‘Can’t Poke a Bear’: State Delivers Emotional Closing Argument Saying Hannah Payne is Guilty
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 12. 2023
- During closing arguments, the state argued Hannah Payne is guilty as charged. Payne is accused of shooting and killing the driver of the car who caused a hit-and-run, Kenneth Herring, after witnessing the crash herself. She claims the shooting was in "self defense" to which the state responded, "You can’t poke a bear, claim a bear attacked you, and then turn around and claim self defense. It doesn’t work that way”.
#HannahPayne #MurderTrial #LawAndCrime
STAY UP-TO-DATE WITH THE LAW&CRIME NETWORK:
Watch Law&Crime Network on CZcamsTV: bit.ly/3td2e3y
Where To Watch Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/3akxLK5
Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter: bit.ly/LawandCrimeNewsletter
Read Fascinating Articles From Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/3td2Iqo
For Licensing Inquiries, Please Contact: licensing@lawandcrime.com
LAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:
Instagram: / lawandcrime
Twitter: / lawcrimenetwork
Facebook: / lawandcrime
Twitch: / lawandcrimenetwork
TikTok: / lawandcrime
LAW&CRIME NETWORK PODCASTS: lawandcrime.com/podcasts/
SUBSCRIBE TO ALL OF LAW&CRIME NETWORK CZcams CHANNELS:
Main Channel: / @lawandcrime
Law&Crime Shorts: / @lawandcrimeshorts
Channel B: / @lawandcrimetrials
Channel C: / @lawandcrimebodycam - Zábava
Her family shaking their heads in the backround is a huge example of why Hannah is in this position. I see no accountability, and entitlement run in the family.
You're just seeing the tree that the apple fell from...
Same with defence lawyer 😡
If the hills had eyes was a family
Look at her she looks evil and like the hills have eyes
RUNS IN THE BLOOD 🤦🏿♂️
Her defense attorney is horrible. If I were a juror in this case, the little faces he keeps making would make me so upset. He's not doing his client any favors by doing that. Her lawyer has a hard enough job as it is, because he's trying to defend the indefendible. She's going to go right where she belongs Behind Bars.
Public defenders work for the state.
@@Enoughalready20237I heard that he was hired.
I was coming here to say about the same thing. He is as arrogant as she is and so unprofessional. They are a real duo.
@@Enoughalready20237I’m not sure a public defender would get away with behaving that way.
Well you’d make a bad juror if you’d judge a suspect based off the facial expressions of their representation or let emotions get in the way of your making a decision. That’s why there’s 12 that must agree. Not saying she’s not guilty but we can’t judge a trial like that.
Between the defendant, her family sitting behind her and the defense attorney, I never thought I could dislike a group of people, without ever meeting them. The facial expressions, the head shaking and the lack of empathy is disgusting.
Their skin color makes so much and says so much about them
It's sad to saay but this is what happened when you teach your children to hate. Instead of blaming everybody else she should have blamed the people who raised her to hate without reason
This is how I was feeling looking at them like why are y’all doing all that 🤦🏾♀️🤦🏾♀️🤦🏾♀️
Agreed at the least they could keep all these disgusting expressions to themselves
Why are they allowed to respond ? I thought that was illegal
This one baffles me because she literally had nothing to do with any of this. Her car wasn't even the one that was hit. Like girl, you're demonic
Hannah went literally, "Out of Her Way, " to murder Mr. Kenneth.
It runs in their 🧬, I’ll bet 💰 that she’s related to “William H.F Payne” she comes from scum
She had no dog in this fight. Welp…..
So many people like her put their nose in others affairs its sickening
and walked into a life sentence
Imagine if she was a police officer!! Lawdy! There would be more murders
She would be going after everybody she came across and find something to book em for. She is one dangerous woman.
She would still probably end up in prison with her trigger happy self.
Kleenex victims
@@barrywallace4415 I feel bad for the Kleenex too, they didn’t ask for this. It’s their mission to provide comfort and relief for real tears and instead here they are..
She wanted to be one and she acted like one when she had no right just audacity
The expressions/body language of the defense attorney is SOOOOO infuriating
He’s paid by the state. He works for the state. It’s not even poor representation. It is calculated, paid for by the state poor representation.
You just hate him cause he's a man.
Her family might pull the gun on their own lawyer for all we know. Doesn’t matter what he did in court, but they might blame him.😂😂😂
it's such a show
Right...like he don't want her to talk...and offering his client water...
The prosecutor is speaking to them on their level and I love this. She’s not being too fancy, she laid out facts. Great job to this prosecutor and her team! They did a fantastic job!
Indeed!
Yes they did SALUTE!
🙌🏾
Yes Lawd, she knew they would try it…. Well let me tell you WHY it’s not gonna fly But THIS WILL
Right!!! Excellent prosecutor, she was educating our people so they are not confused when they go deliberate.
ABSOLUTELY MASTERFUL CLOSING ARGUMENT. Gave me chills. Hannah really should have minded her own business. She must’ve thought it was 1825.
She and her kinfolk probably still believe it's 1825!
lol not 1825
@@voxpopuval They dang sure look like it is!
😂😂😂
Even 1925 this would be common
Defense attorney should be held in contempt, shameful behavior for counsel.
Defense attorney should be admonished for his unprofessional behavior.
I concur! Watching him made me so angry! Is he like trying to get a mistrial or something or trying not to poke the bear? I need to watch this whole trial! It looks so good!
Judge should have called side bar and told him l see you cut it out or you will be held in contempt
Should have been thrown out of court.
Positively Vile behavior!!!!
She followed dude and walked up with a gun…. You didn’t have to do ANY of that. If she just drove off and went home… you continue to live your life and so does he. But for whatever reason she chose to hunt him down, WHY
This was probably her vigilante dream!
Typical Caucasian behavior.Not knowing how to mind their own business, for their own good.
She felt she had to put him in his place.
She has the odd Caucasian mentality of deputizing herself, when she sees someone of brown ethnicity act contrary to what “THEY” find acceptable😮😂
She thought she was hunting an animal in the woods. She wanted to test her gun
Her lawyer is the most CHILDISH I have ever seen in a courtroom.
He is
Did you notice Hannah's attorney trying to offer her water the same water that he was drinking out of that's disgusting
I seen that 😂😂😂😂 so awkward
😂😂😂😂
Eeeew
😂😂
This cereal box Lawyer has no clue what’s going on. That’s why he’s one of the other reasons Hannah lost her “privilege” and freedom😂😂😂
Let’s make it a point to commend the prosecutor. I seen a lot of comments about her cross but make no mistake, she showed UP and showed OUT in this closing. Spoken like a true advocate for justice.
She did 🎉🎉🎉
Facts
Agreed I really liked her and thought she made it very clear and concise to thr jury.
IMO, by going soft on cross, she avoided any possibility of creating a notion of sympathy for Payne through "bullying". She was the opposite of Payne's arrogance. Brilliant and then hammered it all home during this fantastic closing.
@@cjharris3680true! It was strategy I think
Her attorney is a sleaze ball and should be admonished by the court for his facial gestures and head shaking/nodding. Unprofessional. She must have gotten him off of Wish.
Or temu 😅😅😅
haha🤣
@@Sadia34able LOL!
He also faked a heart attack. That's why it took 4 years for trial
Haha Wish!
She could have won the auction on Ebay?
The Goodwill had a red tag special 😂
Hannah is no different than a good portion of the corrupt murderous demons that have badges today. Just imagine her NEARLY becoming an officer… seriously maddening thought.😮😮😮
Her lawyer is disrespectful. He was acting like a child as the prosecutor began her summation. I think this type of power point should be used to educate all jurors in every case. Seriously what do we know outside of sound bites and TV shows. This was brilliant
He reminds me of a man currently on trial in New York.
Good point
Exactly 💯 I am learning just from this smh this isn’t standard
Her attorney is blowing the case for her with all his facial attempts to negate these closing arguments, put forth by the state. He will contribute to her being found guilty!
I just noticed and commented this as well.
I was like he is not doing that is he!! Was about to comment and read yours. He should have been reprimanded by the judge imo
I hope so I was watching him show his rear.
I thought it was me.. seeing in his face.. like whatever and his body language
I totally agree. What she did was WRONG, but she doesn’t stand a chance with that joker as her lawyer.
Prosecutor is a BOSS!
She knows her stuff
What is her name?? Thanx in advance
The prosecutor was way too soft and let thumb face get away with saying disrespectful words! The prosecutor did not hold thumb face accountable enough on her actions! The prosecutor did not call thumb face out or make her answer the “whys”! This was not the time for a soft prosecutor to go easy on a person that committed such an outrageous killing! The other prosecutor should have done the cross examination!
@@CMKing6 Thumbface!😅 🏆….Oh my goodness, perfect description!
@@mom2babygkaterad946 she sort of looks like a Bob's burgers character
Her lawyer is ridiculous. Sitting there shaking his head and making gestures. The judge should admonish him.
I know this has been said over and over again….but this is truly one of the WORST defense attorneys available in our country. He should be ashamed. We *all* know Hannah Payne is guilty and should be thrown in prison…but her defense attorney did her absolutely NO FAVORS in this case. He is the absolute worst attorney we’ve seen in a while.
Him making faces was grounds to throw him in jail with her
HE COULDN'T SAVE HER!!! TOO MUCH VIDEO AND WITNESS
Dude drunk
Well, he had to try something. Nothing would've been good enough. He cannot defend her actions.
@@rocar38possibly 😂 look how red he is
The defendant's mother wasn't present during prosecution closing argument. I guess she didn't want to hear all the truths about her guilty daughter.
I don't blame her imagine if that lunatic was your daughter
@@Joseph-fw6xxRight? I wouldn't have shown up either.
She presented a beautiful, clear cut, closing. I loved when she said “ He should be home with his family this holiday” I think that was perfect. Brought it back to it being about him and his family.
She really lifted her game with her closing as her court examination of Payne was embarrassingly pathetic.
Emotional manipulation.
She was found GUILTY on all charges! She ain't so bad now, is she!
She's a great Attorney.
Her closing was a thing of beauty. So organized and intelligently laid out.
Miss ma’am absolutely killed that closing argument !! 👏🏼🙌🏼💕👑
YESS 💯‼️🔥💪👑
Yassss!
She clearly is incapable of feeling sorry for anyone but herself! Absolutely despicable, and probably the reason why she got into the mess and got convicted of it. That poor man’s family.
The defence lawyer’s demeanour shows complete disrespect during the prosecutor’s closing argument.
Masterclass closing argument by the state attorney. Masterclass!! Game, set and match!
She was superb!
100%. Gave me chills, especially how she paused and just walked away at the end. So clear. So concise. Surgical and authoritative. 💯
@@damoneaves Couldn't agree more. Her walk away ending was just epic and cold as ice. She knew right then it's game over for the defense. Just epic.
Second that emotion.
I’ve been educated!
“Like Miss Jackson stated; Who drives on sidewalks?” I love how she used Miss Jackson’s words to goad the defense attorney. 😂 She was the best witness EVER! 💯
Yasss, she was
Congrats State. She is a entitled bully whom bullying finally caught up with her. 😮😮😮😮
Remember she was going to be a cop with the lower standards plus in need of people . 😮😮😮😮
@@19651Thank God she is off the streets!!!!
The defense attorney is doing his client a disservice by acting this way. Its like hes doing a snl skit. This girl murdered the man
I think the guy's a drunk he definitely sounds like he's drinks with that voice
It was giving Adelson family vibes, like there is nothing to smirk about
I agree. It's very Alarming!!!!
Master Class work from the prosecutor because not only did she lay out her case but she also added within the closing the actual definition of each charge so the jurors wont assume what each charge means. She gets a A++ in my book.
The prosecutor's closing argument was brilliant and spot on. The explanation of the charges was masterful. This closing argument should be used in every single law class.
Prosecutor did a Awesome job explaining and producing her closing arguments
I loved the way she laid everything out with clear explanations!
Agreed! I learned a few things, too
Spoke at the jury’s level of understanding! I love when they do that… it’s clear and concise.
@@bluejayhunter Do you think when she's more clear and concise (in the way you describe) it's taxpayer money well spent?
I’m so glad she broke down the charges! I was so lost. 😂
Guilty as charged!
That prosecutor nailed her closing arguments with facts and confidence 💯💥
Indeed, even with the attorney mocking her, she did great.
They should add on another charge for impersonating an officer. She truly believed she had that power just bc she owned a weapon.
Stay in your lane!
@@davidnorthern0219196 You’re the one merging into mine without using your turn signal.
@@davidnorthern0219196Practice what you preach. Noone asked for your two cents
I loved the slideshow. I learned so much about the specific charges and different terms I hear all the time but don't really know in depth. Awesome presentation!
I agree. It should be done during all closing arguments.
The defendant is a threat to society. Life without parole.
She’s a great prosecutor, it’s the way she delivers her message. 🙏🏽
😂
Morale of story is mind your own business and let Law Enforcement do their job if a crime has been committed ! 😏
The three men in the Arbery case should've taken your advice
@@Joseph-fw6xx Agreed. Vigilante justice is still a crime.
No, but you can't chase them down and put law in your own hands
Exactly. It's see something, say something. Not all the INSANE THINGS Hannah DID!!!!
Moral of the story, don’t be a murderer
The prosecutor is on point great closing argument. This wasn't a complex case. It's common sense.
Her lawyer slid that box of tissues to her like here you go start crying , he was encouraging her to act like she had remorse .
She put her head down as soon as the DA said she blames everyone else
I know. He pushed those tissues like put your big girl panties on your goose is cooked, turn on the water works you might wanna ugly cry too. Prosecutor brought it on home "Guilty as charged" !!!❤
Absolutely
That defense attorney needs to practice some decorum and also play poker with me.
😂😂😂
He is a joke!!
He called photos " pictures "
Like a kid!
He reminds me of the Lollipop guild men , his hair !!
😂
Why doesn't the judge hold this defense attorney in contempt for his despicable behavior?
She should have taken a plea deal before trial.. But her entitled attitude didn't let her. Plus, her attorney's silly face reactions didn't help her either.
Her attorney needs courtroom etiquette. The disrespect delayed is insane. His actions doesn't help his client case one bit.
It's Clayton County Georgia. The Rednecks think they still run that area except that now the court system employee's no longer look like them.
Where did the find him.
Her lawyer’s behavior was disgusting and very childish… All of those gestures and facial expressions… I’ve never seen anything like it
Great closing argument by the state. Calm, factual and clear explanations of each charge for the jury to deliberate on. Very well done 👍
I know we need to let the jury decide and that’s their job. And the Attorneys have their jobs like we all do. But the one thing I feel that’s weird is the facial commentary the Def Attorney doing is really crazy IMO. He looks juvenile and no need for this to me it seems like he’s either on something or he’s acting as this is a joke. And this is my opinion
He reminds me of that actor from King of Queens. I forget his name
@@bobe3250Kevin James plays Doug on KofQ
I agree with you, bizarre behavior.
This is normal behavior for yite men who think they will always win no matter the facts.
@@bobe3250 Kevin James I think is his name
Omg so gross the attorney took a sip of the water and then tried to have her drink from the same bottle
I thought the same thing
Me too. I rewound to check I wasn’t seeing things. Yuck.🤢🤮
They probably share something else also. Perhaps a bed? 😂
When!?!? I missed it
@@prettybrownskin355 At 2.10…🤢
Man sis is too good. The defense lawyer mad af. School them Queen !
She's not your sis
The defense attorney is the most unprofessional lawyer I’ve ever witnessed. What a total buffoon.
Hannah had no business pulling out a gun there was no need for it she didn't need to defend herself. She's guilty 💯
That's what you get when you allow anyone and everyone to own a gun.
@@katbar6066 That's for sure too many psychotic people carry.
@@katbar6066 yep crazy it is
She had no business even stopping at the scene lol
The Defense Lawyer was visibly mocking the Prosecutor's Closing. I was not a fan of this Defense Lawyers opening presentation either.
20 bucks says he's opening the door for her to make an appeal citing poor representation
@@Jupiter1423 This was the comment I was looking for. I was speculating about this as well, and wondered if anyone else was seeing it . Of course I am no lawyer, so I have no idea what qualifies for an appeal to be granted, but it will be interesting to see if she decides to pursue this.
@@Jupiter1423won’t matter she won’t get out . She’s guilty . They got her video clearly with the gun and up on his vehicle. Poor representation or not the Supreme Court will see those images and testimony of the witnesses. She’s done.
@@Jupiter1423just because you hire poor representation, that's no reason for an appeal. If that's the case, everyone that loses a case gets a do over.
It's Clayton County Georgia. The Rednecks think they still run that area except that now the court system employee's no longer look like them.
He's like "here's tissues, don't forget to look like you're crying about all this"
Exactly!!!
The prosecutor did a good job. She laid it out plain as day, she gets an A+
Her lawyer already knows they lost the case 😂
He actually thought she would be found not guilty.
@@BabyYoda230no he didn't 😂 He knew she was cooked
First of all...My condolences to the family. He didn't deserve to be chased down and killed.
I know this is old, but I started watching this closing and was just pulled into it. This prosecutor is so well spoken, intelligent, detailed and presented the information so eloquently. Great Job, prosecutor!!! You Rock‼️
I just started this also. She really thought she had the right to kill Mr Herring . And thought she could live in the free world
@@geraldineallen8060 Yes, I am always amazed how people take lives and think it's okay. I see so many stories like this, and shouldn't be surprised at all...but it's truly sad how people are so heartless and show no remorse. They just cry for themselves.
This is an OUTSTANDING closing argument by the offense!
I feel like I just went to school for law just listening to this deliberation. I don’t think you could have broken that takes down any better I don’t think anyone could’ve done a better job. I’m so grateful that our community has people like her fighting for us in the courtroom.
I pray justice for the family, and I pray also for people like the young ladies, who committed this crime that they find someway somehow to address the issues, they have with self entitlement and the need to police people, and other communities or people in general. The death of this man was so unnecessary.
31:50
This Defense attorney should NOT have reacted the way he did right here. He did a great job of leaving that "ick" feeling with every juror right at the end of closing!
Yea that was really gross
He's gross
Yes, his behavior is disgusting and extremely disrespectful
The judge let him go here, I hope he got a phone call or something. Don’t come in my courtroom acting crazy because your case SUCKED. At his big age!!! Probably been a lawyer as long as his client & the prosecutor have been alive & is acting like a 5 year old. Smh
Her defense attorney is an extension of the defendants state of mind judging by his facial expressions and disrespectful mannerisms while speaking of an innocent man's death.
The prosecution’s PowerPoint was a lovely and needed touch.
What I find I sad is how she said “the law won’t allow us to talk about his past”. Yet we see all the time that when it’s something negative in their past, they don’t hesitate to allow the defense to mention it to prove a point about character and aggression. Like somehow Trayvon Martin smoking weed was relevant to his case, but this man being a good person wasn’t relevant to his?
Thank you
Why is the judge allowing the defense attorney to behave in this way .? I hope she admonishes him for his histrionics when the prosecution finishes her statement
The defense attorney looks childish reacting to the Prosections closing. GROW UP !!!!!
The state closing was spot on.
.
Her and her attorney must have been intimate for him to offer his water bottle to her 😂
Her face alone warrants a guilty verdict. The lack of jawline and chin is a crime 😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Humpty dumpty for sure
@@jojojana4455 🤣🤣🤣🤣
She looks like a Bobs Burger character
THANK YOU!! THAT TINY ONION HEAD ON THAT WIDE BODY BUILT LIKE A BOTTLE OF FINGER NAIL POLISH!
I had a friend who had a boyfriend like this. He was insane and thought he was a cop. I’m talking about buying weapons and gear police would use. The last she told me he was “investigating” their neighbors because he thought they sold drugs. I mind my own business but I told her to run and take her baby. This is Hannah. It was only a matter of time and her family, instead of doing something they sit there and cry for HER.
Her sitting there with her arms crossed and no emotion says everything I need to know about what type of person she is. Go to jail where you belong!
When the cops tell you on the phone FOUR TIMES to not do it, don't do it.
Did that lawyer just take a drink of water from his water bottle, then offer the defendant a drink from his bottle? 😮
I'm so glad I didn't think I was seeing that by myself
Yep.
I saw that too😅
You know they are toasted lmao
I saw that too! 😂😂
Thank God she was found guilty! Great job to the state prosecutor !
The defense attorney drinks his water then offers it to her 😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I’m so happy that her lawyer understood that his defendant was guilty. That has to be the reason why he helped to seal her fate by sitting there making faces and acting immature the entire time the Prosecutor was talking. Hannah deserves to feel the pain by receiving a max sentence.
"Find her guilty on each and every count". The way she grabs her paper and walks off was so epic.
They way the defense lawyer sitting shaking his head shows his mentality
Don't forget that she only had the gun for TWO WEEKS!
My God!!!!
She was looking for a reason to use that gun!
Two attorneys on opposite sides of the spectrum. Should be used as a case study in law school…one attorney, had a terrible defendant but he was terrible lol. On the other hand, this prosecutor needs to be a law professor if she isn’t one already! One of the most articulate and well thought out presentations I’ve ever seen of anything. Left nothing uncovered.
Should've minded her own business
He attorney is just as arrogant as she is
HER ATTORNEY = GROTESQUE
What a disrespectful display of emotion & disregard for the family of the victim.
The defense attorney is being fidgety like he needs a shot of dark liquor 😂
Yep.
Defence attorney trying his best to get a guilty verdict for his client.
The defence attorney making faces and smirking while the prosecutor was speaking, played a role in the jury's decision, in my opinion.
Her attorney is very unprofessional.. arrogant, entitled just like his client
Prosecutor did an excellent job laying out the charges and supporting evidence for each and every charge. She was clear concise and did an awesome job educating jurors, making it easy for them to find the defendant guilty of all charges.
How unprofessional is the defense lawyer? Making faces and gestures during the arguments. You're a grown man, act like it.
Right? I could not stand watching him
@@caseycat it was fun watching his face when the verdict came back 😂
It’s crazy to think that I’ll be in my 70’s possibly hearing about her getting released. This case is SO senseless, the definition of malice murder. Still can’t believe she was free for 4 years afterwards. Told the story over so many times to others to twist herself into the victim that she started to believe it.
The lawyer laid that out so plain that a fool could not error. Payne was wrong from start to finish and the most ridiculous thing of it all is that she had nothing to do with what happened.
The defense attorney took a sip out of the water bottle then offered his client to drink from the same bottle.
I see from the comments that I'm not the only one who noticed the reactions Payne's atty had during the closing arguments. The Defense atty. should have been held accountable for his actions when the State was speaking. He was rolling his eyes and head, mocking the State's every comment he feels will harm his client. Where did they find this joker?! And why isn't the judge doing something about it? I have never seen this behavior in a court of law. Guilty as charged. 💯%
He's like the man with a hundred ticks. At this point l'm wondering if it's one of those new fangled medical issues 🤔
TRAYVON MARTIN "To allow an armed aggressor, who confronts an unarmed non-threatening victim, to claim self-defense, when the victim struggles to disarm the aggressor, is contary to COMMON SENSE and the law." TRAYVON MARTIN
Totally agree, same type of case, Say his name❤
The prosecutor flawlessly explained the facts. Well done!! The defense and murderer were just icing on the cake with those ridiculous facial expressions.
The way Mrs. Prosecutor points back at the defense table feeds my soul. No energy nor f's was expended..lol
Right!
She was letting them know that the doors of prison was opening up for her.
That defense attorneys face throughout this tells me all i need to know about him. P.O.S.M.F...🤬
Who in the right mind does what she did.
Just take the licence plate and report him to the police.
Had she done that she wouldn’t be spending the rest of her life in prison.
Ridiculous woman
Her defense attorney was an absolute clown, so unprofessional and constantly pulling faces during the prosecutors closing was bizarre. Felony prison for the rest of your life for not minding your own business, that’s a whole new level of stupidity.
The slide presentation is extremely effective.
Defense attorney is falling asleep. Unbelievable!
This prosecution team was on point! Wonderful closing argumentsby this DA. Great job & thank you! 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
She is the only attorney that had an ounce of professionalism and class