How To Win A Civil War - The Spanish Civil War (Part 2)
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 06. 2024
- Which side won the Spanish Civil War, and how did they achieve victory? This is the second in a two-part series on the conflict.
Subscribe to the channel if you enjoy this content. You can also find me at the links below.
Odysee: odysee.com/@PaxTube:6
Telegram: t.me/PaxTube
Gab: gab.com/PaxChristus
Twitter: / erenrespecter
The Spanish Civil War began in 1936, waged between the Spanish Republicans and the Spanish Nationalists. It started when General Francisco Franco, as well as General Emilo Mola and Jose Sanjurjo, led a military coup against the unstable Second Spanish Republic. They were joined by large parts of the Spanish military, Catholic Church, and new radical factions like the Spanish Falangists. The Republic, meanwhile, was defended by liberals, communists, and anarchists. This video details the factions and how the war played out. It also investigates what critical factors help win a civil war.
Special thanks to Censored Anon for helping to create the thumbnail for this video.
0:00 The War Begins
3:18 Catholicism VS Communism
5:54 The World Responds
8:05 The Factions
12:40 Early Stages of the War
15:16 Justice for the Church
16:12 The Final Stages of the War
18:59 Aftermath
I do not own any of the images, videos, and songs displayed in this video. They are used for educational and entertainment purposes.
#Documentary #SpanishCivilWar #CivilWar - Zábava
18:30
“Some marxists were even studied by Franco’s Psychiatrists to see what mental traits made them become Marxists. The research discovered those attracted to Marxism had mental health issues.”
No truer words ever spoken.
That seems like a ton of b*llshit to me, and sounds a lot like what the Soviets did to people to didn't agree with the regime.
Don Vallejo-Najera
@@occam7382 it's even true to this day. Franco was not lying.
@@BoricuaKelfa, mmm, no. That still sounds like bullsh*t. There's no political ideology where everyone who agrees with it has a mental illness, at least one that mainstream science agrees exists. The only people who would claim that are people who don't like that particular ideology. Seriously, even an 12-year-old could figure that out.
ok. Explain why communism is popular among the morally corrupt and people with mental health issues.
In the siege of Alcazar, it wasn't just the garrison. There were as many as 600 women and children, the families of the soldiers, taking refuge as well. However, one man did not have his family with him- Colonel Moscardo, whose son Luis had been captured by Republicans.
They called him on the phone and told him that if he did not surrender in ten minutes, his son would be shot immediately. He asked them to put his son on the line.
Luis said, "What should I do?"
Moscardo's response was "Commend your soul to God, and die like a patriot, shouting Viva Christo Rey." (Long live Christ the King)
Luis said, "That, I can do."
Moscardo was forced to listen to his own son be shot, as the price of victory.
Even though Luis ended up murdered by the reds, he wasn’t shot during the call but a few months later.
@@pargoman854 No, he was inmediately shot. That is a rumor.
Luis sounds pretty based
Spain saved itself: it was the only country in Western Europe, along with Finland, not to need the Marshall Plan, not to need Anglo-American troops, let alone Soviet ones. No one blames Finland for defending itself against the red communist threat. But they blame Franco's Spain
Spain (Blue Division) and Finland invaded the USSR in 1941: both returned Stalin's visit. Anarchists, seoaratists and Trotskyists aside, the 'republican' troops that Franco faced was the Red Army (Soviet commissars, generals). If the 'Republica' had won, Hitler's Blitzkrieg would have turned against Red Spain in 1940. Franco saved the country from complete destruction.
Spain inaugurated with the Discoveries who inaugurated the European Era and globalization. France (greater material and hegemonic power in Europe), England, Ottoman Empire, Protestants, Dutch Calvinists (Spain dominated the Netherlands) pirates of the Atlantic and Mediterranean, discover, conquer and organize the world. Spain's disgrace begins in the 19th century and then culminates in continuous civil wars (unlike other European countries, Spain did not have civil wars)
The nationalists did not fight against "republicans" but against populist fronts (Popular Front of socialists, separatists, communists) that had already attacked and destroyed the Republic from within (in the essay of Revolution in 1934 and in the electoral frauds of 1936. The PSOE (socialist party ) was the main agent in the destruction of republican legality, which caused the Civil War.
The Francoist dictatorship was a response to an extraordinary crisis, a non-totalitarian dictatorship, a relatively small state, a market economy, with a lot of individual freedom (paradoxically more than today with laws to control the individual, education, Woke cancel culture.
Unfortunately, Franco was only defeated by those he had saved from the Red genocide: the Catholic Church of the Second Vatican Council approached the Reds, destroying itself, and delegitimized the regime, even supporting Basque terrorists. Franco's Catholic Spain was prosperous. Current Spain is threatened with balkanization and degeneration.
@@lucario2188 Is Pargo Man a communist who goes around spreading rumour and conjecture so as to sow doubt and distrust?
Based and Francopilled.
No grifter Franco who betrayed the axis and child grooming leftist christianity arent based. czcams.com/users/ChristcuckPastors here is your "based Christianity"
@@ilostthreeaccountstoyoutub1434 repent infidel
Spain saved itself: it was the only country in Western Europe, along with Finland, not to need the Marshall Plan, not to need Anglo-American troops, let alone Soviet ones. No one blames Finland for defending itself against the red communist threat. But they blame Franco's Spain
Spain (Blue Division) and Finland invaded the USSR in 1941: both returned Stalin's visit. Anarchists, seoaratists and Trotskyists aside, the 'republican' troops that Franco faced was the Red Army (Soviet commissars, generals). If the 'Republica' had won, Hitler's Blitzkrieg would have turned against Red Spain in 1940. Franco saved the country from complete destruction.
Spain inaugurated with the Discoveries who inaugurated the European Era and globalization. France (greater material and hegemonic power in Europe), England, Ottoman Empire, Protestants, Dutch Calvinists (Spain dominated the Netherlands) pirates of the Atlantic and Mediterranean, discover, conquer and organize the world. Spain's disgrace begins in the 19th century and then culminates in continuous civil wars (unlike other European countries, Spain did not have civil wars)
The nationalists did not fight against "republicans" but against populist fronts (Popular Front of socialists, separatists, communists) that had already attacked and destroyed the Republic from within (in the essay of Revolution in 1934 and in the electoral frauds of 1936. The PSOE (socialist party ) was the main agent in the destruction of republican legality, which caused the Civil War.
The Francoist dictatorship was a response to an extraordinary crisis, a non-totalitarian dictatorship, a relatively small state, a market economy, with a lot of individual freedom (paradoxically more than today with laws to control the individual, education, Woke cancel culture.
Unfortunately, Franco was only defeated by those he had saved from the Red genocide: the Catholic Church of the Second Vatican Council approached the Reds, destroying itself, and delegitimized the regime, even supporting Basque terrorists. Franco's Catholic Spain was prosperous. Current Spain is threatened with balkanization and degeneration.
And?
Degenerate people are drawn to socialist ideology. Well I loved my drugs and degenerate sex in my youth. Although I no longer take opium or go to orgy's after becoming libertarian. I'm still a degenerate so IDK improvement wise just better political ideology.
Dont forget under Franco, Spain once again became a "Great Power" (in the top 8 largest economies)
Yeah but that’s not as good as you think that is
Also cause of Franco, Spain became a Democracy once again cause of his pussy ass son Carlos
Bro,franco got spain on the greatest famines that spain have ever experiencied.If we wre in top 8 is because there are fairly good infldustry.By the way in 2007 the economy was the seventh ,even higher than canada
@@doomernationalist6898 Why?
@@gabinohermosillatamayo8236 Almost like a war torn nation needs to recover lol
This video has taught me a semesters worth of history in 20 minutes.
Spain saved itself: it was the only country in Western Europe, along with Finland, not to need the Marshall Plan, not to need Anglo-American troops, let alone Soviet ones. No one blames Finland for defending itself against the red communist threat. But they blame Franco's Spain
Spain (Blue Division) and Finland invaded the USSR in 1941: both returned Stalin's visit. Anarchists, seoaratists and Trotskyists aside, the 'republican' troops that Franco faced was the Red Army (Soviet commissars, generals). If the 'Republica' had won, Hitler's Blitzkrieg would have turned against Red Spain in 1940. Franco saved the country from complete destruction.
The famine in Franco's Spain was due to the blockade that the country, like a kind of North Korea, suffered from the Anglo-Saxon victors (who occupied Gibraltar and stole the Spanish empire) and the Reds. Spain never had allies.
Spain inaugurated with the Discoveries who inaugurated the European Era and globalization. France (greater material and hegemonic power in Europe), England, Ottoman Empire, Protestants, Dutch Calvinists (Spain dominated the Netherlands) pirates of the Atlantic and Mediterranean, discover, conquer and organize the world. Spain's disgrace begins in the 19th century and then culminates in continuous civil wars (unlike other European countries, Spain did not have civil wars)
The nationalists did not fight against "republicans" but against populist fronts (Popular Front of socialists, separatists, communists) that had already attacked and destroyed the Republic from within (in the essay of Revolution in 1934 and in the electoral frauds of 1936. The PSOE (socialist party ) was the main agent in the destruction of republican legality, which caused the Civil War.
The Francoist dictatorship was a response to an extraordinary crisis, a non-totalitarian dictatorship, a relatively small state, a market economy, with a lot of individual freedom (paradoxically more than today with laws to control the individual, education, Woke cancel culture.
Unfortunately, Franco was only defeated by those he had saved from the Red genocide: the Catholic Church of the Second Vatican Council approached the Reds, destroying itself, and delegitimized the regime, even supporting Basque terrorists. Franco's Catholic Spain was prosperous. Current Spain is threatened with balkanization and degeneration.
I remember Franco being described as basically a facist in school nothing more
@@tobrukasmarduk7732 the only reason Finland exists today is because by the end of WWII, Finnish politicians came to Joseph Stalin to beg him not to turn Finland into a communist puppet-state or to fully annex them into the USSR. And Joseph Stalin was in a good mode after all the gains in Europe and East Asia, so he agreed.
@@alexvig2369 ' Uncle Joe, so magnanimous and generous, after fighting three wars against the Finns, kindly ceded Finland because he was in a good mood and had a satisfied appetite LOL 😀 Russia annexed and still occupies Kuril Islands in Japan, demanded Hokkaido. It's as funny a joke as the Molotov Cocktail, sarcastically dubbed for being Stalin's humanitarian food donation. Simo Häyhä, the White Death and Franco laugh 🤣🤣🤣
@@tobrukasmarduk7732 Territorially, Finland is but a shadow if itself and the most recent border is due to the collaboration with the Nazis. Deal with it. Joseph Stalin utterly cucked you.
it's funny how when my Spanish teacher spoke to us about the Spanish civil war she only mentionned the bombings and the collaboration of National Spain with the third reich and Italy, and we just had to all assume that if the Nationalists were bad then the Republicans must have been way better (well she mentionned that the Republicans also did some bad things but never explained how bad it was, like digging up nun corpses and exposing them in front of churchs bad). Thanks for this great video, im happy to finally see the full history behind the Spanish civil war from the Nationalists percpective
Indeed. I don't know where you are, but in the USA people have barely even heard of the Spanish Civil War, and those who think they know something are about as well-educated on the subject as your teacher. I, too, am elated to find these videos.
@@dougearnest7590 Burger here. Quickly working to educate myself on this matter.
In would say that religion is a mental disease
That is taught in Spain. It was call the red terror and the white terror. Pax Tube is very partial as he talked about the republicans war crimes and ignore all the nationalist war crimes, which were much more. 4 people were executed by the nationalist for every 1 the republicans executed.
@@dougearnest7590 I'm sure mostly don't even know their government help the traitor army
Fun fact: Franco's combat-hardened army was mostly in Morocco. He transported them into Spain _by airplanes._ Small, transport airplanes carrying one or two dozen men each, doing several flights back-to-back every day.
The Republicans were so divided and dealing with in-fighting that they couldn't even stop this slow, mild bleed of soldiers until Franco's full force had landed in Spain, unopposed.
Guess who provided those airplanes..
@@Galland_ Austrian painter?
We call them airplanes German state aid in reality.
@@Galland_ The Germans.
Thank God they were helping the good guys.
@@PMMagrojust like the commies, who actually ran the "republicans" and flooded them with more aid than the nationalist recieved. No commies, no assitence from little mustache painter man. If commies won, Spain got blitzkrieg. Yeah the good guys won one, even if it was temporarily.
With all those casualties and a crippled economy you can understand why Spain didn't want to join Axis in WW2. Spain just had enough for one decade.
Well done Pax, your videos are the best.
They still sent soldiers just not enough.
They did not, spain had voluntary divisions in both sides, spanish soldiers had presence in the liberation of Paris and the siege of Leningrad.
Yes they did. Instead of declaring war he sent his vice president to led the blue divisions.
Spain saved itself: it was the only country in Western Europe, along with Finland, not to need the Marshall Plan, not to need Anglo-American troops, let alone Soviet ones. No one blames Finland for defending itself against the red communist threat. But they blame Franco's Spain
Spain (Blue Division) and Finland invaded the USSR in 1941: both returned Stalin's visit. Anarchists, seoaratists and Trotskyists aside, the 'republican' troops that Franco faced was the Red Army (Soviet commissars, generals). If the 'Republica' had won, Hitler's Blitzkrieg would have turned against Red Spain in 1940. Franco saved the country from complete destruction.
Spain inaugurated with the Discoveries who inaugurated the European Era and globalization. France (greater material and hegemonic power in Europe), England, Ottoman Empire, Protestants, Dutch Calvinists (Spain dominated the Netherlands) pirates of the Atlantic and Mediterranean, discover, conquer and organize the world. Spain's disgrace begins in the 19th century and then culminates in continuous civil wars (unlike other European countries, Spain did not have civil wars)
The nationalists did not fight against "republicans" but against populist fronts (Popular Front of socialists, separatists, communists) that had already attacked and destroyed the Republic from within (in the essay of Revolution in 1934 and in the electoral frauds of 1936. The PSOE (socialist party ) was the main agent in the destruction of republican legality, which caused the Civil War.
The Francoist dictatorship was a response to an extraordinary crisis, a non-totalitarian dictatorship, a relatively small state, a market economy, with a lot of individual freedom (paradoxically more than today with laws to control the individual, education, Woke cancel culture.
Unfortunately, Franco was only defeated by those he had saved from the Red genocide: the Catholic Church of the Second Vatican Council approached the Reds, destroying itself, and delegitimized the regime, even supporting Basque terrorists. Franco's Catholic Spain was prosperous. Current Spain is threatened with balkanization and degeneration.
They were smart about it. Joining the Axis was anything but smart, but sending an army of volunteers to the Eastern Front gave the new government a handy valve release for all those zealots.
7:06
For the record, Russia still has that gold.
Not all of it. Some was used to purchase Hunter Biden paintings.
Well, probably not anymore.
Regards: 2023 AD.
Off course. They gladly sold weapons etc in exchange for gold/cash. Otehrs gave Franco credit and blamed the communists for interfering :)
One of the biggest misconceptions people have on the Carlists is that they are / were "absolutists". Far from the truth. Their motto is "Dios, Patria, Fueros y Rey" which means "God, Fatherland, local institutions / laws and king". They wanted to return to a time when each of Spain's many kingdoms and principalities had local officials and institutions which could govern the territory and limited the king's power. For example, the king had to ask the Cortes (similar to the States General in France but more powerful) to increase taxes or to change any laws. In fact, Carlists see unchecked power by a monarch very unfavorably.
Yeah, thats correct. Are less centralizers than the liberals and the absolutism
Only the Bask wanted that so they lose repeatedly.
props
"And Franco declared victory on April 1st"
What an epic prank
Here come the tankies
That, or anarchists. Both have very hot takes about the Spanish Civil War.
@@intergalactichumanempire9759 anarcho-communits are more honest and real Marxists than the tankies
Yes
This is an excellent introduction to a subject most Americans know little about. As a History teacher with a special interest in this war, I highly recommend it.
The prelude to this war seems eerily familiar to our situation here in the US now. We haven’t escalated to that level yet but the rhetoric is there
glad there are some teachers out there with `real` interests in their subject
Thank you!
Finally, a win for the good guys.
I would recommend you to check Nationalist war crimes before declaring them good guys
There is no such thing like "good" or "bad" guys in War. There are only The Bad and The Worst.
@@panos617 You're right. When it comes to warfare, there are is not "good side" but the countries/ideologies involved can be good or bad. I would argue this was the case in WW1.
Fascists are not the good guys😂
Compared to the marxists they are. All humans are flawed, however. And especially in times as chaotic as war. There will always be wrongdoings, abuses, atrocities on both sides of any war.
“Spain became a republic again after Franco’s death.”
Uhh last I checked the Monarchy was restored. Yeah they became democratic but that’s not the same as being a republic. Forgive me if I’m just being pedantic.
To a monarchist, a constitutional monarchy is no better than a republic. If anything it's worse, because it creates a false frame of reference for what a monarchy ought to be.
@@cupofjoe7900 true enough but saying it has become a glorified republic or crowned republic would have made more sense
Con Mon better
Spain saved itself: it was the only country in Western Europe, along with Finland, not to need the Marshall Plan, not to need Anglo-American troops, let alone Soviet ones. No one blames Finland for defending itself against the red communist threat. But they blame Franco's Spain
Spain (Blue Division) and Finland invaded the USSR in 1941: both returned Stalin's visit. Anarchists, seoaratists and Trotskyists aside, the 'republican' troops that Franco faced was the Red Army (Soviet commissars, generals). If the 'Republica' had won, Hitler's Blitzkrieg would have turned against Red Spain in 1940. Franco saved the country from complete destruction.
The famine in Franco's Spain was due to the blockade that the country, like a kind of North Korea, suffered from the Anglo-Saxon victors (who occupied Gibraltar and stole the Spanish empire) and the Reds. Spain never had allies.
Spain inaugurated with the Discoveries who inaugurated the European Era and globalization. France (greater material and hegemonic power in Europe), England, Ottoman Empire, Protestants, Dutch Calvinists (Spain dominated the Netherlands) pirates of the Atlantic and Mediterranean, discover, conquer and organize the world. Spain's disgrace begins in the 19th century and then culminates in continuous civil wars (unlike other European countries, Spain did not have civil wars)
The nationalists did not fight against "republicans" but against populist fronts (Popular Front of socialists, separatists, communists) that had already attacked and destroyed the Republic from within (in the essay of Revolution in 1934 and in the electoral frauds of 1936. The PSOE (socialist party ) was the main agent in the destruction of republican legality, which caused the Civil War.
The Francoist dictatorship was a response to an extraordinary crisis, a non-totalitarian dictatorship, a relatively small state, a market economy, with a lot of individual freedom (paradoxically more than today with laws to control the individual, education, Woke cancel culture.
Unfortunately, Franco was only defeated by those he had saved from the Red genocide: the Catholic Church of the Second Vatican Council approached the Reds, destroying itself, and delegitimized the regime, even supporting Basque terrorists. Franco's Catholic Spain was prosperous. Current Spain is threatened with balkanization and degeneration.
Good video! I’d like to add A few more points to your video as well.
1) Communism at the end of the day both a distorted intellectual & economically illiterate idea that comes down to justify mass slaughter and expropriation of one’s enemies. Not to mention that if one has read up on the Italian school elite theory, you realize that one of the goals communism is a “dictator of the masses” which is impossible because of the iron law of oligarchy (it’s always why democracy at scale also doesn’t work.)
2. One of the biggest criticism of Franco is the repression his forces did in territory they captured, White Terror” vs the “Red Terror”, and how many they killed (80k to 100k by the Nationalists vs 55k to 70k by the Republicans) A lot of these summary executions early on were done to stop any form of resistance as well as tons of enemies settling scores over the last five years of politicization. It dropped off a lot after 1937. Franco himself only allowed an additional 20,000 executions and gave the rest prison time or had them rebuilt towns and cities
No doubt that Spain would’ve endured a Soviet like system of purges, cultural destruction and mass murder routinely if a Third “Revolutionary” Republic emerged victorious where it was a one and done thing for the Nationalists.
3. Overall it was probably better for Franco to win. He kept the country out of WWII, he modernized the country and kept the country socially Catholic and Spaniards under his rule were freer and more prosperous than every Eastern Bloc country. A shame that Spain fell down quite fast after he died.
Probably one of the few historical examples of a “Victorious Counterrevolution” in recent times. ¡Arriba España!
¡Santiago y cierra, España! 🇪🇸
"he kept the country out of ww2" lmao he was raring to join the axis except he spent his forces on the civil war. He also received air and ground support from mussolini and hitler. "only 20,000 executions" You people are fucking deranged.
atleast the fascist fell
Brilliantly put good Sir
Let's not forget this
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M%C3%A1laga%E2%80%93Almer%C3%ADa_road_massacre
Under Franco's government Spaniards didn't have to pay taxes, and it was very common for the middle class to own more than one house :^)
I'm confused if people didn't pay taxes then how did the goverment pay for anything?
@@ProjectEkerTest33 Real governments dont need your money to build great nations. Our fiat money of today's western countries has nothing to do with the money the romans and the "fascist dictators" used
@@oldgrub So what money did Franco use then? I mean presumably his army and stuff got payed somehow. The Romans payed their army through A: Taxes and B: Conquest and as far as I know after the civil war Franc didn't do a lot of conquest
@@ProjectEkerTest33 why ask me when you can do your own research?
@@oldgrub Because I've tried and haven't found any mention of Franco saying people didn't have to pay taxes. If you have a source I'd love to read it.
One of my family friends fought on the Communist side during the Spanish Civil War. While I and this man were on friendly terms despite the fact that he was a Communist with me a Catholic his family hated my guts.
The common thread for these communists and revolutionaries, no matter what conflict is being referred to, is subhuman levels of violence and grotesqueries. Literally the worst of humanity.
The violence committed by the falangists was far worse across all metrics
We need more videos like this. Most write Franco off as just another fascist but he was a true Spanish hero who saved his people, his country and his faith.
General Wanko was a bastard
He wasn't even a real fascist, his beliefs aligned more with basic Spanish conservatism.
I wouldn’t call him a “hero”
Even after the civil war Spain was still in heavy decline, not being super “prosperous” as the video said it was.
Although economically Spain was doing great, he had killed thousands like most dictators to get to the top.
Franco is one of the better fascists but I feel as though at the end of the day he still is a dictator and this video is a bit biased
Edit: Did some research and for a lot of Fascist Spain’s history the country was either rebuilding or economically stagnant which the 60’s kind of being the only truly “prosperous”(if you can call it that)decade in Francoist Spain.
He was a hero… but the true hero (that never was) was José António Primo de Rivera. Falangist Spain would have never surrender again to a ‘republic’ like in 1975.
@@darthprimalmanrequiem2354commies arent humans so no loss here
it's so refreshing to find a good channel that doesn't sympathize with marxism. 4 videos into my binge and i think you'll be a new favorite.
Keep up the good work!
Not only does it not sympathize with marxism, it misrepresents every part of communism
While Nationalism is gaining ground again in Spain, it's such a shame that division is still plaguing the country.
Excellent video, Pax. The Spanish World and the Anglosphere share many similar problems in the current day.
Concuerdo con todo lo que dice, pero hombre, vaya a Misa y vea un vídeo del Doctor Miguel Ayuso.
hola dum
Based
@BobJeff2003 This but with trans "people". Raise the 41 percent
Based
I came across your channel by mere chance, and I got to say your synopsis of the civil war is great. As a Spaniard I thank you for spreading the reality of this often ignored history.
Franco winning was for the best and he wasn’t a bad leader from what I can tell
Spain saved itself: it was the only country in Western Europe, along with Finland, not to need the Marshall Plan, not to need Anglo-American troops, let alone Soviet ones. No one blames Finland for defending itself against the red communist threat. But they blame Franco's Spain
Spain (Blue Division) and Finland invaded the USSR in 1941: both returned Stalin's visit. Anarchists, seoaratists and Trotskyists aside, the 'republican' troops that Franco faced was the Red Army (Soviet commissars, generals). If the 'Republica' had won, Hitler's Blitzkrieg would have turned against Red Spain in 1940. Franco saved the country from complete destruction.
The famine in Franco's Spain was due to the blockade that the country, like a kind of North Korea, suffered from the Anglo-Saxon victors (who occupied Gibraltar and stole the Spanish empire) and the Reds. Spain never had allies.
Spain inaugurated with the Discoveries who inaugurated the European Era and globalization. France (greater material and hegemonic power in Europe), England, Ottoman Empire, Protestants, Dutch Calvinists (Spain dominated the Netherlands) pirates of the Atlantic and Mediterranean, discover, conquer and organize the world. Spain's disgrace begins in the 19th century and then culminates in continuous civil wars (unlike other European countries, Spain did not have civil wars)
The nationalists did not fight against "republicans" but against populist fronts (Popular Front of socialists, separatists, communists) that had already attacked and destroyed the Republic from within (in the essay of Revolution in 1934 and in the electoral frauds of 1936. The PSOE (socialist party ) was the main agent in the destruction of republican legality, which caused the Civil War.
The Francoist dictatorship was a response to an extraordinary crisis, a non-totalitarian dictatorship, a relatively small state, a market economy, with a lot of individual freedom (paradoxically more than today with laws to control the individual, education, Woke cancel culture.
Unfortunately, Franco was only defeated by those he had saved from the Red genocide: the Catholic Church of the Second Vatican Council approached the Reds, destroying itself, and delegitimized the regime, even supporting Basque terrorists. Franco's Catholic Spain was prosperous. Current Spain is threatened with balkanization and degeneration.
I'm spanish, and franco's regime was quite bad. there was mass famine till the 60s, and after franco sold spain to the us so they could trade with the west, things got better mainly for heavy industry and tourism, but the heavy industry was not enough effivient and depended on the state and it hurt the economy. also, art and culture were very censored and the centralization policies in the 60s made spain the depopulated country it is nowadays
@@tobrukasmarduk7732 not receiving the marshall plan or the comecon was bad, spain needed it but america denied any help to the war-torn countrt
@@arriba_teruel not to mention the white terror. It is a shame that this whole comment section and the video are so biased.
I agree, Franco was the lesser evil, but an evil nonetheless
@@arriba_teruel The US started the century by robbing the colonies of Cuba, the Philippines, Puerto Rico and Guam. United Kingdom occupies part of Spain until today. Both support corrupt Morocco to take Ceuta and Melilla. Traditionally, Anglo-Saxons have always fought to harm Spain. France supported the Etarras. All, with the Soviet tancor, imposed famine on Spain. And Spain in the 1960s progressed to a much healthier society than today. Franco saved Spain from communism and the misfortunes of World War II: the Popular Front hoped to fight the Wermacht in the Pyrenees.
Spain under Generalissimo Franco was formally, officially, a monarchy: Franco was never head of State, but was only head of Government. He ordered that upon his death the legitimate heir to the spanish throne should become King, which in fact did happen, and Spain is till this very day NOT a Republic, but a Monarchy - the Kingdom of Spain.
Republics are better than monarchies
@@machovalkarie7896yes, if you are a republican.
@@snalemsnolek1539 I am a republican democracy for life
@@machovalkarie7896 if you are beyond 70- yes, I guess, you could say,that it is “for life”
@@snalemsnolek1539 what do you mean by that
You should make a vid on Tolkien's beliefs not just by his letters to CK Lewis or looking at what he said in general but also by analysing LoTR along with that would probably make for a good video
Sounds like your wish was granted
It's a shame that after the war, Franco broke the alliance with the Comunion Tradicionalista of the Carlists, and that all the good he did has been swept away. With the Spanish realms and the world at large becoming ever more evil, I think its high time that Carlists and the Falange renew our old alliance.
@@timcusack9388 Alfonso XIII was never a Carlist, he belonged to the illegitimate line of Doña Isabella, whose usurpation of the throne from Don Carlos V in 1833 is what kicked off the First Carlist War. What did happen is that in 1936, Don Alfonso Carlos I, the last direct heir of Don Carlos V, died childless, naming his nephew Don Javier I as regent, and eventually he was proclaimed King by the Comunion Tradicionalista, though to this day not all who call themselves Carlists accept it, and even among those who do they are divided between his two sons, Carlos Hugo who embraced Marxism, and Don Sixto Enrique who holds to Tradition. As to why Franco did chose Alfonso's descendants, I believe it was simply because ideological differences between Carlists and Falangists meant that without a common enemy to fight, they fought each other and relations broke down.
How? People speak of these things but they're not willing to connect or gather in person to take on these evils.
Franco never broke any alliance with carlists, the Nationalists weren’t all carlists. They ended up having a lot of power during the entire regime, but again, they had to share it with other factions like the Falangists (republicans) and other monarchists (wanted Alfonso XIII back).
@@pargoman854 they had to share it with other factions like the Falangists (republicans) and other monarchists (wanted Alfonso XIII back).
Not really, Franco made the unification decree reducing carlists to soldiers fighting for him, rather than their king. Real carlist politicians were then exiled.
Whats the difference with the actual Bourbons ?
I used to be a commie and get mad about the Nationalists won, but now I'm appreciated that Republicans lose
Either way, the democracy ruined it, sadly.
(yes i hate democracy btw)
Democracy always chooses Barabbas
The democracy didn't ruin it, the complete and utter failure to establish the political and economic institutions necessary for a democratic state to function ruined it. And the institutions established under Franco continue to hold Spain back to this day.
@@occam7382 Liberal garbage
Literal horses@*t. Considering liberalism and democratic republican values are what predominantly pervades now and IS currently destroying Spain from within. Progressive values and attitudes.
Much like the U.S. democracy is the inherent flaw.
@@occam7382 no, internal dispute and the refusal of incompetent politicians and treacherous syndicates to fix actual problems, focusing on the repercusion in votes alone, is what's ruining our nation. On top of that, globalism deprives people of purpose, they now live for themselves, for their ego, for their enjoyment. Franco's institutions solved the very same problems that are killing Spain right now
¡Jose Antonio Primo De Rivera Presente!
He would not have liked Franco.
Man, I do love happy endings : )
6:44 The original Antifa was earlier. The "Antifaschistische Aktion" was established by the German Communist party in 1932. Otherwise Great Video, Thanks!
Same flag, different language. Was seen everywhere during the 2020 riots when they made American cities look like Mogadishu.
did they also lie and say their just an idea then too?
@@killgoretrout877 Indeed they did. We just pointed out the vandalism and murders and shot right back, "Did an IDEA do that too?"
@@r.a.5086 no, that was their "free speech". Same as here in Spain, the catalan separatists (a minority, in fact) prepare an anticonstitutional referendum, and when half of it gets crushed because the competent half of the police authority actually moves a finger, they use such freedom to do democratic things like burning down the streets, threatening the lifes of countless citizens, looting several middle class businesses and trashing bars and restaurants. While riot control was active, it was spread thin and took long to even push towards the center of the riots
They fought Nazis, how scary
He's back!
Just a clarification Pax, Carlist were not absolutists because that is a political view based on protestant theology and the Monarchy that they proposed was the traditional one that you rightly indentifie as one from the Middle Ages. God bless you Pax and looking foward to your next videos. For more info: czcams.com/video/MG-v3i2cogs/video.html
Bro absolutism has been in place since the Roman empire. What protestants existed then?
Both Catholics and Protestants tend to be absolutists, if they're consistent in their faith.
@@theclown3967No because Catholic Medieval Monarchies were limited by Catholic Moral Law. The World society was called Christendom for a reason.
Extremadamente basado.
Arriva España y viva Cristo Rey 🇪🇦
I did not know that there was an actual Spanish way of saying based lmao
Basado😎
yet another Pax Tube banger!
At 12:56 that is not the Alcázar de Toledo, but the Alcázar de Segovia, but only a nitpick - this is a very good video.
Another minor nitpick is that Orwell was enrolled in the militias of the Troskyite POUM party, so he had to flee Spain with the NKVD at his heels, returning to England by June 1937
7:24 Tolkien was Catholic, btw. Coincidence? I think not.
Great videos! Your videos are really the only ones I still watch on CZcams. Very well put together and includes all information.
To bad Franco was denied "Jus Exclusivae" (Papal veto) against John XXIII (vile Freemason and Communist), as Franz Josef Of Austria/Hungary succeeded doing in 1903 against the diabolical Mariano Rampolla del Tindaro and ushered in the reign of St. Pius X.
I know, and Franco knew, he himself, was not a monarch, but I give him big time credit for trying.
Just found your channel, subbed.
Just found you on Twitter in light of some Vtuber insanity. Appreciate this history content too. Keep well.
Twitter is horrid
Also you follow a cult so that makes it even cringier
@@LavaCreeperPeople Interesting response.
@@MrAlex_Raven oh
@@MrAlex_Raven ok
Been waiting for this!!!
Fantastic video!
I would love to see if you cover other wars and struggles like the Mexican Cristero War.
Correction. A British owned private aircraft flew Franco from The Canary Islands.
It was hired, like a taxi. It is highly likely that British Intelligence knew what was happening.
Just a note to anyone Analysing the Spanish Civil war.
With the Red and White terror going on in Spain during the Conflict.
Let's just say Spain was Battling two Authoritarian Powers with little Alternatives.
A remarkablely interesting and informative video. Your really giving a perspective not talked about often.
I was going to point out that Spain didn't become a republic after Franco's death, but taking into account how limited and useless the political duties of our king are, maybe you are right in some sense.
Also, Franco should have been king.
Amazing video! You did your research well.
Roe V Wade has been overturned.
Hallelujah
We need to go further. Calrism is the best Unity
Congratulations on a great video. I had the privilege of touring Spain in 2019. Many priests, nuns and seminarians who died in 1936 (martyred by the Republicans) were buried in churches. I saw the church Franco ordered built, northwest of Madrid, to serve the unification of Spain. It has a beautiful set of tapestries depicting the Apocalypse. Just a couple of months after my visit, the Spanish government removed Franco's body from the church, then a couple of years later, Primo de Rivera's body.
No good deed goes unpunished.
another banger paxxo!
this is probably my favourite channel now. so many parallels to the russian civil war
I was trying to remember who Pax Tube when I saw this video. I went "huh I don't remember subbing to a documentary channel". Then I saw your previous video on High Guardian Spice in the suggested videos box.
Fantastic video and great presentation, with one caveat, I would characterize the civil war more as Nationalism vs Communism.
Excellent Doc!
I would not say that Franco was a monarchist.
Awsome video Pax. Good won the war over evil.
So glad there’s a part 2
Great video! very informative
Thank you for teaching me this
the Church was one of the richest institutions in Spain. It of course aligned with the landowners. It was one of them.
George Orwell suffered a breakdown while in British colonial service in Malaysia. Look at how he lived and it becomes obvious that he was mentally disturbed. He hated cruelty in the name of power. Imagine his horror to discover the cruelty of the Republic. He looked for some worldly salvation and never found it. All he could do is leave a warning for the world in the form of Animal Farm and 1984.
Actually, he left a warning for the opposite. Ever read Homage to Catalonia? In the first chapters he praises the collectivization of industry in Anarchist-controlled Catalonia
Fantastic information and your slightly indicated lean is the right one. Thank you for further educating me on this my brother. You do us all a service, and may we avoid the problems of Spain in the future by peaceful, electoral, and legal means; despite the current feel of hopelessness.
All will be well, this too shall pass.
Hey congrats on 10k, forgot to say!
Well made documentary!
In that case, would it also be OK to make a video about the Cristeros Wars in Mexico? It kinda looks like the opposite of the Spanish Civil War.
Can you dive in the differences of Catholic/Roman catholic, Protestant and Orthodox?
New to your channel and love the content you put out
Some differences in the 3
Catholic:
The Dogmas like immaculate conception, Vatican I, II and the Filioque. Papacy with pope as head. Infallibility of the pope in certain cases.
Protestant:
Sola Scriptura, salvation by grace alone, faith alone. No papacy
Orthodoxy:
Theosis
Essence-Energy distinction
Theophany
Divine grace as a divine energy
Patriarchs instead of papacy with pope as head.
Hope this helps Brother. ❤️☦️
@@chocolateneko9912 Alot of Catholics dont accept Vatican II. Most do but a minority dont
Ah, I recognize that Falling Skies OST.
You're a fan of some good stuff I see!
Brilliant. Thanks again for your efforts and research. May be one day you will like to do one on the state of Spain nowadays.
Can I get the study of Marxist brains?
General Francisco Franco's chief psychiatrist, Dr Antonio Vallejo Nagera
His conclusions ranged from the sublime to the sinister. The report claimed, for example, that 58%of English prisoners were "single men with sexual experience outside prostitution", that 7% were recruited "by charlatans in Hyde Park", that 17% had signed up in "employment agencies". All (three) Welsh prisoners were "alcoholics", he found.
"A priori, it seems probable that psychopaths of all types would join the Marxist ranks," he reasoned before starting the project. "Since Marxism goes together with social immorality... we presume those fanatics who fought with arms will show schizoid temperaments."
Little surprise, then, that he classified almost a third of the English prisoners as "mental retards". Another third were deemed to be suffering degenerative mental illnesses that were turning them into schizoids, paranoids or psychopaths. Their fall into Marxism was, in turn, exacerbated by the fact that 29% were also considered "social imbeciles".
"Once more we see confirmed that social resentment, frustrated aspirations and envy are the sources of Marxism," he added. "The persistence of the ideological attitude of the English Marxists is the result of their closed minds and lack of culture."
A small correction Pax, Carlists aren't absolutists, they rather fought for a traditional monarchy as was common in Spain up until 1714, that is with fueros/kingdom statutes, a federal monarchy albeit antiliberal, and Catholicism. The French view of absolute power came to Spain in 1714, but what Carlists saw as the source of power was God who gave power to the people, who invested that power upon the institution of the monarchy and the King, who was on his behalf responsible of being a good ruler for his subjects and a good king for his territories.
Fueros is what it's called. Basically charter rights where the King had strong power but limited in so far as it stopped where actions would corrupt Catholic moral virtue of Spanish society. Also means the monarchy has to respect local regional rights first. Government not Federal and centralized but equally split as a confederation of small kingdoms.
Reactionarist are still mad Franco didn't turn Spain in a traditional monarchy. They talk about how many kings sided with the low class against the aristocracy, that wasn't in Spain.
I visited Spain in 2022, and on the visit to Toledo I saw the Alcázar; it is not the one you posted in the video. The picture you used in 12:55 when discussing the siege is the Alcázar de Segovia, which I also visited. Segovia went to the Nationalists very early so there was no siege there. Just thought u should know.
Great video, but on a slightly autistic note, the International Brigades were not the first instance of Popular Front tactics or Antifascist group (like antifa). This orignally begin with communist paramilitary groups in Weimar Germany like the Roter Frontkampferbund and the original Antifaschistische Aktion. Both of which were KPD (German Communist Party controlled and paid for by Moscow) backed paramilitary groups at odds with any and all Nationalisr paramilitary groups in the Weimar Republic.
True. In fact Antifa is an actual group LITERALLY based directly out of Germany. Says alot.
EXCELLENT JOB!
Wonderful video, Pax!
(I have never seen that footage of those Soviet tanks and American planes.)
He (The Video maker) made a mistake showing a twin engine bomber with U.S.A.A.C. markings in the video. The U.S.A. was neutral in the Spanish Civil War, 1936-39. Many Communists from the U.S. fought on the side of "The Republican government", in "The International Brigades", but they were privateers fighting for their pal Karl Marx.
@@gusloader123 Like ISIS, they should have been stripped of their citizenship and never allowed back into the country.
@@gusloader123 - I wonder how many of them were too stupid to know who they were fighting for. If it happened today I would know the answer to that question, but I wonder if they actually understood what they were doing back then.
@@dougearnest7590 Hello. Hmmmm? I do not know. It seems that some people (usually under 30 years of age) will join whatever group or "ism" is the "Flavor-of-the-day".
You're right about the B-25 Mitchell bomber but those T-26 soviet tanks were the ones the republicans used against the Nationalists and in fact a huge bounty was announced by the Nationalists to anyone who could capture a T-26 as the armor the Germans and Italians had was far inferior.
You should read "Mine were of Trouble" by Peter Kemp. He is the chad to virgin Orwell and his "Homage to Catalonia", so to speak.
Haven't read Homage to Catalonia, but I have read For Whom the Bell Tolls. Quite ironically, it does an excellent job at portraying the randomness and cruelty of the violence in the republican lines, even more so than portraying the nationalists as cruel or bloodthirsty.
I'd imagine Orwell would have something similar to say, considering he had to flee Spain once the PCE and their Soviet friends started purging trotskists and anarchists in 1937
Fantastic video king
Good video man. As a spaniard, I appreciate this content. Just a tiny correction: Spain did not became a republic again after Franco's death (20:17). I am Spanish and we live in a Parliamentary Monarchy, being Felipe VI the King of Spain. After Franco's death, in 1975 Spain became a monarchy, and only after 3 years, in 1978, Spain became a constitutional democracy. With that said, Viva Franco y Arriba España.
2:17 you probably meant a monarchy? Though it was Franco's intention that Spain would return to the monarchy through Juan Carlos I
I quite liked your video and do hope you'll make ones on other counterrevolutions like the vendee, sanfedismo, brigandage and Cristeros but I think you might have made two mistakes
Firstly the Carlists did not want a centralised absolute monarchy but were instead aiming for a restoration of decentralisation and localism through the concept of Fueros which amounted to local privileges, autonomy and rights instead of rule from the bureaucracy in Madrid.
Secondly officially anyway Spain did not become a republic on Franco's death but instead restored the bourbon monarchy even if its just a monarchy in name only
other than that good video and keep it up
I love these videos on history! Could you do more?!
Very based
@Paxtube the image you show when talking about Toledo's Alcazar 12:56 is Segovia's Alcazar. Those are different cities
The Spanish Civil War shares similarities to the USA today
I see it as more like Weimar Germany today - sort of. The Left has its own armies of thugs, but there's no significant "far right" to speak of, just decent people capable of taking care of themselves but not to the point of forming their own army for protection from the left. The media is already hard at work for the bad guys. Hyperinflation should be here soon. Then Civil War after that. Hopefully the good guys will still be capable of resistance - I would like to see the restoration of a Constitutional Republic in my lifetime.
Very well done! Concise and informative for those who may not be familiar with the conflict and who have consequently many Leftist distortions spread across the West by communist sympathizers and bitter Republican who exiled themselves after 1939.
Tolkien is getting more based by the minute
Real
"Captain Levi, do you know about the sea?"
Appreciate the Aot soundtrack
Could you give me your sources please? I would love to learn more.
Please give more info on the carlists. We need more content and information about them and the filangists. Also, Catholic Integralism.
answer: just get the germans to fight with u
Lol can't deny that strategy, as long as it doesn't become a WW
Great history lesson...thank you!
I had never read "For Whom The Bell Tolls," Hemingway. Enjoying Hemingway and his writings, I began to read this title, not knowing anything about the Spanish Civil War, nor Hemingway's political leaning. To my dismay, Hemming supported the Marxists Republicans in Spain and was secretly working for the Russians. This inspired me to research The Spanish Civil War, and found your video. Again, thank you.
Spain isn't a republic today, it's a constitutional monarchy, only with a president instead of a prime minister.
Wrong!!
The leader of the coup was Sanjurjo that had the highest rank (Lieutenant General) and Mola was the one that prepared the plans.
Franco only joined the coup at the elventh hour.
Ave Cristo!!!
Salute Franco!!!
¡Díos, Patria, Rey! ❎👑🇻🇦🇪🇸
Which movie was used in the video?
Will you consider making a video about why and how Spain went from based fascistserino to today's globohomo?
Capitalism
Viva Espana! Viva Franco!
Good Timeline: The Video
The only war yihad and crusade, both.
What books do y'all recommend on the Spanish civil war?