Disney's Doctor Who REVIEW - RIP Doctor Who

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 9. 05. 2024
  • LIVE review of Disney's Doctor Who Season 1 Episodes 1 and 2
    with @nerdrotic
    #Disney #DoctorWho
    Streamlab Donations LINK: streamlabs.com/sutrowatchtowe...
    Nerdrotic Merch Store!
    mixedtees.com/nerdrotic
    FNT T-Shirt!
    mixedtees.com/nerdrotic/frida...
    Sponsored by MetaPCs!
    For a discount, click on the link: www.metapcs.com/creator-nerdr...
    Sponsored by GEEK GRIND!
    Nerdrotic Blend Coffee from Geek Grind
    Use Promo Code "Nerdrotic" for 20% off:
    geekgrindcoffee.com/products/...
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 1K

  • @S4ns
    @S4ns Před 17 dny +161

    "I'm them"
    And I'm done.

    • @themonado5030
      @themonado5030 Před 16 dny +2

      Grow up

    • @StonyDilithium
      @StonyDilithium Před 15 dny +29

      @@themonado5030 He did. That's why he doesn't take childish fantasies like "pronouns" seriously. Take your own advice.

    • @SPM0717
      @SPM0717 Před 15 dny +5

      @@StonyDilithium And yet I guarantee if someone kept referring to Gary as "she/her" all the time in person he'd get pretty pissed off because those aren't his pronouns.

    • @GregorySnipe
      @GregorySnipe Před 15 dny +4

      ​@@StonyDilithiumyou used three pronouns in your comment.

    • @StonyDilithium
      @StonyDilithium Před 15 dny

      @@SPM0717 Problem is, Gary is an actual biological male. That is a fact. The people who complain about using pronouns as a personal identifier are trying to force the world into accepting fantasy. There is a difference.

  • @kevinpope1297
    @kevinpope1297 Před 17 dny +134

    Capaldi was wasted as the doctor so much talent so much lack of writer talent.

    • @MrNovember41
      @MrNovember41 Před 12 dny +3

      Yes, but even then some of his episodes were well written and are the best Doctor Who we've ever witnessed. There was just a lot of filler episodes they gave to token writers who regularly deliver stinkers.

    • @Trev359
      @Trev359 Před 12 dny +1

      I agree. The Capaldi era was, for me, when things started to go wrong (nothing to do with Capaldi). I didn't like the writing style at all. IMO, in three seasons there were only half a dozen decent episodes.

    • @bjornreichert1401
      @bjornreichert1401 Před 12 dny +3

      No. Capaldi was fantastic, best doctor and some of the greatest episodes ever. But Doctor Who ended with Capaldi - at least for me.

    • @kevinpope1297
      @kevinpope1297 Před 11 dny +1

      @@bjornreichert1401 I am saying he could have been shouild have been this generations doctor but they started the agenda.

    • @JRRLewis
      @JRRLewis Před 11 dny +3

      I don't care what the consensus is, Peter Capaldi is my favorite New Who Doctor and I really liked most of his episodes in seasons 8 & 9 and some of the ones in 10. And I think Heaven Sent is the single best episode in the show's history. Of course, I also thought Moffat was a better showrunner (and a much better writer) than Russel T. Davies, which is of course not the consensus, but I imagine more people are coming over to my side at this point about Davies...
      Capaldi spent most of his final episode saying he wasn't going to regenerate, and in retrospect I really, really wish his doctor didn't change his mind at the end. An adventure with the 1st Doctor would have been a fitting place to end the entire show for good.

  • @S-T-E-V-E
    @S-T-E-V-E Před 16 dny +26

    I've come to realise that them re-writing old beloved franchises isn't about laziness or not having any original ideas it's about destroying everything that straight white men love , that's the goal!

    • @Ewil.Bluetooth
      @Ewil.Bluetooth Před 13 dny +4

      I'm glad more people are finally starting to admit that.

  • @jmace2424
    @jmace2424 Před 15 dny +100

    “No one grows up wrong.”
    The real Doctor went literally back in time and changed how a man grew up in A Christmas Carol.

    • @tptk6659
      @tptk6659 Před 15 dny +11

      *Davros has entered the chat* 😋

    •  Před 15 dny +8

      John Lumic also aka the Cybus Cyber Controller.

    • @optominatorbd6596
      @optominatorbd6596 Před 11 dny

      in utopia as well, the doctor literally tells jack that his existence is wrong

    • @AstroTom
      @AstroTom Před 3 dny

      Gosh that episode made me cry

  • @Zanroff
    @Zanroff Před 17 dny +143

    Why they never explored the Doctor's daughters is beyond me. They had ample opportunities to create a "diverse" spin-off without touching the doctor himself. But evil can not create, only destroy.

    • @bjornskivids
      @bjornskivids Před 17 dny +5

      Because unless they're timelords with magical Tardises also, it would be too hard for Disney to write contrivances for.
      They rely on "tardises" and "multiverses". Without them, they'd have to hire skilled writers instead of kids out of college that will push narrative for 1/10th the salary

    • @Zanroff
      @Zanroff Před 17 dny +4

      @@bjornskivids Not sure I understand. You know about the episode "The doctor's daughter"? I'm not specifically talking about Disney. I meant instead of making the Doctor a person of female persuasion and destroying the show completely.

    • @purefoldnz3070
      @purefoldnz3070 Před 17 dny

      what do you mean evil cannot create?

    • @BlindIdiotGaming
      @BlindIdiotGaming Před 16 dny +3

      Yes, it always seemed strange they simply left her behind. I seem to recall she did pop up in a single episode later, though... Unless, that's just something I remember thinking would happen... lol

    • @themonado5030
      @themonado5030 Před 16 dny

      You are such a baby. Grow up

  • @blankadams3120
    @blankadams3120 Před 17 dny +96

    "That's my daddy!"
    Spoken with all the conviction of a child whose father has been legally required to stay miles away from the child he was beating.

    • @magic_manl2572
      @magic_manl2572 Před 14 dny +2

      So is it a man or woman or neither?

    • @JohnM...
      @JohnM... Před 14 dny +1

      @@magic_manl2572it’s something straight out of One Flew over the Cuckoo’s nest….

    • @Detwhat
      @Detwhat Před 13 dny +1

      ​​@@JohnM...Nah, RP MacMurphy would destroy them..along with The Chief.

  • @christaberit
    @christaberit Před 18 dny +227

    The moment I saw the clip of him wearing his kilt incorrectly; no sporran, no kilt socks, no flashings, no kilt pin, no ghillie brogues etc, I knew it was over. Talk about disrespecting culture.

    • @TheGodOfGravy
      @TheGodOfGravy Před 17 dny +36

      “Hai guys! I’m totes Scottish!”

    • @terrystewart1973
      @terrystewart1973 Před 17 dny

      Isn't that all cultural misappropriation. I thought progressives thought that was a bad thing? I'm losing track at this point

    • @TheDetectiveEngineer
      @TheDetectiveEngineer Před 17 dny +14

      ​@@TheGodOfGravyI could imagine Az saying that

    • @Whiskey0880
      @Whiskey0880 Před 17 dny +3

      While the kilt is worn by scots, i wonder how many of them know it's an english invention.

    • @christaberit
      @christaberit Před 17 dny +26

      @@Whiskey0880 the modern military style kilt is but not the original great kilt or feileadh mòr.
      Either way he and the BBC obviously aren’t interested in respecting British culture.

  • @kennifcale480
    @kennifcale480 Před 17 dny +65

    Ncuti threw a tantrum and twerked to get the role of Doctor Who. He literally admitted that.

    • @Luffy2023-uh6ij
      @Luffy2023-uh6ij Před 16 dny +17

      Oh, I think he did more than twerk to get that role of Doctor Who.

    • @swanvictor887
      @swanvictor887 Před 14 dny

      yup....nearly wore out his knees....@@Luffy2023-uh6ij

    • @markp4767
      @markp4767 Před 14 dny

      ​@@Luffy2023-uh6ijYep - it takes one to know one 💋💋💋

  • @JamesSmith-qk1tz
    @JamesSmith-qk1tz Před 17 dny +129

    My mum is in her late 60s and grown-up loving doctor who and was excited about the Xmas special and her face was priceless watching it got about 15 minutes in and she never swears but she just said WTF is this and turned it off she was mortified still Don't think She's gotten over it now

    • @PatstarDeluxe
      @PatstarDeluxe Před 17 dny +13

      That's funny.... but absolutely tragic too.

    • @biggusdickus5986
      @biggusdickus5986 Před 16 dny

      I'm 67 watched the very first ever in 63, and like your mum l said something similar in the vein of whats this f"*:'* Sh*t

    • @martyevans1
      @martyevans1 Před 16 dny +1

      Did she watch 2005-2017 doctor who?

    • @merylmel
      @merylmel Před 15 dny +14

      I'm 60 and fuming! They killed it and I'll never forgive them.

    • @blakecasimir
      @blakecasimir Před 15 dny +4

      Just go back through classic Who again. This show is dead, and died with Capaldi.

  • @captbuckyohare5585
    @captbuckyohare5585 Před 17 dny +110

    "Wait. They force you to have babies and then won't help you look after them?!"
    "I know. It's a very strange planet."
    "Well... not that strange."
    Really clever and biting topical stuff there. Subtle like brick in the face.

    • @theofficialretardschanneld1260
      @theofficialretardschanneld1260 Před 16 dny

      Nothing like highlighting a very real world issue

    • @kaalesrex2933
      @kaalesrex2933 Před 15 dny

      I wonder who forces them to have unprotected sex with men that aren't father material

    • @sebicmiel4221
      @sebicmiel4221 Před 15 dny +1

      Not sure if this is a line from the show or just Nerdrotic being -rrrracist- "funny"

    • @fredericbento630
      @fredericbento630 Před 15 dny +4

      really subtle indeed...... and thats with this kind of topics that they're killing the show.... Zero creativity, none at all... using stuff we can hear daily on the news to make episodes.... Next episode will probably be "Doctor Who in Gaza" ......... ffs....

  • @Daminous_Games
    @Daminous_Games Před 18 dny +183

    The Doctor died with Capaldi and his final words ring true in every way, and there is no way this is all Disney's input as the interviews, the paid for reviews and the attacking of fans all comes from the BBC, RTD and the cru-babies. RIP Doctor Who!

    • @captbuckyohare5585
      @captbuckyohare5585 Před 17 dny +13

      Right down to the moment JW tries to fly the TARDIS, and the old girl says "the fuck you will" and hoofs Dr Karen outta there.
      That's it. That's the end.

    • @jkdbuck7670
      @jkdbuck7670 Před 17 dny +5

      Capaldi was my favorite.

    • @MarkGast
      @MarkGast Před 17 dny +5

      If Dr. Who is ever revived it should start with that regeneration.

    • @Zanroff
      @Zanroff Před 17 dny +7

      I wish Capaldi's doctor was written a little better, but I still loved him!

    • @Daminous_Games
      @Daminous_Games Před 17 dny +5

      @@Zanroff So true, as even any interview he does now he stated he hated what they were doing to his doctor and he said that his final speech was 100% his input as he put a final stamp on his doctor and stated he'd never return to the show after everything.

  • @MellowCorn-xs8bn
    @MellowCorn-xs8bn Před 18 dny +343

    So RTD doesn't want to associate disability with villainy but he's fine with associating drag/trans with villainy?

    • @mayotango1317
      @mayotango1317 Před 18 dny

      Is a homenage to Ursula?

    • @Lundarian1
      @Lundarian1 Před 18 dny +33

      Ding ding ding.

    • @captbuckyohare5585
      @captbuckyohare5585 Před 17 dny +48

      No. Because in RTDs head, thats not a man in drag. That's supposedly, actually, a woman.

    • @ItsaKindOfMagic86
      @ItsaKindOfMagic86 Před 17 dny +20

      he dont see it as villainy, he sees it as wronged and misunderstood

    • @captbuckyohare5585
      @captbuckyohare5585 Před 17 dny +17

      Aul Maestro will be a redeemed anti-hero by the end. RTD gonna try and pull a Missy.

  • @jasonsangwin4006
    @jasonsangwin4006 Před 18 dny +53

    "I'm them"
    Peace out.

  • @Kaweebo
    @Kaweebo Před 18 dny +196

    The Doctor died with Capaldi.
    And much like his incarnation, I say the same to this show.
    “I let you go.”

    • @mayotango1317
      @mayotango1317 Před 18 dny +2

      And is back and better.

    • @dragonback6075
      @dragonback6075 Před 18 dny +23

      RTD's rent boy (@mayotango) in the chat 🤢🤢🤢🤮

    • @mayotango1317
      @mayotango1317 Před 18 dny

      @@dragonback6075 Yeah, yeah, and X-Men 97 is woke trash. Piss off.

    • @mayotango1317
      @mayotango1317 Před 18 dny

      @@dragonback6075 Better that be a Moffat Hater.

    • @mayotango1317
      @mayotango1317 Před 18 dny +1

      @@dragonback6075 Whatever, Rose Tyler fanboy.

  • @kevinpope1297
    @kevinpope1297 Před 17 dny +86

    From Time Lord to Gay lord

    • @Concetta20
      @Concetta20 Před 17 dny +1

      😂😂😂😂

    • @Concetta20
      @Concetta20 Před 17 dny

      It’s sad. Ncuti had some charisma and testosterone in “Masters of the Air”.

    • @boytygaming4007
      @boytygaming4007 Před 13 dny

      😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @mikaclodgo5892
      @mikaclodgo5892 Před 11 dny

      Funny enough a lot of people forget that one of the original people who worked on classic Doctor who way back in 1963 was gay though closed at the time and if you're wondering who I don't remember the name

  • @pwgdeathhawk8146
    @pwgdeathhawk8146 Před 17 dny +19

    In the words of Capaldi “Doctor…I let you go”

  • @grokeffer6226
    @grokeffer6226 Před 16 dny +31

    Jon Pertwee's son, Sean Pertwee, would have made an excellent Doctor Who. This new guy seems just too creepy.

    • @aethersurfer6793
      @aethersurfer6793 Před 15 dny +8

      Good shout, always loved Sean. I’ve always hoped Idris Elba would be Dr Who (I think he’s slightly too old to be James Bond now). The doctor was always a mysterious, charming and powerful entity, I’d even hazard saying he’s meant to be a bit unpredictable and manic, he’d be perfect.

    • @RaymondWilliams-uu1ns
      @RaymondWilliams-uu1ns Před 14 dny +4

      @@aethersurfer6793 Well said. Paapa Essiedu would have been a good Doctor. Very good versatile actor but he’s straight so wouldn’t have been on RTDs radar. I think the show will cancelled by 2027. Which, while sad, is a good thing under the present BBC, who will never cast a white straight male in the role again. It will need the ending of the licence fee for BBC then needing to make a profit with getting bums on seats to change their current mind set of couldn’t give a Monkey’s attitude. Remember, Eastenders fell below a million viewers and they still wouldn’t stop the the constant plots about the LGBTQ community.

    • @MrDunkycraig
      @MrDunkycraig Před 13 dny

      Well said sir he would be excellent just like Gotham and dog soldiers

    • @sopronunciareglignocchi7255
      @sopronunciareglignocchi7255 Před 11 dny

      ​@@aethersurfer6793
      No, he wouldn't make a good doctor because he's Nigerian. Stop trying to earn virtue points.

  • @djb6313
    @djb6313 Před 17 dny +58

    I hated it. I love Dr Who. Been a Who-ver since the 70’s. This was not Dr Who.

    • @Concetta20
      @Concetta20 Před 17 dny +3

      Stick to Big Finish for more true Who.

  • @SteveyP73
    @SteveyP73 Před 17 dny +91

    In the UK my 7 year old daughter came home from school asking to watch the new Doctor Who (now, sadly, she'd never had any interest in DW before.) I said sure, but why did she want to see it now? Apparently promotional material for the new show was shown in her school during lessons. Gary is not wrong at all....

    • @geneangrypenguin5876
      @geneangrypenguin5876 Před 17 dny +31

      I would politely (or not so) ask why the school was selling advertising space to my child...

    • @Drew1365
      @Drew1365 Před 17 dny +34

      I would politely ask why the school is promoting a drag show to children?

    • @biggusdickus5986
      @biggusdickus5986 Před 16 dny

      ​@@Drew1365Promoting ? Now its probably compulsory 😂

    • @racheljames7
      @racheljames7 Před 16 dny +9

      Why did you say sure? Were you not aware of what propagandising filth the Christmas specials were? 7 years old, my goodness. 😢

    •  Před 15 dny

      So the Alphabet Mafia is doing the very things they accuse others of.
      They wanna brainwash kids like they say about the Church doing to kids.
      Bunch of groomer perverts need to stay away from kids.

  • @batguano2803
    @batguano2803 Před 17 dny +45

    OMFG as a brit im so sorry our once epic series has started to turn peoples brains to soup.

    • @lobalee1873
      @lobalee1873 Před 13 dny

      And I'm sorry as an American that our stupid Hollywood ideology has infested your country too. 😮‍💨

  • @indistinctchatter3501
    @indistinctchatter3501 Před 18 dny +65

    I hope to see a raw, unfiltered review of this episode by Reaper. "Christ, who wrote this?!"

    • @1977dclinton
      @1977dclinton Před 17 dny +7

      Yeah he probably will do one, if not surely drinker will have him on open bar, his takedown are epic.

    • @floriangeyer1
      @floriangeyer1 Před 16 dny +3

      Indeed. I am looking forward to Reaper's take.
      It will be epic.

    • @magic_manl2572
      @magic_manl2572 Před 14 dny +1

      He's an honest critical drinker

    • @rennmaxbeta
      @rennmaxbeta Před 14 dny

      "What the fck am I watching?"

  • @Tis_But_A_Scratch
    @Tis_But_A_Scratch Před 17 dny +40

    Remember watching Graham Norton with my wife and she asked 'who is THAT guy'. I said 'no joke - he's the new Dr Who.' Her answer summed it up, 'Oh ffs! Get to f!'

    • @Thomas-kp8mo
      @Thomas-kp8mo Před 16 dny

      Homophobic

    • @lenaoxton8827
      @lenaoxton8827 Před 16 dny +4

      Why did she have a problem with him without seeing him act??

    • @StonyDilithium
      @StonyDilithium Před 15 dny

      @@lenaoxton8827 Because it's 2024 and we all know it was a diversity hire. Facts.

    • @DaveLynchWriter
      @DaveLynchWriter Před 14 dny

      😂😂😂

    • @bookie5667
      @bookie5667 Před 14 dny

      ​@@lenaoxton8827is it because she's a bigot?

  • @The-OGRE
    @The-OGRE Před 14 dny +8

    The doctor's new sonic screwdriver looks like a late 90's MP3 player that only worked during the first set of batteries.

    • @DumbzaUseless
      @DumbzaUseless Před 14 dny +1

      It looks like some sort of dodgy sex device

  • @The_Desert_Hero
    @The_Desert_Hero Před 18 dny +131

    Watching Xray Girl doing squats would be more entertaining.

  • @wafive
    @wafive Před 15 dny +8

    Presumably the black space baby captains' father did not abandon her, he just went out to get some space cigarettes....

  • @user-un9go4qe5i
    @user-un9go4qe5i Před 17 dny +33

    RTD should never have come back. This sounds like my idea of TV hell. Such a shame.

    • @Gamefishing111
      @Gamefishing111 Před 14 dny

      Rocky balboa “should have never come back” clubber lang 1983

  • @KronosGodwisen
    @KronosGodwisen Před 17 dny +85

    This is painful.
    Made for children with lots of abortion, immigration and sexual identity politics.
    You can't spell mentally refarted without RTD.

    • @jamiebrown300
      @jamiebrown300 Před 16 dny +3

      Have you seen season 1(1963) lately? Have you seen series 1(2005) lately? Both of those has tons of messages and what you call 'identity politics'.

    • @KronosGodwisen
      @KronosGodwisen Před 16 dny +7

      @@jamiebrown300 Such a modern RTD take.

    • @jamiebrown300
      @jamiebrown300 Před 16 dny

      @@KronosGodwisen Thank you!

    • @jamiebrown300
      @jamiebrown300 Před 16 dny +4

      I just believe that complaining about something the show has done for 60 (going on 61) years is slightly odd.

    • @StonyDilithium
      @StonyDilithium Před 15 dny +1

      @@jamiebrown300

  • @edwardcatt2399
    @edwardcatt2399 Před 18 dny +112

    ‘I’m “them”!’ . . . _DAMN,_ this is going to be _worse_ than the worst case scenario 😳

    • @hidden6ix742
      @hidden6ix742 Před 17 dny

      i wonder how many people he thinks he is ? and this is'nt mental illness?

    • @GregorySnipe
      @GregorySnipe Před 15 dny

      The word "them"? Is a worst case scenario? Be careful they have entire dictionary's full of words. Watch out they'll get you.

  • @foreshame7370
    @foreshame7370 Před 18 dny +21

    Wouldn't it have been more appropriate to call it the Nepo Babies? Everyone involved is here because of what they are and who they know. Talent is not a factor.

  • @NP-ip3nj
    @NP-ip3nj Před 18 dny +31

    The nuclear winter bit was straight out of Pyramid of Mars where Tom Baker showed Sarah the possible future where Sutekh destroyed everything.

    • @GareWorks
      @GareWorks Před 17 dny +18

      Except Pyramids of Mars was actually decent.

    • @MrPyroCrab
      @MrPyroCrab Před 16 dny +7

      @@GareWorks Decent? It's a fucking masterpiece.

    • @solaire-jd8jd
      @solaire-jd8jd Před 14 dny

      ​@@MrPyroCrab
      Agreed. Arguably the best story arc ever.

    • @tomnorton4277
      @tomnorton4277 Před 11 dny

      @@solaire-jd8jd Fun fact, Sutekh returned to voice Satan in The Impossible Planet and The Satan Pit. Bring Gabriel Woolf back was a great throwback to the Classic era, especially since a lot of people probably don't even know who he is. It shows there were people who genuinely cared in Russel Trash Davies' first era. I expect Elizabeth Sladen asked him to come back considering they worked together on Pyramids of Mars.

  • @andrewfisher956
    @andrewfisher956 Před 17 dny +8

    On behalf of what little sanity remains in Britain, I apologise Gary, and to all the wonderful people in the great USA.

  • @torsten89
    @torsten89 Před 17 dny +17

    For every fan that leaves you're going to gain 3 to 5 more fans of the "modern audience." Hmmm, interesting theory. How has that worked for Star Wars and Marvel? The last time I checked, they drove off fans, and now they are dying.

  • @berserkasaurusrex4233
    @berserkasaurusrex4233 Před 17 dny +8

    Literally the whole plot of that farting alien woman RTD wrote in the first series of NuWho was all about her being turned back into an egg so she could be born again because she was raised wrong.

  • @captainz9
    @captainz9 Před 16 dny +7

    "no one grows up wrong"... So they're excusing Hitler, Stalin, Mao....?

  • @blakecasimir
    @blakecasimir Před 15 dny +9

    I will maintain forever that, despite my general dislike of nu-Who, Peter Capaldi was PERFECT as Doctor Who and could have easily stood alongside the classic Doctors. He was entirely let down by atrocious writing and typically naff BBC production.

    • @Marty2011uk
      @Marty2011uk Před 15 dny +3

      I always thought 3 and 4 were the best plus they had the best Companions, Leela and Sarah Jane Smith.

  • @dragonback6075
    @dragonback6075 Před 18 dny +43

    "Jinx Monstrosity" 🤢🤢🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮

  • @Chicken_Little_Syndrome
    @Chicken_Little_Syndrome Před 17 dny +11

    Doctor Who ended with Capaldi. And even then, New Who was never quite as good as Classic Who.

  • @xman577
    @xman577 Před 18 dny +43

    They call it a reboot, but they bring up the timeless child. And he also mentioned Susan and when he lived on Ters Lane.

    • @notuptome
      @notuptome Před 17 dny +3

      it is not a Reboot regardless of what some say . The reason Susan was brought up including Who he is Who the Doctor is and such is because it is for new viewers so they don't have to feel overwhelmed because there is so many seasons before now and this is now considered Season 1 but does not start from scratch .

    • @captbuckyohare5585
      @captbuckyohare5585 Před 17 dny +7

      It's totally a reboot in name only. Susan, The Rani, The Timeless Child, the Toymaker, the end of Gallifrey... newbies will be lost. RTD has turned the show into ehat Star Wars became, not a new story, but a show that exists to reference itself while jangling keys and presenting incredibly well polished turds in place of good writing.

    • @reaperezekial5168
      @reaperezekial5168 Před 15 dny

      @@captbuckyohare5585Crap on a space cracker, they’ve even done my girl The Rani bad in this new iteration? I remember being so excited trying to figure out who Michelle Gomez’ character was going to be - was she Romana gone evil? Was she The Rani reborn? Sure, she ended up being The Master somehow (which is fine - which is great!) but I was always disappointed that The Rani was forgotten to the annals of time.
      I hate everything about these new versions of Doctor Who. I’ll stand by my defense of the first two Jodi episodes, and there are bits I like from Jodi’s finale with Ace and the 7th Doctor, but that’s where I draw the line and no further will it go. They could shelve Doctor Who for another 20 years and I’d still have to think long and hard about giving it another shot.

    • @GeryonM
      @GeryonM Před 14 dny

      Not only is it a reboot but because they are in a universe that has mavity as a universal constant it is an alternate reality, so this nonsense doesn't involve previous Dr. Who timelines.

  • @RaymondWilliams-uu1ns
    @RaymondWilliams-uu1ns Před 17 dny +11

    RTD obviously doesn’t know anything about babies. There was an orphanage in Romania were young infants died not because lack of food but lack of physical contact. Hugging is extremely important for a baby. Neglected they die!

    • @sorbabaric1
      @sorbabaric1 Před 15 dny +3

      Nick Freitas just did an interview with an economics professor who adopted a toddler from Romania back when, she talks about that, having first hand experience, and the need for a mother’s presence. She says her son is doing well, having had the human contact and mothering after adoption, , but the emotional and mental stunting that neglect causes is scary !!!

  • @ItsaKindOfMagic86
    @ItsaKindOfMagic86 Před 17 dny +12

    My ideal ending for the Doctor is the ending scene in the 50th special, where Tom Baker as the Curator talks to Matt Smith's (11th) Doctor that Gallifrey is still out there. I like the idea of the ending being that the Doctor is forever travelling and searching for his home.
    I am not venturing beyond that nor giving any of this "modern audience" my time. I rather dive into the classic Who and the novels.
    They can shove the Nurse What aka Doctor Woke.

  • @BracchiAlessandroFineArt
    @BracchiAlessandroFineArt Před 15 dny +5

    the Star wars fans, the Lord of the Rings fans, the marvel comics fans, are welcoming the Dr Who fans in the club of "trashed IP's i used to love" , we feel your pain !

  • @jmace2424
    @jmace2424 Před 15 dny +5

    The BBC then tried to blame the low viewership on people going out to touch grass since the weather was nice! 🤣

  • @cutter14
    @cutter14 Před 18 dny +35

    Gary looks like Netflix rendition of Oddjob from James Bond

  • @berliner0
    @berliner0 Před 18 dny +25

    God bless us true whovians

    • @mikaclodgo5892
      @mikaclodgo5892 Před 11 dny

      Obviously you've never watched a single episode of Doctor who

  • @tombradford7035
    @tombradford7035 Před 17 dny +14

    "Horrible version of Pee Wees Playhouse" - haha

  • @JamesJones-zt2yx
    @JamesJones-zt2yx Před 18 dny +19

    Stepped on a butterfly? Hey, let's rip off Ray Bradbury's "A Sound of Thunder"!

    • @DS-ce9cf
      @DS-ce9cf Před 14 dny

      Grow the f up. The entire River Song plot was The Time Traveler's Wife. Have you ever watched this show?

  • @carolhall3565
    @carolhall3565 Před 18 dny +32

    Thanks Gary for suffering having to watch the corpse of Dr Who decaying so we don’t have to. You are a true hero. : )

  • @fionnaitsradag5152
    @fionnaitsradag5152 Před 17 dny +11

    Ah yes. I just love abortion propaganda in my family shows.😑
    So stunning, so brave.

  • @thephiman1
    @thephiman1 Před 16 dny +7

    Gary, Churchill wore a Homberg hat. Sorry to criticise but we Brits take our hats as serious as we do queuing😂
    Ps I’m nominating you for a O.B.E, people get that for selfless charity work, you watching Doctor Who so I don’t have to must count!

  • @phillipjones9981
    @phillipjones9981 Před 16 dny +5

    I have seen every episode since Nov 23rd 1963, it was my 5th birthday and I fell in love with the show, but dear god that ' space babies' episode was abysmal, contrived, no element of danger for the dr or companion, a 'monster' made of snot, I thought Colin Baker's 1st story The twin dilemma was bad but compared to this bollocks it is a masterpiece

  • @adycardiac698
    @adycardiac698 Před 17 dny +21

    Well the stepping on a butterfly thing was stolen straight out of a Ray Bradbury short story….and now the doc has the power to bring stuff back to life?…..from a fan of yesteryear who grew up starting with the Tom Baker years it really looks like doctor who has turned to shit….it all ended when Peter capaldi said “ doctor.i let you go”

    • @countzero1136
      @countzero1136 Před 17 dny +4

      I've been watching Doctor Who since the Jon Pertwee era and stopped watching it (as many others seem to have done) at the third episode of Jodie Whittakers run

    • @terryhill5509
      @terryhill5509 Před 15 dny +2

      I found myself not interested enough to buy the second series of Capaldi's run. I gave him one series. So I never got polluted with Jodi. But it's sounding like they wanted us former fans to reconsider how awful Jodi was (after seeing how much worse it can get).

  • @thegreatburt9005
    @thegreatburt9005 Před 15 dny +4

    The tragedy is we were denied a season of Paul McGann in 1996 during its first American launch 😢 😕 😞

  • @mrcoules
    @mrcoules Před 18 dny +69

    Thank you for sacrificing time to watch this trash, you do us a great service Gary, I salute you!

    • @mayotango1317
      @mayotango1317 Před 18 dny +2

      Everybody loves those episodes, even in Facebook.

    • @dragonback6075
      @dragonback6075 Před 18 dny +5

      All 3 of them 😂😂😂😂

    • @dragonback6075
      @dragonback6075 Před 18 dny +2

      @mrcoules 🫡🫡🫡🫡🫡🫡🫡🫡🫡

    • @mayotango1317
      @mayotango1317 Před 18 dny

      @@dragonback6075 Nerdrotic is a loser like Dalewstrek.

    • @Wanten-the-stormtrooper
      @Wanten-the-stormtrooper Před 15 dny

      @@mayotango1317 Hey, I remember you! You told me that old RTD was - and I quote - "a sopa opera full of SJW" a few years back! I wonder what your thoughts on the infinitely more woke episodes from Chibnall onwards are?

  • @BlindIdiotGaming
    @BlindIdiotGaming Před 16 dny +6

    I loved Capaldi as The Doctor, too, but they did him so dirty with his era.

  • @thetalonsofwaynechiang
    @thetalonsofwaynechiang Před 17 dny +38

    ‘Fruity,’ Gatwa.

  • @Minwolf
    @Minwolf Před 15 dny +5

    There was a recent article that came out saying that they changed the sonic screwdriver into a remote because they thought it looked to much like a gun. Which makes zero sense to me.

  • @brooksy362436
    @brooksy362436 Před 16 dny +7

    Bogeyman? Isn't that assuming the bogey's gender?

  • @thebadtemperedbrit
    @thebadtemperedbrit Před 17 dny +46

    I really disagree with Gary that 'the accent doesn't matter', I think whatever accent he has is awful, it's odd in itself and not nice on the ear and then worse it's not BRITISH! We've so many accents to chose from, English, Welsh, Scots, Irish, South West, Northern, Liverpudlian and on and on, choose someone with one of them, NOT African, it's pretty simple!

    • @captbuckyohare5585
      @captbuckyohare5585 Před 17 dny

      Ugh.... you said Irish.

    • @thebadtemperedbrit
      @thebadtemperedbrit Před 17 dny +12

      @@captbuckyohare5585 Northern Irish is implied, unnecessarily pedantic.

    • @GareWorks
      @GareWorks Před 17 dny +13

      Yeah, I have to agree, the accent is off-putting to me. In fairness, if that was the worst thing about it, it wouldn't be a big deal. Unfortunately, it's just the tip of the iceberg...

    • @thebadtemperedbrit
      @thebadtemperedbrit Před 17 dny +3

      @@GareWorks Agreed, if everything else was amazing, maybe, but!

    • @captbuckyohare5585
      @captbuckyohare5585 Před 17 dny +1

      Meaning Northern Irish by saying Irish implies nothing. Suggesting Irish people are also British is well, its moronic and thats on you. Sorry for my pesky pedantry it's really only been an issue for about 400 years. No biggie. X

  • @Gino1982
    @Gino1982 Před 14 dny +2

    The doctor stole the powers of John Coffey from the Green Mile 😂

  • @KlassiusK
    @KlassiusK Před 17 dny +6

    EXACTLY, if you dont grow up wrong, why identify as something else? 100%

  • @be23skido
    @be23skido Před 17 dny +10

    I've been watching Nerdrotic for quite a while now. Can't say I've ever seen him this shook by a show or movie. Really good sign that we should all avoid subjecting ourselves to such horrific, dare I say it, entertainment.

  • @WilloftheFans
    @WilloftheFans Před 17 dny +27

    Millie didn't bother me that much. Ncuti made me wince. The babies were terrible...the plot made no sense. They accomplished nothing besides a Space Fart.

  • @brickgarden
    @brickgarden Před 14 dny +5

    William Hartnell IS the first doctor. I don’t care what they say.

    • @theotherside8258
      @theotherside8258 Před 12 dny +2

      The Dr should have stayed an elderly professor type

  • @anthonyhamlin1078
    @anthonyhamlin1078 Před 17 dny +17

    A soap in the UK is called Hollyoaks - stuffed with jailbait to cover it being shite. The blonde in the short skirts is straight out of the Hollyoaks jailbait playbook of shite deception.

    • @fredo1070
      @fredo1070 Před 17 dny +1

      New Who 2005 was inspired by Hollyoaks

    • @racheljames7
      @racheljames7 Před 16 dny +1

      I used to love Hollyoaks.

  • @markjones-gu2fj
    @markjones-gu2fj Před 15 dny +4

    Note John Lennon didn't wear round granny glasses until 1966 after he made the film how I won the war where he played a character called private Gripweed who had short hair and round glasses Lennon liked the look and felt comfortable wearing them. Before then he wore Buddy Holly style glasses

  • @stonyfunfazwansk2672
    @stonyfunfazwansk2672 Před 18 dny +68

    In Austria we fought a war so we don't have to talk to someone in third person.
    It went so far that they were forbidden to use their family name.

  • @TheStacanova
    @TheStacanova Před 18 dny +23

    I’m torn, Moffat was always the best New Who writer, right up until he got burnt out & the BBC’s DEI department started micromanaging him.
    On one hand, if his episode is trash, than all of our heroes truly are dead, however, if he writes a banger like “Blink” or “Girl in the Fireplace”, it might fool people into thinking Doctor Who is good again and they might watch more new episodes?

    • @kraven94365
      @kraven94365 Před 17 dny +3

      He WAS great but let's not pretend the DEI crap was pushed on him, he jumped into the deep end of the crap pool. He is the current reason "The message" is being pushed onto who rn

    • @TheStacanova
      @TheStacanova Před 17 dny +5

      @@kraven94365 I have no way of proving this, but even in his most recent interviews, Moffat makes some “problematic” jokes.
      He also seems to still understand what the Doctor needs to be, which enigmatic.
      He’s a pacifist who has committed genocide.
      Moffat’s description of the Doctor was about these contradictions, that the Doctor is “limp wristed” but he’s also really masculine.
      He’s a genius, who can be dumb and ignorant about things.
      His Sum up was that the Doctor needs to be all these things, progressive but with conservative morality.
      If you’re far left or far right, you still need to be able to identify with the Doctor was basically what he said.

    • @kraven94365
      @kraven94365 Před 15 dny +4

      @TheStacanova well if that's his goal for the doctor, he not only miserably failed but is actively working against it. I'm a centrist, so I don't really think of terms of left and right, but damn am I sick of shows shoe horning in social commentary just for the sake of having it and not for any plot point. If a character is Trans whatever, don't shove it down my throat, if it's black or gay fine, but that shouldn't be a characters whole personality for the sake of propaganda. The moral superiority complex in modern entertainment is sickening.

    • @ladyfoxwf1075
      @ladyfoxwf1075 Před 15 dny +1

      @@kraven94365 You're talking about Moffatt but providing examples from Russell T Davis return?

    • @philipc2025
      @philipc2025 Před 15 dny +3

      You can't polish a turd. Roll it in glitter at best.

  • @TardisTV-tj5xs
    @TardisTV-tj5xs Před 14 dny +7

    It was fucking terrible and sad to watch my favourite tv show fall this low

    • @devinpoole4528
      @devinpoole4528 Před 14 dny +2

      Seriously don't think I closed my mouth the entire episode. Just sat there dumbfounded😲

    • @TardisTV-tj5xs
      @TardisTV-tj5xs Před 20 hodinami

      @@devinpoole4528 I think the worst thing is when you have legitimate criticism of it and are labelled as an ist or phobe

  • @Fyrecide
    @Fyrecide Před 17 dny +5

    Anytime entertainment is blatantly didactic, it’s a fail. People don’t go to movies to be reminded of the real world and to be told how shit it is through your personal world view, they go to escape the real world and be entertained.
    They’re making things worse instead of better and they’re too egotistical and stupid to realize it.

  • @Rusty84CV
    @Rusty84CV Před 17 dny +8

    This show is Doctor Who in name only

  • @NihilusShadow
    @NihilusShadow Před 15 dny +4

    1:09:48 Watch Red Dwarf, Gary!!!

  • @iainriley8819
    @iainriley8819 Před 16 dny +5

    STD, is a lazy writer and between that and Disney's DEI push . As a Brit who has grown up on this even when it was real bad, I'm done with it ! We used to call it grooming ...

  • @captbuckyohare5585
    @captbuckyohare5585 Před 17 dny +23

    Oh, by the way. The big mystery?
    Rose is Ruby's mum and Metacrisis is her dad. She's been hidden in our universe from the interdimentional big bad.
    The big monumental actor who in the the finale is Billie Piper.

    • @GareWorks
      @GareWorks Před 17 dny +11

      If that's true, that's beyond hilarious. I'm definitely not watching that crap. What a waste of time. RTD has no talent.

    • @shade38211
      @shade38211 Před 17 dny +4

      Hope they show chest feeding. Some rainbow hair will watch.

    • @berserkasaurusrex4233
      @berserkasaurusrex4233 Před 17 dny +5

      No way they will have Piper back, she’s been around Eccleston while he’s been calling for BBC to fire people from the show.
      They’ll have Tennent back and say Rose is dead.

    • @edwardreed67
      @edwardreed67 Před 17 dny +2

      Source: trust me bro

    • @captbuckyohare5585
      @captbuckyohare5585 Před 17 dny +4

      No source dis just muh theory.

  • @TheAyeAye1
    @TheAyeAye1 Před 15 dny +3

    "Fuckity bye" covers Dr. Who, Star Trek and Star Wars now at least for me.

  • @captbuckyohare5585
    @captbuckyohare5585 Před 17 dny +10

    Repeating beats from his first tenure (last of the timelords, magic phones for phoning home), leaning in the Timeless Child nonsense, heavily referencing his own specials and the Toymaker, more fairytale fantasy than sci-fantasy or even just family sci-fi, and all with a handwavey attitude to worldbuilding and the forced Disneyfied aww-shucks Doctor...?
    Ugh. Exhausting. Maybe the teenage LGBTQIA Gen Alpha audience will love it? I can't imagine how new fans would find this an easy point to jump on and old fans (and old OLD fans) will just find it tedious.

  • @callac
    @callac Před 16 dny +4

    Capaldi punching that wall deserves one Oscar. That was his great episode!!!

    • @AstroTom
      @AstroTom Před 3 dny

      I personally didn't like that episode but I loved Capaldi and want to rewatch his run again. Capaldi is my second favourite doctor

  • @jabbawonger6572
    @jabbawonger6572 Před 17 dny +9

    Capaldi was a good Doctor but he could have been a GREAT Doctor, he was let down by the writing. My interest in Doctor Who started to wane then.
    I still revisit Pertwee, Davidson and the great Tom Baker. I'm done with so called 'New Who'.

    • @krystianzyszczynski4115
      @krystianzyszczynski4115 Před 13 dny +1

      I actually liked him too. But yes the material he was given was trash and his lesbian companion was just terrrrrible. She was insufferable and I hated how much they had to point out that she's a lesbian every 5 minutes. It got to the point where I didn't care at all she was turned into a cyberman.

  • @Carlos_De_Angeles
    @Carlos_De_Angeles Před 18 dny +21

    To quote you: "IT'S SHIT!" Thank you, I've been trying to sum up what I watched at 12am this morning in the UK. RIP DR WHO.

  • @denniseijs
    @denniseijs Před 18 dny +26

    Dr Gay?

  • @cavanriley7373
    @cavanriley7373 Před 17 dny +5

    Ive had to see a man sing spice girls and jump about, to a goblin singalong and another sing along this is just pure and utter woke.

  • @colinthedogfromspaced9365

    I cringed more in the first 10 minutes of The Devils Chord than the whole 12 hours of Eurovision.

  • @DorisDay-lw4xs
    @DorisDay-lw4xs Před 17 dny +5

    Jon is my favourite Doctor too. I was lucky to be able to watch all his stories in real-time as they aired. Happy days.

  • @RandyCantu-zi9ek
    @RandyCantu-zi9ek Před 18 dny +16

    I didn’t know Star Trek was going on either

    • @billhodgson8016
      @billhodgson8016 Před 17 dny

      Google keeps suggesting screen rant articles on kurtsman star trek. I never click on them but it tells me they are still casting in the void.

    • @GareWorks
      @GareWorks Před 17 dny +1

      I only heard about that a few days ago. I think that's probably why Paramount is going bankrupt - they just keep setting their cash on fire.

    • @Maddog3060
      @Maddog3060 Před 17 dny +3

      Because it's not real Star Trek, the same this crap isn't real Doctor Who and the Disney sequels aren't real Star Wars. It's all just terrible fan fiction.

    • @richardpaulcaird9192
      @richardpaulcaird9192 Před 16 dny +1

      It's not, if you want more Star Trek, go watch The Orville lol 🤣😅😂👍🏻👌🏻

    • @tptk6659
      @tptk6659 Před 15 dny

      I like Strange new worlds. It is quite different from what I was expecting but enjoyable. Spock is a bit of an odd one and does cause some issues for me and its because of his emotions but I can overlook it.

  • @zeppelinboys
    @zeppelinboys Před 17 dny +4

    "He COULD have played it gayer" LMAO! oh man, wtf Britain! sad, sad, sad world we live in.

  • @iaineakin9169
    @iaineakin9169 Před 14 dny +4

    Is that new doctor black and gay??? It was never mentioned 😂😂

  • @MrBenfranz
    @MrBenfranz Před 15 dny +4

    Ncuti Gatwa is definitely the British Big Gay Al. I'm just waiting for the episode where he belts out: "I feel thuper! Thankth for athking!"

  • @AndyG73
    @AndyG73 Před 16 dny +4

    A 'whopping' 2.5M people tuned in, which is (just) the second lowest viewership for any episodes (guess whose was the lowest?) of the modern era. But unlike the FFDPBJW era, this will be the high point, because the episodes were deliberately scheduled prior to the Eurovision Song Contest final. I bet the next week's single episode will just top 2M, and the series finish between 1-1.5M live viewers.

  • @gregorylieber8362
    @gregorylieber8362 Před 18 dny +15

    Nurse What?

  • @benwest6633
    @benwest6633 Před 17 dny +11

    I'm sorry but I couldn't bare to watch more than 15 minutes of this. Hearing about the destruction of the doctor at the hands of a conspiracy of his own creators and the house of the mouse is just too painful.
    But I'll say that the fact that they did a bi-generation almost makes me think someone at the BBC knows this is doomed to fail. When it does, they could bring David Tennant out of retirement and attempt to reverse all the damage. I just wonder if anyone will forgive David for his role in the specials. Who am I trying to kid? The show is dead. They murdered it. If not already dead, definitely on life support.

    • @GareWorks
      @GareWorks Před 17 dny

      Tennant is on camera saying we're "on the wrong side of history" amongst other things. He can't save it. Nothing can. It's dead.

    • @jamesg9468
      @jamesg9468 Před 16 dny +4

      David Tennant can't save it, he's actually on board with all the woke nonsense.
      It wasn't long ago that people were calling for Davies return to "save Doctor Who"...well, we got it. And look where we are now.

  • @gail66onutube
    @gail66onutube Před 17 dny +6

    Your forgetting the little buried gem, that was Doctor Ruth, the first Black Doctor Who. So amazing acted the pants off Jodie, without even trying. Why oh why could they not have followed that idea.

    • @aethersurfer6793
      @aethersurfer6793 Před 15 dny +3

      Should have done. She was great. A brilliant actor lifts even the crappiest dialogue, so she could have carried these episodes.

  • @DianeCee57
    @DianeCee57 Před 17 dny +7

    Oh wow things must be bad, Gary's brought out his bowler hat! Love it.

  • @esmannr
    @esmannr Před 17 dny +3

    They're building a show around their message. 'Rot at the core . . .', Frank Herbert

  • @TexasTimeLord
    @TexasTimeLord Před 16 dny +2

    The UK overnight viewership for the last DW show was 4.73 million.
    The viewership for Space Babies & Devil's Chord was 2.4 million. The WORST ratings in DW history by far.
    That tells you all you need to know.

  • @jmace2424
    @jmace2424 Před 15 dny +2

    For me the Doctor Who Beatles episode is when the Third Doctor and Jo do “I am the Walrus.” 🤗🤗

  • @stevenhoeltzel500
    @stevenhoeltzel500 Před 17 dny +3

    I feel dumber for even watching the first two episodes. Disney kills everything pushing the message.

  • @Jadido7
    @Jadido7 Před 16 dny +3

    it’s clear Russel T Davies doesn’t care anymore, he just came back for the money …. Looks like he wrote those stories in a couple of hours

  • @billyhuang
    @billyhuang Před 14 dny +2

    This extemporaneous review was far more entertaining, educational and wholesome than these two new episodes of "Doctor Who."

  • @Renavatio2586
    @Renavatio2586 Před 14 dny +2

    I have to give Disney and the BBC credit.
    They both have perfected the business model of throwing money literally down the toilet 🤦🏾‍♂️🤦🏾‍♂️

  • @jmace2424
    @jmace2424 Před 15 dny +2

    I think what they meant to say was that for every Doctor Who fan that walk out, there will be 3 more walking out right beside them! 🤣

  • @WartimeConsigliere
    @WartimeConsigliere Před 17 dny +3

    Seeing shows like Doctor Who ruined sucks, but fortunately there are over 10 seasons of Stargate SG1 and 4 more offshoot series seasons (plus movies) to offset the loss.