not been overly enthusiastic about some of the movies he's done in recent years. I think I might go and watch this.
I would probably say (to me) his last great one was Lincoln, maybe Munich or Catch Me if You Can.
@@titanguy7316 I thought Lincoln was boring. I enjoyed Munich and War of the worlds, and Tin Tin was fun. Though to be honest I haven't seen The Post or The Terminal.
Bridge of Spies was ok but certainly not his best.
Right there with you. Dan’s enthusiasm for this film has made me think about giving it a chance.
@@heatheraggus7501 I forgot about Bridge of spies
So excited to hear all of this, Dan - great review! Like you, I am looking forward to being "proven wrong" on this film.
@Jogwheel. But, what if you're not "proven wrong?" This film could be a good high school production of the musical with that has the resources of a Hollywood studio.
Looks great
“Remake” inappropriate descriptive … Also it isn’t a competition. This new version of a great musical … is STUNNING. I loved every second. And Rita Moreno getting a certain song?-Heartbreaking, beautiful
Ahhhhh man I was so hoping this would be good, but getting the Murrell enthusiastically excited seal of approval is the GOLD standard of reviewers!!
So many positive reviews for this movie that I’m going to see it. The Oscars really needs to make a category for “Best Choreography (stunts & dance)” because they are as important to the movement of the film as the script.
Agreed!!!
Oscar raarely looks at the value of choregraphy. In essence, they did in 1961 when Jerome Robbins was awarded an Oscar for his directionof the dance numbers in "West Side Story," but he is listed as a "Best Director." In 1968, Onna White won a special Oscar for her spectacular dance work in "Oliver!"
@@williamsnyder5616 we love an Onna White fact! An unsung choreographer of note.
I saw it last night. I'm in love with Rachel Zegler, wow. And the scene she had with Arianna Debose, A Boy Like That… I've never seen a more intensely dramatic moment. There were many moments that made me cry. But the singing of Somewhere turned me into a puddle. On a different note, there were many beautiful automobiles from the 1950s, some even in the choreography.
I came out of this movie thinking, hot damn Anita feels so much better because of that performance DeBose did.
I love Arianna’s voice, especially with America. I think the way that song was done, the singing, dancing, location, is much better that the 1961 version.
Definitely had my doubts as what Spielberg could bring to this…but very happy to hear that he put on his working boots for this one and the casting department did their job. Big musical fan and am tired of lukewarm movie adaptations and glad this looks very alive!
I would love, dearly, if this film succeeds to the point that they put the same effort into others like this. Namely, I REALLY want a new big-screen version of "Guys & Dolls," preferably with Neil Patrick Harris in the role of Nathan Detroit.
Oh that would be brilliant!
A revival of musicals, done right, would be a nice change of movie pace.
@@ShaneyBright if Mama Mia and La La Land didn't really spark off a renewal chances aren't great for Westside Story, but here's hoping!
@@isaacfarrell8136 But nostalgia is a hell of a drug. So with West Side Story seemingly washing the bad taste of Cats out of theater-to-film watchers' mouths there may be new hope! EDIT: How could I forget Dear Evan Hanen?! Okay, so West Side Story has a lot to make up for, but sounds like it might be up to the task?
@Bad Wolf Media. A remake of "Guys & Dolls" with Neil Patrick Harris in the role of Nathan Detroit? I didn't know Nathan Detroit as a character who was gay? Well, representation
seems to be important to so many people.
I'm so glad to see that this has the substance to back the beautiful cinematography showcased in the trailer! It's been a while since I have been excited about a big "holiday season" release and this has me pumped to go to the theater again. Well, so does Spiderman No Way Home, but in a different way lol
Watching the trailers, I suspect Rachel Zegler and Ariana DeBose will be Oscar nominees this year. Ms. Zegler lights up the screen, it's almost like she has a glow to her. I agree, it does feel like watching a real life 'star is born' moment. Ms. DeBose is also riveting, she has an energy to her scenes in the trailers. Cinematography, choreography, costume design, it makes for scenes that are beautiful and energetic. I suspect if the movie as a whole is reflected in the trailers, the movie will be raking in Oscar nominations and wins. BTW, not only did Rita Moreno act in the movie, she was also an executive producer of the film. Talking about the bookends of a long and distinguished career!
A lot of people are saying “we didn’t need a remake the original was perfect”
The original wasn’t perfect most of the Latino characters where not played by Latinos and they were painted to look like a stereotype. So yeah it needed changes ☺️
This is true, but while that's a laudable reason to revisit it, wouldn't it have been tragic if that's the only thing that was improved. I'm so glad to hear Dan say that on the whole this remake is stellar and not just more socially conscious.
And the main character Maria in this remake is still not a Latino. So if you couldn't get a real darker skinned actress for the main role I don't think you should have re-made it.
Hollywood is still in denial.
@@cashaetaylor7466 She's half Columbian according to wiki. Does that not check the box enough?
@@cashaetaylor7466 she is colombian!!!!!
What are you talking about???
This Spielberg film also has the main characters actually singing instead of the dubbing in the 1961 movie. Part of the location shooting was also done not only in NYC but also in East Los Angeles to capture a richer bi-coastal tableau of the Latino immigrant experience in America. Add these to the Latino actors portraying the Latino characters-and you get more authenticity than the ‘61 production.
I'm so excited to hear this!! Was just as skeptical so excited to learn we were wrong!
So happy I was not disappointed Spielberg did a great job!
I come to this review after having seen the film on its first night of release, 12/10/21. I’m 69 and saw the 1961 original within a week of its initial release. It changed my life. When I first heard Spielberg was re-making it, I thought it was a joke, something from The Onion. When I realized it was real, I was offended and determined to boycott the film, but curiosity got the better of me. I rejoice in saying I absolutely love this movie. It’s everything you say. I’ve only one tiny quibble with your review. This remake doesn’t cut a single one of the original songs. It does reorder some, but also reinstates part of the 2nd Act ballet music as underscoring for Maria’s hasty morning prep while A Boy Like That/I Have a Love is performed in full, a number the 1961 film shortens.
he indeed was risking it all in making this movie. you can tell that, like you, he grew up with the original WSS and wanted nothing more than to not damage the original's legacy. so glad you enjoyed it!
I liked that they gave some reasons for the action - originally, it was just the Puerto Ricans against the Gringos - the urban "renewal" gave an urgency to the problem. Also, Tony had a REASON to stay away from the Jets, where he didn't before. Bravo!
Just saw it, can't agree more. It was truly a master class in film.
Just saw the movie today! As someone who loved the original, I agree with everything you said. I absolutely loved it and though they did a GREAT job on it!! Love Rita Moreno! She is still beautiful!!!
Excellent commentary. Thanks for that. I love that you point out the theatrical creds of the cast. Something definitely worth noting is that David Alvarez is a Tony Award winner. He shared the Best Actor in a Musical award with two other young actors who played Billy Elliot on Broadway.
Neat review. Actually made me excited for this
The moral of the story: never doubt the greatest film director of all time. The man’s a legend for a reason. The true GOAT!!
Absolutely. Jaws and Jurassic Park are in my top 5 favourite movies of all time.
@@heatheraggus7501 Same here.
Spielberg is great, but Kubrick is the GOAT
@@-AtomsPhere- Nope. Not even Kubrick. The thing Spielberg has that Kubrick didn’t have is range. Spielberg has done a collage of many films in different genres and has been completely successful. Kubrick films (many classics for sure) have ultimately proven to be more esoteric over time than really fundamentally rewarding, entertaining, etc.
@@-AtomsPhere- He is best, but Spielberg's movies are ones that I will return to more often. Cannot say the same for Kubrick (except maybe Spartacus and 2001).
I’ve been watching Rachel since she started posting videos of her singing musical theater songs on CZcams. Holy crap I can’t believe that’s her! So incredibly talented and well earned. 💗 I’m so excited to watch this adaptation! Also your critique of what’s missing in most movie musicals is dead on. To this day Chicago was the only modern movie musical that got it truly right.
Dan! I stumbled upon this and started watching it and stayed with you till the end. What a great review! It did sound like you didn't take a breath for 13 minutes and I was impressed that you could keep that enthusiasm up and really cover the original WSS and the new WSS in extensive, knowledgeable detail. I'll be following you and I look forward to not only seeing WSS myself, but also to your reviews. FWIW, WSS is one of my favorites of all time and, like you, I thought, "WHY is SS remaking this film?" But... I imagine I'm going to be feeling about the same way you did. Thank you!
Zegler's performance is even better when you realize she had to act with Ansel Elgort. They even kept him out of the marketing as much as they could... but he's Tony.
The difference is at the time of filming those allegations were not know they came out after filming had wrapped
Probably to cover up those sexual assault allegations 😬
Stay classy man..
In recent interviews, Sondheim expressed his approval for Spielberg's changes in how the songs were used -- their order, etc., -- saying it was "very interesting." He added that he felt it was important to keep reinterpreting musicals, so as to keep them fresh. He also admitted that he was actually never happy with his lyrics to "I feel pretty," and was pleased that this song was cur from the new film!
It wasn’t cut though
this was such movie magic! Im so in love. I respectfully disagree with you though. I thought Ansel was a incredible Tony.
THANK you!!
ME TOO!!
Best Tony I've EVER seen, or heard, on Stage AND Screen!!
One of my all time favorite movies. When I heard that Spielberg was going to do a remake I was so excited. The fact that Rita Moreno is in it is the cherry on top. I haven't gone to many movies lately but I will be going to see this one in the movie theater when it opens. I am looking forward to having this movie as part of my personal library.
I was expecting more from "In the Heights" and didn't get it, I am far more interested in this one because I was also not really looking forward to it but now, that so many people who were also esceptical are loving it, I'll give it a shot
The attention to detail in the scenes was accurate in such a respectful manner. I have been in Bernardo & Maria’s apartment. The cabinets, the fridge, the floor tiles, the bedspread. I burst in tears with the nostalgia. 👌🏽
Ansel Elg*rt is so talented but he’s bringing this movie down. Not only that but the accusations are damning & undeniable
Anonymous people make claims with no substantiation; he denies them. That’s your definition of “damning & undeniable”? 18 months later still no statements from the supposed girls’ parents, no police report, no pressed charges, no nothing.
@@0812820 So why did he disappear off the face of the internet up until WSS promo if he has nothing to be guilty about huh?
@@_jolie_ Your question is idiotic. Maybe he did because social media is a sewer of know-nothing scolds and bullies like you.
@@0812820 sure, because being an "innocent" rich white man is sooooo hard
@@_jolie_ It seems believable. But "consensual until it wasn't" is muddy waters. It can be proven that he is an insensitive d-bag, but that's him and every other dude who used the leverage of being famous or attractive to get sex. It would be much worse if this had led to more accusers.
Ariana DeBose absolutely stole the show for me. As soon as "A Boy Like That" finished I was in awe at her performance during that rollercoaster of a moment she feels.
She and Mike Faist definitely had more presence than the two main stars of the movie.
@@geraldobrien7323 Mike Faist and Ariana were TERRIFIC in their Roles of Riff and Anita, as was David Alvarez, as Bernardo, but we're going to have to agree to disagree about the main couple, Ansel Elgort, as Tony and Rachel Zegler, as Maria!
I thought THEY we're EQUALLY as TERRIFIC!!
So excited to hear how happy this made you! Next weekend and the week after are gonna be very happy indeed between this and NWH. Thanks, Dan!
This was long my most anticipated movie of the year and I am so excited for it. Excellent Review as always, thanks for bringing attention to the film!
Just saw the movie. Amazing, from the choreography, production design and music, and meant to watch on the big screen. Spielberg undeniably one of the best director.
1:30 - Dan either missed a great Spielberg joke or intentionally swerved around it.
The line should have been "Directors are so focused on whether they CAN, they don't stop to think of they SHOULD."
Just watched it on Disney+, and I was also not sure if it would work, but my God it is INCREDIBLE. I was surprised to actually feel that it was actually better than the original, and believe me I love the original (have it on VHS, then DVD, then Blu Ray, finally on streaming and have the original album) so yes I love it. But this is great also. Bravo
I had no desire to see this movie until I listened to your review. It reminds me why good film criticism is so important still.
Been looking forward to this review all week! Glad to hear some good news, especially since everyone I talked to wasn't excited for this (they think Spielberg is tapped out and has no more gems in him)!
I like how you were able to make your temporary setup look like something you designed and not just a random room.
Also, good luck in the Scmoedown tomorrow! I hope it's one for the ages!
Just watched this movie and it was great!!!. I enjoyed the original West Side Story and this New Version from one of my favorite produces Steven Spielberg was definitely not disappointing. Living in New York in the 60s in the South Bronx it brought about a lot of memories as I remember playing stick ball in a dead end street, between several 6 story buildings and using the parked vehicle fenders and bumpers as baseball bases. The soft balls bouncing off the tall 6 story structures as we would run at full speed to catch the ball before it dropped to the floor, sometimes we would dangerously launching over obstacles to make the catch(DOM LOL) but fun. I want to give the movie a plus as there were no Spanish Captions on screen when the actors spoke in Spanish(WOW). The actors Latino NY PR cultural genre was of what I remember growing up hearing with friends and family, that almost made it feel a private joke for those in the audience like myself that spoke both English and Spanish and understood the comical language that was used at the time (60s and 70s). Fell in love Rachel Zegler a mix Hispanic actress and soon to be a "STAR"... The movie was funny , entertaining, romantic and full of energy. Would definitely recommend to see. (A+)
I wouldn't really consider this a remake of the original film, but a second adaptation of Sondheim's Broadway stage musical.
Odd that you call it “Sondheim's” musical. He only wrote the words. He’s a genius lyricist but the extraordinary music was Leonard Bernstein.
I still have my doubts about "Somewhere" being given to Rita Moreno. I am such a huge fan of hers, but I always considered this song as an important moment for the couple and I was waiting for next generations to learn this song through the power of the love story.
I loved this change, but I think you have to know and love the 1961 version for it to be as weighty and meaningful as I felt it was. In that moment, I saw Moreno as Anita again, having lived a long life, and there was a beautiful combination of hope and sadness in the way she sang. That said, I missed hearing Maria sing those lines in the final scene.
Same … I was disappointed that she half talked it and for me it was the worst part of the movie. As a huge fan of the original, I was sceptical for this remake but having just seen it - wow! Really enjoyed it. Mike Faist as Riff is stunning! This remake is grittier and darker and for me, the dancing whilst still fab, isn’t as balletic (which was the best part of the original movie) as I would’ve liked but it’s still fab chorey. Ansel’s singing was really fab and Cool being reimagined was amazing!!!!
@@soniachapple3141TOTALLY agree!!
It is wild that for the 2nd time Dan throws down a glowing review to a musical I had very little interest in seeing and now I'm on board! First In the Heights which I was middling on, and that turned out to be excellent. Now West Side Story of which I was 100% on the side of "why are we doing this, just leave it alone!" and now damnit I have to figure out if I can get the spouse into a theater or if I'll be forced to wait for On Demand!
So glad to hear this! I was worried - now I definitely want to see it!
I appreciate your insight. I'm a huge fan of this old film, and am deeply moved by this remake, but it was nice to hear from you why this movie worked so well!
great review, i loved the film! just a note: spielberg wasn't trying to remake the 1961 film adaptation, he wanted to do his own interpretation of the stage show, so technically this isn't a remake of the classic film but a different take on the source material altogether :)
And technically both the stage play book and the play were credited, but not the 1961 film.
Just saw this movie. I didn’t want to watch any reviews because I didn’t want the experience colored in any way. The original movie was one that made me fall in love in musicals. I am SOOO glad I watched it this one, I totally agree, it was so worth remaking. Not to replace (that could never happen) but to build on the original.
YES! The best movie of the year! The best movie I have seen in a long time! Scene by scene perfection. Genuinely magical!
Yeess!! Love hearing the Zegler praise! 💗
I totally agree. I love the use of Spanish by the actors. Adds to the authenticity of the characters.
Good to hear. I was sceptical when I watched the trailer. What you described is everything I want in a musical and what I haven’t really seen in most of the last 30 yrs of film musicals.
So glad that you liked it because I have been looking forward to seeing this from the first trailer tease. The original is one of my all-time favorite films and I have seen 3 different stage versions. So I will be in the theater for the first time since the pandemic, seeing this West Side Story on the big screen.
Love this review, I think you were spot on! I agree this is one of the best film of 2021 if not the best! I am just in awe of everything about it and I’ve been on a cloud since seeing it … twice!
Saw it Friday with my 16 yo daughter in a theater with those big reclining seats. I handed her a bunch of napkins and said, "this is for the crying parts." And, oh, there are crying parts. We loved it! Smart, funny, sexy, joyous, tragic... It was visually stunning and, I think, even more relevant than ever. Ariana DeBose is the real stand-out for me, but everyone was fantastic. The songs have been on a loop in my head for three days.
I just discovered you today and this is a very fine, detailed review. Subscribed!
I'm glad to hear the good review. I was a bit worried since the trailers really seemed to lean away from the music which is concerning for a musical. After watching this review, I'll have to go watch it tonight, tonight.
Oh wait ... the earliest screening is on the 9th.
I hope that either Mike, Ariana, or Rachel get some type of award. All three of them were incredible. The emotion of all three of them and Ariana and Mike’s dancing was so satisfying to watch and Rachel’s vocals were off the charts.
I was skeptical about this going in, but after finally seeing it, I think Spielberg handily outdoes the original in a variety of ways. Visually it’s on another level, and the music is incredibly composed. I also think the restructuring of the story works wonders for this film, dramatically-speaking.
I was really curious about your reveille because I know how much you like Spielberg. West Side Story is my favorite musical and Spielberg is my favorite director. I've been looking forward to this for years now and love hearing how much you enjoyed it, somehow I'm even more excited.
Just randomly came on your page Dan. Your scepticism was the same as mine. So pleased you loved it and sure I will too! Will check out your site brilliant review not of film as such but your analysis 😎
Loved it-and expected to hate it since I REVERE the original!
Awesome review. I was in one of the many touring companies of West Side Story and million years ago when I was a young dancer and watching this reimagined remake of this classic made me scream BRAVO !!! This is a new classic and I am thankful for your opinion.
Man, I SO agree. I was in tears many times during the movie. Spielberg is my here, he has been since I saw E.T. back in 1983, when I was 10 years old. Never stopped loving his work. And now, my favorite musical directed by my favorite director. Soooo glad
So excited for this movie. As a lover of West Side Story, a film fan, and a Latina I cannot wait!
This review just totally nails it! Thank you so much Dan.
Damn Dan! I completely wrote this remake off. You have me intrigued and I will definitely make an effort to see this in theaters.
Thank you, Dan. I am an ENORMOUS fan of the original; I do think that it is a perfect film. When I heard it was being remade, I was genuinely angry. Why does everything need to be a remake? I was sure I was going to skip this one. But I admittedly think all of the trailers for it are great, and it does look good. But knowing that you - as a film and theater fan and really understanding where recent movie musicals have gone wrong - I think I’ll be taking myself on a movie date this Friday.
I'm so very ready for this...
Spielberg has said he based this on the play, not in any way based on the previous film adaptation. So, if musical numbers are omitted or if they are in a different order than the previous film that's because that wasn't his reference for this movie.
I hope that a director of the stature of Speilberg making a musical and really bringing all his skill to to the endeavour, using not only top notch cinematography, but also really good choreography and most of all *performers that can SING and DANCE* as well as act will put a stop to the awful adaptations we've seen lately. (cough Les Miserables cough Cats cough)
Same.
Exactly I'm so sick of celebrities who can't sing being cast in musicals
I didn't think Les Mis was that bad, though it had its problems (I think Toby Hooper's direction being the biggest culprit).
@@titanguy7316 The singing was often atrocious but not becuase of bad singers but his insistence of them doing it live (so stupid). And his unimaginative way of filning it hurt the experience. Yhat's why I'm happy a director of Spielberg's status is stepping in to raise the bar for future musical adaptations. This is how it's done! Not the Toby "I look down on musicals" Hopper way
@@MariaVosa IMO some of the challenges with a musical Les Mis film are baked into and peculiar to *that* show. The story had to be made stagey to fit in the theater. Putting it back on film is like translating from French to English back to French. And then throw in the live performance... however, it didn't bother me nearly as much with that musical style as it would with almost anything else.
The project was regarded as successful, though...
The identity of the show that gets adapted matters a lot. Maybe few enough people have seen the products of the MGM musical machine that they can be profitable again?
Another Spielberg classic? Or another 2010 Spielberg blockbuster “bust”? Let’s find out!
Thanks for the amazing review Dan. This is my first time viewing your channel since I just watched the movie. This is one of my favorite movies of all time (though I'm not an avid movie watcher), and I agree with all of your points. Earned my subscription!
Also like you said, this was my first time seeing either of the two films. From a new watcher's perspective. who didn't know the 1961 movie even existed, perhaps the movie was that much more incredible because I was really watching it for the first time. I think people who criticize it by comparing it to the original production should instead be looking at it as its own piece of art-because after all a good movie should be one thats enjoyable, not one that perfectly honors the original production.
Why did people doubt Spielberg still? If you look at bridge of spies and Lincoln they are more mature films than the majority of the films he made in his early career
I personally think people doubt Spielberg due to his last 3 movies (BFG is bad. The post is ok. I think ready player one is pretty good, but it wasn't the mega hit it should have been.) As well as the internet's general feeling of 'oh no, a remake of a beloved property. Its automatically terrible"
@@Weaponator18 I didn’t think the BFG was that bad but the problem it has is that it’s a bit too English for its own good. The Post I remember liking but thinking that this is only going to appeal to people who like straight dramas and ready player one I enjoyed but I know it wasn’t high art it was stupid fun. I do think people think with Spielberg now if it isn’t breaking massive box office records it’s bad. And something like The Post was never going to be a massive hit and Ready Player One possibly should have been but I don’t know if the marketing sold a story. It just showed action.
As someone who has never seen the original. I love this movie the musical number were really alive and the heart was beating through every scene. The fact he made it look so simple is a Hugh testment to his talent
Wow, ok! I was pretty skeptical but you've convinced me to check it out!
HELL YESS!!! SO EXCITED! have seen the orginal too!
Great review, I'm afraid people won't go see it though because of so much competition from other movies. A stacked December for sure!
December films can have great legs, though. January is typically a slow month, and West Side Story will be exclusively in theaters, for quite some time. There's plenty of room, during this period.
In my country, I have to wait until Boxing Day, 26 December when it opens. I'm super keen!
Such a great review and I agree at all points. I loved the update/recontextualization of the plot within its time. Thank you as always for being so honest and passionate--and being able to admit when you are wrong, which is no small thing on the internet.
Dan glad you didn't spoil the ending!
Sounds like everyone is wonderfully cast save for Tony. You gotta have an exceptional voice to play Tony, “Maria” is a full on operatic aria more or less (Bernstein himself casting Jose Carreras for the definitive sound track) and from every bit I have heard he simply doesn’t have the chops.
He doesn't, wrongfully cast 😕
That was solely a studio recording (not a soundtrack) with Carreras as Tony and Kiri Te Kanawa as Maria. She was heavenly in "One Hand, One Heart". The making-of documentary of the recording can viewed on CZcams.
I love Ansel's version of Maria.
I want to see this movie on opening night, but my friend is making me wait to see it with him on Sunday. I know I'm going to love it.
Why did the algorithm take so long to find you?? Great Great content!!
My birthday is December 12. We just got six tickets for that day! Can’t. Wait. My favorite musical, ever. So so so happy for Spielberg and company…
I’ve never seen OG version but the songs are famous - I recognize the tunes. I’m totally excited about seeing this and the trailers got me ready for it :)
My favorite movies of all time are remakes Oceans 11 and the 1999 Mummy. Remakes aren't bad you just need a talented team that actually wants to do it
So glad you loved this film too. Really bummed that a lot of people missed out during its opening weekend but I am hopeful through word of moth and once it drops on streaming that it’ll pick up in popularity.
Remake? I thought it was based on the play not the film.
It's adaptation no?
It's an adaptation
Thank you, I too have been sceptical about this remake and I'm delighted and relieved to hear your endorsement, I have done this musical professionally in 3 different productions and I felt so strongly and said the same thing, why would you do this, I can now look forward to watching this movie and embrace it.
Saw it today. Just so sad and so beautiful. Spielberg directed a great cast. If you never saw the play or the movie, this is fresh.
Dan.......You are kinda awesome! Thank you for the amazing reviews!
I just discovered your channel. I totally agree with you.. .I went reluctantly to see it and was blown away