Q&A: What Does Islam Teach About Organ Donation? | Dr. Shabir Ally
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 02. 2022
- Dr. Shabir Ally explains that organ donation is permissible according to Islamic teachings so long as the person giving the donation isn't harmed. He discusses consent and cautions that organs shouldn't be sold.
If you enjoy this video, please support our work financially by visiting our website www.quranspeaks.com or sending an etransfer to igive@quranspeaks.com
► DONATE: www.quranspeaks.com/
► SUBSCRIBE: czcams.com/users/subscription_...
COMMENT, LIKE and SHARE
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Twitter: / quran_speaks
Thank you Dr. Shabir. This is exactly the question I had in mind today!
Thank you this was interesting 😊
Jazakhallah Khairan
Wow clearly explain simply in full details and circumstances
I already enrolled myself for organ donation after death!!.. And i request everyone to do the same.. Atleast for your eyes!
This makes sense. If anything it should be encouraged
Excellent. Mr. Shabbir is very rational and quite close to teaching of Quran. 👍
Quite close? 😂 I think all of his answers are in the light of Quran and hadith.
My uncle been has been living on one kidney since 1988 and the one that he's surviving off of is going bad. I can't wait to show him this video and tell him if we can insist him to take one of sons, daughters, nephews, or nieces. He's 74 years old and thinks we should keep our kidneys instead of donating them to him because he believes that he'll pass away eventually and it'll be a total loss. Inshalla Allah SWT helps him and makes him age longer
He's ri8... He's already 74..
So it's not worth it... Think practically
@@ovaiszohan3766 He can say that. Imagine your Dad/Uncle might die because his kidney is only 40% working. Would you try to donate a kidney to keep him living as long as you can?
@@gamal318 I would think of it... But i would also hope that people advice me the same... Coz as a medical practitioner I know its not gonna work as we think it should on a normal person...
H I N D U I S M R E A L I T Y 🕉
The devil has deceived the hindus by making them believe in more than one God 👉 Ekam Evadvitiyam - God is only one without a second (Chandogya Upanishad 6 : 2 :1 )
The hindus believe in many Gods including the following 3 but the reality is the following 3 are names & attributes of the one God, not Gods
1 ➜ Shiva the destroyer.
2 ➜ Vishnu the preserver
3 ➜ Brahma the creator
Islam Teaches the muslims to believe in 0nly one God
The following 3 are names & attributes of the one God 👉Allah
1 ➜ Al-Mumit (المميت) the Taker of Life
2 ➜ Al-Mu’id (المعيد) the Restorer
3 ➜ Al-Muhyi (المحيي) the Giver of Life
⚠️The Problem Is We Trust & Don't Check ⚠️
➜ The aim of all 4 great imams was to guide us to the Quran & Hadith. All the four imams said, if you find a hadith which contradicts what we have taught you then REJECT what we taught you & follow the teachings of the Prophet P.B.U.H
➜ As we know the aim of all the scholars, muftis & preachers is suppose to be turning mankind to the Quran & Hadith therefore if any Scholar, Mufti or Preacher is contradicting the Quran or Hadith we must REJECT what they said
➜ All the muslims agree 0NLY one sect ( group ) will enter PARADISE, this means SCHOLARS from all the other sects will enter the FIRE ( This is why we MUST check what we are being told is correct from the Quran & Hadith )
➜ Allah made it clear whatever the ➡️ Prophet said ⬅️ take it & whatever he forbids you from leave it ( Quran 59:7 )
❌ N0T WHAT THE IMAMS SAID
❌ NOT WHAT THE SCHOLARS SAID
❌ NOT WHAT THE MUFTI SAID
❌ NOT WHAT ANY PREACHER SAID
We must always demand 4 proof from the 🔍 Quran & Hadith or check ourselves when Scholars, muftis, or preachers differ on any matter
mashala , beautifully answered, The diff with Madhab Hanafi ,reason and rational.
Interesting video. Moral and ethics, I love it. I have another question, I have being diagnosed with cardiopathy. I read an article regardig pig heart transplant and pigs valves. In fact, I know a person who went through this procedure 7 month ago, valves I mean. He was given two choices, artificial & pig. The medical observation was that the living tissue was less probable to rejection. Wallah, I hope I never go that bad. But, what's our stand on this new method, for certainly we ain't eating it, yet it is inside one
If it's a matter of life and death there is no harm in using a pig heart valve
It is permissible... Our religion is beyond these silly things...
Hmm seems to me if one has no other choice just like eating pork to survive would seem appropriate, do not take my word I am a new re vert. Problem is do you oink after?
Artificial parts transplantation benefits far outweigh animal and human organ or other parts donations - ethically medically, As this is a channel that deals with spirituality may it be added that a deceased person's organ transplanted is then ALIVE. So the deceased soul is not completely in the after-life. The Qur'an e Sharif hints the fall of civilizations that went against Nature.
in life or death situations eating pig will be also be halal, so pig transplant would be appropriate (sry commenting too late)
What Sura was that again?
Very interesting. I’ve always thought that is was not permissible with the concept in mind that we shall not alter our bodies before returning to God (I.e: tattoos, etc).
Same
Okayh, is monetization permissible or not? Cause i played this video and a musical advertisement appear.
Can u answer my question in quran speaks?
I don’t know why Muslims have made this big issue about organ donation. Taking fatwas from this person or that person. As a matter of fact it is so trivial matter Allah Swt has not mentioned organ donation in Quran “ not a single Ayah “
We human are instructed by Allah to help all life. He who happen to save one life is in fact like he or she saved all man kind. So if any one donate organ as while living like blood and blood products donation or single kidney and in case of cadaver if family of the deceased one agrees to donate any organ to could potentially end up saving a life. This perfectly fits with Quran so why Muslims have made big issue of this matter help a human doesn’t matter what colour, race, sect of religion he or she belongs to. We don’t need intermediaries between Allah and us to give us fatwa that organ donation is permissible in Islam. Hope this will help any one who take Allah alone as source of guidance “ min doonillAllah “
Allah has not mentioned because organ donation was not a thing in 7th century Arabia. Quran or matter of fact any religious book is as smart as it's people who wrote it and the culture where it was written.
Sir, what do you say, regarding a Muslim who would like to donate organs or tissue upon their death? Given that a Muslim is buried without delays, etc. Thank you kindly.
What is the ruling if using a pigs heart to replace ?
Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem said it's not permissible because breaking the bone of the dead person is as though breaking the bone of a live person as per sahih hadeeth. Even a rose petal falls on the skin causes pain so you can't cause the dead so much suffering.
I always thought it was haram because supposedly our soul could still feel and experience what's happening to us and around us after we die, not because it's altering your body or whatever. That's literally the only reason why I'm not an organ donor, I don't want my soul to feel that pain. (Well and also because I saw a Scandinavian documentary about how the families of a dying person are pushed to accelerate their death so they could donate the organs, even though it's not always 100% sure they're actually dying.)
In fact, even Muslims perform surgeries for patients, but what is the Fatwa on the use of animal organs for humans? But, Khinzir (Pig) is indeed forbidden in Islam because it is dirty & najis mughallazah (impure thickener).
This is about using animal organ as transplant to human.
Anything can be used to save your life. Eating pork is forbidden. Not using it as a life saving tool.
We shouldn't take advantage of a person's lack of medical knowledge or kindness or momentary emotional state and accept an offer of organ donation
Basically it’s permissible and more to doctors kind of reasoning and advice
Assalamu Alaikum. I have a question. Is bitcoin or cryptocurrency trading Permitted in Islam? or prohibited?
Yes it’s halal as long as it doesn’t involve in interest
It's fake money so it's probably not allowed
His answer and explanation on the topic make sense. However, what is the basis of rationalizing this in the context of Quran and sunnah? He did not provide any reference. This sounded like his own view. We need references from Quran to make an important decision like this.
If donating an organ will save a person life, I don't see anything wrong with that.
@@a.l7025 there are a lot of other common sense things that we do not do because they are not mandated by the Quran and sunnah, because Allah knows better than you and me. On the surface something may look right but this could be otherwise that is beyond human comprehension; only Allah knows. If you know or come by any Quranic reference on the topic, please share; this is very important for us, Muslims.
@@abdullahalkafi5584 It will be impossible to know, but as a muslim physician, I have seen ppl live another day because of transplant. They must be on lifelong immunosuppression and complications can arise but it gives a person more time. Imagine a young muslim who would die without a transplant. With a transplant one can live years iA and continue religious duties.
@@twixotic04 I agree with you on the apparent benefit of this but again, I am looking for the reference so I can make a decision to donate my organs. I can clearly see how human can be benefited by organ donation, but at the same I don’t want to do anything that is not permitted in Islam. Please share any reference; I am contemplating organ donation.
I think that the issue is that Quran is silent on this
What is the reference from Quran or Hadith for this fatwa...?
Lol you asking the wrong guy for that
@@jeep7612 No..... he is intelligent and knowledgeable, but what Allah says in Quran that we have given very small knowledge to human.
Apart from this what is my concern, that we need to give reference and don't just carry others though & pass it on if you like.
There is no Quran or Hadith reference. Just like there is no Quran or Hadith reference about traveling via rockets to the space. These things DID NOT EXIST BACK THEN. Use your brain, or donate that too.
@@jamieammar6131 😂😂 well said
@@jamieammar6131 yeah lmao 😂
Can a muslim donate organs or blood to a kafer and vice versa.
I heard you can donate as long as the non-Muslim is not enemy combatant. Allah know best.
@KojLok-dy6gp All non Muslims are enemy of Allah, they will be thrown into jahannum 100%.
In our faith, we Orthodox Christians are forbidden to be organ donors. If you want to know why, you can ask an Orthodox priest in the Toronto area to explain to you why. He probably would give you a better explanation than I would. Also, you might want him to explain to you theosis. In one of your previous videos, you mentioned theosis, but it became clear to me that you really do not understand the doctrine after watching it.
It's not allowed in Islam either but some scholars dispute it.
That's because your Bible and Qur'an came out 1500 years ago where people were so simple minded, nobody at that time ever imagined humans being able to transplant organs. The fact that none of your religions ever prepared or gave thought to such possibilities shows that they are not from a divine god with visions of the future. They were manmade by people of that time.
@@crestfire8008 So, I guess you have already talked with one of our priests and had him explain all of this to you. With whom did you speak and what did he tell you?
Sad that you can't donate organs, I'm assuming then you forego accepting organs as well. Still strange, since donated organs can really increase the years to someone's life. Donated eyes can really change someone's life too.
Here In the United States, I seen many people who died into accident and the doctors took most of their organs without permission from the family, not only the kidney but also the brain, tongue. They just don't care and they say it's a state and local law to do this and the people can't do anything about it.
They don't require family permission as long as the person who died had 'donor' mentioned in the ID or driving license or something.
@@jamieammar6131 two kids that were my friend was killed last year and they were the age of 17, 13 and they ha no license or id but they still took their organs. Disgusting
@@cybercracker3781 Well it's the US laws I suppose. Presumed consent. If one does not register to organ donation opt out registry, authorities think of it as presumed consent. Unethical I agree.
DR SHABYR IS ALWAYS LOOKING FOR GOOD FOR MANKIND .I WISH ALL MUSLIMS WERE LIKKE THESE PEOPLE
It was narrated from Umm Salamah that the Prophet (ﷺ) said:
“Breaking the bones of the deceased is, in sin, like breaking his bones when he is alive.”
On that bases even cutting and bringing organs too not allowed from the dead person.
Allah knows best....
Not all hadees are true!..
Saving somebody's life is a bigger deed.. And maybe this hadees is about not to harm dead bodies in an insulting way... It nowhere states about organ donation...
There’s a difference between desecrating dead bodies (breaking bones) and willing, consensually giving away ur organs when u die…
@@ovaiszohan3766 this is sahee Hadith and indeed saving someone's life is equal to saving all humans but this case is different.
@@TheFloatingcats you are the owner of your body and it is different from the wealth which can be distributed after the death.
More discussion required on it because in Saudi Arabia fatwa is opposite on dead person.
1. This hadith talks about bones while people donate kydney,liver etc
2. People were beheaded during the Prophet SW's time.
3. Stop taking fatwas from Salafi scholars. Take from Sunni scholars.
4. This hadith has a war context and is talking about mutilating bodies for show. Quraysh used to raid each other's caravans and kill the rider and hang up his body parts like ears and hands for show. Its talking about that kind of mutilation. Prophet ordered everyone strictly not to mutilate bodies during war.
Yes donation but not from uygurmuslims 😇
china left the chat...
What the hell!!!!
Don't you know that the Prophet Sallallaho Alayhi Wasallam said not to manhandle a deceased person because he feels it????
So it's ok by you to dismember a dead person for their organs and the Ummah start throwing the Aahadith of Rasulullah Sallallaho Alayhi Wasallam in the dustbin???
SubhanAllah!!!!
May Allah AzzaWaJal save us from these so-called "Sheikhs"
Organ donation is a shady business