Why are so many Afghans being kicked out of Pakistan? | Start Here
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 12. 2023
- More than 370,000 Afghans have fled Pakistan after the government there announced a crackdown on undocumented refugees. What’s going on? And what do deteriorating relations between Pakistan’s government and the Taliban government in Afghanistan have to do with it? #AJStartHere with Sandra Gathmann explains.
Chapters
00:52 - Why are there many Afghan refugees in Pakistan?
01:15 - The difference between documented and undocumented refugees.
01:38 - What’s behind the Pakistani government’s policy?
02:37 - Why are Pakistani officials linking Afghan refugees to security?
02:59 - Who are the Pakistani Taliban? (Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan, TTP)
04:44 - Why the TTP issue is straining relations between Pakistan’s government and the Taliban government in Afghanistan.
05:42 - How is the TTP issue linked to Pakistan’s refugee crackdown?
06:03 - Who is among Pakistan’s undocumented refugees?
07:34 - How the deportation policy caused shock and panic among Afghans in Pakistan.
08:17 - How Afghans have been threatened and harassed by Pakistani officials.
09:43 - What happens once the refugees cross into Afghanistan?
This episode features:
Babar Baloch - Regional spokesperson, UNHCR
Abid Hussain - Pakistan correspondent, Al Jazeera digital
Madiha Afzal - Fellow, Foreign Policy, Brookings
Abdul Khaliq Sediqi - Communication Coordinator, Intl Rescue Committee
Check out our other Start Here episodes bit.ly/3o0BEIW
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
And let us know in the comments if there’s a topic you find confusing and would like Start Here to cover ⤵️
You can find the full Start Here playlist with all our episodes here ➡
czcams.com/play/PLzGHKb8i9vTxodrArxXFPziklf0iqFdC5.html
Qatar should take some refugees 😂
Anjelina ❤
Please stop making anti Pakistan videos. We hosted Afghans more then 50 years and what they gave us is terrorism , samagling and they they supported anti Pakistan factors across the world . We have legal right to deport illegal afghans from our country.
Because America orders to do that... 😅
how much usa paid aid to pakistan to destablize afghanistan again
If Europe does this then every Muslim gets angry.
Every country has right to deport illegal immigrants. That's what every European country is already doing since long
LOL you forgot it was U$EU led b0mbing that has led to this.
Afghans have their own country named as Afghanistan which was invaded by USA for last 20 years, now the US has decided to call their troops back and give afghanistan back to taliban so afghans can go back to their country who took refuge in Pakistan. I think before complaining why not ask your governments to stop playing the World’s Police Role and better work for the betterment of their own citizens.
It is USA and Europe , what Pakistan has to face today . You fool .
People generally don't like Europe cause of colonialism and commiting genocides and supporting genocides. Not long ago France in Africa and now whole Europe is supporting another genocide. So try to do one good thing. Those refugees exist cause of NATO. And then don't complain about it. There weren't no refugees before.
If Europe do : Islamophobia
If muslim do : internal matter
also: "what about ... "
it's a shameful act of Pakistan. As a Muslim, I condemn this government action.
Not like the West who's blindly backing up Israel to do the Genocide of Palastinin.
Afghans have been here in Pakistan for 40 years, they're almost 4 millions and what's the problem with sending back illegal ones... They can come through Visa...
@@2012WhatsNext
Prove Genocide!
Under Israel, the “Palestinian” population has increased, not decreased.
Israel is getting rid of Hamas. It’s not Israel’s fault that Hamas use their own people as human shields, Hamas are cowards, and criminals, who have used money for the people of Gaza, to buy weapons, instead of helping their own citizens.
Pakistan made right decision, no country allows unregistered civilians to stay
my heart bleeds for the innocent young people whose problem has been created by fully grown adults.😭😭😭😭😭😭
hateful ageist! Shame. Shame. Shame.
US has already ruined a lot in the region by creating mess and handing over weapons
go see a doctor then why crying here , your tears are as useless as you .
Hello Maurice same here , I also need to understand why in this day and age fully grown Adults are still creating problems for people living in their own homelands which is causing more and more problems from people in other countries who cannot recognise that they are the same as any other human beings from our World , Palestinians will become another failure all round, approximately 84% of Conservative Government MPs are part of the largest pro-Israel group in Europe , most Government MPs have been invited to Israel which have included various levels of expenses , things like this must be addressed and investigated ,
They will not care for us in their warped religious world.😊
Its not just in Pakistan, Iran is deporting About 5 million Afghans. Its sad really, i befriended a few Afghans and then they were kicked out. 😢
😢😮😅😮😢😢😅😅😅😅
I say this as a Pakistani: *our government will not prioritise our needs, even with so many Afghans gone; the Afghan refugees' presence is an excuse and nothing but an excuse, albeit a valid one.*
Israelis highlighting this issue to legitimize forced displacement of Palestinians from Gaza to Egypt.
more money to pocket
Then it's good that this excuse is being taken care of
Thank you for seeing through the bull
Afghan refugees have never been a burden on Pakistan, however Pakistan exists because of Afghan bloods, otherwise Pakistan would have been a part of USSR.... Pakistan owes Afghans,
..... Afghans never forget... will act at the right time.... indeed you will harvest whatever you are planting now.....read Afghan history....
Being a Pakistani,this is shameful. The authorities are deporting only poor and underprivileged people. They are helpless. Wealthy and resourceful Afghans are living peacefully in all the posh areas of the country.
I suspect UN has stopped funding for those immigrants and our Generals are something really found of American dollars.
Shameful, really shameful.
How can 1.5 million be a burden on 250 million people. 90 percent of the Afghans provided cheap labour and maintained the recycling industry of Pakistan.
I feel for those poor people
The problem is that they're living in Pakistan without a passport and visa
@@wajahat7133tumhare mulk Islam ke naam pe bna tha na 😂😂😂 har muslim vahan reh sakega ye vada kia tha na to ab kya hua
Nikl gayi hwa saari apne hee musalman bhaiyo ko nikl rhe ho 😢
@@wajahat7133 they were illiterate and knew nothing about legal process. Even if they tried to be legal, our system never supports such people even local Pakistanis let alone Afghans. Secondly why this idea came into your mind after 40 years that they had no passport and visa. 40 years mean almost 3 generations. Which include two generations born in PAKISTAN. It's as cruel as Israel capturing the land of Palestinians.
You are not Pakistani. You are really an indian 😂
@@ayankachhwaha3203 kon sa nasha kiya hai?
If Pakistan can do it, so can any other nation. The rules based world is coming to an end. Europe should do same.
I see you have no reply. Yes they are very hypocritical with the other countries.
Since when did rules matter.
The difference is that Pakistan puts Islam first while non-Muslim countries put themselves first. Other countries have a duty to help their neighbours eg how many European countries took in Ukrainians. Pakistan should take in its Muslim neighbours, now they kick them out because there is a crisis
Europe should do the same? So European countries should take 4.4 MILLION refugees and allow 1.2 MILLION of them to live in their country for decades without ANY documentation despite several pushes over the decades for every resident to have a national ID card that ties itself to EVERY aspect of everyday life including our cell phone and phone SIMs in a bid to root out terrorism?
Which European country does NOT deport undocumented migrants? Lol. European countries are MUCH quicker to deport. And VERY resistant to taking any refugees in the first place. There is NO comparison.
It isn't against the 'rules' to deport undocumented folk who refuse to get documented despite several drives to ensure everyone is on the system.
That's a terrible idea, ronnie.
Being a Pakistani I must say this is a very complicated situation. On one hand state has the right to take the action because millions of undocumented Afghans are living in Pakistan and that is of course a serious security threat. But, on the other hand this sudden action is not something to appreciate. Many of these people even born here and the have never seen Afghanistan. It will be very hard for these people to go back to Afghanistan. Pakistan is like a dreamland for these afghan people. The Pakistani government was sleeping for so many decades. That is the governments fault. Giving them order to leave the country in such a short period of time is not justified.
they have been living here for more than 40+ years. What security threat? You mean the USA is not providing billions to the Pak gov anymore to fight terrorists, so now blame all of your issues on the refugees. lol
How is it a security threat if so many undocumented afghan refugees came to pakistan? This situation was created because of pakistan, a terror hub. They gave shelter to the talibans and let them operate freely! A lot pf taliban masterminds were given shelter in pakistan. And now, when the whole Afghanistan has been forcefully taken by taliban where even the majority of the citizens never supported taliban in the first place , when their own lives in their own country is in danger because of pakistan, you have the audacity to say that they are a security threat to Pakistan? Lol. Pakistan is a threat to the whole world. You guys can never understand the importance of gaining freeedom from oppressors in your own land because you got your country handed it out for free.
your sitting on Afghan territory that is why many are born there. Punjab and SInd is your Pakistan the rest is Afghan territory stolen by the British.
@@ashsuri1289Pashtuns are eastern iranic all South Asian land was ethnic Indian originally you’re a foreigner. I’m not Paki but I prefer them over you Afghans
@@ashsuri1289your people molest children in caves
I say this as Pakistani: This is being done by a caretaker govt that no one voted for. Astonishing.
Installed by USA.
Toh sadko pe aao na bhai. Caretaker govt banne kaise di?
@@AnujAgarwal_96 are ladoo, jo tere smj se bhar hai wo rehne do. Vegan body building ke uppar dehan do. Aur mn Afghan hoon, Pakistani nahi
@@mdw4700tumko india sey bhi bhagna chahehey
@@VinodBandari-kc1cg India pe hum thookte bhi nahi
Maybe because off the terror attacks Pakistan is facing !! Visited Pakistan and loved it
Pakistan been doing that to Afghanistan for the last 50 years it’s pay back time they supported these guys in the past
naa its all Pak military
Pakistan created talibans w USA during Soviet Invasion
@@adamhaaaq6113 Pakistan has not been doing terror attacks in Afghanistan. It only supported the Afghan resistance during the 50 years of foreigners trying to invade Afghanistan.
@@adamhaaaq6113 Pakistan never attacked afghans but yes they supported USA during the USA invasion but then again they took in 4millions afghans at the time
This is about the best review I've seen of this situation. All sides are heard, and objectively presented by authors who seem to have carefully researched the situation.
Get a visa and visit Pakistan we will welcome you again.. You can do businesses or study here but for this you must fulfill all legal requirements and paper work.. Well done Pakistan, IMMIGRATION & NADRA❤
you said correct
Pakistan never promised Afghan refugees any citizenship. Us, opening our country for Afghans was meant to be temporary, some of the Afghans were given POR (Permit of Residency) but it expired, and many of them did not bother to get it renewed. Pakistan's government is going through a major cleaning process and is fully bent on making sure that Pakistan's passport in not used by Afghans to malign our name abroad. Just today Pak Gov cancelled the Pakistani passport of Afghanistan's interior minister. As a Pakistani, I am certain that the public opinion and majority of the public here is happy at what culminated. Although, it can rightfully be argued that this exodus is not under the mandate of the current interim government. However, the outcome of all this is +++
When God will ask on the day of judgement why you kicked your brother unjustly from his house, tell it to him oh Allah it was all +++
@@Rommyaly Bro, there's no denying them work if they have proper documents. Even during the Khilafat Period foreign traders without an agreement/license were not allowed to work. Today in the modern era of Nations-States things don't work in a simple manner. Every country only allows work permit if they have proper documentation/visas, there are other bordering countries of Afghanistan, if they don't allow Afghan refugees to enter in their country then it's alright but when Pakistan doesn't allow its anti-Islamic??
@@Rommyaly Even during the Brotherhood bond of Mawakhat during the time of Prophet (PBUH) all the Muhajaireen eventually became independent, many of them later moved to other places like Iraq etc. Comparing this to today's situation, the Afghans are still deeply dependent on Pakistan's exchequer, they should find ways to be more productive.
@@Rommyalywhat answer you will give to Allah when he will ask why you did so much terrorism in your brother country? Why you kill 140 innocent children in school? Those children didn't even no why they were being killed😢
@@Rommyaly
What happens when we are registered, can we go to Afghanistan by being registered like this? Afghanis definitely do not tolerate us. People who are protesting against the government's actions should be ashamed of themselves. Historical actions are being taken by the government on the Pakistan nation. What a great favor this government has always remembered in history
For 30 years, Pakistan made these illegal Afghan refugees a part of its society, they did business in our areas, built houses, got married.
But the Afghan majority remained anti-Pakistan, involved in smuggling and terrorism.
رجسٹرڈ کیا ھوتا ھے کیا ھم افغانستان ایسے رجسٹرڈ ھو کے جا سکتے ہیں کبھی نہیں افغانی ھمیں قطعاً برداشت نہیں کرتے جو لوگ حکومتی اقدامات کے خلاف احتجاج کر رھے ھیں انکو شرم آنی چاہیے تاریخی اقدامات کیے جا رہے ہیں حکومت کی جانب سے پاکستان قوم پر بہت بڑا احسان کیا ھے اس حکومت نے تاریخ میں ھمیشہ یاد رکھا
پاکستان نے 30 سال ان غیر قانونی افغان مہاجرین کو اپنے معاشرے کا حصہ بنایا، ہمارے علاقوں میں کاروبار کیا،گھر بنائے، شادیاں کیں۔
لیکن افغان اکثریت پاکستان مخالف رہی، سمگلنگ اور دہشتگردی کی۔
You know I used to have sympathy towards the Afghans but when I started interacting with Afghans I noticed, every Afghan I interacted with have negative things to say about Pakistan forget being thankful.
Pakistan have suffered so much because of them they don’t realize that, Pakistan has helped them which they don’t recognize.
Look how the Afghan crowd acts in cricket games against Pakistan.
It is about time that Pakistan closes the door for them.
That's so true. Afghan hates pakistani people
Boo hoo 🇵🇰🚮
So you have decided to take a stand on this over a cricket game 🙂
Bro Pakistan did not welcome them out of the goodness of its heart. Our gov and namaloom afrad was paid dollars to host Afghans. We were the one who backed U.S in its war on Terror put of fear that U.S would also destroy Pakistan. I know people of Pakistan do not hate Afghans, but our establishment does what benefits them. They dont care about Afghanistan or pakistan
Yes. Got a problem?@@koshurpheran9191
Very sad situation. My heart breaks for the innocent caught up in this tragedy. Thank you for your reporting.
Europe needs to learn after Pakistan. They share values and religion, and even they dont want to host them anymore
Lots of illegal immigrants from India are in the UK 🇬🇧 🤔
There’s a huge issue of the black market. They’re one of the reasons we’re not able to collect from tariffs and taxes. Our local economy is suffering massively.
Drugs and terrorism is another subject.
Black markets bleeding the economy dry and dodging taxes? That's bad business. But let's be direct: when the ISI plays the stock market with the Taliban, it's no surprise the economy gets jittery. And sure, drugs and terrorism are another chapter, but it's the same book where Pakistan helped author the return of the Taliban in 2021-after Afghanistan had started writing a new story where its people, especially women, had a shot at a better life. So, talking about economic woes without mentioning that backstory? That's like complaining about smoke and ignoring the fire you helped start.
Same thing should be done with illegal Bangladeshis in Indian States like west bengal and Northeast States , it's a shame even Pakistan is Taking Actions yet indian Govt Remains Silent
Chennai city of India pays more property tax than Pakistan state of Afghanistan. Punjabi pak army will know this soon, that demonizing pathans will cost them heav
Couldn't agree more!
Pakistan army is main culprit in smuggling. Nobody can smuggle without their permission.
As a Pakistani I’m sad for my Afghan brothers and sisters. The government does nothing for them, they are hardworking people and earn money themselves. How are they burden?
Wo pakistan mai rahai kar pakistan ko accept nahi karthai, they eat from pakistani plate likin india ka nara lagathai ha, jab pakistan bana tha shuru sai pakistan ko accept nahi kia or itnai saal raha kar mulk ko karab kardia or india india, boj thi mangahai tha, aghar chup chap sai kaam karthai baghir india ka nara lagai pakistan kuch nahi kartha albatha pakistan ki foji bagarat ha
keep them in your house then. the pathan afghans are terrorist. they curse on pakistan and always chant support for india. In karachi they harrass our women and do theft. they also create religious tensions in the country and chant pro pathan slogans. these afghani pathans should be sent back
Jab gand me danda dalke lotege na phir pata chale ga
Can you make sure they don’t come to white countries? we don’t want anymore coloureds, we’ve got too many and they’re turning our countries into the 💩holes like the ones they came from. Can we deport some coloureds back to Pakistani? Are you ok with that?
You are not Pakistani, you are indian. Just admit it. 😂
For over five decades, Pakistan, despite its economic constraints, has generously provided food and shelter to Afghan refugees-a feat even major global powers like the US and India, touted as the world's largest democracies, have struggled with. Given this significant contribution, one might ask: what more does the world expect from Pakistan?
Many people would agree with your statement. Although wealthy Muslim Nations like Saudi Arabia, Quatar, Kuwait, UAE do not seem to offer support to Pakistan nor Afghanistan. Why is that?
@@ronibieri2357 because they don't care about them but we did, we tried everything to provide them what best we could with our limited resources but it is enough now, their country is free now and they can go there and start a new life
@@mustafamoeezfamily they earn their food, money....everything. The only thing we gave them was a safe land. You as a Pakistani should know how corrupt government officials and why people might want to avoid them. They never get your work done
Always enjoy your reporting. Well done !
Can't understand why they are not happy to go back to their motherland. The taliban finally freed afghanistan. No more war there. Now all the refugees from all over the world can go back. Why aren't they happy ?`Now they have a country for themselves.
No handouts back home😂
In Pakistan free clothes free food from charity organisations.
Because your billion diolaar army us responsible for destabilizing that nation for more than 40 YEARS you Id**t
All of you are pieces of Sh**. They are kicking out the most vulnerable. Clearly you don't have a problem with the afghan people, rather, poor people.
You should change your profile picture. It doesn't befit your comments.@@4th_Disciple
If India had done something like this.. it would have been a major uproar.. imagine the illegal migrants from Bangladesh are asked to move..
With Pakistan it's like a cakewalk
Don't worry Qatar is watching it as a responsible Islamic country. They will give asylum to all the Afghan refugees.
Qatar is not a country of Mushriks. Ahamdulillah.
I was thinking the same. Remember NRC and CAA protests.The world criticized Modi govt. . Even I was against this NRC n CAA. Kitna bada chutiya tha main.
India has no refugees.and nobody wants to go there,why afghans don't go to india
Lol
Lol
As a Pakistani I am so disgusted with this imported government. No one should be forced out of a country that they have known all their life or most of their life.
Pakistan is punishing the innocent to get revenge on Afghanistan government. So cruel and immature.
I hope people in Pakistan will give the afghans shelter and protect them.
Fact 💯 powerful always try to oppress weak ......
Good decision
Being a Pakistani it's enough now for us to host 3.3 million Afghani brothers & sisters we are happy that we could host them a long but they all were here illegally but we still hosted them , but some of Afghanis are members of TTP(Terrorist Party against PAKISTAN 🇵🇰) and we had suffered a long almost 20+ years with terrorism. But now the whole world knows that Pakistan 🇵🇰 is under economical crises, terrorism victim and we had lost thousands of our civilians and army men , please our brothers 🇦🇫we know everyone is not bad but due to illegal immigration some terrorists were taking advantage of your immigrations and attacking us , now we are enough to suffer! And host Afgani brother 🇦🇫 now it's time of them departure to their Homeland! 🇦🇫♥️ .... don't mind please love 💕 from Pakistan 🇵🇰 you are now in better position and economy in Afghanistan.... Hope so everyone is doubtless now
Pakistan throwing the terrorism word around.....funny
@@brucefale6132 shut up we're not terrorists ohk ....Even we are the victims of terrorists!!!... You don't know about terrorism of Your RAW
Afghan government should take care of their own citizens instead of pushing to others😢
Afghan government is not accepting them
They are too busy making a certain type of magic vest that sends j ih a dees to ji ha dee heaven where 72 girlies are waiting for them
What Afghan government you talking about? A terror group created and reared by Pakistan that took control of the country which not a single country in the world including Pakistan recognises, is not a government. Please revisit your thoughts and talk realistically.
@@paulphilips7486you do realise Taliban were created by USA? To fight the ussr?
1) Pakistan is a made-up name created by the Brits
2) Pakistan is an artificial state created by the Brits
3) Pakistan is the most corrupt state on the face of the earth
4) Pakistan is governed by 2 most corrupt parties that oppress its people
5) Pakistan elite are the army & mostly educated in Western countries and have been stealing from its citizens
6) The only way to empower this country to go under Afghanistan 🇦🇫 and bestow the Afghan pride upon this prideless state. Go figure!
No one should be allowed to live in any country illegally, period.
I disagree they belong in Pakistan
How about pakis in UK?
@@HK00088 will you be allowed to be part of any country you move to for any reason , illegally
@@jojipk4I agree..... Israel, Europe, america etc should take notes from this gentleman....
@@HK00088 Quaid e Azam did not make Pakistan for Afghanistan citizens
He made it for citizens of British India
For me what is ironic is the fact that this has happened and there has not been any global outrage and if a similar situation was done in the west the entire world would have considered to be either a racist or some kind of religious hate towards the afghan people. This is just purely cruelty towards the afghanis.
Exactly
only illegal refugees are being sent back, Imagine, West having over 40 million of illegal refugees,
It's not religious hate, but more of a racial hate
Where is pakistani fake narrative of muslim brotherhood now ??? Just talking one thing n doing exactly the opposite. What did dey do to their muslim brother of east pakistan or gilgit or kashmir or balochistan or sindhis..
I feel so sad for these people. The US should return all the Afghanistan froze assets and allow them to rebuild their homes, land, properties, and villages.
Huh? I thought taliban won the war… I also thought the victors of war enjoy all the spoils and gain control of things…
The frozen assets were donations from western government to help keep the Afghanistan functioning. Its not Afghanistan money, they haven't had a functioning economy for nearly 50 years. Technically they are just keeping what was there's to begin with. Taliban need to rebuild their own economy and stop relying on international aid. The first step is to allow women in the workforce also equal education for boys and girls.
@@VolReed Not if the spoils are 9 billion dollars thats been effectively stolen by the US. Textbook scorched-earth policy.
Truth is they would have better treatment if they became a US colony. The people of the world wish they were under the umbrella of US justice
Faiz Hameed cabinet cannot be trusted to receive the Afghan assets. USA must wait for a democracy to be established in Afghanistan
Wise decision by Pakistani Government, we as a nation and we Pakistanis get blamed for these attacks caused by TTP which is directly funded and supported by Afghan government. They smuggle things into the country and are a threat to security while also being a burden on the economy
Your govt LITERALLY created the Taliban along with other terror groups, when they didn't function as told the onus is still on them
You are a burden
What you sow you will reap.
You ppl being the centre of Terrorism and brought Terrorism to so many countries. Hence you are now facing this kind of problem
Well said.
Right
As a Pakistani I am ashamed of our government. LOVE FOR AFGHANISTAN
When there are involve torest activity and harm public properties and robbing public that's right?
@@Petro72690 you probably are not aware of politics.
You’re not even Pakistani but Indian. These Afghans are staying illegally in Pakistan which is crime in any country, while the other Afghans who are legal and paying tax are not being deported. Please understand before commenting about the situation. Don’t just hear and believe half the story told on Western media. And if you Indians feel so bad for Afghans then you’re free to take them to India, after they bootlick you and treat you as brothers, while you show them plenty of affection for political motives such as using them against Pakistan.
@@ImranKhan-mw8yj I am Pakistani. Mujhe Urdu bhi ath hai aurpashto bhi. Just because I support my Muslim brothers doesn't mean I am indian. Don't you dare call me that again. You are Indian.
@@ImranKhan-mw8yj these are our Muslim brothers. They are suffering and we have to help them. Stop listening to corrupt govt
I feel sorry for these poor Afghan people. Pakistan govt should deal in better way particularly for those who born and raised in Pakistan and have legal documents and those should go who don't have legal documents.
Bhai khud inho ne documents nai bnai. Kuch logo ka documents bna hai. Gov.t has allow them to stay
People can stay if they have documents
Does a country not have the authority to take measures for it's own security?
No only US dollar decides that.
When Europe does it its islamapobia ? Heck even turkey is calling out Pakistanis and syrians.
As long as western countries can do same kick u out .can they?
pakistan is a muslim country . Muslim countries should help other Muslim countries. coz the brotherhood & stuffs 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@user-ls7ek4ul1jthe same pakistan & al-jizzira goes haywire when west, israel or india does so🤡
It is very good decision by Pakistani Government even no country allows anyone to live in it without any official documents
Good. In that case all western nations should kick out paksitanis. That would be right with you?
But if the west does this to Pakistanis then you cry of racism
@pankajpassi7233 Stop comparing Afghanis to Palestinians. Palestinian people do not even have their own country, they only have flag. By the way Pakistan gave 2.4 million Afghanis to be permanently stay in Pakistan with documents as long as they wish. 1.7 million Afghanis are undocumented with no record. These undocumented Afghanis are coming and staying in Pakistan since 1979. Most Afghans are not living in a Shelter in Pakistan. They grabbed land, and made permanent house, and do business of their liking without paying a single tax.
@@AI-qn8be yes brother you said correct
@pankajpassi7233that's bot what he's trying to say but it's true no one what's to give there shelter to people suffering in gaza, but as a refugee is different and undocumented once aren't living in pakistan peacefully afgans no matter now much help pakistan gave them they have always neglected pakistan filled it with drugs and pro india india while using the land of pakistan.
Very good decision of Pakistan government 👍
Not good decision not good
Yes Very Good Decision 💯
iPhones which are snatched in Karachi pakistan, and thereafter relocate in Mazar e shareef in afghanistan this is also a major issue for us pakistanis
Even though it may sound harsh, it had to be done eventually. In actuality, Pakistan was the only neighbor of Afghanistan that permitted refugees to enter its borders with such freedom. They were fed, clothed, and safe in Pakistan. The worst thing about Afghans is that, while they were living in Pakistan, they began publicly praising India and openly criticizing Pakistan, its government, and its citizens. Un-accept-able !!! 45 years of help and then you bite the hand that fed you. Get out !!!
Provide proofs that Afghans were fed by the govt of Pakistan.
Nationalism is as much a disease as tribalism.
45 Years of terror- financing received by pakistan.. trump pulled the plug, so pak now no longer has the motive to hold them
I was born and raised in Pakistan and I did school and college there. Never have I heard any Afghan praising India unless over a cricket match. I love Pakistani people and I’ve always criticised the govt because of their selfish interest and only keeping Afghans because they are getting benefits which is all facts. You talk about feeding Afghan, I am the example of how wrong your concept are. We never had a single ounce of food, shelter or money from this govt. please keep your facts straight.
Bite the hand that fed them? Pakistan or rather pak goverment profited from afghan war for 30 years. Pakistan was aiding US weapons to get in Afghanistan and then say there should be no reaction? Pakistan is not the only country to allow refugees. The freely part you added so freely like afghan are not the same as pashtuns of Pakistan and the borders are unfencable. The reason all your shops sell smuggled goods. Thats how your politicians use smuggled land cruisers.
You guys talk abt the Afghans same way US talks abt Pakistan and then complain that they are brainwashed. Its time you realize your hypocrisy.
Before Pak army crack down on PTI supporters you called those pashtoons and baloch liars and indians sympathizers when they were telling that their families were abducted. Now what pti supporters need to be deported also? They are now indian sympathizers?
Imagine US attacks pakistan and china helps US bring their weapons into pakistan to kill pakistanis. How would you feel abt China? Taliban still welcomed pakistan after US defeat, then what Pakistan does? Drones Afghan civilians which US use to do from Pakistan's territory. No this time it wasnt even US, it was Pakistan goverment.
Go educate yourself before posting.
exactly. atleast they took people in
As afghan I'm happy that finally Pakistani establishment takes responsibility and I hope they don't play their evil dirty terrorism game like wise they've played in last +40 years😡.
Afghans🇦🇫 must understand that in No countries you are welcome so there is only one country that you belong to; it's Afghanistan 🇦🇫. We afghans must build our beloved country🇦🇫 and work towards unity, democracy, and economy and have good relations with our neighbouring countries.
Long live Afghanistan 🇦🇫 and peace ✌️ around the world 🌎.
Please stay there 🙏
@@erikmorales1004 and let this toryal guy take all the rascal Afghanis with them.
Same thing should be done with illegal Bangladeshis in Indian States like west bengal and Northeast States , it's a shame even Pakistan is Taking Actions yet indian Govt Remains Silent
Tajik, Uzbek, Persian areas of Afghanistan are safe. Punjab and Sindh in Pakistan are safe. Only the Pashtun belt on either side of the border has a problem. And these d*mbf*cks have the audacity to call Pak Army terrorist.
@@CocLegend317 do want you want we have a country from India which is great as we don't have to be under Hindu rule
Why can’t the Afghan refugees walk over the border to Iran? Why do they always need to come to the West. Build your own country up. You have the resources.
The wars in Afghanistan were not started by Pakistan, and it is not Pakistan's burden to bear the shortfalls from their results. If the world is that outraged, surely they can accomodate the refugees.
As a Pakistani I applaud the accurate content of this report. Its a shame our govt doing it the way they are right now, specially Afghans who are vorn here are Pakistani as we follow Jus Soli, I know Peshawar Highcourt said it does not apply to refugees but I think its absurd. Its true abt two govt not meeting eye to eye and also about TTP or fact many Afghans are involved in crimes but u can not say all are like this due to few bad eggs. Also west specially US caused this mess but does not take them leaving poor country like Pakistan to suffer.
@arsalanvideos , How many Afghans living in Your home? We dont pay taxes to get attacked by Afghanistan side. We sheltered these basters & they always abused us.
@@osmpunja00087 bro relax. Even i agree with u but you can also tell your view with polite words
Afgand00 pretending to be a pakistani
Harbouring terrorists created this mess
Have you ever heard the term "Afghan Wali"? What does it mean?
This is good for both Pakistan and Afghanistan
America should provide relief to the refugees and give them facilities again !
Because this should be the responsibility of American government .
Huh? So you’re kneeling before America and admitting who the ruler of the world is?
@@VolReed No, I don't see that as kneeling. It's more like charging the guy who caused the damage to fix it. And the Americans are. The UN feeds the poor in Afghanistan mostly with US money.
Started beging again 😂
@@VolReed America has to pay the damages it caused
@@VolReed use your brain, it's getting rusty
So Afghan’s Taliban govt that is friendly with India, keeps shelling the border area, then the terrorist Pakistan Taliban operates from afghan territory. Then you see rich afghans living in . Dubai, London, etc insult Pakistan, praise India, etc so why doesn’t India take them? Why doesn’t Afghanistan govt cosy with India take them back?
Thank lots for sharing 👍 💚 💙 ♥️
The State of Pakistan must take every step needed to protect the people of Pakistan from cross border terrorism. The Taliban government which is also illegitimate, is using TTP as their proxy in Pakistan. Their so-called Jihadi mindset is creating problems for common Afghans.
Nice one! Pakistan is the inventor of jihad. Pakistan has the most advanced factories for producing the best terrorists The whole world knows that.
OMG, are you serious? Weren't you guys supporting the Taliban against the democratic government of Afghanistan just 3 years ago? TTP is your internal problem and you should share power with them.
Your an idiot. You think the TTP are the only ones with this mindset?
@@FJ20244those people who only looked upon this situation by saying ooh ok now these people follow Islam well so they mean good for themselves and us as well supported these people blindly irrespective of what place they have for us in their hearts and how they have slowly started taking a turn against us. Those who followed this situation while having knowledge of both deen and dunya absolutely condemned Afghanistan since it started hating us for just existing, whether it was the democratic government or the taliban government. Even after giving the afghans a welcoming shelter for them to feel safe and be able to secure and support themselves it came back at us with fraud by using our currency, passport and other various identification documents nationally and internationally, as well as a rise in illegal arms activity and various forms of crimes at the rise. We thought good for them but in turn they thought bad of us. They themselves made us have a stern opinion about them and left us with no other solution than to send them back to their real country their soil their home. What’s the problem in this? And it’s only taking place for the illegals who haven’t certified themselves properly according to our national database, but those afghans who have pak nationality are still living as if it’s their home nation and they are welcome to do so, no one’s saying anything to them.
😹😹
People always remember Palestine but they have forgotten Afghanistan refugees, what a hypocrisy Muslim world is.
You Pashtun dont have unity and fight for your righhts. Palestinians stand up and fight for their kand and nation . You must learn unity, political organisation and struggle for your freedom and independence and dignity. Punjabi Pakistan is a army dictatorship that humilaites you bt still you run there , go and build your own country and make it better than Terroristan than you dont have to run away.
Pakistan did no favor taking Afghans as refugees after first wrecking peaceful Afghanistan in collusion with Americans and later trying to develop "strategic depth" to foster trouble for India
There are exactly 2 reasons for this deportation.
1. No money coming in from the USA, since the war stopped
2. The Taliban refuses to play a slave to Pak army and accept it as a master
Pakistan have every right to protect their own citizens at any cost
paki's have never protected their citizens... they will never
As a Pakistani you are right but I disagree Afghanistan is our brothers . THEY SHOULD STAY!
@@HK00088 This is not a movie scene dude don't be so emotional. You're running out of resources and yeah they are creating problems for you and we have to protect our own interests not that so called brotherhood. Peace
@@HK00088they are not our anything out they go
@@playlist6264where is muslim brotherhood now?
Afghans can have better life in their own country as first national. It will hard initially but this will be better soon. They should never allow anyone in future to ruin their country and not play in other hands
Both the countries already in deep crisis and trying to seek each other's help by playing with the lives of poor refugees. There's no actual solution to such a circumstance. I'm afraid things might get worse...
Colonial mindsets (British left upon) still we consider superior to others 😢...... Islam preaches all humans are equals 😢
Very sad
May Allaha SWT give hidayat
As a Pakistani, i say deportation is not a problem, the govt didn't gave them sufficient time to deport. they have been pushed in a panic way and are treated inhumanely. they were familes, children and women.
Sufficient time? They had 45 years to leave, and mind it, only the illegal ones are being pushed out. Why? because these bastards were involved in all illegal activities; armed dacoity and killing, land grabbing, terrorism, you name it. If you feel sorry for them, then move to Afghanistan with them !!!!
You know what they did right thing and Same thing should be done with illegal Bangladeshis in Indian States like west bengal and Northeast States , it's a shame even Pakistan is Taking Actions yet indian Govt Remains Silent
@@CocLegend317 This is the first time I agree with an Indian finally you have commonsense
Subha Shaam punjabiuon ki maon behno ko wo Gali daitay Hain wo log Jo gaali firghoun Kay dada ko bhi nahi aati ti. Baaray harami hai Afghani.mai gawah houn is BAAT ka
@@CocLegend317 idhar Say bhaag madarchod.tera west Bengal bhi Bangladesh ka part hai.tu idhar q maa chuda Raha hai Bengali log afghanion ki tarha harami log nahi hai.
We had a major Afghan neighbourhood in Karachi called Al-Asif, filled with illegal refugees and drugs. Was a full on no go zone as they would kill you, torture, put super glue in your ears and eyes etc. They were living there illegally and stole electricity, gas etc. Now it’s a peaceful place since the Afghans have been removed.
Yay liberals doggy ha.
Inko sab pata hai mgr phir bhe anjaan ban I pakistan ko blame krtay hain bc.
Namak haramo afghandu ko jana hoga ab
We have the same problem in Iran. Over ten million afghan😔
So the same thing is what the Pakistanis are doing in our Gulf countries, Saudi Arabia and the Emirates .Not only theft, but they are skilled at forgery and harass children and women. They should be expelled
We have the same problem in peshawar
@@farraf4009
These namak haram should be thrown back to their home
I must say I have personally met many afghans who don't have a single word of appreciation for Pakistani hospitality and their behaviour has been anything but a good brotherly neighbor however average afghans are hard working and good people Pakistan should not act like Taliban and could have sent them peacefully. What Talibans are doing is the height of ungratefulness they couldn't do a darn thing w o Pakistan s military help.
Pakistani hospitality? What a joke!😂
@srn9993 try t9 host a stranger in a day I bet you can't
@@RG769 already done it! Helped countless, no need to prove anything to a Pakistani for sure lol
I have experienced afghan hospitality though! The best i would say! India is hosting them well and the afghans sure no how to reciprocate it unlike ungrateful hypocrites like Pakistan, the terror hub of the world
As an Afghan this is painful but hopefully it’s a wake up call for Afghans to go back to their own country instead of being trained in terror Madrasas and send back to destroy and give control of Afghanistan to Pakistan. Afghanistan needs its people and Pakistan has the right to remove undocumented immigrants.
What happens when we are registered, can we go to Afghanistan by being registered like this? Afghanis definitely do not tolerate us. People who are protesting against the government's actions should be ashamed of themselves. Historical actions are being taken by the government on the Pakistan nation. What a great favor this government has always remembered in history
For 30 years, Pakistan made these illegal Afghan refugees a part of its society, they did business in our areas, built houses, got married.
But the Afghan majority remained anti-Pakistan, involved in smuggling and terrorism.
😂😂😂😂😂, Pakistan is anti terrorist. 😂😂😂😂😂, your masters gave you orders and you obeyed like a good little doggie
Excellent reply 👏
Asking a country stuck in war for 40 years to tolerate you is a bit much. In a time of peace did Pakistan tolerate Bangladesh. Pakistan is akin to Saudi arabia, an obedient dog
So pakistan=afghanistan are same in terms of treatment then pakistan must not pretend its better country than afg
The irony. Do you know how much aid Pakistan receives for Afghan refugees ?
Pakistan hosted them for many decades even though the came illegally without any documentation. I think the place is now stable and they should help develop their nation. Those people who have documentation are not being deported. Moreover, if these people can go through proper process they can comeback. They are not being restricted. It doesn't matter they are burden or not. Point is if I come to your country without documentation I can stay hidden from state. I'm pretty sure I would be deported without coming through legal process and there is no exception to it.
👏 👏
😂They got paid in dolors untill few years ago, that's why they kept them, your government played both sides at the end so they lost, watch you x ISI chefe interview on Oxford Union talkes 😅
@@zachazia443acha aesa hai to tm rakhlo afghanio ko tm to paise le kr bhi na rakho
And Pakistanis messed up in Afghanistan and Pakistan took money for these refugees no?
@@totallypointlessvideos3832 yes we do so what it's been 40 years they are live in if you so worry about then tell your indian government to import them in india
Information is incomplete. One of the major issues and factors behind all this is porus border between Afg and PK. People (and terrorists) can move easily. Afghans who are living in PK oppose border fencing and security, as they visit Afg whenever they need to. I think the issue isn't with their desire to visit Agh. Instead, the way is open for terrorists too. They prepare and plan attacks in Afg and execute them in PK. Because of historic ties, Taliban government provides safe haven to TTP, TJP, and other terrorist outfits. So, in order to create a safe and sound environment and stop terrorism, border fencing and security is necessary. Afghan refugees, who have family ties with Afg, need to be sent back. After this, the border will be secured.
if Europe had done it we would have heard only xenophobia and islamophobia.
As a Pakistani. I live in Capital of Pakistan, Islamabad. There had been surge of theft and crime. and Culprits were always Afghans. I am not stereotyping any people but when you come to another country after fleeing war, who is giving you shelter, work and food. And you started stealing them that means it always going to be a problem
😂😂😂😂
"I am not stereotyping anyone.." just before stereotyping a whole community.
@@aliiqbal88 You missed the point entirely
Same thing should be done with illegal Bangladeshis in Indian States like west bengal and Northeast States , it's a shame even Pakistan is Taking Actions yet indian Govt Remains Silent
oh please stop these lies your own chief of police says that not nearly 1% are involved in crimes that have been reported less than 1%. you brainwashed
The refugees were doubled by Mr Imran Khan who distributed free Pakistani passports to TTP and rolled out free healthcare for them
That was after stopping CPEC and dev projects and taking 80% historical loans from IMF when we were out of it.
Any reversal of such policy is in pakistans interest
JHe was always a an Af-Gaand who should have never been i the country himself
Informative
This is so unfair. 😢
It is easier to view these events from an external perspective, but we have endured significant challenges due to Afghan refugees. That journalist easily said "without any evidence" while quoting internal minister but it is a fact that Afghan nationals are often involved in terrorism in Pakistan.
The afghan neighborhood depicted in this report is with in a mile of where i live, and its a ground reality that wherever Afghan migrants had a presence, incidents of crimes like theft and looting increased in the surrounding areas.
Also it is a huge burden on our struggling economy. 1.7M is a big number. So this decision by the government absolutely makes sense
But when Europe tries to deport illegall Syrians why muslim world cry so much islamaphobia
what about Muslim brotherhood?
It was and is Pakistan who funds and train jihadis in Afghansitan and Kashmir. World's biggest terrorist is found by Americans in a pakistani miltary town. What a hypocrisy by the Pakistanis
@@Blaze9946 muslim brotherhood is just overrated term. You cant see this anywhere unless they fight against other religion. Recent example is Israel palestini issue. 😂
@@shiningstar958 Pakistan says they are Muslim country, so they should show it in their action🤣🤣🤣. don't get me wrong i am also a Muslim
I completely support this decision. These refugees have been living in pakistan for decades, a country grappling with its economic issues. Further, they were displaced due to Russia and US invasion so why does Pakistan has to settle them any longer? Us and Nato should take them if they r so concerned for them
👏 👏
True
@3rpaan if your heart is bleeding so much take them to your home or go to Afghanistan with them!!
Same thing should be done with illegal Bangladeshis in Indian States like west bengal and Northeast States , it's a shame even Pakistan is Taking Actions yet indian Govt Remains Silent
If it is not dealing with Pakistan then why did it help Americans invading Afghanistan twice. This problem is created by Pakistan itself without thinking of the consequences. Be ready to face the consequences.
If there is no possibility of Afghans living in Pakistan, then we should provide them with all necessary aid such as winter blankets, food, and camps to support Afghanistan in housing them. Alternatively, we could establish a designated area within Pakistan for all Afghans to reside, while ensuring security measures are in place to monitor the movement of individuals in and out. However, it is crucial not to abandon them to endure suffering on their own.
I think Pakistan should not deport them in this weather at least. Pakistan can wait until march. What the poor people will do in this too much cold weather. Very sad.
Which country in world let live 4 million without visas ???
4 Million? That only without Visa.
25million+ total refugees.
What happened to the ummah?
Sounds like South Africa and Zimbabwe
We SAns should do the same as Pakistan
And even there are 40000 people killed due to afgan illegal involvement
America america...oh that is not a genuine question?
You have only covered a very brief issue on Afghanis behaviour in Pakistan, security issues is one but there have been countless incidents of their extreme lawlessness there are plenty of videos flying around full of terror stories. So in a nutshell they have brought it upon themselves. PK does not need their extreme views.
Yes. This is only showing 1 side. They brought drugs, crime, fundamentalism and are ungrateful for all Pk did and suffered because of them.
Got love Al Jazeera they bring coverage no other news outlet brings
Lots of pray and love for our poor afganistani brothers 😢 🇦🇫❤️🇮🇳
Don't bother, descendants of Shakuni will turn on us if we help them.
Shut up! They don't need your support they are going back to their home Afghanistan 🇦🇫.... They are happy that Pakistan 🇵🇰 hosted them for more than 30 years !!!
Open your country border for them if you like afghans too much
Apne desh mein rkh le itna pyar a rha hai tou
@@kashifiqbal2324 apny hi desh ja rahay hain ohk shut up, ...Tum Khalistan aur Manipur dekhu apna
As an American, I never knew that Afghans were being deported from Pakistan 🇵🇰 back into Afghanistan 🇦🇫.
I always thought Pakistan 🇵🇰 and Afghanistan 🇦🇫 had a good relationship and were friends.
😂😂😂 you are funny
Afghans have more better relationship with India than Pakistan
For your info Afghanistan attacked Pakistan in 1961, Afghanistan was the only country in the world which opposed Pakistan admission in 1947 when Pakistan came into existence. Afghanistan always aligned itself with India and enemies of Pakistan to pressurise Pakistan. The first prime minister of Pakistan was assassinated by Afghan.
@@salmansadozai5500 who are Sadozais basically ?
@@sarhban11Sadozai's are Afghans basically but my forefathers migrated hundreds of years ago along with others to fight Hindus and Sikhs of British India. However, my grandfather was born in Pakistan, my father was born in Pakistan and me as well that's why I'm a proud Pakistani.
They won't support Afghans but they want to fight for Palestinians lol...what a hypocrites
Yes, hypocrisy at its peak
Hmmm who attacked afghanistan.
Alteast the leaders are not hyprocite. The Pakistani dictator Zia ul Haq himself killed many Palestinians 🤣
@@JonySmith-bb4gx who?
@@eddardstark3272 I asked the question
This is beyond sad. I understand Pakistan’s viewpoint about not having enough money to support them but they are literally in thatched huts. Surely the international
Community can provide aide DIRECTLY to them and not to Pakistan
Perhaps immigration will eventually do to Pakistan what immigration has done to Britain? Role-on cultural diversity for Pakistan as it becomes a multi-cultural society enriched by millions of people from all around the world making it their home (including from Africa)!
Btw, the claim made by one of the participants in this clip that illegal immigrants, particularly Afghanis, were not posing any financial burden upon Pakistan, is a vague statement which is far from facts. These illegal immigrants usually set up slums in major cities where they first of all use water, electricity and Gas through illegal connections and this theft committed by them causes huge dent upon our economy. Secondly, their settlements are build upon illegal occupied lands which again is disastrous for our economy. Thirdly, these illegal immigrants due to being undocumented are mostly involved in illegal activities due to which authorities are compelled to tighten up security which again increases security expense which further burdens our economy. Apart from that, these illegal immigrants due to being undocumented, do not pay any tax to the state which also is detrimental for our economy. Therefore, as a regular viewer of Al-jazeera, it is my humble request to you to kindly invite participants in your documentaries whose narrative is based upon facts and unbiased.
Pakistan should have thought about all these issues before helping America invade Afghanistan. Pakistan is responsible for all these issue.
@@salahsabri2925 most of these refugees are from taliban takeover and what about the refugees from soviet afghan which has nothing to do with Pakistan
@@averroes9143 I know there is no democracy in Pakistan and hence people opinion were not considered by the dictators like Zia and Musharraf. But they have done it and Pakistan is facing their consequences.
Qatar is a stinking rich Islamic country ; high time they took some Islamic responsibility and helped their Muslim brethren in their hour of need . All they do is fund terrorist organisations like Hamas and Hezbollah and preach to the world through Al Jazeera.
Miserable Pakistan should also help their minorities who have been living in their country from partition times and not persecute them . Pakistanis want to migrate and live as minorities in other countries.
That's a long due initiative that Government of Pakistan taking it now. Enough is enough we gave them food, shelter, jobs and in return they dent our economy and involved in every possible crime. They are burden on our country from last 45 years and 3.5 million refugees is a big number. They have illegal settlements in every major cities of Pakistan where they have slums use water, electricity and natural gas without paying a penny. Sorry cannot be a good host anymore. But I also feel sorry for those who are legally moved to Pakistan. Governments should take strict actions if these legal immigrants have been harassed.
Host?? Bro what about the aid our authorities have been taking in the name of refugees from the international authorities? This might be something new for you, but what you call a great gesture of hosting, the international communities have been paying for it. If our authorities have been looting the aid and we Pakistanis, as a dead nation as we are, never bothered to raise a point on it, we got no point to come out clean on it pretending as if we ever did a favor to anyone .... Here's a reality, our authorities didn't bother to integrate refugees into our system in the first place, lack of intention. What do you think will happen when a father sees his children hungry and the authorities give a 0 F about it? He'll do it in whatever way he can. 2 wrongs don't make a right but let's point out the root cause before doing any cosmetic surgery.
Let's put ourselves accountable before pointing someone else out
@@zohaibhasannaqvi7808Those Pakistani didn't even use the aid on Afgans.
Afgans got zero assistance from Pak government and instead do manual labour or anything for livelihood by themselves
@@redeyexxx1841They did get aid. Most of it just like the pakistani people's money was looted by the generals and politicians and powerful beraucrats. But they did get aid, although not comparable to the money sent by international organizations as most of it got looted. But what can we so about it?? Our own taxes get looted, how are we gonna speak about aid.
@@zohaibhasannaqvi7808Our own taxes are looted and we do nothing. You think we're gonna speak about the refugees' aid. Everyone fears the black vigos.
Logically correct!
I did not see similar balanced view from Al Jazeera or Pakistanis when India tries to expel undocumented Rohingya or Bangladeshis for security reasons. In fact, in that case the coverage and views from Pakistanis was totally one-sided. That is why I do not take Al Jazeera seriously.
Rohingyas are not Indians so are bangaldeshis...India is a Hindu country not an islamic country.sorry like America or Europe we don't want any Islamic refugees
We Pakistani are against this act of na pak army which is American pet dog in the region.we has not voted this caretaker Government to take such decisions their mandate to conduct election not to expell afghan are something else .
I m Pakistani living in France and can understand the pain of those who came here for bright future here in eu there r alot of Pakistanis without doucements but with the passage of time they became legal so Pakistan also should legal those who have spent at least 10 years.
Miserable Pakistan should also help their minorities who have been living in their country from partition times and not persecute them . Pakistanis want to migrate and live as minorities in other countries.
@@jkardez4794 yup as in india minorities have alo the freedom to do or wear or eat what thy want
@@umermaqsood3486indian jews parsis jains sikhs anglos are well respected in india.
the immigration policy in EU is different than in PK, number of years do not seem to matter.
@@jkardez4794 Did you mean Biharis as minority?
All afghani born in pakistan should be given pakistani citizenship.
Many Afghans have been living here illegally for many years and many Afghan men and women have been involved in various attacks. And many Afghanis work for India's secret agency RAW in Pakistan and many Afghanis are working for America and Europe in Pakistan. A few days ago, the US sent a list containing the names of 25,000 Afghani people, and the US was saying that they should be allowed to stay in Pakistan. But while researching these 25,000 people living here illegally, I have personally seen Afghan men and women involved in various attacks. If you are so merciful, you should keep them in America and the Afghan Taliban is also involved in the Pakistan attack and a few days ago, US weapons were seized from a truckload of vegetables from Afghanistan to Pakistan. In this way Afghan Taliban supply arms to their people in Pakistan and then they attack here and some work for India and some for America.
Good decision. These same countries criticizing this idea are the ones who would deport or put illegal refugees in Prison. Again, this could have been done in a better way, but Pakistan is itself in a huge economic burden, this can happen in these situations.
good decision by Pakistan government hope they will be success in a right way ...
That's Army and Same thing should be done with illegal Bangladeshis in Indian States like west bengal and Northeast States , it's a shame even Pakistan is Taking Actions yet indian Govt Remains Silent
Yes, i hope they are able to drive all 1.7 million out and even some of the documented Afghans who moved recently.
@@CocLegend317its the responsibility of state government
The same Pakistan that screaming free Palestine! 😂😂😂
If Europe does : islamophobia
If Pakistan does: internal matter
People saying this is not the right time ... need to know that time is never right
Time is never right for difficult decisions ... Difficult decisions are always taken in difficult times with pain.
Peace has returned and Afghans should happily go back and build their country.(and behave like good neighbours)
Isn't it already enough that we hosted them and provided them shelter during most difficult times when none of their neighbours did anything for them.
Pakistan still helps Afghanistan like no other neighbour country in the world.
Excellent reply 👏 👏
@@monanadeem8523Get ready for another Long March darling
🍭......🐩
Well Said, As per afghan officals peace is maintained in afghanistan so every afghanies should go back their homes.
Extactly my friend you're 100% correct also terror is down because of the deportations
@@erikmorales1004this is Islamophobia
Treating all afghans as terrorists
You didn't put enough of an emphasis on the fact that Afghans are only allowed to take a small amount of money
why even that so small amout of money. Get it from afghansitan haram khor
Afghanistan is our brother in arm but they need to understand the situation of Pakistan as well..
Pakistan has not even signed UN charter for refuges but still has inhabited millions of Afghans for decades.. and its time build and help their country.
Our prayer are with our Afghn brothers...
Long live Afghanistan and Pakistan.
Here is an interim government in Pakistan. The government is not really representing Pakistan, they are hired and imposed on us. Also mention that our publicly elected PM was kicked out from his seat at a midnight.
They are stealing there money and taking their properties
They are and that's unfortunate but no one can accept millions of refuges .
Germany took 1 million and they regret it now, it is impossible.
It's not theirs though they are afgan and must go out
@@erikmorales1004 fruit of their work 🤗🤗 they are leaving houses and businesses I believe that's enough. Good luck for everyone
@@micaeloliveira2727 but can I go to afganistan and take a house and job nope
@@erikmorales1004 I agree with the return of afeganie people. Keep strong Pakistan
Isn't this just returning refugee to their home place?
Afghanistan is in the process of recovery after being taken over by the new government. Even though there a little turmoil here and there, it's no longer a war zone.
From POV of countries, these is a pretty okay move?
Some would say it's a little heartless, but that's the problem with Nationalism in the first place. Nations divides people. But since almost everyone subscribes to that idea, the returning of people to their home is not an extreme move at all.
From Islam POV, I'm not sure how to say this. They are Muslim brothers afterall.
Idk. but in a way, aren't refugee count as guest? Guest shouldn't overstay their welcome. Guest definitely shouldn't make trouble to host (like refugee in my country, Malaysia). They have been welcomed and allow to stay for about 30 years? Since home is quite peaceful, there isn't any valid reason to refuse the deportation.
They are undocumented. Here in the UK we need to remove about 1m undocumented / illegals too but are too weak to do what Pakistan is doing. We have far far too many people here in the UK. Countries cannot just take everyone. Pakistan is within its rights to have them leave and the Taliban can deal with it.
I watch every start here episode.
My suggestion for future video
1. Why Finland joined NATO
2. Sweden hurdle in joining NATO
3. Argentina election and javier milei win
4. Dutch election and Geert wilders
5. Rise of Far Right in Europe and America
6. Pakistan next general election
7. Current Status in Russia Ukraine War
8. Armenia and Azerbaijan Conflict and Turkey involvement.
This will never ends. There always be a group of people wants to build their own country, their own militia, their own power to gain control wherever they want across generation, that's why Afghanistan and Pakistan exist and still on going.
As a Pakistani: my grave concern is that what is the motive of US and UK settling afghan refugees in their lands, like what are they planning or what they have planned ??
if you were so concerned you would've protested their deportation. whatever US or UK does now shouldn't be your concern at all
Kick all afghans out of Pakistan.
Afghans are Namak Haram Nation
Pakistan is forcefully deporting them and also asking a mandatory deport fees.
Shows how nasty pakistanis are by there mentality
A base for future Anti-Afghanistan Movement!
@@haybee2898I think us and UK should take all Pakistani Christians who are living in poor condition
The Afghans came as refugees.
They didn't get any IDs in Pakistan so still had no status legally.
This caused alot of security issues as many others came into the country and crime surged and became uncontrollable.
The war in Afghanistan is over as well.
But this should have been done very slowly so that people have time to re -settle.
Afghans in Pakistan never really considered themselves Pakistani, all the major mafias of pakistan from drugs, smuggling, money laundering, land grabbing, snatching, dealing in stolen cars and alot more all this is mostly associated with poor afghans who are being sent back. As a law abiding citizen it is clearly evident that Afghans always took Pakistan for granted they doesnt respect our law. They are also involved in ordering goods in huge stocks in containers for fghanistan but those containers are never sent to Afghanistan instead all the goods in those containers are sold over here in Pakistan due to which they dont get to pay the custom duty. You need to be a Pakistani by heart if you want to live here.