Battle of Dacia Duster! 1.3 TCe 130 vs 1.5 dCI Snow Offroad
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 01. 2020
- Read Article: www.dustercooltravels.com/dac...
Programare Test Drive:
www.darex.ro
Tudor Avramii - 0758 106 671
tudor_avramii@darex.ro
Simona Broșteanu - 0747017709
simona_brosteanu@darex.ro
Be my Patreon:
/ dct21
Please do not reupload my video! Share it so you can help my channel grow.
I put alot of effort for every video and I hope you enjoy every one of it!
Thank you!!!
Duster in the Snow Videos: • Duster In The Snow
Duster vs Other SUV's: • Duster Vs Other SUVs
Follow me on Facebook:
/ duster-cool-travels-42...
/ duster.trails
Follow me on Instagram: @dustercooltravels
Song 1: Bonjour by Peyruis
/ peyruis
Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported - CC BY 3.0
Free Download / Stream: bit.ly/bonjour-peyruis
Music promoted by Audio Library • Bonjour - Peyruis (No ...
peyruismusic-74.webself.net/
Song 2: Jarlie - Voices
open.spotify.com/artist/71W5a...
/ jarliemusic
/ jarlie - Auta a dopravní prostředky
Both cars are excellent in my opinion! I am very proud this car is made in Romania! Its an excellent car ( for this price) . Congrat. for ur video! Keep it up!
Thank you for this beautiful impression.
You really are a true Dacia Duster ambassador. Dacia should support you!
I have seen almost all of your videos.
Every time beautiful images in a beautiful landscape.
I'm a little jealous of that.
thank you for the kind words!. You should visit these places if you like them so much!!:D
This is driver vs driver not engine vs engine.
Also the tires, people think AT tires are great, but in reality their snow braking length is much longer than winter or even all seasons.
inexperienced drivers... i mean,17" wheels in off road and locking the wheels while going down? nope... that is a big no.... the difference in the weight it is not that big, 74kg less for the tce.... the torque it is not that different either, 250(yes,250Nm not less) for the tce and 260 for the dci BUT, 250Nm from 1700rpm and 260Nm from 1750rpm.....anyway, this is the first 1.3 tce in off-road that i see and it did better than expected....
I can add nothing that already has not been said....👍 thumbs up for the interesting field test....
thank you!!!
From the first ascent my feeling was that 1.5 dci had weaker grip. You used the tires offfroad this winter a lot. The 1.3 had new tires for sure.
You should test with identical tires. Cooper tends to be more adequate for mud then snow, is not really a snow tire. Also same driver on both will give us a better understanding.
Will do that when I get a 150 HP 4x4 Duster 😁
Great video, thnx
How would the new 1.0 Turbo do in these conditions?
Maybe it is the fact that the duster with the petrol engine is lighter than the duster with diesel engine.
Which engine is more durable?
Conteaza si experienta in drum dificil. Succes
Excellent video, i was always suspecting that TCE will perform better and now we have evidence.. TCE has longer 1st gear with more HP up near the rev limit, which helps momentum in steep uphill climbs like the first one we saw. TCE clear winner. Apart from this even the winter tyres seem to grip better than cooper which is strange given the fact that the soil is not frozen and beneath there is mud...
Both cars have identical gear boxes with same ratio. The main difference is the RPM higher in TCE (more than 5000) comparing to Diesel and this allows to maintain de box on the same gear longer.
Don't forget the weight of the Diesel one which is higher than of the TCE (lighter aluminium engine).
Plus the tyres quality and the experience of the driver on these conditions; the diesel driver should have used the 2nd/3re gear when feeling that the car is losing momentum, but instead keeps forcing the climbing in gear 1 or 2 (noted by the sound of the engine).
TCE 130 has 240 Nm of torgue comparing 260 on Diesel and sometimes when climbing more aggresive is good to lose some torgue by shifting upwards on higher gear so that the contact ground/wheel is maintained better.
@@TheSpeedlow I think it was about the tires. Honestly, I am sorry i didn't use the winter tires on my duster. Next time, when I get my hands on a 150 HP 4WD 1.3 TCe Duster:D
AT nie robią na śniegu.
hello - Debica tires surprised me - I was born in this city :) but ... I have a Coopey discoverer At3 - I have access to the house 4m up a steep mountain in the summer on stones and in winter you know snow and ice.
Cooper was cool for 2-3 years later, as if they were worn out more slippery - especially on wet asphalt - I was wondering about the new version of the Cooper AT2 4s - do you have a comparison of AT3 with AT3 4s or maybe geolander g015 is a better universal all-season tire - I will appreciate your feedback
please join the Dacia Duster Trails & Technical group on facebook. Search there about these tires and you will find informations. I only used the Cooper AT3 4S.
Testul corect ar fi fost dacă ambele mașini ar fi avut exact același tip de cauciucuri, dar, dincolo de acest aspect, cred că Duster-ul pe benzină e mai ușor...
215 tires, both? I think it's a mix of torque (in this case less is better) and weight.
...by the way: a FIAT Panda with Steyr-Puch 4x4 (the old 4WD system) and 155 offroad tires goes literally everywhere - 740 Kg mass ;-)
The petrol looked better and balanced, great video.
Indeed the petrol was somehow lighter on the snow 😁
I will buy a used 1.5 dCi 4x4 from 2015, what tires are the best? these cooper at3 4s are the best in normal class but any simexx could be better foe offroad? the computer won't disable 4x4 with non standard tire characteristic?
The computer will disable 4x4 in some cases, I read something about the 4WD system disabling when the oil from the differentials is warming up. The tires alone can't get the the 4x4 system to disable.
The computer disables it when it heats up. Tires will help a bit because it needs to lock less often but the best thing you could do is use it on Auto and only temporarily on Lock when it doesn't work with auto.
@@pycanthusderossi4665 I also noticed that the 4WD Lock Mode is disabled after reaching a certain speed. On some forums it says that it is disabled after 40 km/h. Sometimes, when the car is stuck and you push the acceleration and the wheels are turning without moving the car, the speed will rise and then the 4WD will disable. The computer doesn't know how to make a difference between going on the road with a higher speed or when the car it's stuck and from acceleration you reach the speed, without any movement. 😁
@@Dougtroutfisher.4046 too late for me, put cooper discoverer at3 4s on mine 215/70 R16, but it is already 1cm bigger how yours could fit even in turns?
@@DusterCoolTravels I also noticed that there is too big rpm on the tires when stuck, I don't know why no very low speed mode when stuck so computer won't disable 4wd mode also slower rotation could get you out from mud
A lot of difference to the way two drivers approach the path...obviously the tce has much more speed which is the key to such terrains
Interesanta comparatie! Totodata daca as fi putut (si sunt constient de limitarile administrative), as fi comparat ambele masini cu aceleasi anvelope si cu acelasi pilot...
cam greu de pus aceleasi anvelope pe ambele masini. Poate pe viitor sa fie o coincidenta:D
Amândouă mașini se descurca destul de bine in test,totuși dacă erau echipate cu anvelope de off-road se descurcau mult mai bine. Să aveți parte de ele cat mai mult și fără evenimente
Mulțumim!! 😁
Eu am ARO uită-te pe canalul meu de CZcams
Drivers are different ! Greetings from neighborhood, from Srbija (Serbia).
You guys certainly like your Dusters! I am thinking of buying one. I sat in one yesterday in the showroom. Big, aren't they? Thing is the Dacia dealer is next to the Renault dealer. I sat in a Clio. Lovely. The Duster? Oh my God, a big difference...but still something something attracts me to the Duster. The looks are nice. And the price is amazing for the size of the vehicle. Are they reliable? Does anything break or fall off inside? Please let me know. I am interested in a 1.3 petrol 4WD. Not the top spec.
Well, the 1.3 TCe engine is relatively new and I don't know about any problems of it. Mine is 1.5 Blue dCi and in 36000 km (my current mileage) I had a small problem with the ad-blue system, that was solved easy on warranty.
In such cases, interference is not allowed for several factors that can make a difference,...but also the 86 kg. weight gain for diesel has influenced behavior and performence,...
Un test corect este atunci când cele doua mașini au și aceleași cauciucuri și jante
Eu am ARO uită-te pe canalul meu de CZcams
Un test corect era sa fiu eu sofer, astia urca cu treapta 1 blana 🤦♂️da.i coaie de jos a doua 😒
@@adelingaspar2903 da
@@farzanarp îți place?
Cit a fost consumul benzinar vr. diesel?
Consum afisat la 1.3 - 7.7. Consum afisat la dCI - 5.9.
Cool movies, we like you. More engine sound less music;)
Eu cred că la panta aceea ..daca era nevoie de viteza....și mă refer la 1.5 dci. Putea să ruleze in treapta 2(care este destul de scurta și are destul de multa putere) și astfel nu mai rupea aderenta atât de rău. Mașinile sunt aproape identice..... Doar stilul de condus diferă.
Great DusterS ....
Do they use ESP or not?
No, the Esp was Off all the time.
Sunt curios la Duster ul diesel cu ce treapta de viteza a încercat sa urce ?
cu treapta a doua. La fel am reusit si eu sa urc intr-un video anterior, exact in acelasi loc. cu treapta 1 nu am avut nicio sansa.
@@DusterCoolTravels asa ma gândeam si eu...cu treapta 1 nicio sansa
Dizel belli bir devirden sonra sarmaya başlıyor, benzinli en yuksek devire kadar sarma yapmaz. Benzinli her zaman avantajlı tabiki
Frumusel video dar comparatia dintre benzinar si diesel irelevanta in acest caz.Anvelopele,soferii,greutatea masinii(diesel e mai greu cu aproape 200kg) fac diferenta.Nu stiu de ce dar parca diesel-ul 'sa lasat' batut....orisicum succes in continuare,frumos ce faci,poate ne intalnim cand vin pe acasa la Sv.Îl probam si pe al meu Dusterica🧐😉
Nu s-a lasat, urmeaza un video cum am facut un drag race pe un deal, cred ca anvelopele de pe benzinar au facut diferenta. da-mi add pe facebook si vorbim pentru o iesire, cand ajungi prin Sv. Bafta!
@@DusterCoolTravels Succes🙂
Inexperienced drivers.
On slippery roads light weight and less torque is advantage so 1.3 climbs better.
Salutare,prin ce zona este filmat videoclipul?
Salut, pe dealurile dintre Pătrăuți și Dărmănești.😁
Fain clip, câți km ai parcurs cu ea până acum și ce probleme ai avut cu ea ( dacă ai avut) . Mulțumesc, te salut 🤝
Ms, am 35.000 de km. Doar o problema la sistemul ad-blue, care s-a rezolvat prin soft. O folosesc zi de zi, sunt foarte multumit de ea:D
@@DusterCoolTravels ce ai recomanda intre benzinar si diesel?
@@alatroyt652 le-am condus pe amândouă, la benzinar trebuie avut în vedere consumul mai mare ca la diesel și faptul că motorul este relativ nou și încă nu se cunosc eventualele probleme. Eu cred că tot pe diesel aș merge, chiar mi-a plăcut foarte mult cum s-a comportat dusterul pe benzină la test drive. 😁
@@DusterCoolTravels mulțumesc de raspuns. Ma tot uit la Duster si numai nu ma hotarasc intre benzina sau diesel.... Cum e etajata cutia la benzina fata de diesel? Simti diferenta?
@@alatroyt652 nu este nicio diferență între cutiile de viteze de la cele două modele, la versiunile cu 4x4. Poate la modelul pe benzină sunt un pic mai lungi, de la a 4-a în sus. În schimb, la modelul 4x2 pe benzină, vitezele sunt mult mai lungi. Asta mi-a plăcut foarte mult. Dacă vrei cu 4x4 chiar nu este diferență vizibilă.
Ăla din Dusterul albastru e șofer de Weekend
Ai perfecta dreptate
Daca îi dădea cu a 2-a din prima cu avans mai mare urca lejer
Have fun,nice adventure
Thank you very much!!! 😁
Ce noroc ai avut ca nu ai busit bara la arbustul ala! Masinile s-au comportat foarte bine avand in vedere anvelopele lor si faptului ca Duster-ul ofera un rulaj bun si on-road si off-road! Ce consumuri au la urcarile astea?
Cam cu 1-2 l mai mult dar având în vedere că de obicei facem doar 10-20 de km astfel, nu se observă diferența la un plin sau după câteva sute de km.
driving through the mountains, the diesel engine is always better than the gasoline engine, due to its better torque, in addition to its much lower consumption ... but, for the comparison to be fair, both cars should use the same type of tires which is a very, very important factor driving in cross country ...
You have to decide what you compare.Cars or tyres.You cant compare cars when each have different tyres.My advice is use secind gear.First is too slow and you only torture your engine.In snow you need quick wheelspin not crankshaft spin
👍
I think first climb's first 2 attempts of diesel was unsuccessful, because of driving
in the first he used only the 1st gear, so not enough power.
the bottom of the car touched the road and wheels were in the air, how to compare offroad like that? :)
This kind of trial must be done with the same Tires!!! What's the meaning???
Winter debica is better than cooper at
PS cooper is cheap compromise tire that probably does the job in most situations
now I konw. I didn't know the difference would be so significant between the tires.
@@DusterCoolTravels :))))))))))))))) Tires make most of the difference on any 4WD comparison test. Forget lockers etc. . . .
Contează mult de tot si şoferul. Se vede destul de clar, cel care conduce Duster-ul negru e mai putin experimentat. Nu abordeaza panta in cel mai potrivit mod. :)
Eu am ARO uită-te pe canalul meu de CZcams
DUSTER TEAM TÜRKİYEDEN GELEN YOMUUI
1.5 dCi the best
conteaza greutatea masinii, soferul cat e de nebun si in primul rand cauciucurile !
Eu am ARO uită-te pe canalul meu de CZcams
17 inch tyre is better than 16 inch tyre. I understand this from this video.
I think controlling throttle pedal of diesel Duster is harder than gasoline. Especially when ESP is off. Beacuse diesel engine has too much torque in less rpm range. On the other hand, gasoline engine have less torque but it have more rpm range, which gives driver has chance to drive without shifting gears. In my opinion, diesel Duster maybe could climb 1st hill at 1st attemp with 4th or 3th gear. It seems driver tried it with 2nd or 1st gear.
Why not put a set of Goodrich AT tyres on both vehicles and try again
Too expensive for one test. Buying two set of bfg AT, especially when just one car is mine. The other was on a weekend test drive from the dealership where I got my Duster😁
Duster Cool Travels did you tell the dealership you were climbing mountains with it 👍🏻😂 love the videos I think the duster is a great car, I go metal detecting and with my Goodrich tyres it will go anywhere a discovery will go 👍🏻
@@HammyHunting yes, they know and don't have anything against what I'm doing with the car😄thank you very much 😁
testul trebuia facut cu acelasi tip de anvelope. Este cam irelevant acest test. Dizelul are un mic + de cuplu dar este si mai greu deci sunt cam pe egale amandoua, este subiectiva alegerea, daca faci multi km pe an iei dci iar daca nu faci km sau esti fan benzina iei 1.3 tce. Eu unul as merge pe benzinar. Cred ca trage mai bine la mers de zi cu zi avand mai multi cai si fiind mai usor si totodata silentios, singurul semn de intrebare ramane fiabilitatea motorului,care inca nu se stie
Less music... and more engine rev
When u down 1.3 engine compressor is not enough to keep on way
Albul a plecat cu mai mult elan. Conteaza viteza.
Eu am ARO uită-te pe canalul meu de CZcams
You comparing two different engines, when drivers drives them like they both been petrol engines. In diesel you have really short first gear, and what I hear you didn't change it. Put second gear, on even third one, hold your rpm's 3000-4000 and diesel will have enough Nm to pull duster up this hill without any problems.
it did use the 2nd gear, but the tires didn't help on the diesel duster:D
Cred că este cel mai bun 4×4 din Europa și mai încolo...,
Tires make a difference...
And olso the driver:))
BENZİNLİ motor her türlü yolda kazanır
Cea mai mare necunoscuta e soferul si apoi cauciucurile. difernta de putere si mai ales de cuplu este zero pentru asrfel de test! VAX!
Se compară mere cu pere!
Întotdeauna o anvelopă de iarnă va avea mai mult succes pe zăpadă decât un 4s...
Glume ! Vin eu cu un dci echipat corespuzator !!!!
Te aștept cu drag. 😁ești din Suceava? 😁
@@DusterCoolTravels Din Brasov !
In off-road nu conteaza cuplul si reductia atat de mult. Conteaza puterea si turatia. Motorul pe benzinase tureaza mai mult
Cirstea Radu
Cu cat turezi mai mult cu ata sapi mai mult .
Diesel-urile astea noi am inteles ca sunt mai mofturoase si mai fac fite pe la unii posesori. Si eu sunt in dilema sa cumpar insa nu stiu ce sa aleg intre benzina si diesel. Parca as merge totusi pe benzina, 13tce, 130 cp, suficienti pt. mine, nu ma prea intereseaza cp cat ma intereseaza fiabilitatea.
Am Duster 1,5 dCi 2018, 110CP fara adblue. Mi se pare OK. De ce sunt mofturoase sau fac fite ??
@@stefanpopescu6479 am citit pe forumurile aferente modelului, mai multi posesori reclamau fel si fel in privinta motorului, dci-urile fara adblue au fost printre cele mai reusite motoare vreodata. De cand le-au introdus rahatul ala de adblue, inteleg ca sunt multe care fac nazuri. Da un search pe mr. google sa te convingi.
Depinde de cine se află la butoane,,,, Oricum Diesel ul e diesel nu acolo trebuie făcută comparația pe Transfăgărășan sau pe Transalpina pe asfalt încărcate la greutate maxima sau la sprint pe distanța scurtă 👍
Daca te intereseaza fiabilitatea cred ca 1.6 sce 115 aspirat e pt tine.
@@1mYsTeRYo nu se mai produce acea versiune decat variantele turbo. @Denis Posea, conteaza, nu zic, dar deja cand mai multi se plang de dci-urile cu adblue, devine suspecta treaba. :)
Diesel este mai greu cu 200 kg,
Duster 1,5 dCi - masa proprie 1405 kg, Duster 1,3 TCe 130CP - masa proprie 1331 Kg adica este mai greu cu doar 74 kg.
Eu am ARO uită-te pe canalul meu de CZcams
Yo hace dos meses me he comprado el Dacia Duster del 2023 y estoy contentísimo va de lujo y me encanta su línea robusta osea estoy enamorado de mi Dacia Duster que si Dios quiere será para años además yo cuido mucho los coches os recomiendo el Dacia Duster si puede ser la versión del 2023 tiene mejor motor
The tce has winter tires. So its unfair for the diesel one, which is known that is better in off road conditions
agree with you, I didn't know the difference would be so big. if I will get my hands on a 1.3 TCe 150 HP 4WD Duster, then I will use winter tires on my 1.5 Duster:D
Comparatiile astea sunt greu de facut. Terenul e foarte diferit la fiecare urcare, soferul accelereaza diferit, alege traiectorii diferite fata de celalalt... Mna, e greu sa faci. Eu zic ca 1.5 ul e in avantaj cu cuplul lui de jos.
Cauciucuri diferite, soferi diferiti, rezultate diferite. Sistemul de tractiune e acelasi, iar diesel-ul are cuplu mai potent, deci ar fi trebuit sa se descurce mai bine in offroad. Daca nu asta a fost rezultatul, eu unul cred ca de vina au fost cauciucurile (cele dedicate de zapada au rezultate mai bune pe terenul pt care au fost concepute decat niste cauciucuri gandite sa dea rezultate acceptabile pe toate felurile de teren). Pentru o comparatie realista, as zice ca soferul si cauciucurile sa fie comune pentru cele doua masini.
nu m-am asteptat sa fie asa mare diferenta. si nu am mai avut timp sa pun anvelope de iarna pe dusterul meu si sa mai mergem o data pe aceleasi trasee. astept una de 150 CP cu motor 1.3 si atunci o sa pun anvelope de iarna si pe a mea.:D si acelasi sofer pe ambele cand le incercam:D
it is the weight of the vehicle as well, diesel is heavier more that 200 kilos !!
Well, I didn't know that until now and I see that this weight difference is a deal breaker in offroad. In my next video you will see a drag race uphill between the cars😁
Diesel is havier with just 74 kilos.
if petrol engine win,
diesel lover : engine more heavier,less hp,etc...bla..bla..bla..
if diesel engine win,
petrol lover : quiet and no reason
На сером дустере резина -дерьмо ..
Tyres don't look great for that track
Slabe rău Dusteurile, cu ARO al meu zburam pe acolo!
Si ARO e slab, eu cu G63 6x6 zburam si mai tare pe acolo.
@@pycanthusderossi4665 ai tu G63??
Si ils sont neuf j’aimerais pas être le prochains proprio
pour quoi?:D
1.5 DCİ ❤🧡💛💚💙🖤❤🤍
test is highly irrelevant as it only reveals the experience of drivers, nothin else.
Возможно Рено хочет отказаться от дизеля , по этому пропагандирует турбо малолитровые моторы
Alexander,in Russia do you have Renault!In Romania it is Dacia!Dacia Duster is better then Renault Duster!
DEPINDE SI DE SOFER!
الديزل أفضل
Предвзятый тест чтобы обосрать дизель!
The 1.3 was the clear winner
Mai baieti, Dusterul nu e vehicol offroad.... :)) Aveti grija sa nu va răsturnati... :))
Vrei sa zici ca masinile dedicate pentru offroad se rastoarna mai greu sa ce? Dimpotriva, au garda mai inalta si centrul de greutate mai sus majoritatea.
Резина на дизельном Дастер хреновая
La motorașele astea mici cereți prea mult de la ele
Eu nu înțeleg un lucru de comentează străinii cum cacat n au experiența șoferii țin mașina pe drum merg cat de cat bn vb străinii care englezii sunt vai de capu lor sau nemții care sunt tarii doar in linie dreapta când vine o curba pe un drum național se face coada n spatele lor fiind șofer de tir știu ceea ce vorbesc.
white one was driven better, end of debate sadly.
Neskutečně týraný ty motory👎🏻
Pilote pas terrible 👎
M-i se pare o porcarie,1.3 pe ditamai masina,chiar daca dezvolta .....cai multi,este prea mic pentru un SUV,sincer sa fiu si 1.5 e mic pentru un Duster...dar se pare ca producatorul Daciei nu pune pret prea mare pe lucrurile astea...nu mai vorbim de design interior ca exteriorul este unul ok.....totusi sunt 20.000 de mi si ceva de €€€€€
Eu cred că motorul de 1.5 este suficient pentru drumurile noastre. 😁
Duster nu e "ditamai" masina, nu e un SUV ca celelalte, avand in vedere ca varianta diesel cu tractiune integrala (adica cea mai grea) are 1,4 tone. Este suficient 1.5 diesel de 110 cp sau 1.3 turbo benzinarul de 130 cp. Eu am SUV coreean benzinar aspirat cu tractiune integrala si are 1,6 tone. Cam asa trebuie sa aiba SUV-urile la clasa asta. Parerea mea. Numai sistemul de tractiune integrala creste masa cu 90-100 kg.
Mașini slabe
Da mașini care se tîrîie și sună,mobra mult spus mașină
Este adevarat ca atunci cand sufli in maini pe bicicleta, spui ca dusterul este slab😉
@@zoltanracz5799,serios,eu unul nu am vazut pana acum duster nou la 9500 euro dar stiti vorba aceea,Vulpea cand nu ajunge la struguri spune ca sunt acrii!😉