Gangles' Grand MIS
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 07. 2021
- CHECK OUT THE NEW VERSION HERE: • Gangles' Grand MIS V2
GanglesXIII was the first one to find both easter eggs in my Simple Storage Input video and lucky for us he was the right guy for this feature! Gangles has a wealth of knowledge when it comes to the Multi-Item Sorter and has decided to share his design for a complete storage system!
Gangles' Channel: / @ganglesxiii
World Download: [OUTDATED]
metamilo's Discord: / discord
Storage Tech Discord: / discord
Box Sorter used in the design: • New Better Box Sorter!
1-wide tileable MIS config: • 1-Wide Tileable Multi-...
Credit to Command Leo for the Unstackable Sorter: / discord - Hry
![It just keeps getting better! [Cart-Based Multi-Item Sorter + Hybrid Storage]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9eHcvMi7HUw/mqdefault.jpg)
Sorry for the mismatched voice levels. Damnit Jim, I'm a block game guy not an audio/visual guy!
loud boi ait boi
Real blok gaem guys play with master audio set to 0!
@@monochromeart7311 real block game guys play with sounds on and VanillaTweak's quieter droppers/portals/minecarts/shulkers/pistons addons
Full audio all the way
He's -dead- *silent* Jim
Now this looks cool asf. Gotta keep doing the whole easter egg thing when you can, because it seems like a very cool way to interact with the community
Continue doing the Easter eggs, it was really fun trying to find them!
Just came across your channel now. This is the sorter I'm gonna build!
Ive done research across countless channels, and then I came across yours, and this one is the best! Maizuma games and gnembom also have some very cool MIS storage arrays, but this one take the cake!
I like the concept of MIS, but many designs are significantly slower than hopper speed, and dont integrate bulk storage into it.
This design does both, and I love it! 11/10 stars for you!
I’m experimenting with modifying the MIS 4.2 to have a single item gate incorporated, so you can interleave MIS and bulk slices, because usually you have a default item and a bunch of variants (cobble, cobble steps/slabs/walls/etc). Gives a little more flexibility to make your design more of a chest hall than a chest room, and takes up less space
Just as a I finished building a 2 wide MIS lol.
Great video Rapscallion!!
Finished and working perfectly - thanks GanglesXIII!
cutest storage system ive seen, i want it
What great compact design, might build it on my server :)
This is a way! Great works! And Hello from Russia
Love this system and the ui, sad that I just finished my mis v4.0 but for sure I know already Im gonna update it all :p
6:34 lol 'A glitch in the Matrix' - That's how I feel every time I try to record a video and something goes wrong.
It never fails... or it always fails? I'm not sure how the idiom applies in this situation lol
So hyped to get my hands on the schematic and take a closer look at everything, I'm really impressed by the relative compactness of the whole system, especially the non-stackable sorter, I often struggle to make my non-stackable sorters as compact as that one is.
All credit to CommandLeo for the unstackable sorting.
@@RaPsCaLLioN1138 Its truely very impressive. I’ve been looking for a complete system for a while and this was exactly what I’ve been looking for, I spent a long time expanding and “completing” the system you showcased previously, but was struggling with those bulk sorters and found the entire room to be a little too small for my liking, again, spent a while expanding and polishing, and after many failed attempts and nearly giving up, BOOM, here’s this one!
Awesome work brother, I’ve always been a redstone head since I started playing almost eight years ago, always been big into storage systems and chest halls, but for the longest time the standard single item sorter on mass seemed to be the easiest reliable option, there were multi-item sorters invented, but always with the downside of needing each space in a chest being filled which was just to easy to neglect, especially on a server with other players.
Your videos completely re-sparked my love for building big sorting systems and I feel I’ve really found my niche in the storage tech community.
Keep up the awesome work brother!
Much love.
@Aidan @RaPsCaLLioN1138 Just had a look at the world download and sadly I had to find a very big flaw in the design of the bulk storage. The chests where the filled shulkers are stored is locking the hoppers between the chests. While this is great for lag-reduction it means that shulkers will only ever advance to the next chests when new items are added to the storage. So if you clear out the one accessible chest you can't access the shulkers in the chests behind it.
@@The_M1k3y thank you for bringing this to my attention, i'll see what i can come up with
@@ganglesxiii don't sweat it. Just thought I give some heads up (didn't find your handle or I would have tagged you directly). To be fair I was mostly interested in the box-presenter you created/used. This thing trumps my own design both in size, features and robustness. Though I would replace the rails with observers. Those are way cheaper in a survival setting than the rails.
Unstackables sorters? that's illegal, great job!
if you put in a shulker box for the MIS to sort, where does the empty shulker box go? i tested it in the world download and it never ended up in the empty shulker box area. also, when you add items that sort into bulk storage initially not in a shulker box, does the system know to put them in a shulker box? and where does it get shulker boxes for this?
EDIT: i figured it out, didnt realize the empty shulker box storage had so much storage, just kept taking out the empty shulkers and found the ones i put in. this system is truly incredible and you guys did an amazing job with it
Hey friend =D, as always pushin the envelope for whats possible in minecraft
An entire double chest of arrows is way too much xD. Considering that the system uses one arrow for each armor/unsorted item and the fact that you have only 3 double chests of storage for each category, the amount of arrows a dispenser can have is more than enough.
A minecart gets hold because at the end of the minecart sorter there is an unstackable filter. If you care about that buffer minecart you can add another hopper below.
I'm happy to see it used in this storage but I have bad news for you :P. I've started making a 1.17 unstackable sorter that will sort powder snow (and that will be fish-preserving), so people will have either to rebuild their storage or have it asymmetric xD
1dc is entirely too much, would double as player arrows also, not bad news good news for the next version! Thanks Command Leo!
Can't wait for it! as of now, the powdered snow ends up in my lava box, i also sped up how quickly the boats showed up by replacing the cobweb with powder snow
@@ADHeyDonuts you can replace the cobweb with a dropper/hopper tower if you want, I just aimed for as few hoppers as possible (for when it's not in use).
@@CommandLeoive removed it all together seems fine
@CommandLeo what would cause the armor stand to go to the armor chests along with the armor piece? Each time and armor item goes through, the stand comes along with it.
Super cool storage system, looking forward to building it! Sorry if I missed it in the video but is this directional?
made a recreation of this and am having trouble getting the shulker box sorter part done. The hopper is not grabbing the shulker box out of the dropper above it to give to the dispenser. Is there some sort of fix? Also my piston heads don't pop back out?
is there a simple way to change the shulker box display so it fills fully before displaying?
Got it block for block but im still gettin odd stragglers. Not too sure why but gettin a couple items out of place =[
So I might be doing this wrong but the MIS + box sorter filters aren't there when i paste the schematic in a 1.17 test world. What have I done wrong?
EDIT: What I did wrong was have pasteIgnoreInventories set to "true" instead of "false." My bad, hopefully I'm not the only one that's made this mistake! ;)
How does this system effect the mspt while running and not running
what wasnt really explained was the unstackable itemsorter. i know how to split unstackables from stackables but i dont know how to sort the unstackables. so can you explain please?
so i built this a while ago on a small minecraft server. but it doesnt work properly and i cant figure out why. it doesnt sort the items, the filters break and its just a huge pain. did this by any chance break in 1.19/1.20?
If you put "bulk" items in small quantities into the system, the boxes in the bulk storage get filled up with the respective items eventually? Or in order to get full boxes you have to put them as such into the system?
This is probably the biggest drawback of the system. The item gate can group up the items to an extent, but if the input is broken up too much it will result in less ideal bulk output of smaller quantities in more boxes. I am still working on improving this aspect, and have found somewhat of a workaround, if you're interested come visit me on discord. Info can be found on my yt channel.
@@ganglesxiii I didn't see anything on your channel? Am I missing something currently getting "bulk" Items with about 100 items?
Is this worth to build in a singleplayer world where you need less storage capacity?
Wether its worth it or not is up to you, it can be made smaller or larger by changing a few things. I personally found that MIS only is too small for things like stone(even when gathered manually) and for farm outputs, and found also i had too much for a reasonably sized silo. So i would recommend box storage at some point. Probably don't need 5 dc of box storage per slice but that fit nicely between the modules. Which brings me to my next point , its modular so you could build up MIS first and once you grow out of that, start to work on bulk sections as needed. The design was mostly for the convenience of being able to store pretty much every thing in a small area as opposed to a 700 slice hall.
I seem go be getting wrong items in chests with the MIS every now and then. Any ideas that could help? And would increasing the timing if the item gates comparator clock help, or would it break the system?
It seems to mostly be on the second side. Which makes me thing the dropper line across is what's messing it up. But I'm not sure
@@InvidiousApple i think youtube thinks im spamming replies or something and is blocking my response to this, check droppers for clogged items
@@ganglesxiii yes I saw it in my notifications but didn't see it here, thank you
I found a flaw I cannot identify. I used litematica and verified it. Sometimes the items of a newer batch get to the adjacent slices. I would guess that something is wrong with the defragmetator. Can someone help me on this one?
Would really love to see the world download or schematic for this soon!
they are now in the description
I ended up with petrified oak slabs in the empty shulker box chest. I cannot for the life of me work out where they came from. I tried loading the schematic afresh and checking all the hoppers and droppers but no sign. Do you know where they came from / Is the system now broken?
I have also had issues with the schematic that I pasted in my world acting a little flakey, but not sure if it is something I did. It works fine in the world download. After I pasted it in a world I started messing with the bulk sort filter so I could bulk cobble, stone, etc. and started moving some items around in the filter. I think I broke it by messing with filters while items were running through it, and started finding Filter paper in chests, then everything started ending up in the Andesite chest. Couldn't figure out what I did so blew it away and reloaded the schematic and still had some issues. So I think I am going to make my own schematic off of the world download. The build is awesome tho'!
OK, me n00b, schematic was fine. I did a couple things that I don't know if they mattered or not, but after deleting and re-pasting the schematic into my world it works fine. 1) I originally pasted it underground and it was touching some walls - I have no idea if this matters but I removed more space around it so it is surrounded by airblocks. 2) At one point I had litematica pasteIgnoreInventories to true which is horribly wrong (no items in filters!), made sure it was back to false. 3) I changed pasteCommandInterval to 2 which probably had nothing to do with it, but I am superstitious so now 2 is the right answer. 4) I think my original problem was caused by me messing with filter chests while it was on and running - won't do that again. 5) Finally, I love running it with the lightmatica placement on because you can really see the way it is working and what is happening because lightmatica shows all the states changing.
Other stoopid things I did which may or may not have messed me up: 1) Let a villager in who turned into a farmer and started messing with composters. 2) Clicked repeaters while trying to access hoppers 3) Put item frames near filters (so I could remember what is in them) not thinking that the item frame was putting out a signal 4) accidentally broke droppers and put them back backwards. Avoid these.
I do recall an instance where i some petrified slabs turned up in the empty shulker storage, which i did find to be odd since i don't ever use petrified slabs. So its kinda wierd if they still show up. Im not sure off hand if raps set up a filter to sort petrified slabs, and if so a filter could have been compromised. Possibly due to items stuck in droppers. Can happen and break filters if system is unloaded during operation .
I really like this system... but the sound it makes is just getting annoying. Is there a way to make it silent instead of the consistant click sounds?
turn down your volume 🧠
This would be perfect if it had an input chest for full bulk storage shulkers that skips the unloader and goes straight to the sorter
You can put one in very easily. Just connect it to the purple water stream and it'll go straight to the box sorter
↑
Can the bulk storage handle 16-stackables?
Yes
@@ganglesxiii Awesome thanks heaps! Hey also noticed a tiny flaw when testing the system, I'm seeing some items appear in the empty shulkerbox chests, I can combat this by adding another shulkerbox filter in that upper part of the dropper chain to redirect any items that have found their way into the wrong elevator back into the input, but I'm just wondering why this is happening?
@@anml8512 i can see no obvious reason why it should, i can provide better help on discord
why so quite?
When's the world download coming out?
Will post tomorrow.
@@RaPsCaLLioN1138 awesome I’m really excited to check this out in a real world
@@RaPsCaLLioN1138 it is now tomorrow 😤😤
@@zuccy_93 I came back here looking for this too lol
@@zuccy_93 Perfect timing. Check description!
As a newbie to MIS, am I insane to try to build this from the schematic?
It seems like youtube doesnt like me posting my discord id and blocks my replies i would recommend getting to know the system a bit first, its likely that you will come across an issue from time to time and the knowledge would be usefull for troubleshooting. It is a moderately complex system made up of separate modules i could help you understand it better if you'd like. I've posted my discord in the about tab on my youtube channel, since my messages don't get through if i post here
found slave I ;)
Is the system directional?
No
@@ganglesxiii I was looking for more information on the unstackable sorter but the link doesn't go to a discord channel for me. Is that link valid?
Saw that he replied below and went to his profile. Nevermind about the link. :)
'simple'
Not for survival